Showing 1–50 of 51 results for author: Bouchaud, J

The Diffusive Nature of Housing Prices

Authors: Antoine-Cyrus Becharat, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We analyze the French housing market prices in the period 1970-2022, with high-resolution data from 2018 to 2022. The spatial correlation of the observed price field exhibits logarithmic decay characteristic of the two-dimensional random diffusion equation -- local interactions may create long-range correlations. We introduce a stylized model, used in the past to model spatial regularities in voti… ▽ More We analyze the French housing market prices in the period 1970-2022, with high-resolution data from 2018 to 2022. The spatial correlation of the observed price field exhibits logarithmic decay characteristic of the two-dimensional random diffusion equation -- local interactions may create long-range correlations. We introduce a stylized model, used in the past to model spatial regularities in voting patterns, that accounts for both spatial and temporal correlations with reasonable values of parameters. Our analysis reveals that price shocks are persistent in time and their amplitude is strongly heterogeneous in space. Our study confirms and quantifies the diffusive nature of housing prices that was anticipated long ago (Clapp et al. 1994, Pollakowski et al. 1997), albeit on much restricted, local data sets. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2025; v1 submitted 19 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures

Emergent Inequalities in a Primitive Agent-Based Good-Exchange Model

Authors: Nirbhay Patil, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Rising inequalities around the globe bring into question our economic systems and the origin of such inequalities. Here we propose a toy agent-based model where each entity is simultaneously producing and consuming indivisible goods. We find that the system exhibits a non-trivial phase transition beyond which a market clearing equilibrium exists but becomes dynamically unreachable. When production… ▽ More Rising inequalities around the globe bring into question our economic systems and the origin of such inequalities. Here we propose a toy agent-based model where each entity is simultaneously producing and consuming indivisible goods. We find that the system exhibits a non-trivial phase transition beyond which a market clearing equilibrium exists but becomes dynamically unreachable. When production capacity exceeds a threshold and adapts too slowly, some agents cannot sell all their goods. This leads to global price deflation and induces strong wealth inequalities, with the spontaneous separation of the population into a rich class and a poor class. We explore ways to alleviate poverty in this model and whether they have real life significance. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 14 pages, 10 figures, 1 table

Unlearnable Games and "Satisficing'' Decisions: A Simple Model for a Complex World

Authors: Jerome Garnier-Brun, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: As a schematic model of the complexity economic agents are confronted with, we introduce the ``SK-game'', a discrete time binary choice model inspired from mean-field spin-glasses. We show that even in a completely static environment, agents are unable to learn collectively-optimal strategies. This is either because the learning process gets trapped in a sub-optimal fixed point, or because learnin… ▽ More As a schematic model of the complexity economic agents are confronted with, we introduce the ``SK-game'', a discrete time binary choice model inspired from mean-field spin-glasses. We show that even in a completely static environment, agents are unable to learn collectively-optimal strategies. This is either because the learning process gets trapped in a sub-optimal fixed point, or because learning never converges and leads to a never ending evolution of agents intentions. Contrarily to the hope that learning might save the standard ``rational expectation'' framework in economics, we argue that complex situations are generically unlearnable and agents must do with satisficing solutions, as argued long ago by Herbert Simon (Simon 1955). Only a centralized, omniscient agent endowed with enormous computing power could qualify to determine the optimal strategy of all agents. Using a mix of analytical arguments and numerical simulations, we find that (i) long memory of past rewards is beneficial to learning whereas over-reaction to recent past is detrimental and leads to cycles or chaos; (ii) increased competition destabilizes fixed points and leads first to chaos and, in the high competition limit, to quasi-cycles; (iii) some amount of randomness in the learning process, perhaps paradoxically, allows the system to reach better collective decisions; (iv) non-stationary, ``aging'' behaviour spontaneously emerge in a large swath of parameter space of our complex but static world. On the positive side, we find that the learning process allows cooperative systems to coordinate around satisficing solutions with rather high (but markedly sub-optimal) average reward. However, hyper-sensitivity to the game parameters makes it impossible to predict ex ante who will be better or worse off in our stylized economy. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2024; v1 submitted 19 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 35 pages, 19 figures

Wrapping and unwrapping multifractal fields

Authors: Samy Lakhal, Laurent Ponson, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We develop a powerful yet simple method that generates multifractal fields with fully controlled scaling properties. Adopting the Multifractal Random Walk (MRW) model of Bacry et al. (2001), synthetic multifractal fields are obtained from the fractional integration of non-Gaussian fluctuations, built by a non-linear transformation of log-correlated Gaussian fields. The resulting fields are paramet… ▽ More We develop a powerful yet simple method that generates multifractal fields with fully controlled scaling properties. Adopting the Multifractal Random Walk (MRW) model of Bacry et al. (2001), synthetic multifractal fields are obtained from the fractional integration of non-Gaussian fluctuations, built by a non-linear transformation of log-correlated Gaussian fields. The resulting fields are parameterized by their roughness exponent $H$, intermittency $λ$ and multifractal range $ξ_ω$. We retrieve all the salient features of the MRW, namely a quadratic scaling exponent spectrum $ζ_q$, fat-tail statistics of fluctuations, and spatial correlations of local volatility. Such features can be finely tuned, allowing for the generation of ideal multifractals mimicking real multi-affine fields. The construction procedure is then used the other way around to unwrap experimental data -- here the roughness map of a fractured metallic alloy. Our analysis evidences subtle differences with synthetic fields, namely anisotropic filamental clusters reminiscent of dissipation structures found in fluid turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 9 pages, 8 figures

Timeliness criticality in complex systems

Authors: José Moran, Matthijs Romeijnders, Pierre Le Doussal, Frank P. Pijpers, Utz Weitzel, Debabrata Panja, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: In complex systems, external parameters often determine the phase in which the system operates, i.e., its macroscopic behavior. For nearly a century, statistical physics has extensively studied systems' transitions across phases, (universal) critical exponents, and related dynamical properties. Here we consider the functionality of systems, notably operations in socio-technical ones, production in… ▽ More In complex systems, external parameters often determine the phase in which the system operates, i.e., its macroscopic behavior. For nearly a century, statistical physics has extensively studied systems' transitions across phases, (universal) critical exponents, and related dynamical properties. Here we consider the functionality of systems, notably operations in socio-technical ones, production in economic ones and, more generally, any schedule-based system, where timing is of crucial importance. We introduce a stylized model of delay propagation on temporal networks, where the magnitude of delay-mitigating buffer acts as a control parameter. The model exhibits {\it timeliness criticality}, a novel form of critical behavior. We characterize fluctuations near criticality, commonly referred to as ``avalanches'', and identify the corresponding critical exponents. The model exhibits timeliness criticality also when run on real-world temporal systems such as production networks. Additionally, we explore potential connections with the Mode-Coupling Theory of glasses, the depinning transition and the directed polymer problem. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2024; v1 submitted 26 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 12 pages of main paper, 12 figures, 9 pages of supplementary information

Journal ref: Nature Physics 20 (8), 1352-1358 (2024)

From Statistical Physics to Social Sciences: The Pitfalls of Multi-disciplinarity

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: This is the English version of my inaugural lecture at Collège de France in 2021, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxktplKMhKU. I reflect on the difficulty of multi-disciplinary research, which often hinges of unexpected epistemological and methodological differences, for example about the scientific status of models. What is the purpose of a model? What are we ultimately trying to est… ▽ More This is the English version of my inaugural lecture at Collège de France in 2021, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxktplKMhKU. I reflect on the difficulty of multi-disciplinary research, which often hinges of unexpected epistemological and methodological differences, for example about the scientific status of models. What is the purpose of a model? What are we ultimately trying to establish: rigorous theorems or ad-hoc calculation recipes; absolute truth, or heuristic representations of the world? I argue that the main contribution of statistical physics to social and economic sciences is to make us realise that unexpected behaviour can emerge at the aggregate level, that isolated individuals would never experience. Crises, panics, opinion reversals, the spread of rumours or beliefs, fashion effects and the zeitgeist, but also the existence of money, lasting institutions, social norms and stable societies, must be understood in terms of collective belief and/or trust, self-sustained by interactions, or on the contrary, the rapid collapse of this belief or trust. The Appendix contains my opening remarks to the workshop ``More is Different'', as a tribute to Phil Anderson. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: French version published as a book by Fayard (2021)

