-
Complete set of observables in pseudo-scalar meson photoproduction -- Controversy solved
Authors:
A. Švarc
Abstract:
The long-standing debate over whether the complete set of observables in pseudo-scalar meson photoproduction consists of eight or merely four elements continues to persist. From the perspective of amplitude analysis, it is argued that all eight observables are necessary to completely determine the others. On the other hand, proponents of partial-wave analysis, working with theoretically precise da…
▽ More
The long-standing debate over whether the complete set of observables in pseudo-scalar meson photoproduction consists of eight or merely four elements continues to persist. From the perspective of amplitude analysis, it is argued that all eight observables are necessary to completely determine the others. On the other hand, proponents of partial-wave analysis, working with theoretically precise data of infinite accuracy, claim that only four observables are needed. However, this claim is not acceptable from an experimental viewpoint, as all data in the real world contain some uncertainty. This paper illustrates that the controversy is artificial and is due to additional mathematical assumptions used in partial-wave analysis. Our research advances this discussion by moving from exact synthetic numerical data to also synthetic, but more realistic data in partial-wave analysis and shows that the claimed reduction in observables is unjustified. Consequently, the final conclusion is that the complete set of observables in pseudo-scalar meson photoproduction, whether using amplitude analysis or partial-wave analysis with practical data, must consist of eight observables.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Single-channel, single-energy partial-wave analysis with continuity improved through minimal phase constraints
Authors:
A. Svarc,
R. L. Workman
Abstract:
Single-energy partial-wave analysis has often been applied as a way to fit data with minimal model dependence. However, remaining unconstrained, partial waves at neighboring energies will vary discontinuously because the overall amplitude phase cannot be determined through single-channel measurements. This problem can be mitigated through the use of a constraining penalty function based on an asso…
▽ More
Single-energy partial-wave analysis has often been applied as a way to fit data with minimal model dependence. However, remaining unconstrained, partial waves at neighboring energies will vary discontinuously because the overall amplitude phase cannot be determined through single-channel measurements. This problem can be mitigated through the use of a constraining penalty function based on an associated energy-dependent fit. However, the weight given to this constraint results in a biased fit to the data. In this paper, for the first time, we explore a constraining function which does not influence the fit to data. The constraint comes from the overall phase found in multi-channel fits which, in the present study, are the Bonn-Gatchina and Jülich-Bonn multi-channel analyses. The data are well reproduced and weighting of the penalty function does not influence the result. The method is applied to $K Λ$ photoproduction data and all observables can be maximally well reproduced. While the employed multi-channel analyses display very different multipole amplitudes, we show that the major difference between two sets of multipoles can be related to the different overall phases.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2024; v1 submitted 18 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Extended SAID Partial-Wave Analysis of Pion Photoproduction
Authors:
William J. Briscoe,
Axel Schmidt,
Igor Strakovsky,
Ron L. Workman,
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
A unified Chew-Mandelstam description of single-pion photoproduction data, together with pion- and eta-hadroproduction data, has been extended to include measurements carried out over the last decade. We consider photo-decay amplitudes evaluated at the pole with particular emphasis on ng couplings and the influence of weighting on our fits. Both energy-dependent and single-energy analysis (energy-…
▽ More
A unified Chew-Mandelstam description of single-pion photoproduction data, together with pion- and eta-hadroproduction data, has been extended to include measurements carried out over the last decade. We consider photo-decay amplitudes evaluated at the pole with particular emphasis on ng couplings and the influence of weighting on our fits. Both energy-dependent and single-energy analysis (energy-binned data) are considered.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Laurent+Pietarinen Partial Wave Analysis
Authors:
A. Svarc,
R. L. Workman
Abstract:
A new energy-dependent fit strategy, independent of any specific microscopic theory, is applied to kaon photoproduction data with center-of-mass energies ranging from 1625 MeV to 2296 MeV. Experimental data are fitted in terms of a modified Laurent expansion (Laurent+Pietarinen expansion) which previously has been successfully applied to multipoles. The present aim is to extract resonance pole par…
▽ More
A new energy-dependent fit strategy, independent of any specific microscopic theory, is applied to kaon photoproduction data with center-of-mass energies ranging from 1625 MeV to 2296 MeV. Experimental data are fitted in terms of a modified Laurent expansion (Laurent+Pietarinen expansion) which previously has been successfully applied to multipoles. The present aim is to extract resonance pole parameters directly from the data, rather than from sets of multipoles. A constrained single-energy fit is then used to search for missing structures. In this proof-of-principle study, the data are well-described by the initial L+P fit, and it is shown that only a moderate amount of structure, mostly in higher multipoles, is missing from the original fit. Problems due to an unmeasurable overall phase, plaguing single-channel multipole analyses, are mitigated by implementing a form of phase limitation, fixing the initial values of fit parameters using a multi-channel analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2023; v1 submitted 13 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Application of the single-channel, single-energy AA/PWA method to $K^{+} Λ$ photoproduction
Authors:
A. Švarc,
Y. Wunderlich,
L. Tiator
Abstract:
The new single-channel, single-energy partial wave analysis method based on a simultaneous use of amplitude and partial wave analysis called AA/PWA, developed and tested on $η$ photoproduction in ref. Svarc et al, PRC 102, 064609 (2020), is applied to the $K^{+} Λ$ photoproduction for the center-of-mass energy range of 1625 MeV $< W <$ 2296 MeV. A complete set of multipoles has been created. The a…
▽ More
The new single-channel, single-energy partial wave analysis method based on a simultaneous use of amplitude and partial wave analysis called AA/PWA, developed and tested on $η$ photoproduction in ref. Svarc et al, PRC 102, 064609 (2020), is applied to the $K^{+} Λ$ photoproduction for the center-of-mass energy range of 1625 MeV $< W <$ 2296 MeV. A complete set of multipoles has been created. The advantages of the method have been confirmed, and a comparison with the only existing single-energy partial wave analysis of $K^{+} Λ$ photoproduction given in refs. Anisovich et al PRL 119 062004 (2017) and Anisovich et al Eur. Phys. J. A 53: 242 (2017) is presented. We confirm the size and shape of Bonn-Gatchina multipoles, but we do not confirm the unambiguous interpretation of the structure in the $M_{1-}$ multipole as a $N(1880) \frac{1}{2}^{+}$ resonance. The decisive role of the self-consistency of the world database is emphasized.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Single-energy partial wave analysis for pion photoproduction with fixed-t analyticity
Authors:
H. Osmanović,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
V. Kashevarov,
M. Ostrick,
L. Tiator,
A. Švarc
Abstract:
Experimental data for pion photoproduction including differential cross sections and various polarization observables from four reaction channels, $γp \to π^0 p$, $γp \to π^+n$, $γn \to π^- p$ and $γn \to π^0 n$ from threshold up to $W=2.2$ GeV have been used in order to perform a single-energy partial wave analysis with minimal model dependence by imposing constraints from unitarity and fixed-…
▽ More
Experimental data for pion photoproduction including differential cross sections and various polarization observables from four reaction channels, $γp \to π^0 p$, $γp \to π^+n$, $γn \to π^- p$ and $γn \to π^0 n$ from threshold up to $W=2.2$ GeV have been used in order to perform a single-energy partial wave analysis with minimal model dependence by imposing constraints from unitarity and fixed-$t$ analyticity in an iterative procedure. Reaction models were only used as starting point in the very first iteration. We demonstrate that with this procedure partial wave amplitudes can be obtained which show only a minimal dependence on the initial model assumptions.
The analysis has been obtained in full isospin, and the Watson theorem is enforced for energies below $W=1.3$ GeV but is even fulfilled up to $W\approx 1.6$ GeV in many partial waves. Electromagnetic multipoles $E_{\ell\pm}$ and $M_{\ell\pm}$ are presented and discussed for $S,P,D$ and $F$-waves.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Is the pole content of each single-energy, single-channel partial wave analysis inherently model dependent?
