-
Uncertainty quantification in $(p,n)$ reactions
Authors:
A. J. Smith,
C. Hebborn,
F. M. Nunes,
R. G. T. Zegers
Abstract:
Charge-exchange reactions are versatile probes for nuclear structure. In particular, when populating isobaric analog states, these reactions are used to study isovector nuclear densities and neutron skins. The quality of the information extracted from charge-exchange data depends on the accuracy of the reaction models and their inputs; this work addresses these two points. First, we quantify the u…
▽ More
Charge-exchange reactions are versatile probes for nuclear structure. In particular, when populating isobaric analog states, these reactions are used to study isovector nuclear densities and neutron skins. The quality of the information extracted from charge-exchange data depends on the accuracy of the reaction models and their inputs; this work addresses these two points. First, we quantify the uncertainties due to effective nucleon-nucleus interactions by propagating the parameter posterior distributions of the recent global optical model KDUQ [1] to $(p,n)$ reaction observables populating the isobaric analogue state, at beam energies in the range of $25-160$ MeV. Our analysis, focusing on $^{48}$Ca, shows that the total parametric uncertainties on the cross sections are around 60-100%. The source of this uncertainty is mainly the transition operator as the uncertainties from the distorted waves alone are less than about 15%. Second, we perform a comparison between two- and three-body models that both describe the dynamics of the reaction within the DWBA. The predictions from these two models are similar and generally agree with the available data, suggesting that 1-step DWBA is sufficient to describe the reaction process. Only at a beam energy of 25 MeV there are possibly signs that a 1-step assumption is not fully correct. This work provides motivation for the quantification of uncertainties associated with the transition operator in three-body model. It also suggests that further constraint of the optical potential parameters is needed for increased model precision.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2024; v1 submitted 27 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
The role of the likelihood for elastic scattering uncertainty quantification
Authors:
C. D. Pruitt,
A. E. Lovell,
C. Hebborn,
F. M. Nunes
Abstract:
Background: Analyses of elastic scattering with the optical model (OMP) are widely used in nuclear reactions.
Purpose: Previous work compared a traditional frequentist approach and a Bayesian approach to quantify uncertainties in the OMP. In this study, we revisit this comparison and consider the role of the likelihood used in the analysis.
Method: We compare the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm…
▽ More
Background: Analyses of elastic scattering with the optical model (OMP) are widely used in nuclear reactions.
Purpose: Previous work compared a traditional frequentist approach and a Bayesian approach to quantify uncertainties in the OMP. In this study, we revisit this comparison and consider the role of the likelihood used in the analysis.
Method: We compare the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm for $χ^{2}$ minimization with Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling to obtain parameter posteriors. Following previous work, we consider how results are affected when $χ^{2}$/N is used for the likelihood function, N being the number of data points, to account for possible correlations in the model and underestimation of the error in the data.
Results: We analyze a simple linear model and then move to OMP analysis of elastic angular distributions using a) a 5-parameter model and b) a 6-parameter model. In the linear model, the frequentist and Bayesian approaches yield consistent optima and uncertainty estimates. The same is qualitatively true for the 5-parameter OMP analysis. For the 6-parameter OMP analysis, the parameter posterior is no longer well-approximated by a Gaussian and a covariance-based frequentist prediction becomes unreliable. In all cases, when the Bayesian approach uses $χ^{2}$/N in the likelihood, uncertainties increase by $\sqrt{N}$.
