-
Comparison of integral equations used to study $T_{cc}^+$
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Fernando Romero-López,
Stephen R. Sharpe
Abstract:
We perform a detailed comparison between three formalisms used in recent studies of $DD^*$ scattering, which aim to understand the properties of the doubly-charmed tetraquark, $T_{cc}^+(3875)$. These methods are the three-particle relativistic field theory (RFT) formalism, the two-body Lippmann-Schwinger (LS) equation with chiral effective field theory potentials, and the two-particle relativistic…
▽ More
We perform a detailed comparison between three formalisms used in recent studies of $DD^*$ scattering, which aim to understand the properties of the doubly-charmed tetraquark, $T_{cc}^+(3875)$. These methods are the three-particle relativistic field theory (RFT) formalism, the two-body Lippmann-Schwinger (LS) equation with chiral effective field theory potentials, and the two-particle relativistic framework proposed by Baiao Raposo and Hansen (BRH approach). In a simplified single-channel setting, we derive the conditions under which the infinite-volume integral equations from the RFT and BRH approaches reduce to the LS form. We present numerical examples showing that differences between these methods can be largely removed by adjusting short-range couplings. We also address a number of technical issues in the RFT approach.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Two- and three-meson scattering amplitudes with physical quark masses from lattice QCD
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Zachary T. Draper,
Andrew D. Hanlon,
Ben Hörz,
Colin Morningstar,
Fernando Romero-López,
Stephen R. Sharpe,
Sarah Skinner
Abstract:
We study systems of two and three mesons composed of pions and kaons at maximal isospin using four CLS ensembles with $a\approx 0.063\;$fm, including one with approximately physical quark masses. Using the stochastic Laplacian-Heaviside method, we determine the energy spectrum of these systems including many levels in different momentum frames and irreducible representations. Using the relativisti…
▽ More
We study systems of two and three mesons composed of pions and kaons at maximal isospin using four CLS ensembles with $a\approx 0.063\;$fm, including one with approximately physical quark masses. Using the stochastic Laplacian-Heaviside method, we determine the energy spectrum of these systems including many levels in different momentum frames and irreducible representations. Using the relativistic two- and three-body finite-volume formalism, we constrain the two and three-meson K matrices, including not only the leading $s$ wave, but also $p$ and $d$ waves. By solving the three-body integral equations, we determine, for the first time, the physical-point scattering amplitudes for $3π^+$, $3K^+$, $π^+π^+ K^+$ and $K^+ K^+ π^+$ systems. These are determined for total angular momentum $J^P=0^-$, $1^+$, and $2^-$. We also obtain accurate results for $2π^+$, $π^+ K^+$, and $2K^+$ phase shifts. We compare our results to Chiral Perturbation Theory, and to phenomenological fits.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
QCD predictions for physical multimeson scattering amplitudes
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Zachary T. Draper,
Andrew D. Hanlon,
Ben Hörz,
Colin Morningstar,
Fernando Romero-López,
Stephen R. Sharpe,
Sarah Skinner
Abstract:
We use lattice QCD calculations of the finite-volume spectra of systems of two and three mesons to determine, for the first time, three-particle scattering amplitudes with physical quark masses. Our results are for combinations of $π^+$ and $K^+$, at a lattice spacing $a=0.063\;$fm, and in the isospin-symmetric limit. We also obtain accurate results for maximal-isospin two-meson amplitudes, with t…
▽ More
We use lattice QCD calculations of the finite-volume spectra of systems of two and three mesons to determine, for the first time, three-particle scattering amplitudes with physical quark masses. Our results are for combinations of $π^+$ and $K^+$, at a lattice spacing $a=0.063\;$fm, and in the isospin-symmetric limit. We also obtain accurate results for maximal-isospin two-meson amplitudes, with those for $π^+ K^+$ and $2K^+$ being the first determinations at the physical point. Dense lattice spectra are obtained using the stochastic Laplacian-Heaviside method, and the analysis leading to scattering amplitudes is done using the relativistic finite-volume formalism. Results are compared to chiral perturbation theory and to phenomenological fits to experimental data, finding good agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2025; v1 submitted 20 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Finite-volume quantization condition from the $N/D$ representation
