-
Numerical study of the Transverse Diffusion coefficient for a one component model of plasma
Authors:
Lorenzo Valvo,
Andrea Carati
Abstract:
In this paper we discuss the results of some Molecular Dynamics simulations of a magnetized One Component Plasma, targeted to estimate the diffusion coefficient $D_{\perp}$ in the plane orthogonal to the magnetic field lines. We find that there exists a threshold with respect to the magnetic field strength $|\vec B|$: for weak magnetic field the diffusion coefficients scales as $1/|\vec B|^2$, whi…
▽ More
In this paper we discuss the results of some Molecular Dynamics simulations of a magnetized One Component Plasma, targeted to estimate the diffusion coefficient $D_{\perp}$ in the plane orthogonal to the magnetic field lines. We find that there exists a threshold with respect to the magnetic field strength $|\vec B|$: for weak magnetic field the diffusion coefficients scales as $1/|\vec B|^2$, while a slower decay appears at high field strength. The relation of this transition with the different mixing properties of the microscopic dynamics is investigated by looking at the behavior of the velocity auto correlation.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Nonuniqueness of nonrunaway solutions of Abraham-Lorentz-Dirac equation in an external laser pulse
Authors:
A. Carati,
M. Stroppi
Abstract:
In the paper \cite{carati95} it was shown that, for motions on a line under the action of a potential barrier, the third-order Abraham-Lorentz-Dirac equation presents the phenomenon of nonuniqueness of nonrunaway solutions. Namely, at least for a sufficiently steep barrier, the physical solutions of the equation are not determined by the "mechanical state" of position and velocity, and knowledge o…
▽ More
In the paper \cite{carati95} it was shown that, for motions on a line under the action of a potential barrier, the third-order Abraham-Lorentz-Dirac equation presents the phenomenon of nonuniqueness of nonrunaway solutions. Namely, at least for a sufficiently steep barrier, the physical solutions of the equation are not determined by the "mechanical state" of position and velocity, and knowledge of the initial acceleration too is required. Due to recent experiments, both in course and planned, on the interactions between strong laser pulses and ultra relativistic electrons, it becomes interesting to establish whether such a nonuniqueness phenomenon extends to the latter case, and for which ranges of the parameters. In the present work we will consider just the simplest model, i.e., the case of an electromagnetic plane wave, and moreover for the Abraham-Lorentz-Dirac equation dealt with in the nonrelativistic approximation. The result we found is that the nonuniqueness phenomenon occurs if, at a given frequency of the incoming wave, the field intensity is sufficiently large. An analytic estimate of such a threshold is also given. At the moment it is unclear whether such a phenomenon applies also in the full relativistic case, which is the one of physical interest.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2020; v1 submitted 7 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Tsallis distributions, their relaxations and the relation $Δt \cdot ΔE \simeq h$, in the dynamical fluctuations of a classical model of a crystal
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Luigi Galgani,
Fabrizio Gangemi,
Roberto Gangemi
Abstract:
We report the results of a numerical investigation, performed in the frame of dynamical systems' theory, for a realistic model of a ionic crystal for which, due to the presence of long--range Coulomb interactions, the Gibbs distribution is not well defined. Taking initial data with a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution for the mode-energies $E_k$, we study the dynamical fluctuations, computing the modu…
▽ More
We report the results of a numerical investigation, performed in the frame of dynamical systems' theory, for a realistic model of a ionic crystal for which, due to the presence of long--range Coulomb interactions, the Gibbs distribution is not well defined. Taking initial data with a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution for the mode-energies $E_k$, we study the dynamical fluctuations, computing the moduli of the the energy-changes $|E_k(t)-E_k(0)|$. The main result is that they follow Tsallis distributions, which relax to distributions close to Maxwell-Boltzmann ones; indications are also given that the system remains correlated. The relaxation time $τ$ depends on specific energy $\varepsilon$, and for the curve $τ$ vs, $\varepsilon$ one has two results. First, there exists an energy threshold $\varepsilon_0$, above which the curve has the form $$
τ\cdot \varepsilon \simeq h\ , $$ where, unexpectedly, Planck's constant $h$ shows up. In terms of the standard deviation $ΔE$ of a mode-energy (for which one has $ΔE=\varepsilon$), denoting by $Δt$ the relaxation time $τ$, the relation reads $Δt \cdot ΔE \simeq h$, which reminds of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. Moreover, the threshold corresponds to zero-point energy. Indeed, the quantum value of the latter is $hν/2$ ( where $ν$ is the characterisic infrared frequency of the system), while we find $\varepsilon \simeq hν/4$, so that one only has a discrepancy of a factor 2. So it seems that lack of full chaoticity manifests itself, in Statistical Thermodynamics, through quantum-like phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Chemical bond by Newtonian trajectories in the $H_2^+$ ion
