Showing 1–50 of 118 results for author: Cohen, T

Gauge invariance and color charge fluctuations

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: The nature of confinement is connected with color charge. Unfortunately, the color charge densities in QCD, the Noether charge densities associated with the global color invariance, are not invariant under local color rotations. This implies that the expectation values of the net color charge in any region of any physical state in QCD, states that satisfy the color Gauss law, are automatically zer… ▽ More The nature of confinement is connected with color charge. Unfortunately, the color charge densities in QCD, the Noether charge densities associated with the global color invariance, are not invariant under local color rotations. This implies that the expectation values of the net color charge in any region of any physical state in QCD, states that satisfy the color Gauss law, are automatically zero for all components of color. In this paper it is shown that the expectation value of the square of the net color charge in a region, a measure of the color charge fluctuations, is necessarily nonzero when evaluated in physical states and the result, while depending on the scheme and scale by which the theory is regulated, is gauge invariant. This holds despite the formal lack of gauge invariance of the operator. Moreover, there is a particular combination of the color charge fluctuations for the vacuum and for a system describable by a non-trivial density matrix that is independent that has a well-defined continuum limit △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Comments: 4 pages

Numerical study of computational cost of maintaining adiabaticity for long paths

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Hyunwoo Oh, Veronica Wang

Abstract: Recent work argued that the scaling of a dimensionless quantity $Q_D$ with path length is a better proxy for quantifying the scaling of the computational cost of maintaining adiabaticity than the timescale. It also conjectured that generically the scaling will be superlinear (although special cases exist in which it is linear). The quantity $Q_D$ depends only on the properties of ground states alo… ▽ More Recent work argued that the scaling of a dimensionless quantity $Q_D$ with path length is a better proxy for quantifying the scaling of the computational cost of maintaining adiabaticity than the timescale. It also conjectured that generically the scaling will be superlinear (although special cases exist in which it is linear). The quantity $Q_D$ depends only on the properties of ground states along the Hamiltonian path and the rate at which the path is followed. In this paper, we demonstrate that this conjecture holds for simple Hamiltonian systems that can be studied numerically. In particular, the systems studied exhibit the behavior that $Q_D$ grows approximately as $L \log L$ where $L$ is the path length when the threshold error is fixed. △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2025; v1 submitted 11 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures

The Hypertriton Puzzle in Relativistic Heavy-Ion Collisions

Authors: Thomas Cohen, Maneesha Pradeep

Abstract: The yields of hadrons and light nuclei in relativistic collisions of heavy-nuclei at a center of mass energy of 2.6 TeV can be described remarkably well by a thermal distribution of an ideal gas of hadrons and light nuclei interacting only via the decay of resonances. Given the particularly small binding energy of hypertritons relative to the temperature describing the yields (about 156 MeV), one… ▽ More The yields of hadrons and light nuclei in relativistic collisions of heavy-nuclei at a center of mass energy of 2.6 TeV can be described remarkably well by a thermal distribution of an ideal gas of hadrons and light nuclei interacting only via the decay of resonances. Given the particularly small binding energy of hypertritons relative to the temperature describing the yields (about 156 MeV), one might naturally expect hypertrions to dissociate in medium, making the agreement of hypertriton yields with thermal predictions highly puzzling. The puzzle is compounded by the fact that small binding energy is associated with the large size of the hypertriton. This size is on a similar scale to the overall size of the fireball and much larger than the length scale over which temperatures in the fireball vary over phenomenologically relevant amounts. This paper quantifies the tension this effect causes and shows that it is sufficiently large to render the thermal model inconsistent: its natural assumptions are in conflict with its outputs. The possibility that hypertritons are formed at freeze out as compact objects, quark droplets, that subsequently evolve into hypertritons is considered as a way to resolve the puzzle. It is noted that beyond making the assumption that compact quark droplets form, additional detailed dynamical assumptions which have not been justified are needed to make the thermal model work. The issue of why, despite these issues, the hypertriton is well described by a simple statistical description at freeze out is unresolved. Resolving the hypertriton puzzle is important as it may clarify whether the phenomenological success of the simple thermal model for yields accurately reflects the simple picture of the underlying physics on which it is based. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: 21 pages