Conclusions: When the parameter posterior is near-Gaussian and the same likelihood is used, the frequentist and Bayesian approaches recover consistent parameter uncertainty estimates. If the parameter posterior has significant higher moments, the covariance-only frequentist approach becomes unreliable and the Bayesian approach should be used. Empirical coverage can serve as an important internal check for uncertainty estimation, providing red flags for uncertainty analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Sensitivity of one-neutron knockout observables of loosely- to more deeply-bound nuclei
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
For the last few decades, one-nucleon knockout reactions on light composite targets -- $^9$Be or $^{12}$C -- have been extensively used to study the single-particle (s.p.) structure of nuclei far from stability. To determine which information can be accurately inferred from knockout cross sections, we conduct a sensitivity analysis of these observables considering various s.p. descriptions within…
▽ More
For the last few decades, one-nucleon knockout reactions on light composite targets -- $^9$Be or $^{12}$C -- have been extensively used to study the single-particle (s.p.) structure of nuclei far from stability. To determine which information can be accurately inferred from knockout cross sections, we conduct a sensitivity analysis of these observables considering various s.p. descriptions within the usual eikonal description of the reaction. This work shows that total one-neutron knockout cross sections are not sensitive to the short-range part of the s.p. wave function. Rather, they scale with the mean square radius of the overlap function. Using a perturbative expression of the cross section, we can easily explain our numerical predictions analytically. This analysis suggests that (i) spectroscopic factors extracted from knockout data suffer from sizeable model uncertainties associated with the choice of s.p. wave functions and (ii) knockout reactions constitute an excellent probe of the radius of the nucleus and therefore offer an alternative technique to infer the neutron-skin thickness of exotic nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Impact of the $^6$Li asymptotic normalization constant onto $α$-induced reactions of astrophysical interest
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Melina L. Avila,
Konstantinos Kravvaris,
Gregory Potel,
Sofia Quaglioni
Abstract:
Indirect methods have become the predominant approach in experimental nuclear astrophysics for studying several low-energy nuclear reactions occurring in stars, as direct measurements of many of these relevant reactions are rendered infeasible due to their low reaction probability. Such indirect methods, however, require theoretical input that in turn can have significant poorly-quantified uncerta…
▽ More
Indirect methods have become the predominant approach in experimental nuclear astrophysics for studying several low-energy nuclear reactions occurring in stars, as direct measurements of many of these relevant reactions are rendered infeasible due to their low reaction probability. Such indirect methods, however, require theoretical input that in turn can have significant poorly-quantified uncertainties, which can then be propagated to the reaction rates and have a large effect on our quantitative understanding of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis processes. We present two such examples involving $α$-induced reactions, $^{13}$C($α,n)^{16}$O and $^{12}$C$(α,γ)^{16}$O, for which the low-energy cross sections have been constrained with $(^6$Li$,d)$ transfer data. In this Letter, we discuss how a first-principle calculation of $^6$Li leads to a 21% reduction of the $^{12}$C$(α,γ)^{16}$O cross sections with respect to a previous estimation. This calculation further resolves the discrepancy between recent measurements of the $^{13}$C$(α,n)^{16}$O reaction and points to the need for improved theoretical formulations of nuclear reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2024; v1 submitted 11 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
New perspectives on spectroscopic factor quenching from reactions
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Filomena M. Nunes,
Amy E. Lovell
Abstract:
The evolution of single-particle strengths as the neutron-to-proton asymmetry changes informs us of the importance of short- and long-range correlations in nuclei and has therefore been extensively studied for the last two decades. Surprisingly, the strong asymmetry dependence of these strengths and their extreme values for highly-asymmetric nuclei inferred from knockout reaction measurements on a…
▽ More
The evolution of single-particle strengths as the neutron-to-proton asymmetry changes informs us of the importance of short- and long-range correlations in nuclei and has therefore been extensively studied for the last two decades. Surprisingly, the strong asymmetry dependence of these strengths and their extreme values for highly-asymmetric nuclei inferred from knockout reaction measurements on a target nucleus are not consistent with what is extracted from electron-induced, transfer, and quasi-free reaction data, constituting a two-decade old puzzle. This work presents the first consistent analysis of one-nucleon transfer and one-nucleon knockout data, in which theoretical uncertainties associated with the nucleon-nucleus effective interactions considered in the reaction models are quantified using a Bayesian analysis. Our results demonstrate that, taking into account these uncertainties, the spectroscopic strengths of loosely-bound nucleons extracted from both probes agree with each other and, although there are still discrepancies for deeply-bound nucleons, the slope of the asymmetry dependence of the single-particle strengths inferred from transfer and knockout reactions are consistent within $1σ$. Both probes are consistent with a small asymmetry dependence of these strengths. The uncertainties obtained in this work represent a lower bound and are already significantly larger than the original estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Quantifying uncertainties due to optical potentials in one-neutron knockout reactions