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Luigi Galgani,
Fabrizio Gangemi,
Roberto Gangemi
Abstract:
According to the correspondence principle, classical mechanics and quantum mechanics agree in the semiclassical limit, although presently it has become more and more clear how intriguing would be to try to fix a boundary between them. Here we give a significant example in which the agreement concerns Newtonian trajectories of an electron with initial data corresponding to a quantum ground state. T…
▽ More
According to the correspondence principle, classical mechanics and quantum mechanics agree in the semiclassical limit, although presently it has become more and more clear how intriguing would be to try to fix a boundary between them. Here we give a significant example in which the agreement concerns Newtonian trajectories of an electron with initial data corresponding to a quantum ground state. The example is the simplest case in which a chemical bond occurs, i.e. the $H_2^+$ ion. By molecular dynamics simulations for the full system (two protons and one electron) we show that there exist initial data producing an ``effective potential'' among the protons, which superposes in a surprisingly good way the quantum one computed in the Born-Oppenheimer approximation (Fig~1). Preliminarily, following the perturbation procedure first exhibited by Born and Heisenberg in the year 1924, we recall why an effective potential should exist in a classical frame, and also describe the numerical procedure employed in computing it.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Approach to equilibrium via Tsallis distributions in a realistic ionic--crystal model and in the FPU model
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Luigi Galgani,
Fabrizio Gangemi,
Roberto Gangemi
Abstract:
In Statistical Mechanics, Tsallis distributions were apparently conceived in connection with systems presenting long--range interactions. In fact, they were observed in numerical computations for models of such a type, as occurring in the approach to equilibrium, i.e., to a Maxwell--Boltzmann distribution. Here we exhibit two apparently new results. The first one is that Tsallis distributions occu…
▽ More
In Statistical Mechanics, Tsallis distributions were apparently conceived in connection with systems presenting long--range interactions. In fact, they were observed in numerical computations for models of such a type, as occurring in the approach to equilibrium, i.e., to a Maxwell--Boltzmann distribution. Here we exhibit two apparently new results. The first one is that Tsallis distributions occur also in an ionic--crystal model with long--range Coulomb forces, which is so realistic as to reproduce in an impressively good way the experimental infrared spectra. Thus such distributions may be expected to be actual physical features of crystals. The second result is that Tsallis distributions occur in the standard short--range FPU model too, so that the presence of long--range interactions is not a necessary condition for Tsallis distributions to occur. In fact, this is in agreement with a previous result of the first author in connection with the statistics of return times for the classical FPU model. We thus confirm the thesis advanced by Tsallis himself, that the relevant property for a dynamical system to present Tsallis distributions is that its dynamics should be not fully chaotic, a property which is known to actually pertain to long--range systems.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Relaxation times and ergodicity properties in a realistic ionic--crystal model, and the modern form of the FPU problem
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Luigi Galgani,
Fabrizio Gangemi,
Roberto Gangemi
Abstract:
It is well known that Gibbs' statistical mechanics is not justified for systems presenting long-range interactions, such as plasmas or galaxies. In a previous work we considered a realistic FPU-like model of an ionic crystal (and thus with long-range interactions), and showed that it reproduces the experimental infrared spectra from 1000 K down to 7 K, provided one abandons the Gibbs identificatio…
▽ More
It is well known that Gibbs' statistical mechanics is not justified for systems presenting long-range interactions, such as plasmas or galaxies. In a previous work we considered a realistic FPU-like model of an ionic crystal (and thus with long-range interactions), and showed that it reproduces the experimental infrared spectra from 1000 K down to 7 K, provided one abandons the Gibbs identification of temperature in terms of specific kinetic energy, at low temperatures. Here we investigate such a model in connection with its ergodicity properties. The conclusion we reach is that at low temperatures ergodicity does not occur, and thus the Gibbs prescriptions are not dynamically justified, up to geological time scales. We finally give a preliminary result indicating how the so-called `nonclassical' q-statistics show up in the realistic ionic-crystal model. How to formulate a consistent statistical mechanics, with the corresponding suitable identification of temperature in such nonergodicity conditions, remains an open problem, which apparently constitutes the modern form of the FPU problem.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Classical infrared spectra of ionic crystals and their relevance for statistical mechanics