Corrections to adiabatic behavior for long paths

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Hyunwoo Oh

Abstract: The cost and the error of the adiabatic theorem for preparing the final eigenstate are discussed in terms of path length. Previous studies in terms of the norm of the Hamiltonian and its derivatives with the spectral gap are limited in their ability to describe the cost of adiabatic state preparation for certain physically large systems. We argue that total time is not a good measure for determini… ▽ More The cost and the error of the adiabatic theorem for preparing the final eigenstate are discussed in terms of path length. Previous studies in terms of the norm of the Hamiltonian and its derivatives with the spectral gap are limited in their ability to describe the cost of adiabatic state preparation for certain physically large systems. We argue that total time is not a good measure for determining the computational difficulty of adiabatic quantum computation by developing a no-go theorem. From the result of time-periodic Hamiltonian cases, we suggest that there are proxies for computational cost which typically grow as path length increases when the error is kept fixed and small and consider possible conjectures on how general the behavior is. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2024; v1 submitted 16 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 11 pages, 0 figures

Zeno Effect Suppression of Gauge Drift in Quantum Simulations

Authors: Carter Ball, Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: Quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories is a promising tool for the study of many complicated problems including ones with real-time dynamics. For gauge theories, however, there is a major challenge in maintaining gauge invariance during time evolution. Such theories have a full Hilbert space that is larger than the physical space -- the set of states which are gauge invariant or equivalently… ▽ More Quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories is a promising tool for the study of many complicated problems including ones with real-time dynamics. For gauge theories, however, there is a major challenge in maintaining gauge invariance during time evolution. Such theories have a full Hilbert space that is larger than the physical space -- the set of states which are gauge invariant or equivalently respect the Gauss law. While an exact implementation of Hamiltonian dynamics starting in the physical Hilbert space will keep the system in the physical space, various types of errors will inevitably produce components outside of it. This work proposes a method of suppressing this gauge drift via the Zeno effect. As in the standard picture of the Zeno effect, our method relies on frequent projection onto the physical subspace. Additionally, a technique is discussed to reduce the speed of the gauge drift, which helps to reduce the required frequency of projections. We demonstrate our method on a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ gauge theory toy model. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2024; v1 submitted 15 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

On interpretation of fluctuations of conserved charges at high T

Authors: T. D. Cohen, L. Ya. Glozman

Abstract: Fluctuations of conserved charges calculated on the lattice which can be measured experimentally, are well reproduced by a hadron resonanse gas model at temperatures below T_{ch} ~ 155 MeV and radically deviate from the hadron resonance gas predictions above the chiral restoration crossover. This behavior is typically interpreted as an indication of deconfinement in the quark-gluon plasma regime.… ▽ More Fluctuations of conserved charges calculated on the lattice which can be measured experimentally, are well reproduced by a hadron resonanse gas model at temperatures below T_{ch} ~ 155 MeV and radically deviate from the hadron resonance gas predictions above the chiral restoration crossover. This behavior is typically interpreted as an indication of deconfinement in the quark-gluon plasma regime. We present an argument that this interpretation may be too simple. The argument is based on the scaling of quantities with the number of colors: demonstration of deconfinement and QGP requires observable that is sensitive to N_c^2 gluons while the conserved charges are sensitive only to quarks and above T_{ch} scale as N_c^1. The latter scaling is consistent with the existence of an intermediate regime characterized by restored chiral symmetry and by approximate chiral spin symmetry which is a symmetry of confining interaction. In this regime the energy density, pressure and entropy density scale as N_c^1. In the large N_c limit this regime might become a distinct phase separated from the hadron gas and from QGP by phase transitions. A natural observable that associates with deconfinement and is directly sensitive to deconfined N_c^2-1 gluons is the Polyakov loop; in the N_c=3 world it remains very close to 0 at temperatures well above chiral crossover, reaches the value 0.5 around 3T_{ch} and the value close to 1 at temperatures ~1 GeV. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2024; v1 submitted 8 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 5 pages; final version accepted by EPJA

