-
On relation between bulk, surface and curvature parts of nuclear binding energy within the model of hexagonal clusters
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi
Abstract:
Using the model of hexagonal clusters we express the surface, curvature and Gauss curvature coefficients of the nuclear binding energy in terms of its bulk coefficient. Using the derived values of these coefficients and a single fitting parameter we are able to reasonably well describe the experimental binding energies of nuclei with more than 100 nucleons. To improve the description of lighter nu…
▽ More
Using the model of hexagonal clusters we express the surface, curvature and Gauss curvature coefficients of the nuclear binding energy in terms of its bulk coefficient. Using the derived values of these coefficients and a single fitting parameter we are able to reasonably well describe the experimental binding energies of nuclei with more than 100 nucleons. To improve the description of lighter nuclei we introduce the same correction for all the coefficients. In this way we determine the apparent values of the surface, curvature and Gauss curvature coefficients which may be used for infinite nuclear matter equation of state. This simple model allows us to fix the temperature dependence of all these coefficients, if the temperature dependence for the bulk term is known. The found estimates for critical temperature are well consistent both with experimental and with theoretical findings.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Possible signals of two QCD phase transitions at NICA-FAIR energies
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
B. E. Grinyuk,
D. O. Savchenko,
G. M. Zinovjev,
E. G. Nikonov,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
D. B. Blaschke,
S. Kabana,
A. V. Taranenko
Abstract:
The chemical freeze-out irregularities found with the most advanced hadron resonance gas model and possible signals of two QCD phase transitions are discussed. We found that the center-of-mass collision energy range of tricritical endpoint of QCD phase diagram is [9; 9.2] GeV which is consistent both with QCD inspired exactly solvable model and with experimental findings.
The chemical freeze-out irregularities found with the most advanced hadron resonance gas model and possible signals of two QCD phase transitions are discussed. We found that the center-of-mass collision energy range of tricritical endpoint of QCD phase diagram is [9; 9.2] GeV which is consistent both with QCD inspired exactly solvable model and with experimental findings.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Hard-core Radius of Nucleons within the Induced Surface Tension Approach
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
B. E. Grinyuk,
D. O. Savchenko,
G. M. Zinovjev,
E. G. Nikonov,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
D. B. Blaschke,
A. V. Taranenko,
L. Turko
Abstract:
In this work we discuss a novel approach to model the hadronic and nuclear matter equations of state using the induced surface tension concept. Since the obtained equations of state, classical and quantum, are among the most successful ones in describing the properties of low density phases of strongly interacting matter, they set strong restrictions on the possible value of the hard-core radius o…
▽ More
In this work we discuss a novel approach to model the hadronic and nuclear matter equations of state using the induced surface tension concept. Since the obtained equations of state, classical and quantum, are among the most successful ones in describing the properties of low density phases of strongly interacting matter, they set strong restrictions on the possible value of the hard-core radius of nucleons. Therefore, we perform a detailed analysis of its value which follows from hadronic and nuclear matter properties and find the most trustworthy range of its values: the hard-core radius of nucleons is 0.30--0.36 fm. A comparison with the phenomenology of neutron stars implies that the hard-core radius of nucleons has to be temperature and density dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2018; v1 submitted 30 September, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
The induced surface tension contribution for the equation of state of neutron stars
Authors:
Violetta V. Sagun,
Ilidio Lopes,
Aleksei I. Ivanytskyi
Abstract:
We apply a novel equation of state (EoS) that includes the surface tension contribution induced by interparticle interaction and asymmetry between neutrons and protons, to the study of neutron star (NS) properties. This elaborated EoS is obtained from the virial expansion applied to multicomponent particle mixtures with hard core repulsion. The considered model is in full concordance with all the…
▽ More
We apply a novel equation of state (EoS) that includes the surface tension contribution induced by interparticle interaction and asymmetry between neutrons and protons, to the study of neutron star (NS) properties. This elaborated EoS is obtained from the virial expansion applied to multicomponent particle mixtures with hard core repulsion. The considered model is in full concordance with all the known properties of normal nuclear matter, provides a high-quality description of the proton flow constraints, hadron multiplicities created during the nuclear-nuclear collision experiments, and equally is consistent with astrophysical data coming from NS observations. The analysis suggests that the best model parameterization gives the incompressibility factor $K_{0}$, symmetry energy $J$, and symmetry energy slope $L$ at normal nuclear density equal to $200$ MeV, $30$ MeV, and $113.28-114.91$ MeV, respectively. The mass-radius relations found for NSs computed with this EoS are consistent with astrophysical observations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2019; v1 submitted 13 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Probing the tricritical endpoint of QCD phase diagram at NICA-FAIR energies
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
G. M. Zinovjev,
E. G. Nikonov,
R. Emaus,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
A. V. Taranenko
Abstract:
In this contributions we discuss the novel version of hadron resonance gas model which is based on the induced surface tension concept. Also we present new arguments in favor of a hypothesis that the chiral symmetry restoration transition in central nuclear collisions may occur at the center of mass energies 4.3-4.9 GeV and that the deconfinement phase transition may occur at the center of mass en…
▽ More