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
T. R. Whitehead,
Amy E. Lovell,
Filomena M. Nunes
Abstract:
One-neutron knockout reactions have been widely used to extract information about the single-particle structure of nuclei from the valley of stability to the driplines. The interpretation of knockout data relies on reaction models, where the uncertainties are typically not accounted for. In this work we quantify uncertainties of optical potentials used in these reaction models and propagate them,…
▽ More
One-neutron knockout reactions have been widely used to extract information about the single-particle structure of nuclei from the valley of stability to the driplines. The interpretation of knockout data relies on reaction models, where the uncertainties are typically not accounted for. In this work we quantify uncertainties of optical potentials used in these reaction models and propagate them, for the first time, to knockout observables using a Bayesian analysis. We study two reactions in the present paper, the first of which involves a loosely-bound halo projectile, $^{11}$Be, and the second a tightly-bound projectile, $^{12}$C. We first quantify the parametric uncertainties associated with phenomenological optical potentials. Complementing to this approach, we also quantify the model uncertainties associated with the chiral forces that can be used to construct microscopic optical potentials. For the phenomenological study, we investigate the impact of the imaginary terms of the optical potential on the breakup and stripping components of the knockout cross sections as well as the impact of the angular range. For the $^{11}$Be case, the theoretical uncertainty from the phenomenological method is on the order of the experiment uncertainty on the knockout observables; however, for the $^{12}$C case, the theoretical uncertainty is significantly larger. The widths of the confidence intervals for the knockout observables obtained for the microscopic study and the phenomenological approach are of similar order of magnitude. Based on this work we conclude that structure information inferred from the ratio of the knockout cross sections, will carry a theoretical uncertainty of at least $20\%$ for halo nuclei and at least $40\%$ for tightly-bound nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2023; v1 submitted 12 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Ab initio investigations of A=8 nuclei: $α{-}α$ scattering, deformation in $^8$He, radiative capture of protons on $^7$Be and $^7$Li and the X17 boson
Authors:
P. Navratil,
K. Kravvaris,
P. Gysbers,
C. Hebborn,
G. Hupin,
S. Quaglioni
Abstract:
We apply the No-Core Shell Model with Continuum (NCSMC) that is capable of describing both bound and unbound states in light nuclei in a unified way with chiral two- and three-nucleon interactions as the only input. The NCSMC can predict structure and dynamics of light nuclei and, by comparing to available experimental data, test the quality of chiral nuclear forces. We discuss applications of NCS…
▽ More
We apply the No-Core Shell Model with Continuum (NCSMC) that is capable of describing both bound and unbound states in light nuclei in a unified way with chiral two- and three-nucleon interactions as the only input. The NCSMC can predict structure and dynamics of light nuclei and, by comparing to available experimental data, test the quality of chiral nuclear forces. We discuss applications of NCSMC to the $α{-}α$ scattering and the structure of $^8$Be, the p+$^7$Be and p+$^7$Li radiative capture and the production of the hypothetical X17 boson claimed in ATOMKI experiments. The $^7$Be(p,$γ$)$^8$B reaction plays a role in Solar nucleosynthesis and Solar neutrino physics and has been subject of numerous experimental investigations. We also highlight our investigation of the neutron rich exotic $^8$He that has been recently studied experimentally at TRIUMF with an unexpected deformation reported.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Perspectives on few-body cluster structures in exotic nuclei
Authors:
D. Bazin,
K. Becker,
F. Bonaiti,
Ch. Elster,
K. Fossez,
T. Frederico,
A. Gnech,
C. Hebborn,
M. Higgins,
L. Hlophe,
B. Kay,
S. König,
K. Kravvaris,
J. Lubian,
A. Macchiavelli,
F. Nunes,
L. Platter,
G. Potel,
X. Zhang
Abstract:
It is a fascinating phenomenon in nuclear physics that states with a pronounced few-body structure can emerge from the complex dynamics of many nucleons. Such halo or cluster states often appear near the boundaries of nuclear stability. As such, they are an important part of the experimental program beginning at the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB). A concerted effort of theory and experimen…
▽ More