Large $N_c$ QCD phase diagram at $μ_B = 0$

Authors: T. D. Cohen, L. Ya. Glozman

Abstract: Lattice studies suggest that at zero baryon chemical potential and increasing temperature there are three characteristic regimes in QCD that are connected by smooth analytical crossovers: a hadron gas regime at T < T_ch ~ 155 MeV, an intermediate regime, called stringy fluid, at T_ch < T < ~ 3 T_ch, and a quark-gluon plasma regime at higher temperatures. These regimes have been interpreted to refl… ▽ More Lattice studies suggest that at zero baryon chemical potential and increasing temperature there are three characteristic regimes in QCD that are connected by smooth analytical crossovers: a hadron gas regime at T < T_ch ~ 155 MeV, an intermediate regime, called stringy fluid, at T_ch < T < ~ 3 T_ch, and a quark-gluon plasma regime at higher temperatures. These regimes have been interpreted to reflect different approximate symmetries and effective degrees of freedom. In the hadron gas the effective degrees of freedom are hadrons and the approximate chiral symmetry of QCD is spontaneously broken. The intermediate regime has been interpreted as lacking spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking along with the emergence of new approximate symmetry, chiral spin symmetry, that is not a symmetry of the Dirac Lagrangian, but is a symmetry of the confining part of the QCD Lagrangian. While the high temperature regime is the usual quark-gluon plasma which is often considered to reflect "deconfinement" in some way. This paper explores the behavior of these regimes of QCD as the number of colors in the theory, N_c, gets large. In the large N_c limit the theory is center-symmetric and notions of confinement and deconfinement are unambiguous. The energy density is O(N_c^0) in the meson gas, O(N_c^1) in the intermediate regime and O(N_c^2) in the quark-gluon plasma regime. In the large N_c limit these regimes may become distinct phases separated by first order phase transitions. The intermediate phase has the peculiar feature that glueballs should exist and have properties that are unchanged from what is seen in the vacuum (up to 1/N_c corrections), while the ordinary dilute gas of mesons with broken chiral symmetry disappears and approximate chiral spin symmetry should emerge. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2024; v1 submitted 13 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 10 pages. Final version accepted by EPJA

Efficient vacuum state preparation for quantum simulation of strongly interacting local quantum field theories

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Hyunwoo Oh

Abstract: We present an efficient approach for preparing ground states in the context of strongly interacting local quantum field theories on quantum computers. The approach produces the vacuum state in a time proportional to the square-root of the volume, which is a square-root improvement in speed compared to traditional approaches. The approach exploits a novel method for traversing the path in parameter… ▽ More We present an efficient approach for preparing ground states in the context of strongly interacting local quantum field theories on quantum computers. The approach produces the vacuum state in a time proportional to the square-root of the volume, which is a square-root improvement in speed compared to traditional approaches. The approach exploits a novel method for traversing the path in parameter space in which the resources scale linearly with a path length suitably defined in parameter space. Errors due to practical limitations are controlled and do not exhibit secular growth along the path. The final accuracy can be arbitrarily improved with an additive cost, which is independent of the volume and grows slower than logarithmically with the overlap between the state produced and the exact ground state. We expect that the method could potentially hold practical value not only within the realm of quantum field theories but also in addressing other challenges involving long path lengths. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2024; v1 submitted 29 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