In this contributions we discuss the novel version of hadron resonance gas model which is based on the induced surface tension concept. Also we present new arguments in favor of a hypothesis that the chiral symmetry restoration transition in central nuclear collisions may occur at the center of mass energies 4.3-4.9 GeV and that the deconfinement phase transition may occur at the center of mass energies 8.8-9.2 GeV. These arguments are based on the unique thermostatic properties of the mixed phase and the ones of an exponential mass spectrum of hadrons.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Evidence of the QCD tricritical endpoint existence at NICA-FAIR energies
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
R. Emaus,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
L. V. Bravina,
D. B. Blaschke,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
E. E. Zabrodin,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
We present a summary of possible signals of the chiral symmetry restoration and deconfinement phase transitions which may be, respectively, probed at the center of mass collision energies at 4.3-4.9 GeV and above 8.7-9.2 GeV. It is argued that these signals may evidence for an existence of the tricritical endpoint of QCD phase diagram at the collision energy around 8.7-9.2 GeV. The equation of sta…
▽ More
We present a summary of possible signals of the chiral symmetry restoration and deconfinement phase transitions which may be, respectively, probed at the center of mass collision energies at 4.3-4.9 GeV and above 8.7-9.2 GeV. It is argued that these signals may evidence for an existence of the tricritical endpoint of QCD phase diagram at the collision energy around 8.7-9.2 GeV. The equation of state of hadronic matter with the restored chiral symmetry is discussed and the number of bosonic and fermionic degrees of freedom is found.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
The Flow Constraint Influence on the Properties of Nuclear Matter Critical Endpoint
Authors:
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
K. A. Bugaev,
V. V. Sagun,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin
Abstract:
We propose a novel family of equations of state for symmetric nuclear matter based on the induced surface tension concept for the hard-core repulsion. It is shown that having only four adjustable parameters the suggested equations of state can, simultaneously, reproduce not only the main properties of the nuclear matter ground state, but the proton flow constraint up its maximal particle number de…
▽ More
We propose a novel family of equations of state for symmetric nuclear matter based on the induced surface tension concept for the hard-core repulsion. It is shown that having only four adjustable parameters the suggested equations of state can, simultaneously, reproduce not only the main properties of the nuclear matter ground state, but the proton flow constraint up its maximal particle number densities. Varying the model parameters we carefully examine the range of values of incompressibility constant of normal nuclear matter and its critical temperature which are consistent with the proton flow constraint. This analysis allows us to show that the physically most justified value of nuclear matter critical temperature is 15.5-18 MeV, the incompressibility constant is 270-315 MeV and the hard-core radius of nucleons is less than 0.4 fm.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Equation of State of Quantum Gases Beyond the Van der Waals Approximation
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
E. G. Nikonov,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
A recently suggested equation of state with the induced surface tension is generalized to the case of quantum gases with mean-field interaction. The self-consistency conditions of such a model and the necessary one to obey the Third Law of thermodynamics are found. The quantum virial expansion of the Van der Waals models of such a type is analyzed and its virial coefficients are given. In contrast…
▽ More
A recently suggested equation of state with the induced surface tension is generalized to the case of quantum gases with mean-field interaction. The self-consistency conditions of such a model and the necessary one to obey the Third Law of thermodynamics are found. The quantum virial expansion of the Van der Waals models of such a type is analyzed and its virial coefficients are given. In contrast to traditional beliefs, it is shown that an inclusion of the third and higher virial coefficients of the gas of hard spheres into the interaction pressure of the Van der Waals models either breaks down the Third Law of thermodynamics or does not allow one to go beyond the Van der Waals approximation at low temperatures. It is demonstrated that the generalized equation of state with the induced surface tension allows one to avoid such problems and to safely go beyond the Van der Waals approximation. Besides, the effective virial expansion for quantum version of the induced surface tension equation of state is established and all corresponding virial coefficients are found exactly.The explicit expressions for the true quantum virial coefficients of an arbitrary order of this equation of state are given in the low density approximation. A few basic constraints on such models which are necessary to describe the nuclear and hadronic matter properties are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2018; v1 submitted 22 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Evidence of the mixed phase formation in nucleus-nucleus collisions
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko
Abstract:
Searchers for various irregularities in the behavior of thermodynamic quantities at chemical freeze-out (CFO) are rather important in a view of experimental studies of quark-gluon plasma (QGP). Using the multicomponent hadron resonance gas model (HRGM), developed in (Sagun, 2014; Bugaev et al., 2015), we performed a high-quality fit of 111 hadronic ratios measured for 14 values of the center of ma…
▽ More
Searchers for various irregularities in the behavior of thermodynamic quantities at chemical freeze-out (CFO) are rather important in a view of experimental studies of quark-gluon plasma (QGP). Using the multicomponent hadron resonance gas model (HRGM), developed in (Sagun, 2014; Bugaev et al., 2015), we performed a high-quality fit of 111 hadronic ratios measured for 14 values of the center of mass collision energies between 2.7 GeV and 200 GeV with the overall fit quality $χ^2/dof \simeq 0.95$. In addition to previously reported singularities (Bugaev et al., 2015) at CFO we found that the hadron yield ratios $\fracΛ{p}$, $\frac{K^{+}}{p}$, $\frac{K^{+}}Λ$, $\frac{Ω^{-}}{p}$ and $\frac{Ξ^{-}}{p}$ measured in central nuclear collisions demonstrate a significant change of slope in the same range of center of mass collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 4.3-4.9$ GeV (Bugaev et al., 2015). This change of slopes is accompanied by a dramatic increase of resonance decays at CFO.
