-
Neutrino Theory in the Precision Era
Authors:
Asmaa Abada,
Gabriela Barenboim,
Toni Bertólez-Martínez,
Sandipan Bhattacherjee,
Sara Bolognesi,
Patrick D. Bolton,
Nilay Bostan,
Gustavo C. Branco,
Sabya Sachi Chatterjee,
Adriano Cherchiglia,
Marco Chianese,
B. A. Couto e Silva,
Peter B. Denton,
Stephen Dolan,
Marco Drewes,
Ilham El Atmani,
Miguel Escudero,
Ivan Esteban,
Manuel Ettengruber,
Enrique Fernández-Martínez,
Julien Froustey,
Raj Gandhi,
Julia Gehrlein,
Srubabati Goswami,
André de Gouvêa
, et al. (54 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This document summarises discussions on future directions in theoretical neutrino physics, which are the outcome of a neutrino theory workshop held at CERN in February 2025. The starting point is the realisation that neutrino physics offers unique opportunities to address some of the most fundamental questions in physics. This motivates a vigorous experimental programme which the theory community…
▽ More
This document summarises discussions on future directions in theoretical neutrino physics, which are the outcome of a neutrino theory workshop held at CERN in February 2025. The starting point is the realisation that neutrino physics offers unique opportunities to address some of the most fundamental questions in physics. This motivates a vigorous experimental programme which the theory community fully supports. \textbf{A strong effort in theoretical neutrino physics is paramount to optimally take advantage of upcoming neutrino experiments and to explore the synergies with other areas of particle, astroparticle, and nuclear physics, as well as cosmology.} Progress on the theory side has the potential to significantly boost the physics reach of experiments, as well as go well beyond their original scope. Strong collaboration between theory and experiment is essential in the precision era. To foster such collaboration, \textbf{we propose to establish a CERN Neutrino Physics Centre.} Taking inspiration from the highly successful LHC Physics Center at Fermilab, the CERN Neutrino Physics Centre would be the European hub of the neutrino community, covering experimental and theoretical activities.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Neutrino Scattering: Connections Across Theory and Experiment
Authors:
L. Alvarez-Ruso,
A. M. Ankowski,
A. Ashkenazi,
J. Barrow,
M. Betancourt,
K. Borah,
M. Sajjad Athar,
E. Catano-Mur,
P. Coloma,
P. Dunne,
L. Doria,
A. Fedynitch,
A. Garcia-Soto,
S. Gardiner,
R. Gonzalez-Jimenez,
P. Huber,
N. Jachowicz,
E. Kajomovitz,
B. Klicek,
J. Kopp,
K. Long,
I. Martinez-Soler,
A. S. Meyer,
C. Marshall,
L. Munteanu
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this document drafted by the Neutrino Scattering Theory Experiment Collaboration (NuSTEC), we provide input on the synergies between theoretical and experimental efforts that can provide critical input to the prediction accuracy needed for the forthcoming high-precision neutrino measurements. These efforts involve a wide range of energies and interaction processes, as well as target nuclei and…
▽ More
In this document drafted by the Neutrino Scattering Theory Experiment Collaboration (NuSTEC), we provide input on the synergies between theoretical and experimental efforts that can provide critical input to the prediction accuracy needed for the forthcoming high-precision neutrino measurements. These efforts involve a wide range of energies and interaction processes, as well as target nuclei and interaction probes. The challenges discussed will be overcome only through the active support of integrated collaboration across strong and electroweak physics from both the nuclear and high energy physics communities.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2025; v1 submitted 30 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
On the sensitivity of nuclear clocks to new physics
Authors:
Andrea Caputo,
Doron Gazit,
Hans-Werner Hammer,
Joachim Kopp,
Gil Paz,
Gilad Perez,
Konstantin Springmann
Abstract:
The recent demonstration of laser excitation of the $\approx 8$ eV isomeric state of thorium-229 is a significant step towards a nuclear clock. The low excitation energy likely results from a cancellation between the contributions of the electromagnetic and strong forces. Physics beyond the Standard Model could disrupt this cancellation, highlighting nuclear clocks' sensitivity to new physics. Acc…
▽ More
