-
Toward a resolution of the NN controversy
Authors:
Amy Nicholson,
Evan Berkowitz,
John Bulava,
Chia Cheng Chang,
M. A. Clark,
Andrew D. Hanlon,
Ben Horz,
Dean Howarth,
Christopher Korber,
Wayne Tai Lee,
Aaron S. Meyer,
Henry Monge-Camacho,
Colin Morningstar,
Enrico Rinaldi,
Pavlos Vranasc,
Andre Walker-Loud
Abstract:
Lattice QCD calculations of two-nucleon interactions have been underway for about a decade, but still haven't reached the pion mass regime necessary for matching onto effective field theories and extrapolating to the physical point. Furthermore, results from different methods, including the use of the Luscher formalism with different types of operators, as well as the HALQCD potential method, do n…
▽ More
Lattice QCD calculations of two-nucleon interactions have been underway for about a decade, but still haven't reached the pion mass regime necessary for matching onto effective field theories and extrapolating to the physical point. Furthermore, results from different methods, including the use of the Luscher formalism with different types of operators, as well as the HALQCD potential method, do not agree even qualitatively at very heavy pion mass. We investigate the role that different operators employed in the literature may play on the extraction of spectra for use within the Luscher method. We first explore expectations from Effective Field Theory solved within a finite volume, for which the exact spectrum may be computed given different physical scenarios. We then present preliminary lattice QCD results for two-nucleon spectra calculated using different operators on a common lattice ensemble.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Detailed analysis of excited state systematics in a lattice QCD calculation of $g_A$
Authors:
Jinchen He,
David A. Brantley,
Chia Cheng Chang,
Ivan Chernyshev,
Evan Berkowitz,
Dean Howarth,
Christopher Körber,
Aaron S. Meyer,
Henry Monge-Camacho,
Enrico Rinaldi,
Chris Bouchard,
M. A. Clark,
Arjun Singh Gambhir,
Christopher J. Monahan,
Amy Nicholson,
Pavlos Vranas,
André Walker-Loud
Abstract:
Excited state contamination remains one of the most challenging sources of systematic uncertainty to control in lattice QCD calculations of nucleon matrix elements and form factors: early time separations are contaminated by excited states and late times suffer from an exponentially bad signal-to-noise problem. High-statistics calculations at large time separations $\gtrsim1$ fm are commonly used…
▽ More
Excited state contamination remains one of the most challenging sources of systematic uncertainty to control in lattice QCD calculations of nucleon matrix elements and form factors: early time separations are contaminated by excited states and late times suffer from an exponentially bad signal-to-noise problem. High-statistics calculations at large time separations $\gtrsim1$ fm are commonly used to combat these issues. In this work, focusing on $g_A$, we explore the alternative strategy of utilizing a large number of relatively low-statistics calculations at short to medium time separations (0.2--1 fm), combined with a multi-state analysis. On an ensemble with a pion mass of approximately 310 MeV and a lattice spacing of approximately 0.09 fm, we find this provides a more robust and economical method of quantifying and controlling the excited state systematic uncertainty. A quantitative separation of various types of excited states enables the identification of the transition matrix elements as the dominant contamination. The excited state contamination of the Feynman-Hellmann correlation function is found to reduce to the 1% level at approximately 1 fm while for the more standard three-point functions, this does not occur until after 2 fm. Critical to our findings is the use of a global minimization, rather than fixing the spectrum from the two-point functions and using them as input to the three-point analysis. We find that the ground state parameters determined in such a global analysis are stable against variations in the excited state model, the number of excited states, and the truncation of early-time or late-time numerical data.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2022; v1 submitted 12 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Scale setting the Möbius Domain Wall Fermion on gradient-flowed HISQ action using the omega baryon mass and the gradient-flow scales $t_0$ and $w_0$