Also at CFO the trace anomaly and baryonic density demonstrate the pronounced peaks at the collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 4.9 $ GeV. We argue that all these and previously found irregularities provide an evidence for the QGP formation in nuclear collisions at about $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 4.9 $ GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Geometrical Clusterization in SU(2) gluodynamics and Liquid-gas Phase Transition
Authors:
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
K. A. Bugaev,
V. V. Sagun,
D. R. Oliinychenko
Abstract:
The liquid droplet formula is applied to an analysis of the properties of geometrical (anti)clusters formed in SU(2) gluodynamics by the Polyakov loops of the same sign. Using this approach, we explain the phase transition in SU(2) gluodynamics as a transition between two liquids during which one of the liquid droplets (the largest cluster of a certain Polyakov loop sign) experiences a condensatio…
▽ More
The liquid droplet formula is applied to an analysis of the properties of geometrical (anti)clusters formed in SU(2) gluodynamics by the Polyakov loops of the same sign. Using this approach, we explain the phase transition in SU(2) gluodynamics as a transition between two liquids during which one of the liquid droplets (the largest cluster of a certain Polyakov loop sign) experiences a condensation, while another droplet (the next to the largest cluster of the opposite sign of Polyakov loop) evaporates. The clusters of smaller sizes form two accompanying gases, which behave oppositely to their liquids. The liquid droplet formula is used to analyze the size distributions of the gas (anti)clusters. The fit of these distributions allows us to extract the temperature dependence of surface tension and the value of Fisher topological exponent $τ$ for both kinds of gaseous clusters. It is shown that the surface tension coeficient of gaseous (anti)clusters can serve as an order parameter of the deconfinement phase transition in SU(2) gluodynamics. The Fisher topological exponent $τ$ of (anti)clusters is found to have the same value $1.806 \pm 0.008$. This value disagrees with the famous Fisher droplet model, but it agrees well with an exactly solvable model of nuclear liquid-gas phase transition. This finding may evidence for the fact that the SU(2) gluodynamics and this exactly solvable model of nuclear liquid-gas phase transition are in the same universality class.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2016; v1 submitted 22 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Hadron Resonance Gas Model for An Arbitrarily Large Number of Different Hard-Core Radii
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
I. P. Yakimenko,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
We develop a novel formulation of the hadron-resonance gas model which, besides a hard-core repulsion, explicitly accounts for the surface tension induced by the interaction between the particles. Such an equation of state allows us to go beyond the Van der Waals approximation for any number of different hard-core radii. A comparison with the Carnahan-Starling equation of state shows that the new…
▽ More
We develop a novel formulation of the hadron-resonance gas model which, besides a hard-core repulsion, explicitly accounts for the surface tension induced by the interaction between the particles. Such an equation of state allows us to go beyond the Van der Waals approximation for any number of different hard-core radii. A comparison with the Carnahan-Starling equation of state shows that the new model is valid for packing fractions 0.2-0.22, while the usual Van der Waals model is inapplicable at packing fractions above 0.1-0.11. Moreover, it is shown that the equation of state with induced surface tension is softer than the one of hard spheres and remains causal at higher particle densities. The great advantage of our model is that there are only two equations to be solved and it does not depend on the various values of the hard-core radii used for different hadronic resonances. Using this novel equation of state we obtain a high-quality fit of the ALICE hadron multiplicities measured at center-of-mass energies of 2.76 TeV per nucleon. Furthermore, using the traditional hadron-resonance gas model with multi-component hard-core repulsion and the novel one we investigate the recently suggested model in which the proper volume of a hadron is proportional to its mass. We find that the high-temperature maximum of $χ^2/ndf$ observed in the latter model always appears in the region located far above the limit of its applicability.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2016; v1 submitted 20 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Effects of Induced Surface Tension in Nuclear and Hadron Matter
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
K. A. Bugaiev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
I. N. Mishustin
Abstract:
Short range particle repulsion is rather important property of the hadronic and nuclear matter equations of state. We present a novel equation of state which is based on the virial expansion for the multicomponent mixtures with hard-core repulsion. In addition to the hard-core repulsion taken into account by the proper volumes of particles, this equation of state explicitly contains the surface te…
▽ More
Short range particle repulsion is rather important property of the hadronic and nuclear matter equations of state. We present a novel equation of state which is based on the virial expansion for the multicomponent mixtures with hard-core repulsion. In addition to the hard-core repulsion taken into account by the proper volumes of particles, this equation of state explicitly contains the surface tension which is induced by another part of the hard-core repulsion between particles. At high densities the induced surface tension vanishes and the excluded volume treatment of hard-core repulsion is switched to its proper volume treatment. Possible applications of this equation of state to a description of hadronic multiplicities measured in A+A collisions, to an investigation of the nuclear matter phase diagram properties and to the neutron star interior modeling are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2016; v1 submitted 21 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Separate chemical freeze-outs of strange and non-strange hadrons and problem of residual chemical non-equilibrium of strangeness in relativistic heavy ion collisions
