-
Women in academia: a warning on selection bias in gender studies from the astronomical perspective
Authors:
M. L. L. Dantas,
E. Cameron,
Rafael S. de Souza,
A. R. da Silva,
A. L. Chies-Santos,
C. Heneka,
P. R. T. Coelho,
A. Ederoclite,
I. S. Beloto,
V. Branco,
Morgan S. Camargo,
V. M. Carvalho de Oliveira,
C. de Sá-Freitas,
G. Gonçalves,
T. A. Pacheco,
Isabel Rebollido
Abstract:
The recent paper by AlShebli et al. (2020) investigates the impact of mentorship in young scientists. Among their conclusions, they state that female protégés benefit more from male than female mentorship. We herein expose a critical flaw in their methodological design that is a common issue in Astronomy, namely "selection biases". An effect that if not treated properly may lead to unwarranted cau…
▽ More
The recent paper by AlShebli et al. (2020) investigates the impact of mentorship in young scientists. Among their conclusions, they state that female protégés benefit more from male than female mentorship. We herein expose a critical flaw in their methodological design that is a common issue in Astronomy, namely "selection biases". An effect that if not treated properly may lead to unwarranted causality claims. In their analysis, selection biases seem to be present in the response rate of their survey (8.35%), the choice of database, success criterion, and the overlook of the numerous drawbacks female researchers face in academia. We discuss these issues and their implications -- one of them being the potential increase in obstacles for women in academia. Finally, we reinforce the dangers of not considering selection bias effects in studies aimed at retrieving causal relations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Analysis of the relevance of the filtered radiative transfer equation terms for large eddy simulation of turbulence-radiation interaction
Authors:
Maxime Roger,
Pedro Coelho,
Carlos Da Silva
Abstract:
An analysis of the turbulence-radiation interaction in the framework of large eddy simulation (LES) is presented. Direct numerical simulation (DNS) of statistical steady forced homogeneous isotropic turbulence is used to evaluate the relevance of the unclosed terms of the filtered radiative transfer equation (RTE) and to study the influence of parameters like the optical thickness and the turbulen…
▽ More
An analysis of the turbulence-radiation interaction in the framework of large eddy simulation (LES) is presented. Direct numerical simulation (DNS) of statistical steady forced homogeneous isotropic turbulence is used to evaluate the relevance of the unclosed terms of the filtered radiative transfer equation (RTE) and to study the influence of parameters like the optical thickness and the turbulence intensity. LES without subgrid-scale models of the filtered RTE has also been investigated. Neglecting the subgrid-scale fluctuations of radiation has proved to be an accurate assumption in various cases, especially for the absorption terms of radiation. However, turbulence-radiation interaction effects increase significantly with the optical thickness based on the size of the filter or with the turbulence intensity, and consequently subgrid-scale modelling should be developed in cases where the optical thickness is not thin and the turbulence intensity higher than 20%.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
A Flexible Fitness Function for Community Detection in Complex Networks
Authors:
Fabricio Olivetti de Franca,
Guilherme Palermo Coelho
Abstract:
Most community detection algorithms from the literature work as optimization tools that minimize a given \textit{fitness function}, while assuming that each node belongs to a single community. Since there is no hard concept of what a community is, most proposed fitness functions focus on a particular definition. As such, these functions do not always lead to partitions that correspond to those obs…
▽ More
Most community detection algorithms from the literature work as optimization tools that minimize a given \textit{fitness function}, while assuming that each node belongs to a single community. Since there is no hard concept of what a community is, most proposed fitness functions focus on a particular definition. As such, these functions do not always lead to partitions that correspond to those observed in practice. This paper proposes a new flexible fitness function that allows the identification of communities with distinct characteristics. Such flexibility was evaluated through the adoption of an immune-inspired optimization algorithm, named cob-aiNet[C], to identify both disjoint and overlapping communities in a set of benchmark networks. The results have shown that the obtained partitions are much closer to the ground-truth than those obtained by the optimization of the modularity function.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