Authors:
Nolan Miller,
Logan C Carpenter,
Evan Berkowitz,
Chia Cheng Chang,
Ben Hörz,
Dean Howarth,
Henry Monge-Camacho,
Enrico Rinaldi,
David A. Brantley,
Christopher Körber,
Chris Bouchard,
M. A. Clark,
Arjun Singh Gambhir,
Christopher J. Monahan,
Amy Nicholson,
Pavlos Vranas,
André Walker-Loud
Abstract:
We report on a sub-percent scale determination using the omega baryon mass and gradient-flow methods. The calculations are performed on 22 ensembles of $N_f=2+1+1$ highly improved, rooted staggered sea-quark configurations generated by the MILC and CalLat Collaborations. The valence quark action used is Möbius Domain-Wall fermions solved on these configurations after a gradient-flow smearing is ap…
▽ More
We report on a sub-percent scale determination using the omega baryon mass and gradient-flow methods. The calculations are performed on 22 ensembles of $N_f=2+1+1$ highly improved, rooted staggered sea-quark configurations generated by the MILC and CalLat Collaborations. The valence quark action used is Möbius Domain-Wall fermions solved on these configurations after a gradient-flow smearing is applied with a flowtime of $t_{\rm gf}=1$ in lattice units. The ensembles span four lattice spacings in the range $0.06 \lesssim a \lesssim 0.15$ fm, six pion masses in the range $130 \lesssim m_π\lesssim 400$ MeV and multiple lattice volumes. On each ensemble, the gradient-flow scales $t_0/a^2$ and $w_0/a$ and the omega baryon mass $a m_Ω$ are computed. The dimensionless product of these quantities is then extrapolated to the continuum and infinite volume limits and interpolated to the physical light, strange and charm quark mass point in the isospin limit, resulting in the determination of $\sqrt{t_0}=0.1422(14)$ fm and $w_0 = 0.1709(11)$ fm with all sources of statistical and systematic uncertainty accounted for. The dominant uncertainty in this result is the stochastic uncertainty, providing a clear path for a few-per-mille uncertainty, as recently obtained by the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal Collaboration.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021; v1 submitted 24 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Two-nucleon S-wave interactions at the $SU(3)$ flavor-symmetric point with $m_{ud}\simeq m_s^{\rm phys}$: a first lattice QCD calculation with the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method
Authors:
Ben Hörz,
Dean Howarth,
Enrico Rinaldi,
Andrew Hanlon,
Chia Cheng Chang,
Christopher Körber,
Evan Berkowitz,
John Bulava,
M. A. Clark,
Wayne Tai Lee,
Colin Morningstar,
Amy Nicholson,
Pavlos Vranas,
André Walker-Loud
Abstract:
We report on the first application of the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method for computing multi-particle interactions with lattice QCD to the two-nucleon system. Like the Laplacian Heaviside method, this method allows for the construction of interpolating operators which can be used to construct a positive definite set of two-nucleon correlation functions, unlike nearly all other applications…
▽ More
We report on the first application of the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method for computing multi-particle interactions with lattice QCD to the two-nucleon system. Like the Laplacian Heaviside method, this method allows for the construction of interpolating operators which can be used to construct a positive definite set of two-nucleon correlation functions, unlike nearly all other applications of lattice QCD to two nucleons in the literature. It also allows for a variational analysis in which optimal linear combinations of the interpolating operators are formed that couple predominantly to the eigenstates of the system. Utilizing such methods has become of paramount importance in order to help resolve the discrepancy in the literature on whether two nucleons in either isospin channel form a bound state at pion masses heavier than physical, with the discrepancy persisting even in the $SU(3)$-flavor symmetric point with all quark masses near the physical strange quark mass. This is the first in a series of papers aimed at resolving this discrepancy. In the present work, we employ the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method without a hexaquark operator in the basis at a lattice spacing of $a\sim0.086$~fm, lattice volume of $L=48a\simeq4.1$~fm and pion mass $m_π\simeq714$ MeV. With this setup, the observed spectrum of two-nucleon energy levels strongly disfavors the presence of a bound state in either the deuteron or dineutron channel.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2021; v1 submitted 24 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