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
J. Cleymans,
E. S. Mironchuk,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
We present an elaborate version of the hadron resonance gas model with the combined treatment of separate chemical freeze-outs for strange and non-strange hadrons and with an additional $γ_{s}$ factor which accounts for the remaining strange particle non-equilibration. Within suggested approach the parameters of two chemical freeze-outs are connected by the conservation laws of entropy, baryonic c…
▽ More
We present an elaborate version of the hadron resonance gas model with the combined treatment of separate chemical freeze-outs for strange and non-strange hadrons and with an additional $γ_{s}$ factor which accounts for the remaining strange particle non-equilibration. Within suggested approach the parameters of two chemical freeze-outs are connected by the conservation laws of entropy, baryonic charge, third isospin projection and strangeness. The developed model enables us to perform a high-quality fit of the hadron multiplicity ratios measured at AGS, SPS and RHIC with $χ^2/dof \simeq 0.93$. A special attention is paid to a successful description of the Strangeness Horn. The well-known problem of selective suppression of $\bar Λ$ and $\bar Ξ$ hyperons is also discussed. The main result is that for all collision energies the $γ_{s}$ factor is about 1 within the error bars, except for the center of mass collision energy 7.6 GeV at which we find about 20\% enhancement of strangeness. Also we confirm an existence of strong jumps in pressure, temperature and effective number of degrees of freedom at the stage of strange particle chemical freeze-out, when the center of mass collision energy changes from 4.3 to 4.9 GeV. We argue that these irregularities may signal about the quark-hadron phase transition.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
A possible evidence of observation of two mixed phases in nuclear collisions
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
G. M. Zinovjev,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
V. S. Trubnikov,
E. G. Nikonov
Abstract:
Using an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model we have found several remarkable irregularities at chemical freeze-out. The most prominent of them are two sets of highly correlated quasi-plateaus in the collision energy dependence of the entropy per baryon, total pion number per baryon, and thermal pion number per baryon which we found at center of mass energies 3.6-4.9 GeV and 7.6-10…
▽ More
Using an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model we have found several remarkable irregularities at chemical freeze-out. The most prominent of them are two sets of highly correlated quasi-plateaus in the collision energy dependence of the entropy per baryon, total pion number per baryon, and thermal pion number per baryon which we found at center of mass energies 3.6-4.9 GeV and 7.6-10 GeV. The low energy set of quasi-plateaus was predicted a long time ago. On the basis of the generalized shock-adiabat model we demonstrate that the low energy correlated quasi-plateaus give evidence for the anomalous thermodynamic properties of the mixed phase at its boundary to the quark-gluon plasma. The question is whether the high energy correlated quasi-plateaus are also related to some kind of mixed phase. In order to answer this question we employ the results of a systematic meta-analysis of the quality of data description of 10 existing event generators of nucleus-nucleus collisions in the range of center of mass collision energies from 3.1 GeV to 17.3 GeV. These generators are divided into two groups: the first group includes the generators which account for the quark-gluon plasma formation during nuclear collisions, while the second group includes the generators which do not assume the quark-gluon plasma formation in such collisions. Comparing the quality of data description of more than a hundred of different data sets of strange hadrons by these two groups of generators, we find two regions of the equal quality of data description which are located at the center of mass collision energies 4.3-4.9 GeV and 10.-13.5 GeV. These two regions of equal quality of data description we interpret as regions of the hadron-quark-gluon mixed phase formation.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
New Signals of Quark-Gluon-Hadron Mixed Phase Formation
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
E. -M. Ilgenfritz,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Here we present several remarkable irregularities at chemical freeze-out which are found using an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model. The most prominent of them are the sharp peak of the trace anomaly existing at chemical freeze-out at the center of mass energy 4.9 GeV and two sets of highly correlated quasi-plateaus in the collision energy dependence of the entropy per baryon, tot…
▽ More
Here we present several remarkable irregularities at chemical freeze-out which are found using an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model. The most prominent of them are the sharp peak of the trace anomaly existing at chemical freeze-out at the center of mass energy 4.9 GeV and two sets of highly correlated quasi-plateaus in the collision energy dependence of the entropy per baryon, total pion number per baryon, and thermal pion number per baryon which we found at the center of mass energies 3.8-4.9 GeV and 7.6-10 GeV. The low energy set of quasi-plateaus was predicted a long time ago. On the basis of the generalized shock-adiabat model we demonstrate that the low energy correlated quasi-plateaus give evidence for the anomalous thermodynamic properties inside the quark-gluon-hadron mixed phase. It is also shown that the trace anomaly sharp peak at chemical freeze-out corresponds to the trace anomaly peak at the boundary between the mixed phase and quark gluon plasma. We argue that the high energy correlated quasi-plateaus may correspond to a second phase transition and discuss its possible origin and location. Besides we suggest two new observables which may serve as clear signals of these phase transformations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Recent Results of the Hadron Resonance Gas Model and the Chemical Freeze-out of Strange Hadrons