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Andrew W. Jackura,
Adam P. Szczepaniak
Abstract:
We propose a new model-independent method for determining hadronic resonances from lattice QCD. The formalism is derived from the general principles of unitarity and analyticity, as encoded in the $N/D$ representation of a partial-wave two-body amplitude. The associated quantization condition relates the finite-volume spectrum to the infinite-volume numerator, $\mathcal{N}$, used to reconstruct th…
▽ More
We propose a new model-independent method for determining hadronic resonances from lattice QCD. The formalism is derived from the general principles of unitarity and analyticity, as encoded in the $N/D$ representation of a partial-wave two-body amplitude. The associated quantization condition relates the finite-volume spectrum to the infinite-volume numerator, $\mathcal{N}$, used to reconstruct the scattering amplitude from dispersive relations. Unlike the original Lüscher condition, this new formalism is valid for energies coinciding with the left-hand cuts from arbitrary one- and multi-particle exchanges.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Finite- and infinite-volume study of $DDπ$ scattering
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Fernando Romero-López,
Stephen R. Sharpe
Abstract:
We develop a comprehensive framework for extracting the pole position and properties of the doubly-charmed tetraquark $T_{\rm cc}^+(3875)$ from lattice QCD data using the relativistic three-particle formalism. This approach incorporates the effect of the one-pion exchange diagram in $DDπ$ and $DD^*$ scattering, making it applicable at energies coinciding with the left-hand cut in the partial-wave…
▽ More
We develop a comprehensive framework for extracting the pole position and properties of the doubly-charmed tetraquark $T_{\rm cc}^+(3875)$ from lattice QCD data using the relativistic three-particle formalism. This approach incorporates the effect of the one-pion exchange diagram in $DDπ$ and $DD^*$ scattering, making it applicable at energies coinciding with the left-hand cut in the partial-wave projected $DD^*$ amplitude. We present an example application of this framework to existing lattice QCD data at $m_π= 280$ MeV. We solve the integral equations describing the $DDπ$ reaction, use LSZ reduction to determine the corresponding $DD^*$ amplitude, and find the values of the infinite-volume two- and three-body $K$ matrices that lead to agreement with lattice $DD^*$ phase shifts within their uncertainties. Using these $K$ matrices in the three-particle quantization condition, we describe the finite-volume $DD^*$ spectrum and find good agreement with the lattice QCD energies. Our results suggest that, at this pion mass, the tetraquark appears as a pair of subthreshold complex poles whose precise location strongly depends on the value of the $DDπ$ three-particle $K$ matrix.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025; v1 submitted 25 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Coulomb confinement in the Hamiltonian limit
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Wyatt A. Smith,
Arkaitz Rodas,
Robert J. Perry,
César Fernández-Ramírez,
Eric S. Swanson,
Adam P. Szczepaniak
Abstract:
The Gribov--Zwanziger scenario attributes the phenomenon of confinement to the instantaneous interaction term in the QCD Hamiltonian in the Coulomb gauge. For a static quark-antiquark pair, it leads to a potential energy that increases linearly with the distance between them. Lattice studies of the SU(2) Yang--Mills theory determined the corresponding (Coulomb) string tension for sources in the fu…
▽ More
The Gribov--Zwanziger scenario attributes the phenomenon of confinement to the instantaneous interaction term in the QCD Hamiltonian in the Coulomb gauge. For a static quark-antiquark pair, it leads to a potential energy that increases linearly with the distance between them. Lattice studies of the SU(2) Yang--Mills theory determined the corresponding (Coulomb) string tension for sources in the fundamental representation, $σ_{C}$, to be about three times larger than the Wilson loop string tension, $σ_F$. It is far above the Zwanziger variational bound, $σ_C \geq σ_F$. We argue that the value established in the literature is artificially inflated. We examine the lattice definition of the instantaneous potential, find the source of the string tension's enhancement, and perform its improved determination in SU(2) lattice gauge theory. We report our conservative estimate for the value of the Coulomb string tension as $σ_C/σ_F = 2.0 \pm 0.4$ and discuss its phenomenological implications.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Analytic continuation of the finite-volume three-particle amplitudes