Optimizing rodeo projection

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Hyunwoo Oh

Abstract: The rodeo algorithm has been proposed recently as an efficient method in quantum computing for projection of a given initial state onto a state of fixed energy for systems with discrete spectra. In the initial formulation of the rodeo algorithm these times were chosen randomly via a Gaussian distribution with fixed RMS times. In this paper it is shown that such a random approach for choosing times… ▽ More The rodeo algorithm has been proposed recently as an efficient method in quantum computing for projection of a given initial state onto a state of fixed energy for systems with discrete spectra. In the initial formulation of the rodeo algorithm these times were chosen randomly via a Gaussian distribution with fixed RMS times. In this paper it is shown that such a random approach for choosing times suffers from exponentially large fluctuations in the suppression of unwanted components: as the number of iterations gets large, the distribution of suppression factors obtained from random selection approaches a log-normal distribution leading to remarkably large fluctuations. We note that by choosing times intentionally rather than randomly such fluctuations can be avoided and strict upper bounds on the suppression can be obtained. Moreover, the average suppression using fixed computational cost can be reduced by many orders of magnitude relative to the random algorithm. A key to doing this is to choose times that vary over exponentially many times scales, starting from a modest maximum scale and going down to time scales exponentially smaller. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2023; v1 submitted 31 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 17 pages, 6 figures

Boltzmann Distributions on a Quantum Computer via Active Cooling

Authors: Carter Ball, Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: Quantum computing raises the possibility of solving a variety of problems in physics that are presently intractable. A number of such problems involves the physics of systems in or near thermal equilibrium. There are two main ways to compute thermal expectation values on a quantum computer: construct a thermal state that reproduces thermal expectation values, or sample various energy eigenstates f… ▽ More Quantum computing raises the possibility of solving a variety of problems in physics that are presently intractable. A number of such problems involves the physics of systems in or near thermal equilibrium. There are two main ways to compute thermal expectation values on a quantum computer: construct a thermal state that reproduces thermal expectation values, or sample various energy eigenstates from a Boltzmann distribution of a given temperature. In this paper we address the second approach and propose an algorithm that uses active cooling to produce the distribution. While this algorithm is quite general and applicable to a wide variety of systems, it was developed with the specific intention of simulating thermal configurations of non-Abelian gauge theories such as QCD, which would allow the study of quark-gluon plasma created in heavy-ion collisions. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2023; v1 submitted 13 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Pure gauge theories and spatial periodicity

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: Properties of pure gauge theories in thermal equilibrium as calculated via standard functional integral treatments are mathematically identical to ground state properties of a theory with spatially-periodic boundary conditions imposed on the gauge fields. Such a theory has states that have no analog in a theory in which only physical observables associated with gauge-invariant operators are requir… ▽ More Properties of pure gauge theories in thermal equilibrium as calculated via standard functional integral treatments are mathematically identical to ground state properties of a theory with spatially-periodic boundary conditions imposed on the gauge fields. Such a theory has states that have no analog in a theory in which only physical observables associated with gauge-invariant operators are required to be periodic, rather than the gauge fields themselves; these states are in topological sectors that do not exist in the unconstrained theory. The topology arises because the boundary conditions in the functional integral are gauge invariant on a cylinder but not in the unconstrained theory. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2022; v1 submitted 17 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Quantum algorithms for transport coefficients in gauge theories

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Henry Lamm, Scott Lawrence, Yukari Yamauchi

Abstract: In the future, ab initio quantum simulations of heavy ion collisions may become possible with large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computers. We propose a quantum algorithm for studying these collisions by looking at a class of observables requiring dramatically smaller volumes: transport coefficients. These form nonperturbative inputs into theoretical models of heavy ions; thus, their calculation r… ▽ More In the future, ab initio quantum simulations of heavy ion collisions may become possible with large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computers. We propose a quantum algorithm for studying these collisions by looking at a class of observables requiring dramatically smaller volumes: transport coefficients. These form nonperturbative inputs into theoretical models of heavy ions; thus, their calculation reduces theoretical uncertainties without the need for a full-scale simulation of the collision. We derive the necessary lattice operators in the Hamiltonian formulation and describe how to obtain them on quantum computers. Additionally, we discuss ways to efficiently prepare the relevant thermal state of a gauge theory. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Report number: FERMILAB-PUB-21-091-T

The thermodynamics of large-N QCD and the nature of metastable phases

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Scott Lawrence, Yukari Yamauchi