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
E. G. Nikonov,
V. V. Sagun,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
A detailed discussion of recent results obtained within the hadron resonance gas model with the multi-component hard core repulsion is presented. Among them there are the adiabatic chemical freeze-out criterion, the concept of separate chemical freeze-out of strange particles and the effects of enhancement and sharpening of wide resonances and quark gluon bags occurring in a thermal medium. These…
▽ More
A detailed discussion of recent results obtained within the hadron resonance gas model with the multi-component hard core repulsion is presented. Among them there are the adiabatic chemical freeze-out criterion, the concept of separate chemical freeze-out of strange particles and the effects of enhancement and sharpening of wide resonances and quark gluon bags occurring in a thermal medium. These findings are discussed in order to strengthen the planned heavy-ion collision experimental programs at low collision energies. We argue, that due to found effects, at the center of mass collision energy 4-8 GeV the quark gluon bags may appear directly or in decays as new heavy resonances with the narrow width of about 50-150 MeV and with the mass above 2.5 GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2015; v1 submitted 19 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Thermodynamically Anomalous Regions and Possible New Signals of Mixed Phase Formation
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
V. V. Sagun,
I. N. Mishustin,
D. H. Rischke,
L. M. Satarov,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Using an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model we have found indications for irregularities in data for hadrons produced in relativistic heavy-ion collisions. These include an abrupt change of the effective number of degrees of freedom, a change of the slope of the ratio of lambda hyperons to protons at laboratory energies 8.6--11.6 AGeV, as well as highly correlated plateaus in the c…
▽ More
Using an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model we have found indications for irregularities in data for hadrons produced in relativistic heavy-ion collisions. These include an abrupt change of the effective number of degrees of freedom, a change of the slope of the ratio of lambda hyperons to protons at laboratory energies 8.6--11.6 AGeV, as well as highly correlated plateaus in the collision-energy dependence of the entropy per baryon, total pion number per baryon, and thermal pion number per baryon at laboratory energies 6.9-11.6 AGeV. Also, we observe a sharp peak in the dimensionless trace anomaly at a laboratory energy of 11.6 AGeV. On the basis of the generalized shock-adiabat model we demonstrate that these observations give evidence for the anomalous thermodynamic properties of the mixed phase at its boundary to the quark-gluon plasma. We argue that the trace-anomaly peak and the local minimum of the generalized specific volume observed at a laboratory energy of 11.6 AGeV provide a signal for the formation of a mixed phase between the quark-gluon plasma and the hadron phase. This naturally explains the change of slope in the energy dependence of the yield of lambda hyperons per proton at a laboratory energy of 8.6 GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2015; v1 submitted 1 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Strangeness enhancement at the hadronic chemical freeze-out
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
K. A. Bugaev,
J. Cleymans,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
I. N. Mishustin,
E. G. Nikonov
Abstract:
The chemical freeze-out of hadrons created in the high energy nuclear collisions is studied within the realistic version of the hadron resonance gas model. The chemical non-equilibrium of strange particles is accounted via the usual $γ_{s}$ factor which gives us an opportunity to perform a high quality fit with $χ^2/dof \simeq 63.5/55 \simeq 1.15$ of the hadronic multiplicity ratios measured from…
▽ More
The chemical freeze-out of hadrons created in the high energy nuclear collisions is studied within the realistic version of the hadron resonance gas model. The chemical non-equilibrium of strange particles is accounted via the usual $γ_{s}$ factor which gives us an opportunity to perform a high quality fit with $χ^2/dof \simeq 63.5/55 \simeq 1.15$ of the hadronic multiplicity ratios measured from the low AGS to the highest RHIC energies. In contrast to previous findings, at low energies we observe the strangeness enhancement instead of a suppression. In addition, the performed $γ_{s}$ fit allows us to achieve the highest quality of the Strangeness Horn description with $χ^2/dof=3.3/14$. For the first time the top point of the Strangeness Horn is perfectly reproduced, which makes our theoretical horn as sharp as an experimental one. However, the $γ_{s}$ fit approach does not sizably improve the description of the multi-strange baryons and antibaryons. Therefore, an apparent deviation of multi-strange baryons and antibaryons from chemical equilibrium requires further explanation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Separate chemical freeze-out of strange particles with conservation laws
Authors:
D. R. Oliinychenko,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
K. A. Bugaev
Abstract:
The Hadron Resonance Gas Model with two chemical freeze-outs, connected by conservation laws is considered. We are arguing that the chemical freeze-out of strange hadrons should occur earlier than the chemical freeze-out of non-strange hadrons. The hadron multiplicities measured in the heavy ion collisions for the center of mass energy range 2.7 - 200 GeV are described well by such a model. Based…