Authors:
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
Unfortunately, yes, it is. In ref.[1] it has been shown that without fixing the reaction-amplitude phase, many combinations of partial waves at neighboring energies in single-energy, single-channel partial wave analysis reproduce experimental data identically, but are discontinuous and disconnected. To obtain the continuous solution, the phase has to be fixed to some continuous value. In the same…
▽ More
Unfortunately, yes, it is. In ref.[1] it has been shown that without fixing the reaction-amplitude phase, many combinations of partial waves at neighboring energies in single-energy, single-channel partial wave analysis reproduce experimental data identically, but are discontinuous and disconnected. To obtain the continuous solution, the phase has to be fixed to some continuous value. In the same reference it has also been shown that the change of angular part of reaction-amplitude phase mixes partial waves, so the pole structure of any single-energy single-channel partial wave analysis depends on the chosen phase. As in any single-channel analysis the overall reaction-amplitude phase cannot be determined because of continuum ambiguity, it is in principle free and has to be taken from some coupled-channel model. Because of the difference in the angular part of the phase, choosing different phases results in the change of the pole content of the obtained solution. Therefore, single-energy single-channel partial wave analysis is inherently model dependent, and the number of poles it contains strongly depends on the choice of the phase. In that reference these facts have been illustrated on the pseudo-scalar meson production toy model. This truth is now for the measured observables demonstrated on the realistic model of ref. [2] which combines amplitude and partial wave analysis in one self-consistent scheme for the the world collection of η-photoproduction data, and fixes the phase to BG2014-2 solution [3]. We show that the pole structure of the solution whose phase is very close to the BG2014-2 theoretical ED phase is very similar to the pole structure of BG2014-2 solution, but the agreement with the data is not ideal. However, improving the agreement with the data requires the departure from BG2014-2 ED phase, and this spoils analytic structure of the obtained solution.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Strange Hadron Spectroscopy with Secondary KL Beam in Hall D
Authors:
KLF Collaboration,
Moskov Amaryan,
Mikhail Bashkanov,
Sean Dobbs,
James Ritman,
Justin Stevens,
Igor Strakovsky,
Shankar Adhikari,
Arshak Asaturyan,
Alexander Austregesilo,
Marouen Baalouch,
Vitaly Baturin,
Vladimir Berdnikov,
Olga Cortes Becerra,
Timothy Black,
Werner Boeglin,
William Briscoe,
William Brooks,
Volker Burkert,
Eugene Chudakov,
Geraint Clash,
Philip Cole,
Volker Crede,
Donal Day,
Pavel Degtyarenko
, et al. (128 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We propose to create a secondary beam of neutral kaons in Hall D at Jefferson Lab to be used with the GlueX experimental setup for strange hadron spectroscopy. The superior CEBAF electron beam will enable a flux on the order of $1\times 10^4~K_L/sec$, which exceeds the flux of that previously attained at SLAC by three orders of magnitude. The use of a deuteron target will provide first measurement…
▽ More
We propose to create a secondary beam of neutral kaons in Hall D at Jefferson Lab to be used with the GlueX experimental setup for strange hadron spectroscopy. The superior CEBAF electron beam will enable a flux on the order of $1\times 10^4~K_L/sec$, which exceeds the flux of that previously attained at SLAC by three orders of magnitude. The use of a deuteron target will provide first measurements ever with neutral kaons on neutrons. The experiment will measure both differential cross sections and self-analyzed polarizations of the produced $Λ$, $Σ$, $Ξ$, and $Ω$ hyperons using the GlueX detector at the Jefferson Lab Hall D. The measurements will span CM $\cosθ$ from $-0.95$ to 0.95 in the range W = 1490 MeV to 2500 MeV. The new data will significantly constrain the partial wave analyses and reduce model-dependent uncertainties in the extraction of the properties and pole positions of the strange hyperon resonances, and establish the orbitally excited multiplets in the spectra of the $Ξ$ and $Ω$ hyperons. Comparison with the corresponding multiplets in the spectra of the charm and bottom hyperons will provide insight into he accuracy of QCD-based calculations over a large range of masses. The proposed facility will have a defining impact in the strange meson sector through measurements of the final state $Kπ$ system up to 2 GeV invariant mass. This will allow the determination of pole positions and widths of all relevant $K^\ast(Kπ)$ $S$-,$P$-,$D$-,$F$-, and $G$-wave resonances, settle the question of the existence or nonexistence of scalar meson $κ/K_0^\ast(700)$ and improve the constrains on their pole parameters. Subsequently improving our knowledge of the low-lying scalar nonet in general.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2021; v1 submitted 18 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Amplitude- and truncated partial-wave analyses combined: A novel, almost theory-independent single-channel method for extracting photoproduction multipoles directly from measured data
Authors:
A. Švarc,
Y. Wunderlich,
L. Tiator
Abstract:
Amplitude- and truncated partial-wave analyses are combined into a single procedure and a novel, almost theory-independent single-channel method for extracting multipoles directly from measured data is developed. In practice, we have created a two-step procedure which is fitted to the same data base: in the first step we perform an energy independent amplitude analysis where continuity is achieved…
▽ More
Amplitude- and truncated partial-wave analyses are combined into a single procedure and a novel, almost theory-independent single-channel method for extracting multipoles directly from measured data is developed. In practice, we have created a two-step procedure which is fitted to the same data base: in the first step we perform an energy independent amplitude analysis where continuity is achieved by constraining the amplitude phase, and the result of this first step is then taken as a constraint for the second step where a constrained, energy independent, truncated partial-wave analysis is done. The method is tested on the world collection of data for $η$ photoproduction, and the obtained fit-results are very good. The sensitivity to different possible choices of amplitude phase is investigated and it is demonstrated that the present data base is insensitive to notable phase changes, due to an incomplete database. New measurements are recommended to remedy the problem.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Single-Energy Partial Wave Analysis for $π^0$ Photoproduction on Proton with Fixed-$t$ Analyticity Imposed
Authors:
H. Osmanović,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
M. Gorchtein,
V. Kashevarov,
K. Nikonov,
M. Ostrick,
L. Tiator,
A. Švarc
Abstract:
High precision data of the $γp \to π^0 p$ reaction from its threshold up to $W=2$~GeV have been used in order to perform a single-energy partial wave analysis with minimal model dependence. Continuity in energy was achieved by imposing constraints from fixed-$t$ analyticity in an iterative procedure. Reaction models were only used as starting point in the very first iteration. We demonstrate that…
▽ More
High precision data of the $γp \to π^0 p$ reaction from its threshold up to $W=2$~GeV have been used in order to perform a single-energy partial wave analysis with minimal model dependence. Continuity in energy was achieved by imposing constraints from fixed-$t$ analyticity in an iterative procedure. Reaction models were only used as starting point in the very first iteration. We demonstrate that with this procedure partial wave amplitudes can be obtained which show only a minimal dependence on the initial model assumptions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Cross Section for $γn \to π^0 n$ measured at Mainz/A2
