-
Breaking Kelvin: Circulation conservation and vortex breakup in MHD at low Magnetic Prandtl Number
Authors:
D. G. Dritschel,
P. H. Diamond,
S. M. Tobias
Abstract:
In this paper we examine the role of weak magnetic fields in breaking Kelvin's circulation theorem and in vortex breakup in two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics for the physically important case of a low magnetic Prandtl number (low $Pm$) fluid. We consider three canonical inviscid solutions for the purely hydrodynamical problem, namely a Gaussian vortex, a circular vortex patch and an elliptical…
▽ More
In this paper we examine the role of weak magnetic fields in breaking Kelvin's circulation theorem and in vortex breakup in two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics for the physically important case of a low magnetic Prandtl number (low $Pm$) fluid. We consider three canonical inviscid solutions for the purely hydrodynamical problem, namely a Gaussian vortex, a circular vortex patch and an elliptical vortex patch. We examine how magnetic fields lead to an initial loss of circulation $Γ$ and attempt to derive scaling laws for the loss of circulation as a function of field strength and diffusion as measured by two non-dimensional parameters. We show that for all cases the loss of circulation depends on the integrated effects of the Lorentz force, with the patch cases leading to significantly greater circulation loss. For the case of the elliptical vortex the loss of circulation depends on the total area swept out by the rotating vortex and so this leads to more efficient circulation loss than for a circular vortex.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Comparison of variational balance models for the rotating shallow water equations
Authors:
David G. Dritschel,
Georg A. Gottwald,
Marcel Oliver
Abstract:
We present an extensive numerical comparison of a family of balance models appropriate to the semi-geostrophic limit of the rotating shallow water equations, and derived by variational asymptotics in Oliver (2006) for small Rossby numbers ${\mathrm{Ro}}$. This family of generalized large-scale semi-geostrophic (GLSG) models contains the $L_1$-model introduced by Salmon (1983) as a special case. We…
▽ More
We present an extensive numerical comparison of a family of balance models appropriate to the semi-geostrophic limit of the rotating shallow water equations, and derived by variational asymptotics in Oliver (2006) for small Rossby numbers ${\mathrm{Ro}}$. This family of generalized large-scale semi-geostrophic (GLSG) models contains the $L_1$-model introduced by Salmon (1983) as a special case. We use these models to produce balanced initial states for the full shallow water equations. We then numerically investigate how well these models capture the dynamics of an initially balanced shallow water flow. It is shown that, whereas the $L_1$-member of the GLSG family is able to reproduce the balanced dynamics of the full shallow water equations on time scales of ${\mathcal{O}}(1/{\mathrm{Ro}})$ very well, all other members develop significant unphysical high wavenumber contributions in the ageostrophic vorticity which spoil the dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
On the Late-Time Behaviour of a Bounded, Inviscid Two-Dimensional Flow
Authors:
David G. Dritschel,
Wanming Qi,
J. B. Marston
Abstract:
Using complementary numerical approaches at high resolution, we study the late-time behaviour of an inviscid, incompressible two-dimensional flow on the surface of a sphere. Starting from a random initial vorticity field comprised of a small set of intermediate wavenumber spherical harmonics, we find that -- contrary to the predictions of equilibrium statistical mechanics -- the flow does not evol…
▽ More
Using complementary numerical approaches at high resolution, we study the late-time behaviour of an inviscid, incompressible two-dimensional flow on the surface of a sphere. Starting from a random initial vorticity field comprised of a small set of intermediate wavenumber spherical harmonics, we find that -- contrary to the predictions of equilibrium statistical mechanics -- the flow does not evolve into a large-scale steady state. Instead, significant unsteadiness persists, characterised by a population of persistent small-scale vortices interacting with a large-scale oscillating quadrupolar vorticity field. Moreover, the vorticity develops a stepped, staircase distribution, consisting of nearly homogeneous regions separated by sharp gradients. The persistence of unsteadiness is explained by a simple point vortex model characterising the interactions between the four main vortices which emerge.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Ergodicity and spectral cascades in point vortex flows on the sphere
Authors:
David G. Dritschel,
Marcello Lucia,
Andrew C. Poje
Abstract:
We present results for the equilibrium statistics and dynamic evolution of moderately large ($n = {\mathcal{O}}(10^2 - 10^3)$) numbers of interacting point vortices on the unit sphere under the constraint of zero mean angular momentum. We consider a binary gas consisting of equal numbers of vortices with positive and negative circulations. When the circulations are chosen to be proportional to…
▽ More
We present results for the equilibrium statistics and dynamic evolution of moderately large ($n = {\mathcal{O}}(10^2 - 10^3)$) numbers of interacting point vortices on the unit sphere under the constraint of zero mean angular momentum. We consider a binary gas consisting of equal numbers of vortices with positive and negative circulations. When the circulations are chosen to be proportional to $1/\sqrt{n}$, the energy probability distribution function, $p(E)$, converges rapidly with $n$ to a function that has a single maximum, corresponding to a maximum in entropy. Ensemble-averaged wavenumber spectra of the nonsingular velocity field induced by the vortices exhibit the expected $k^{-1}$ behavior at small scales for all energies. The spectra at the largest scales vary continuously with the inverse temperature $β$ of the system and show a transition from positively sloped to negatively sloped as $β$ becomes negative. The dynamics are ergodic and, regardless of the initial configuration of the vortices, statistical measures simply relax towards microcanonical ensemble measures at all observed energies. As such, the direction of any cascade process measured by the evolution of the kinetic energy spectrum depends only on the relative differences between the initial spectrum and the ensemble mean spectrum at that energy; not on the energy, or temperature, of the system.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2015; v1 submitted 11 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
