-
Direct numerical simulation of complete transition to turbulence with a fluid at supercritical pressure
Authors:
Pietro Carlo Boldini,
Benjamin Bugeat,
Jurriaan W. R. Peeters,
Markus Kloker,
Rene Pecnik
Abstract:
The objective of this work is to investigate the unexplored laminar-to-turbulent transition of a heated flat-plate boundary layer with a fluid at supercritical pressure. Two temperature ranges are considered: a subcritical case, where the fluid remains entirely in the liquid-like regime, and a transcritical case, where the pseudo-critical (Widom) line is crossed and pseudo-boiling occurs. Fully co…
▽ More
The objective of this work is to investigate the unexplored laminar-to-turbulent transition of a heated flat-plate boundary layer with a fluid at supercritical pressure. Two temperature ranges are considered: a subcritical case, where the fluid remains entirely in the liquid-like regime, and a transcritical case, where the pseudo-critical (Widom) line is crossed and pseudo-boiling occurs. Fully compressible direct numerical simulations are used to study (i) the linear and nonlinear instabilities, (ii) the breakdown to turbulence, and (iii) the fully developed turbulent boundary layer. In the transcritical regime, two-dimensional forcing generates not only a train of billow-like structures around the Widom line, resembling Kelvin-Helmholtz instability, but also near-wall travelling regions of flow reversal. These spanwise-oriented billows dominate the early nonlinear stage. When high subharmonic three-dimensional forcing is applied, staggered $Λ$-vortices emerge more abruptly than in the subcritical case. However, unlike the classic H-type breakdown under zero pressure gradient observed in ideal-gas and subcritical regimes, the H-type breakdown is triggered by strong shear layers caused by flow reversals -- similar to that observed in adverse-pressure-gradient boundary layers. Without oblique wave forcing, transition is only slightly delayed and follows a naturally selected fundamental breakdown (K-type) scenario. Hence, in the transcritical regime, it is possible to trigger nonlinearities and achieve transition to turbulence relatively early using only a single two-dimensional wave that strongly amplifies background noise. In the fully turbulent region, we demonstrate that variable-property scaling accurately predicts turbulent skin-friction and heat-transfer coefficients.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Direct Numerical Simulations of K-type transition in a flat-plate boundary layer with supercritical fluids
Authors:
Pietro Carlo Boldini,
Benjamin Bugeat,
Jurriaan W. R. Peeters,
Markus Kloker,
Rene Pecnik
Abstract:
We investigate the controlled K-type breakdown of a flat-plate boundary-layer with highly non-ideal supercritical fluid at a reduced pressure of $p_{r,\infty}=1.10$. Direct numerical simulations are performed at a Mach number of $M_\infty=0.2$ for one subcritical (liquid-like regime) temperature profile and one strongly-stratified transcritical (pseudo-boiling) temperature profile with slightly he…
▽ More
We investigate the controlled K-type breakdown of a flat-plate boundary-layer with highly non-ideal supercritical fluid at a reduced pressure of $p_{r,\infty}=1.10$. Direct numerical simulations are performed at a Mach number of $M_\infty=0.2$ for one subcritical (liquid-like regime) temperature profile and one strongly-stratified transcritical (pseudo-boiling) temperature profile with slightly heated wall. In the subcritical case, the formation of aligned $Λ$-vortices is delayed compared to the reference ideal-gas case of Sayadi et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 724, 2013, pp. 480-509), with steady longitudinal modes dominating the late-transitional stage. When the wall temperature exceeds the pseudo-boiling temperature, streak secondary instabilities lead to the simultaneous development of additional hairpin vortices and near-wall streaky structures near the legs of the primary aligned $Λ$-vortices. Nonetheless, transition to turbulence is not violent and is significantly delayed compared to the subcritical regime.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Transient growth in diabatic boundary layers with fluids at supercritical pressure
Authors:
Pietro Carlo Boldini,
Benjamin Bugeat,
Jurriaan W. R. Peeters,
Markus Kloker,
Rene Pecnik
Abstract:
In the region close to the thermodynamic critical point and in the proximity of the pseudo-boiling (Widom) line, strong property variations substantially alter the growth of modal instabilities, as revealed in Ren et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 871, 2019, pp. 831-864). Here, we study non-modal disturbances in the spatial framework using an eigenvector decomposition of the linearized Navier-Stokes eq…
▽ More
In the region close to the thermodynamic critical point and in the proximity of the pseudo-boiling (Widom) line, strong property variations substantially alter the growth of modal instabilities, as revealed in Ren et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 871, 2019, pp. 831-864). Here, we study non-modal disturbances in the spatial framework using an eigenvector decomposition of the linearized Navier-Stokes equations under the assumption of locally parallel flow. The boundary layers with the fluid at supercritical pressure are heated or cooled by prescribing the wall and free-stream temperatures so that the temperature profile is either entirely subcritical (liquid-like), supercritical (gas-like), or transcritical (across the Widom line). The free-stream Mach number is set to $10^{-3}$. In the non-transcritical regimes, the resulting streamwise-independent streaks originate from the lift-up effect. Wall cooling enhances the energy amplification for both subcritical and supercritical regimes. When the temperature profile is increased beyond the Widom line, a strong sub-optimal growth is observed over very short streamwise distances due to the Orr mechanism. The non-modal growth is put in perspective with modal growth by means of an $N$-factor comparison. In the non-transcritical regimes, modal stability dominates regardless of a wall-temperature variation. In contrast, in the transcritical regime, non-modal $N$-factors are found to resemble the imposition of an adverse pressure gradient in the ideal-gas regime. When cooling beyond the Widom line, optimal growth is greatly enhanced, yet strong inviscid instability prevails. When heating beyond the Widom line, optimal growth could be sufficiently large to favor transition, particularly with a high free-stream turbulence level.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024; v1 submitted 10 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Acoustic resolvent analysis of turbulent jets
Authors:
B. Bugeat,
U. Karban,
A. Agarwal,
L. Lesshafft,
P. Jordan
Abstract:
We perform a resolvent analysis of a compressible turbulent jet, where the optimisation domain of the response modes is located in the acoustic field, excluding the hydrodynamic region, in order to promote acoustically efficient modes. We examine the properties of the acoustic resolvent and assess its potential for jet-noise modelling, focusing on the subsonic regime. Resolvent forcing modes, cons…
▽ More
We perform a resolvent analysis of a compressible turbulent jet, where the optimisation domain of the response modes is located in the acoustic field, excluding the hydrodynamic region, in order to promote acoustically efficient modes. We examine the properties of the acoustic resolvent and assess its potential for jet-noise modelling, focusing on the subsonic regime. Resolvent forcing modes, consistent with previous studies, are found to contain supersonic waves associated with Mach wave radiation in the response modes. This differs from the standard resolvent in which hydrodynamic instabilities dominate. We compare resolvent modes with SPOD modes educed from LES data. Acoustic resolvent response modes generally have better alignment with acoustic SPOD modes than standard resolvent response modes. For the optimal mode, the angle of the acoustic beam is close to that found in SPOD modes for moderate frequencies. However, there is no significant separation between the singular values of the leading and sub-optimal modes. Some suboptimal modes are furthermore shown to contain irrelevant structure for jet noise. Thus, even though it contains essential acoustic features absent from the standard resolvent approach, the SVD of the acoustic resolvent alone is insufficient to educe a low-rank model for jet noise. But because it identifies the prevailing mechanisms of jet noise, it provides valuable guidelines in the search of a forcing model (Karban \textit{et al.} An empirical model of noise sources in subsonic jets. \textit{Journal of Fluid Mechanics} (2023): A18).