Authors:
W. J. Briscoe,
M. Hadzimehmedovi,
A. E. Kudryavtsev,
V. V. Kulikov,
M. A. Martemianov,
I. I. Strakovsky,
A. Svarc,
V. E. Tarasov,
R. L. Workman,
S. Abt,
P. Achenbach,
C. S. Akondi,
F. Afzal,
P. Aguar-Bartolome,
Z. Ahmed,
J. R. M. Annand,
H. J. Arends,
K. Bantawa,
M. Bashkanov,
R. Beck,
M. Biroth,
N. Borisov,
A. Braghieri,
S. A. Bulychjov,
F. Cividini
, et al. (67 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The $γn \to π^0 n$ differential cross section evaluated for 27 energy bins span the photon-energy range 290-813 MeV (W = 1.195-1.553 GeV) and the pion c.m. polar production angles, ranging from 18 deg to 162 deg, making use of model-dependent nuclear corrections to extract pi0 production data on the neutron from measurements on the deuteron target. Additionally, the total photoabsorption cross sec…
▽ More
The $γn \to π^0 n$ differential cross section evaluated for 27 energy bins span the photon-energy range 290-813 MeV (W = 1.195-1.553 GeV) and the pion c.m. polar production angles, ranging from 18 deg to 162 deg, making use of model-dependent nuclear corrections to extract pi0 production data on the neutron from measurements on the deuteron target. Additionally, the total photoabsorption cross section was measured. The tagged photon beam produced by the 883-MeV electron beam of the Mainz Microtron MAMI was used for the 0-meson production. Our accumulation of 3.6 x 10^6 $γn \to π^0 n$ events allowed a detailed study of the reaction dynamics. Our data are in reasonable agreement with previous A2 measurements and extend them to lower energies. The data are compared to predictions of previous SAID, MAID, and BnGa partial-wave analyses and to the latest SAID fit MA19 that included our data. Selected photon decay amplitudes $N^* \to γn$ at the resonance poles are determined for the first time.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Eta and Etaprime Photoproduction on the Nucleon with the Isobar Model EtaMAID2018
Authors:
L. Tiator,
M. Gorchtein,
V. L. Kashevarov,
K. Nikonov,
M. Ostrick,
M. Hadzimehmedovic,
R. Omerovic,
H. Osmanovic,
J. Stahov,
A. Svarc
Abstract:
The isobar model EtaMAID has been updated with new and high precision data for eta and etaprime photoproduction on protons and neutrons from MAMI, ELSA, GRAAL and CLAS. The background is described in a recently developed Regge-cut model, and for the resonance part the whole list of nucleon resonances has been investigated with 21 N* states contributing to eta photoproduction and 12 N* states contr…
▽ More
The isobar model EtaMAID has been updated with new and high precision data for eta and etaprime photoproduction on protons and neutrons from MAMI, ELSA, GRAAL and CLAS. The background is described in a recently developed Regge-cut model, and for the resonance part the whole list of nucleon resonances has been investigated with 21 N* states contributing to eta photoproduction and 12 N* states contributing to etaprime photoproduction. A new approach is discussed to avoid double counting in the overlap region of Regge and resonances. A comparison is done among four newly updated partial waves analyses for observables and partial waves. Finally, the possibility of a narrow resonance near W=1900 MeV is discussed, that would be able to explain unexpected energy and angular dependence of observables in p(gamma,etaprime)p near etaprime threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2018; v1 submitted 12 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
The role of angle dependent phase rotations of reaction amplitudes in $η$ photoproduction on protons
Authors:
A. Švarc,
H. Osmanović,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
V. Kashevarov,
K. Nikonov,
M. Ostrick,
L. Tiator
Abstract:
It has recently been proven that the invariance of observables with respect to angle dependent phase rotations of reaction amplitudes mixes multipoles changing also their relative strength [1]. All contemporary partial wave analyses (PWA) in $η$ photoproduction on protons, either energy dependent (ED) [2-5] or single energy (SE) [6] do not take this effect into consideration. It is commonly accept…
▽ More
It has recently been proven that the invariance of observables with respect to angle dependent phase rotations of reaction amplitudes mixes multipoles changing also their relative strength [1]. All contemporary partial wave analyses (PWA) in $η$ photoproduction on protons, either energy dependent (ED) [2-5] or single energy (SE) [6] do not take this effect into consideration. It is commonly accepted that there exist quite some similarity in the $E0+$ multipole for all PWA, but notable differences in this, but also in remaining partial waves still remain. In this paper we demonstrate that once this phase rotations are properly taken into account, all contemporary ED and SE partial wave analysis become almost identical for the dominant $E0+$ multipole, and the agreement among all other multipoles becomes much better. We also show that the the measured observables are almost equally well reproduced for all PWA, and the remaining differences among multipoles can be attributed solely to the difference of predictions for unmeasured observables. So, new measurements are needed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
From Experimental Data to Pole Parameters in a Direct Way (Angle Dependent Continuum Ambiguity and Laurent + Pietarinen Expansion)
Authors:
A. Švarc,
Y. Wunderlich,
H. Osmanović,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
V. Kashevarov,
K. Nikonov,
M. Ostrick,
L. Tiator,
R. Workman
Abstract:
Unconstrained partial-wave amplitudes obtained at discrete energies from fits to complete sets of eight independent observables which are required to uniquely reconstruct reaction amplitudes do not vary smoothly with energy, and are in principle non-unique. We demonstrate how this behavior can be ascribed to the continuum ambiguity. Starting from the spinless scattering case, we demonstrate how an…
▽ More
Unconstrained partial-wave amplitudes obtained at discrete energies from fits to complete sets of eight independent observables which are required to uniquely reconstruct reaction amplitudes do not vary smoothly with energy, and are in principle non-unique. We demonstrate how this behavior can be ascribed to the continuum ambiguity. Starting from the spinless scattering case, we demonstrate how an unknown overall phase depending on energy and angle mixes the structures seen in the associated partial-wave amplitudes making the partial wave decomposition non-unique, and illustrate it on a simple toy model. We then apply these principles to pseudo-scalar meson photoproduction and show that the non-uniqueness effect can be removed through a phase rotation generating "up-to-a-phase" unique set of SE partial wave amplitudes. Extracting pole positions from partial wave amplitudes is the next step. Up to now, there was no reliable way to extract pole parameters from SE partial waves, but a new and simple single-channel method (Laurent + Pietarinen expansion) applicable for continuous and discrete data has been recently developed. It is based on applying the Laurent decomposition of partial wave amplitude, and expanding the nonresonant background into a power series of a conformal-mapping, quickly converging power series obtaining the simplest analytic function with well-defined partial wave analytic properties which fits the input. The generalization of this method to multi- channel case is also developed and presented. Unifying both methods in succession, one constructs a model independent procedure to extract pole parameters directly from experimental data without referring to any theoretical model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
The Roper resonance: a genuine quark state or a dynamically generated structure?