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid
Abstract:
One has to study multivariable scattering amplitudes to extract properties of the three-body states from the generalizations of the Lüscher finite-volume formalism. In particular, a three-body amplitude obtained from a Lattice QCD calculation must be analytically continued to unphysical Riemann sheets of the complex energy plane, where resonances of interest appear as poles. In this article, we pr…
▽ More
One has to study multivariable scattering amplitudes to extract properties of the three-body states from the generalizations of the Lüscher finite-volume formalism. In particular, a three-body amplitude obtained from a Lattice QCD calculation must be analytically continued to unphysical Riemann sheets of the complex energy plane, where resonances of interest appear as poles. In this article, we provide a pedagogical overview of a method for solving and analytically continuing the on-shell integral equations describing a three-body elastic scattering process. We illustrate the procedure by applying it to a relativistic system of three identical bosons characterized by pair-wise interactions. We describe the analytic structure of the reaction amplitude, show how to access its physical and unphysical Riemann sheets, and analyze the behavior of the three-body spectrum under variations of the interaction parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Evolution of Efimov States
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Md Habib E Islam,
Raúl A. Briceño,
Andrew W. Jackura
Abstract:
The Efimov phenomenon manifests itself as an emergent discrete scaling symmetry in the quantum three-body problem. In the unitarity limit, it leads to an infinite tower of three-body bound states with energies forming a geometric sequence. In this work, we study the evolution of these so-called Efimov states using relativistic scattering theory. We identify them as poles of the three-particle $S$…
▽ More
The Efimov phenomenon manifests itself as an emergent discrete scaling symmetry in the quantum three-body problem. In the unitarity limit, it leads to an infinite tower of three-body bound states with energies forming a geometric sequence. In this work, we study the evolution of these so-called Efimov states using relativistic scattering theory. We identify them as poles of the three-particle $S$ matrix and trace their trajectories in the complex energy plane as they evolve from virtual states through bound states to resonances. We dial the scattering parameters toward the unitarity limit and observe the emergence of the universal scaling of energies and couplings -- a behavior known from the non-relativistic case. Interestingly, we find that Efimov resonances follow unusual, cyclic trajectories accumulating at the three-body threshold and then disappear at some values of the two-body scattering length. We propose a partial resolution to this "missing states" problem.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Analytic continuation of the relativistic three-particle scattering amplitudes
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Md Habib E Islam,
Raúl A. Briceño
Abstract:
We investigate the relativistic scattering of three identical scalar bosons interacting via pair-wise interactions. Extending techniques from the non-relativistic three-body scattering theory, we provide a detailed and general prescription for solving and analytically continuing integral equations describing the three-body reactions. We use these techniques to study a system with zero angular mome…
▽ More
We investigate the relativistic scattering of three identical scalar bosons interacting via pair-wise interactions. Extending techniques from the non-relativistic three-body scattering theory, we provide a detailed and general prescription for solving and analytically continuing integral equations describing the three-body reactions. We use these techniques to study a system with zero angular momenta described by a single scattering length leading to a bound state in a two-body sub-channel. We obtain bound-state--particle and three-particle amplitudes in the previously unexplored kinematical regime; in particular, for real energies below elastic thresholds and complex energies in the physical and unphysical Riemann sheets. We extract positions of three-particle bound-states that agree with previous finite-volume studies, providing further evidence for the consistency of the relativistic finite-volume three-body quantization conditions. We also determine previously unobserved virtual bound states in this theory. Finally, we find numerical evidence of the breakdown of the two-body finite-volume formalism in the vicinity of the left-hand cuts and argue for the generalization of the existing formalism.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Snowmass white paper: Need for amplitude analysis in the discovery of new hadrons