It is a fascinating phenomenon in nuclear physics that states with a pronounced few-body structure can emerge from the complex dynamics of many nucleons. Such halo or cluster states often appear near the boundaries of nuclear stability. As such, they are an important part of the experimental program beginning at the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB). A concerted effort of theory and experiment is necessary both to analyze experiments involving effective few-body states, as well as to constrain and refine theories of the nuclear force in light of new data from these experiments. As a contribution to exactly this effort, this paper compiles a collection of ``perspectives'' that emerged out of the Topical Program ``Few-body cluster structures in exotic nuclei and their role in FRIB experiments'' that was held at FRIB in August 2022 and brought together theorists and experimentalists working on this topic.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023; v1 submitted 11 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Optical potentials for the rare-isotope beam era
Authors:
C. Hebborn,
F. M. Nunes,
G. Potel,
W. H. Dickhoff,
J. W. Holt,
M. C. Atkinson,
R. B. Baker,
C. Barbieri,
G. Blanchon,
M. Burrows,
R. Capote,
P. Danielewicz,
M. Dupuis,
Ch. Elster,
J. E. Escher,
L. Hlophe,
A. Idini,
H. Jayatissa,
B. P. Kay,
K. Kravvaris,
J. J. Manfredi,
A. Mercenne,
B. Morillon,
G. Perdikakis,
C. D. Pruitt
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We review recent progress and motivate the need for further developments in nuclear optical potentials that are widely used in the theoretical analysis of nucleon elastic scattering and reaction cross sections. In regions of the nuclear chart away from stability, which represent a frontier in nuclear science over the coming decade and which will be probed at new rare-isotope beam facilities worldw…
▽ More
We review recent progress and motivate the need for further developments in nuclear optical potentials that are widely used in the theoretical analysis of nucleon elastic scattering and reaction cross sections. In regions of the nuclear chart away from stability, which represent a frontier in nuclear science over the coming decade and which will be probed at new rare-isotope beam facilities worldwide, there is a targeted need to quantify and reduce theoretical reaction model uncertainties, especially with respect to nuclear optical potentials. We first describe the primary physics motivations for an improved description of nuclear reactions involving short-lived isotopes, focusing on its benefits for fundamental science discoveries and applications to medicine, energy, and security. We then outline the various methods in use today to build optical potentials starting from phenomenological, microscopic, and ab initio methods, highlighting in particular the strengths and weaknesses of each approach. We then discuss publicly-available tools and resources facilitating the propagation of recent progresses in the field to practitioners. Finally, we provide a set of open challenges and recommendations for the field to advance the fundamental science goals of nuclear reaction studies in the rare-isotope beam era.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023; v1 submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Green's Function Knockout Formalism
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Gregory Potel
Abstract:
Knockout nuclear reactions, in which a nucleon is removed from a nucleus as a result of the collision with another nucleus, have been widely used as an experimental tool, both to populate isotopes further removed from stability, and to obtain information about the single-particle nature of the nuclear spectrum. In order to fully exploit the experimental information, theory is needed for the descri…
▽ More
Knockout nuclear reactions, in which a nucleon is removed from a nucleus as a result of the collision with another nucleus, have been widely used as an experimental tool, both to populate isotopes further removed from stability, and to obtain information about the single-particle nature of the nuclear spectrum. In order to fully exploit the experimental information, theory is needed for the description of both the structure of the nuclei involved, and the dynamics associated with the nucleon removal mechanisms. The standard approach, using theoretical shell-model spectroscopic factors for the structure description coupled with an eikonal model of reaction, has been successful when used in the context of the removal of valence nucleons in nuclei close to stability. However, it has been argued that the reaction theory might need to be revisited in the case of exotic nuclei, more specifically for highly asymmetric nuclei in which the deficient species (neutrons or protons) is being removed. We present here a new formalism for the nucleon-removal and -addition reaction through knockout and transfer reactions, that treats consistently structure and reaction properties using dispersive optical potentials. In particular, our formalism includes the dynamical effects associated with the removal of a neutron from the projectile, which might explain the long standing puzzle of the quenching of spectroscopic factors in nuclei with extreme neutrons-to-protons ratios.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2022; v1 submitted 20 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Ab initio prediction of the $^4{\rm He}(d,γ)\,^6\rm Li$ big bang radiative capture
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Guillaume Hupin,
Konstantinos Kravvaris,
Sofia Quaglioni,
Petr Navrátil,
Peter Gysbers
Abstract:
The rate at which helium ($^4$He) and deuterium ($d$) fuse together to produce lithium-6 ($^6$Li) and a $γ$ ray, $^4$He$(d,γ)^6$Li, is a critical puzzle piece in resolving the roughly three orders of magnitude discrepancy between big bang predictions and astronomical observations for the primordial abundance of $^6$Li. The accurate determination of this radiative capture rate requires the quantita…
▽ More
