Showing 1–29 of 29 results for author: Bae, H J

Transient growth and nonlinear breakdown of wavelet-based resolvent modes in turbulent channel flow

Authors: Eric Ballouz, Scott T. M. Dawson, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: We study the effectiveness of the time-localised principal resolvent forcing mode at actuating the near wall cycle of turbulence. The mode is restricted to a wavelet pulse and computed from an SVD of the windowed wavelet-based resolvent operator so that it produces the largest amplification via the linearised Navier-Stokes equations. We then inject this time-localised mode into the turbulent minim… ▽ More We study the effectiveness of the time-localised principal resolvent forcing mode at actuating the near wall cycle of turbulence. The mode is restricted to a wavelet pulse and computed from an SVD of the windowed wavelet-based resolvent operator so that it produces the largest amplification via the linearised Navier-Stokes equations. We then inject this time-localised mode into the turbulent minimal flow unit at different intensities, and measure the instantaneous deviation of the system's response from the optimal resolvent response mode. This is possible under the new formulation, which enables the modes to represent transient trajectories. For the most energetic spatial wave numbers in the minimal flow unit -- constant in the streamwise direction and once-periodic in the spanwise direction -- the forcing mode takes the shape of streamwise rolls and produces a response mode in the form of streamwise streaks that transiently grow and decay. For initial times and close to the wall, the DNS response matches the principal response mode well, but due to nonlinearities, the response across all forcing intensities decays prematurely, and a higher forcing intensity leads to faster energy decay. The principal forcing mode still leads to significant energy amplification and is more effective than a randomly-generated forcing structure and the second suboptimal resolvent forcing mode at amplifying the near-wall streaks. We compute the nonlinear energy transfer to secondary modes and observe that the breakdown of the actuated mode proceeds similarly across all forcing intensities: in the near-wall region, the induced streak forks into a structure twice periodic in the spanwise direction; in the outer region, the streak breaks up into a structure that is once periodic in the streamwise direction. In both regions, spanwise gradients account for the dominant share of nonlinear energy transfer. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2025; v1 submitted 11 February, 2025; originally announced February 2025.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2312.15465

Wavelet-based resolvent analysis of non-stationary flows

Authors: Eric Ballouz, Barbara Lopez-Doriga, Scott T. M. Dawson, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: This work introduces a formulation of resolvent analysis that uses wavelet transforms rather than Fourier transforms in time. Under this formulation, resolvent analysis may extend to turbulent flows with non-stationary mean states; the optimal resolvent modes are augmented with a temporal dimension and are able to encode the time-transient trajectories that are most amplified by the linearised Nav… ▽ More This work introduces a formulation of resolvent analysis that uses wavelet transforms rather than Fourier transforms in time. Under this formulation, resolvent analysis may extend to turbulent flows with non-stationary mean states; the optimal resolvent modes are augmented with a temporal dimension and are able to encode the time-transient trajectories that are most amplified by the linearised Navier-Stokes equations. We first show that the wavelet- and Fourier-based resolvent analyses give equivalent results for statistically-stationary flow by applying them to turbulent channel flow. We then use wavelet-based resolvent analysis to study the transient growth mechanism in the near-wall region of turbulent channel flow by windowing the resolvent operator in time and frequency. The computed principal resolvent response mode, i.e. the velocity field optimally amplified by the linearised dynamics of the flow, exhibits the Orr mechanism, supporting the claim that this mechanism is key to linear transient energy growth. We also apply this method to non-stationary parallel shear flows such as an oscillating boundary layer, and three-dimensional channel flow in which a sudden spanwise pressure gradient perturbs a fully-developed turbulent channel flow. In both cases, wavelet-based resolvent analysis yields modes that are sensitive to the changing mean profile of the flow. For the oscillating boundary layer, wavelet-based resolvent analysis produces oscillating principal forcing and response modes that peak at times and wall-normal locations associated with high turbulent activity. For the three-dimensional turbulent channel flow, the resolvent modes gradually realign themselves with the mean flow as it deviates. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2024; v1 submitted 9 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2212.02660

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 999 (2024) A53

Sparse space-time resolvent analysis for statistically-stationary and time-varying flows

Authors: Barbara Lopez-Doriga, Eric Ballouz, H. Jane Bae, Scott T. M. Dawson

Abstract: Resolvent analysis provides a framework to predict coherent spatio-temporal structures of largest linear energy amplification, through a singular value decomposition (SVD) of the resolvent operator, obtained by linearizing the Navier-Stokes equations about a known turbulent mean velocity profile. Resolvent analysis utilizes a Fourier decomposition in time, which limits its application to statistic… ▽ More Resolvent analysis provides a framework to predict coherent spatio-temporal structures of largest linear energy amplification, through a singular value decomposition (SVD) of the resolvent operator, obtained by linearizing the Navier-Stokes equations about a known turbulent mean velocity profile. Resolvent analysis utilizes a Fourier decomposition in time, which limits its application to statistically-stationary or time-periodic flows. This work develops a variant of resolvent analysis applicable to time-evolving flows, and proposes a variant that identifies spatio-temporally sparse structures, applicable to either stationary or time-varying systems. Spatio-temporal resolvent analysis is formulated through the incorporation of the temporal dimension via a discrete time-differentiation operator. Sparsity (localisation) is achieved through the addition of an l1-norm penalisation term to the optimisation associated with the SVD. This modified problem can be formulated as a nonlinear eigenproblem, and solved via an inverse power method. We first showcase the implementation of the sparse analysis on statistically-stationary turbulent channel flow, and demonstrate that the sparse variant can identify aspects of the physics not directly evident from standard resolvent analysis. This is followed by applying the sparse space-time formulation on systems that are time-varying: a time-periodic turbulent Stokes boundary layer, and then a turbulent channel flow with a sudden imposition of a lateral pressure gradient, with the original streamwise pressure gradient unchanged. We present results demonstrating how the sparsity-promoting variant can either change the quantitative structure of the leading space-time modes to increase their sparsity, or identify entirely different linear amplification mechanisms compared to non-sparse resolvent analysis. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2024; v1 submitted 9 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Are the dynamics of wall turbulence in minimal channels and larger domain channels equivalent? A graph-theoretic approach