The recent demonstration of laser excitation of the $\approx 8$ eV isomeric state of thorium-229 is a significant step towards a nuclear clock. The low excitation energy likely results from a cancellation between the contributions of the electromagnetic and strong forces. Physics beyond the Standard Model could disrupt this cancellation, highlighting nuclear clocks' sensitivity to new physics. Accurate predictions of the different contributions to nuclear transition energies, and therefore of the quantitative sensitivity of a nuclear clock, are challenging. We improve upon previous sensitivity estimates and assess a ''nightmare scenario'', where all binding energy differences are small and the new physics sensitivity is poor. A classical geometric model of thorium-229 suggests that fine-tuning is needed for such a scenario. We also propose a $d$-wave halo model, inspired by effective field theory. We show that it reproduces observations and suggests the ''nightmare scenario'' is unlikely. We find that the nuclear clock's sensitivity to variations in the effective fine structure constant is enhanced by a factor of order $10^4$. We finally propose auxiliary nuclear measurements to reduce uncertainties and further test the validity of the halo model.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Unleashing the Power of EFT in Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering
Authors:
Joachim Kopp,
Noemi Rocco,
Zahra Tabrizi
Abstract:
Neutrino physics is advancing into a precision era with the construction of new experiments, particularly in the few GeV energy range. Within this energy range, neutrinos exhibit diverse interactions with nucleons and nuclei. This study delves in particular into neutrino--nucleus quasi-elastic cross sections, taking into account both standard and, for the first time, non-standard interactions, all…
▽ More
Neutrino physics is advancing into a precision era with the construction of new experiments, particularly in the few GeV energy range. Within this energy range, neutrinos exhibit diverse interactions with nucleons and nuclei. This study delves in particular into neutrino--nucleus quasi-elastic cross sections, taking into account both standard and, for the first time, non-standard interactions, all within the framework of effective field theory (EFT). The main uncertainties in these cross sections stem from uncertainties in the nucleon-level form factors, and from the approximations necessary to solve the nuclear many-body problem. We explore how these uncertainties influence the potential of neutrino experiments to probe new physics introduced by left-handed, right-handed, scalar, pseudoscalar, and tensor interactions. For some of these interactions the cross section is enhanced, making long-baseline experiments an excellent place to search for them. Our results, including tabulated cross sections for all interaction types and all neutrino flavors, can serve as the foundation for such searches.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2024; v1 submitted 15 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Electron and Muon Dynamics in Neutron Stars Beyond Chemical Equilibrium
Authors:
Joachim Kopp,
Toby Opferkuch
Abstract:
A neutron star harbors of order $10^{56}$ electrons in its core, and almost the same number of muons, with muon decay prohibited by Pauli blocking. However, as macroscopic properties of the star such as its mass, rotational velocity, or magnetic field evolve over time, the equilibrium lepton abundances (dictated by the weak interactions) change as well. Scenarios where this can happen include spin…
▽ More
A neutron star harbors of order $10^{56}$ electrons in its core, and almost the same number of muons, with muon decay prohibited by Pauli blocking. However, as macroscopic properties of the star such as its mass, rotational velocity, or magnetic field evolve over time, the equilibrium lepton abundances (dictated by the weak interactions) change as well. Scenarios where this can happen include spin-down, accretion, magnetic field decay, and tidal deformation. We discuss the mechanisms by which a star disrupted in one of these ways re-establishes lepton chemical equilibrium. In most cases, the dominant processes are out-of-equilibrium Urca reactions, the rates of which we compute for the first time. If, however, the equilibrium muon abundance decreases, while the equilibrium electron abundance increases (or decreases less than the equilibrium muon abundance), outward diffusion of muons plays a crucial role as well. This is true in particular for stars older than about 10,000 yrs whose core has cooled to $\lesssim 20$ keV. The muons decay in a region where Pauli blocking is lifted, and we argue that these decays lead to a flux of $\mathcal{O}$(10 MeV) neutrinos. Realistically, however, this flux will remain undetectable for the foreseeable future.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Towards Resolving the Gallium Anomaly