The rate at which helium ($^4$He) and deuterium ($d$) fuse together to produce lithium-6 ($^6$Li) and a $γ$ ray, $^4$He$(d,γ)^6$Li, is a critical puzzle piece in resolving the roughly three orders of magnitude discrepancy between big bang predictions and astronomical observations for the primordial abundance of $^6$Li. The accurate determination of this radiative capture rate requires the quantitative and predictive description of the fusion probability across the big bang energy window ($30$ keV $\lesssim E\lesssim 400$ keV), where measurements are hindered by low counting rates. We present first-principles (or, ab initio) predictions of the $^4$He$(d,γ)^6$Li astrophysical S-factor using validated nucleon-nucleon and three-nucleon interactions derived within the framework of chiral effective field theory. By employing the ab initio no-core shell model with continuum to describe $^4{\rm He}$-$d$ scattering dynamics and bound $^6\rm Li$ product on an equal footing, we accurately and consistently determine the contributions of the main electromagnetic transitions driving the radiative capture process. Our results reveal an enhancement of the capture probability below 100 keV owing to previously neglected magnetic dipole (M1) transitions and reduce by an average factor of 7 the uncertainty of the thermonuclear capture rate between $0.002$ and $2$ GK.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2022; v1 submitted 29 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Ab initio informed evaluation of the radiative capture of protons on $^7$Be
Authors:
Konstantinos Kravvaris,
Petr Navrátil,
Sofia Quaglioni,
Chloë Hebborn,
Guillaume Hupin
Abstract:
The radiative capture of protons by $^7$Be, which is the source of $^8$B that $β$-decays emitting the majority of solar neutrinos measured on earth, has not yet been measured at astrophysically relevant energies. The recommended value for its zero-energy S-factor, $S_{17}$(0) = 20.8$\pm$(0.7)exp$\pm$(1.4)theory eV$\cdot$b, relies on theoretical extrapolations from higher-energy measurements, a pro…
▽ More
The radiative capture of protons by $^7$Be, which is the source of $^8$B that $β$-decays emitting the majority of solar neutrinos measured on earth, has not yet been measured at astrophysically relevant energies. The recommended value for its zero-energy S-factor, $S_{17}$(0) = 20.8$\pm$(0.7)exp$\pm$(1.4)theory eV$\cdot$b, relies on theoretical extrapolations from higher-energy measurements, a process that leads to significant uncertainty. We performed a set of first-principle (or, ab initio) calculations of the $^7$Be($p$, $γ$)$^8$B reaction to provide an independent prediction of the low-energy S-factor with quantified uncertainties. We demonstrate underlying features in the predicted S-factor allowing the combination of theoretical calculations and measurements to produce an evaluated S-factor of $S_{17}$(0) = 19.8$\pm$0.3 eV$\cdot$b. We expect the calculations and uncertainty quantification process described here to set a new standard for the evaluation of light-ion astrophysical reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Considering non-locality in the optical potentials within eikonal models
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Filomena M. Nunes
Abstract:
Background: For its simplicity, the eikonal method is the tool of choice to analyze nuclear reactions at high energies ($E>100$ MeV/nucleon), including knockout reactions. However, so far, the effective interactions used in this method are assumed to be fully local.
Purpose: Given the recent studies on non-local optical potentials, in this work we assess whether non-locality in the optical poten…
▽ More
Background: For its simplicity, the eikonal method is the tool of choice to analyze nuclear reactions at high energies ($E>100$ MeV/nucleon), including knockout reactions. However, so far, the effective interactions used in this method are assumed to be fully local.
Purpose: Given the recent studies on non-local optical potentials, in this work we assess whether non-locality in the optical potentials is expected to impact reactions at high energies and then explore different avenues for extending the eikonal method to include non-local interactions.
Method: We compare angular distributions obtained for non-local interactions (using the exact R-matrix approach for elastic scattering and the adiabatic distorted wave approximation for transfer) with those obtained using their local-equivalent interactions.
Results: Our results show that transfer observables are significantly impacted by non-locality in the high-energy regime. Because knockout reactions are dominated by stripping (transfer to inelastic channels), non-locality is expected to have a large effect on knockout observables too. Three approaches are explored for extending the eikonal method to non-local interactions, including an iterative method and a perturbation theory.
Conclusions: None of the derived extensions of the eikonal model provide a good description of elastic scattering. This work suggests that non-locality removes the formal simplicity associated with the eikonal model.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2021; v1 submitted 20 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Halo effective field theory analysis of one-neutron knockout reactions of $^{11}\rm Be$ and $^{15}\rm C$
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
Background: One-nucleon knockout reactions provide insightful information on the single-particle structure of nuclei. When applied to one-neutron halo nuclei, they are purely peripheral, suggesting that they could be properly modeled by describing the projectile within a Halo Effective Field Theory (Halo-EFT).