Authors: Ahmed Elnahhas, Emma Lenz, Parviz Moin, Adrián Lozano-Durán, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: This work proposes two algorithmic approaches to extract critical dynamical mechanisms in wall-bounded turbulence with minimum human bias. In both approaches, multiple types of coherent structures are spatiotemporally tracked, resulting in a complex multilayer network. Network motif analysis, i.e., extracting dominant non-random elemental patterns within these networks, is used to identify the mos… ▽ More This work proposes two algorithmic approaches to extract critical dynamical mechanisms in wall-bounded turbulence with minimum human bias. In both approaches, multiple types of coherent structures are spatiotemporally tracked, resulting in a complex multilayer network. Network motif analysis, i.e., extracting dominant non-random elemental patterns within these networks, is used to identify the most dominant dynamical mechanisms. Both approaches, combined with network motif analysis, are used to answer whether the main dynamical mechanisms of a minimal flow unit (MFU) and a larger unconstrained channel flow, labeled a full channel (FC), at $Re_τ\approx 180$, are equivalent. The first approach tracks traditional coherent structures defined as low- and high-speed streaks, ejections, and sweeps. It is found that the roll-streak pairing, consistent with the current understanding of self-sustaining processes, is the most significant and simplest dynamical mechanism in both flows. However, the MFU has a timescale for this mechanism that is approximately $2.83$ times slower than that of the FC. In the second approach, we use semi-Lagrangian wavepackets and define coherent structures from their energetic streak, roll, and small-scale phase space. This method also shows similar motifs for both the MFU and FC. It indicates that, on average, the most dominant phase-space motifs are similar between the two flows, with the significant events taking place approximately $2.21$ times slower in the MFU than in the FC. This value is more consistent with the implied timescale ratio of only the slow speed streaks taking part in the roll-streak pairing extracted using the first multi-type spatiotemporal approach, which is approximately $2.17$ slower in the MFU than the FC. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Linear and nonlinear Granger causality analysis of turbulent duct flows

Authors: Barbara Lopez-Doriga, Marco Atzori, Ricardo Vinuesa, H. Jane Bae, Ankit Srivastava, Scott T. M. Dawson

Abstract: This research focuses on the identification and causality analysis of coherent structures that arise in turbulent flows in square and rectangular ducts. Coherent structures are first identified from direct numerical simulation data via proper orthogonal decomposition (POD), both by using all velocity components, and after separating the streamwise and secondary components of the flow. The causal r… ▽ More This research focuses on the identification and causality analysis of coherent structures that arise in turbulent flows in square and rectangular ducts. Coherent structures are first identified from direct numerical simulation data via proper orthogonal decomposition (POD), both by using all velocity components, and after separating the streamwise and secondary components of the flow. The causal relations between the mode coefficients are analysed using pairwise-conditional Granger causality analysis. We also formulate a nonlinear Granger causality analysis that can account for nonlinear interactions between modes. Focusing on streamwise-constant structures within a duct of short streamwise extent, we show that the causal relationships are highly sensitive to whether the mode coefficients or their squared values are considered, whether nonlinear effects are explicitly accounted for, and whether streamwise and secondary flow structures are separated prior to causality analyses. We leverage these sensitivities to determine that linear mechanisms underpin causal relationships between modes that share the same symmetry or anti-symmetry properties about the corner bisector, while nonlinear effects govern the causal interactions between symmetric and antisymmetric modes. In all cases, we find that the secondary flow fluctuations (manifesting as streamwise vorticial structures) are the primary cause of both the presence and movement of near-wall streaks towards and away from the duct corners. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Transient growth of wavelet-based resolvent modes in the buffer layer of wall-bounded turbulence

Authors: Eric Ballouz, Scott T. M. Dawson, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: In this work, we study the transient growth of the principal resolvent modes in the minimal flow unit using a reformulation of resolvent analysis in a time-localized wavelet basis. We target the most energetic spatial wavenumbers for the minimal flow unit and obtain modes that are constant in the streamwise direction and once-periodic in the spanwise direction. The forcing modes are in the shape o… ▽ More In this work, we study the transient growth of the principal resolvent modes in the minimal flow unit using a reformulation of resolvent analysis in a time-localized wavelet basis. We target the most energetic spatial wavenumbers for the minimal flow unit and obtain modes that are constant in the streamwise direction and once-periodic in the spanwise direction. The forcing modes are in the shape of streamwise rolls, though pulse-like in time, and the response modes are in the form of transiently growing streaks. We inject the principal transient forcing mode at different intensities into a simulation of the minimal flow unit and compare the resulting nonlinear response to the linear one. The peak energy amplification scales quadratically with the intensity of the injected mode, and this peak occurs roughly at the same time for all forcing intensities. However, the larger energy amplification intensifies the magnitude of the nonlinear terms, which play an important role in damping the energy growth and accelerating energy decay of the principal resolvent mode. We also observe that the damping effect of the nonlinearities is less prominent close to the wall. Finally, we find that the principal resolvent forcing mode is more effective than other structures at amplifying the streak energy in the turbulent minimal-flow unit. In addition to lending support to the claim that linear mechanisms are important to near-wall turbulence, this work identifies time scales for the nonlinear breakdown of linearly-generated streaks. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Sensitivity analysis of wall-modeled large-eddy simulation for separated turbulent flow

Authors: Di Zhou, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: In this study, we conduct a parametric analysis to evaluate the sensitivities of wall-modeled large-eddy simulation (LES) with respect to subgrid-scale (SGS) models, mesh resolution, wall boundary conditions and mesh anisotropy. While such investigations have been conducted for attached/flat-plate flow configurations, systematic studies specifically targeting turbulent flows with separation are no… ▽ More In this study, we conduct a parametric analysis to evaluate the sensitivities of wall-modeled large-eddy simulation (LES) with respect to subgrid-scale (SGS) models, mesh resolution, wall boundary conditions and mesh anisotropy. While such investigations have been conducted for attached/flat-plate flow configurations, systematic studies specifically targeting turbulent flows with separation are notably sparse. To bridge this gap, our study focuses on the flow over a two-dimensional Gaussian-shaped bump at a moderately high Reynolds number, which involves smooth-body separation of a turbulent boundary layer under pressure-gradient and surface-curvature effects. In the simulations, the no-slip condition at the wall is replaced by three different forms of boundary condition based on the thin boundary layer equations and the mean wall-shear stress from high-fidelity numerical simulation to avoid the additional complexity of modeling the wall-shear stress. Various statistics, including the mean separation bubble size, mean velocity profile, and dissipation from SGS model, are compared and analyzed. The results reveal that capturing the separation bubble strongly depends on the choice of SGS model. While simulations approach grid convergence with resolutions nearing those of wall-resolved LES meshes, above this limit, the LES predictions exhibit intricate sensitivities to mesh resolution. Furthermore, both wall boundary conditions and the anisotropy of mesh cells exert discernible impacts on the turbulent flow predictions, yet the magnitudes of these impacts vary based on the specific SGS model chosen for the simulation. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2024; v1 submitted 24 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Wall Modeling of Turbulent Flows with Varying Pressure Gradients Using Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning

