-
Turbulence in Earth's core generates large topographic torques on the mantle
Authors:
Tobias G. Oliver,
Eric G. Blackman,
John A. Tarduno,
Michael A. Calkins
Abstract:
Seismic and geodynamic studies indicate that the boundary between the Earth's liquid outer core and solid mantle is not spherical, but is likely characterized by topography in the form of inverted mountains and valleys that have typical amplitudes of several kilometers. One of the dynamical consequences of these deformations is that turbulent flow in the core can exert pressure torques on the mant…
▽ More
Seismic and geodynamic studies indicate that the boundary between the Earth's liquid outer core and solid mantle is not spherical, but is likely characterized by topography in the form of inverted mountains and valleys that have typical amplitudes of several kilometers. One of the dynamical consequences of these deformations is that turbulent flow in the core can exert pressure torques on the mantle, thereby resulting in a transfer of angular momentum between the outer core and the mantle. Understanding this transfer of angular momentum is important for explaining variations in the Earth's rotation rate, or length of day. Whether kilometer-sized topography can explain observed variations in length of day is a longstanding question in geophysics. Here we use a suite of state-of-the-art numerical simulations of hydrodynamic convection in a rotating spherical shell with boundary topography to show that topographic torques exhibit a linear dependence on topographic amplitude and approach a quadratic dependence on flow speeds. This observation is explained with the asymptotic theory of rapidly rotating convection. These results imply that topographic torques are of sufficient magnitude to explain length of day variations.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025; v1 submitted 25 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
A numerical investigation of quasi-static magnetoconvection with an imposed horizontal magnetic field
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Talal AlRefae,
Angel Hernandez,
Ming Yan,
Stefano Maffei
Abstract:
Quasi-static Rayleigh-Bénard convection with an imposed horizontal magnetic field is investigated numerically for Chandrasekhar numbers up to $Q=10^6$ with stress free boundary conditions. Both $Q$ and the Rayleigh number ($Ra$) are varied to identify the various dynamical regimes that are present in this system. We find three primary regimes: (I) a two-dimensional (2D) regime in which the axes of…
▽ More
Quasi-static Rayleigh-Bénard convection with an imposed horizontal magnetic field is investigated numerically for Chandrasekhar numbers up to $Q=10^6$ with stress free boundary conditions. Both $Q$ and the Rayleigh number ($Ra$) are varied to identify the various dynamical regimes that are present in this system. We find three primary regimes: (I) a two-dimensional (2D) regime in which the axes of the convection rolls are oriented parallel to the imposed magnetic field; (II) an anisotropic three-dimensional (3D) regime; and (III) a mean flow regime characterized by a large scale horizontal flow directed transverse to the imposed magnetic field. The transition to 3D dynamics is preceded by a series of 2D transitions in which the number of convective rolls decreases as $Ra$ is increased. For sufficiently large $Q$, there is an eventual transition to two rolls just prior to the 2D/3D transition. The 2D/3D transition occurs when inertial forces become comparable to the Lorentz force, i.e. when $\sqrt{Q}/Re = O(1)$; 2D, magnetically constrained states persist when $\sqrt{Q}/Re \gtrsim O(1)$. Within the 2D regime we find heat and momentum transport scalings that are consistent with the hydrodynamic asymptotic predictions of Chini and Cox [Phys. Fluids \textbf{21}, 083603 (2009)]: the Nusselt number ($Nu$) and Reynolds number ($Re$) scale as $Nu \sim Ra^{1/3}$ and $Re \sim Ra^{2/3}$, respectively. For $Q=10^6$, we find that the scaling behavior of $Nu$ and $Re$ breaks down at large values of $Ra$ due to a sequence of bifurcations and the eventual manifestation of mean flows.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Asymptotic scaling relations for rotating spherical convection with strong zonal flows
Authors:
Justin A. Nicoski,
Anne R. O'Connor,
Michael A. Calkins
Abstract:
We analyse the results of direct numerical simulations of rotating convection in spherical shell geometries with stress-free boundary conditions, which develop strong zonal flows. Both the Ekman number and the Rayleigh number are varied. We find that the asymptotic theory for rapidly rotating convection can be used to predict the Ekman number dependence of each term in the governing equations, alo…
▽ More