▽ More
The Hadron Resonance Gas Model with two chemical freeze-outs, connected by conservation laws is considered. We are arguing that the chemical freeze-out of strange hadrons should occur earlier than the chemical freeze-out of non-strange hadrons. The hadron multiplicities measured in the heavy ion collisions for the center of mass energy range 2.7 - 200 GeV are described well by such a model. Based on a success of such an approach, a radical way to improve the Hadron Resonance Gas Model performance is suggested. Thus, we suggest to identify the hadronic reactions that freeze-out noticeably earlier or later that most of the others reactions (for different collision energies they may be different) and to consider a separate freeze-out for them.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Bimodality as a signal of the nuclear liquid-gas phase transition
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
K. A. Bugaev
Abstract:
Here we present an explicit counterexample to a bimodality concept as the unique signal of first order phase transition. Using an exact solution of the simplified version of the statistical multifragmentation model we demonstrate that the bimodal distributions can naturally appear in infinite system without a phase transition in the regions of the negative values of the surface tension coefficient…
▽ More
Here we present an explicit counterexample to a bimodality concept as the unique signal of first order phase transition. Using an exact solution of the simplified version of the statistical multifragmentation model we demonstrate that the bimodal distributions can naturally appear in infinite system without a phase transition in the regions of the negative values of the surface tension coefficient. Also we propose a new parameterization for the compressible nuclear liquid which is consistent with the L. van Hove axioms of statistical mechanics. As a result the proposed model does not lead to the irregular behaviour of the isotherms in the mixed phase region which is typical for mean-field models. Peculiarly, the suggested approach to account for the nuclear liquid compressibility automatically leads to an appearance of an additional state that in many respects resembles the physical antinuclear matter.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Non-smooth Chemical Freeze-out and Apparent Width of Wide Resonances and Quark Gluon Bags in a Thermal Environment
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
E. G. Nikonov,
V. V. Sagun,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Here we develop the hadron resonance gas model with the Gaussian width of hadron resonances. This model allows us to treat the usual hadrons and the quark gluon bags on the same footing and to study the stability of the results obtained within different formulations of the hadron resonance gas model. In this work we perform a successful fit of 111 independent hadronic multiplicity ratios measured…
▽ More
Here we develop the hadron resonance gas model with the Gaussian width of hadron resonances. This model allows us to treat the usual hadrons and the quark gluon bags on the same footing and to study the stability of the results obtained within different formulations of the hadron resonance gas model. In this work we perform a successful fit of 111 independent hadronic multiplicity ratios measured for $\sqrt{s_{NN}} $= 2.7- 200 GeV. We demonstrate that in a narrow range of collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =$ 4.3-4.9 GeV there exist peculiar irregularities in various thermodynamic quantities found at chemical freeze-out. The most remarkable irregularity is an unprecedented jump of the number of effective degrees of freedom observed in this narrow energy range which is seen in all realistic versions of the hadron resonance gas model. Therefore, the developed concept is called the non-smooth chemical freeze-out. We are arguing that these irregularities evidence for the possible formation of quark gluon bags. In order to develop other possible signals of their formation here we study the apparent width of wide hadronic resonances and quark gluon bags in a thermal environment. Two new effects generated for the wide resonances and quark gluon bags by a thermal medium are discussed here: the near threshold thermal resonance enhancement and the near threshold thermal resonance sharpening. On the basis of the new effects we argue that the most optimistic chance to find experimentally the quark gluon bags may be related to their sharpening and enhancement in a thermal medium. In this case the wide quark gluon bags may appear directly or in decays as narrow resonances that are absent in the tables of elementary particles and that have the apparent width about 50-120 MeV and the mass about or above 2.5 GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2014; v1 submitted 16 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Bimodality Phenomenon in Finite and Infinite Systems Within an Exactly Solvable Statistical Model
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
K. A. Bugaev,
D. R. Oliinychenko
Abstract:
We present a few explicit counterexamples to the widely spread belief about an exclusive role of the bimodal nuclear fragment size distributions as the first order phase transition signal. In thermodynamic limit the bimodality may appear at the supercritical temperatures due to the negative values of the surface tension coefficient. Such a result is found within a novel exactly solvable formulatio…
▽ More