Purpose: We reanalyze the one-neutron knockout measurements of $^{11}$Be and $^{15}$C-…
▽ More
Background: One-nucleon knockout reactions provide insightful information on the single-particle structure of nuclei. When applied to one-neutron halo nuclei, they are purely peripheral, suggesting that they could be properly modeled by describing the projectile within a Halo Effective Field Theory (Halo-EFT).
Purpose: We reanalyze the one-neutron knockout measurements of $^{11}$Be and $^{15}$C-both one-neutron halo nuclei-on beryllium at about 60MeV/nucleon. We consider Halo-EFT descriptions of these nuclei which already provide excellent agreement with breakup and transfer data.
Method: We include a Halo-EFT description of the projectile within an eikonal-based model of the reaction and compare its outcome to existing data.
Results: Excellent agreement with experiment is found for both nuclei. The asymptotic normalization coefficients inferred from this comparison confirm predictions from \emph{ab initio} nuclear-structure calculations and values deduced from transfer data.
Conclusions: Halo-EFT can be reliably used to analyze one-neutron knockout reactions measured for halo nuclei and test predictions from state-of-the-art nuclear structure models on these experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2021; v1 submitted 10 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Detailed Study of the Eikonal Reaction Theory for the breakup of one-neutron halo nuclei
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
Background: One-neutron removal reactions are used to study the single-particle structure of unstable nuclei, and in particular the exotic halo nuclei. The Eikonal Reaction Theory (ERT) has been developed by Yahiro, Ogata and Minomo in Prog. Theor. Phys. 126, 167 (2011) to include dynamical effects, which are missing in the usual eikonal description of these reactions. Encouraging results have bee…
▽ More
Background: One-neutron removal reactions are used to study the single-particle structure of unstable nuclei, and in particular the exotic halo nuclei. The Eikonal Reaction Theory (ERT) has been developed by Yahiro, Ogata and Minomo in Prog. Theor. Phys. 126, 167 (2011) to include dynamical effects, which are missing in the usual eikonal description of these reactions. Encouraging results have been obtained for total breakup cross sections in comparison to more elaborate reaction models.
Purpose: We extend these comparisons to more differential breakup cross sections expressed as functions of the relative energy or parallel momentum between the core and halo neutron.
Method: ERT predictions of these cross sections are compared to state-of-the-art calculations.
Results: The hypotheses upon which the ERT is based are confirmed and their range of validity is made clearer. The actual ordering of the evolution operators {affects ERT differential} cross sections and a specific choice leads to excellent agreement with the reference calculation. Dynamical effects in the treatment of the neutron-target interaction can be significant in the parallel-momentum observable.
Conclusions: The role of the different interactions in the dynamics of breakup reactions of one-neutron halo nuclei are better understood and improvements to the ERT are suggested.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Simplified dynamical eikonal approximation
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Daniel Baye
Abstract:
Background: Breakup reactions are often used to probe the nuclear structure of halo nuclei. The eikonal model diverges for Coulomb breakup since it relies on the adiabatic approximation. To correct this weakness, a Coulomb-corrected eikonal method (CCE) using the Coulomb first-order-perturbation approximation was developed.
Purpose: Since the CCE mixes two reaction models and treats the Coulomb…
▽ More
Background: Breakup reactions are often used to probe the nuclear structure of halo nuclei. The eikonal model diverges for Coulomb breakup since it relies on the adiabatic approximation. To correct this weakness, a Coulomb-corrected eikonal method (CCE) using the Coulomb first-order-perturbation approximation was developed.
Purpose: Since the CCE mixes two reaction models and treats the Coulomb and nuclear interactions on different footings, we study here an alternative approach. We develop a simplification to the dynamical eikonal approximation (S-DEA) which has a similar numerical cost as the usual eikonal model, and study its efficiency for both nuclear- and Coulomb-dominated breakup reactions.
Methods: We compare the energy and parallel-momentum cross sections obtained with the dynamical eikonal approximation, the usual eikonal approximation, the CCE and the S-DEA.