We analyse the results of direct numerical simulations of rotating convection in spherical shell geometries with stress-free boundary conditions, which develop strong zonal flows. Both the Ekman number and the Rayleigh number are varied. We find that the asymptotic theory for rapidly rotating convection can be used to predict the Ekman number dependence of each term in the governing equations, along with the convective flow speeds and the dominant length scales. Using a balance between the Reynolds stress and the viscous stress, together with the asymptotic scaling for the convective velocity, we derive an asymptotic prediction for the scaling behaviour of the zonal flow with respect to the Ekman number, which is supported by the numerical simulations. We do not find evidence of distinct asymptotic scalings for the buoyancy and viscous forces and, in agreement with previous results from asymptotic plane layer models, we find that the ratio of the viscous force to the buoyancy force increases with Rayleigh number. Thus, viscosity remains non-negligible and we do not observe a trend towards a diffusion-free scaling behaviour within the rapidly rotating regime.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Small scale quasi-geostrophic convective turbulence at large Rayleigh number
Authors:
Tobias G. Oliver,
Adrienne S. Jacobi,
Keith Julien,
Michael A. Calkins
Abstract:
A numerical investigation of an asymptotically reduced model for quasi-geostrophic Rayleigh-Bénard convection is conducted in which the depth-averaged flows are numerically suppressed by modifying the governing equations. The Reynolds number and Nusselt number show evidence of approaching the diffusion-free scalings of $Re \sim Ra E/Pr$ and $Nu \sim Pr^{-1/2} Ra^{3/2} E^2$, respectively, where…
▽ More
A numerical investigation of an asymptotically reduced model for quasi-geostrophic Rayleigh-Bénard convection is conducted in which the depth-averaged flows are numerically suppressed by modifying the governing equations. The Reynolds number and Nusselt number show evidence of approaching the diffusion-free scalings of $Re \sim Ra E/Pr$ and $Nu \sim Pr^{-1/2} Ra^{3/2} E^2$, respectively, where $E$ is the Ekman number and $Pr$ is the Prandtl number. For large $Ra$, the presence of depth-invariant flows, such as large-scale vortices, yield heat and momentum transport scalings that exceed those of the diffusion-free scaling laws. The Taylor microscale does not vary significantly with increasing $Ra$, whereas the integral length scale grows weakly. The computed length scales remain $O(1)$ with respect to the linearly unstable critical wavenumber; we therefore conclude that these scales remain viscously controlled. We do not find a point-wise Coriolis-Inertia-Archimedean (CIA) force balance in the turbulent regime; interior dynamics are instead dominated by horizontal advection (inertia), vortex stretching (Coriolis) and the vertical pressure gradient. A secondary, sub-dominant balance between the buoyancy force and the viscous force occurs in the interior and the ratio of the rms of these two forces is found to approach unity with increasing $Ra$. This secondary balance is attributed to the turbulent fluid interior acting as the dominant control on the heat transport. These findings indicate that a pointwise CIA balance does not occur in the high Rayleigh number regime of quasi-geostrophic convection in the plane layer geometry. Instead, simulations are characterized by what may be termed a \textsl{non-local} CIA balance in which the buoyancy force is dominant within the thermal boundary layers and is spatially separated from the interior Coriolis and inertial forces.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2023; v1 submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Asymptotic behaviour of rotating convection-driven dynamos in the plane layer geometry
Authors:
Ming Yan,
Michael A. Calkins
Abstract:
Dynamos driven by rotating convection in the plane layer geometry are investigated numerically for a range of Ekman number ($E$), magnetic Prandtl number ($Pm$) and Rayleigh number ($Ra$). The primary purpose of the investigation is to compare results of the simulations with previously developed asymptotic theory that is applicable in the limit of rapid rotation. We find that all of the simulation…
▽ More
Dynamos driven by rotating convection in the plane layer geometry are investigated numerically for a range of Ekman number ($E$), magnetic Prandtl number ($Pm$) and Rayleigh number ($Ra$). The primary purpose of the investigation is to compare results of the simulations with previously developed asymptotic theory that is applicable in the limit of rapid rotation. We find that all of the simulations are in the quasi-geostrophic regime in which the Coriolis and pressure gradient forces are approximately balanced at leading order, whereas all other forces, including the Lorentz force, act as perturbations. Agreement between simulation output and asymptotic scalings for the energetics, flow speeds, magnetic field amplitude and length scales is found. The transition from large scale dynamos to small scale dynamos is well described by the magnetic Reynolds number based on the small convective length scale, $\widetilde{Rm}$, with large scale dynamos preferred when $\widetilde{Rm} \lesssim O(1)$. The magnitude of the large scale magnetic field is observed to saturate and become approximately constant with increasing Rayleigh number. Energy spectra show that all length scales present in the flow field and the small-scale magnetic field are consistent with a scaling of $E^{1/3}$, even in the turbulent regime. For a fixed value of $E$, we find that the viscous dissipation length scale is approximately constant over a broad range of $Ra$; the ohmic dissipation length scale is approximately constant within the large scale dynamo regime, but transitions to a $\widetilde{Rm}^{-1/2}$ scaling in the small scale dynamo regime.