-
A renormalizable theory for not-so-light nuclei
Authors:
L. Contessi,
M. Schäfer,
A. Gnech,
A. Lovato,
U. van Kolck
Abstract:
We present an improved action for Pionless Effective Field Theory (EFT). Previous formulations of renormalizable nuclear EFTs have encountered instabilities in systems with more than four nucleons. We resolve this issue by introducing a finite interaction range at leading order, which is compensated for in perturbation theory at next-to-leading order. Calculated ground-state energies of $^4$He,…
▽ More
We present an improved action for Pionless Effective Field Theory (EFT). Previous formulations of renormalizable nuclear EFTs have encountered instabilities in systems with more than four nucleons. We resolve this issue by introducing a finite interaction range at leading order, which is compensated for in perturbation theory at next-to-leading order. Calculated ground-state energies of $^4$He, $^6$Li, $^{12}$C, and $^{16}$O converge and agree with experiment within theoretical uncertainties. This first successful implementation of systematic renormalizability beyond the lightest nuclei enables not only applications to larger nuclei but also extensions to other EFTs in the strong-coupling regime.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Limits on an improved action for contact effective field theory in two-body systems
Authors:
L. Contessi,
M. Pavon Valderrama,
U. van Kolck
Abstract:
We consider a possible resummation of subleading effects in two-body systems with a large scattering length as described by a short-range effective field theory (EFT). In particular, we investigate the consequences of a resummation of part of the range corrections. Explicit calculations of the two-body phase shifts and charge form factor indicate that, except for extreme choices, resummations do n…
▽ More
We consider a possible resummation of subleading effects in two-body systems with a large scattering length as described by a short-range effective field theory (EFT). In particular, we investigate the consequences of a resummation of part of the range corrections. Explicit calculations of the two-body phase shifts and charge form factor indicate that, except for extreme choices, resummations do not alter the convergence of the EFT expansion and are often beneficial at lowest orders. We have considered the expansion when the regulator cutoff is removed as well as when it is finite, and find that the cutoff is not an important factor for resummations. Our results connect with other works where the partial resummation is induced by potentials with finite cutoffs or interaction ranges.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Improved action for contact effective field theory
Authors:
L. Contessi,
M. Schäfer,
U. van Kolck
Abstract:
We present an improved action for renormalizable effective field theories (EFTs) of systems near the two-body unitarity limit. The ordering of EFT interactions is constrained, but not entirely fixed, by the renormalization group. The remaining freedom can be used to improve the theory's convergence, to simplify its applications, and to connect it to phenomenological models. We exemplify the method…
▽ More
We present an improved action for renormalizable effective field theories (EFTs) of systems near the two-body unitarity limit. The ordering of EFT interactions is constrained, but not entirely fixed, by the renormalization group. The remaining freedom can be used to improve the theory's convergence, to simplify its applications, and to connect it to phenomenological models. We exemplify the method on a contact theory applied to systems of up to five $^4$He atoms. We solve the EFT at leading order including a subleading interaction that accounts for part of the two-body effective range. We show that the effects of such fake range can be compensated in perturbation theory at next-to-leading order, as long as the fake range is smaller or comparable to the experimental effective range. These results open the possibility of using similar improved actions for other many-body systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024; v1 submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Unitary interaction geometries in few-body systems
Authors:
Lorenzo Contessi,
Johannes Kirscher,
Manuel Pavon Valderrama
Abstract:
We consider few-body systems in which only a certain subset of the particle-particle interactions is resonant. We characterize each subset by a {\it unitary graph} in which the vertices represent distinguishable particles and the edges resonant 2-body interactions. Few-body systems whose unitary graph is connected will collapse unless a repulsive 3-body interaction is included. We find two categor…
▽ More
We consider few-body systems in which only a certain subset of the particle-particle interactions is resonant. We characterize each subset by a {\it unitary graph} in which the vertices represent distinguishable particles and the edges resonant 2-body interactions. Few-body systems whose unitary graph is connected will collapse unless a repulsive 3-body interaction is included. We find two categories of graphs, distinguished by the kind of 3-body repulsion necessary to stabilize the associated system. Each category is characterized by whether the graph contains a loop or not: for tree-like graphs (graphs containing a loop) the 3-body force renormalizing them is the same as in the 3-body system with two (three) resonant interactions. We show numerically that this conjecture is correct for the 4-body case as well as for a few 5-body configurations. We explain this result in the 4-body sector qualitatively by imposing Bethe-Peierls boundary conditions on the pertinent Faddeev-Yakubovsky~decomposition of the wave function.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Emergence of $^4$H $J^π=1^-$ resonance in contact theories
Authors:
Lorenzo Contessi,
Martin Schäfer,
Johannes Kirscher,
Rimantas Lazauskas,
Jaume Carbonel
Abstract:
We obtain the $s$- and $p$-wave low-energy scattering parameters for n$^3$H elastic scattering and the position of the $^4$H $J^π=1^-$ resonance using the pionless effective field theory at leading order. Results are extracted with three numerical techniques: confining the system in a harmonic oscillator trap, solving the Faddeev-Yakubovsky equations in configuration space, and using an effective…
▽ More
We obtain the $s$- and $p$-wave low-energy scattering parameters for n$^3$H elastic scattering and the position of the $^4$H $J^π=1^-$ resonance using the pionless effective field theory at leading order. Results are extracted with three numerical techniques: confining the system in a harmonic oscillator trap, solving the Faddeev-Yakubovsky equations in configuration space, and using an effective two-body cluster approach. The renormalization of the theory for the relevant amplitudes is assessed in a cutoff-regulator range between $1\,\text{fm}^{-1}$ and $10\,\text{fm}^{-1}$.