Authors:
B. Golli,
H. Osmanović,
S. Širca,
A. Švarc
Abstract:
In view of the recent results of lattice QCD simulation in the P11 partial wave that has found no clear signal for the three-quark Roper state we investigate a different mechanism for the formation of the Roper resonance in a coupled channel approach including the $πN$, $πΔ$ and $σN$ channels. We fix the pion-baryon vertices in the underlying quark model while the $s$-wave sigma-baryon interaction…
▽ More
In view of the recent results of lattice QCD simulation in the P11 partial wave that has found no clear signal for the three-quark Roper state we investigate a different mechanism for the formation of the Roper resonance in a coupled channel approach including the $πN$, $πΔ$ and $σN$ channels. We fix the pion-baryon vertices in the underlying quark model while the $s$-wave sigma-baryon interaction is introduced phenomenologically with the coupling strength, the mass and the width of the $σ$ meson as free parameters. The Laurent-Pietarinen expansion is used to extract the information about the $S$-matrix pole. The Lippmann-Schwinger equation for the $K$ matrix with a separable kernel is solved to all orders. For sufficiently strong $σNN$ coupling the kernel becomes singular and a quasi-bound state emerges at around 1.4~GeV, dominated by the $σN$ component and reflecting itself in a pole of the $S$-matrix. The alternative mechanism involving a $(1s)^22s$ quark resonant state is added to the model and the interplay of the dynamically generated state and the three-quark resonant state is studied. It turns out that for the mass of the three-quark resonant state above 1.6~GeV the mass of the resonance is determined solely by the dynamically generated state, nonetheless, the inclusion of the three-quark resonant state is imperative to reproduce the experimental width and the modulus of the resonance pole.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2018; v1 submitted 26 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Towards an understanding of discrete ambiguities in truncated partial wave analyses
Authors:
Y. Wunderlich,
A. Švarc,
R. L. Workman,
L. Tiator,
R. Beck
Abstract:
It is well known that the observables in a single-channel scattering problem remain invariant once the amplitude is multiplied by an overall energy- and angle-dependent phase. This invariance is called the continuum ambiguity and acts on the infinite partial wave set. It has also long been known that, in the case of a truncated partial wave set, another invariance exists, originating from the repl…
▽ More
It is well known that the observables in a single-channel scattering problem remain invariant once the amplitude is multiplied by an overall energy- and angle-dependent phase. This invariance is called the continuum ambiguity and acts on the infinite partial wave set. It has also long been known that, in the case of a truncated partial wave set, another invariance exists, originating from the replacement of the roots of partial wave amplitudes with their complex conjugate values. This discrete ambiguity is also known as the Omelaenko-Gersten-type ambiguity. In this paper, we show that for scalar particles, discrete ambiguities are just a subset of continuum ambiguities with a specific phase and thus mix partial waves, as the continuum ambiguity does. We present the main features of both, continuum and discrete ambiguities, and describe a numerical method which establishes the relevant phase connection.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Fixed-t analyticity as a constraint in single energy partial wave analyses of meson photoproduction reactions
Authors:
H. Osmanović,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
V. Kashevarov,
K. Nikonov,
M. Ostrick,
L. Tiator,
A. Švarc
Abstract:
Partial wave amplitudes of meson photoproduction reactions are an important source of information in baryon spectroscopy. We investigate a new approach in single-energy partial wave analyses of these reactions. Instead of using a constraint to theoretical models in order to achieve solutions which are continuous in energy, we enforce the analyticity of the amplitudes at fixed values of the Mandels…
▽ More
Partial wave amplitudes of meson photoproduction reactions are an important source of information in baryon spectroscopy. We investigate a new approach in single-energy partial wave analyses of these reactions. Instead of using a constraint to theoretical models in order to achieve solutions which are continuous in energy, we enforce the analyticity of the amplitudes at fixed values of the Mandelstam variable $t$. We present an iterative procedure with successive fixed-$t$ amplitude analyses which constrain the single-energy partial wave analyses and apply this method to the $γp \to ηp$ reaction. We use pseudo data, generated by the EtaMAID model, to test the method and to analyze ambiguities. Finally, we present an analytically constrained partial wave analysis using experimental data for four polarization observables recently measured at MAMI and GRAAL in the energy range from threshold to $\sqrt{s}=1.85$ GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
A connection between angular dependent phase ambiguities and the uniqueness of the partial wave decomposition
Authors:
A. Švarc,
Y. Wunderlich,
H. Osmanović,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
V. Kashevarov,
K. Nikonov,
M. Ostrich,
L. Tiator,
R. Workman
Abstract:
Unconstrained partial-wave amplitudes obtained at discrete energies from fits to complete sets of experimental data may not vary smoothly with energy, and are in principle non-unique. We demonstrate how this behavior can be ascribed to the continuum ambiguity. Starting from the spinless scattering case, we demonstrate how an unknown overall phase depending on energy and angle mixes the structures…
▽ More
Unconstrained partial-wave amplitudes obtained at discrete energies from fits to complete sets of experimental data may not vary smoothly with energy, and are in principle non-unique. We demonstrate how this behavior can be ascribed to the continuum ambiguity. Starting from the spinless scattering case, we demonstrate how an unknown overall phase depending on energy and angle mixes the structures seen in the associated partial-wave amplitudes making the partial wave decomposition non-unique, and illustrate it on a simple toy model. We then apply these principles to pseudo-scalar meson photoproduction and show that the non-uniqueness effect can be removed through a phase rotation, allowing a consistent comparison with model amplitudes. The effect of this phase ambiguity is also considered for Legendre expansions of experimental observables. 5 pages,
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2018; v1 submitted 10 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Baryon transition form factors at the pole
Authors:
L. Tiator,
M. Döring,
R. L. Workman,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
H. Osmanović,
R. Omerović,
J. Stahov,
A. Švarc
Abstract:
Electromagnetic resonance properties are uniquely defined at the pole and do not depend on the separation of the resonance from background or the decay channel. Photon-nucleon branching ratios are nowadays often quoted at the pole, and we generalize the considerations to the case of virtual photons. We derive and compare relations for nucleon to baryon transition form factors both for the Breit-Wi…
▽ More
Electromagnetic resonance properties are uniquely defined at the pole and do not depend on the separation of the resonance from background or the decay channel. Photon-nucleon branching ratios are nowadays often quoted at the pole, and we generalize the considerations to the case of virtual photons. We derive and compare relations for nucleon to baryon transition form factors both for the Breit-Wigner and the pole positions. Using the MAID2007 and SAID SM08 partial wave analyses of pion electroproduction data, we compare the $G_M$, $G_E$, and $G_C$ form factors for the $Δ(1232)$ resonance excitation at the Breit-Wigner resonance and pole positions up to $Q^2=5$ GeV$^2$. We also explore the $E/M$ and $S/M$ ratios as functions of $Q^2$. For pole and residue extraction, we apply the Laurent + Pietarinen method.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Generalization of the model-independent Laurent-Pietarinen single-channel pole-extraction formalism to multiple channels
Authors:
Alfred Svarc,
Mirza Hadzimehmedovic,
Hedim Osmanovic,
Jugoslav Stahov,
Lothar Tiator,
Ron L. Workman
Abstract:
A method to extract resonance pole information from single-channel partial-wave amplitudes based on a Laurent (Mittag-Leffler) expansion and conformal mapping techniques has recently been developed. This method has been applied to a number of reactions and provides a model-independent extraction procedure which is particularly useful in cases where a set of amplitudes is available only at descrete…
▽ More
A method to extract resonance pole information from single-channel partial-wave amplitudes based on a Laurent (Mittag-Leffler) expansion and conformal mapping techniques has recently been developed. This method has been applied to a number of reactions and provides a model-independent extraction procedure which is particularly useful in cases where a set of amplitudes is available only at descrete energies. This method has been generalized and applied to the case of a multi-channel fit, where several sets of amplitudes are analysed simultaneously. The importance of unitarity constraints is discussed. The final result provides a powerful, model-independent tool for analyzing partial-wave amplitudes of coupled or connected channels based entirely on the concepts of analyticity and unitarity.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Resonance Extraction from the SAID Analysis
Authors:
Ron Workman,
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
Resonances are extracted from a number of energy-dependent and single-energy fits to scattering data. The influence of recent, precise EPECUR data is investigated. Results for the single-energy fits are derived using the L+P method of analysis and are compared to those obtained using contour integration applied to the global energy-dependent fits.
