-
A posteriori closure of turbulence models: are symmetries preserved ?
Authors:
André Freitas,
Kiwon Um,
Mathieu Desbrun,
Michele Buzzicotti,
Luca Biferale
Abstract:
Turbulence modeling remains a longstanding challenge in fluid dynamics. Recent advances in data-driven methods have led to a surge of novel approaches aimed at addressing this problem. This work builds upon our previous study (arXiv:2411.13194), where we introduced a new closure for a shell model of turbulence using an a posteriori (or solver-in-the-loop) approach. Unlike most deep learning-based…
▽ More
Turbulence modeling remains a longstanding challenge in fluid dynamics. Recent advances in data-driven methods have led to a surge of novel approaches aimed at addressing this problem. This work builds upon our previous study (arXiv:2411.13194), where we introduced a new closure for a shell model of turbulence using an a posteriori (or solver-in-the-loop) approach. Unlike most deep learning-based models, our method explicitly incorporates physical equations into the neural network framework, ensuring that the closure remains constrained by the underlying physics benefiting from enhanced stability and generalizability. In this paper, we further analyze the learned closure, probing its capabilities and limitations. In particular, we look at joint probability density functions to assess whether cross-correlations are well preserved or if just the mean behavior is captured. Additionally, we investigate the scale invariance of multipliers - ratios between adjacent shells - within the inertial range. Although our model excels in reproducing high-order observables such as flatness, it breaks this known symmetry near the cutoff, indicating a fundamental limitation. We discuss the implications of these findings for subgrid-scale modeling in 3D turbulence and outline directions for future research.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Immersed boundary - lattice Boltzmann method for wetting problems
Authors:
Elisa Bellantoni,
Fabio Guglietta,
Francesca Pelusi,
Mathieu Desbrun,
Kiwon Um,
Mihalis Nicolaou,
Nikos Savva,
Mauro Sbragaglia
Abstract:
We develop a mesoscale computational model to describe the interaction of a droplet with a solid. The model is based on the hybrid combination of the immersed boundary and the lattice Boltzmann computational schemes: the former is used to model the non-ideal sharp interface of the droplet coupled with the inner and outer fluids, simulated with the lattice Boltzmann scheme. We further introduce an…
▽ More
We develop a mesoscale computational model to describe the interaction of a droplet with a solid. The model is based on the hybrid combination of the immersed boundary and the lattice Boltzmann computational schemes: the former is used to model the non-ideal sharp interface of the droplet coupled with the inner and outer fluids, simulated with the lattice Boltzmann scheme. We further introduce an interaction force to model the wetting interactions of the droplet with the solid: this interaction force is designed with the key computational advantage of providing a regularization of the interface profile close to the contact line, avoiding abrupt curvature changes that could otherwise cause numerical instabilities. The proposed model substantially improves earlier immersed boundary - lattice Boltzmann models for wetting in that it allows a description of an ample variety of wetting interactions, ranging from hydrophobic to hydrophilic cases, without the need for any pre-calibration study on model parameters to be used. Model validations against theoretical results for droplet shape at equilibrium and scaling laws for droplet spreading dynamics are addressed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025; v1 submitted 26 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Solver-in-the-loop approach to closure of shell models of turbulence
Authors:
André Freitas,
Kiwon Um,
Mathieu Desbrun,
Michele Buzzicotti,
Luca Biferale
Abstract:
This work studies an a posteriori data-driven approach (known as solver-in-the-loop) for sub-grid modeling of a shell model for turbulence. This approach takes advantage of the differentiable physics paradigm of deep learning, allowing a neural network model to interact with the differential equation solver over time during the training process. The closure model is, then, naturally exposed to equ…
▽ More
This work studies an a posteriori data-driven approach (known as solver-in-the-loop) for sub-grid modeling of a shell model for turbulence. This approach takes advantage of the differentiable physics paradigm of deep learning, allowing a neural network model to interact with the differential equation solver over time during the training process. The closure model is, then, naturally exposed to equations-informed input distributions by accounting for prior corrections over the temporal evolution in training. Such a characteristic makes this approach depart from the conventional a priori instantaneous training paradigm and often leads to a more accurate and stable closure model. Our study demonstrates that the closure learned via this a posteriori approach is able to reproduce high-order statistical moments of interest also in closures of high Reynolds number turbulence. Moreover, we investigate the performance of the learned model by experimenting with the effect of unrolling in time, which has remained for the most part unexplored in the literature. Finally, we discuss potential extensions of this approach to Navier-Stokes equations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2025; v1 submitted 20 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
On the coupling between an ideal fluid and immersed particles
Authors:
Henry O. Jacobs,
Tudor S. Ratiu,
Mathieu Desbrun
Abstract:
In this paper we use Lagrange-Poincare reduction to understand the coupling between a fluid and a set of Lagrangian particles that are supposed to simulate it. In particular, we reinterpret the work of Cendra et al. by substituting velocity interpolation from particle velocities for their principal connection. The consequence of writing evolution equations in terms of interpolation is two-fold. Fi…
▽ More
In this paper we use Lagrange-Poincare reduction to understand the coupling between a fluid and a set of Lagrangian particles that are supposed to simulate it. In particular, we reinterpret the work of Cendra et al. by substituting velocity interpolation from particle velocities for their principal connection. The consequence of writing evolution equations in terms of interpolation is two-fold. First, it gives estimates on the error incurred when interpolation is used to derive the evolution of the system. Second, this form of the equations of motion can inspire a family of particle and hybrid particle-spectral methods where the error analysis is "built-in". We also discuss the influence of other parameters attached to the particles, such as shape, orientation, or higher-order deformations, and how they can help with conservation of momenta in the sense of Kelvin's circulation theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2013; v1 submitted 31 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