Critical fragility in socio-technical systems

Authors: José Moran, Frank P. Pijpers, Utz Weitzel, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Debabrata Panja

Abstract: Socio-technical systems, where technological and human elements interact in a goal-oriented manner, provide important functional support to our societies. Here we draw attention to the underappreciated concept of timeliness -- i.e., system elements being available at the right place at the right time -- that has been ubiquitously and integrally adopted as a quality standard in the \textit{modus op… ▽ More Socio-technical systems, where technological and human elements interact in a goal-oriented manner, provide important functional support to our societies. Here we draw attention to the underappreciated concept of timeliness -- i.e., system elements being available at the right place at the right time -- that has been ubiquitously and integrally adopted as a quality standard in the \textit{modus operandi\/} of socio-technical systems. We point out that a variety of incentives, often reinforced by competitive pressures, prompt system operators to myopically optimize for efficiencies, running the risk of inadvertently taking timeliness to the limit of its operational performance, correspondingly making the system critically fragile to perturbations by pushing the entire system towards the proverbial `edge of a cliff'. Invoking a stylized model for operational delays, we identify the limiting operational performance of timeliness, as a true critical point, where the smallest of perturbations can lead to a systemic collapse. Specifically for firm-to-firm production networks, we suggest that the proximity to \textit{critical fragility\/} is an important ingredient for understanding the fundamental ``excess volatility puzzle'' in economics. Further, in generality for optimizing socio-technical systems, we propose that critical fragility is a crucial aspect in managing the trade-off between efficiency and robustness. △ Less

Submitted 20 January, 2025; v1 submitted 7 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures, perspective paper, to appear in PNAS

Journal ref: PNAS 122, e2415139122 (2025)

Application of spin glass ideas in social sciences, economics and finance

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Matteo Marsili, Jean-Pierre Nadal

Abstract: Classical economics has developed an arsenal of methods, based on the idea of representative agents, to come up with precise numbers for next year's GDP, inflation and exchange rates, among (many) other things. Few, however, will disagree with the fact that the economy is a complex system, with a large number of strongly heterogeneous, interacting units of different types (firms, banks, households… ▽ More Classical economics has developed an arsenal of methods, based on the idea of representative agents, to come up with precise numbers for next year's GDP, inflation and exchange rates, among (many) other things. Few, however, will disagree with the fact that the economy is a complex system, with a large number of strongly heterogeneous, interacting units of different types (firms, banks, households, public institutions) and different sizes. Now, the main issue in economics is precisely the emergent organization, cooperation and coordination of such a motley crowd of micro-units. Treating them as a unique ``representative'' firm or household clearly risks throwing the baby with the bathwater. As we have learnt from statistical physics, understanding and characterizing such emergent properties can be difficult. Because of feedback loops of different signs, heterogeneities and non-linearities, the macro-properties are often hard to anticipate. In particular, these situations generically lead to a very large number of possible equilibria, or even the lack thereof. Spin-glasses and other disordered systems give a concrete example of such difficulties. In order to tackle these complex situations, new theoretical and numerical tools have been invented in the last 50 years, including of course the replica method and replica symmetry breaking, and the cavity method, both static and dynamic. In this chapter we review the application of such ideas and methods in economics and social sciences. Of particular interest are the proliferation (and fragility) of equilibria, the analogue of satisfiability phase transitions in games and random economies, and condensation (or concentration) effects in opinion, wealth, etc △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Contribution to the edited volume "Spin Glass Theory & Far Beyond - Replica Symmetry Breaking after 40 Years", World Scientific, 2023

Income Inequalities Increase with City Size: Evidence from French Data

Authors: Nirbhay Patil, Jean-Pierre Nadal, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We analyse the income distributions of cities in France and the scaling of the income of different deciles as a function of the population. We find a significant difference in the scaling exponents for the richer and poorer parts of the population, implying an unequivocal rise in inequalities in larger cities, made worse by living costs that are disproportionately higher for the poor. We find that… ▽ More We analyse the income distributions of cities in France and the scaling of the income of different deciles as a function of the population. We find a significant difference in the scaling exponents for the richer and poorer parts of the population, implying an unequivocal rise in inequalities in larger cities, made worse by living costs that are disproportionately higher for the poor. We find that the distribution of revenues of cities in France has a universal, Gumbel-like form, with mean and variance growing with the logarithm of population. We show how this result directly implies different income scaling exponents as a function of decile. We also study the spatial correlations of income and population, which decay exponentially with distance. We find that large cities are not more income-segregated than small cities. Finally, we search for couplings between social and economic factors, like age and income, and propose a toy model that reproduces some of our observations. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2023; v1 submitted 22 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 11 pages, 11 figures

Bounded Rationality and Animal Spirits: A Fluctuation-Response Approach to Slutsky Matrices

Authors: Jerome Garnier-Brun, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: The Slutsky equation, central in consumer choice theory, is derived from the usual hypotheses underlying most standard models in Economics, such as full rationality, homogeneity, and absence of interactions. We present a statistical physics framework that allows us to relax such assumptions. We first derive a general fluctuation-response formula that relates the Slutsky matrix to spontaneous fluct… ▽ More The Slutsky equation, central in consumer choice theory, is derived from the usual hypotheses underlying most standard models in Economics, such as full rationality, homogeneity, and absence of interactions. We present a statistical physics framework that allows us to relax such assumptions. We first derive a general fluctuation-response formula that relates the Slutsky matrix to spontaneous fluctuations of consumption rather than to response to changing prices and budget. We then show that, within our hypotheses, the symmetry of the Slutsky matrix remains valid even when agents are only boundedly rational but non-interacting. We then propose a model where agents are influenced by the choice of others, leading to a phase transition beyond which consumption is dominated by herding (or `"fashion") effects. In this case, the individual Slutsky matrix is no longer symmetric, even for fully rational agents. The vicinity of the transition features a peak in asymmetry. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 25 pages, 5 figures

Scale Dependencies and Self-Similar Models with Wavelet Scattering Spectra

Authors: Rudy Morel, Gaspar Rochette, Roberto Leonarduzzi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Stéphane Mallat

Abstract: We introduce the wavelet scattering spectra which provide non-Gaussian models of time-series having stationary increments. A complex wavelet transform computes signal variations at each scale. Dependencies across scales are captured by the joint correlation across time and scales of wavelet coefficients and their modulus. This correlation matrix is nearly diagonalized by a second wavelet transform… ▽ More We introduce the wavelet scattering spectra which provide non-Gaussian models of time-series having stationary increments. A complex wavelet transform computes signal variations at each scale. Dependencies across scales are captured by the joint correlation across time and scales of wavelet coefficients and their modulus. This correlation matrix is nearly diagonalized by a second wavelet transform, which defines the scattering spectra. We show that this vector of moments characterizes a wide range of non-Gaussian properties of multi-scale processes. We prove that self-similar processes have scattering spectra which are scale invariant. This property can be tested statistically on a single realization and defines a class of wide-sense self-similar processes. We build maximum entropy models conditioned by scattering spectra coefficients, and generate new time-series with a microcanonical sampling algorithm. Applications are shown for highly non-Gaussian financial and turbulence time-series. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2023; v1 submitted 19 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Exogenous and Endogenous Price Jumps Belong to Different Dynamical Classes

Authors: Riccardo Marcaccioli, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: Synchronising a database of stock specific news with 5 years worth of order book data on 300 stocks, we show that abnormal price movements following news releases (exogenous) exhibit markedly different dynamical features from those arising spontaneously (endogenous). On average, large volatility fluctuations induced by exogenous events occur abruptly and are followed by a decaying power-law relaxa… ▽ More Synchronising a database of stock specific news with 5 years worth of order book data on 300 stocks, we show that abnormal price movements following news releases (exogenous) exhibit markedly different dynamical features from those arising spontaneously (endogenous). On average, large volatility fluctuations induced by exogenous events occur abruptly and are followed by a decaying power-law relaxation, while endogenous price jumps are characterized by progressively accelerating growth of volatility, also followed by a power-law relaxation, but slower than for exogenous jumps. Remarkably, our results are reminiscent of what is observed in different contexts, namely Amazon book sales and YouTube views. Finally, we show that fitting power-laws to {\it individual} volatility profiles allows one to classify large events into endogenous and exogenous dynamical classes, without relying on the news feed. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Why does individual learning endure when crowds are wiser?