Resonances are extracted from a number of energy-dependent and single-energy fits to scattering data. The influence of recent, precise EPECUR data is investigated. Results for the single-energy fits are derived using the L+P method of analysis and are compared to those obtained using contour integration applied to the global energy-dependent fits.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Status of some P-wave baryon resonances and importance of inelastic channels
Authors:
Volker D. Burkert,
Hiroyuki Kamano,
Eberhard Klempt,
Deborah Ronchen,
Andrey V. Sarantsev,
Toru Sato,
Alfred Svarc,
Lothar Tiator,
Ron L. Workman
Abstract:
We analyze the current status of three P-wave baryon states $N(1710){1/ 2}^+$, $N(1900){3/2}^+$, and $Δ(1600){3/2}^+$ as given in the Review of Particles Physics (RPP). Since the evidence for a particle's existence is linked to its RPP "star" rating, we discuss its subjective present definition. We also present the accumulating evidence supporting these states and give our new "star" rating recomm…
▽ More
We analyze the current status of three P-wave baryon states $N(1710){1/ 2}^+$, $N(1900){3/2}^+$, and $Δ(1600){3/2}^+$ as given in the Review of Particles Physics (RPP). Since the evidence for a particle's existence is linked to its RPP "star" rating, we discuss its subjective present definition. We also present the accumulating evidence supporting these states and give our new "star" rating recommendations.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Pole structure from energy-dependent and single-energy fits to $πN$ elastic scattering data
Authors:
Alfred Švarc,
Mirza Hadžimehmedović,
Hedim Osmanović,
Jugoslav Stahov,
Ron L. Workman
Abstract:
The pole structure of the current GW/SAID partial-wave analysis of elastic $πN$ scattering and $ηN$ production data is studied. Pole positions and residues are extracted from both the energy-dependent and single-energy fits, using two different methods. For the energy-dependent fits, both contour integration and a Laurent+Pietarinen approach are used. In the case of single-energy fits, the Laurent…
▽ More
The pole structure of the current GW/SAID partial-wave analysis of elastic $πN$ scattering and $ηN$ production data is studied. Pole positions and residues are extracted from both the energy-dependent and single-energy fits, using two different methods. For the energy-dependent fits, both contour integration and a Laurent+Pietarinen approach are used. In the case of single-energy fits, the Laurent+Pietarinen approach is used. Errors are estimated and the two sets of results are compared to other recent and older fits to data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2015; v1 submitted 26 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Pole positions and residues from pion photoproduction using the Laurent+Pietarinen expansion method
Authors:
Alfred Švarc,
Mirza Hadžimehmedović,
Hedim Osmanović,
Jugoslav Stahov,
Lothar Tiator,
Ron L. Workman
Abstract:
We have applied a new approach to determine the pole positions and residues from pion photoproduction multipoles. The method is based on a Laurent expansion of the partial wave T-matrices, with a Pietarinen series representing the regular part of energy-dependent and single-energy photoproduction solutions. The method has been applied to multipole fits generated by the MAID and GWU/SAID groups. We…
▽ More
We have applied a new approach to determine the pole positions and residues from pion photoproduction multipoles. The method is based on a Laurent expansion of the partial wave T-matrices, with a Pietarinen series representing the regular part of energy-dependent and single-energy photoproduction solutions. The method has been applied to multipole fits generated by the MAID and GWU/SAID groups. We show that the number and properties of poles extracted from photoproduction data correspond very well to results from $π$N elastic data and values cited by Particle Data Group (PDG). The photoproduction residues provide new information for the electromagnetic current at the pole position, which are independent of background parameterizations, as opposed to the Breit-Wigner representation. Finally, we present the photo-decay amplitudes from the current MAID and SAID solutions at the pole, for all four-star nucleon resonances below W=2 GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Light Meson Dynamics Workshop. Mini proceedings
Authors:
J. Bijnens,
R. Escribano,
S. Fang,
S. Giovannella,
W. Gradl,
C. Hanhart,
B. Kubis. S. Leupold,
M. F. M. Lutz,
P. Masjuan,
B. Moussallam,
A. Neiser,
E. Oset,
M. Ostrick,
J. R. Pelaez,
S. Scherer,
A. Švarc,
M. Unverzagt,
R. Wanke,
M. Wolke
Abstract:
The mini-proceedings of the Light Meson Dynamics Workshop held in Mainz from February 10th to 12th, 2014, are presented. The web page of the conference, which contains all talks, can be found at https://indico.cern.ch/event/287442/overview .
The mini-proceedings of the Light Meson Dynamics Workshop held in Mainz from February 10th to 12th, 2014, are presented. The web page of the conference, which contains all talks, can be found at https://indico.cern.ch/event/287442/overview .
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2014; v1 submitted 25 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Poles of Karlsruhe-Helsinki KH80 and KA84 solutions extracted by using Laurent+Pietarinen method
Authors:
Alfred Svarc,
Mirza Hadzimehmedovic,
Rifat Omerovic,
Hedim Osmanovic,
Jugoslav Stahov
Abstract:
Poles of partial wave scattering matrices have also in hadron spectroscopy recently been established as a sole link between experiment and QCD theories and models [1-4]. We have, however, noticed the fact that Karlsruhe-Helsinki (KH) partial wave analyses, one of the two partial wave analyses which have been "above the line" in PDG [1] for over three decades, does calculate and PDG compiles the ab…
▽ More
Poles of partial wave scattering matrices have also in hadron spectroscopy recently been established as a sole link between experiment and QCD theories and models [1-4]. We have, however, noticed the fact that Karlsruhe-Helsinki (KH) partial wave analyses, one of the two partial wave analyses which have been "above the line" in PDG [1] for over three decades, does calculate and PDG compiles the abundance of Breit-Wigner (BW) parameters obtained by local BW fit, but has produced only a limited number of pole information obtained by using speed plot (SP) method [5]. We stress the fact that in KH method only Mandelstam analyticity is used as a theoretical constraint, so KH partial wave solutions are as model independent as possible. Therefore, they represent a very confident and valuable input, so it is of extreme importance to extract as many resonance pole parameters from them as possible. In addition, the troubling fact is that BW parameters given in PDG have been obtained from KH80 solution, while pole parameters have been obtained from KA84 version of KH solution. To remedy this, we have used newly developed Laurent+Pietarinen expansion method [6,7] for obtaining pole positions for all partial waves for KH80 and KA84 solutions, compared them, and shown that the differences in pole parameters are, with very few discussed exceptions, negligible for all partial waves. We finally give a full set of pole parameters for both solutions for all partial waves; results which are until now unpublished.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2014; v1 submitted 9 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
PWA tools in Hadronic Spectroscopy
Authors:
S. Ceci,
M. Döring,
E. Epple,
C. Fernández-Ramírez,
A. Fix,
M. Fritsch,
R. W. Gothe,
B. Grube,
H. Haberzettl,
C. Hanhart,
X. Ji,
D. M. Manley,
P. Masjuan,
H. Osmanovic,
M. Ostrick,
K. Peters,
W. Przygoda,
J. J. Sanz-Cillero,
V. Shklyar,
I. I. Strakovsky,
A. Svarc,
A. P. Szczepaniak,
L. Tiator,
Y. Wunderlich
Abstract:
The mini-proceedings of the Workshop on PWA tools in Hadronic Spectroscopy held in Mainz from February 18th to 20th, 2013.
The mini-proceedings of the Workshop on PWA tools in Hadronic Spectroscopy held in Mainz from February 18th to 20th, 2013.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
A new method for extracting poles from single-channel data based on Laurent expansion of T-matrices with Pietarinen power series representing the non-singular part
Authors:
Alfred Svarc,
Mirza Hadzimehmedovic,
Hedim Osmanovic,
Jugoslav Stahov
Abstract:
We present a new approach to quantifying pole parameters of single-channel processes based on Laurent expansion of partial wave T-matrices. Instead of guessing the analytical form of non-singular part of Laurent expansion as it is usually done, we represent it by the convergent series of Pietarinen functions. As the analytic structure of non-singular term is usually very well known (physical cuts…
▽ More
We present a new approach to quantifying pole parameters of single-channel processes based on Laurent expansion of partial wave T-matrices. Instead of guessing the analytical form of non-singular part of Laurent expansion as it is usually done, we represent it by the convergent series of Pietarinen functions. As the analytic structure of non-singular term is usually very well known (physical cuts with branhcpoints at inelastic thresholds, and unphysical cuts in the negative energy plane), we show that we need one Pietarinen series per cut, and the number of terms in each Pietarinen series is automatically determined by the quality of the fit. The method is tested on a toy model constructed from two known poles, various background terms, and two physical cuts, and shown to be robust and confident up to three Pietarinen series. We also apply this method to Zagreb CMB amplitudes for the N(1535) 1/2- resonance, and confirm the full success of the method on realistic data. This formalism can also be used for fitting experimental data, and the procedure is very similar as when Breit-Wigner functions are used, but with one modification: Laurent expansion with Pietarinen series is replacing the standard Breit-Wigner T-matrix form.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2012; v1 submitted 6 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Potential dangers when phase shifts are used as a link between experiment and QCD
Authors:
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
Luscher has shown that in single channel problem (elastic region below first inelastic threshold) there exists a direct link between the discrete value of the energy in a finite QCD volume and the scattering phase shift at the same energy. However, when the extension of the theorem is made to the baryon resonance sector (multi-channel situation in the inelastic region above first inelastic thresho…
▽ More
Luscher has shown that in single channel problem (elastic region below first inelastic threshold) there exists a direct link between the discrete value of the energy in a finite QCD volume and the scattering phase shift at the same energy. However, when the extension of the theorem is made to the baryon resonance sector (multi-channel situation in the inelastic region above first inelastic threshold), eigenphases (diagonal multi-channel quantities) replace phase shifts (single channel quantities). It is necessary to stress that the renowned pi/2 resonance criterion is formulated for eigenphases and not for phase shifts, so the resonance extracting procedure has to be applied with utmost care. The potential instability of extracting eigenphases from experimental data which occurs if insufficient number of channels is used can be reduced if a trace function which explicitly takes multi-channel aspect of the problem into account is used instead of single-channel phase shifts.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Reviving old, almost lost knowledge on T and K matrix poles and a link to the contemporary QCD spectrum
Authors:
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
The old knowledge about interrelation among T-matrix, K-matrix and bare poles is summarized and put into modern perspective.