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2022; v1 submitted 2 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Quasi-static magnetoconvection with a tilted magnetic field
Authors:
Justin A. Nicoski,
Ming Yan,
Michael A. Calkins
Abstract:
A numerical study of convection with stress-free boundary conditions in the presence of an imposed magnetic field that is tilted with respect to the direction of gravity is carried out in the limit of small magnetic Reynolds number. The dynamics are investigated over a range of Rayleigh number $Ra$ and Chandrasekhar numbers up to $Q = 2\times10^6$, with the tilt angle between the gravity vector an…
▽ More
A numerical study of convection with stress-free boundary conditions in the presence of an imposed magnetic field that is tilted with respect to the direction of gravity is carried out in the limit of small magnetic Reynolds number. The dynamics are investigated over a range of Rayleigh number $Ra$ and Chandrasekhar numbers up to $Q = 2\times10^6$, with the tilt angle between the gravity vector and imposed magnetic field vector fixed at $45^{\circ}$. For a fixed value of $Q$ and increasing $Ra$, the convection dynamics can be broadly characterized by three primary flow regimes: (1) quasi-two-dimensional convection rolls near the onset of convection; (2) isolated convection columns aligned with the imposed magnetic field; and (3) unconstrained convection reminiscent of non-magnetic convection. The influence of varying $Q$ and $Ra$ on the various fields is analyzed. Heat and momentum transport, as characterized by the Nusselt and Reynolds numbers, are quantified and compared with the vertical field case. Ohmic dissipation dominates over viscous dissipation in all cases investigated. Various mean fields are investigated and their scaling behavior is analyzed. Provided $Ra$ is sufficiently large, all investigated values of $Q$ exhibit an inverse kinetic energy cascade that yields strong `zonal' flows. Relaxation oscillations, as characterized by a quasi-periodic shift in the predominance of either the zonal or non-zonal component of the mean flow, appear for sufficiently large $Ra$ and $Q$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2021; v1 submitted 27 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Strong large scale magnetic fields in rotating convection-driven dynamos: the important role of magnetic diffusion
Authors:
Ming Yan,
Michael A. Calkins
Abstract:
Natural dynamos such as planets and stars generate global scale magnetic field despite the inferred presence of small scale turbulence. Such systems are known as large scale dynamos and are typically driven by convection and influenced by rotation. Previous numerical studies of rotating dynamos generally find that the large scale magnetic field becomes weaker as the flow becomes more turbulent. Th…
▽ More
Natural dynamos such as planets and stars generate global scale magnetic field despite the inferred presence of small scale turbulence. Such systems are known as large scale dynamos and are typically driven by convection and influenced by rotation. Previous numerical studies of rotating dynamos generally find that the large scale magnetic field becomes weaker as the flow becomes more turbulent. The underlying physical processes necessary for sustaining so-called large scale dynamos is therefore still debated. Here we use a suite of numerical simulations to show that strong large scale magnetic fields can be generated in rotating convective turbulence provided that two conditions are satisfied: (1) the flow remains rotationally constrained; and (2) magnetic diffusion is important on the small convective length scale. These findings are in agreement with previous asymptotic predictions and suggest that natural dynamos might satisfy these two conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2022; v1 submitted 6 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Efficiency gains of a multi-scale integration method applied to a scale-separated model for rapidly rotating dynamos
Authors:
Krasymyr Tretiak,
Meredith Plumley,
Michael Calkins,
Steven Tobias
Abstract:
Numerical geodynamo simulations with parameters close to an Earth-like regime would be of great interest for understanding the dynamics of the Earth's liquid outer core and the associated geomagnetic field. Such simulations are far too computationally demanding owing to the large range in spatiotemporal scales. This paper explores the application of a multi-scale timestepping method to an asymptot…
▽ More
Numerical geodynamo simulations with parameters close to an Earth-like regime would be of great interest for understanding the dynamics of the Earth's liquid outer core and the associated geomagnetic field. Such simulations are far too computationally demanding owing to the large range in spatiotemporal scales. This paper explores the application of a multi-scale timestepping method to an asymptotic model for the generation of magnetic field in the fluid outer core of the Earth. The method is based on the heterogeneous multiscale modelling (HMM) strategy, which incorporates scale separation and utilizes several integrating models for the fast and slow fields. Quantitative comparisons between the multi-scale simulations and direct solution of the asymptotic model in the limit of rapid rotation and low Ekman number are performed. The multi-scale method accurately captures the varying temporal and spatial dynamics of the mean magnetic field at lower computational costs compared to the direct solution of the asymptotic model.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2021; v1 submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
On the inverse cascade and flow speed scaling behavior in rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection
Authors:
S. Maffei,
M. J. Krouss,
K. Julien,
M. A. Calkins
Abstract:
Rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection is investigated numerically with the use of an asymptotic model that captures the rapidly rotating, small Ekman number limit, $Ek \rightarrow 0$. The Prandtl number ($Pr$) and the asymptotically scaled Rayleigh number ($\widetilde{Ra} = Ra Ek^{4/3}$, where $Ra$ is the typical Rayleigh number) are varied systematically. For sufficiently vigorous convection, an in…
▽ More
Rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection is investigated numerically with the use of an asymptotic model that captures the rapidly rotating, small Ekman number limit, $Ek \rightarrow 0$. The Prandtl number ($Pr$) and the asymptotically scaled Rayleigh number ($\widetilde{Ra} = Ra Ek^{4/3}$, where $Ra$ is the typical Rayleigh number) are varied systematically. For sufficiently vigorous convection, an inverse kinetic energy cascade leads to the formation of a depth-invariant large-scale vortex (LSV). With respect to the kinetic energy, we find a transition from convection dominated states to LSV dominated states at an asymptotically reduced (small-scale) Reynolds number of $\widetilde{Re} \approx 6$ for all investigated values of $Pr$. The ratio of the depth-averaged kinetic energy to the kinetic energy of the convection reaches a maximum at $\widetilde{Re} \approx 24$, then decreases as $\widetilde{Ra}$ is increased. This decrease in the relative kinetic energy of the LSV is associated with a decrease in the convective correlations with increasing Rayleigh number. The scaling behavior of the convective flow speeds is studied; although a linear scaling of the form $\widetilde{Re} \sim \widetilde{Ra}/Pr$ is observed over a limited range in Rayleigh number and Prandtl number, a clear departure from this scaling is observed at the highest accessible values of $\widetilde{Ra}$. Calculation of the forces present in the governing equations shows that the ratio of the viscous force to the buoyancy force is an increasing function of $\widetilde{Ra}$, that approaches unity over the investigated range of parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Heat transfer and flow regimes in quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field
Authors:
Ming Yan,
Michael A. Calkins,
Stefano Maffei,
Keith Julien,
Steven M. Tobias,
Philippe Marti
Abstract:
Numerical simulations of quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field are carried out up to a Chandrasekhar number of $Q=10^8$ over a broad range of Rayleigh numbers $Ra$. Three magnetoconvection regimes are identified: two of the regimes are magnetically-constrained in the sense that a leading-order balance exists between the Lorentz and buoyancy forces, whereas the third regime…
▽ More
