-
A Novel Solution of the Quantum Measurement Problem
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
In spite of the innumerable attempts to resolve the quantum measurement problem, almost since its beginning a century ago, a satisfactory solution still remains elusive. However, after the advent of quantum entanglement leading to environmental decoherence studies, a substantial leap forward has been achieved by Zurek and his associates. Their investigation has led to the existence of sturdy point…
▽ More
In spite of the innumerable attempts to resolve the quantum measurement problem, almost since its beginning a century ago, a satisfactory solution still remains elusive. However, after the advent of quantum entanglement leading to environmental decoherence studies, a substantial leap forward has been achieved by Zurek and his associates. Their investigation has led to the existence of sturdy pointer states that survive decoherence leading to classicality although still remaining entangled with the environment and the apparatus states. But in order to avoid the inexplicable collapse postulate, Zurek invokes Everett's many world conjecture, which is not accepted by many experts. In this article, we present the observation of entanglement sudden death (ESD), demonstrating that disentanglement of the pointer states is caused by the quantum fluctuations of the electromagnetic field. We reveal that the decoherence between the pointer states and the environment is consistent with unitary evolution when the vacuum modes are included in the calculation, in analogy to the unitary evolution of the whole system in the spontaneous emission process. However, the ultimate state of the system is still subject to the totally unpredictable nature of individual quantum fluctuations, causing the stochastic appearance of an arbitrary classical state in von Neumann's collapse axiom even when the entire system evolves unitarily. Therefore, we suggest that an acceptable solution of the long standing measurement problem has finally been achieved.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Emergence of the wavefunction of a non-relativistic quantum particle from QFT
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
The nonrelativistic wavefunction of a quantum state that contains all its information is derived directly from the effective quantum fields of the standard model of particle physics, which are the fundamental elements of reality of the universe unveiled to us so far. Consequently, the endless debate about the reality of a wavefunction can now be reasonably put to rest and nonrelativistic quantum m…
▽ More
The nonrelativistic wavefunction of a quantum state that contains all its information is derived directly from the effective quantum fields of the standard model of particle physics, which are the fundamental elements of reality of the universe unveiled to us so far. Consequently, the endless debate about the reality of a wavefunction can now be reasonably put to rest and nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can cogently be considered as a genuine theory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Active Sourced Wavefield Modeling for Layered Half-Space
Authors:
Mrinal Bhaumik,
Tarun Naskar
Abstract:
Traditional free vibration-based forward models generate theoretical dispersion curves under the assumption of planar waves, neglecting the influence of the actual source-receiver configuration. While 2D/3D numerical wavefield modeling approaches mimic real-field scenarios with source-receiver information, they suffer from computational inefficiency. This study introduces a semi-analytical wavefie…
▽ More
Traditional free vibration-based forward models generate theoretical dispersion curves under the assumption of planar waves, neglecting the influence of the actual source-receiver configuration. While 2D/3D numerical wavefield modeling approaches mimic real-field scenarios with source-receiver information, they suffer from computational inefficiency. This study introduces a semi-analytical wavefield modeling approach incorporating source-receiver data acquisition layouts. The method considers a cylindrically spreading wavefield described by the Hankel function instead of the planer wave assumption. The approach considers both propagating waves characterized by real wavenumbers and decaying waves with complex wavenumbers, allowing for calculating surface displacements in both the far and near fields. The proposed model captures the complete wavefield, including source-offset effects and leaky waves, while maintaining computational efficiency comparable to any free vibration-based approaches. The method entails solving the eigenvalue problem constructed through the higher-order thin-layer method. Subsequently, it calculates the frequency domain vertical and radial surface responses at any desired location in space generated by a vertically positioned active source. The overall performance of the proposed method is investigated on diverse profiles, including regularly dispersive media, low-velocity layer models, and thin plate structures. The vertical and radial component dispersion images are validated against the numerical approach. The proposed method is at least two orders of magnitude faster than the numerical method. Notably, it captures the smooth transition of modal energy from the fundamental mode to higher modes, occurring due to modal osculation at low frequencies. The present approach offers a valuable tool to enhance the efficiency of active surface wave methods.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The Enigmas of Fluctuations of the Universal Quantum Fields
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
The primary ingredients of reality are the universal quantum fields, which fluctuate persistently, spontaneously, and randomly. The general perception of the scientific community is that these quantum fluctuations are due to the uncertainty principle. Here, we present cogent arguments to show that the uncertainty principle is a consequence of the quantum fluctuations, but not their cause. This pos…
▽ More
The primary ingredients of reality are the universal quantum fields, which fluctuate persistently, spontaneously, and randomly. The general perception of the scientific community is that these quantum fluctuations are due to the uncertainty principle. Here, we present cogent arguments to show that the uncertainty principle is a consequence of the quantum fluctuations, but not their cause. This poses a conspicuous enigma as to how the universal fields remain immutable with an expectation value so accurate that it leads to experimental results, which are precise to one part in a trillion. We discuss some reasonable possibilities in the absence of a satisfactory solution to this enigma.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2023;
originally announced January 2024.