Abstract: In the limit of a large number of colors (N), both Yang-Mills and quantum chromodynamics are expected to have a first-order phase transition separating a confined hadronic phase and a deconfined plasma phase. One aspect of this separation is that at large N, one can unambiguously identify a plasma regime that is strongly coupled. The existence of a first-order transition suggests that the hadronic… ▽ More In the limit of a large number of colors (N), both Yang-Mills and quantum chromodynamics are expected to have a first-order phase transition separating a confined hadronic phase and a deconfined plasma phase. One aspect of this separation is that at large N, one can unambiguously identify a plasma regime that is strongly coupled. The existence of a first-order transition suggests that the hadronic phase can be superheated and the plasma phase supercooled. The supercooled deconfined plasma present at large N, if it exists, has the remarkable property that it has negative absolute pressure -- i.e. a pressure below that of the vacuum. For energy densities of order unity in a 1/N expansion but beyond the endpoint of the hadronic superheated phase, a description of homogeneous matter composed of ordinary hadrons with masses of order unity in a 1/N expansion can exist, and acts as though it has a temperature of $T_H$ in order unity. However, the connection between the canonical and microcanonical descriptions breaks down and the system cannot fully equilibrate as $N \rightarrow \infty$. Rather, in a hadronic description, energy is pushed to hadrons with masses that are arbitrarily large. The thermodynamic limit of large volumes becomes subtle for such systems: the energy density is no longer intensive. These conclusions follow provided that standard large N scaling rules hold, the system at large N undergoes a generic first-order phase transition between the hadronic and plasma phases and that the mesons and glueballs follow a Hagedorn-type spectrum. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2021; v1 submitted 25 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures; version for PRC

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 102, 065206 (2020)

A Somewhat Random Walk Through Nuclear and Particle Physics

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Nicholas R. Poniatowski

Abstract: These notes are an outgrowth of an advanced undergraduate course taught at the University of Maryland, College Park. They are intended as an introduction to various aspects of particle and nuclear physics with an emphasis on the role of symmetry. The basic philosophy is to introduce many of the fundamental ideas in nuclear and particle physics using relatively sophisticated mathematical tools -- b… ▽ More These notes are an outgrowth of an advanced undergraduate course taught at the University of Maryland, College Park. They are intended as an introduction to various aspects of particle and nuclear physics with an emphasis on the role of symmetry. The basic philosophy is to introduce many of the fundamental ideas in nuclear and particle physics using relatively sophisticated mathematical tools -- but to do so in as a simplified a context to explain the underlying ideas. Thus, for example, the Higgs mechanism is discussed in terms of an Abelian Higgs model. The emphasis is largely, but not entirely theoretical in orientation. The goal is for readers to develop an understanding of many of the underlying issues in a relatively sophisticated way. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2021; v1 submitted 22 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 158 pages; submission to SciPost Lecture Notes

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. Lect. Notes 34 (2021)

Precision Model-Independent Bounds from Global Analysis of $b \to c \ell ν$ Form Factors

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Henry Lamm, Richard F. Lebed

Abstract: We present a model-independent global analysis of hadronic form factors for the semileptonic decays $b\rightarrow c\ellν$ that exploits lattice-QCD data, dispersion relations, and heavy-quark symmetries. The analysis yields predictions for the relevant form factors, within quantifiable bounds. These form factors are used to compute the semileptonic ratios $R(H_c)$ and various decay-product polariz… ▽ More We present a model-independent global analysis of hadronic form factors for the semileptonic decays $b\rightarrow c\ellν$ that exploits lattice-QCD data, dispersion relations, and heavy-quark symmetries. The analysis yields predictions for the relevant form factors, within quantifiable bounds. These form factors are used to compute the semileptonic ratios $R(H_c)$ and various decay-product polarizations. In particular, we find $R(D_s^*)=0.20(3)$ and $R(J/ψ)=0.25(3)$, predictions that can be compared to results of upcoming LHCb measurements. In developing this treatment, we obtain leading-order NRQCD results for the nonzero-recoil relations between the $B_c^+ \rightarrow \{J/ψ, η_c \}$ form factors. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 094503 (2019)

Yields of weakly-bound light nuclei as a probe of the statistical hadronization model

