-
Bayesian model-data comparison incorporating theoretical uncertainties
Authors:
Sunil Jaiswal,
Chun Shen,
Richard J. Furnstahl,
Ulrich Heinz,
Matthew T. Pratola
Abstract:
Accurate comparisons between theoretical models and experimental data are critical for scientific progress. However, inferred physical model parameters can vary significantly with the chosen physics model, highlighting the importance of properly accounting for theoretical uncertainties. In this article, we explicitly incorporate these uncertainties using Gaussian processes that model the domain of…
▽ More
Accurate comparisons between theoretical models and experimental data are critical for scientific progress. However, inferred physical model parameters can vary significantly with the chosen physics model, highlighting the importance of properly accounting for theoretical uncertainties. In this article, we explicitly incorporate these uncertainties using Gaussian processes that model the domain of validity of theoretical models, integrating prior knowledge about where a theory applies and where it does not. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach using two systems: a simple ball drop experiment and multi-stage heavy-ion simulations. In both cases incorporating model discrepancy leads to improved parameter estimates, with systematic improvements observed as additional experimental observables are integrated.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2025; v1 submitted 17 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Why are hydrodynamic theories applicable beyond the hydrodynamic regime?
Authors:
Sunil Jaiswal,
Jean-Paul Blaizot,
Rajeev S. Bhalerao,
Zenan Chen,
Amaresh Jaiswal,
Li Yan
Abstract:
We present an alternative approach to deriving second-order non-conformal hydrodynamics from the relativistic Boltzmann equation. We demonstrate how constitutive relations for shear and bulk stresses can be transformed into dynamical evolution equations, resulting in Israel-Stewart-like (ISL) hydrodynamics. To understand the far-from-equilibrium applicability of such ISL theories, we investigate t…
▽ More
We present an alternative approach to deriving second-order non-conformal hydrodynamics from the relativistic Boltzmann equation. We demonstrate how constitutive relations for shear and bulk stresses can be transformed into dynamical evolution equations, resulting in Israel-Stewart-like (ISL) hydrodynamics. To understand the far-from-equilibrium applicability of such ISL theories, we investigate the one-dimensional boost-invariant Boltzmann equation using special moments of the distribution function for a system with finite particle mass. Our analysis reveals that the mathematical structure of the ISL equations is akin to that of moment equations, enabling them to approximately replicate even the collisionless dynamics. We conclude that this particular feature is important in extending the applicability of ISL theories beyond the hydrodynamic regime.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Relativistic second-order viscous hydrodynamics from kinetic theory with extended relaxation-time approximation
Authors:
Dipika Dash,
Sunil Jaiswal,
Samapan Bhadury,
Amaresh Jaiswal
Abstract:
We use the extended relaxation time approximation for the collision kernel, which incorporates a particle-energy dependent relaxation time, to derive second-order viscous hydrodynamics from the Boltzmann equation for a system of massless particles. The resulting transport coefficients are found to be sensitive to the energy dependence of the relaxation time and have significant influence on the fl…
▽ More
We use the extended relaxation time approximation for the collision kernel, which incorporates a particle-energy dependent relaxation time, to derive second-order viscous hydrodynamics from the Boltzmann equation for a system of massless particles. The resulting transport coefficients are found to be sensitive to the energy dependence of the relaxation time and have significant influence on the fluid's evolution. Using the derived hydrodynamic equations, we study the evolution of a fluid undergoing (0+1)-dimensional expansion with Bjorken symmetry and investigate the fixed point structure inherent in the equations. Further, by employing a power law parametrization to describe the energy dependence of the relaxation time, we successfully reproduce the stable free-streaming fixed point for a specific power of the energy dependence. The impact of the energy-dependent relaxation time on the processes of isotropization and thermalization of an expanding plasma is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2023; v1 submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Metric anisotropies and nonequilibrium attractor for expanding plasma
Authors:
Nisarg Vyas,
Sunil Jaiswal,
Amaresh Jaiswal
Abstract:
We consider the evolution of a system of chargeless and massless particles in an anisotropic space-time given by the Bianchi type I metric. Specializing to the axis-symmetric case, we derive the framework of anisotropic hydrodynamics from the Boltzmann equation in the relaxation-time approximation. We consider the case of the axis-symmetric Kasner metric and study the approach to the emergent attr…
▽ More