Authors: Di Zhou, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: We propose a framework for developing wall models for large-eddy simulation that is able to capture pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning. Within this framework, the distributed reinforcement learning agents receive off-wall environmental states including pressure gradient and turbulence strain rate, ensuring adaptability to a wide range of flows characterized by press… ▽ More We propose a framework for developing wall models for large-eddy simulation that is able to capture pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning. Within this framework, the distributed reinforcement learning agents receive off-wall environmental states including pressure gradient and turbulence strain rate, ensuring adaptability to a wide range of flows characterized by pressure-gradient effects and separations. Based on these states, the agents determine an action to adjust the wall eddy viscosity, and consequently the wall-shear stress. The model training is in situ with wall-modeled large-eddy simulation grid resolutions and does not rely on the instantaneous velocity fields from high-fidelity simulations. Throughout the training, the agents compute rewards from the relative error in the estimated wall-shear stress, which allows the agents to refine an optimal control policy that minimizes prediction errors. Employing this framework, wall models are trained for two distinct subgrid-scale models using low-Reynolds-number flow over periodic hills. These models are validated through simulations of flows over periodic hills at higher Reynolds numbers and flow over the Boeing Gaussian bump. The developed wall models successfully capture the acceleration and deceleration of wall-bounded turbulent flows under pressure gradients and outperform the equilibrium wall model in predicting skin friction. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2024; v1 submitted 4 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2211.16427

Log-law recovery through reinforcement-learning wall model for large-eddy simulation

Authors: Aurélien Vadrot, Xiang I. A. Yang, H. Jane Bae, Mahdi Abkar

Abstract: This paper focuses on the use of reinforcement learning (RL) as a machine-learning (ML) modeling tool for near-wall turbulence. RL has demonstrated its effectiveness in solving high-dimensional problems, especially in domains such as games. Despite its potential, RL is still not widely used for turbulence modeling and is primarily used for flow control and optimization purposes. A new RL wall mode… ▽ More This paper focuses on the use of reinforcement learning (RL) as a machine-learning (ML) modeling tool for near-wall turbulence. RL has demonstrated its effectiveness in solving high-dimensional problems, especially in domains such as games. Despite its potential, RL is still not widely used for turbulence modeling and is primarily used for flow control and optimization purposes. A new RL wall model (WM) called VYBA23 is developed in this work, which uses agents dispersed in the flow near the wall. The model is trained on a single Reynolds number ($Re_τ= 10^4$) and does not rely on high-fidelity data, as the back-propagation process is based on a reward rather than output error. The states of the RLWM, which are the representation of the environment by the agents, are normalized to remove dependence on the Reynolds number. The model is tested and compared to another RLWM (BK22) and to an equilibrium wall model, in a half-channel flow at eleven different Reynolds numbers ($Re_τ\in [180;10^{10}]$). The effects of varying agents' parameters such as actions range, time-step, and spacing are also studied. The results are promising, showing little effect on the average flow field but some effect on wall-shear stress fluctuations and velocity fluctuations. This work offers positive prospects for developing RLWMs that can recover physical laws, and for extending this type of ML models to more complex flows in the future. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2211.03614

Towards real-time reconstruction of velocity fluctuations in turbulent channel flow

Authors: Rahul Arun, H. Jane Bae, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: We develop a framework for efficient streaming reconstructions of turbulent velocity fluctuations from limited sensor measurements with the goal of enabling real-time applications. The reconstruction process is simplified by computing linear estimators using flow statistics from an initial training period and evaluating their performance during a subsequent testing period with data obtained from d… ▽ More We develop a framework for efficient streaming reconstructions of turbulent velocity fluctuations from limited sensor measurements with the goal of enabling real-time applications. The reconstruction process is simplified by computing linear estimators using flow statistics from an initial training period and evaluating their performance during a subsequent testing period with data obtained from direct numerical simulation. We address cases where (i) no, (ii) limited, and (iii) full-field training data are available using estimators based on (i) resolvent modes, (ii) resolvent-based estimation, and (iii) spectral proper orthogonal decomposition modes. During training, we introduce blockwise inversion to accurately and efficiently compute the resolvent operator in an interpretable manner. During testing, we enable efficient streaming reconstructions by using a temporal sliding discrete Fourier transform to recursively update Fourier coefficients using incoming measurements. We use this framework to reconstruct with minimal time delay the turbulent velocity fluctuations in a minimal channel at ${\rm Re}_τ\approx 186$ from sparse planar measurements. We evaluate reconstruction accuracy in the context of the extent of data required and thereby identify potential use cases for each estimator. The reconstructions capture large portions of the dynamics from relatively few measurement planes when the linear estimators are computed with sufficient fidelity. We also evaluate the efficiency of our reconstructions and show that the present framework has the potential to help enable real-time reconstructions of turbulent velocity fluctuations in an analogous experimental setting. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2023; v1 submitted 17 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 36 pages, 22 figures, accepted by Physical Review Fluids

Journal ref: Physical Review Fluids 8, 064612 (2023)

A sparsity-promoting resolvent analysis for the identification of spatiotemporally-localized amplification mechanisms