Authors: Yiming Cai, Thomas D. Cohen, Boris A. Gelman, Yukari Yamauchi

Abstract: The statistical hadronization model is a simple and efficient phenomenological framework in which the relative yields for very high energy heavy ion collisions are essentially determined by a single model parameter---the chemical freeze-out temperature. Recent measurements of yields of hadrons and light nuclei covering over 9 orders of magnitudes from the ALICE collaboration at the LHC were descri… ▽ More The statistical hadronization model is a simple and efficient phenomenological framework in which the relative yields for very high energy heavy ion collisions are essentially determined by a single model parameter---the chemical freeze-out temperature. Recent measurements of yields of hadrons and light nuclei covering over 9 orders of magnitudes from the ALICE collaboration at the LHC were described by the model with remarkable accuracy with a chemical freeze-out temperature of 156.5 $\pm$ 1.5 MeV. A key physical question is whether the freeze-out temperature can be understood, literally, as the temperature at which the various species of an equilibrated gas of hadrons (including resonances) and nuclei chemically freeze out as the model assumes, or whether it successfully parametrizes the yield data for a different reason. The yields of weakly-bound light nuclei---the deuteron and the hypertriton---provide insights into this issue. The analysis indicates that a key assumption underlying the model---that hadrons (and nuclei), just prior to chemical freeze-out temperature, are in thermal equilibrium and are sufficiently dilute as to have particle distributions accurately described statistically by a nearly ideal gas of hadrons and nuclei with masses given by their free space values---appears to be inconsistent with the chemical freeze-out temperature output by the model, at least for these weakly-bound nuclei. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2019; v1 submitted 7 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 100, 024911 (2019)

Narrow exotic hadrons in the heavy quark limit of QCD

Authors: Yiming Cai, Thomas Cohen

Abstract: This paper focuses on tetraquarks containing two heavy quarks in the formal limit where the heavy quark masses are taken to be arbitrarily large. There are well-established model-independent arguments for the existence of deeply bound exotic $\bar{q}\bar{q}'QQ$ tetraquark in the formal limit of arbitrarily large heavy quark masses. However, these previous arguments did not address the question whe… ▽ More This paper focuses on tetraquarks containing two heavy quarks in the formal limit where the heavy quark masses are taken to be arbitrarily large. There are well-established model-independent arguments for the existence of deeply bound exotic $\bar{q}\bar{q}'QQ$ tetraquark in the formal limit of arbitrarily large heavy quark masses. However, these previous arguments did not address the question whether tetraquark states exist close to the threshold for breaking up into two heavy mesons. Such states are not stable under strong interactions---they can emit pions and decay to lower-lying tetraquark states. This raises the issue of whether the nature of the heavy quark limit requires such states to exist as resonances that are narrow. Here we present a model-independent argument that establishes the existence of parametrically narrow tetraquark states. The argument here is based on Born-Oppenheimer and semi-classical considerations. The results derived here are only valid in a formal limit that is well outside the regime occurring for charm quarks in nature. However the analysis may give some insight in the experimentally observed narrow near-threshold tetraquark states containing a heavy quark and antiquark. △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2019; v1 submitted 16 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Does chiral perturbation theory rule out QCD-based solutions to the strong CP problem?

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: The conventional view is that a solution of the strong CP problem lies beyond QCD. A strong argument supporting this view is that the chiral expansion shows that observables depend on theta (unless a quark mass is zero); this eliminates the possibility that theta is physically irrelevant and appears to necessitate an explanation beyond the standard model. However, scenarios that solve the strong C… ▽ More The conventional view is that a solution of the strong CP problem lies beyond QCD. A strong argument supporting this view is that the chiral expansion shows that observables depend on theta (unless a quark mass is zero); this eliminates the possibility that theta is physically irrelevant and appears to necessitate an explanation beyond the standard model. However, scenarios that solve the strong CP problem exist that are consistent with known chiral behavior; in these, QCD becomes nonviable as a theory for nonzero theta. Such scenarios appear to be compatible with lattice studies of the topological susceptibility. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2019; v1 submitted 12 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: The paper has been expanded. It now includes a discussion of how evidence for this class of scenario might be obtained