We consider the evolution of a system of chargeless and massless particles in an anisotropic space-time given by the Bianchi type I metric. Specializing to the axis-symmetric case, we derive the framework of anisotropic hydrodynamics from the Boltzmann equation in the relaxation-time approximation. We consider the case of the axis-symmetric Kasner metric and study the approach to the emergent attractor in near and far-off-equilibrium regimes. Further, by relaxing the Kasner conditions on metric coefficients, we study the effect of expansion geometries on the far-off-equilibrium attractor and discuss its implications in the context of relativistic heavy-ion collisions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2023; v1 submitted 5 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Dynamics of Hot QCD Matter -- Current Status and Developments
Authors:
Santosh K. Das,
Prabhakar Palni,
Jhuma Sannigrahi,
Jan-e Alam,
Cho Win Aung,
Yoshini Bailung,
Debjani Banerjee,
Gergely Gábor Barnaföldi,
Subash Chandra Behera,
Partha Pratim Bhaduri,
Samapan Bhadury,
Rajesh Biswas,
Pritam Chakraborty,
Vinod Chandra,
Prottoy Das,
Sadhana Dash,
Saumen Datta,
Sudipan De,
Vaishnavi Desai,
Suman Deb,
Debarshi Dey,
Jayanta Dey,
Sabyasachi Ghosh,
Najmul Haque,
Mujeeb Hasan
, et al. (42 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The discovery and characterization of hot and dense QCD matter, known as Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP), remains the most international collaborative effort and synergy between theorists and experimentalists in modern nuclear physics to date. The experimentalists around the world not only collect an unprecedented amount of data in heavy-ion collisions, at Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC), at Brook…
▽ More
The discovery and characterization of hot and dense QCD matter, known as Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP), remains the most international collaborative effort and synergy between theorists and experimentalists in modern nuclear physics to date. The experimentalists around the world not only collect an unprecedented amount of data in heavy-ion collisions, at Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC), at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) in New York, USA, and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), at CERN in Geneva, Switzerland but also analyze these data to unravel the mystery of this new phase of matter that filled a few microseconds old universe, just after the Big Bang. In the meantime, advancements in theoretical works and computing capability extend our wisdom about the hot-dense QCD matter and its dynamics through mathematical equations. The exchange of ideas between experimentalists and theoreticians is crucial for the progress of our knowledge. The motivation of this first conference named "HOT QCD Matter 2022" is to bring the community together to have a discourse on this topic. In this article, there are 36 sections discussing various topics in the field of relativistic heavy-ion collisions and related phenomena that cover a snapshot of the current experimental observations and theoretical progress. This article begins with the theoretical overview of relativistic spin-hydrodynamics in the presence of the external magnetic field, followed by the Lattice QCD results on heavy quarks in QGP, and finally, it ends with an overview of experiment results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
From moments of the distribution function to hydrodynamics: The non-conformal case
Authors:
Sunil Jaiswal,
Jean-Paul Blaizot,
Rajeev S. Bhalerao,
Zenan Chen,
Amaresh Jaiswal,
Li Yan
Abstract:
We study the one-dimensional boost-invariant Boltzmann equation in the relaxation-time approximation using special moments of the distribution function for a system with a finite particle mass. The infinite hierarchy of moments can be truncated by keeping only the three lowest moments that correspond to the three independent components of the energy-momentum tensor. We show that such a three-momen…
▽ More
We study the one-dimensional boost-invariant Boltzmann equation in the relaxation-time approximation using special moments of the distribution function for a system with a finite particle mass. The infinite hierarchy of moments can be truncated by keeping only the three lowest moments that correspond to the three independent components of the energy-momentum tensor. We show that such a three-moment truncation reproduces accurately the exact solution of the kinetic equation after a simple renormalization that takes into account the effects of the neglected higher moments. We derive second-order Israel-Stewart hydrodynamic equations from the three-moment equations, and show that, for most physically relevant initial conditions, these equations yield results comparable to those of the three-moment truncation, albeit less accurate. We attribute this feature to the fact that the structure of Israel-Stewart equations is similar to that of the three-moment truncation. In particular, the presence of the relaxation term in the Israel-Stewart equations, yields an early-time regime that mimics approximately the collisionless regime. A detailed comparison of the three-moment truncation with second-order non-conformal hydrodynamics reveals ambiguities in the definition of second-order transport coefficients. These ambiguities affect the ability of Israel-Stewart hydrodynamics to reproduce results of kinetic theory.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2022; v1 submitted 4 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Far-from-equilibrium attractor in non-conformal plasmas