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024; v1 submitted 9 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The steady behavior of the supercritical carbon dioxide natural circulation loop
Authors:
Marko Draskic,
Benjamin Bugeat,
Rene Pecnik
Abstract:
The steady state behavior of thermodynamically supercritical natural circulation loops (NCLs) is investigated in this work. Experimental steady state results with supercritical carbon dioxide are presented for reduced pressures in the range of 1.1-1.5, and temperatures in the range of 20-65 °C. Distinct thermodynamic states are reached by traversing a set of isochors. A generalized equation for th…
▽ More
The steady state behavior of thermodynamically supercritical natural circulation loops (NCLs) is investigated in this work. Experimental steady state results with supercritical carbon dioxide are presented for reduced pressures in the range of 1.1-1.5, and temperatures in the range of 20-65 °C. Distinct thermodynamic states are reached by traversing a set of isochors. A generalized equation for the prediction of the steady state is presented, and its performance is assessed using empirical data. Changes of mass flow rate as a result of changes of thermodynamic state, heating- and driving height are shown to be accurately captured by the proposed predictive equation. However, the enhanced viscous losses in the instrumentation of the loop and in the proximity of heat transfer equipment are shown to significantly limit the steady state flow rate. Subsequently, the findings are put forward in aid of the development of safe, novel supercritical natural circulation facilities.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023; v1 submitted 18 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Instability in strongly stratified plane Couette flow with application to supercritical fluids
Authors:
B. Bugeat,
P. C. Boldini,
A. M. Hasan,
R. Pecnik
Abstract:
This paper addresses the stability of plane Couette flow in the presence of strong density and viscosity stratifications. It demonstrates the existence of a generalised inflection point that satisfies the generalised Fjortoft's criterion of instability when a minimum of kinematic viscosity is present in the base flow. The characteristic scales associated with this minimum are identified as the pri…
▽ More
This paper addresses the stability of plane Couette flow in the presence of strong density and viscosity stratifications. It demonstrates the existence of a generalised inflection point that satisfies the generalised Fjortoft's criterion of instability when a minimum of kinematic viscosity is present in the base flow. The characteristic scales associated with this minimum are identified as the primary controlling parameters of the associated instability, regardless of the type of stratification. To support this finding, analytical stability models are derived in the long wave approximation using piecewise linear base flows. Numerical stability calculations are carried out to validate these models and to provide further information on the production of disturbance vorticity. All instabilities are interpreted as arising from the interaction between two vorticity waves. Depending on the type of stratification, these two waves are produced by different physical mechanisms. When both strong density and viscosity stratifications are present, we show that they result from the concurrent action of shear and inertial baroclinic effects. The stability models developed for simple fluid models ultimately shed light on a recently observed unstable mode in supercritical fluids (Ren et al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 871, 2019, pp. 831-864), providing a quantitative prediction of the stability diagram and identifying the dominant mechanisms at play. Furthermore, our study suggests that the minimum of kinematic viscosity reached at the Widom line in these fluids is the leading cause of their instability. The existence of similar instabilities in different fluids and flows (e.g., miscible fluids) is finally discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2024; v1 submitted 9 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
An empirical model of noise sources in subsonic jets
Authors:
Ugur Karban,
Benjamin Bugeat,
Aaron Towne,
Lutz Lesshafft,
Anurag Agarwal,
Peter Jordan
Abstract:
Modelling the noise emitted by turbulent jets is made difficult by their acoustic inefficiency: only a tiny fraction of the near-field turbulent kinetic energy is propagated to the far field as acoustic waves. As a result, jet-noise models must accurately capture this small, acoustically efficient component hidden among comparatively inefficient fluctuations. In this paper, we identify this acoust…
▽ More