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Luigi Galgani,
Alberto Maiocchi,
Roberto Gangemi,
Fabrizio Gangemi
Abstract:
It was recently shown that the experimental infrared spectra of ionic crystals at room temperature are very well reproduced by classical realistic models, and here new results are reported on the temperature dependence of the spectra, for the LiF crystal. The principal aim of the present work is however to highlight the deep analogy existing between the problem of spectra in ionic crystal models o…
▽ More
It was recently shown that the experimental infrared spectra of ionic crystals at room temperature are very well reproduced by classical realistic models, and here new results are reported on the temperature dependence of the spectra, for the LiF crystal. The principal aim of the present work is however to highlight the deep analogy existing between the problem of spectra in ionic crystal models on the one hand, and that of energy equipartition in the Fermi--Pasta--Ulam model, on the other. Indeed at low temperatures the computations of the spectra show that the dynamics of the considered system is not completely chaotic, so that the use of the Boltzmann--Gibbs statistics is put in question, as in the Fermi--Pasta--Ulam case. Here, however, at variance with the equipartition problem, a first positive indication is given on the modifications that should be introduced in a classical statistical treatment: the new results at low temperatures show that it is indeed the Clausius identification of temperature that has to be modified. In fact, at very low temperatures the theoretical spectra fail to reproduce the experimental ones, if the temperature is taken as proportional to mean kinetic energy, but agreement is recovered through the only expedient of introducing a suitable temperature rescaling. Analogous results are also found in connection with thermal expansion.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Chopping time of the FPU $α$-model
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Antonio Ponno
Abstract:
We study, both numerically and analytically, the time needed to observe the breaking of an FPU $α$-chain in two or more pieces, starting from an unbroken configuration at a given temperature. It is found that such a "chopping" time is given by a formula that, at low temperatures, is of the Arrhenius-Kramers form, so that the chain does not break up on an observable time-scale. The result explains…
▽ More
We study, both numerically and analytically, the time needed to observe the breaking of an FPU $α$-chain in two or more pieces, starting from an unbroken configuration at a given temperature. It is found that such a "chopping" time is given by a formula that, at low temperatures, is of the Arrhenius-Kramers form, so that the chain does not break up on an observable time-scale. The result explains why the study of the FPU problem is meaningful also in the ill-posed case of the $α$-model
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Infrared optical properties of $α$ quartz by molecular dynamics simulations
Authors:
Fabrizio Gangemi,
Roberto Gangemi,
Andrea Carati,
Alberto Maiocchi,
Luigi Galgani
Abstract:
This paper is concerned with theoretical estimates of the refractive--index curves for quartz, obtained by the Kubo formulæ in the classical approximation, through MD simulations for the motions of the ions. Two objectives are considered. The first one is to understand the role of nonlinearities in situations where they are very large, as at the $α$--$β$ structural phase transition. We show that o…
▽ More
This paper is concerned with theoretical estimates of the refractive--index curves for quartz, obtained by the Kubo formulæ in the classical approximation, through MD simulations for the motions of the ions. Two objectives are considered. The first one is to understand the role of nonlinearities in situations where they are very large, as at the $α$--$β$ structural phase transition. We show that on the one hand they don't play an essential role in connection with the form of the spectra in the infrared. On the other hand they play an essential role in introducing a chaoticity which involves a definite normal mode. This might explain why that mode is Raman active in the $α$ phase, but not in the $β$ phase. The second objective concerns whether it is possible in a microscopic model to obtain normal mode frequencies, or peak frequencies in the optical spectra, that are in good agreement with the experimental data for quartz. Notwithstanding a lot of effort, we were unable to find results agreeing better than about 6%, as apparently also occurs in the whole available literature. We interpret this fact as indicating that some essential qualitative feature is lacking in all models which consider, as the present one, only short--range repulsive potentials and unretarded long--range electric forces.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Numerical study of the Transverse Diffusion coefficient for a one component model of a plasma
Authors:
Lorenzo Valvo,
Andrea Carati
Abstract:
We report the results of MD numerical simulations for a one component model of a plasma in the weakly coupled regime, at different values of temperature $T$ and applied magnetic field $\vec B$, in which the diffusion coefficient $D_{\perp}$ transverse to the field is estimated. We find that there exists a threshold in temperature, at which an inversion occurs, namely, for $T$ above the threshold t…
