-
A Cryogenic Sapphire Resonator Oscillator with 1e-16 mid-term fractional frequency stability
Authors:
Christophe Fluhr,
Benoit Dubois,
Claudio E. Calosso,
Francois Vernotte,
Enrico Rubiola,
Vincent Giordano
Abstract:
We report in this letter the outstanding frequency stability performances of an autonomous cryogenique sapphire oscillator presenting a flicker frequency noise floor below 2e-16 near 1,000 s of integration time and a long term Allan Deviation (ADEV) limited by a random walk process of 1e-18/sqr(tau). The frequency stability qualification at this level called for the implementation of sophisticated…
▽ More
We report in this letter the outstanding frequency stability performances of an autonomous cryogenique sapphire oscillator presenting a flicker frequency noise floor below 2e-16 near 1,000 s of integration time and a long term Allan Deviation (ADEV) limited by a random walk process of 1e-18/sqr(tau). The frequency stability qualification at this level called for the implementation of sophisticated instrumentation associated with ultra-stable frequency references and ad hoq averaging and correlation methods.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Reliability and Reproducibility of the Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator Technology
Authors:
Christophe Fluhr,
Benoît Dubois,
Guillaume Le Tetu,
Valerie Soumann,
Julien Paris,
Enrico Rubiola,
Vincent Giordano
Abstract:
The cryogenic sapphire oscillator (CSO) is a highly specialized machine, which delivers a reference signal exhibiting the lowest frequency fluctuations. For the best units, the Allan deviation (ADEV) is <1e-15 for integration time between 1 and 10,000 s, with a drift <1e-14 in one day.The oscillator is based on a sapphire monocrystal resonating at 10 GHz in a whispering-gallery mode, cooled at 6 K…
▽ More
The cryogenic sapphire oscillator (CSO) is a highly specialized machine, which delivers a reference signal exhibiting the lowest frequency fluctuations. For the best units, the Allan deviation (ADEV) is <1e-15 for integration time between 1 and 10,000 s, with a drift <1e-14 in one day.The oscillator is based on a sapphire monocrystal resonating at 10 GHz in a whispering-gallery mode, cooled at 6 K for highest Q-factor and zero thermal coefficient. We report on the progress accomplished implementing eleven CSOs in about 10 years since the first sample delivered to the ESA station in Argentina.
Short-term stability is improved by a factor of 3-10, depending on the integration time, and the refrigerator's electric power is reduced to 3 kW. Frequency stability and overall performances are reproducible, with unattended operation between scheduled maintenance every two years. The CSO is suitable to scientific applications requiring extreme frequency stability with reliable long-term operation. For example, the flywheel for primary frequency standards, the ground segment of GNSS, astrometry, VLBI, and radio astronomy stations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Magnetic sensitivity of the Microwave Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator
Authors:
Vincent Giordano,
Christophe Fluhr,
Benoit Dubois
Abstract:
The Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator is today recognized for its unprecedented frequency stability, mainly coming from the exceptional physical properties of its resonator made in a high quality sapphire crystal. With these instruments, the fractional frequency measurement resolution, currently of the order of 1e-16, is such that it is possible to detect very small phenomena like residual resonator e…
▽ More
The Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator is today recognized for its unprecedented frequency stability, mainly coming from the exceptional physical properties of its resonator made in a high quality sapphire crystal. With these instruments, the fractional frequency measurement resolution, currently of the order of 1e-16, is such that it is possible to detect very small phenomena like residual resonator environmental sensitivities. Thus, we highlighted an unexpected magnetic sensitivity of the Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator (CSO) at low magnetic field. The fractional frequency sensitivity has been preliminary evaluated to 1e-13/Gauss, making this phenomenon a potential cause of frequency stability limitation. In this paper we report the experimental data related to the magnetic sensitivity of the quasi-transverse magnetic Whispering Gallery (WGH) modes excited in sapphire crystals differing from their paramagnetic contaminants concentration. The magnetic behavior of the WGH modes does not follow the expected theory combining the Curie law and the Zeeman effect affecting the Electron Spin Resonance of the paramagnetic ions present in the crystal.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
KLTS: A rigorous method to compute the confidence intervals for the Three-Cornered Hat and for Groslambert Covariance
Authors:
Éric Lantz,
Claudio E. Calosso,
Enrico Rubiola,
Vincent Giordano,
Christophe Fluhr,
Benoît Dubois,
François Vernotte
Abstract:
The three-cornered hat / Groslambert Covariance methods are widely used to estimate the stability of each individual clock in a set of three, but no method gives reliable confidence intervals for large integration times.