Numerical simulations of quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field are carried out up to a Chandrasekhar number of $Q=10^8$ over a broad range of Rayleigh numbers $Ra$. Three magnetoconvection regimes are identified: two of the regimes are magnetically-constrained in the sense that a leading-order balance exists between the Lorentz and buoyancy forces, whereas the third regime is characterized by unbalanced dynamics that is similar to non-magnetic convection. Each regime is distinguished by flow morphology, momentum and heat equation balances, and heat transport behavior. One of the magnetically-constrained regimes appears to represent an `ultimate' magnetoconvection regime in the dual limit of asymptotically-large buoyancy forcing and magnetic field strength; this regime is characterized by an interconnected network of anisotropic, spatially-localized fluid columns aligned with the direction of the imposed magnetic field that remain quasi-laminar despite having large flow speeds. As for non-magnetic convection, heat transport is controlled primarily by the thermal boundary layer. Empirically, the scaling of the heat transport and flow speeds with $Ra$ appear to be independent of the thermal Prandtl number within the magnetically-constrained, high-$Q$ regimes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2019; v1 submitted 31 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Magnetic quenching of the inverse cascade in rapidly rotating convective turbulence
Authors:
Stefano Maffei,
Michael A. Calkins,
Keith Julien,
Philippe D. Marti
Abstract:
We present results from an asymptotic magnetohydrodynamic model that is suited for studying the rapidly rotating, low viscosity regime typical of the electrically conducting fluid interiors of planets and stars. We show that the presence of sufficiently strong magnetic fields prevents the formation of large-scale vortices and saturates the inverse cascade at a finite length-scale. This saturation…
▽ More
We present results from an asymptotic magnetohydrodynamic model that is suited for studying the rapidly rotating, low viscosity regime typical of the electrically conducting fluid interiors of planets and stars. We show that the presence of sufficiently strong magnetic fields prevents the formation of large-scale vortices and saturates the inverse cascade at a finite length-scale. This saturation corresponds to an equilibrated state in which the energetics of the depth-averaged flows are characterized by a balance of convective power input and ohmic dissipation. A quantitative criteria delineating the transition between finite-size flows and domain-filling (large-scale) vortices in electrically conducting fluids is found. By making use of the inferred and observed properties of planetary interiors, our results suggest that convection-driven large-scale vortices do not form in the electrically conducting regions of many bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2019; v1 submitted 9 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Prandtl-Number Effects in High-Rayleigh-Number Spherical Convection
Authors:
Ryan J. Orvedahl,
Michael A. Calkins,
Nicholas A. Featherstone,
Bradley W. Hindman
Abstract:
Convection is the predominant mechanism by which energy and angular momentum are transported in the outer portion of the Sun. The resulting overturning motions are also the primary energy source for the solar magnetic field. An accurate solar dynamo model therefore requires a complete description of the convective motions, but these motions remain poorly understood. Studying stellar convection num…
▽ More
Convection is the predominant mechanism by which energy and angular momentum are transported in the outer portion of the Sun. The resulting overturning motions are also the primary energy source for the solar magnetic field. An accurate solar dynamo model therefore requires a complete description of the convective motions, but these motions remain poorly understood. Studying stellar convection numerically remains challenging; it occurs within a parameter regime that is extreme by computational standards. The fluid properties of the convection zone are characterized in part by the Prandtl number $\mathrm{Pr}=ν/κ$, where $ν$ is the kinematic viscosity and $κ$ is the thermal diffusion; in stars, $\mathrm{Pr}$ is extremely low, $\mathrm{Pr}\approx 10^{-7}$. The influence of $\mathrm{Pr}$ on the convective motions at the heart of the dynamo is not well understood since most numerical studies are limited to using $\mathrm{Pr}\approx1$. We systematically vary $\mathrm{Pr}$ and the degree of thermal forcing, characterized through a Rayleigh number, to explore its influence on the convective dynamics. For sufficiently large thermal driving, the simulations reach a so-called convective free-fall state where diffusion no longer plays an important role in the interior dynamics. Simulations with a lower $\mathrm{Pr}$ generate faster convective flows and broader ranges of scales for equivalent levels of thermal forcing. Characteristics of the spectral distribution of the velocity remain largely insensitive to changes in $\mathrm{Pr}$. Importantly, we find that $\mathrm{Pr}$ plays a key role in determining when the free-fall regime is reached by controlling the thickness of the thermal boundary layer.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Inertia-less convectively-driven dynamo models in the limit of low Rossby number and large Prandtl number
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Keith Julien,
Steven M. Tobias
Abstract:
Compositional convection is thought to be an important energy source for magnetic field generation within planetary interiors. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, characterizing compositional convection is significantly larger than unity, suggesting that the inertial force may not be important on the small scales of convection as long as the buoyancy force is not too strong. We develop asymptotic dynamo mod…
▽ More
Compositional convection is thought to be an important energy source for magnetic field generation within planetary interiors. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, characterizing compositional convection is significantly larger than unity, suggesting that the inertial force may not be important on the small scales of convection as long as the buoyancy force is not too strong. We develop asymptotic dynamo models for the case of small Rossby number and large Prandtl number in which inertia is absent on the convective scale. The relevant diffusivity parameter for this limit is the compositional Roberts number, $q = D/η$, which is the ratio of compositional and magnetic diffusivities. Dynamo models are developed for both order one $q$ and the more geophysically relevant low $q$ limit. For both cases the ratio of magnetic to kinetic energy densities, $M$, is asymptotically large and reflects the fact that Alfvén waves have been filtered from the dynamics. Along with previous investigations of asymptotic dynamo models for $Pr=O(1)$, our results show that the ratio $M$ is not a useful indicator of dominant force balances in the momentum equation since many different asymptotic limits of $M$ can be obtained without changing the leading order geostrophic balance. Furthermore, the present models show that inertia is not a requirement for driving low $q$, large-scale dynamos.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2017; v1 submitted 13 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Convection-driven kinematic dynamos at low Rossby and magnetic Prandtl numbers
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Louie Long,
David Nieves,
Keith Julien,
Steven M. Tobias
Abstract:
Most large-scale planetary magnetic fields are thought to be driven by low Rossby number convection of a low magnetic Prandtl number fluid. Here kinematic dynamo action is investigated with an asymptotic, rapidly rotating dynamo model for the plane layer geometry that is intrinsically low magnetic Prandtl number. The thermal Prandtl number and Rayleigh number are varied to illustrate fundamental c…
▽ More
Most large-scale planetary magnetic fields are thought to be driven by low Rossby number convection of a low magnetic Prandtl number fluid. Here kinematic dynamo action is investigated with an asymptotic, rapidly rotating dynamo model for the plane layer geometry that is intrinsically low magnetic Prandtl number. The thermal Prandtl number and Rayleigh number are varied to illustrate fundamental changes in flow regime, ranging from laminar cellular convection to geostrophic turbulence in which an inverse energy cascade is present. A decrease in the efficiency of the convection to generate a dynamo, as determined by an increase in the critical magnetic Reynolds number, is observed as the buoyancy forcing is increased. This decreased efficiency may result from both the loss of correlations associated with the increasingly disordered states of flow that are generated, and boundary layer behavior that enhances magnetic diffusion locally. We find that the spatial characteristics of $α$, and thus the large-scale magnetic field, is dependent only weakly on changes in flow behavior. However, our results are limited to the linear, kinematic dynamo regime, and future simulations including the Lorentz force are therefore necessary to assess the robustness of this result. In contrast to the large-scale magnetic field, the behavior of the small-scale magnetic field is directly dependent on, and therefore shows significant variations with, the small-scale convective flow field.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
A nonlinear model for rotationally constrained convection with Ekman pumping
Authors:
Keith Julien,
Jonathan M. Aurnou,
Michael A. Calkins,
Edgar Knobloch,
Philippe Marti,
Stephan Stellmach,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
It is a well established result of linear theory that the influence of differing mechanical boundary conditions, i.e., stress-free or no-slip, on the primary instability in rotating convection becomes asymptotically small in the limit of rapid rotation. This is accounted for by the diminishing impact of the viscous stresses exerted within Ekman boundary layers and the associated vertical momentum…
▽ More