Most remarkably, we find a cutoff-stable/RG-invariant resonance in the $^4$H $J^π=1^-$ system. This $p$-wave resonance is a universal consequence of a shallow two-body state and the introduction of a three-body $s$-wave scale set by the triton binding energy. The stabilization of a resonant state in a few-fermion system through pure contact interactions has a significant consequence for the powercounting of the pionless theory. Specifically, it suggests the appearance of similar resonant states also in larger nuclei, like 16-oxygen, in which the theory's leading order does not predict stable states. Those resonances would provide a starting state to be moved to the correct physical position by the perturbative insertion of sub-leading orders, possibly resolving the discrepancy between data and contact EFT.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2023; v1 submitted 27 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Emergent four-body parameter in universal two-species bosonic systems
Authors:
Lorenzo Contessi,
Johannes Kirscher,
Manuel Pavon Valderrama
Abstract:
The description of unitary few-boson systems is conceptually simple: only one parameter -- the three-body binding energy -- is required to predict the binding energies of clusters with an arbitrary number of bosons. Whether this correlation between the three- and many-boson systems still holds for two species of bosons for which only the inter-species interaction is resonant depends on how many pa…
▽ More
The description of unitary few-boson systems is conceptually simple: only one parameter -- the three-body binding energy -- is required to predict the binding energies of clusters with an arbitrary number of bosons. Whether this correlation between the three- and many-boson systems still holds for two species of bosons for which only the inter-species interaction is resonant depends on how many particles of each species are in the system. For few-body clusters with species $A$ and $B$ and a resonant $AB$ interaction, it is known that the emergent $AAB$ and $ABB$ three-body scales are correlated to the ground-state binding energies of the $AAAB$ and $ABBB$ systems, respectively. We find that this link between three and four bodies is broken for the $AABB$ tetramer whose binding energy is neither constrained by the $AAB$ nor by the $ABB$ trimer. From this de-correlation, we predict the existence of a scale unique to the $AABB$ tetramer. In our explanation of this phenomenon, we understand the $AABB$ and $AAAB$/$ABBB$ tetramers as representatives of two different universal classes of $N$-body systems with distinct renormalization-group and discrete-scaling properties.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2021; v1 submitted 26 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Triple-X and beyond: hadronic systems of three and more X(3872)
Authors:
Lorenzo Contessi,
Johannes Kirscher,
Manuel Pavon Valderrama
Abstract:
The $X(3872)$ resonance has been conjectured to be a $J^{PC} = 1^{++}$ charm meson-antimeson two-body molecule. Meanwhile, there is no experimental evidence for larger, few-body compounds of multiple charm meson-antimeson pairs which would resemble larger molecules or nuclei. Here, we investigate such multi-meson states to the extent of what can be deduced theoretically from essentials of the inte…
▽ More
The $X(3872)$ resonance has been conjectured to be a $J^{PC} = 1^{++}$ charm meson-antimeson two-body molecule. Meanwhile, there is no experimental evidence for larger, few-body compounds of multiple charm meson-antimeson pairs which would resemble larger molecules or nuclei. Here, we investigate such multi-meson states to the extent of what can be deduced theoretically from essentials of the interaction between uncharged $D^{0}$ and $D^{*0}$ mesons. From a molecular $X(3872)$, we predict a $4X$ ($4^{++}$) octamer with a binding energy \mbox{$B_{4X} > 2.08\,{\rm MeV}$,} assuming a $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ system close to the unitary limit (as suggested by the mass of the $X(3872)$). If we consider heavy-quark spin symmetry explicitly, the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ ($2^{++}$) system is close to unitarity, too. In this case, we predict a bound $3X$ ($3^{++}$) hexamer with $B_{3X} > 2.29\,{\rm MeV}$ and a more deeply bound $4X$ octamer with $B_{4X} > 11.21\,{\rm MeV}$. These results exemplify with hadronic molecules a more general phenomenon of equal-mass two-species Bose systems comprised of equal number of either type: the emergence of unbound four- and six-boson clusters in the limit of a short-range two-body interaction which acts only between bosons of different species. Finally, we also study the conditions under which a $2X$ ($2^{++}$) tetramer might form.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2021; v1 submitted 27 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Multi-fermion systems with contact theories