Authors: Barbara Lopez-Doriga, Eric Ballouz, H. Jane Bae, Scott T. M. Dawson

Abstract: This work introduces a variant of resolvent analysis that identifies forcing and response modes that are sparse in both space and time. This is achieved through the use of a sparse principal component analysis (PCA) algorithm, which formulates the associated optimization problem as a nonlinear eigenproblem that can be solved with an inverse power method. We apply this method to parallel shear flow… ▽ More This work introduces a variant of resolvent analysis that identifies forcing and response modes that are sparse in both space and time. This is achieved through the use of a sparse principal component analysis (PCA) algorithm, which formulates the associated optimization problem as a nonlinear eigenproblem that can be solved with an inverse power method. We apply this method to parallel shear flows, both in the case where we assume Fourier modes in time (as in standard resolvent analysis) and obtain spatial localization, and where we allow for temporally-sparse modes through the use of a linearized Navier-Stokes operator discretized in both space and time. Appropriate choice of desired mode sparsity allows for the identification of structures corresponding to high amplification that are localized in both space and time. We report on the similarities and differences between these structures and those from standard methods of analysis. After validating this space-time resolvent analysis on statistically-stationary channel flow, we next implement the methodology on a time-periodic Stokes boundary layer, demonstrating the applicability of the approach to non-statistically-stationary systems. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Wavelet-based resolvent analysis for statistically-stationary and temporally-evolving flows

Authors: Eric Ballouz, Barbara Lopez-Doriga, Scott T. M. Dawson, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: This work introduces a formulation of resolvent analysis that uses wavelet transforms rather than Fourier transforms in time. This allows resolvent analysis to be extended to turbulent flows with non-stationary means in addition to statistically-stationary flows. The optimal resolvent modes for this formulation correspond to the potentially time-transient structures that are most amplified by the… ▽ More This work introduces a formulation of resolvent analysis that uses wavelet transforms rather than Fourier transforms in time. This allows resolvent analysis to be extended to turbulent flows with non-stationary means in addition to statistically-stationary flows. The optimal resolvent modes for this formulation correspond to the potentially time-transient structures that are most amplified by the linearized Navier-Stokes operator. We validate this methodology for turbulent channel flow and show that the wavelet-based and Fourier-based resolvent analyses are equivalent for statistically-stationary flows. We then apply the wavelet-based resolvent analysis to study the transient growth mechanism in the buffer layer of a turbulent channel flow by windowing the resolvent operator in time and frequency. The method is also applied to temporally-evolving parallel shear flows such as an oscillating boundary layer and three-dimensional channel flow, in which a lateral pressure gradient perturbs a fully-developed turbulent flow in a channel. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Multi-agent reinforcement learning for wall modeling in LES of flow over periodic hills

Authors: Di Zhou, Michael P. Whitmore, Kevin P. Griffin, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: We develop a wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) that takes into account various pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). The model is trained using low-Reynolds-number flow over periodic hills with agents distributed on the wall along the computational grid points. The model utilizes a wall eddy-viscosity formulation as the boundary condition, which is sho… ▽ More We develop a wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) that takes into account various pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). The model is trained using low-Reynolds-number flow over periodic hills with agents distributed on the wall along the computational grid points. The model utilizes a wall eddy-viscosity formulation as the boundary condition, which is shown to provide better predictions of the mean velocity field, rather than the typical wall-shear stress formulation. Each agent receives states based on local instantaneous flow quantities at an off-wall location, computes a reward based on the estimated wall-shear stress, and provides an action to update the wall eddy viscosity at each time step. The trained wall model is validated in wall-modeled LES (WMLES) of flow over periodic hills at higher Reynolds numbers, and the results show the effectiveness of the model on flow with pressure gradients. The analysis of the trained model indicates that the model is capable of distinguishing between the various pressure gradient regimes present in the flow. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Investigating nonlinearity in wall turbulence: regenerative versus parametric mechanisms

Authors: B. F. Farrell, E. Kim, H. J. Bae, M. -A. Nikolaidis, P. J. Ioannou

Abstract: Both linear growth processes associated with non-normality of the mean flow and nonlinear interaction transferring energy among fluctuations contribute to maintaining turbulence. However, a detailed understanding of the mechanism by which they cooperate in sustaining the turbulent state is lacking. In this report, we examine the role of fluctuation-fluctuation nonlinearity by varying the magnitude… ▽ More Both linear growth processes associated with non-normality of the mean flow and nonlinear interaction transferring energy among fluctuations contribute to maintaining turbulence. However, a detailed understanding of the mechanism by which they cooperate in sustaining the turbulent state is lacking. In this report, we examine the role of fluctuation-fluctuation nonlinearity by varying the magnitude of the associated term in the dynamics of Couette flow turbulence to determine how this nonlinear component helps maintain and determine the structure of the turbulent state, and particularly whether this mechanism is parametric or regenerative. Having determined that the mechanism supporting the fluctuation field in Navier-Stokes turbulence is parametric, we then study the mechanism by which the fluctuation component of turbulence is maintained by parametric growth in a time-dependent mean flow by examining the parametric growth mechanism in the frequency domain using analysis of the time-dependent resolvent. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 fgures

Report number: CTR 2022 Report

Machine learning building-block-flow wall model for large-eddy simulation

Authors: Adrián Lozano-Durán, H. Jane Bae

Abstract: A wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) is proposed by devising the flow as a combination of building blocks. The core assumption of the model is that a finite set of simple canonical flows contains the essential physics to predict the wall-shear stress in more complex scenarios. The model is constructed to predict zero/favourable/adverse mean pressure gradient wall turbulence, separation, st… ▽ More A wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) is proposed by devising the flow as a combination of building blocks. The core assumption of the model is that a finite set of simple canonical flows contains the essential physics to predict the wall-shear stress in more complex scenarios. The model is constructed to predict zero/favourable/adverse mean pressure gradient wall turbulence, separation, statistically unsteady turbulence with mean flow three-dimensionality, and laminar flow. The approach is implemented using two types of artificial neural networks: a classifier, which identifies the contribution of each building block in the flow, and a predictor, which estimates the wall-shear stress via combination of the building-block flows. The training data are directly obtained from wall-modelled LES (WMLES) optimised to reproduce the correct mean quantities. This approach guarantees the consistency of the training data with the numerical discretisation and the gridding strategy of the flow solver. The output of the model is accompanied by a confidence score in the prediction that aids the detection of regions where the model underperforms. The model is validated in canonical flows (e.g. laminar/turbulent boundary layers, turbulent channels, turbulent Poiseuille-Couette flow, turbulent pipe) and two realistic aircraft configurations: the NASA Common Research Model High-lift and NASA Juncture Flow experiment. It is shown that the building-block-flow wall model outperforms (or matches) the predictions by an equilibrium wall model. It is also concluded that further improvements in WMLES should incorporate advances in subgrid-scale modelling to minimise error propagation to the wall model. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2023; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Numerical and modeling error assessment of large-eddy simulation using direct-numerical-simulation-aided large-eddy simulation