Authors: Benoît de Courson, Léo Fitouchi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: The ability to learn from others (social learning) is often deemed a cause of human species success. But if social learning is indeed more efficient (whether less costly or more accurate) than individual learning, it raises the question of why would anyone engage in individual information seeking, which is a necessary condition for social learning's efficacy. We propose an evolutionary model solvi… ▽ More The ability to learn from others (social learning) is often deemed a cause of human species success. But if social learning is indeed more efficient (whether less costly or more accurate) than individual learning, it raises the question of why would anyone engage in individual information seeking, which is a necessary condition for social learning's efficacy. We propose an evolutionary model solving this paradox, provided agents (i) aim not only at information quality but also vie for audience and prestige, and (ii) do not only value accuracy but also reward originality -- allowing them to alleviate herding effects. We find that under some conditions (large enough success rate of informed agents and intermediate taste for popularity), both social learning's higher accuracy and the taste for original opinions are evolutionary-stable, within a mutually beneficial division of labour-like equilibrium. When such conditions are not met, the system most often converges towards mutually detrimental equilibria. △ Less

Submitted 28 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures, 1 table

Did lockdowns serve their purpose?

Authors: Serena Bradde, Benedetta Cerruti, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We show that the dynamics of the number of deaths due to Covid in different countries is to a large extent universal once the origin of time is chosen to be the start of the lockdown, and the number of death is rescaled by the total number of deaths after the lockdown, itself a proxy of the number of infections at the start of the lockdown. Such a curve collapse is much less convincing when normal… ▽ More We show that the dynamics of the number of deaths due to Covid in different countries is to a large extent universal once the origin of time is chosen to be the start of the lockdown, and the number of death is rescaled by the total number of deaths after the lockdown, itself a proxy of the number of infections at the start of the lockdown. Such a curve collapse is much less convincing when normalizing by the total population. Sweden, with its no-lockdown, light-touch approach, is the only outlier that deviates considerably from the average behavior. We argue that these model-free findings provide strong support for the effectiveness of the lockdowns in mitigating the lethality of the virus. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Short note, 4 pages, 3 figures

V-, U-, L-, or W-shaped economic recovery after COVID: Insights from an Agent Based Model

Authors: Dhruv Sharma, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Stanislao Gualdi, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: We discuss the impact of a Covid-19--like shock on a simple model economy, described by the previously developed Mark-0 Agent-Based Model. We consider a mixed supply and demand shock, and show that depending on the shock parameters (amplitude and duration), our model economy can display V-shaped, U-shaped or W-shaped recoveries, and even an L-shaped output curve with permanent output loss. This is… ▽ More We discuss the impact of a Covid-19--like shock on a simple model economy, described by the previously developed Mark-0 Agent-Based Model. We consider a mixed supply and demand shock, and show that depending on the shock parameters (amplitude and duration), our model economy can display V-shaped, U-shaped or W-shaped recoveries, and even an L-shaped output curve with permanent output loss. This is due to the economy getting trapped in a self-sustained "bad" state. We then discuss two policies that attempt to moderate the impact of the shock: giving easy credit to firms, and the so-called helicopter money, i.e. injecting new money into the households savings. We find that both policies are effective if strong enough. We highlight the potential danger of terminating these policies too early, although inflation is substantially increased by lax access to credit. Finally, we consider the impact of a second lockdown. While we only discuss a limited number of scenarios, our model is flexible and versatile enough to accommodate a wide variety of situations, thus serving as a useful exploratory tool for a qualitative, scenario-based understanding of post-Covid recovery. The corresponding code is available on-line. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 15 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 20 Pages. Model description within the main text. Discussion on multiple lockdowns added. See code for paper at https://gitlab.com/sharma.dhruv/markovid

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 16, e0247823 (2021)

Good speciation and endogenous business cycles in a constraint satisfaction macroeconomic model

Authors: Dhruv Sharma, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: We introduce a prototype agent-based model of the macroeconomy, with budgetary constraints at its core. The model is related to a class of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), which has been thoroughly investigated in computer science. The CSP paradigm allows us to propose an alternative price-setting mechanism: given agents' preferences and budgets, what set of prices satisfies the maximum nu… ▽ More We introduce a prototype agent-based model of the macroeconomy, with budgetary constraints at its core. The model is related to a class of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), which has been thoroughly investigated in computer science. The CSP paradigm allows us to propose an alternative price-setting mechanism: given agents' preferences and budgets, what set of prices satisfies the maximum number of agents? Such an approach permits the coupling of production and output within the economy to the allowed level of debt in a simplified framework. Within our model, we identify three different regimes upon varying the amount of debt that each agent can accumulate before defaulting. In presence of a very loose constraint on debt, endogenous crises leading to waves of synchronized bankruptcies are present. In the opposite regime of very tight debt constraining, the bankruptcy rate is extremely high and the economy remains structure-less. In an intermediate regime, the economy is stable with very low bankruptcy rate and no aggregate-level crises. This third regime displays a rich phenomenology:the system spontaneously and dynamically self-organizes in a set of cheap and expensive goods (i.e. some kind of "speciation"), with switches triggered by random fluctuations and feedback loops. Our analysis confirms the central role that debt levels play in the stability of the economy. More generally, our model shows that constraints at the individual scale can generate highly complex patterns at the aggregate level. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2021; v1 submitted 24 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 14 Pages, 11 Figures. Updated Journal Reference

Journal ref: J. Stat. Mech. (2021) 063403

Schrödinger's ants: A continuous description of Kirman's recruitment model

Authors: José Moran, Antoine Fosset, Michael Benzaquen, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We show how the approach to equilibrium in Kirman's ants model can be fully characterized in terms of the spectrum of a Schrödinger equation with a Pöschl-Teller ($\tan^2$) potential. Among other interesting properties, we have found that in the bimodal phase where ants visit mostly one food site at a time, the switch time between the two sources only depends on the ``spontaneous conversion" rate… ▽ More We show how the approach to equilibrium in Kirman's ants model can be fully characterized in terms of the spectrum of a Schrödinger equation with a Pöschl-Teller ($\tan^2$) potential. Among other interesting properties, we have found that in the bimodal phase where ants visit mostly one food site at a time, the switch time between the two sources only depends on the ``spontaneous conversion" rate and not on the recruitment rate. More complicated correlation functions can be computed exactly, and involve higher and higher eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the Schrödinger operator, which can be expressed in terms of hypergeometric functions. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