The old knowledge about interrelation among T-matrix, K-matrix and bare poles is summarized and put into modern perspective.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Relevance of complex branch points for partial wave analysis
Authors:
S. Ceci,
M. Döring,
C. Hanhart,
S. Krewald,
U. -G. Meißner,
A. Svarc
Abstract:
A central issue in hadron spectroscopy is to deduce --- and interpret --- resonance parameters, namely pole positions and residues, from experimental data, for those are the quantities to be compared to lattice QCD or model calculations. However, not every structure in the observables derives from a resonance pole: the origin might as well be branch points, either located on the real axis (when a…
▽ More
A central issue in hadron spectroscopy is to deduce --- and interpret --- resonance parameters, namely pole positions and residues, from experimental data, for those are the quantities to be compared to lattice QCD or model calculations. However, not every structure in the observables derives from a resonance pole: the origin might as well be branch points, either located on the real axis (when a new channel comprised of stable particles opens) or in the complex plane (when at least one of the intermediate particles is unstable). In this paper we demonstrate first the existence of such branch points in the complex plane and then show on the example of the piN P11 partial wave that it is not possible to distinguish the structures induced by the latter from a true pole signal based on elastic data alone.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Stability of the Zagreb Carnegie-Mellon-Berkeley model
Authors:
H. Osmanović,
S. Ceci,
A. Švarc,
M. Hadžimehmedović,
J. Stahov
Abstract:
In ref. [1] we have used the Zagreb realization of Carnegie-Melon-Berkeley coupled-channel, unitary model as a tool for extracting pole positions from the world collection of partial wave data, with the aim of eliminating model dependence in pole-search procedures. In order that the method is sensible, we in this paper discuss the stability of the method with respect to the strong variation of dif…
▽ More
In ref. [1] we have used the Zagreb realization of Carnegie-Melon-Berkeley coupled-channel, unitary model as a tool for extracting pole positions from the world collection of partial wave data, with the aim of eliminating model dependence in pole-search procedures. In order that the method is sensible, we in this paper discuss the stability of the method with respect to the strong variation of different model ingredients. We show that the Zagreb CMB procedure is very stable with strong variation of the model assumptions, and that it can reliably predict the pole positions of the fitted partial wave amplitudes.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2012; v1 submitted 15 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Poles, the only true resonant-state signals, are extracted from a worldwide collection of partial wave amplitudes using only one, well controlled pole-extraction method
Authors:
M. Hadžimehmedović,
S. Ceci,
A. Švarc,
H. Osmanović,
J. Stahov
Abstract:
Each and every energy dependent partial-wave analysis is parameterizing the pole positions in a procedure defined by the way how the continuous energy dependence is implemented. These pole positions are, henceforth, inherently model dependent. To reduce this model dependence, we use only one, coupled-channel, unitary, fully analytic method based on the isobar approximation to extract the pole posi…
▽ More
Each and every energy dependent partial-wave analysis is parameterizing the pole positions in a procedure defined by the way how the continuous energy dependence is implemented. These pole positions are, henceforth, inherently model dependent. To reduce this model dependence, we use only one, coupled-channel, unitary, fully analytic method based on the isobar approximation to extract the pole positions from the each available member of the worldwide collection of partial wave amplitudes which are understood as nothing more but a good energy dependent representation of genuine experimental numbers assembled in a form of partial-wave data. In that way, the model dependence related to the different assumptions on the analytic form of the partial-wave amplitudes is avoided, and the true confidence limit for the existence of a particular resonant state, at least in one model, is established. The way how the method works, and first results are demonstrated for the S11 partial wave.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Singularity structure of the pi N scattering amplitude in a meson-exchange model up to energies W < 2.0 GeV
Authors:
L. Tiator,
S. S. Kamalov,
S. Ceci,
G. Y. Chen,
D. Drechsel,
A. Svarc,
S. N. Yang
Abstract:
Within the previously developed Dubna-Mainz-Taipei meson-exchange model, the singularity structure of the pi N scattering amplitudes has been investigated. For all partial waves up to F waves and c.m. energies up to W = 2 GeV, the T-matrix poles have been calculated by three different techniques: analytic continuation into the complex energy plane, speed-plot and the regularization method. For all…
▽ More
Within the previously developed Dubna-Mainz-Taipei meson-exchange model, the singularity structure of the pi N scattering amplitudes has been investigated. For all partial waves up to F waves and c.m. energies up to W = 2 GeV, the T-matrix poles have been calculated by three different techniques: analytic continuation into the complex energy plane, speed-plot and the regularization method. For all 4-star resonances, we find a perfect agreement between the analytic continuation and the regularization method. We also find resonance poles for resonances that are not so well established, but in these cases the pole positions and residues obtained by analytic continuation can substantially differ from the results predicted by the speed-plot and regularization methods.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Influence of the eta exchange to the eta production in proton-proton scattering
Authors:
S. Ceci,
A. Svarc,
B. Zauner
Abstract:
Eta meson production in the proton-proton scattering is dominated by the low-mass meson exchange. We present a brief study on how the type of the exchanged mesons within coupled-channel and multi-resonance model influences the scattering observables. We show under which circumstances the eta exchange may explain the shape of the observed cross sections, and present a few selected results: total…
▽ More
Eta meson production in the proton-proton scattering is dominated by the low-mass meson exchange. We present a brief study on how the type of the exchanged mesons within coupled-channel and multi-resonance model influences the scattering observables. We show under which circumstances the eta exchange may explain the shape of the observed cross sections, and present a few selected results: total cross section in the full energy range, and the proton-proton energy distribution at 15.5 MeV.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
The physical meaning of scattering matrix singularities in coupled-channel formalisms
Authors:
S. Capstick,
A. Svarc,
L. Tiator,
J. Gegelia,
M. M. Giannini,
E. Santopinto,
C. Hanhart,
S. Scherer,
T. -S. H. Lee,
T. Sato,
N. Suzuki
Abstract:
The physical meaning of bare and dressed scattering matrix singularities has been investigated. Special attention has been attributed to the role of well known invariance of scattering matrix with respect to the field transformation of the effective Lagrangian. Examples of evaluating bare and dressed quantities in various models are given.