Modelling the noise emitted by turbulent jets is made difficult by their acoustic inefficiency: only a tiny fraction of the near-field turbulent kinetic energy is propagated to the far field as acoustic waves. As a result, jet-noise models must accurately capture this small, acoustically efficient component hidden among comparatively inefficient fluctuations. In this paper, we identify this acoustically efficient near-field source from large-eddy-simulation data and use it to inform a predictive model. Our approach uses the resolvent framework, in which the source takes the form of nonlinear fluctuation terms that act as a forcing on the linearized Navier-Stokes equations. First, we identify the forcing that, when acted on by the resolvent operator, produces the leading spectral proper orthogonal decomposition modes in the acoustic field for a Mach 0.4 jet. Second, the radiating components of this forcing are isolated by retaining only portions with a supersonic phase speed. This component makes up less than 0.05% of the total forcing energy but generates most of the acoustic response, especially at peak (downstream) radiation angles. Finally, we propose an empirical model for the identified acoustically efficient forcing components. The model is tested at other Mach numbers and flight-stream conditions and predicts noise within 2 dB accuracy for a range of frequencies, downstream angles, and flight conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Low-frequency resolvent analysis of the laminar oblique shock wave / boundary layer interaction
Authors:
B. Bugeat,
J. -C. Robinet,
J. -C. Chassaing,
P. Sagaut
Abstract:
Resolvent analysis is used to study the low-frequency behaviour of the laminar oblique shock wave / boundary layer interaction (SWBLI). It is shown that the computed optimal gain, which can be seen as a transfer function of the system, follows a first-order low-pass filter equation, recovering the results of Touber and Sandham (JFM, 2011). This behaviour is understood as proceeding from the excita…
▽ More
Resolvent analysis is used to study the low-frequency behaviour of the laminar oblique shock wave / boundary layer interaction (SWBLI). It is shown that the computed optimal gain, which can be seen as a transfer function of the system, follows a first-order low-pass filter equation, recovering the results of Touber and Sandham (JFM, 2011). This behaviour is understood as proceeding from the excitation of a single stable, steady global mode whose damping rate sets the time scale of the filter. Different Mach and Reynolds numbers are studied, covering different recirculation lengths $L$. This damping rate is found to scale as $1/L$, leading to a constant Strouhal number $St_L$ as observed in the literature. It is associated with a breathing motion of the recirculation bubble. This analysis furthermore supports the idea that the low-frequency dynamics of the SWBLI is a forced dynamics, in which background perturbations continuously excite the flow. The investigation is then carried out for 3D perturbations for which two regimes are identified. At low wave numbers of the order of $L$, a modal mechanism similar to that of 2D perturbations is found and exhibits larger values of the optimal gain. At larger wave numbers of the order of the boundary layer thickness, the growth of streaks, which results from a non-modal mechanism, is detected. No interaction with the recirculation region is observed. Based on these results, the potential prevalence of 3D effects in the low-frequency dynamics of the SWBLI is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Ambiguity in mean-flow-based linear analysis
Authors:
U. Karban,
B. Bugeat,
E. Martini,
A. Towne,
A. V. G. Cavalieri,
L. Lesshafft,
A. Agarwal,
P. Jordan,
T. Colonius
Abstract:
Linearisation of the Navier-Stokes equations about the mean of a turbulent flow forms the foundation of popular models for energy amplification and coherent structures, including resolvent analysis. While the Navier-Stokes equations can be equivalently written using many different sets of dependent variables, we show that the properties of the linear operator obtained via linearisation about the m…
▽ More
Linearisation of the Navier-Stokes equations about the mean of a turbulent flow forms the foundation of popular models for energy amplification and coherent structures, including resolvent analysis. While the Navier-Stokes equations can be equivalently written using many different sets of dependent variables, we show that the properties of the linear operator obtained via linearisation about the mean depend on the variables in which the equations are written prior to linearisation. For example, we show that using primitive and conservative variables leads to differences in the singular values and modes of the resolvent operator for turbulent jets, and that the differences become more severe as variable-density effects increase. This lack of uniqueness of mean-flow-based linear analysis provides new opportunities for optimizing models by specific choice of variables while also highlighting the importance of carefully accounting for the nonlinear terms that act as a forcing on the resolvent operator.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021; v1 submitted 12 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