Authors:
Sunil Jaiswal,
Subrata Pal,
Chandrodoy Chattopadhyay,
Lipei Du,
Ulrich Heinz
Abstract:
We study the far-off-equilibrium dynamics of a Bjorken expanding non-conformal system within kinetic theory and hydrodynamics. We show that, in contrast to the conformal case, neither shear nor bulk viscous pressure relax quickly to a non-equilibrium attractor. In kinetic theory an early-time, far-from-equilibrium attractor exists for the scaled longitudinal pressure, driven by the rapid longitudi…
▽ More
We study the far-off-equilibrium dynamics of a Bjorken expanding non-conformal system within kinetic theory and hydrodynamics. We show that, in contrast to the conformal case, neither shear nor bulk viscous pressure relax quickly to a non-equilibrium attractor. In kinetic theory an early-time, far-from-equilibrium attractor exists for the scaled longitudinal pressure, driven by the rapid longitudinal expansion of the medium. Second-order dissipative hydrodynamics fails to accurately describe this attractor, but a modified anisotropic hydrodynamic formulation reproduces it and provides excellent agreement with kinetic theory.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Extended relaxation time approximation and relativistic dissipative hydrodynamics
Authors:
Dipika Dash,
Samapan Bhadury,
Sunil Jaiswal,
Amaresh Jaiswal
Abstract:
Development of a new framework for derivation of order-by-order hydrodynamics from Boltzmann equation is necessary as the widely used Anderson-Witting formalism leads to violation of fundamental conservation laws when the relaxation-time depends on particle energy, or in a hydrodynamic frame other than the Landau frame. We generalize an existing framework for consistent derivation of relativistic…
▽ More
Development of a new framework for derivation of order-by-order hydrodynamics from Boltzmann equation is necessary as the widely used Anderson-Witting formalism leads to violation of fundamental conservation laws when the relaxation-time depends on particle energy, or in a hydrodynamic frame other than the Landau frame. We generalize an existing framework for consistent derivation of relativistic dissipative hydrodynamics from the Boltzmann equation with a energy-dependent relaxation-time by extending the Anderson-Witting relaxation-time approximation. We argue that the present framework is compatible with conservation laws and derive first-order hydrodynamic equations in landau frame. Further, we show that the transport coefficients, such as shear and bulk viscosity as well as charge and heat diffusion currents, have corrections due to the energy dependence of relaxation time compared to what one obtains from the Anderson-Witting approximation of the collision term. The ratio of these transport coefficients are studied using a parametrized relaxation-time, and several interesting scaling features are reported.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2022; v1 submitted 29 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
On non-conformal kinetic theory and hydrodynamics for Bjorken flow
Authors:
Sunil Jaiswal,
Chandrodoy Chattopadhyay,
Lipei Du,
Ulrich Heinz,
Subrata Pal
Abstract:
Using and comparing kinetic theory and second-order Chapman-Enskog hydrodynamics, we study the non-conformal dynamics of a system undergoing Bjorken expansion. We use the concept of `free-streaming fixed lines' for scaled shear and bulk stresses in non-conformal kinetic theory and hydrodynamics, and show that these `fixed lines' behave as early-time attractors and repellors of the evolution. In th…
▽ More
Using and comparing kinetic theory and second-order Chapman-Enskog hydrodynamics, we study the non-conformal dynamics of a system undergoing Bjorken expansion. We use the concept of `free-streaming fixed lines' for scaled shear and bulk stresses in non-conformal kinetic theory and hydrodynamics, and show that these `fixed lines' behave as early-time attractors and repellors of the evolution. In the conformal limit, the free-streaming fixed lines reduce to the well-known fixed points of conformal Bjorken dynamics. A new fixed point in the free streaming regime is identified which lies at the intersection of these fixed lines. Contrary to the conformal scenario, both kinetic theory and hydrodynamics predict the absence of attractor behavior in the normalised shear stress channel. In kinetic theory a far-off-equilibrium attractor is found for the normalised effective longitudinal pressure, driven by rapid longitudinal expansion. Second-order viscous hydrodynamics fails to accurately describe this attractor. From a thorough analysis of the free-streaming dynamics in Chapman-Enskog hydrodynamics we conclude that this failure results from an inaccurate approximation of the fixed lines and a related incorrect description of the nature of the fixed point. A modified anisotropic hydrodynamic description is presented that provides excellent agreement with kinetic theory results and reproduces the far-from-equilibrium attractor for the scaled longitudinal pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Hydrodynamical attractor and thermal particle production in heavy-ion collision