-
How Does Nature Accomplish Spooky Action at a Distance?
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
The enigmatic nonlocal quantum correlation that was famously derided by Einstein as "spooky action at a distance" has now been experimentally demonstrated to be authentic. The quantum entanglement and nonlocal correlations emerged as inevitable consequences of John Bell's epochal paper on Bell's inequality. However, in spite of some extraordinary applications as well as attempts to explain the rea…
▽ More
The enigmatic nonlocal quantum correlation that was famously derided by Einstein as "spooky action at a distance" has now been experimentally demonstrated to be authentic. The quantum entanglement and nonlocal correlations emerged as inevitable consequences of John Bell's epochal paper on Bell's inequality. However, in spite of some extraordinary applications as well as attempts to explain the reason for quantum nonlocality, a satisfactory account of how Nature accomplishes this astounding phenomenon is yet to emerge. A cogent mechanism for the occurrence of this incredible event is presented in terms of a plausible quantum mechanical Einstein-Rosen bridge.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Can Decoherence Solve the Measurement Problem?
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
The quantum decoherence program has become more attractive in providing an acceptable solution for the long-standing quantum measurement problem. Decoherence by quantum entanglement happens very quickly to entangle the quantum system with the environment including the detector. But in the final stage of measurement, acquiring the unentangled pointer states poses some problems. Recent experimental…
▽ More
The quantum decoherence program has become more attractive in providing an acceptable solution for the long-standing quantum measurement problem. Decoherence by quantum entanglement happens very quickly to entangle the quantum system with the environment including the detector. But in the final stage of measurement, acquiring the unentangled pointer states poses some problems. Recent experimental observations of the effect of the ubiquitous quantum vacuum fluctuations in destroying quantum entanglement appears to provide a solution.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2022;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Is Schrödinger's Cat Alive?
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
Erwin Schrödinger is famous for presenting his wave equation of motion that jump-started quantum mechanics. His disenchantment with the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics led him to unveil the Schrödinger's cat paradox, which did not get much attention for nearly half a century. In the meantime, disappointment with quantum mechanics turned his interest to biology facilitating, albeit i…
▽ More
Erwin Schrödinger is famous for presenting his wave equation of motion that jump-started quantum mechanics. His disenchantment with the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics led him to unveil the Schrödinger's cat paradox, which did not get much attention for nearly half a century. In the meantime, disappointment with quantum mechanics turned his interest to biology facilitating, albeit in a peripheral way, the revelation of the structure of DNA. Interest in Schrödinger's cat has recently come roaring back making its appearance conspicuously in numerous scientific articles. From the arguments presented here, it would appear that the legendary Schrödinger's cat is here to stay, symbolizing a profound truth that quantum reality exists at all scales; but we do not observe it in our daily macroscopic world as it is masked for all practical purposes, most likely by environmental decoherence with irreversible thermal effects.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Is the Quantum State Real in the Hilbert Space Formulation?