We present a few explicit counterexamples to the widely spread belief about an exclusive role of the bimodal nuclear fragment size distributions as the first order phase transition signal. In thermodynamic limit the bimodality may appear at the supercritical temperatures due to the negative values of the surface tension coefficient. Such a result is found within a novel exactly solvable formulation of the simplified statistical multifragmentation model based on the virial expansion for a system of the nuclear fragments of all sizes. The developed statistical model corresponds to the compressible nuclear liquid with the tricritical endpoint located at one third of the normal nuclear density. Its exact solution for finite volumes demonstrates the bimodal fragment size distribution right inside the finite volume analog of a gaseous phase. These counterexamples clearly demonstrate the pitfalls of Hill approach to phase transitions in finite systems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Chemical Freeze-out of Strange Particles and Possible Root of Strangeness Suppression
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
J. Cleymans,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
I. N. Mishustin,
E. G. Nikonov,
V. V. Sagun
Abstract:
Two approaches to treat the chemical freeze-out of strange particles in hadron resonance gas model are analyzed. The first one employs their non-equillibration via the usual γ_s factor and such a model describes the hadron multiplicities measured in nucleus-nucleus collisions at AGS, SPS and RHIC energies with χ^2/dof = 1.15. Surprisingly, at low energies we find not the strangeness suppression, b…
▽ More
Two approaches to treat the chemical freeze-out of strange particles in hadron resonance gas model are analyzed. The first one employs their non-equillibration via the usual γ_s factor and such a model describes the hadron multiplicities measured in nucleus-nucleus collisions at AGS, SPS and RHIC energies with χ^2/dof = 1.15. Surprisingly, at low energies we find not the strangeness suppression, but its enhancement. Also we suggest an alternative approach to treat the strange particle freeze-out separately, but with the full chemical equilibration. This approach is based on the conservation laws which allow us to connect the freeze-outs of strange and non-strange hadrons. Within the suggested approach the same set of hadron multiplicities can be described better than within the conventional approach with χ^2/dof = 1.06. Remarkably, the fully equilibrated approach describes the strange hyperons and antihyperons much better than the conventional one.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Is bimodality a sufficient condition for a first order phase transition existence?
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
D. R. Oliinychenko
Abstract:
Here we present two explicit counterexamples to the widely spread beliefs about an exclusive role of bimodality as the first order phase transition signal. On the basis of an exactly solvable statistical model generalizing the statistical multifragmentation model we demonstrate that the bimodal distributions can naturally appear both in infinite and in finite systems without a phase transition. In…
▽ More
Here we present two explicit counterexamples to the widely spread beliefs about an exclusive role of bimodality as the first order phase transition signal. On the basis of an exactly solvable statistical model generalizing the statistical multifragmentation model we demonstrate that the bimodal distributions can naturally appear both in infinite and in finite systems without a phase transition. In the first counterexample a bimodal distribution appears in an infinite system at the supercritical temperatures due to the negative values of the surface tension coefficient. In the second counterexample we explicitly demonstrate that a bimodal fragment distribution appears in a finite volume analog of a gaseous phase. In contrast to the statistical multifragmentation model, the developed statistical model corresponds to the compressible nuclear liquid with the tricritical endpoint located at one third of the normal nuclear density. The suggested parameterization of the liquid phase equation of state is consistent with the L. van Hove axioms of statistical mechanics and it does not lead to an appearance of the non-monotonic isotherms in the macroscopic mixed phase region which are typical for the classical models of the Van der Waals type. Peculiarly, such a way to account for the nuclear liquid compressibility automatically leads to an appearance of an additional state that in many respects resembles the physical antinuclear matter.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The statistical multifragmentation model for liquid-gas phase transition with a compressible nuclear liquid
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
K. A. Bugaev,
I. N. Mishustin
Abstract:
We propose a new formulation of the statistical multifragmentation model based on the analysis of the virial expansion for a system of the nuclear fragments of all sizes. The developed model not only enables us to account for short-range repulsion, but also to calculate the surface free energy which is induced by the interaction between the fragments.
We propose a new parameterization for the li…
▽ More
We propose a new formulation of the statistical multifragmentation model based on the analysis of the virial expansion for a system of the nuclear fragments of all sizes. The developed model not only enables us to account for short-range repulsion, but also to calculate the surface free energy which is induced by the interaction between the fragments.
We propose a new parameterization for the liquid phase pressure which allows us to introduce a compressible nuclear liquid into the statistical multifragmentation model. The resulting model is exactly solvable and has no irregular behavior of the isotherms in the mixed phase region that is typical for mean-field models. The general conditions for the 1-st and 2-nd (or higher) order phase transitions are formulated. It is shown that all endpoints of the present model phase diagram are the tricritical points, if the Fisher exponent $τ$ is in the range $\{3}{2} \le τ\le 2$. The treatment of nuclear liquid compressibility allows us to reduce the tricritical endpoint density of the statistical multifragmentation model to one third of the normal nuclear density. A specific attention is paid to of the fragment size distributions in the region of a negative surface tension at supercritical temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Can bimodality exist without phase transition?