▽ More
We report the results of MD numerical simulations for a one component model of a plasma in the weakly coupled regime, at different values of temperature $T$ and applied magnetic field $\vec B$, in which the diffusion coefficient $D_{\perp}$ transverse to the field is estimated. We find that there exists a threshold in temperature, at which an inversion occurs, namely, for $T$ above the threshold the diffusion coefficient $D_{\perp}$ starts decreasing as $T$ increases. This is at variance with the behavior predicted by the Bohm law $D_{\perp}\sim T/B$, which actually holds below the threshold. In addition we find that, for temperatures above such a threshold, another transition occurs, now with respect to the values of the magnetic field: for weak magnetic fields the diffusion coefficients scales as $1/B^2$, in agreement with the predictions of the standard kinetics theory, while it apparently saturates when the field strength is sufficiently increased.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
A replacement of the Lorentz law for the shape of the spectral lines in the infrared region
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Alberto Maiocchi
Abstract:
We propose a new phenomenological law for the shape of the spectral lines in the infrared, which accounts for the exponential decay of the extinction coefficient in the high frequency region, observed in many spectra. We apply this law to the measured infrared spectra of LiF, NaCl and MgF$_2$, finding a good agreement, over a wide range of frequencies.
We propose a new phenomenological law for the shape of the spectral lines in the infrared, which accounts for the exponential decay of the extinction coefficient in the high frequency region, observed in many spectra. We apply this law to the measured infrared spectra of LiF, NaCl and MgF$_2$, finding a good agreement, over a wide range of frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Classical microscopic theory of dispersion, emission and absorption of light in dielectrics
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Luigi Galgani
Abstract:
This paper is a continuation of a recent one in which, apparently for the first time, the existence of polaritons in ionic crystals was proven in a microscopic electrodynamic theory. This was obtained through an explicit computation of the dispersion curves. Here the main further contribution consists in studying electric susceptibility, from which the spectrum can be inferred. We show how suscept…
▽ More
This paper is a continuation of a recent one in which, apparently for the first time, the existence of polaritons in ionic crystals was proven in a microscopic electrodynamic theory. This was obtained through an explicit computation of the dispersion curves. Here the main further contribution consists in studying electric susceptibility, from which the spectrum can be inferred. We show how susceptibility is obtained by the Green--Kubo methods of Hamiltonian statistical mechanics, and give for it a concrete expression in terms of time--correlation functions. As in the previous paper, here too we work in a completely classical framework, in which the electrodynamic forces acting on the charges are all taken into account, both the retarded forces and the radiation reaction ones. So, in order to apply the methods of statistical mechanics, the system has to be previously reduced to a Hamiltonian one. This is made possible in virtue of two global properties of classical electrodynamics, namely, the Wheeler--Feynman identity and the Ewald resummation properties, the proofs of which were already given for ordered system. The second contribution consists in formulating the theory in a completely general way, so that in principle it applies also to disordered systems such as glasses, or liquids or gases, provided the two general properties mentioned above continue to hold. A first step in this direction is made here by providing a completely general proof of the Wheeler--Feynman identity, which is shown to be the counterpart of a general causality property of classical electrodynamics. Finally it is shown how a line spectrum can appear at all in classical systems, as a counterpart of suitable stability properties of the motions, with a broadening due to a coexistence of chaoticity.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Proof of concept of a zinc-silver battery for the extraction of energy from a concentration difference
Authors:
M. Marino,
L. Misuri,
A. Carati,
D. Brogioli
Abstract:
The conversion of heat into current can be obtained by a process with two stages. In the first one, the heat is used for distilling a solution and obtaining two flows with different concentrations. In the second stage, the two flows are sent to an electrochemical cell that produces current by consuming the concentration difference. In this paper, we propose such an electrochemical cell, working wi…
▽ More