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Adrian Lozano-Duran

Abstract: We study the numerical errors of large-eddy simulation (LES) in isotropic and wall-bounded turbulence. A direct-numerical-simulation (DNS)-aided LES formulation, where the subgrid-scale (SGS) term of the LES is computed by using filtered DNS data is introduced. We first verify that this formulation has zero error in the absence of commutation error between the filter and the differentiation operat… ▽ More We study the numerical errors of large-eddy simulation (LES) in isotropic and wall-bounded turbulence. A direct-numerical-simulation (DNS)-aided LES formulation, where the subgrid-scale (SGS) term of the LES is computed by using filtered DNS data is introduced. We first verify that this formulation has zero error in the absence of commutation error between the filter and the differentiation operator of the numerical algorithm. This method allows the evaluation of the time evolution of numerical errors for various numerical schemes at grid resolutions relevant to LES. The analysis shows that the numerical errors are of the same order of magnitude as the modeling errors and often cancel each other. This supports the idea that supervised machine learning algorithms trained on filtered DNS data might not be suitable for robust SGS model development, as this approach disregards the existence of numerical errors in the system that accumulates over time. The assessment of errors in turbulent channel flow also identifies that numerical errors close to the wall dominate, which has implications for the development of wall models. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

A local dynamic gradient Smagorinsky model for large-eddy simulation

Authors: Wybe Rozema, H. Jane Bae, Roel W. C. P. Verstappen

Abstract: This paper proposes a local dynamic model for large-eddy simulation (LES) without averaging in homogeneous directions. It is demonstrated that the widely-used dynamic Smagorinsky model (DSM) has a singular dynamic model constant if it is used without averaging. The singularity can cause exceedingly large local values of the dynamic model constant. If these large values are not mitigated by applica… ▽ More This paper proposes a local dynamic model for large-eddy simulation (LES) without averaging in homogeneous directions. It is demonstrated that the widely-used dynamic Smagorinsky model (DSM) has a singular dynamic model constant if it is used without averaging. The singularity can cause exceedingly large local values of the dynamic model constant. If these large values are not mitigated by application of averaging, they can amplify discretization errors and impair the stability of simulations. To improve the local applicability of the DSM, the singularity is removed by replacing the resolved rate-of-strain tensors in the Smagorinsky model with the resolved velocity gradient tensor. These replacements result in the new dynamic gradient Smagorinsky model (DGSM). Results of simulations of three canonical turbulent flows (decaying homogeneous isotropic turbulence, a temporal mixing layer, and turbulent channel flow) are presented to demonstrate the potential of this model. The DGSM provides improved stability compared to the local DSM, and does not require averaging for stability at time step sizes that are typically used for a static locally consistent LES model. Results obtained with the DGSM are generally as accurate as results obtained with the DSM, while the DGSM has lower computational complexity. Moreover, the DGSM is easy to implement and does not require any homogeneous direction in space or time. It is thus anticipated that the model has a high potential for the simulation of complex flows. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2022; v1 submitted 11 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Scientific multi-agent reinforcement learning for wall-models of turbulent flows

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Petros Koumoutsakos

Abstract: The predictive capabilities of turbulent flow simulations, critical for aerodynamic design and weather prediction, hinge on the choice of turbulence models. The abundance of data from experiments and simulations and the advent of machine learning have provided a boost to turbulence modeling efforts. However, simulations of turbulent flows remain hindered by the inability of heuristics and supervis… ▽ More The predictive capabilities of turbulent flow simulations, critical for aerodynamic design and weather prediction, hinge on the choice of turbulence models. The abundance of data from experiments and simulations and the advent of machine learning have provided a boost to turbulence modeling efforts. However, simulations of turbulent flows remain hindered by the inability of heuristics and supervised learning to model the near-wall dynamics. We address this challenge by introducing scientific multi-agent reinforcement learning (SciMARL) for the discovery of wall models for large-eddy simulations (LES). In SciMARL, discretization points act also as cooperating agents that learn to supply the LES closure model. The agents self-learn using limited data and generalize to extreme Reynolds numbers and previously unseen geometries. The present simulations reduce by several orders of magnitude the computational cost over fully-resolved simulations while reproducing key flow quantities. We believe that SciMARL creates unprecedented capabilities for the simulation of turbulent flows. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2022; v1 submitted 21 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Life-cycle of streaks in the buffer layer of wall-bounded turbulence

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Myoungkyu Lee

Abstract: Streaks in the buffer layer of wall-bounded turbulence are tracked in time to study their life-cycle. Spatially and temporally resolved direct numerical simulation data is used to analyze the strong wall-parallel movements conditioned to low-speed streamwise flow. The analysis of the streaks shows that there is a clear distinction between wall-attached and detached streaks, and that the former can… ▽ More Streaks in the buffer layer of wall-bounded turbulence are tracked in time to study their life-cycle. Spatially and temporally resolved direct numerical simulation data is used to analyze the strong wall-parallel movements conditioned to low-speed streamwise flow. The analysis of the streaks shows that there is a clear distinction between wall-attached and detached streaks, and that the former can be further categorized into streaks that are contained in the buffer layer and the ones that reach the outer region. The results reveal that streaks are born in the buffer layer, coalescing with each other to create larger streaks that are still attached to the wall. Once the streak becomes large enough, it starts to meander due to the large streamwise-to-wall-normal aspect ratio, and consequently the elongation in the streamwise direction, which makes it more difficult for the streak to be oriented strictly in the streamwise direction. While the continuous interaction of the streaks allows the super-structure to span extremely long temporal and length scales, individual streak components are relatively small and short-lived. Tall-attached streaks eventually split into wall-attached and wall-detached components. These wall-detached streaks have a strong wall-normal velocity away from the wall, similar to ejections or bursts observed in the literature. Conditionally averaging the flow fields to these split events show that the detached streak has not only a larger wall-normal velocity compared to the wall-attached counterpart, it also has a larger (less negative) streamwise velocity, similar to the velocity field at the tip of a vortex cluster. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2021; v1 submitted 6 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 064603 (2021)