We propose a new KLTS (Karhunen-Loève Tansform using Sufficient statistics) method which uses these estimators to take into account the statistics of all the measurements betwee…
▽ More
The three-cornered hat / Groslambert Covariance methods are widely used to estimate the stability of each individual clock in a set of three, but no method gives reliable confidence intervals for large integration times.
We propose a new KLTS (Karhunen-Loève Tansform using Sufficient statistics) method which uses these estimators to take into account the statistics of all the measurements between the pairs of clocks in a Bayesian way. The resulting Cumulative Density Function (CDF) yields confidence intervals for each clock AVAR. This CDF provides also a stability estimator which is always positive.
Checked by massive Monte-Carlo simulations, KLTS proves to be perfectly reliable even for one degree of freedom. An example of experimental measurement is given.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2019; v1 submitted 11 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Frequency Stability Measurement of Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators with a Multichannel Tracking DDS and the Two-Sample Covariance
Authors:
Claudio E. Calosso,
François Vernotte,
Vincent Giordano,
Christophe Fluhr Benoît Dubois,
Enrico Rubiolar
Abstract:
This article shows the first measurement of three 100 MHz signals exhibiting fluctuations from 2E-16 to parts in 1E-15 for integration time tau between 1 s and 1 day. Such stable signals are provided by three Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators (CSOs) operating at about 10 GHz, also delivering the 100 MHz output via a dedicated synthesizer. The measurement is made possible by a 6-channel Tracking DDS (…
▽ More
This article shows the first measurement of three 100 MHz signals exhibiting fluctuations from 2E-16 to parts in 1E-15 for integration time tau between 1 s and 1 day. Such stable signals are provided by three Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators (CSOs) operating at about 10 GHz, also delivering the 100 MHz output via a dedicated synthesizer. The measurement is made possible by a 6-channel Tracking DDS (TDDS) and the two-sample covariance tool, used to estimate the Allan variance. The use of two TDDS channels per CSO enables high rejection of the instrument background noise. The covariance outperforms the Three-Cornered Hat (TCH) method in that the background converges to zero "out of the box," with no need of the hypothesis that the instrument channels are equally noisy, nor of more sophisticated techniques to estimate the background noise of each channel. Thanks to correlation and averaging, the instrument background (AVAR) rolls off with a slope 1/sqrt(m), the number of measurements, down to 1E-18 tau = 1E4 s. For consistency check, we compare the results to the traditional TCH method beating the 10 GHz outputs down to the MHz region. Given the flexibility of the TDDS, our methods find immediate application to the measurement of the 250 MHz output of the FS combs.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Photonic Generation of High Power, Ultrastable Microwave Signals by Vernier Effect in a Femtosecond Laser Frequency Comb
Authors:
Khaldoun Saleh,
Jacques Millo,
Baptiste Marechal,
Benoît Dubois,
Ahmed Bakir,
Alexandre Didier,
Clément Lacroûte,
Yann Kersalé
Abstract:
Optical frequency division of an ultrastable laser to the microwave frequency range by an optical frequency comb has allowed the generation of microwave signals with unprecedently high spectral purity and stability. However, the generated microwave signal will suffer from a very low power level if no external optical frequency comb repetition rate multiplication device is used. This paper reports…
▽ More
Optical frequency division of an ultrastable laser to the microwave frequency range by an optical frequency comb has allowed the generation of microwave signals with unprecedently high spectral purity and stability. However, the generated microwave signal will suffer from a very low power level if no external optical frequency comb repetition rate multiplication device is used. This paper reports theoretical and experimental studies on the beneficial use of the Vernier effect together with the spectral selective filtering in a double directional coupler add-drop optical fibre ring resonator to increase the comb repetition rate and generate high power microwaves. The studies are focused on two selective filtering aspects: the high rejection of undesirable optical modes of the frequency comb and the transmission of the desirable modes with the lowest possible loss. Moreover, the conservation of the frequency comb stability and linewidth at the resonator output is particularly considered. Accordingly, a fibre ring resonator is designed, fabricated, and characterized, and a technique to stabilize the resonator's resonance comb is proposed. A significant power gain is achieved for the photonically generated beat note at 10 GHz. Routes to highly improve the performances of such proof-of-concept device are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Characterization of Zero-Bias Microwave Diode Power Detectors at Cryogenic Temperature
Authors:
Vincent Giordano,
Christophe Fluhr,
Benoît Dubois,
Enrico Rubiola
Abstract:
We present the characterization of commercial tunnel diode low-level microwave power detectors at room and cryogenic temperatures. The sensitivity as well as the output voltage noise of the tunnel diodes are measured as functions of the applied microwave power, the signal frequency being 10 GHz. We highlight strong variations of the diode characteristics when the applied microwave power is higher…
▽ More
We present the characterization of commercial tunnel diode low-level microwave power detectors at room and cryogenic temperatures. The sensitivity as well as the output voltage noise of the tunnel diodes are measured as functions of the applied microwave power, the signal frequency being 10 GHz. We highlight strong variations of the diode characteristics when the applied microwave power is higher than few microwatt. For a diode operating at ${4}$ K, the differential gain increases from ${1,000}$ V/W to about ${4,500}$ V/W when the power passes from ${-30}$ dBm to ${-20}$ dBm. The diode present a white noise floor equivalent to a NEP of ${0.8}$ pW/ ${\sqrt{\mathrm{Hz}}}$ and ${8}$ pW/${ \sqrt{\mathrm{Hz}}}$ at 4 K and 300 K respectively. Its flicker noise is equivalent to a relative amplitude noise power spectral density ${S_α(1~\mathrm{Hz})=-120}$~dB/Hz at ${4}$ K. Flicker noise is 10 dB higher at room temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Characterization of the individual short-term frequency stability of Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators at the 1e-16 level
Authors:
Christophe Fluhr,
Serge Grop,
Benoît Dubois,
Yann Kersalé,
Enrico Rubiola,
Vincent Giordano
Abstract:
We present the characterisation of three Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators using the three-corner-hat method. Easily implemented with commercial components and instruments, this method reveals itself very useful to analyse the frequency stability limitations of these state-of-the-art ultra-stable oscillators. The best unit presents a fractional frequency stability better than 5e-16 at 1 s and below 2…
▽ More
We present the characterisation of three Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators using the three-corner-hat method. Easily implemented with commercial components and instruments, this method reveals itself very useful to analyse the frequency stability limitations of these state-of-the-art ultra-stable oscillators. The best unit presents a fractional frequency stability better than 5e-16 at 1 s and below 2e-16 for integration times less than 5,000s.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Tests of Sapphire Crystals Produced with Different Growth Processes for Ultra-stable Microwave Oscillators
Authors:
Vincent Giordano,
Christophe Fluhr,
Serge Grop,
Benoit Dubois
Abstract:
We present the characterization of 8-12 GHz whispering gallery mode resonators machined in high-quality sapphire crystals elaborated with different growth techniques. These microwave resonators are intended to constitute the reference frequency of ultra-stable Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators. We conducted systematic tests near 4 K on these crystals to determine the unloaded Q-factor and the turnove…
▽ More
We present the characterization of 8-12 GHz whispering gallery mode resonators machined in high-quality sapphire crystals elaborated with different growth techniques. These microwave resonators are intended to constitute the reference frequency of ultra-stable Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillators. We conducted systematic tests near 4 K on these crystals to determine the unloaded Q-factor and the turnover temperature for whispering gallery modes in the 8-12 GHz frequency range. These characterizations show that high quality sapphire crystals elaborated with the Heat Exchange or the Kyropoulos growth technique are both suitable to meet a fractional frequency stability better than 1x10-15 for 1 s to 10.000 s integration times.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Ultra-low phase noise all-optical microwave generation setup based on commercial devices
Authors:
A. Didier,
J. Millo,
S. Grop,
B. Dubois,
E. Bigler,
E. Rubiola,
C. Lacroûte,
Y. Kersalé
Abstract:
In this paper, we present a very simple design based on commercial devices for the all-optical generation of ultra-low phase noise microwave signals. A commercial, fibered femtosecond laser is locked to a laser that is stabilized to a commercial ULE Fabry-Perot cavity. The 10 GHz microwave signal extracted from the femtosecond laser output exhibits a single sideband phase noise…
▽ More
In this paper, we present a very simple design based on commercial devices for the all-optical generation of ultra-low phase noise microwave signals. A commercial, fibered femtosecond laser is locked to a laser that is stabilized to a commercial ULE Fabry-Perot cavity. The 10 GHz microwave signal extracted from the femtosecond laser output exhibits a single sideband phase noise $\mathcal{L}(f)=-104 \ \mathrm{dBc}/\mathrm{Hz}$ at 1 Hz Fourier frequency, at the level of the best value obtained with such "microwave photonics" laboratory experiments \cite{Fortier2011}. Close-to-the-carrier ultra-low phase noise microwave signals will now be available in laboratories outside the frequency metrology field, opening up new possibilities in various domains.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