The physical meaning of bare and dressed scattering matrix singularities has been investigated. Special attention has been attributed to the role of well known invariance of scattering matrix with respect to the field transformation of the effective Lagrangian. Examples of evaluating bare and dressed quantities in various models are given.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Recent progress in eta-nucleus physics
Authors:
Vadim Baru,
Michael Doering,
Alexander Fix,
Humberto Garcilazo,
Ashot Gasparyan,
Johann Haidenbauer,
Christoph Hanhart,
Bo Hoistad,
Daniil Kirillov,
Bernd Krusche,
Alexander Kudryavtsev,
Sasha Kvinikhidze,
Timo Mersmann,
Ulrich Mosel,
Pawel Moskal,
Jouni Niskanen,
Andreas Nogga,
Eulogio Oset,
Teresa Pena,
Vitaliy Shklyar,
Alexander Sibirtsev,
Aleksandr Starostin,
Alfred Svarc,
Lothar Tiator,
Colin Wilkin
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This is the summary of the 'International Workshop on eta--Nucleus Physics' held in Juelich, May 8--12, 2006. Each talk is represented by an extended abstract. At the same time the document provides a progress report of the corresponding working group.
This is the summary of the 'International Workshop on eta--Nucleus Physics' held in Juelich, May 8--12, 2006. Each talk is represented by an extended abstract. At the same time the document provides a progress report of the corresponding working group.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Presence of Extra P11 Resonances in Zagreb Analysis Since 1995
Authors:
S. Ceci,
A. Svarc,
B. Zauner
Abstract:
The partial wave T-matrices for the pi N, eta N and pi2 N channels have been obtained within the framework of the coupled channel model using the pi N elastic and pi N --> eta N data base as input. It has been shown that for the P11 partial wave an equally good representation of the experimental data (namely the T(pi N,pi N) and T(pi N,eta N) T-matrices) can be obtained using either three, or fo…
▽ More
The partial wave T-matrices for the pi N, eta N and pi2 N channels have been obtained within the framework of the coupled channel model using the pi N elastic and pi N --> eta N data base as input. It has been shown that for the P11 partial wave an equally good representation of the experimental data (namely the T(pi N,pi N) and T(pi N,eta N) T-matrices) can be obtained using either three, or four poles for the Green function propagator. However, the three Green function pole solution is not acceptable due to the structure of the extracted resonances. The two out of four P11 resonances, those lying in the energy range 1700 MeV < MR < 1800 MeV, are poorly determined, but they seem to be strongly inelastic. The inclusion of other inelastic channels is needed to determine masses and widths of missing resonances with greater precision.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
Nucleon resonances and processes involving strange particles
Authors:
S. Ceci,
A. Svarc,
B. Zauner
Abstract:
An existing single resonance model with S11, P11 and P13 Breit-Wiegner resonances in the s-channel has been re-applied to the old pi N --> K Lambda data. It has been shown that the standard set of resonant parameters fails to reproduce the shape of the differential cross section. The resonance parameter determination has been repeated retaining the most recent knowledge about the nucleon resonan…
▽ More
An existing single resonance model with S11, P11 and P13 Breit-Wiegner resonances in the s-channel has been re-applied to the old pi N --> K Lambda data. It has been shown that the standard set of resonant parameters fails to reproduce the shape of the differential cross section. The resonance parameter determination has been repeated retaining the most recent knowledge about the nucleon resonances. The extracted set of parameters has confirmed the need for the strong contribution of a P11(1710) resonance. The need for any significant contribution of the P13 resonance has been eliminated. Assuming that the Baker. et al data set\cite{Bak78} is a most reliable one, the P11 resonance can not but be quite narrow. It emerges as a good candidate for the non-strange counter partner of the established pentaquark anti-decuplet.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
The N(1710)P11 state is confirmed in the re-analysis of the pi N --> K Lambda production; it is a good candidate for a non-strange pentaquark
Authors:
S. Ceci,
A. Svarc,
B. Zauner
Abstract:
Re-analyzing the old pi N --> K Lambda data, the additional proof is given for the existence of the N(1710) P11 state, critically needed in light of reported observations of exotic Theta(1539) and Xi(1862) pentaquarks. An existing single-resonance model with S11, P11 and P13 Breit-Wiegner resonances in the s-channel has been applied. It has been shown that the standard set of resonant parameters…
▽ More
Re-analyzing the old pi N --> K Lambda data, the additional proof is given for the existence of the N(1710) P11 state, critically needed in light of reported observations of exotic Theta(1539) and Xi(1862) pentaquarks. An existing single-resonance model with S11, P11 and P13 Breit-Wiegner resonances in the s-channel has been applied. It has been shown that the standard set of resonant parameters fails to reproduce the shape of the differential cross section. The new resonance parameter determination has been performed keeping in mind the most recent knowledge about nucleon resonances. The extracted set of parameters has confirmed the need for the strong contribution of a N(1710) P11 resonance. The need for any significant contribution of the P13 resonance has been eliminated. To reproduce the total cross section at the same time with the linear dependence of the differential cross sections with the cos(theta) in the energy range 1650 MeV < W < 1800 MeV the P11 resonance can not but be quite narrow.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2004; v1 submitted 16 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
The detailed mechanism of the eta production in pp scattering up to the Tlab = 4.5 GeV
Authors:
S. Ceci,
A. Svarc,
B. Zauner
Abstract:
Contrary to very early beliefs, the experimental cross section data for the eta production in proton-proton scattering are well described if pi and only eta meson exchange diagrams are used to calculate the Born term. The inclusion of initial and final state interactions is done in the factorization approximation by using the inverse square of the Jost function. The two body Jost functions are o…
▽ More
Contrary to very early beliefs, the experimental cross section data for the eta production in proton-proton scattering are well described if pi and only eta meson exchange diagrams are used to calculate the Born term. The inclusion of initial and final state interactions is done in the factorization approximation by using the inverse square of the Jost function. The two body Jost functions are obtained from the S matrices in the low energy effective range approximation. The danger of double counting in the p-eta final state interaction is discussed. It is shown that higher partial waves in meson-nucleon amplitudes do not contribute significantly bellow excess energy of Q=100 MeV. Known difficulties of reducing the multi resonance model to a single resonance one are illustrated.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2004; v1 submitted 12 February, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
-
Eta Production in the pp Scattering
Authors:
Sasa Ceci,
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
Total cross section for pp->pp eta process has been calculated in meson exchange model. Eta production T-matrices are from our PWA. Initial and final state interactions are disregarded for the moment, due to large uncertainties. Preliminary results do not show rho meson exchange dominance.
Total cross section for pp->pp eta process has been calculated in meson exchange model. Eta production T-matrices are from our PWA. Initial and final state interactions are disregarded for the moment, due to large uncertainties. Preliminary results do not show rho meson exchange dominance.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2003;
originally announced January 2003.
-
Detailed analysis of eta production in proton-proton collisions
Authors:
Alfred Svarc,
Sasa Ceci
Abstract:
The check whether the presently available multiresonance coupled channel analyses can explain the more complex processes is made. The process chosen is a well measured proces of eta production in proton proton collisions.
The check whether the presently available multiresonance coupled channel analyses can explain the more complex processes is made. The process chosen is a well measured proces of eta production in proton proton collisions.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2001;
originally announced May 2001.
-
The importance of the nucleon-nucleon correlations for the eta alpha S-wave scattering length, and the pi-eta mixing angle in the low-energy eta alpha scattering length model
Authors:
S. Ceci,
D. Hrupec,
A. Svarc
Abstract:
Using the new set of dd --> eta alpha near threshold experimental data, the estimate of the importance of the nucleon-nucleon correlations for the eta alpha S-wave scattering length in the multiple scattering theory is obtained using the low-energy scattering length model. The contribution turns out to be much bigger then previously believed. The pi-eta mixing angle is extracted using the experi…
▽ More
Using the new set of dd --> eta alpha near threshold experimental data, the estimate of the importance of the nucleon-nucleon correlations for the eta alpha S-wave scattering length in the multiple scattering theory is obtained using the low-energy scattering length model. The contribution turns out to be much bigger then previously believed. The pi-eta mixing angle is extracted using the experimental data on the dd --> eta alpha and dd --> pi alpha processes. The model is dominated by the subthreshold extrapolation recipe for the eta alpha scattering amplitudes. When the recipe is chosen the model is completely insensitive to the eta alpha parameters for the subthreshold value of the eta cm momentum of p_{eta}^2 = -(0.46)^2 fm^{-2}. Provided that the subthreshold extrapolation recipe is correct, a good estimate of the pi-eta mixing angle is obtained, if the experimental cross sections for the dd --> pi alpha reaction at the corresponding deuteron input energy are taken from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2001; v1 submitted 11 April, 2001;
originally announced April 2001.