It is a well established result of linear theory that the influence of differing mechanical boundary conditions, i.e., stress-free or no-slip, on the primary instability in rotating convection becomes asymptotically small in the limit of rapid rotation. This is accounted for by the diminishing impact of the viscous stresses exerted within Ekman boundary layers and the associated vertical momentum transport by Ekman pumping. By contrast, in the nonlinear regime recent experiments and supporting simulations are now providing evidence that the efficiency of heat transport remains strongly influenced by Ekman pumping in the rapidly rotating limit. In this paper, a reduced model is developed for the case of low Rossby number convection in a plane layer geometry with no-slip upper and lower boundaries held at fixed temperatures. A complete description of the dynamics requires the existence of three distinct regions within the fluid layer: a geostrophically balanced interior where fluid motions are predominately aligned with the axis of rotation, Ekman boundary layers immediately adjacent to the bounding plates, and thermal wind layers driven by Ekman pumping in between. The reduced model uses a classical Ekman pumping parameterization to alleviate the need for spatially resolving the Ekman boundary layers. Results are presented for both linear stability theory and a special class of nonlinear solutions described by a single horizontal spatial wavenumber. It is shown that Ekman pumping allows for significant enhancement in the heat transport relative to that observed in simulations with stress-free boundaries. Without the intermediate thermal wind layer the nonlinear feedback from Ekman pumping would be able to generate a heat transport that diverges to infinity. This layer arrests this blowup resulting in finite heat transport at a significantly enhanced value.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Convection-driven kinematic dynamos at low Rossby and magnetic Prandtl numbers: single mode solutions
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Keith Julien,
Steven M. Tobias,
Jonathan M. Aurnou,
Philippe Marti
Abstract:
The onset of dynamo action is investigated within the context of a newly developed low Rossby, low magnetic Prandtl number, convection-driven dynamo model. This multiscale model represents an asymptotically exact form of an $α^2$ mean field dynamo model in which the small-scale convection is represented explicitly by finite amplitude, single mode solutions. Both steady and oscillatory convection a…
▽ More
The onset of dynamo action is investigated within the context of a newly developed low Rossby, low magnetic Prandtl number, convection-driven dynamo model. This multiscale model represents an asymptotically exact form of an $α^2$ mean field dynamo model in which the small-scale convection is represented explicitly by finite amplitude, single mode solutions. Both steady and oscillatory convection are considered for a variety of horizontal planforms. The kinetic helicity is observed to be a monotonically increasing function of the Rayleigh number. As a result, very small magnetic Prandtl number dynamos can be found for sufficiently large Rayleigh numbers. All dynamos are found to be oscillatory with an oscillation frequency that increases as the strength of the convection is increased and the magnetic Prandtl number is reduced. Kinematic dynamo action is strongly controlled by the profile of the helicity; single mode solutions which exhibit boundary layer behavior in the helicity show a decrease in the efficiency of dynamo action due to the enhancement of magnetic diffusion in the boundary layer regions. For a given value of the Rayleigh number, lower magnetic Prandtl number dynamos are excited for the case of oscillatory convection in comparison to steady convection. With regards to planetary dynamos, these results suggest that the low magnetic Prandtl number dynamos typical of liquid metals are more easily driven by thermal convection than by compositional convection.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2016; v1 submitted 19 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
The asymptotic equivalence of fixed heat flux and fixed temperature thermal boundary conditions for rapidly rotating convection
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Kevin Hale,
Keith Julien,
David Nieves,
Derek Driggs,
Philippe Marti
Abstract:
The influence of fixed temperature and fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions on rapidly rotating convection in the plane layer geometry is investigated for the case of stress-free mechanical boundary conditions. It is shown that whereas the leading order system satisfies fixed temperature boundary conditions implicitly, a double boundary layer structure is necessary to satisfy the fixed heat…
▽ More