Authors:
Vedran Brdar,
Julia Gehrlein,
Joachim Kopp
Abstract:
A series of experiments studying neutrinos from intense radioactive sources have reported a deficit in the measured event rate which, in combination, has reached a statistical significance of $\sim 5σ$. In this paper, we explore avenues for explaining this anomaly, both within the Standard Model and beyond. First, we discuss possible biases in the predicted cross section for the detection reaction…
▽ More
A series of experiments studying neutrinos from intense radioactive sources have reported a deficit in the measured event rate which, in combination, has reached a statistical significance of $\sim 5σ$. In this paper, we explore avenues for explaining this anomaly, both within the Standard Model and beyond. First, we discuss possible biases in the predicted cross section for the detection reaction $ν_e + ^{71}\text{Ga} \to e^- + ^{71}\text{Ge}$, which could arise from mismeasurement of the inverse process, $^{71}\text{Ge}$ decay, or from the presence of as yet unknown low-lying excited states of $^{71}\text{Ga}$. The latter would imply that not all $^{71}\text{Ge}$ decays go to the ground state of $^{71}\text{Ga}$, so the extraction of the ground state-to-ground state matrix element relevant for neutrino capture on gallium would be incorrect. Second, we scrutinize the measurement of the source intensity in gallium experiments, and we point out that a $\sim 2\%$ error in the branching ratios for $^{51}\text{Cr}$ decay would be enough to explain the anomaly. Third, we investigate the calibration of the radiochemical germanium extraction efficiency as a possible origin of anomaly. Finally, we outline several new explanations beyond the Standard Model, including scenarios with sterile neutrinos coupled to fuzzy dark matter or to dark energy, as well as a model with decaying sterile neutrinos. We critically assess the viability of these scenarios, and others that have been proposed, in a summary table.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2023; v1 submitted 9 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Project X: Physics Opportunities
Authors:
Andreas S. Kronfeld,
Robert S. Tschirhart,
Usama Al-Binni,
Wolfgang Altmannshofer,
Charles Ankenbrandt,
Kaladi Babu,
Sunanda Banerjee,
Matthew Bass,
Brian Batell,
David V. Baxter,
Zurab Berezhiani,
Marc Bergevin,
Robert Bernstein,
Sudeb Bhattacharya,
Mary Bishai,
Thomas Blum,
S. Alex Bogacz,
Stephen J. Brice,
Joachim Brod,
Alan Bross,
Michael Buchoff,
Thomas W. Burgess,
Marcela Carena,
Luis A. Castellanos,
Subhasis Chattopadhyay
, et al. (111 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Part 2 of "Project X: Accelerator Reference Design, Physics Opportunities, Broader Impacts". In this Part, we outline the particle-physics program that can be achieved with Project X, a staged superconducting linac for intensity-frontier particle physics. Topics include neutrino physics, kaon physics, muon physics, electric dipole moments, neutron-antineutron oscillations, new light particles, had…
▽ More
Part 2 of "Project X: Accelerator Reference Design, Physics Opportunities, Broader Impacts". In this Part, we outline the particle-physics program that can be achieved with Project X, a staged superconducting linac for intensity-frontier particle physics. Topics include neutrino physics, kaon physics, muon physics, electric dipole moments, neutron-antineutron oscillations, new light particles, hadron structure, hadron spectroscopy, and lattice-QCD calculations. Part 1 is available as arXiv:1306.5022 [physics.acc-ph] and Part 3 is available as arXiv:1306.5024 [physics.acc-ph].
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2016; v1 submitted 20 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Light Sterile Neutrinos: A White Paper
Authors:
K. N. Abazajian,
M. A. Acero,
S. K. Agarwalla,
A. A. Aguilar-Arevalo,
C. H. Albright,
S. Antusch,
C. A. Arguelles,
A. B. Balantekin,
G. Barenboim,
V. Barger,
P. Bernardini,
F. Bezrukov,
O. E. Bjaelde,
S. A. Bogacz,
N. S. Bowden,
A. Boyarsky,
A. Bravar,
D. Bravo Berguno,
S. J. Brice,
A. D. Bross,
B. Caccianiga,
F. Cavanna,
E. J. Chun,
B. T. Cleveland,
A. P. Collin
, et al. (162 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This white paper addresses the hypothesis of light sterile neutrinos based on recent anomalies observed in neutrino experiments and the latest astrophysical data.