The conversion of heat into current can be obtained by a process with two stages. In the first one, the heat is used for distilling a solution and obtaining two flows with different concentrations. In the second stage, the two flows are sent to an electrochemical cell that produces current by consuming the concentration difference. In this paper, we propose such an electrochemical cell, working with water solutions of zinc chloride. The cell contains two electrodes, made respectively of zinc and silver covered by silver chloride. The operation of the cell is analogous to that of the capacitive mixing and of the "mixing entropy battery": the electrodes are charged while dipped in the concentrated solution and discharged when dipped in the diluted solution. The cyclic operation allows us to extract a surplus of energy, at the expense of the free energy of the concentration difference. We evaluate the feasibility of such a cell for practical applications, and find that a power up to 2 W per square meter of surface of the electrodes can be achieved.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Classical microscopic theory of polaritons in ionic crystals
Authors:
A. Lerose,
A. Sanzeni,
A Carati,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
It is well known that the optical branches of the dispersion curves of ionic crystals exhibit a polaritonic feature, i.e., a splitting about the electromagnetic dispersion line $ω=ck$. This phenomenon is considered to be due to the retardation of the electromagnetic forces among the ions. However, the problem is usually discussed at a phenomenological level, through the introduction of a macroscop…
▽ More
It is well known that the optical branches of the dispersion curves of ionic crystals exhibit a polaritonic feature, i.e., a splitting about the electromagnetic dispersion line $ω=ck$. This phenomenon is considered to be due to the retardation of the electromagnetic forces among the ions. However, the problem is usually discussed at a phenomenological level, through the introduction of a macroscopic polarization field, so that a microscopic treatment is apparently lacking. A microscopic first principles deduction is given here, in a classical frame, for a model in which the ions are dealt with as point charges. At a qualitative level it is made apparent that retardation is indeed responsible for the splitting. A quantitative comparison with the empirical data for LiF is also given, showing a fairly good agreement over the whole Brillouin zone.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Theoretical thermodynamic analysis of a closed-cycle process for the conversion of heat into electrical energy by means of a distiller and an electrochemical cell
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Massimo Marino,
Doriano Brogioli
Abstract:
We analyse a device aimed at the conversion of heat into electrical energy, based on a closed cycle in which a distiller generates two solutions at different concentrations, and an electrochemical cell consumes the concentration difference, converting it into electrical current. We first study an ideal model of such a process. We show that, if the device works at a single fixed pressure (i.e. with…
▽ More
We analyse a device aimed at the conversion of heat into electrical energy, based on a closed cycle in which a distiller generates two solutions at different concentrations, and an electrochemical cell consumes the concentration difference, converting it into electrical current. We first study an ideal model of such a process. We show that, if the device works at a single fixed pressure (i.e. with a ``single effect''), then the efficiency of the conversion of heat into electrical power can approach the efficiency of a reversible Carnot engine operating between the boiling temperature of the concentrated solution and that of the pure solvent. When two heat reservoirs with a higher temperature difference are available, the overall efficiency can be incremented by employing an arrangement of multiple cells working at different pressures (``multiple effects''). We find that a given efficiency can be achieved with a reduced number of effects by using solutions with a high boiling point elevation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2014; v1 submitted 14 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Transition to chaos in magnetized, weakly coupled plasmas
Authors:
Andrea Carati,
Francesco Benfenati,
Alberto Maiocchi,
Luigi Galgani,
Matteo Zuin
Abstract:
We report the results of numerical simulations for a model of a one component plasma (a system of N point electrons with mutual Coulomb interactions) in a uniform stationary magnetic field. We take N up to 512, with periodic boundary conditions, and macroscopic parameters corresponding to the weak coupling regime, with a coupling parameter Γ=1/64. We find that a transition from order to chaos take…
▽ More
We report the results of numerical simulations for a model of a one component plasma (a system of N point electrons with mutual Coulomb interactions) in a uniform stationary magnetic field. We take N up to 512, with periodic boundary conditions, and macroscopic parameters corresponding to the weak coupling regime, with a coupling parameter Γ=1/64. We find that a transition from order to chaos takes place when the density is increased or the field decreased so that the ratio ω_p/ω_c between plasma and cyclotron frequencies becomes of order 1 (or equivalently the ratio r_L/λ_D between Larmor radius and Debye length becomes of order 1). The result is in agreement with the theoretical prediction obtained in [1], on the basis of an old estimate of Iglesias, Lebowitz and MacGowan [2] for the intensity of the electric field acting on one electron and due to all the other ones. A comparison can be made with the threshold obtained from kinetic theory arguments, which corresponds to the condition ν_{ee}/ω_c=1, where ν_{ee} is the electron collision frequency. The latter threshold has a completely different dependence on the physical parameters and, for Γ=1/64, gives a critical value of ω_p about 80 times larger.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Transition from order to chaos, and density limit, in magnetized plasmas