By Force of Habit: Self-Trapping in a Dynamical Utility Landscape

Authors: José Moran, Antoine Fosset, Davide Luzzati, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: Historically, rational choice theory has focused on the utility maximization principle to describe how individuals make choices. In reality, there is a computational cost related to exploring the universe of available choices and it is often not clear whether we are truly maximizing an underlying utility function. In particular, memory effects and habit formation may dominate over utility maximisa… ▽ More Historically, rational choice theory has focused on the utility maximization principle to describe how individuals make choices. In reality, there is a computational cost related to exploring the universe of available choices and it is often not clear whether we are truly maximizing an underlying utility function. In particular, memory effects and habit formation may dominate over utility maximisation. We propose a stylized model with a history-dependent utility function where the utility associated to each choice is increased when that choice has been made in the past, with a certain decaying memory kernel. We show that self-reinforcing effects can cause the agent to get stuck with a choice by sheer force of habit. We discuss the special nature of the transition between free exploration of the space of choice and self-trapping. We find in particular that the trapping time distribution is precisely a Zipf law at the transition, and that the self-trapped phase exhibits super-aging behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures, 1 table

Beauty and structural complexity

Authors: Samy Lakhal, Alexandre Darmon, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Michael Benzaquen

Abstract: We revisit the long-standing question of the relation between image appreciation and its statistical properties. We generate two different sets of random images well distributed along three measures of entropic complexity. We run a large-scale survey in which people are asked to sort the images by preference, which reveals maximum appreciation at intermediate entropic complexity. We show that the… ▽ More We revisit the long-standing question of the relation between image appreciation and its statistical properties. We generate two different sets of random images well distributed along three measures of entropic complexity. We run a large-scale survey in which people are asked to sort the images by preference, which reveals maximum appreciation at intermediate entropic complexity. We show that the algorithmic complexity of the coarse-grained images, expected to capture structural complexity while abstracting from high frequency noise, is a good predictor of preferences. Our analysis suggests that there might exist some universal quantitative criteria for aesthetic judgement. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, 1 table

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 022058 (2020)

Confidence Collapse in a Multi-Household, Self-Reflexive DSGE Model

Authors: Federico Guglielmo Morelli, Michael Benzaquen, Marco Tarzia, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We investigate a multi-household DSGE model in which past aggregate consumption impacts the confidence, and therefore consumption propensity, of individual households. We find that such a minimal setup is extremely rich, and leads to a variety of realistic output dynamics: high output with no crises; high output with increased volatility and deep, short lived recessions; alternation of high and lo… ▽ More We investigate a multi-household DSGE model in which past aggregate consumption impacts the confidence, and therefore consumption propensity, of individual households. We find that such a minimal setup is extremely rich, and leads to a variety of realistic output dynamics: high output with no crises; high output with increased volatility and deep, short lived recessions; alternation of high and low output states where relatively mild drop in economic conditions can lead to a temporary confidence collapse and steep decline in economic activity. The crisis probability depends exponentially on the parameters of the model, which means that markets cannot efficiently price the associated risk premium. We conclude by stressing that within our framework, {\it narratives} become an important monetary policy tool, that can help steering the economy back on track. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

May's Instability in Large Economies

Authors: José Moran, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Will a large economy be stable? Building on Robert May's original argument for large ecosystems, we conjecture that evolutionary and behavioural forces conspire to drive the economy towards marginal stability. We study networks of firms in which inputs for production are not easily substitutable, as in several real-world supply chains. Relying on results from Random Matrix Theory, we argue that su… ▽ More Will a large economy be stable? Building on Robert May's original argument for large ecosystems, we conjecture that evolutionary and behavioural forces conspire to drive the economy towards marginal stability. We study networks of firms in which inputs for production are not easily substitutable, as in several real-world supply chains. Relying on results from Random Matrix Theory, we argue that such networks generically become dysfunctional when their size increases, when the heterogeneity between firms becomes too strong or when substitutability of their production inputs is reduced. At marginal stability and for large heterogeneities, we find that the distribution of firm sizes develops a power-law tail, as observed empirically. Crises can be triggered by small idiosyncratic shocks, which lead to "avalanches" of defaults characterized by a power-law distribution of total output losses. This scenario would naturally explain the well-known "small shocks, large business cycles" puzzle, as anticipated long ago by Bak, Chen, Scheinkman and Woodford. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2019; v1 submitted 28 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 100, 032307 (2019)

Econophysics: Still fringe after 30 years?

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Some personal reflections on the past and future of "econophysics", to appear in Europhysics News Some personal reflections on the past and future of "econophysics", to appear in Europhysics News △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: 5 pages + references, 1 figure

Optimal Inflation Target: Insights from an Agent-Based Model

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Stanislao Gualdi, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: Which level of inflation should Central Banks be targeting? We investigate this issue in the context of a simplified Agent Based Model of the economy. Depending on the value of the parameters that describe the behaviour of agents (in particular inflation anticipations), we find a rich variety of behaviour at the macro-level. Without any active monetary policy, our ABM economy can be in a high infl… ▽ More Which level of inflation should Central Banks be targeting? We investigate this issue in the context of a simplified Agent Based Model of the economy. Depending on the value of the parameters that describe the behaviour of agents (in particular inflation anticipations), we find a rich variety of behaviour at the macro-level. Without any active monetary policy, our ABM economy can be in a high inflation/high output state, or in a low inflation/low output state. Hyper-inflation, deflation and "business cycles" between coexisting states are also found. We then introduce a Central Bank with a Taylor rule-based inflation target, and study the resulting aggregate variables. Our main result is that too-low inflation targets are in general detrimental to a CB-monitored economy. One symptom is a persistent under-realisation of inflation, perhaps similar to the current macroeconomic situation. Higher inflation targets are found to improve both unemployment and negative interest rate episodes. Our results are compared with the predictions of the standard DSGE model. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2018; v1 submitted 15 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: 19 pages, 6 figures. The paper is under review for the online journal "Economics". The reviews are public at this link: http://www.economics-ejournal.org/economics/discussionpapers/2017-64 . This version has been modified and improved following the advice of the reviewers and commentators

Journal ref: Economics: The Open-Access, Open-Assessment E-Journal, 12 (2018-15): 1-26

Dissecting cross-impact on stock markets: An empirical analysis

Authors: Michael Benzaquen, Iacopo Mastromatteo, Zoltan Eisler, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: The vast majority of market impact studies assess each product individually, and the interactions between the different order flows are disregarded. This strong approximation may lead to an underestimation of trading costs and possible contagion effects. Transactions in fact mediate a significant part of the correlation between different instruments. In turn, liquidity shares the sectorial structu… ▽ More The vast majority of market impact studies assess each product individually, and the interactions between the different order flows are disregarded. This strong approximation may lead to an underestimation of trading costs and possible contagion effects. Transactions in fact mediate a significant part of the correlation between different instruments. In turn, liquidity shares the sectorial structure of market correlations, which can be encoded as a set of eigenvalues and eigenvectors. We introduce a multivariate linear propagator model that successfully describes such a structure, and accounts for a significant fraction of the covariance of stock returns. We dissect the various dynamical mechanisms that contribute to the joint dynamics of assets. We also define two simplified models with substantially less parameters in order to reduce overfitting, and show that they have superior out-of-sample performance. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2016; v1 submitted 8 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 22 pages, 9 figures

On the overlaps between eigenvectors of correlated random matrices

Authors: Joël Bun, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marc Potters

Abstract: We obtain general, exact formulas for the overlaps between the eigenvectors of large correlated random matrices, with additive or multiplicative noise. These results have potential applications in many different contexts, from quantum thermalisation to high dimensional statistics. We find that the overlaps only depend on measurable quantities, and do not require the knowledge of the underlying "tr… ▽ More We obtain general, exact formulas for the overlaps between the eigenvectors of large correlated random matrices, with additive or multiplicative noise. These results have potential applications in many different contexts, from quantum thermalisation to high dimensional statistics. We find that the overlaps only depend on measurable quantities, and do not require the knowledge of the underlying "true" (noiseless) matrices. We apply our results to the case of empirical correlation matrices, that allow us to estimate reliably the width of the spectrum of the true correlation matrix, even when the latter is very close to the identity. We illustrate our results on the example of stock returns correlations, that clearly reveal a non trivial structure for the bulk eigenvalues. We also apply our results to the problem of matrix denoising in high dimension. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2017; v1 submitted 14 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 12 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 98, 052145 (2018)