Results: The S-DEA leads to precise energy distributions for both breakup reactions. The corresponding parallel-momentum distributions obtained with the S-DEA are improved compared to the ones computed with the eikonal model. It is more efficient for nuclear-dominated breakup than the CCE since it reproduces better the shape and magnitude of the distribution. However, for the Coulomb breakup, the distribution lacks asymmetry.
Conclusions: The simplification of the DEA developed in this work improves significantly the eikonal descriptions of breakup energy distribution for both Coulomb- and nuclear-dominated reactions. The asymmetry of the parallel-momentum distribution is enhanced for nuclear-dominated breakup. This study confirms that the asymmetry is due to dynamical effects. A direct prospect of this work would be to extend this model to two-neutron halo-nucleus projectiles.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2020; v1 submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Sensitivity of one-neutron knockout of halo nuclei to their nuclear structure
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
Halo nuclei are located far from stability and exhibit a very peculiar structure. Due to their very short lifetime, they are often studied through reactions. Breakup reactions are of particular interest since their cross sections are large for these loosely-bound nuclei. Inclusive measurements of breakup--also called knockout reactions--have even higher statistics. In this proceeding, we study whi…
▽ More
Halo nuclei are located far from stability and exhibit a very peculiar structure. Due to their very short lifetime, they are often studied through reactions. Breakup reactions are of particular interest since their cross sections are large for these loosely-bound nuclei. Inclusive measurements of breakup--also called knockout reactions--have even higher statistics. In this proceeding, we study which nuclear-structure information can be inferred from the parallel-momentum distribution of the core of one-neutron halo nuclei after the knockout of its halo neutron. In particular, we analyse the influence of the ground-state wavefunction, the presence of excited states within the halo-nucleus spectrum and resonances in the core-neutron continuum. Our analysis shows that such observables are sensitive to the tail of the ground-state wavefunction. The presence of excited state decreases the breakup strength, and this flux is transferred to the inelastic-scattering channel. This indicates a conservation of the flux within each partial wave. We also show that the parallel-momentum distributions are insensitive to the existence of resonances within the continuum, they can thus be ignored in practice. This independence on the continuum argues that the parallel-momentum distributions are ideal observables to extract very precisely the ANCs of halo nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Sensitivity of one-neutron knockout to the nuclear structure of halo nuclei
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
Background: Information about the structure of halo nuclei are often inferred from one-neutron knockout reactions. Typically the parallel-momentum distribution of the remaining core is measured after a high-energy collision of the exotic projectile with a light target.
Purpose: We study how the structure of halo nuclei affects knockout observables considering an eikonal model of reaction.
Meth…
▽ More
Background: Information about the structure of halo nuclei are often inferred from one-neutron knockout reactions. Typically the parallel-momentum distribution of the remaining core is measured after a high-energy collision of the exotic projectile with a light target.
Purpose: We study how the structure of halo nuclei affects knockout observables considering an eikonal model of reaction.
Method: To evaluate the sensitivity of both the diffractive and stripping parallel-momentum distributions to the structure of halo nuclei, we consider several descriptions of the projectile within a halo effective field theory. We consider the case of 11Be, the archetypical one-neutron halo nucleus, impinging on 12C at 68 MeV/nucleon, which are usual experimental conditions for such measurements. The low-energy constants of the description of 11Be are fitted to experimental data as well as to predictions of an ab initio nuclear-structure model.
Results: One-neutron knockout reaction is confirmed to be purely peripheral, the parallel-momentum distribution of the remaining core is only sensitive to the asymptotics of the ground-state wavefunction and not to its norm. The presence of an excited state in the projectile spectrum reduces the amplitude of the breakup cross section; the corresponding probability flux is transferred to the inelastic-scattering channel. Although the presence of a resonance in the core-neutron continuum significantly affects the energy distribution, it has no impact on the parallel-momentum distribution.