Authors:
A. Carati,
M. Zuin,
A. Maiocchi,
M. Marino,
E. Martines,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
It is known that a plasma in a magnetic field, conceived microscopically as a system of point charges, can exist in a magnetized state, and thus remain confined, inasmuch as it is in an ordered state of motion, with the charged particles performing gyrational motions transverse to the field. Here we give an estimate of a threshold, beyond which transverse motion become chaotic, the electrons being…
▽ More
It is known that a plasma in a magnetic field, conceived microscopically as a system of point charges, can exist in a magnetized state, and thus remain confined, inasmuch as it is in an ordered state of motion, with the charged particles performing gyrational motions transverse to the field. Here we give an estimate of a threshold, beyond which transverse motion become chaotic, the electrons being unable to perform even one gyration, so that a breakdown should occur, with complete loss of confinement. The estimate is obtained by the methods of perturbation theory, taking as perturbing force acting on each electron that due to the so--called microfield, i.e., the electric field produced by all the other charges. We first obtain a general relation for the threshold, which involves the fluctuations of the microfield. Then, taking for such fluctuations the fomula given by Iglesias, Lebowitz and MacGowan for the model of a one component plasma with neutralizing background, we obtain a definite formula for the threshold, which corresponds to a density limit increasing as the square of the imposed magnetic field. Such a theoretical density limit is found to fit pretty well the empirical data for collapses of fusion machines.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Density limit in a first principles model of a magnetized plasma in the Debye--Hückel approximation
Authors:
A. Carati,
M. Zuin,
A. Maiocchi,
M. Marino,
E. Martines,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
A crucial problem concerning a large variety of fusion devices is that the confinement due to an external magnetic field is lost above a critical density, while a widely accepted first principles explanation of such a fact is apparently lacking. In the present paper, making use of standard methods of statistical mechanics in the Debye--Hückel approximation, we give indications that for a plasma th…
▽ More
A crucial problem concerning a large variety of fusion devices is that the confinement due to an external magnetic field is lost above a critical density, while a widely accepted first principles explanation of such a fact is apparently lacking. In the present paper, making use of standard methods of statistical mechanics in the Debye--Hückel approximation, we give indications that for a plasma there exists a density threshold corresponding to a transition from order to chaos, the ordered motions being those in which the confining Lorentz force on a single electron prevails over the diffusive effect of the Coulomb forces. The density limit, which is proportional to the square of the magnetic field, turns out to fit not too badly the empirical data for plasma collapses in a large set of fusion devices.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
A microscopic instability in neutral magnetized plasmas
Authors:
M. Marino,
M. Zuin,
A. Carati,
E. Martines,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
We show that in a neutral magnetized plasma there exist microscopic oscillatory modes, with wavelengths of the order of magnitude of the mean interparticle distance, which become unstable when the electron density exceeds a limit proportional to the square of the magnetic field. The model we consider is just a linearization of the classical one for neutral plasmas, namely a system of electrons sub…
▽ More
We show that in a neutral magnetized plasma there exist microscopic oscillatory modes, with wavelengths of the order of magnitude of the mean interparticle distance, which become unstable when the electron density exceeds a limit proportional to the square of the magnetic field. The model we consider is just a linearization of the classical one for neutral plasmas, namely a system of electrons subjected to Coulomb interactions among themselves and with a uniform positive neutralizing background. This model is here dealt with as an actual many-body problem, without introducing any averaging over the individual particles. The expression of the density limit coincides, apart possibly from a numerical factor of order one, with the well-known Brillouin density limit for a nonneutral plasma, which has however a macroscopic origin. The density limit here found has the same order of magnitude as the operational density limit observed in several conventional tokamak devices. We finally show that, when the full electromagnetic interactions are taken into account, dispersion relations are obtained which for short wavelengths reduce to those obtained here in the purely Coulomb case, and for long wavelengths reproduce the familiar ones of MHD.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2010; v1 submitted 5 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