Authors:
Lakshmi J. Naik,
Sunil Jaiswal,
K. Sreelakshmi,
Amaresh Jaiswal,
V. Sreekanth
Abstract:
Study of thermal particle production is crucial to understand the space-time evolution of the fireball produced in high energy heavy-ion collisions. We consider thermal particle production within the framework of relativistic viscous hydrodynamics and employ recently obtained analytical solutions of higher-order viscous hydrodynamics with longitudinal Bjorken expansion to calculate the spectra of…
▽ More
Study of thermal particle production is crucial to understand the space-time evolution of the fireball produced in high energy heavy-ion collisions. We consider thermal particle production within the framework of relativistic viscous hydrodynamics and employ recently obtained analytical solutions of higher-order viscous hydrodynamics with longitudinal Bjorken expansion to calculate the spectra of dileptons and photons. Using these analytical solutions, we constrain the allowed initial states by demanding positivity and reality of energy density throughout the evolution. Further, we compute thermal particle spectra and study the particle yield in context of hydrodynamic attractors. We find that, of all allowed solutions, the evolution corresponding to attractor solution leads to maximum production of thermal particles.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Non-conformal attractor in boost-invariant plasmas
Authors:
Chandrodoy Chattopadhyay,
Sunil Jaiswal,
Lipei Du,
Ulrich Heinz,
Subrata Pal
Abstract:
We study the dissipative evolution of (0+1)-dimensionally expanding media with Bjorken symmetry using the Boltzmann equation for massive particles in relaxation-time approximation. Breaking conformal symmetry by a mass induces a non-zero bulk viscous pressure in the medium. It is shown that even a small mass (in units of the local temperature) drastically modifies the well-known attractor for the…
▽ More
We study the dissipative evolution of (0+1)-dimensionally expanding media with Bjorken symmetry using the Boltzmann equation for massive particles in relaxation-time approximation. Breaking conformal symmetry by a mass induces a non-zero bulk viscous pressure in the medium. It is shown that even a small mass (in units of the local temperature) drastically modifies the well-known attractor for the shear Reynolds number previously observed in massless systems. For generic nonzero particle mass, neither the shear nor the bulk viscous pressure relax quickly to a non-equilibrium attractor; they approach the hydrodynamic limit only late, at small values of the inverse Reynolds numbers. Only the longitudinal pressure, which is a combination of thermal, shear and bulk viscous pressures, continues to show early approach to a far-off-equilibrium attractor, driven by the rapid longitudinal expansion at early times. Second-order dissipative hydrodynamics based on a gradient expansion around locally isotropic thermal equilibrium fails to reproduce this attractor.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Dynamics of QCD Matter -- current status
Authors:
Amaresh Jaiswal,
Najmul Haque,
Aman Abhishek,
Raktim Abir,
Aritra Bandyopadhyay,
Khatiza Banu,
Samapan Bhadury,
Sumana Bhattacharyya,
Trambak Bhattacharyya,
Deeptak Biswas,
H. C. Chandola,
Vinod Chandra,
Bhaswar Chatterjee,
Chandrodoy Chattopadhyay,
Nilanjan Chaudhuri,
Aritra Das,
Arpan Das,
Santosh K. Das,
Ashutosh Dash,
Kishan Deka,
Jayanta Dey,
Ricardo L. S. Farias,
Utsab Gangopadhyaya,
Ritesh Ghosh,
Sabyasachi Ghosh
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this article, there are 18 sections discussing various current topics in the field of relativistic heavy-ion collisions and related phenomena, which will serve as a snapshot of the current state of the art.
Section 1 reviews experimental results of some recent light-flavored particle production data from ALICE collaboration. Other sections are mostly theoretical in nature.
Very strong but t…
▽ More
In this article, there are 18 sections discussing various current topics in the field of relativistic heavy-ion collisions and related phenomena, which will serve as a snapshot of the current state of the art.
Section 1 reviews experimental results of some recent light-flavored particle production data from ALICE collaboration. Other sections are mostly theoretical in nature.
Very strong but transient magnetic field created in relativistic heavy-ion collisions could have important observational consequences. This has generated a lot of theoretical activity in the last decade. Sections 2, 7, 9, 10 and 11 deal with the effects of the magnetic field on the properties of the QCD matter. There are several unanswered questions about the QCD phase diagram. Sections 3, 11 and 18 discuss various aspects of the QCD phase diagram and phase transitions.
Recent years have witnessed interesting developments in foundational aspects of hydrodynamics and their application to heavy-ion collisions. Sections 12, 15, 16 and 17 of this article probe some aspects of this exciting field.