The influence of fixed temperature and fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions on rapidly rotating convection in the plane layer geometry is investigated for the case of stress-free mechanical boundary conditions. It is shown that whereas the leading order system satisfies fixed temperature boundary conditions implicitly, a double boundary layer structure is necessary to satisfy the fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions. The boundary layers consist of a classical Ekman layer adjacent to the solid boundaries that adjust viscous stresses to zero, and a layer in thermal wind balance just outside the Ekman layers adjusts the temperature such that the fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions are satisfied. The influence of these boundary layers on the interior geostrophically balanced convection is shown to be asymptotically weak, however. Upon defining a simple rescaling of the thermal variables, the leading order reduced system of governing equations are therefore equivalent for both boundary conditions. These results imply that any horizontal thermal variation along the boundaries that varies on the scale of the convection has no leading order influence on the interior convection.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
A Multiscale Dynamo Model Driven by Quasi-geostrophic Convection
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Keith Julien,
Steven M. Tobias,
Jonathan M. Aurnou
Abstract:
A convection-driven multiscale dynamo model is developed in the limit of low Rossby number for the plane layer geometry in which the gravity and rotation vectors are aligned. The small-scale fluctuating dynamics are described by a magnetically-modified quasi-geostrophic equation set, and the large-scale mean dynamics are governed by a diagnostic thermal wind balance. The model utilizes three times…
▽ More
A convection-driven multiscale dynamo model is developed in the limit of low Rossby number for the plane layer geometry in which the gravity and rotation vectors are aligned. The small-scale fluctuating dynamics are described by a magnetically-modified quasi-geostrophic equation set, and the large-scale mean dynamics are governed by a diagnostic thermal wind balance. The model utilizes three timescales that respectively characterize the convective timescale, the large-scale magnetic evolution timescale, and the large-scale thermal evolution timescale. Distinct equations are derived for the cases of order one and low magnetic Prandtl number. It is shown that the low magnetic Prandtl number model is characterized by a magnetic to kinetic energy ratio that is asymptotically large, with ohmic dissipation dominating viscous dissipation on the large-scales. For the order one magnetic Prandtl number model the magnetic and kinetic energies are equipartitioned and both ohmic and viscous dissipation are weak on the large-scales; large-scale ohmic dissipation occurs in thin magnetic boundary layers adjacent to the solid boundaries. For both magnetic Prandtl number cases the Elsasser number is small since the Lorentz force does not enter the leading order force balance. The new models can be considered fully nonlinear, generalized versions of the dynamo model originally developed by Childress and Soward [Phys. Rev. Lett., \textbf{29}, p.837, 1972]. These models may be useful for understanding the dynamics of convection-driven dynamos in regimes that are only just becoming accessible to direct numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2015; v1 submitted 12 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
The Breakdown of the Anelastic Approximation in Rotating Compressible Convection: Implications for Astrophysical Systems
Authors:
Michael A. Calkins,
Keith Julien,
Philippe Marti
Abstract:
The linear theory for rotating compressible convection in a plane layer geometry is presented for the astrophysically-relevant case of low Prandtl number gases. When the rotation rate of the system is large, the flow remains geostrophically balanced for all stratification levels investigated and the classical (i.e., incompressible) asymptotic scaling laws for the critical parameters are recovered.…
▽ More
The linear theory for rotating compressible convection in a plane layer geometry is presented for the astrophysically-relevant case of low Prandtl number gases. When the rotation rate of the system is large, the flow remains geostrophically balanced for all stratification levels investigated and the classical (i.e., incompressible) asymptotic scaling laws for the critical parameters are recovered. For sufficiently small Prandtl numbers, increasing stratification tends to further destabilise the fluid layer, decrease the critical wavenumber and increase the oscillation frequency of the convective instability. In combination, these effects increase the relative magnitude of the time derivative of the density perturbation contained in the conservation of mass equation to non-negligible levels; the resulting convective instabilities occur in the form of compressional quasi-geostrophic oscillations. We find that the anelastic equations, which neglect this term, cannot capture these instabilities and possess spuriously-growing eigenmodes in the rapidly rotating, low Prandtl number regime. It is shown that the Mach number for rapidly rotating compressible convection is intrinsically small for all background states, regardless of the departure from adiabaticity.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2014; v1 submitted 5 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