A first principles explanation for the density limit in magnetized plasmas
Authors:
M. Zuin,
A. Carati,
M. Marino,
E. Martines,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
Fusion research on magnetic confinement is confronted with a severe problem concerning the electron densities ne to be used in fusion devices. Indeed, high densities are mandatory for obtaining large efficiencies, whereas it is empirically found that catastrophic disruptive events occur for densities exceeding a maximal one n^M_e. On the other hand, despite the large theoretical work there is no…
▽ More
Fusion research on magnetic confinement is confronted with a severe problem concerning the electron densities ne to be used in fusion devices. Indeed, high densities are mandatory for obtaining large efficiencies, whereas it is empirically found that catastrophic disruptive events occur for densities exceeding a maximal one n^M_e. On the other hand, despite the large theoretical work there is no widely accepted, first principles model for the density limit (see [1], abstract). Here, we propose a simple microscopic model of a magnetized plasma suited for a tokamak, for which the existence of a density limit is proven. This property turns out to be a general collective feature of electrodynamics of point charges, which is lost in the continuum approximation. The law we find is n^M_e = 1.74 1/(me c^2) B^2/ μ_0, (1), where μ_0 is the vacuum permeability, c the speed of light, me the electron mass, and B the magnetic field. As shown in Fig. 1, the theoretical limit (big circles) is in rather good agreement with the empirical data, actually a surprisingly good one for a model based on first principles, with no adjustable parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2010; v1 submitted 25 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Classical light dispersion theory in a regular lattice
Authors:
M. Marino,
A. Carati,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
We study the dynamics of an infinite regular lattice of classical charged oscillators. Each individual oscillator is described as a point particle subject to a harmonic restoring potential, to the retarded electromagnetic field generated by all the other particles, and to the radiation reaction expressed according to the Lorentz--Dirac equation. Exact normal mode solutions, describing the propag…
▽ More
We study the dynamics of an infinite regular lattice of classical charged oscillators. Each individual oscillator is described as a point particle subject to a harmonic restoring potential, to the retarded electromagnetic field generated by all the other particles, and to the radiation reaction expressed according to the Lorentz--Dirac equation. Exact normal mode solutions, describing the propagation of plane electromagnetic waves through the lattice, are obtained for the complete linearized system of infinitely many oscillators. At variance with all the available results, our method is valid for any values of the frequency, or of the ratio between wavelength and lattice parameter. A remarkable feature is that the proper inclusion of radiation reaction in the dynamics of the individual oscillators does not give rise to any extinction coefficient for the global normal modes of the lattice. The dispersion relations resulting from our solution are numerically studied for the case of a simple cubic lattice. New predictions are obtained in this way about the behavior of the crystal at frequencies near the proper oscillation frequency of the dipoles.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2010; v1 submitted 15 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Nonradiating normal modes in a classical many-body model of matter radiation interaction
Authors:
A. Carati,
L. Galgani
Abstract:
We consider a classical model of matter--radiation interaction, in which the matter is represented by a system of infinitely many dipoles on a one--dimensional lattice, and the system is dealt with in the so--called dipole (i.e. linearized) approximation. We prove that there exist normal--mode solutions of the complete system, so that in particular the dipoles, though performing accelerated moti…
▽ More
We consider a classical model of matter--radiation interaction, in which the matter is represented by a system of infinitely many dipoles on a one--dimensional lattice, and the system is dealt with in the so--called dipole (i.e. linearized) approximation. We prove that there exist normal--mode solutions of the complete system, so that in particular the dipoles, though performing accelerated motions, do not radiate energy away. This comes about in virtue of an exact compensation which we prove to occur, for each dipole, between the ``radiation reaction force'' and a part of the retarded forces due to all the other dipoles. This fact corresponds to a certain identity which we name after Oseen, since it occurs that this researcher did actually propose it, already in the year 1916. We finally make a connection with a paper of Wheeler and Feynman on the foundations of electrodynamics. It turns out indeed that the Oseen identity, which we prove here in a particular model, is in fact a weak form of a general identity that such authors were assuming as an independent postulate.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2003;
originally announced December 2003.