Resolvent analysis of stratification effects on wall-bounded shear flows

Authors: M. A. Ahmed, H. J. Bae, A. F. Thompson, B. J. McKeon

Abstract: The interaction between shear driven turbulence and stratification is a key process in a wide array of geophysical flows with spatio-temporal scales that span many orders of magnitude. A quick numerical model prediction based on external parameters of stratified boundary layers could greatly benefit the understanding of the interaction between velocity and scalar flux at varying scales. For these… ▽ More The interaction between shear driven turbulence and stratification is a key process in a wide array of geophysical flows with spatio-temporal scales that span many orders of magnitude. A quick numerical model prediction based on external parameters of stratified boundary layers could greatly benefit the understanding of the interaction between velocity and scalar flux at varying scales. For these reasons, here, we use the resolvent framework to investigate the effects of an active scalar on incompressible wall-bounded turbulence. We obtain the state of the flow system by applying the linear resolvent operator to the nonlinear terms in the governing Navier-Stokes equations with the Boussinesq approximation. This extends the formulation to include the scalar advection equation with the scalar component acting in the wall-normal direction in the momentum equations. We use the mean velocity profiles from a DNS of a stably-stratified turbulent channel flow at varying friction Richardson number. The results obtained from the resolvent analysis are compared to the premultiplied energy spectra, auto-correlation coefficient, and the energy budget terms obtained from the DNS. It is shown that despite using only a very limited range of representative scales, the resolvent model is able to reproduce the balance of energy budget terms as well as provide meaningful insight of coherent structures occurring in the flow. Computation of the leading resolvent models, despite considering a limited range of scales, reproduces the balance of energy budget terms, provides meaningful predictions of coherent structures in the flow, and is more cost-effective than performing full-scale simulations. This quick model can provide further understanding of stratified flows with only information about the mean profile and prior knowledge of energetic scales of motion in the neutrally-buoyant boundary layers. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 084804 (2021)

Self-critical machine-learning wall-modeled LES for external aerodynamics

Authors: Adrián Lozano-Durán, Hyunji Jane Bae

Abstract: The prediction of aircraft aerodynamic quantities of interest remains among the most pressing challenges for computational fluid dynamics. The aircraft aerodynamics are inherently turbulent with mean-flow three-dimensionality, often accompanied by laminar-to-turbulent transition, flow separation, secondary flow motions at corners, and shock wave formation, to name a few. However, the most widespre… ▽ More The prediction of aircraft aerodynamic quantities of interest remains among the most pressing challenges for computational fluid dynamics. The aircraft aerodynamics are inherently turbulent with mean-flow three-dimensionality, often accompanied by laminar-to-turbulent transition, flow separation, secondary flow motions at corners, and shock wave formation, to name a few. However, the most widespread wall models are built upon the assumption of statistically-in-equilibrium wall-bounded turbulence and do not faithfully account for the wide variety of flow conditions described above. This raises the question of how to devise models capable of accounting for such a vast and rich collection of flow physics in a feasible manner. In this work, we propose tackling the wall-modeling challenge by devising the flow as a collection of building blocks, whose information enables the prediction of the stress as the wall. The model relies on the assumption that simple canonical flows contain the essential flow physics to devise accurate models. Three types of building block units were used to train the model: turbulent channel flows, turbulent ducts and turbulent boundary layers with separation. This limited training set will be extended in future versions of the model. The approach is implemented using two interconnected artificial neural networks: a classifier, which identifies the contribution of each building block in the flow; and a predictor, which estimates the wall stress via non-linear combinations of building-block units. The output of the model is accompanied by the confidence in the prediction. The latter value aids the detection of areas where the model underperforms, such as flow regions that are not representative of the building blocks used to train the model. The model is validated in a unseen case representative of external aerodynamic applications: the NASA Juncture Flow Experiment. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2021; v1 submitted 17 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: Minor typos corrected

Journal ref: Annual Research Brief (Center for Turbulence Research, Stanford University) 2020

Nonlinear mechanism of the self-sustaining process in the buffer and logarithmic layer of wall-bounded flows

Authors: Hyunji Jane Bae, Adrian Lozano-Duran, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The nonlinear mechanism in the self-sustaining process (SSP) of wall-bounded turbulence is investigated. Resolvent analysis is used to identify the principal forcing mode which produces the maximum amplification of the velocities in numerical simulations of the minimal channel for the buffer layer and a modified logarithmic (log) layer. The wavenumbers targeted in this study are those of the funda… ▽ More The nonlinear mechanism in the self-sustaining process (SSP) of wall-bounded turbulence is investigated. Resolvent analysis is used to identify the principal forcing mode which produces the maximum amplification of the velocities in numerical simulations of the minimal channel for the buffer layer and a modified logarithmic (log) layer. The wavenumbers targeted in this study are those of the fundamental mode that is infinitely long in the streamwise direction and once periodic in the spanwise direction. The identified mode is then projected out from the nonlinear term of the Navier-Stokes equations at each time step from the simulation of the corresponding minimal channel. The results show that the removal of the principal forcing mode of the fundamental wavenumber can inhibit turbulence in both the buffer and log layer, with the effect being greater in the buffer layer. Removing other modes instead of the principal mode of the fundamental wavenumber only marginally affects the flow. Closer inspection of the dyadic interactions in the nonlinear term shows that contributions toward the principal forcing mode come from a limited set of wavenumber interactions. Using conditional averaging, the flow structures that are responsible for generating the nonlinear interaction to self-sustain turbulence are identified as spanwise rolls interacting with oblique streaks. This method, based on the equations of motion, validates the similarities in the SSP of the buffer and log layer, and characterises the underlying quadratic interactions in the SSP of the minimal channel. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2020; v1 submitted 16 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 914, A3 (2021)

Resolvent-based study of compressibility effects on supersonic turbulent boundary layers