This white paper addresses the hypothesis of light sterile neutrinos based on recent anomalies observed in neutrino experiments and the latest astrophysical data.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
On a theory of neutrino oscillations with entanglement
Authors:
Boris Kayser,
Joachim Kopp,
R. G. Hamish Robertson,
Petr Vogel
Abstract:
We show that, despite appearances, a theoretical approach to neutrino oscillation in which the neutrino and its interaction partners are entangled yields the standard result for the neutrino oscillation wavelength. We also shed some light on the question of why plane-wave approaches to the neutrino oscillation problem can yield the correct oscillation wavelength even though they do not explicitly…
▽ More
We show that, despite appearances, a theoretical approach to neutrino oscillation in which the neutrino and its interaction partners are entangled yields the standard result for the neutrino oscillation wavelength. We also shed some light on the question of why plane-wave approaches to the neutrino oscillation problem can yield the correct oscillation wavelength even though they do not explicitly account for the localization of the neutrino source and the detector.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2010; v1 submitted 11 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Ultra-low Q values for neutrino mass measurements
Authors:
Joachim Kopp,
Alexander Merle
Abstract:
We investigate weak nuclear decays with extremely small kinetic energy release (Q value) and thus extremely good sensitivity to the absolute neutrino mass scale. In particular, we consider decays into excited daughter states, and we show that partial ionization of the parent atom can help to tune Q values to << 1 keV. We discuss several candidate isotopes undergoing beta+, beta-, bound state bet…
▽ More
We investigate weak nuclear decays with extremely small kinetic energy release (Q value) and thus extremely good sensitivity to the absolute neutrino mass scale. In particular, we consider decays into excited daughter states, and we show that partial ionization of the parent atom can help to tune Q values to << 1 keV. We discuss several candidate isotopes undergoing beta+, beta-, bound state beta, or electron capture decay, and come to the conclusion that a neutrino mass measurement using low-Q decays might only be feasible if no ionization is required, and if future improvements in isotope production technology, nuclear mass spectroscopy, and atomic structure calculations are possible. Experiments using ions, however, are extremely challenging due to the large number of ions that must be stored. New precision data on nuclear excitation levels could help to identify further isotopes with low-Q decay modes and possibly less challenging requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2010; v1 submitted 17 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
The GSI anomaly
Authors:
Hendrik Kienert,
Joachim Kopp,
Manfred Lindner,
Alexander Merle
Abstract:
Recently, an experiment at GSI Darmstadt has observed oscillating decay rates of heavy ions. Several controversial attempts have been made to explain this effect in terms of neutrino mixing. We briefly describe the experimental results, give an overview of the literature, and show that the effect cannot be due to neutrino mixing. If the effect survives, it could, however, be explained by hypothe…
▽ More
Recently, an experiment at GSI Darmstadt has observed oscillating decay rates of heavy ions. Several controversial attempts have been made to explain this effect in terms of neutrino mixing. We briefly describe the experimental results, give an overview of the literature, and show that the effect cannot be due to neutrino mixing. If the effect survives, it could, however, be explained by hypothetical internal excitations of the mother ions (~ 10^(-15) eV).
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Oscillations of Mossbauer neutrinos
Authors:
Evgeny Kh. Akhmedov,
Joachim Kopp,
Manfred Lindner
Abstract:
We calculate the probability of recoilless emission and detection of neutrinos (Mossbauer effect with neutrinos) taking into account the boundedness of the parent and daughter nuclei in the neutrino source and detector as well as the leptonic mixing. We show that, in spite of their near monochromaticity, the recoillessly emitted and captured neutrinos oscillate. After a qualitative discussion of…
▽ More
We calculate the probability of recoilless emission and detection of neutrinos (Mossbauer effect with neutrinos) taking into account the boundedness of the parent and daughter nuclei in the neutrino source and detector as well as the leptonic mixing. We show that, in spite of their near monochromaticity, the recoillessly emitted and captured neutrinos oscillate. After a qualitative discussion of this issue, we corroborate and extend our results by computing the combined rate of $\barν_e$ production, propagation and detection in the framework of quantum field theory, starting from first principles. This allows us to avoid making any a priori assumptions about the energy and momentum of the intermediate-state neutrino. Our calculation permits quantitative predictions of the transition rate in future experiments, and shows that the decoherence and delocalization factors, which could in principle suppress neutrino oscillations, are irrelevant under realistic experimental conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2008; v1 submitted 18 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