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. R. Oliinychenko,
K. A. Bugaev
Abstract:
Here we present an explicit counterexample to the widely spread beliefs about an exclusive role of bimodality as the first order phase transition signal. On the basis of an exactly solvable statistical model generalizing the statistical multifragmentation model of nuclei we demonstrate that the bimodal nuclear fragment size distributions can naturally appear in infinite system without a phase tran…
▽ More
Here we present an explicit counterexample to the widely spread beliefs about an exclusive role of bimodality as the first order phase transition signal. On the basis of an exactly solvable statistical model generalizing the statistical multifragmentation model of nuclei we demonstrate that the bimodal nuclear fragment size distributions can naturally appear in infinite system without a phase transition. It appears at the supercritical temperatures due to the negative values of the surface tension coefficient. The developed statistical model corresponds to the compressible nuclear liquid with the tricritical endpoint located at one third of the normal nuclear density.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Critical exponents of the quark-gluon bags model with the critical endpoint
Authors:
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
K. A. Bugaev,
A. S. Sorin,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
The critical indices α', β, γ' and δof the Quark Gluon Bags with Surface Tension Model that has the critical endpoint are calculated and compared with the exponents of other models. These indices are expressed in terms of the most general parameters of the model. Despite the usual expectations the found critical indices do not depend on the Fisher exponent τand on the parameter \varkappa which rel…
▽ More
The critical indices α', β, γ' and δof the Quark Gluon Bags with Surface Tension Model that has the critical endpoint are calculated and compared with the exponents of other models. These indices are expressed in terms of the most general parameters of the model. Despite the usual expectations the found critical indices do not depend on the Fisher exponent τand on the parameter \varkappa which relates the mean bag surface to its volume. The scaling relations for the obtained critical exponents are verified and it is demonstrated that for the standard definition of the index α' the Fisher and the Griffiths scaling inequalities are not fulfilled in general case, whereas the Liberman scaling inequality is always obeyed. This is not surprising for the phase diagram with the asymmetric properties of pure phases, but the present model also provides us with the first and explicit example that the specially defined index α'_s does not recover the scaling relations as well. Therefore, here we suggest the physically motivated definition of the index α' = α'_c and demonstrate that such a definition recovers the Fisher scaling inequality, while it is shown that the Griffiths inequality should be generalized for the phase diagram with the asymmetric properties. The critical exponents of several systems that belong to different universality classes are successfully described by the parameters of the present model and hence its equation of state can be used for a variety of practical applications.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Can We Rigorously Define Phases in a Finite System?
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. S. Sorin,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Here we propose the generalized statistical multifragmentation model which includes the liquid phase pressure of the most general form. This allows us to get rid of the absolute incompressibility of the nuclear liquid. Also the present model employes a very general form the surface tension coefficient of nuclear fragments. Such a model is solved analytically for finite volumes by the Laplace-Fouri…
▽ More
Here we propose the generalized statistical multifragmentation model which includes the liquid phase pressure of the most general form. This allows us to get rid of the absolute incompressibility of the nuclear liquid. Also the present model employes a very general form the surface tension coefficient of nuclear fragments. Such a model is solved analytically for finite volumes by the Laplace-Fourier transform method to isobaric ensemble. A complete analysis of the isobaric partition singularities of this model is also done for finite volumes. It is shown that the real part of any simple pole of the isobaric partition defines the free energy of the corresponding state, whereas its imaginary part, depending on the sign, defines the inverse decay/formation time of this state. The developed formalism allows us to exactly define the finite volume analogs of gaseous, liquid and mixed phases of the class of similar models from the first principles of statistical mechanics and demonstrate the pitfalls of earlier works. The finite width effects for large nuclear fragments and quark gluon bags are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
The critical indices of the Quark-Gluon Bags with Surface Tension Model with tricritical endpoint
Authors:
A. I. Ivanytskyi
Abstract:
The critical indices α', β, γ' and δof the Quark Gluon Bags with Surface Tension Model with the tricritical endpoint are calculated as functions of the usual parameters of this model and two newly introduces parameters (indices). They are compared with the critical exponents of other models. It is shown that for the newly introduced indices χ= 0 and ξ^T < 1 there is a branch of solutions for which…
▽ More
The critical indices α', β, γ' and δof the Quark Gluon Bags with Surface Tension Model with the tricritical endpoint are calculated as functions of the usual parameters of this model and two newly introduces parameters (indices). They are compared with the critical exponents of other models. It is shown that for the newly introduced indices χ= 0 and ξ^T < 1 there is a branch of solutions for which the critical exponents of the present model and the statistical multifragmentation model coincide, otherwise these models belong to different universality classes. It is shown that for realistic values of the parameter \varkappa the critical exponents α', β, γ' and δof simple liquids and 3-dimensional Ising model can be only described by the branch of solutions in which all indices except for α' correspond to their values within the statistical multifragmentation model. The scaling relations for the found critical exponents are verified and it is demonstrated that for the standard definition of the index α' the Fisher and Griffiths scaling inequalities are not fulfilled for some values of the model parameters, whereas the Liberman scaling inequality is always obeyed. Although it is shown that the specially defined index α'_s recovers the scaling relations, another possibility, an existence of the non-Fisher universality classes, is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