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Scott T. M. Dawson, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010) is applied to supersonic turbulent boundary layers to study the validity of Morkovin's hypothesis, which postulates that high-speed turbulence structures in zero pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers remain largely the same as its incompressible counterpart. Supersonic zero-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers with adiabatic wall bou… ▽ More The resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010) is applied to supersonic turbulent boundary layers to study the validity of Morkovin's hypothesis, which postulates that high-speed turbulence structures in zero pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers remain largely the same as its incompressible counterpart. Supersonic zero-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers with adiabatic wall boundary conditions at Mach numbers ranging from 2 to 4 are considered. Resolvent analysis highlights two distinct regions of the supersonic turbulent boundary layer in the wave parameter space: the relatively supersonic region and the relatively subsonic region. In the relatively supersonic region, where the flow is supersonic relative to the freestream, resolvent modes display structures consistent with Mach wave radiation that are absent in the incompressible regime. In the relatively subsonic region, we show that the low-rank approximation of the resolvent operator is an effective approximation of the full system and that the response modes predicted by the model exhibit universal and geometrically self-similar behaviour via a transformation given by the semi-local scaling. Moreover, with the semi-local scaling, we show that the resolvent modes follow the same scaling law as their incompressible counterparts in this region, which has implications for modelling and the prediction of turbulent high-speed wall-bounded flows. We also show that the thermodynamic variables exhibit similar mode shapes to the streamwise velocity modes, supporting the strong Reynolds analogy. Finally, we demonstrate that the principal resolvent modes can be used to capture the energy distribution between momentum and thermodynamic fluctuations. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2019; v1 submitted 29 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 883, A29 (2020)

A nonlinear subgrid-scale model for large-eddy simulations of rotating turbulent flows

Authors: Maurits H. Silvis, H. Jane Bae, F. Xavier Trias, Mahdi Abkar, Roel Verstappen

Abstract: Rotating turbulent flows form a challenging test case for large-eddy simulation (LES). We, therefore, propose and validate a new subgrid-scale (SGS) model for such flows. The proposed SGS model consists of a dissipative eddy viscosity term as well as a nondissipative term that is nonlinear in the rate-of-strain and rate-of-rotation tensors. The two corresponding model coefficients are a function o… ▽ More Rotating turbulent flows form a challenging test case for large-eddy simulation (LES). We, therefore, propose and validate a new subgrid-scale (SGS) model for such flows. The proposed SGS model consists of a dissipative eddy viscosity term as well as a nondissipative term that is nonlinear in the rate-of-strain and rate-of-rotation tensors. The two corresponding model coefficients are a function of the vortex stretching magnitude. Therefore, the model is consistent with many physical and mathematical properties of the Navier-Stokes equations and turbulent stresses, and is easy to implement. We determine the two model constants using a nondynamic procedure that takes into account the interaction between the model terms. Using detailed direct numerical simulations (DNSs) and LESs of rotating decaying turbulence and spanwise-rotating plane-channel flow, we reveal that the two model terms respectively account for dissipation and backscatter of energy, and that the nonlinear term improves predictions of the Reynolds stress anisotropy near solid walls. We also show that the new SGS model provides good predictions of rotating decaying turbulence and leads to outstanding predictions of spanwise-rotating plane-channel flow over a large range of rotation rates for both fine and coarse grid resolutions. Moreover, the new nonlinear model performs as well as the dynamic Smagorinsky and scaled anisotropic minimum-dissipation models in LESs of rotating decaying turbulence and outperforms these models in LESs of spanwise-rotating plane-channel flow, without requiring (dynamic) adaptation or near-wall damping of the model constants. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 41 pages, 15 figures, 3 tables

Causality of energy-containing eddies in wall turbulence

Authors: Adrián Lozano-Durán, H. Jane Bae, Miguel P. Encinar

Abstract: Turbulent flows in the presence of walls may be apprehended as a collection of momentum- and energy-containing eddies (energy-eddies), whose sizes differ by many orders of magnitude. These eddies follow a self-sustaining cycle, i.e., existing eddies are seeds for the inception of new ones, and so forth. Understanding this process is critical for the modelling and control of geophysical and industr… ▽ More Turbulent flows in the presence of walls may be apprehended as a collection of momentum- and energy-containing eddies (energy-eddies), whose sizes differ by many orders of magnitude. These eddies follow a self-sustaining cycle, i.e., existing eddies are seeds for the inception of new ones, and so forth. Understanding this process is critical for the modelling and control of geophysical and industrial flows, in which a non-negligible fraction of the energy is dissipated by turbulence in the immediate vicinity of walls. In this study, we examine the causal interactions of energy-eddies in wall-bounded turbulence by quantifying how the knowledge of the past states of eddies reduces the uncertainty of their future states. The analysis is performed via direct numerical simulation (DNS) of turbulent channel flows in which time-resolved energy-eddies are isolated at a prescribed scale. Our approach unveils, in a simple manner, that causality of energy-eddies in the buffer and logarithmic layers is similar and independent of the eddy size. We further show an example of how novel flow control and modelling strategies can take advantage of such self-similar causality. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2019; v1 submitted 23 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: even more improved wording and typos corrected, format changed

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 882, A2 (2019)

DNS-aided explicitly filtered LES

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Adrián Lozano-Durán

Abstract: The equations for LES are formally derived by low-pass filtering the NS equations with the effect of the small scales on the larger ones captured by a SGS model. However, it is known that the LES equations usually employed in practical applications are inconsistent with the filter operator when no explicit filter is used. Moreover, even for explicitly filtered LES, some inconsistencies remain in t… ▽ More The equations for LES are formally derived by low-pass filtering the NS equations with the effect of the small scales on the larger ones captured by a SGS model. However, it is known that the LES equations usually employed in practical applications are inconsistent with the filter operator when no explicit filter is used. Moreover, even for explicitly filtered LES, some inconsistencies remain in the wall-normal direction due to the constraining effect of the wall. A typically undesirable effect stemming from the inconsistency between LES and the filtered NS (fNS) equations is that DNS data can not be used to aid SGS modeling. Using the proposed form of the incompressible fNS equations for flows over flat walls in which the continuity equation, the filter operator, and the boundary condition at the wall are consistently formulated, we compute a set of plane turbulent channel flow explicitly filtered LES at different grid resolutions with the SGS term computed from a parallel DNS computation starting with an equivalent initial condition. The results show that the SGS term computed from DNS provide a truthful SGS model for short times until the numerical errors compound and the two parallel computations diverge. The effective time where the statistics remain similar is longer for lower-order statistics such as mean velocity profile, as expected. This demonstrates that with the consistent fNS equations, the abundant DNS data can be used to inform SGS model development for explicitly filtered LES. Moreover, the diverging of statitics at longer times shows that the SGS contribution is not necessarily homogeous as most SGS models assume, and a more precise correlation between the instantaneous LES velocity field and SGS model is required to capture the dynamics of turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Journal ref: Center for Turbulence Research, Annual Research Briefs 2018