-
Eta Production in Hadronic Interactions
Authors:
Alfred Svarc,
Sasa Ceci
Abstract:
A short, and definitely not a complete representation of ηproduction processes on hadrons is given. First of all, the different ways of obtaining the πN \to ηN and πN \to ηN amplitudes are presented. After that, an overview of results obtained using these amplitudes as input for calculating processes like: NN \to ηNN, pd \to η^{3}He, πd \to ηNN and ηd, η^{3}He and η^{4}He as well as η-light nucl…
▽ More
A short, and definitely not a complete representation of ηproduction processes on hadrons is given. First of all, the different ways of obtaining the πN \to ηN and πN \to ηN amplitudes are presented. After that, an overview of results obtained using these amplitudes as input for calculating processes like: NN \to ηNN, pd \to η^{3}He, πd \to ηNN and ηd, η^{3}He and η^{4}He as well as η-light nuclei bond states, will be given. The experimental and theoretical results will be reviewed. The opened problems and the way how to solve them will be presented.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2000;
originally announced September 2000.
-
Evidence for the fourth P11 resonance predicted by the constituent quark model
Authors:
Simon Capstick,
T. -S. H. Lee,
W. Roberts,
A. Svarc
Abstract:
It is pointed out that the third of five low-lying P11 states predicted by a constituent quark model can be identified with the third of four states in a solution from a three-channel analysis by the Zagreb group. This is one of the so-called ``missing'' resonances, predicted at 1880 MeV. The fit of the Zagreb group to the pi N -> eta N data is the crucial element in finding this fourth resonanc…
▽ More
It is pointed out that the third of five low-lying P11 states predicted by a constituent quark model can be identified with the third of four states in a solution from a three-channel analysis by the Zagreb group. This is one of the so-called ``missing'' resonances, predicted at 1880 MeV. The fit of the Zagreb group to the pi N -> eta N data is the crucial element in finding this fourth resonance in the P11 partial wave.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 1999; v1 submitted 1 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Update of the pi N --> eta N and eta N --> eta N partial-wave amplitudes
Authors:
Mijo Batinic,
Ivan Dadic,
Ivo Slaus,
Alfred Svarc,
B. M. K. Nefkens,
T. -S. H. Lee
Abstract:
A three-channel, multi-resonance, unitary model developed in 1995 is used to determine the $πN \rightarrow ηN$ and $ηN \rightarrow ηN$ amplitudes using as input the latest data for the dominant $S_{11}$ $πN$ elastic scattering partial wave following suggestions of Prof. G. Höhler. The sign error in the numerical evaluation of the dispersion integral in the original publication is eliminated. The…
▽ More
A three-channel, multi-resonance, unitary model developed in 1995 is used to determine the $πN \rightarrow ηN$ and $ηN \rightarrow ηN$ amplitudes using as input the latest data for the dominant $S_{11}$ $πN$ elastic scattering partial wave following suggestions of Prof. G. Höhler. The sign error in the numerical evaluation of the dispersion integral in the original publication is eliminated. The remaining weighted data set for the $πN \rightarrow ηN$ total and differential cross sections is used as in the original publication. The correction of the numerical error influences the $ηN$ cusp effect and improves the quality of the fit to the input data. However, our new result for the $ηN$ scattering length, $a_{ηN }= (0.717 \pm 0.030) + i (0.263 \pm 0.025)$ fm, is a sole consequence of the correction of the $S_{11}$ input and suggests that the $ηd$ system is unbound or loosely bound.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 1997;
originally announced March 1997.
-
Near threshold eta production in proton-proton collisions
Authors:
M. Batinic,
A. Svarc,
T. -S. H. Lee
Abstract:
The total cross section for the near threshold eta production in proton-proton collisions has been investigated with the assumption that the production mechanism is due to the emission of a meson x (pi, eta, sigma) from one of the nucleons followed by a x N --> eta N transition on the second one. The x N --> eta N amplitudes are generated from the unitary multi-channel multi-resonance model whic…
▽ More
The total cross section for the near threshold eta production in proton-proton collisions has been investigated with the assumption that the production mechanism is due to the emission of a meson x (pi, eta, sigma) from one of the nucleons followed by a x N --> eta N transition on the second one. The x N --> eta N amplitudes are generated from the unitary multi-channel multi-resonance model which has recently been constructed in analyzing the pi N scattering and pi N --> eta N reaction. The initial and final pp distortions are calculated from a coupled-channel pi-NN model which describes the NN scattering data up to about 2 GeV. With the x-NN vertex functions taken from the Bonn potential, the predicted total cross sections of threshold pp --> eta pp reaction are in good agreement with the data. In contrast to previous works, we find that the eta-exchange plays an important role. The effect of the two-pion exchange, simulated by sigma- exchange, is found to be significant but not as dominant as the vector meson-exchange introduced in previous works.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 1996;
originally announced April 1996.
-
The eta-N S-wave scattering length in one resonance model
Authors:
Mijo Batinic,
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
We show that the S-wave $ηN$ scattering length can be extracted in a model independent way within the scope of the multichannel model, but with the restricting assumption that only one resonance is included per partial wave. One has only to use the information on $πN$ elastic S-wave T-matrix at the $η$ production threshold, and near threshold $π^{-} p \rightarrow ηn$ total cross section. The res…
▽ More
We show that the S-wave $ηN$ scattering length can be extracted in a model independent way within the scope of the multichannel model, but with the restricting assumption that only one resonance is included per partial wave. One has only to use the information on $πN$ elastic S-wave T-matrix at the $η$ production threshold, and near threshold $π^{-} p \rightarrow ηn$ total cross section. The results are independent of the particular parametrization of the elastic T-matrix and of the number of channels. For the described model the unitarity requires that the number of channels must be at least three. These assumptions are more general then the assumptions of the existing single resonance models up to now used for extracting the $ηN$ S-wave scattering length. The agreement of our approach with former estimates is anticipated and confirmed for all cases for which the input data agree with the commonly accepted values.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 1995;
originally announced March 1995.
-
eta N S-wave scattering length in a three coupled channel, multiresonance, unitary model
Authors:
Mijo Batinic,
Ivo Slaus,
Alfred Svarc
Abstract:
The S-wave scattering length for eta-N elastic scattering is extracted from the S-wave T-matrix in a three coupled channel, multiresonance unitary model. Results are compared with values already reported in literature which are obtained applying multichannel, but single resonance -- no background models. A dispersion among the previously published values of the real part of the S-wave scattering l…
▽ More
The S-wave scattering length for eta-N elastic scattering is extracted from the S-wave T-matrix in a three coupled channel, multiresonance unitary model. Results are compared with values already reported in literature which are obtained applying multichannel, but single resonance -- no background models. A dispersion among the previously published values of the real part of the S-wave scattering length is observed. We demonstrate that the reported spread originates from the strong sensitivity of the scattering length upon the small variation of the used input resonance parameters. In addition, we show that eta-N scattering length value obtained in single resonance -- no background models significantly increases if background term is added in a unitary way. We question the reliability of previously reported values based only on the single resonance -- no background models, and demonstrate that the value of the eta-N S-wave scattering length obtained in this publication is much more realistic because of the multiresonance and unitary approach.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 1995; v1 submitted 7 February, 1995;
originally announced February 1995.