Conclusions: One-neutron knockout cross section can be used to infer information about the tail of the ground-state wavefunction, viz. its asymptotic normalization coefficient (ANC). The independence of the parallel-momentum distribution on the continuum description makes the extraction of the ANC from this observable very reliable.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2019; v1 submitted 18 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Low-energy corrections to the eikonal description of elastic scattering and breakup of one-neutron halo nuclei in nuclear-dominated reactions
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
Background: The eikonal approximation is a high-energy reaction model which is very computationally efficient and provides a simple interpretation of the collision. Unfortunately, it is not valid at energies around 10 MeV/nucleon, the range of energy of HIE-ISOLDE at CERN and the future ReA12 at MSU. Fukui etal. [Phys. Rev. C 90, 034617 (2014)] have shown that a simple semiclassical correction of…
▽ More
Background: The eikonal approximation is a high-energy reaction model which is very computationally efficient and provides a simple interpretation of the collision. Unfortunately, it is not valid at energies around 10 MeV/nucleon, the range of energy of HIE-ISOLDE at CERN and the future ReA12 at MSU. Fukui etal. [Phys. Rev. C 90, 034617 (2014)] have shown that a simple semiclassical correction of the projectile-target deflection could improve the description of breakup of halo nuclei on heavy targets down to 20 MeV/nucleon.
Purpose: We study two similar corrections, which aim at improving the projectile-target relative motion within the eikonal approximation, with the goal to extend its range of validity down to 10 MeV/nucleon in nuclear-dominated collisions, viz. on light targets. The semiclassical correction substitutes the impact parameter by the distance of closest approach of the corresponding classical trajectory. The exact continued $S$-matrix correction replaces the eikonal phase by the exact phase shift. Both corrections successfully describe the elastic scattering of one-neutron halo nuclei.
Method: We extend these corrections and study their efficiency in describing the breakup channel. We evaluate them in the case of $^{11}\mathrm{Be}$ impinging on $^{12}\mathrm{C}$ at 20 and 10 MeV/nucleon.
Results: Albeit efficient to reproduce the elastic channel, these corrections do not improve the description of the breakup of halo nuclei within the eikonal approximation down to 20 MeV/nucleon.
Conclusions: Our analysis of these corrections shows that improving the projectile-target relative motion is not the ultimate answer to extend the eikonal approximation down to low energies. We suggest another avenue to reach this goal.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2018; v1 submitted 20 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Analysis of corrections to the eikonal approximation
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
Various corrections to the eikonal approximations are studied for two- and three-body nuclear collisions with the goal to extend the range of validity of this approximation to beam energies of 10 MeV/nucleon. Wallace's correction does not improve much the elastic-scattering cross sections obtained at the usual eikonal approximation. On the contrary, a semiclassical approximation that substitutes t…
▽ More
Various corrections to the eikonal approximations are studied for two- and three-body nuclear collisions with the goal to extend the range of validity of this approximation to beam energies of 10 MeV/nucleon. Wallace's correction does not improve much the elastic-scattering cross sections obtained at the usual eikonal approximation. On the contrary, a semiclassical approximation that substitutes the impact parameter by a complex distance of closest approach computed with the projectile-target optical potential efficiently corrects the eikonal approximation. This opens the possibility to analyze data measured down to 10 MeV/nucleon within eikonal-like reaction models.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Study of corrections to the eikonal approximation
Authors:
Chloë Hebborn,
Pierre Capel
Abstract:
For the last decades, multiple international facilities have developed Radioactive-Ion Beams (RIB) to measure reaction processes including exotic nuclei. These measurements coupled with an accurate theoretical model of the reaction enable us to infer information about the structure of these nuclei. The partial-wave expansion provides a precise description of two-body collisions but has a large com…
▽ More
For the last decades, multiple international facilities have developed Radioactive-Ion Beams (RIB) to measure reaction processes including exotic nuclei. These measurements coupled with an accurate theoretical model of the reaction enable us to infer information about the structure of these nuclei. The partial-wave expansion provides a precise description of two-body collisions but has a large computational cost. To cope with this issue, the eikonal approximation is a powerful tool as it reduces the computational time and still describes the quantum effects observed in reaction observables. However, its range of validity is restricted to high energy and to forward scattering angles. In this work, we analyse the extension of the eikonal approximation to lower energies and larger angles through the implementation of two corrections. These aim to improve the treatment of the nuclear and Coulomb interactions within the eikonal model. The first correction is based on an expansion of the $T$-matrix while the second relies on a semi-classical approach. They permit to better account for the deflection of the projectile by the target, which is neglected in the standard eikonal model. The gain in accuracy of each correction is evaluated through the analyses of angular cross sections computed with the standard eikonal model, its corrections and the partial-wave expansion. These analyses have been performed for tightly bound projectiles ($^{10}\mathrm{Be}$) from intermediate energies (67 MeV/nucleon) down to energies of interest of future RIB facilities such as HIE-ISOLDE and ReA12 at MSU (10 MeV/nucleon).
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