Characteristic scales of Townsend's wall attached eddies

Authors: Adrián Lozano-Durán, Hyunji Jane Bae

Abstract: Townsend (1976) proposed a structural model for the logarithmic layer (log-layer) of wall turbulence at high Reynolds numbers, where the dominant momentum-carrying motions are organised into a multi-scale population of eddies attached to the wall. In the attached eddy framework, the relevant length and velocity scales of the wall-attached eddies are the friction velocity and the distance to the wa… ▽ More Townsend (1976) proposed a structural model for the logarithmic layer (log-layer) of wall turbulence at high Reynolds numbers, where the dominant momentum-carrying motions are organised into a multi-scale population of eddies attached to the wall. In the attached eddy framework, the relevant length and velocity scales of the wall-attached eddies are the friction velocity and the distance to the wall. In the present work, we hypothesise that the momentum-carrying eddies are controlled by the mean momentum flux and mean shear with no explicit reference to the distance to the wall and propose new characteristic velocity, length, and time scales consistent with this argument. Our hypothesis is supported by direct numerical simulation (DNS) of turbulent channel flows driven by non-uniform body forces and modified mean velocity profiles, where the resulting outer-layer flow structures are substantially altered to accommodate the new mean momentum transfer. The proposed scaling is further corroborated by simulations where the no-slip wall is replaced by a Robin boundary condition for the three velocity components, allowing for substantial wall-normal transpiration at all lengths scales. We show that the outer-layer one-point statistics and spectra of this channel with transpiration agree quantitatively with those of its wall-bounded counterpart. The results reveal that the wall-parallel no-slip condition is not required to recover classic wall-bounded turbulence far from the wall and, more importantly, neither is the impermeability condition at the wall. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2019; v1 submitted 14 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: Section 3 revised, typos corrected

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 868, 698-725 (2019)

Dynamic slip wall model for large-eddy simulation

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Adrián Lozano-Durán, Sanjeeb T. Bose, Parviz Moin

Abstract: Wall modelling in large-eddy simulation (LES) is necessary to overcome the prohibitive near-wall resolution requirements in high-Reynolds-number turbulent flows. Most existing wall models rely on assumptions about the state of the boundary layer and require a priori prescription of tunable coefficients. They also impose the predicted wall stress by replacing the no-slip boundary condition at the w… ▽ More Wall modelling in large-eddy simulation (LES) is necessary to overcome the prohibitive near-wall resolution requirements in high-Reynolds-number turbulent flows. Most existing wall models rely on assumptions about the state of the boundary layer and require a priori prescription of tunable coefficients. They also impose the predicted wall stress by replacing the no-slip boundary condition at the wall with a Neumann boundary condition in the wall-parallel directions while maintaining the no-transpiration condition in the wall-normal direction. In the present study, we first motivate and analyse the Robin (slip) boundary condition with transpiration (nonzero wall-normal velocity) in the context of wall-modelled LES. The effect of the slip boundary condition on the one-point statistics of the flow is investigated in LES of turbulent channel flow and flat-plate turbulent boundary layer. It is shown that the slip condition provides a framework to compensate for the deficit or excess of mean momentum at the wall. Moreover, the resulting nonzero stress at the wall alleviates the well-known problem of the wall-stress under-estimation by current subgrid-scale (SGS) models. Secondly, we discuss the requirements for the slip condition to be used in conjunction with wall models and derive the equation that connects the slip boundary condition with the stress at the wall. Finally, a dynamic procedure for the slip coefficients is formulated, providing a dynamic slip wall model free of a priori specified coefficients. The performance of the proposed dynamic wall model is tested in a series of LES of turbulent channel flow, non-equilibrium three-dimensional channel flow, and flat-plate turbulent boundary layer. The results show that the dynamic wall model is able to accurately predict one-point turbulence statistics for various flow configurations, Reynolds numbers, and grid resolutions. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 859, 400-432 (2019)

Error scaling of large-eddy simulation in the outer region of wall-bounded turbulence

Authors: Adrián Lozano-Durán, Hyunji Jane Bae

Abstract: We study the error scaling properties of large-eddy simulation (LES) in the outer region of wall-bounded turbulence at moderately high Reynolds numbers. In order to avoid the additional complexity of wall-modeling, we perform LES of turbulent channel flows in which the no-slip condition at the wall is replaced by a Neumann condition supplying the exact mean wall-stress. The statistics investigated… ▽ More We study the error scaling properties of large-eddy simulation (LES) in the outer region of wall-bounded turbulence at moderately high Reynolds numbers. In order to avoid the additional complexity of wall-modeling, we perform LES of turbulent channel flows in which the no-slip condition at the wall is replaced by a Neumann condition supplying the exact mean wall-stress. The statistics investigated are the mean velocity profile, turbulence intensities, and kinetic energy spectra. The errors follow $(Δ/L)^αRe_τ^γ$, where $Δ$ is the characteristic grid resolution, $Re_τ$ is the friction Reynolds number, and $L$ is the meaningful length-scale to normalize $Δ$ in order to collapse the errors across the wall-normal distance. We show that $Δ$ can be expressed as the $L_2$-norm of the grid vector and that $L$ is well represented by the ratio of the friction velocity and mean shear. The exponent $α$ is estimated from theoretical arguments for each statistical quantity of interest and shown to roughly match the values computed by numerical simulations. For the mean profile and kinetic energy spectra, $α\approx1$, whereas the turbulence intensities converge at a slower rate $α<1$. The exponent $γ$ is approximately $0$, i.e. the LES solution is independent of the Reynolds number. The expected behavior of the turbulence intensities at high Reynolds numbers is also derived and shown to agree with the classic log-layer profiles for grid resolutions lying within the inertial range. Further examination of the LES turbulence intensities and spectra reveals that both quantities resemble their filtered counterparts from direct numerical simulation (DNS) data, but that the mechanism responsible for this similarity is related to the balance between the input power and dissipation rather than to filtering. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2019; v1 submitted 5 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: Improved clarity and typo correction

Journal ref: Journal of Computational Physics 392, 532-555 (2019)