Authors:
Miguel Albaladejo,
Marco Battaglieri,
Lukasz Bibrzycki,
Andrea Celentano,
Igor V. Danilkin,
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Michael Doring,
Cristiano Fanelli,
Cesar Fernandez-Ramirez,
Sergi Gonzalez-Solis,
Astrid N. Hiller Blin,
Andrew W. Jackura,
Vincent Mathieu,
Mikhail Mikhasenko,
Victor I. Mokeev,
Emilie Passemar,
Robert J. Perry,
Alessandro Pilloni,
Arkaitz Rodas,
Matthew R. Shepherd,
Nathaniel Sherrill,
Jorge A. Silva-Castro,
Tomasz Skwarnicki,
Adam P. Szczepaniak,
Daniel Winney
Abstract:
We highlight the need for the development of comprehensive amplitude analysis methods to further our understanding of hadron spectroscopy. Reaction amplitudes constrained by first principles of $S$-matrix theory and by QCD phenomenology are needed to extract robust interpretations of the data from experiments and from lattice calculations.
We highlight the need for the development of comprehensive amplitude analysis methods to further our understanding of hadron spectroscopy. Reaction amplitudes constrained by first principles of $S$-matrix theory and by QCD phenomenology are needed to extract robust interpretations of the data from experiments and from lattice calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Novel approaches in Hadron Spectroscopy
Authors:
JPAC Collaboration,
Miguel Albaladejo,
Lukasz Bibrzycki,
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Cesar Fernandez-Ramirez,
Sergi Gonzalez-Solis,
Astrid N. Hiller Blin,
Andrew W. Jackura,
Vincent Mathieu,
Mikhail Mikhasenko,
Victor I. Mokeev,
Emilie Passemar,
Alessandro Pilloni,
Arkaitz Rodas,
Jorge A. Silva-Castro,
Wyatt A. Smith,
Adam P. Szczepaniak,
Daniel Winney
Abstract:
The last two decades have witnessed the discovery of a myriad of new and unexpected hadrons. The future holds more surprises for us, thanks to new-generation experiments. Understanding the signals and determining the properties of the states requires a parallel theoretical effort. To make full use of available and forthcoming data, a careful amplitude modeling is required, together with a sound tr…
▽ More
The last two decades have witnessed the discovery of a myriad of new and unexpected hadrons. The future holds more surprises for us, thanks to new-generation experiments. Understanding the signals and determining the properties of the states requires a parallel theoretical effort. To make full use of available and forthcoming data, a careful amplitude modeling is required, together with a sound treatment of the statistical uncertainties, and a systematic survey of the model dependencies. We review the contributions made by the Joint Physics Analysis Center to the field of hadron spectroscopy.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022; v1 submitted 26 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Infinite volume, three-body scattering formalisms in the presence of bound states
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid
Abstract:
Strong interactions produce a rich spectrum of resonances that decay into three or more hadrons. Understanding their phenomenology requires a theoretical framework to extract parameters fromexperimental data and Lattice QCD simulations of hadron scattering. Two classes of relativistic three-body approaches are currently being pursued: the EFT-based and unitarity-based one. We consider a model of r…
▽ More
Strong interactions produce a rich spectrum of resonances that decay into three or more hadrons. Understanding their phenomenology requires a theoretical framework to extract parameters fromexperimental data and Lattice QCD simulations of hadron scattering. Two classes of relativistic three-body approaches are currently being pursued: the EFT-based and unitarity-based one. We consider a model of relativistic three-body scattering with an S-wave bound state in the two-body sub-channel using both formalisms. We present and discuss numerical solutions for the multi-hadron scattering amplitudes in different kinematical regions, obtained from integral equationsof the EFT-based approach. The connection of our work to the ongoing program of computingthe three-body spectrum from the lattice is highlighted. Finally, we show how to generalizethe unitarity-based framework to include all relevant open channels, discuss the nonphysicalsingularities near the physical region, and show how to eliminate them in a simple case.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Solving relativistic three-body integral equations in the presence of bound states