Transport coefficients together with their temperature- and density-dependence, are essential inputs in hydrodynamical calculations. Sections 5, 8 and 14 deal with calculation/estimation of various transport coefficients (shear and bulk viscosity, thermal conductivity, relaxation times, etc.) of quark matter and hadronic matter.
Sections 4, 6 and 13 deals with interesting new developments in the field. Section 4 discusses color dipole gluon distribution function at small transverse momentum in the form of a series of Bells polynomials. Section 6 discusses the properties of Higgs boson in the quark gluon plasma using Higgs-quark interaction. Section 13 discusses modification of coalescence model to incorporate viscous corrections and application of this model.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2021; v1 submitted 29 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Constraining dense matter physics using f-mode oscillations in neutron stars
Authors:
Sukrit Jaiswal,
Debarati Chatterjee
Abstract:
In this undergraduate project, f-mode oscillations in neutron stars are used to constrain the equation of state of dense matter. For the first time, a systematic investigation of the role of nuclear saturation parameters on the mode oscillations is performed. It is found that the uncertainty in the determination of effective nucleon mass plays the most significant role in controlling the f-mode fr…
▽ More
In this undergraduate project, f-mode oscillations in neutron stars are used to constrain the equation of state of dense matter. For the first time, a systematic investigation of the role of nuclear saturation parameters on the mode oscillations is performed. It is found that the uncertainty in the determination of effective nucleon mass plays the most significant role in controlling the f-mode frequencies. Correlations of the frequencies with astrophysical observables relevant for asteroseismology are also investigated. Future detection of f-mode frequencies could then provide a unique way of constraining nuclear empirical parameters and therefore the behaviour of dense matter.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Exact solutions and attractors of higher-order viscous fluid dynamics for Bjorken flow
Authors:
Sunil Jaiswal,
Chandrodoy Chattopadhyay,
Amaresh Jaiswal,
Subrata Pal,
Ulrich Heinz
Abstract:
We consider causal higher order theories of relativistic viscous hydrodynamics in the limit of one-dimensional boost-invariant expansion and study the associated dynamical attractor. We obtain evolution equations for the inverse Reynolds number as a function of Knudsen number. The solutions of these equations exhibit attractor behavior which we analyze in terms of Lyapunov exponents using several…
▽ More
We consider causal higher order theories of relativistic viscous hydrodynamics in the limit of one-dimensional boost-invariant expansion and study the associated dynamical attractor. We obtain evolution equations for the inverse Reynolds number as a function of Knudsen number. The solutions of these equations exhibit attractor behavior which we analyze in terms of Lyapunov exponents using several different techniques. We compare the attractors of the second-order Müller-Israel-Stewart (MIS), transient DNMR, and third-order theories with the exact solution of the Boltzmann equation in the relaxation-time approximation. It is shown that for Bjorken flow the third-order theory provides a better approximation to the exact kinetic theory attractor than both MIS and DNMR theories. For three different choices of the time dependence of the shear relaxation rate we find analytical solutions for the energy density and shear stress and use these to study the attractors analytically. By studying these analytical solutions at both small and large Knudsen numbers we characterize and uniquely determine the attractors and Lyapunov exponents. While for small Knudsen numbers the approach to the attractor is exponential, strong power-law decay of deviations from the attractor and rapid loss of initial state memory is found even for large Knudsen numbers. Implications for the applicability of hydrodynamics in far-off-equilibrium situations are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2019; v1 submitted 18 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Analytical solutions of causal relativistic hydrodynamic equations for Bjorken and Gubser flows
Authors:
Chandrodoy Chattopadhyay,
Amaresh Jaiswal,
Sunil Jaiswal,
Subrata Pal
Abstract:
We obtain general analytical solutions of third-order viscous hydrodynamic equations for Bjorken and Gubser flows in systems with vanishing bulk viscosity and chemical potential, and having a constant shear relaxation time. We also analytically characterize and determine the hydrodynamic attractors for such systems by studying the universal behavior of these solutions at both early and late times.…
▽ More
We obtain general analytical solutions of third-order viscous hydrodynamic equations for Bjorken and Gubser flows in systems with vanishing bulk viscosity and chemical potential, and having a constant shear relaxation time. We also analytically characterize and determine the hydrodynamic attractors for such systems by studying the universal behavior of these solutions at both early and late times. Finally we study the properties of these hydrodynamic attractors for transport coefficients obtained from relativistic kinetic theory in the relaxation-time approximation.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
