Comment on "Inverse Square Lévy Walks are not Optimal Search Strategies for d $\geq$ 2" [Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 080601 (2020)]
Authors:
S. V. Buldyrev,
E. P. Raposo,
F. Bartumeus,
S. Havlin,
F. R. Rusch,
M. G. E. da Luz,
G. M. Viswanathan
Abstract:
It is widely accepted that inverse square Lévy walks are optimal search strategies because they maximize the encounter rate with sparse, randomly distributed, replenishable targets when the search restarts in the vicinity of the previously visited target, which becomes revisitable again with high probability, i.e., non-destructive foraging [Nature 401, 911 (1999)]. The precise conditions for the v…
▽ More
It is widely accepted that inverse square Lévy walks are optimal search strategies because they maximize the encounter rate with sparse, randomly distributed, replenishable targets when the search restarts in the vicinity of the previously visited target, which becomes revisitable again with high probability, i.e., non-destructive foraging [Nature 401, 911 (1999)]. The precise conditions for the validity of this Lévy flight foraging hypothesis (LFH) have been widely described in the literature [Phys. Life Rev. 14, 94 (2015)]. Nevertheless, three objecting claims to the LFH have been raised recently for $d \geq 2$: (i) the capture rate $η$ has linear dependence on the target density $ρ$ for all values of the Lévy index $α$; (ii) "the gain $η_{max}/η$ achieved by varying $α$ is bounded even in the limit $ρ\to 0 $" so that "tuning $α$ can only yield a marginal gain"; (iii) depending on the values of the radius of detection $a$, the restarting distance $l_c$ and the scale parameter $s$, the optimum is realized for a range of $α$ [Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 080601 (2020)]. Here we answer each of these three criticisms in detail and show that claims (i)-(iii) do not actually invalidate the LFH. Our results and analyses restore the original result of the LFH for non-destructive foraging.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2021; v1 submitted 19 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
Active and reactive behaviour in human mobility: the influence of attraction points on pedestrians
Authors:
Mario Gutiérrez-Roig,
Oleguer Sagarra,
Aitana Oltra,
John R. B. Palmer,
Frederic Bartumeus,
Albert Diaz-Guilera,
Josep Perelló
Abstract:
Human mobility is becoming an accessible field of study thanks to the progress and availability of tracking technologies as a common feature of smart phones. We describe an example of a scalable experiment exploiting these circumstances at a public, outdoor fair in Barcelona (Spain). Participants were tracked while wandering through an open space with activity stands attracting their attention. We…
▽ More
Human mobility is becoming an accessible field of study thanks to the progress and availability of tracking technologies as a common feature of smart phones. We describe an example of a scalable experiment exploiting these circumstances at a public, outdoor fair in Barcelona (Spain). Participants were tracked while wandering through an open space with activity stands attracting their attention. We develop a general modeling framework based on Langevin Dynamics, which allows us to test the influence of two distinct types of ingredients on mobility: reactive or context-dependent factors, modelled by means of a force field generated by attraction points in a given spatial configuration, and active or inherent factors, modelled from intrinsic movement patterns of the subjects. The additive and constructive framework model accounts for the observed features. Starting with the simplest model (purely random walkers) as a reference, we progressively introduce different ingredients such as persistence, memory, and perceptual landscape, aiming to untangle active and reactive contributions and quantify their respective relevance. The proposed approach may help in anticipating the spatial distribution of citizens in alternative scenarios and in improving the design of public events based on a facts-based approach.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2015; v1 submitted 11 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