Authors:
Martin Schäfer,
Lorenzo Contessi,
Johannes Kirscher,
Jiří Mareš
Abstract:
We address the question of minimal requirements for the existence of quantum
bound states. In particular, we demonstrate that a few-body system with zero-range momentum-independent two-body interactions is unstable against decay into clusters, if mixed-symmetry of its wave function is enforced. We claim that any theory in which the two-body scattering length is much larger than any other scale i…
▽ More
We address the question of minimal requirements for the existence of quantum
bound states. In particular, we demonstrate that a few-body system with zero-range momentum-independent two-body interactions is unstable against decay into clusters, if mixed-symmetry of its wave function is enforced. We claim that any theory in which the two-body scattering length is much larger than any other scale involved exhibits such instability. We exemplify this with the inability of the leading-order pionless effective field theory to describe stable states of $A>4$ nuclei. A finite interaction range is identified as a sufficient condition for a bound mixed-symmetry system. The minimal value of this range depends on the proximity of a system to unitarity, on the number of constituents, and on the particular realization of discrete scale invariance of the three-body spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2021; v1 submitted 22 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
B$_Λ$($^5_Λ$He) from short range effective field theory
Authors:
Lorenzo Contessi,
Nir Barnea,
Avraham Gal
Abstract:
We present an effective field theory (EFT) at leading order to describe light single-$Λ$ hypernuclei. Owing to the weak $Λ$ binding and to the $ΛN$ short interaction range, meson exchange forces are approximated by contact interactions within a pionless EFT where the only degrees of freedom are baryons. At leading order, the $Λ$-nuclear interaction contains two 2-body (singlet and triplet) and thr…
▽ More
We present an effective field theory (EFT) at leading order to describe light single-$Λ$ hypernuclei. Owing to the weak $Λ$ binding and to the $ΛN$ short interaction range, meson exchange forces are approximated by contact interactions within a pionless EFT where the only degrees of freedom are baryons. At leading order, the $Λ$-nuclear interaction contains two 2-body (singlet and triplet) and three 3-body interaction terms, a total of 5 terms associated with 5 coupling strengths or low energy constants (LECs). We adopt the 2-body LECs from hyperon-nucleon scattering data and interaction models that constrain the $ΛN$ scattering lengths, while the 3-body LECs are adjusted using both 3-body and 4-body hypernuclear binding energies. To calculate the binding energies for A-body systems with A$>$2, we expand the wavefunctions using a correlated Gaussian basis. The stochastic variational method is employed to select the non-linear parameters. The resulting \nopieft~is then applied to calculate the $Λ$ separation energy in $_Λ^5$He, where the adjusted 3-body interactions largely resolve the known overbinding problem of $_Λ^5$He.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
The onset of $ΛΛ$ hypernuclear binding
Authors:
L. Contessi,
M. Schäfer,
N. Barnea,
A. Gal,
J. Mareš
Abstract:
Binding energies of light, $A\leq 6$, $ΛΛ$ hypernuclei are calculated using the stochastic variational method in a pionless effective field theory (EFT) approach at leading order with the purpose of assessing critically the onset of binding in the strangeness S=-2 hadronic sector. The EFT input in this sector consists of (i) a $ΛΛ$ contact term constrained by the $ΛΛ$ scattering length $a_{ΛΛ}$, u…
▽ More
Binding energies of light, $A\leq 6$, $ΛΛ$ hypernuclei are calculated using the stochastic variational method in a pionless effective field theory (EFT) approach at leading order with the purpose of assessing critically the onset of binding in the strangeness S=-2 hadronic sector. The EFT input in this sector consists of (i) a $ΛΛ$ contact term constrained by the $ΛΛ$ scattering length $a_{ΛΛ}$, using a range of values compatible with $ΛΛ$ correlations observed in relativistic heavy ion collisions, and (ii) a $ΛΛN$ contact term constrained by the only available $A\leq 6$ $ΛΛ$ hypernucler binding energy datum of $^{6}_{ΛΛ}$He. The recently debated neutral three-body and four-body systems $^{3}_{ΛΛ}$n and $^{4}_{ΛΛ}$n are found unbound by a wide margin. A relatively large value of $|a_{ΛΛ}| \gtrsim 1.5$ fm is needed to bind $^{4}_{ΛΛ}$H, thereby questioning its particle stability. In contrast, the particle stability of the $A=5$ $ΛΛ$ hypernuclear isodoublet $^{5}_{ΛΛ} $H--$^{5}_{ΛΛ}$He is robust, with $Λ$ separation energy of order 1 MeV.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2019; v1 submitted 16 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Resolving the $Λ$ hypernuclear overbinding problem in pionless effective field theory