On the Mathematical Formulation of Radiance
Authors:
Christian Lessig,
Eugene Fiume,
Mathieu Desbrun
Abstract:
Radiance is widely regarded as the principal quantity in light transport theory. Yet, the concept of radiance in use today has remained mostly unchanged since Lambert's work in the 18th century. His formulation of the measurement of light intensity is based on classical differentials, and is known to suffer from several theoretical and practical limitations. After tracing the historic development…
▽ More
Radiance is widely regarded as the principal quantity in light transport theory. Yet, the concept of radiance in use today has remained mostly unchanged since Lambert's work in the 18th century. His formulation of the measurement of light intensity is based on classical differentials, and is known to suffer from several theoretical and practical limitations. After tracing the historic development of radiance and its shortcomings, we provide a modern formulation of light intensity measurements that models radiance as a differential form. We demonstrate the utility of this use of exterior calculus for questions in light transport theory by rigorously deriving the cosine term and the area formulation, without the need for postulates or heuristic arguments. The formulation of radiance as a differential form introduced in this paper hence provides the first step towards a modern theory of light transport.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Geometric, Variational Discretization of Continuum Theories
Authors:
Evan S. Gawlik,
Patrick Mullen,
Dmitry Pavlov,
Jerrold E. Marsden,
Mathieu Desbrun
Abstract:
This study derives geometric, variational discretizations of continuum theories arising in fluid dynamics, magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), and the dynamics of complex fluids. A central role in these discretizations is played by the geometric formulation of fluid dynamics, which views solutions to the governing equations for perfect fluid flow as geodesics on the group of volume-preserving diffeomorphi…
▽ More
This study derives geometric, variational discretizations of continuum theories arising in fluid dynamics, magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), and the dynamics of complex fluids. A central role in these discretizations is played by the geometric formulation of fluid dynamics, which views solutions to the governing equations for perfect fluid flow as geodesics on the group of volume-preserving diffeomorphisms of the fluid domain. Inspired by this framework, we construct a finite-dimensional approximation to the diffeomorphism group and its Lie algebra, thereby permitting a variational temporal discretization of geodesics on the spatially discretized diffeomorphism group. The extension to MHD and complex fluid flow is then made through an appeal to the theory of Euler-Poincaré systems with advection, which provides a generalization of the variational formulation of ideal fluid flow to fluids with one or more advected parameters. Upon deriving a family of structured integrators for these systems, we test their performance via a numerical implementation of the update schemes on a cartesian grid. Among the hallmarks of these new numerical methods are exact preservation of momenta arising from symmetries, automatic satisfaction of solenoidal constraints on vector fields, good long-term energy behavior, robustness with respect to the spatial and temporal resolution of the discretization, and applicability to irregular meshes.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Variational Integrators for Maxwell's Equations with Sources
Authors:
Ari Stern,
Yiying Tong,
Mathieu Desbrun,
Jerrold E. Marsden
Abstract:
In recent years, two important techniques for geometric numerical discretization have been developed. In computational electromagnetics, spatial discretization has been improved by the use of mixed finite elements and discrete differential forms. Simultaneously, the dynamical systems and mechanics communities have developed structure-preserving time integrators, notably variational integrators t…
▽ More
In recent years, two important techniques for geometric numerical discretization have been developed. In computational electromagnetics, spatial discretization has been improved by the use of mixed finite elements and discrete differential forms. Simultaneously, the dynamical systems and mechanics communities have developed structure-preserving time integrators, notably variational integrators that are constructed from a Lagrangian action principle. Here, we discuss how to combine these two frameworks to develop variational spacetime integrators for Maxwell's equations. Extending our previous work, which first introduced this variational perspective for Maxwell's equations without sources, we also show here how to incorporate free sources of charge and current.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2008;
originally announced March 2008.
-
Geometric Computational Electrodynamics with Variational Integrators and Discrete Differential Forms
Authors:
Ari Stern,
Yiying Tong,
Mathieu Desbrun,
Jerrold E. Marsden
Abstract:
In this paper, we develop a structure-preserving discretization of the Lagrangian framework for electromagnetism, combining techniques from variational integrators and discrete differential forms. This leads to a general family of variational, multisymplectic numerical methods for solving Maxwell's equations that automatically preserve key symmetries and invariants.
In doing so, we demonstrate…
▽ More
In this paper, we develop a structure-preserving discretization of the Lagrangian framework for electromagnetism, combining techniques from variational integrators and discrete differential forms. This leads to a general family of variational, multisymplectic numerical methods for solving Maxwell's equations that automatically preserve key symmetries and invariants.
In doing so, we demonstrate several new results, which apply both to some well-established numerical methods and to new methods introduced here. First, we show that Yee's finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) scheme, along with a number of related methods, are multisymplectic and derive from a discrete Lagrangian variational principle. Second, we generalize the Yee scheme to unstructured meshes, not just in space but in 4-dimensional spacetime. This relaxes the need to take uniform time steps, or even to have a preferred time coordinate at all. Finally, as an example of the type of methods that can be developed within this general framework, we introduce a new asynchronous variational integrator (AVI) for solving Maxwell's equations. These results are illustrated with some prototype simulations that show excellent energy and conservation behavior and lack of spurious modes, even for an irregular mesh with asynchronous time stepping.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2009; v1 submitted 30 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