A self-similar cascade of instabilities in the surface quasigeostrophic system
Authors:
R. K. Scott,
D. G. Dritschel
Abstract:
We provide numerical evidence for the existence of a cascade of filament instabilities in the surface quasigeostrophic system for atmospheric and oceanic motions near a horizontal boundary. The cascade involves geometrically shrinking spatial and temporal scales and implies the singular collapse of the filament width to zero in a finite time. The numerical method is both spatially and temporally a…
▽ More
We provide numerical evidence for the existence of a cascade of filament instabilities in the surface quasigeostrophic system for atmospheric and oceanic motions near a horizontal boundary. The cascade involves geometrically shrinking spatial and temporal scales and implies the singular collapse of the filament width to zero in a finite time. The numerical method is both spatially and temporally adaptive, permitting the accurate simulation of the evolution over an unprecedented range of spatial scales spanning over ten orders of magnitude. It provides the first convincing demonstration of the cascade, in which the large separation of scales between subsequent instabilities has made previous numerical simulation difficult.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Energy dissipation and resolution of steep gradients in one-dimensional Burgers flows
Authors:
Chuong V. Tran,
David G. Dritschel
Abstract:
Travelling-wave solutions of the inviscid Burgers equation having smooth initial wave profiles of suitable shapes are known to develop shocks (infinite gradients) in finite times. Such singular solutions are characterized by energy spectra that scale with the wave number $k$ as $k^{-2}$. ****
In this study, we carry out an analysis which verifies the dynamical features described above and deri…
▽ More
Travelling-wave solutions of the inviscid Burgers equation having smooth initial wave profiles of suitable shapes are known to develop shocks (infinite gradients) in finite times. Such singular solutions are characterized by energy spectra that scale with the wave number $k$ as $k^{-2}$. ****
In this study, we carry out an analysis which verifies the dynamical features described above and derive upper bounds for $ε$ and $N$. It is found that $ε$ satisfies $ε\le ν^{2α-1}\norm{u_*}_\infty^{2(1-α)} \norm{(-Δ)^{α/2}u_*}^2$, where $α<1$ and $u_*=u(x,t_*)$ is the velocity field at $t=t_*$. Given $ε>0$ in the limit $ν\to0$, this implies that the energy spectrum remains no steeper than $k^{-2}$ in that limit. For the critical $k^{-2}$ scaling, the bound for $ε$ reduces to $ε\le\sqrt{3}k_0\norm{u_0}_\infty\norm{u_0}^2$, where $k_0$ marks the lower end of the inertial range and $u_0=u(x,0)$. This implies $N\le\sqrt{3}L\norm{u_0}_\infty/ν$, where $L$ is the domain size, which is shown to coincide with a rigorous estimate for the number of degrees of freedom defined in terms of local Lyapunov exponents. We demonstrate both analytically and numerically an instance where the $k^{-2}$ scaling is uniquely realizable. The numerics also return $ε$ and $t_*$, consistent with analytic values derived from the corresponding limiting weak solution.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Effective degrees of nonlinearity in a family of generalized models of two-dimensional turbulence
Authors:
Chuong V. Tran,
David G. Dritschel,
Richard K. Scott
Abstract:
We study the small-scale behavior of generalized two-dimensional turbulence governed by a family of model equations, in which the active scalar $θ=(-Δ)^{α/2}ψ$ is advected by the incompressible flow $\u=(-ψ_y,ψ_x)$. The dynamics of this family are characterized by the material conservation of $θ$, whose variance $<θ^2>$ is preferentially transferred to high wave numbers. As this transfer proceed…
▽ More
We study the small-scale behavior of generalized two-dimensional turbulence governed by a family of model equations, in which the active scalar $θ=(-Δ)^{α/2}ψ$ is advected by the incompressible flow $\u=(-ψ_y,ψ_x)$. The dynamics of this family are characterized by the material conservation of $θ$, whose variance $<θ^2>$ is preferentially transferred to high wave numbers. As this transfer proceeds to ever-smaller scales, the gradient $\nablaθ$ grows without bound. This growth is due to the stretching term $(\nablaθ\cdot\nabla)\u$ whose ``effective degree of nonlinearity'' differs from one member of the family to another. This degree depends on the relation between the advecting flow $\u$ and the active scalar $θ$ and is wide ranging, from approximately linear to highly superlinear. Linear dynamics are realized when $\nabla\u$ is a quantity of no smaller scales than $θ$, so that it is insensitive to the direct transfer of the variance of $θ$, which is nearly passively advected. This case corresponds to $α\ge2$, for which the growth of $\nablaθ$ is approximately exponential in time and non-accelerated. For $α<2$, superlinear dynamics are realized as the direct transfer of $<θ^2>$ entails a growth in $\nabla\u$, thereby enhancing the production of $\nablaθ$. This superlinearity reaches the familiar quadratic nonlinearity of three-dimensional turbulence at $α=1$ and surpasses that for $α<1$. The usual vorticity equation ($α=2$) is the border line, where $\nabla\u$ and $θ$ are of the same scale, separating the linear and nonlinear regimes of the small-scale dynamics. We discuss these regimes in detail, with an emphasis on the locality of the direct transfer.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