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
The persistent debate about the reality of a quantum state has recently come under limelight because of its importance to quantum information and the quantum computing community. Almost all of the deliberations are taking place using the elegant and powerful but abstract Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics developed with seminal contributions from John von Neumann. Since it is rather diff…
▽ More
The persistent debate about the reality of a quantum state has recently come under limelight because of its importance to quantum information and the quantum computing community. Almost all of the deliberations are taking place using the elegant and powerful but abstract Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics developed with seminal contributions from John von Neumann. Since it is rather difficult to get a direct perception of the events in an abstract vector space, it is hard to trace the progress of a phenomenon. Among the multitude of recent attempts to show the reality of the quantum state in Hilbert space, the Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph theory gets most recognition for their proof. But some of its assumptions have been criticized, which are still not considered to be entirely loophole free. A straightforward proof of the reality of the wave packet function of a single particle has been presented earlier based on the currently recognized fundamental reality of the universal quantum fields. Quantum states like the atomic energy levels comprising the wave packets have been shown to be just as real. Here we show that an unambiguous proof of reality of the quantum states gleaned from the reality of quantum fields can also provide an explicit substantiation of the reality of quantum states in Hilbert space.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
How Do the Probabilities Arise in Quantum Measurement?
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
A satisfactory resolution of the persistent quantum measurement problem remains stubbornly unresolved in spite of an overabundance of efforts of many prominent scientists over the decades. Among others, one key element is considered yet to be resolved. It comprises of where the probabilities of the measurement outcome stem from. This article attempts to provide a plausible answer to this enigma, t…
▽ More
A satisfactory resolution of the persistent quantum measurement problem remains stubbornly unresolved in spite of an overabundance of efforts of many prominent scientists over the decades. Among others, one key element is considered yet to be resolved. It comprises of where the probabilities of the measurement outcome stem from. This article attempts to provide a plausible answer to this enigma, thus eventually making progress toward a cogent solution of the longstanding measurement problem.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
How Dirac's Seminal Contributions Pave the Way for Comprehending Nature's Deeper Designs
Authors:
Mani L. Bhaumik
Abstract:
Credible reasons are presented to reveal that many of the lingering century old enigmas, surrounding the behavior of at least an individual quantum particle, can be comprehended in terms of an objectively real specific wave function. This wave function is gleaned from the single particle energy-momentum eigenstate offered by the theory of space filling universal quantum fields that is an inevitabl…
▽ More
Credible reasons are presented to reveal that many of the lingering century old enigmas, surrounding the behavior of at least an individual quantum particle, can be comprehended in terms of an objectively real specific wave function. This wave function is gleaned from the single particle energy-momentum eigenstate offered by the theory of space filling universal quantum fields that is an inevitable outcome of Dirac's pioneering masterpiece. Examples of these well-known enigmas are wave particle duality, the de Broglie hypothesis, the uncertainty principle, wave function collapse, and predictions of measurement outcomes in terms of probability instead of certainty. Paul Dirac successfully incorporated special theory of relativity into quantum mechanics for the first time. This was accomplished through his ingenious use of matrices that allowed the equations of motion to maintain the necessary first order time derivative feature necessary for positive probability density. The ensuing Dirac equation for the electron led to the recognition of the mystifying quantized spin and magnetic moment as intrinsic properties in contrast to earlier ad hoc assumptions. The solution of his relativistic equation for the hydrogen atom produced results in perfect agreement with experimental data available at the time. The most far reaching prediction of the celebrated Dirac equation was the totally unexpected existence of anti-particles, culminating in the eventual development of the quantum field theory of the Standard Model that reveals the deepest secrets of the universe known to date.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Deciphering the Enigma of Wave-Particle Duality
Authors:
Mani Bhaumik
Abstract:
A reasonable explanation of the confounding wave-particle duality of matter is presented in terms of the reality of the wave nature of a particle. In this view a quantum particle is an objectively real wave packet consisting of irregular disturbances of underlying quantum fields. It travels holistically as a unit and thereby acts as a particle. Only the totality of the entire wave packet at any in…
▽ More
A reasonable explanation of the confounding wave-particle duality of matter is presented in terms of the reality of the wave nature of a particle. In this view a quantum particle is an objectively real wave packet consisting of irregular disturbances of underlying quantum fields. It travels holistically as a unit and thereby acts as a particle. Only the totality of the entire wave packet at any instance embodies all the conserved quantities, for example the energy-momentum, rest mass, and charge of the particle, and as such must be acquired all at once during detection. On this basis, many of the bizarre behaviors observed in the quantum domain, such as wave function collapse, the limitation of prediction to only a probability rather than a certainty, the apparent simultaneous existence of a particle in more than one place, and the inherent uncertainty can be adequately understood. The reality of comprehending the wave function as an amplitude distribution of irregular disturbances imposes the necessity of acquiring the wave function in its entirety for detection. This is evinced by the observed certainty of wave function collapse that supports the paradigm of reality of the wave function portrayed in this article.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2017; v1 submitted 29 October, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Was Einstein Wrong on Quantum Physics?