Monetary Policy and Dark Corners in a stylized Agent-Based Model

Authors: Stanislao Gualdi, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We extend in a minimal way the stylized model introduced in in "Tipping Points in Macroeconomic Agent Based Models" [JEDC 50, 29-61 (2015)], with the aim of investigating the role and efficacy of monetary policy of a `Central Bank' that sets the interest rate such as to steer the economy towards a prescribed inflation and employment level. Our major finding is that provided its policy is not too a… ▽ More We extend in a minimal way the stylized model introduced in in "Tipping Points in Macroeconomic Agent Based Models" [JEDC 50, 29-61 (2015)], with the aim of investigating the role and efficacy of monetary policy of a `Central Bank' that sets the interest rate such as to steer the economy towards a prescribed inflation and employment level. Our major finding is that provided its policy is not too aggressive (in a sense detailed in the paper) the Central Bank is successful in achieving its goals. However, the existence of different equilibrium states of the economy, separated by phase boundaries (or "dark corners"), can cause the monetary policy itself to trigger instabilities and be counter-productive. In other words, the Central Bank must navigate in a narrow window: too little is not enough, too much leads to instabilities and wildly oscillating economies. This conclusion strongly contrasts with the prediction of DSGE models. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2016; v1 submitted 2 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: Contribution to the CRISIS project, 25 pages, 21 figures, pseudo-code of the model, revised and improved version

Journal ref: Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination 12, 507-537 (2017)

Sudden Trust Collapse in Networked Societies

Authors: João da Gama Batista, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Damien Challet

Abstract: Trust is a collective, self-fulfilling phenomenon that suggests analogies with phase transitions. We introduce a stylized model for the build-up and collapse of trust in networks, which generically displays a first order transition. The basic assumption of our model is that whereas trust begets trust, panic also begets panic, in the sense that a small decrease in trust may be amplified and ultimat… ▽ More Trust is a collective, self-fulfilling phenomenon that suggests analogies with phase transitions. We introduce a stylized model for the build-up and collapse of trust in networks, which generically displays a first order transition. The basic assumption of our model is that whereas trust begets trust, panic also begets panic, in the sense that a small decrease in trust may be amplified and ultimately lead to a sudden and catastrophic drop of trust. We show, using both numerical simulations and mean-field analytic arguments, that there are extended regions of the parameter space where two equilibrium states coexist: a well-connected network where confidence is high, and a poorly connected network where confidence is low. In these coexistence regions, spontaneous jumps from the well-connected state to the poorly connected state can occur, corresponding to a sudden collapse of trust that is not caused by any major external catastrophe. In large systems, spontaneous crises are replaced by history dependence: whether the system is found in one state or in the other essentially depends on initial conditions. Finally, we document a new phase, in which agents are connected yet distrustful. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2015; v1 submitted 22 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 15 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. B 88 (3) 55 (2015)

On the emergence of an "intention field" for socially cohesive agents

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Christian Borghesi, Pablo Jensen

Abstract: We argue that when a social convergence mechanism exists and is strong enough, one should expect the emergence of a well defined "field", i.e. a slowly evolving, local quantity around which individual attributes fluctuate in a finite range. This condensation phenomenon is well illustrated by the Deffuant-Weisbuch opinion model for which we provide a natural extension to allow for spatial heterogen… ▽ More We argue that when a social convergence mechanism exists and is strong enough, one should expect the emergence of a well defined "field", i.e. a slowly evolving, local quantity around which individual attributes fluctuate in a finite range. This condensation phenomenon is well illustrated by the Deffuant-Weisbuch opinion model for which we provide a natural extension to allow for spatial heterogeneities. We show analytically and numerically that the resulting dynamics of the emergent field is a noisy diffusion equation that has a slow dynamics. This random diffusion equation reproduces the long-ranged, logarithmic decrease of the correlation of spatial voting patterns empirically found in [1, 2]. Interestingly enough, we find that when the social cohesion mechanism becomes too weak, cultural cohesion breaks down completely, in the sense that the distribution of intentions/opinions becomes infinitely broad. No emerging field exists in this case. All these analytical findings are confirmed by numerical simulations of an agent-based model. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2014; v1 submitted 4 November, 2013; originally announced November 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures

Explore or exploit? A generic model and an exactly solvable case

Authors: Thomas Gueudré, Alexander Dobrinevski, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Finding a good compromise between the exploitation of known resources and the exploration of unknown, but potentially more profitable choices, is a general problem, which arises in many different scientific disciplines. We propose a stylized model for these exploration-exploitation situations, including population or economic growth, portfolio optimisation, evolutionary dynamics, or the problem of… ▽ More Finding a good compromise between the exploitation of known resources and the exploration of unknown, but potentially more profitable choices, is a general problem, which arises in many different scientific disciplines. We propose a stylized model for these exploration-exploitation situations, including population or economic growth, portfolio optimisation, evolutionary dynamics, or the problem of optimal pinning of vortices or dislocations in disordered materials. We find the exact growth rate of this model for tree-like geometries and prove the existence of an optimal migration rate in this case. Numerical simulations in the one-dimensional case confirm the generic existence of an optimum. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2013; v1 submitted 18 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 5 pages 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 050602 (2014)

Tipping points in macroeconomic Agent-Based models

Authors: Stanislao Gualdi, Marco Tarzia, Francesco Zamponi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: The aim of this work is to explore the possible types of phenomena that simple macroeconomic Agent-Based models (ABM) can reproduce. We propose a methodology, inspired by statistical physics, that characterizes a model through its 'phase diagram' in the space of parameters. Our first motivation is to understand the large macro-economic fluctuations observed in the 'Mark I' ABM. Our major finding i… ▽ More The aim of this work is to explore the possible types of phenomena that simple macroeconomic Agent-Based models (ABM) can reproduce. We propose a methodology, inspired by statistical physics, that characterizes a model through its 'phase diagram' in the space of parameters. Our first motivation is to understand the large macro-economic fluctuations observed in the 'Mark I' ABM. Our major finding is the generic existence of a phase transition between a 'good economy' where unemployment is low, and a 'bad economy' where unemployment is high. We introduce a simpler framework that allows us to show that this transition is robust against many modifications of the model, and is generically induced by an asymmetry between the rate of hiring and the rate of firing of the firms. The unemployment level remains small until a tipping point, beyond which the economy suddenly collapses. If the parameters are such that the system is close to this transition, any small fluctuation is amplified as the system jumps between the two equilibria. We have explored several natural extensions of the model. One is to introduce a bankruptcy threshold, limiting the leverage of firms. This leads to a rich phase diagram with, in particular, a region where acute endogenous crises occur, during which the unemployment rate shoots up before the economy can recover. We also introduce simple wage policies. This leads to inflation (in the 'good' phase) or deflation (in the 'bad' phase), but leaves the overall phase diagram of the model essentially unchanged. We have also started exploring the effect of simple monetary policies that attempt to contain rising unemployment and defang crises. We end the paper with general comments on the usefulness of ABMs to model macroeconomic phenomena, in particular in view of the time needed to reach a steady state that raises the issue of ergodicity in these models. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2014; v1 submitted 11 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: 42 pages, 8 figures. Important revisions with respect to v2. Final version, to appear in a special issue of the Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control dedicated to the CRISIS project ( http://www.crisis-economics.eu )

Journal ref: Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control 50, 29-61 (2015)