Authors:
Lorenzo Contessi,
Nir Barnea,
Avraham Gal
Abstract:
We address the $Λ$-hypernuclear `overbinding problem' in light hypernuclei which stands for a 1--3 MeV excessive $Λ$ separation energy calculated in $_Λ^5$He. This problem arises in most few-body calculations that reproduce ground-state $Λ$ separation energies in the lighter $Λ$ hypernuclei within various hyperon-nucleon interaction models. Recent pionless effective field theory nuclear few-body c…
▽ More
We address the $Λ$-hypernuclear `overbinding problem' in light hypernuclei which stands for a 1--3 MeV excessive $Λ$ separation energy calculated in $_Λ^5$He. This problem arises in most few-body calculations that reproduce ground-state $Λ$ separation energies in the lighter $Λ$ hypernuclei within various hyperon-nucleon interaction models. Recent pionless effective field theory nuclear few-body calculations are extended in this work to $Λ$ hypernuclei. At leading order, the $ΛN$ low-energy constants are associated with $ΛN$ scattering lengths and the $ΛNN$ low-energy constants are fitted to $Λ$ separation energies ($B_Λ^{\rm exp}$) for $A\leq 4$. The resulting pionless-EFT interaction reproduces in few-body stochastic variational method calculations the reported value $B_Λ^{\rm exp}(_Λ^5 $He)=3.12$\pm$0.02 MeV within a fraction of MeV over a broad range of momentum-space cut-off parameters. Possible consequences and extensions to heavier hypernuclei and to neutron-star matter are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2018; v1 submitted 11 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Ground-State Properties of $^{4}$He and $^{16}$O Extrapolated from Lattice QCD with Pionless EFT
Authors:
L. Contessi,
A. Lovato,
F. Pederiva,
A. Roggero,
J. Kirscher,
U. van Kolck
Abstract:
We extend the prediction range of Pionless Effective Field Theory with an analysis of the ground state of $^{16}$O in leading order. To renormalize the theory, we use as input both experimental data and lattice QCD predictions of nuclear observables, which probe the sensitivity of nuclei to increased quark masses. The nuclear many-body Schrödinger equation is solved with the Auxiliary Field Diffus…
▽ More
We extend the prediction range of Pionless Effective Field Theory with an analysis of the ground state of $^{16}$O in leading order. To renormalize the theory, we use as input both experimental data and lattice QCD predictions of nuclear observables, which probe the sensitivity of nuclei to increased quark masses. The nuclear many-body Schrödinger equation is solved with the Auxiliary Field Diffusion Monte Carlo method. For the first time in a nuclear quantum Monte Carlo calculation, a linear optimization procedure, which allows us to devise an accurate trial wave function with a large number of variational parameters, is adopted. The method yields a binding energy of $^{4}$He which is in good agreement with experiment at physical pion mass and with lattice calculations at larger pion masses. At leading order we do not find any evidence of a $^{16}$O state which is stable against breakup into four $^4$He, although higher-order terms could bind $^{16}$O.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Effective Field Theory for Lattice Nuclei
Authors:
N. Barnea,
L. Contessi,
D. Gazit,
F. Pederiva,
U. van Kolck
Abstract:
We show how nuclear effective field theory (EFT) and ab initio nuclear-structure methods can turn input from lattice quantum chromodynamics (LQCD) into predictions for the properties of nuclei. We argue that pionless EFT is the appropriate theory to describe the light nuclei obtained in recent LQCD simulations carried out at pion masses much heavier than the physical pion mass. We solve the EFT us…
▽ More
We show how nuclear effective field theory (EFT) and ab initio nuclear-structure methods can turn input from lattice quantum chromodynamics (LQCD) into predictions for the properties of nuclei. We argue that pionless EFT is the appropriate theory to describe the light nuclei obtained in recent LQCD simulations carried out at pion masses much heavier than the physical pion mass. We solve the EFT using the effective-interaction hyperspherical harmonics and auxiliary-field diffusion Monte Carlo methods. Fitting the three leading-order EFT parameters to the deuteron, dineutron and triton LQCD energies at $m_π\approx 800$ MeV, we reproduce the corresponding alpha-particle binding and predict the binding energies of mass-5 and 6 ground states.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