Authors:
Andrew W. Jackura,
Raúl A. Briceño,
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Md Habib E Islam,
Connor McCarty
Abstract:
We present a systematically improvable method for numerically solving relativistic three-body integral equations for the partial-wave projected amplitudes. The method consists of a discretization procedure in momentum space, which approximates the continuum problem with a matrix equation. It is solved for different matrix sizes, and in the end, an extrapolation is employed to restore the continuum…
▽ More
We present a systematically improvable method for numerically solving relativistic three-body integral equations for the partial-wave projected amplitudes. The method consists of a discretization procedure in momentum space, which approximates the continuum problem with a matrix equation. It is solved for different matrix sizes, and in the end, an extrapolation is employed to restore the continuum limit. Our technique is tested by solving a three-body problem of scalar particles with an $S$ wave two-body bound state. We discuss two methods of incorporating the pole contribution in the integral equations, both of them leading to agreement with previous results obtained using finite-volume spectra of the same theory. We provide an analytic and numerical estimate of the systematic errors. Although we focus on kinematics below the three-particle threshold, we provide numerical evidence that the methods presented allow for determination of amplitude above this threshold as well.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Bound states in the B-matrix formalism for the three-body scattering
Authors:
Sebastian M. Dawid,
Adam P. Szczepaniak
Abstract:
We consider a model of relativistic three-body scattering with a bound state in the two-body sub-channel. We show that the naïve K-matrix type parametrization, here referred to as the B-matrix, has nonphysical singularities near the physical region. We show how to eliminate such singularities by using dispersion relations and also show how to reproduce unitarity relations by taking into account al…
▽ More
We consider a model of relativistic three-body scattering with a bound state in the two-body sub-channel. We show that the naïve K-matrix type parametrization, here referred to as the B-matrix, has nonphysical singularities near the physical region. We show how to eliminate such singularities by using dispersion relations and also show how to reproduce unitarity relations by taking into account all relevant open channels.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2020; v1 submitted 15 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On the Equivalence of Three-Particle Scattering Formalisms
Authors:
A. W. Jackura,
S. M. Dawid,
C. Fernández-Ramírez,
V. Mathieu,
M. Mikhasenko,
A. Pilloni,
S. R. Sharpe,
A. P. Szczepaniak
Abstract:
In recent years, different on-shell $\mathbf{3}\to\mathbf{3}$ scattering formalisms have been proposed to be applied to both lattice QCD and infinite volume scattering processes. We prove that the formulation in the infinite volume presented by Hansen and Sharpe in Phys.~Rev.~D92, 114509 (2015) and subsequently Briceño, Hansen, and Sharpe in Phys.~Rev.~D95, 074510 (2017) can be recovered from the…
▽ More
In recent years, different on-shell $\mathbf{3}\to\mathbf{3}$ scattering formalisms have been proposed to be applied to both lattice QCD and infinite volume scattering processes. We prove that the formulation in the infinite volume presented by Hansen and Sharpe in Phys.~Rev.~D92, 114509 (2015) and subsequently Briceño, Hansen, and Sharpe in Phys.~Rev.~D95, 074510 (2017) can be recovered from the $B$-matrix representation, derived on the basis of $S$-matrix unitarity, presented by Mai {\em et al.} in Eur.~Phys.~J.~A53, 177 (2017) and Jackura {\em et al.} in Eur.~Phys.~J.~C79, 56 (2019). Therefore, both formalisms in the infinite volume are equivalent and the physical content is identical. Additionally, the Faddeev equations are recovered in the non-relativistic limit of both representations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