Authors:
Mani Bhaumik
Abstract:
Einstein is considered by many as the father of quantum physics in some sense. Yet there is an unshakable view that he was wrong on quantum physics. Although it may be a subject of considerable debate, the core of his allegedly wrong demurral was the insistence on finding an objective reality underlying the manifestly bizarre behavior of quantum objects. The uncanny wave-particle duality of a quan…
▽ More
Einstein is considered by many as the father of quantum physics in some sense. Yet there is an unshakable view that he was wrong on quantum physics. Although it may be a subject of considerable debate, the core of his allegedly wrong demurral was the insistence on finding an objective reality underlying the manifestly bizarre behavior of quantum objects. The uncanny wave-particle duality of a quantum particle is a prime example. In view of the latest developments, particularly in quantum field theory, objections of Einstein are substantially corroborated. Careful investigation suggests that a travelling quantum particle is a holistic wave packet consisting of an assemblage of irregular disturbances in quantum fields. It acts as a particle because only the totality of all the disturbances in the wave packet yields the energy momentum with the mass of a particle, along with its other conserved quantities such as charge and spin. Thus the wave function representing a particle is not just a fictitious mathematical construct but embodies a reality of nature as asserted by Einstein.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2021; v1 submitted 5 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Reality of the wave function and quantum entanglement
Authors:
Mani Bhaumik
Abstract:
The intrinsic fluctuations of the underlying, immutable quantum fields that fill all space and time can support the element of reality of a wave function in quantum mechanics. The mysterious non-locality of quantum entanglement may also be understood in terms of these inherent quantum fluctuations, ever-present at the most fundamental level of the universe.
The intrinsic fluctuations of the underlying, immutable quantum fields that fill all space and time can support the element of reality of a wave function in quantum mechanics. The mysterious non-locality of quantum entanglement may also be understood in terms of these inherent quantum fluctuations, ever-present at the most fundamental level of the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2014; v1 submitted 15 December, 2013;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Comprehending Quantum Theory from Quantum Fields
Authors:
Mani Bhaumik
Abstract:
At the primary level of reality as described by quantum field theory, a fundamental particle like an electron represents a stable, discrete, propagating excited state of its underlying quantum field. QFT also tells us that the lowest vacuum state as well as the excited states of such a field is always very active with spontaneous, unpredictable quantum fluctuations. Also an underlying quantum fiel…
▽ More
At the primary level of reality as described by quantum field theory, a fundamental particle like an electron represents a stable, discrete, propagating excited state of its underlying quantum field. QFT also tells us that the lowest vacuum state as well as the excited states of such a field is always very active with spontaneous, unpredictable quantum fluctuations. Also an underlying quantum field is known to be indestructible and immutable possessing the same value in each element of spacetime comprising the universe. These characteristics of the primary quantum fields together with the fact that the quantum fluctuations can be cogently substantiated to be quantum coherent throughout the universe provide a possible ontology of the quantum theory. In this picture, the wave function of a quantum particle represents the reality of the inherent quantum fluctuations at the core of the universe and endows the particle its counter intuitive quantum behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2014; v1 submitted 4 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