Some applications of first-passage ideas to finance

Authors: Rémy Chicheportiche, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Many problems in finance are related to first passage times. Among all of them, we chose three on which we contributed personally. Our first example relates Kolmogorov-Smirnov like goodness-of-fit tests, modified in such a way that tail events and core events contribute equally to the test (in the standard Kolmogorov-Smirnov, the tails contribute very little to the measure of goodness-of-fit). We… ▽ More Many problems in finance are related to first passage times. Among all of them, we chose three on which we contributed personally. Our first example relates Kolmogorov-Smirnov like goodness-of-fit tests, modified in such a way that tail events and core events contribute equally to the test (in the standard Kolmogorov-Smirnov, the tails contribute very little to the measure of goodness-of-fit). We show that this problem can be mapped onto that of a random walk inside moving walls. The second example is the optimal time to sell an asset (modelled as a random walk with drift) such that the sell time is as close as possible to the time at which the asset reaches its maximum value. The last example concerns optimal trading in the presence of transaction costs. In this case, the optimal strategy is to wait until the predictor reaches (plus or minus) a threshold value before buying or selling. The value of this threshold is found by mapping the problem onto that of a random walk between two walls. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 30 pages. To appear in the special volume "First-Passage Phenomena and Their Applications", Eds. R. Metzler, G. Oshanin, S. Redner. World Scientific (2013)

Crises and collective socio-economic phenomena: simple models and challenges

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: Financial and economic history is strewn with bubbles and crashes, booms and busts, crises and upheavals of all sorts. Understanding the origin of these events is arguably one of the most important problems in economic theory. In this paper, we review recent efforts to include heterogeneities and interactions in models of decision. We argue that the Random Field Ising model (RFIM) indeed provides… ▽ More Financial and economic history is strewn with bubbles and crashes, booms and busts, crises and upheavals of all sorts. Understanding the origin of these events is arguably one of the most important problems in economic theory. In this paper, we review recent efforts to include heterogeneities and interactions in models of decision. We argue that the Random Field Ising model (RFIM) indeed provides a unifying framework to account for many collective socio-economic phenomena that lead to sudden ruptures and crises. We discuss different models that can capture potentially destabilising self-referential feedback loops, induced either by herding, i.e. reference to peers, or trending, i.e. reference to the past, and account for some of the phenomenology missing in the standard models. We discuss some empirically testable predictions of these models, for example robust signatures of RFIM-like herding effects, or the logarithmic decay of spatial correlations of voting patterns. One of the most striking result, inspired by statistical physics methods, is that Adam Smith's invisible hand can badly fail at solving simple coordination problems. We also insist on the issue of time-scales, that can be extremely long in some cases, and prevent socially optimal equilibria to be reached. As a theoretical challenge, the study of so-called "detailed-balance" violating decision rules is needed to decide whether conclusions based on current models (that all assume detailed-balance) are indeed robust and generic. △ Less

Submitted 29 December, 2012; v1 submitted 2 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: Review paper accepted for a special issue of J Stat Phys; several minor improvements along reviewers' comments

Election turnout statistics in many countries: similarities, differences, and a diffusive field model for decision-making

Authors: Christian Borghesi, Jean-Claude Raynal, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We study in details the turnout rate statistics for 77 elections in 11 different countries. We show that the empirical results established in a previous paper for French elections appear to hold much more generally. We find in particular that the spatial correlation of turnout rates decay logarithmically with distance in all cases. This result is quantitatively reproduced by a decision model that… ▽ More We study in details the turnout rate statistics for 77 elections in 11 different countries. We show that the empirical results established in a previous paper for French elections appear to hold much more generally. We find in particular that the spatial correlation of turnout rates decay logarithmically with distance in all cases. This result is quantitatively reproduced by a decision model that assumes that each voter makes his mind as a result of three influence terms: one totally idiosyncratic component, one city-specific term with short-ranged fluctuations in space, and one long-ranged correlated field which propagates diffusively in space. A detailed analysis reveals several interesting features: for example, different countries have different degrees of local heterogeneities and seem to be characterized by a different propensity for individuals to conform to the cultural norm. We furthermore find clear signs of herding (i.e. strongly correlated decisions at the individual level) in some countries, but not in others. △ Less

Submitted 2 January, 2012; originally announced January 2012.

Comments: 15 pages, 9 figures, 7 tables

Anomalous price impact and the critical nature of liquidity in financial markets

Authors: Bence Toth, Yves Lemperiere, Cyril Deremble, Joachim de Lataillade, Julien Kockelkoren, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We propose a dynamical theory of market liquidity that predicts that the average supply/demand profile is V-shaped and {\it vanishes} around the current price. This result is generic, and only relies on mild assumptions about the order flow and on the fact that prices are (to a first approximation) diffusive. This naturally accounts for two striking stylized facts: first, large metaorders have to… ▽ More We propose a dynamical theory of market liquidity that predicts that the average supply/demand profile is V-shaped and {\it vanishes} around the current price. This result is generic, and only relies on mild assumptions about the order flow and on the fact that prices are (to a first approximation) diffusive. This naturally accounts for two striking stylized facts: first, large metaorders have to be fragmented in order to be digested by the liquidity funnel, leading to long-memory in the sign of the order flow. Second, the anomalously small local liquidity induces a breakdown of linear response and a diverging impact of small orders, explaining the "square-root" impact law, for which we provide additional empirical support. Finally, we test our arguments quantitatively using a numerical model of order flow based on the same minimal ingredients. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2011; v1 submitted 9 May, 2011; originally announced May 2011.

Comments: 16 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review X 1, 021006 (2011)

How does the market react to your order flow?

Authors: Bence Toth, Zoltan Eisler, Fabrizio Lillo, Julien Kockelkoren, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, J. Doyne Farmer

Abstract: We present an empirical study of the intertwined behaviour of members in a financial market. Exploiting a database where the broker that initiates an order book event can be identified, we decompose the correlation and response functions into contributions coming from different market participants and study how their behaviour is interconnected. We find evidence that (1) brokers are very heterogen… ▽ More We present an empirical study of the intertwined behaviour of members in a financial market. Exploiting a database where the broker that initiates an order book event can be identified, we decompose the correlation and response functions into contributions coming from different market participants and study how their behaviour is interconnected. We find evidence that (1) brokers are very heterogeneous in liquidity provision -- some are consistently liquidity providers while others are consistently liquidity takers. (2) The behaviour of brokers is strongly conditioned on the actions of {\it other} brokers. In contrast brokers are only weakly influenced by the impact of their own previous orders. (3) The total impact of market orders is the result of a subtle compensation between the same broker pushing the price in one direction and the liquidity provision of other brokers pushing it in the opposite direction. These results enforce the picture of market dynamics being the result of the competition between heterogeneous participants interacting to form a complicated market ecology. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2012; v1 submitted 4 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 22 pages, 5+9 figures

Spatial correlations in vote statistics: a diffusive field model for decision-making

Authors: Christian Borghesi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We study the statistics of turnout rates and results of the French elections since 1992. We find that the distribution of turnout rates across towns is surprisingly stable over time. The spatial correlation of the turnout rates, or of the fraction of winning votes, is found to decay logarithmically with the distance between towns. Based on these empirical observations and on the analogy with a two… ▽ More We study the statistics of turnout rates and results of the French elections since 1992. We find that the distribution of turnout rates across towns is surprisingly stable over time. The spatial correlation of the turnout rates, or of the fraction of winning votes, is found to decay logarithmically with the distance between towns. Based on these empirical observations and on the analogy with a two-dimensional random diffusion equation, we propose that individual decisions can be rationalised in terms of an underlying "cultural" field, that locally biases the decision of the population of a given region, on top of an idiosyncratic, town-dependent field, with short range correlations. Using symmetry considerations and a set of plausible assumptions, we suggest that this cultural field obeys a random diffusion equation. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2010; v1 submitted 14 March, 2010; originally announced March 2010.