$F_K / F_π$ from Möbius domain-wall fermions solved on gradient-flowed HISQ ensembles
Authors:
Nolan Miller,
Henry Monge-Camacho,
Chia Cheng Chang,
Ben Hörz,
Enrico Rinaldi,
Dean Howarth,
Evan Berkowitz,
David A. Brantley,
Arjun Singh Gambhir,
Christopher Körber,
Christopher J. Monahan,
M. A. Clark,
Bálint Joó,
Thorsten Kurth,
Amy Nicholson,
Kostas Orginos,
Pavlos Vranas,
André Walker-Loud
Abstract:
We report the results of a lattice quantum chromodynamics calculation of $F_K/F_π$ using Möbius domain-wall fermions computed on gradient-flowed $N_f=2+1+1$ highly-improved staggered quark (HISQ) ensembles. The calculation is performed with five values of the pion mass ranging from $130 \lesssim m_π\lesssim 400$ MeV, four lattice spacings of $a\sim 0.15, 0.12, 0.09$ and $0.06$ fm and multiple valu…
▽ More
We report the results of a lattice quantum chromodynamics calculation of $F_K/F_π$ using Möbius domain-wall fermions computed on gradient-flowed $N_f=2+1+1$ highly-improved staggered quark (HISQ) ensembles. The calculation is performed with five values of the pion mass ranging from $130 \lesssim m_π\lesssim 400$ MeV, four lattice spacings of $a\sim 0.15, 0.12, 0.09$ and $0.06$ fm and multiple values of the lattice volume. The interpolation/extrapolation to the physical pion and kaon mass point, the continuum, and infinite volume limits are performed with a variety of different extrapolation functions utilizing both the relevant mixed-action effective field theory expressions as well as discretization-enhanced continuum chiral perturbation theory formulas. We find that the $a\sim0.06$ fm ensemble is helpful, but not necessary to achieve a subpercent determination of $F_K/F_π$. We also include an estimate of the strong isospin breaking corrections and arrive at a final result of $F_{K^\pm}/F_{π^\pm} = 1.1942(45)$ with all sources of statistical and systematic uncertainty included. This is consistent with the Flavour Lattice Averaging Group average value, providing an important benchmark for our lattice action. Combining our result with experimental measurements of the pion and kaon leptonic decays leads to a determination of $|V_{us}|/|V_{ud}| = 0.2311(10)$.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2020; v1 submitted 10 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
The sigma meson from lattice QCD with two-pion interpolating operators
Authors:
Dean Howarth,
Joel Giedt
Abstract:
In this article we describe our studies of the sigma meson, f_0(500), using two-pion correlation functions. We use lattice quantum chromodynamics in the quenched approximation with so-called clover fermions. By working at unphysical pion masses we are able to identify a would-be resonance with mass less than $2 m_π$, and then extrapolate to the physical point. We include the most important annihil…
▽ More
In this article we describe our studies of the sigma meson, f_0(500), using two-pion correlation functions. We use lattice quantum chromodynamics in the quenched approximation with so-called clover fermions. By working at unphysical pion masses we are able to identify a would-be resonance with mass less than $2 m_π$, and then extrapolate to the physical point. We include the most important annihilation diagram, which is "partially disconnnected" or "single annihilation." Because this diagram is quite expensive to compute, we introduce a somewhat novel technique for the computation of all-to-all diagrams, based on momentum sources and a truncation in momentum space. In practice, we use only ${\bf p}=0$ modes, so the method reduces to wall sources. At the point where the mass of the pion takes its physical value, we find a resonance in the $0^{++}$ two-pion channel with a mass of approximately $609 \pm 80$ MeV, consistent with the expected properties of the sigma meson, given the approximations we are making.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2017; v1 submitted 23 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