Comments: 18 pages, 5 figures; added sociophysics references.

The (unfortunate) complexity of the economy

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: This article is a follow-up of a short essay that appeared in Nature 455, 1181 (2008) [arXiv:0810.5306]. It has become increasingly clear that the erratic dynamics of markets is mostly endogenous and not due to the rational processing of exogenous news. I elaborate on the idea that spin-glass type of problems, where the combination of competition and heterogeneities generically leads to long epo… ▽ More This article is a follow-up of a short essay that appeared in Nature 455, 1181 (2008) [arXiv:0810.5306]. It has become increasingly clear that the erratic dynamics of markets is mostly endogenous and not due to the rational processing of exogenous news. I elaborate on the idea that spin-glass type of problems, where the combination of competition and heterogeneities generically leads to long epochs of statis interrupted by crises and hyper-sensitivity to small changes of the environment, could be metaphors for the complexity of economic systems. I argue that the most valuable contribution of physics to economics might end up being of methodological nature, and that simple models from physics and agent based numerical simulations, although highly stylized, are more realistic than the traditional models of economics that assume rational agents with infinite foresight and infinite computing abilities. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Journal ref: Physics World, April 2009, p.28-32

Economics need a scientific revolution

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: I argue that the current financial crisis highlights the crucial need of a change of mindset in economics and financial engineering, that should move away from dogmatic axioms and focus more on data, orders of magnitudes, and plausible, albeit non rigorous, arguments. I argue that the current financial crisis highlights the crucial need of a change of mindset in economics and financial engineering, that should move away from dogmatic axioms and focus more on data, orders of magnitudes, and plausible, albeit non rigorous, arguments. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2008; originally announced October 2008.

Comments: An edited version of this essay appeared in Nature

Journal ref: Nature, vol 455, p. 1181 (2008)

Smile dynamics -- a theory of the implied leverage effect

Authors: Stefano Ciliberti, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marc Potters

Abstract: We study in details the skew of stock option smiles, which is induced by the so-called leverage effect on the underlying -- i.e. the correlation between past returns and future square returns. This naturally explains the anomalous dependence of the skew as a function of maturity of the option. The market cap dependence of the leverage effect is analyzed using a one-factor model. We show how this… ▽ More We study in details the skew of stock option smiles, which is induced by the so-called leverage effect on the underlying -- i.e. the correlation between past returns and future square returns. This naturally explains the anomalous dependence of the skew as a function of maturity of the option. The market cap dependence of the leverage effect is analyzed using a one-factor model. We show how this leverage correlation gives rise to a non-trivial smile dynamics, which turns out to be intermediate between the "sticky strike" and the "sticky delta" rules. Finally, we compare our result with stock option data, and find that option markets overestimate the leverage effect by a large factor, in particular for long dated options. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: Submitted to Wilmott

Optimal Time to Sell a Stock in Black-Scholes Model: Comment on "Thou shall buy and hold", by A. Shiryaev, Z. Xu and X.Y. Zhou

Authors: Satya N. Majumdar, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We reconsider the problem of optimal time to sell a stock studied recently by Shiryaev, Xu and Zhou using path integral methods. This method allows us to confirm the results obtained by these authors and extend them to a parameter region inaccessible to the method used by Shiryaev et. al. We also obtain the full distribution of the time t_m at which the maximum of the price is reached for arbitr… ▽ More We reconsider the problem of optimal time to sell a stock studied recently by Shiryaev, Xu and Zhou using path integral methods. This method allows us to confirm the results obtained by these authors and extend them to a parameter region inaccessible to the method used by Shiryaev et. al. We also obtain the full distribution of the time t_m at which the maximum of the price is reached for arbitrary values of the drift. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures included

How markets slowly digest changes in supply and demand

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, J. Doyne Farmer, Fabrizio Lillo

Abstract: In this article we revisit the classic problem of tatonnement in price formation from a microstructure point of view, reviewing a recent body of theoretical and empirical work explaining how fluctuations in supply and demand are slowly incorporated into prices. Because revealed market liquidity is extremely low, large orders to buy or sell can only be traded incrementally, over periods of time a… ▽ More In this article we revisit the classic problem of tatonnement in price formation from a microstructure point of view, reviewing a recent body of theoretical and empirical work explaining how fluctuations in supply and demand are slowly incorporated into prices. Because revealed market liquidity is extremely low, large orders to buy or sell can only be traded incrementally, over periods of time as long as months. As a result order flow is a highly persistent long-memory process. Maintaining compatibility with market efficiency has profound consequences on price formation, on the dynamics of liquidity, and on the nature of impact. We review a body of theory that makes detailed quantitative predictions about the volume and time dependence of market impact, the bid-ask spread, order book dynamics, and volatility. Comparisons to data yield some encouraging successes. This framework suggests a novel interpretation of financial information, in which agents are at best only weakly informed and all have a similar and extremely noisy impact on prices. Most of the processed information appears to come from supply and demand itself, rather than from external news. The ideas reviewed here are relevant to market microstructure regulation, agent-based models, cost-optimal execution strategies, and understanding market ecologies. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: 111 pages, 24 figures

Stock price jumps: news and volume play a minor role

Authors: Armand Joulin, Augustin Lefevre, Daniel Grunberg, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: In order to understand the origin of stock price jumps, we cross-correlate high-frequency time series of stock returns with different news feeds. We find that neither idiosyncratic news nor market wide news can explain the frequency and amplitude of price jumps. We find that the volatility patterns around jumps and around news are quite different: jumps are followed by increased volatility, wher… ▽ More In order to understand the origin of stock price jumps, we cross-correlate high-frequency time series of stock returns with different news feeds. We find that neither idiosyncratic news nor market wide news can explain the frequency and amplitude of price jumps. We find that the volatility patterns around jumps and around news are quite different: jumps are followed by increased volatility, whereas news tend on average to be followed by lower volatility levels. The shape of the volatility relaxation is also markedly different in the two cases. Finally, we provide direct evidence that large transaction volumes are_not_ responsible for large price jumps. We conjecture that most price jumps are induced by order flow fluctuations close to the point of vanishing liquidity. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2008; originally announced March 2008.

The Student ensemble of correlation matrices: eigenvalue spectrum and Kullback-Leibler entropy

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marc Potters

Abstract: We study a new ensemble of random correlation matrices related to multivariate Student (or more generally elliptic) random variables. We establish the exact density of states of empirical correlation matrices that generalizes the Marcenko-Pastur result. The comparison between the theoretical density of states in the Student case and empirical financial data is surprisingly good, even if we are s… ▽ More We study a new ensemble of random correlation matrices related to multivariate Student (or more generally elliptic) random variables. We establish the exact density of states of empirical correlation matrices that generalizes the Marcenko-Pastur result. The comparison between the theoretical density of states in the Student case and empirical financial data is surprisingly good, even if we are still able to detect systematic deviations. Finally, we compute explicitely the Kullback-Leibler entropies of empirical Student matrices, which are found to be independent of the true correlation matrix, as in the Gaussian case. We provide numerically exact values for these Kullback-Leibler entropies. △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2007; originally announced October 2007.

On the top eigenvalue of heavy-tailed random matrices

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Marc Potters

Abstract: We study the statistics of the largest eigenvalue lambda_max of N x N random matrices with unit variance, but power-law distributed entries, P(M_{ij})~ |M_{ij}|^{-1-mu}. When mu > 4, lambda_max converges to 2 with Tracy-Widom fluctuations of order N^{-2/3}. When mu < 4, lambda_max is of order N^{2/mu-1/2} and is governed by Fréchet statistics. The marginal case mu=4 provides a new class of limit… ▽ More We study the statistics of the largest eigenvalue lambda_max of N x N random matrices with unit variance, but power-law distributed entries, P(M_{ij})~ |M_{ij}|^{-1-mu}. When mu > 4, lambda_max converges to 2 with Tracy-Widom fluctuations of order N^{-2/3}. When mu < 4, lambda_max is of order N^{2/mu-1/2} and is governed by Fréchet statistics. The marginal case mu=4 provides a new class of limiting distribution that we compute explicitely. We extend these results to sample covariance matrices, and show that extreme events may cause the largest eigenvalue to significantly exceed the Marcenko-Pastur edge. Connections with Directed Polymers are briefly discussed. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2006; originally announced September 2006.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures

Of Songs and Men: a Model for Multiple Choice with Herding

Authors: Christian Borghesi, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We propose a generic model for multiple choice situations in the presence of herding and compare it with recent empirical results from a Web-based music market experiment. The model predicts a phase transition between a weak imitation phase and a strong imitation, `fashion' phase, where choices are driven by peer pressure and the ranking of individual preferences is strongly distorted at the agg… ▽ More We propose a generic model for multiple choice situations in the presence of herding and compare it with recent empirical results from a Web-based music market experiment. The model predicts a phase transition between a weak imitation phase and a strong imitation, `fashion' phase, where choices are driven by peer pressure and the ranking of individual preferences is strongly distorted at the aggregate level. The model can be calibrated to reproduce the main experimental results of Salganik et al. (Science, 311, pp. 854-856 (2006)); we show in particular that the value of the social influence parameter can be estimated from the data. In one of the experimental situation, this value is found to be close to the critical value of the model. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2006; originally announced June 2006.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures

Relation between Bid-Ask Spread, Impact and Volatility in Double Auction Markets

Authors: Matthieu Wyart, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Julien Kockelkoren, Marc Potters, Michele Vettorazzo

Abstract: We show that the cost of market orders and the profit of infinitesimal market-making or -taking strategies can be expressed in terms of directly observable quantities, namely the spread and the lag-dependent impact function. Imposing that any market taking or liquidity providing strategies is at best marginally profitable, we obtain a linear relation between the bid-ask spread and the instantane… ▽ More We show that the cost of market orders and the profit of infinitesimal market-making or -taking strategies can be expressed in terms of directly observable quantities, namely the spread and the lag-dependent impact function. Imposing that any market taking or liquidity providing strategies is at best marginally profitable, we obtain a linear relation between the bid-ask spread and the instantaneous impact of market orders, in good agreement with our empirical observations on electronic markets. We then use this relation to justify a strong, and hitherto unnoticed, empirical correlation between the spread and the volatility_per trade_, with R^2s exceeding 0.9. This correlation suggests both that the main determinant of the bid-ask spread is adverse selection, and that most of the volatilitycomes from trade impact. We argue that the role of the time-horizon appearing in the definition of costs is crucial and that long-range correlations in the order flow, overlooked in previous studies, must be carefully factored in. We find that the spread is significantly larger on the nyse, a liquid market with specialists, where monopoly rents appear to be present. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2007; v1 submitted 10 March, 2006; originally announced March 2006.

Comments: 35 pages, 12 figures, still improved version

Large dimension forecasting models and random singular value spectra

Authors: Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Laurent Laloux, M. Augusta Miceli, Marc Potters

Abstract: We present a general method to detect and extract from a finite time sample statistically meaningful correlations between input and output variables of large dimensionality. Our central result is derived from the theory of free random matrices, and gives an explicit expression for the interval where singular values are expected in the absence of any true correlations between the variables under… ▽ More We present a general method to detect and extract from a finite time sample statistically meaningful correlations between input and output variables of large dimensionality. Our central result is derived from the theory of free random matrices, and gives an explicit expression for the interval where singular values are expected in the absence of any true correlations between the variables under study. Our result can be seen as the natural generalization of the Marcenko-Pastur distribution for the case of rectangular correlation matrices. We illustrate the interest of our method on a set of macroeconomic time series. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2005; originally announced December 2005.

Comments: 20 pages, 5 figures, submitted to EPJB

Trend followers lose more often than they gain

Authors: Marc Potters, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud

Abstract: We solve exactly a simple model of trend following strategy, and obtain the analytical shape of the profit per trade distribution. This distribution is non trivial and has an option like, asymmetric structure. The degree of asymmetry depends continuously on the parameters of the strategy and on the volatility of the traded asset. While the average gain per trade is always exactly zero, the fract… ▽ More We solve exactly a simple model of trend following strategy, and obtain the analytical shape of the profit per trade distribution. This distribution is non trivial and has an option like, asymmetric structure. The degree of asymmetry depends continuously on the parameters of the strategy and on the volatility of the traded asset. While the average gain per trade is always exactly zero, the fraction f of winning trades decreases from f=1/2 for small volatility to f=0 for high volatility, showing that this winning probability does not give any information on the reliability of the strategy but is indicative of the trading style. △ Less

Submitted 16 August, 2005; originally announced August 2005.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures, submitted to Wilmott magazine

Financial Applications of Random Matrix Theory: Old Laces and New Pieces

Authors: M. Potters, J. P. Bouchaud, L. Laloux

Abstract: This contribution to the proceedings of the Cracow meeting on `Applications of Random Matrix Theory' summarizes a series of studies, some old and others more recent on financial applications of Random Matrix Theory (RMT). We first review some early results in that field, with particular emphasis on the applications of correlation cleaning to portfolio optimisation, and discuss the extension of t… ▽ More This contribution to the proceedings of the Cracow meeting on `Applications of Random Matrix Theory' summarizes a series of studies, some old and others more recent on financial applications of Random Matrix Theory (RMT). We first review some early results in that field, with particular emphasis on the applications of correlation cleaning to portfolio optimisation, and discuss the extension of the Marcenko-Pastur (MP) distribution to a non trivial `true' underlying correlation matrix. We then present new results concerning different problems that arise in a financial context: (a) the generalisation of the MP result to the case of an empirical correlation matrix (ECM) constructed using exponential moving averages, for which we give a new elegant derivation (b) the specific dynamics of the `market' eigenvalue and its associated eigenvector, which defines an interesting Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process on the unit sphere and (c) the problem of the dependence of ECM's on the observation frequency of the returns and its interpretation in terms of lagged cross-influences. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2005; originally announced July 2005.

Comments: Proceedings of the Cracow conference on `Applications of Random Matrix Theory to Economy and Other Complex Systems'

On a multi-timescale statistical feedback model for volatility fluctuations

Authors: L. Borland, J. -Ph. Bouchaud

Abstract: We study, both analytically and numerically, an ARCH-like, multiscale model of volatility, which assumes that the volatility is governed by the observed past price changes on different time scales. With a power-law distribution of time horizons, we obtain a model that captures most stylized facts of financial time series: Student-like distribution of returns with a power-law tail, long-memory of… ▽ More We study, both analytically and numerically, an ARCH-like, multiscale model of volatility, which assumes that the volatility is governed by the observed past price changes on different time scales. With a power-law distribution of time horizons, we obtain a model that captures most stylized facts of financial time series: Student-like distribution of returns with a power-law tail, long-memory of the volatility, slow convergence of the distribution of returns towards the Gaussian distribution, multifractality and anomalous volatility relaxation after shocks. At variance with recent multifractal models that are strictly time reversal invariant, the model also reproduces the time assymmetry of financial time series: past large scale volatility influence future small scale volatility. In order to quantitatively reproduce all empirical observations, the parameters must be chosen such that our model is close to an instability, meaning that (a) the feedback effect is important and substantially increases the volatility, and (b) that the model is intrinsically difficult to calibrate because of the very long range nature of the correlations. By imposing the consistency of the model predictions with a large set of different empirical observations, a reasonable range of the parameters value can be determined. The model can easily be generalized to account for jumps, skewness and multiasset correlations. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2005; originally announced July 2005.

Comments: 22 pages, 11 figures