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 99, 094007 (2019)

Model-Independent Bounds on $R(J/ψ)$

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Henry Lamm, Richard F. Lebed

Abstract: We present a model-independent bound on $R(J/ψ) \! \equiv \! \mathcal{BR} (B_c^+ \rightarrow J/ψ\, τ^+ν_τ)/ \mathcal{BR} (B_c^+ \rightarrow J/ψ\, μ^+ν_μ)$. This bound is constructed by constraining the form factors through a combination of dispersive relations, heavy-quark relations at zero-recoil, and the limited existing determinations from lattice QCD. The resulting 95\% confidence-level bound,… ▽ More We present a model-independent bound on $R(J/ψ) \! \equiv \! \mathcal{BR} (B_c^+ \rightarrow J/ψ\, τ^+ν_τ)/ \mathcal{BR} (B_c^+ \rightarrow J/ψ\, μ^+ν_μ)$. This bound is constructed by constraining the form factors through a combination of dispersive relations, heavy-quark relations at zero-recoil, and the limited existing determinations from lattice QCD. The resulting 95\% confidence-level bound, $0.20\leq R(J/ψ)\leq0.39$, agrees with the recent LHCb result at $1.3 \, σ$, and rules out some previously suggested model form factors. △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2018; v1 submitted 7 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 19 pages, 4 figures, JHEP format, revised to match published version

Resummed Photon Spectra for WIMP Annihilation

Authors: Matthew Baumgart, Timothy Cohen, Ian Moult, Nicholas L. Rodd, Tracy R. Slatyer, Mikhail P. Solon, Iain W. Stewart, Varun Vaidya

Abstract: We construct an effective field theory (EFT) description of the hard photon spectrum for heavy WIMP annihilation. This facilitates precision predictions relevant for line searches, and allows the incorporation of non-trivial energy resolution effects. Our framework combines techniques from non-relativistic EFTs and soft-collinear effective theory (SCET), as well as its multi-scale extensions that… ▽ More We construct an effective field theory (EFT) description of the hard photon spectrum for heavy WIMP annihilation. This facilitates precision predictions relevant for line searches, and allows the incorporation of non-trivial energy resolution effects. Our framework combines techniques from non-relativistic EFTs and soft-collinear effective theory (SCET), as well as its multi-scale extensions that have been recently introduced for studying jet substructure. We find a number of interesting features, including the simultaneous presence of SCET$_{\text{I}}$ and SCET$_{\text{II}}$ modes, as well as collinear-soft modes at the electroweak scale. We derive a factorization formula that enables both the resummation of the leading large Sudakov double logarithms that appear in the perturbative spectrum, and the inclusion of Sommerfeld enhancement effects. Consistency of this factorization is demonstrated to leading logarithmic order through explicit calculation. Our final result contains both the exclusive and the inclusive limits, thereby providing a unifying description of these two previously-considered approximations. We estimate the impact on experimental sensitivity, focusing for concreteness on an SU(2)$_{W}$ triplet fermion dark matter - the pure wino - where the strongest constraints are due to a search for gamma-ray lines from the Galactic Center. We find numerically significant corrections compared to previous results, thereby highlighting the importance of accounting for the photon spectrum when interpreting data from current and future indirect detection experiments. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2019; v1 submitted 20 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 55+25 pages, 11+2 figures; v3, updated an expression in the appendix to make it applicable at higher order - no impact on the results in this work

Report number: CALT-TH-2017-066, LA-UR-17-31169, MIT-CTP 4959

The interplay of the sign problem and the infinite volume limit: gauge theories with a theta term

Authors: Yiming Cai, Thomas Cohen, Ari Goldbloom-Helzner, Brian McPeak

Abstract: QCD and related gauge theories have a sign problem when a $θ$-term is included; this complicates the extraction of physical information from Euclidean space calculations as one would do in lattice studies. The sign problem arises in this system because the partition function for configurations with fixed topological charge $Q$, $\mathcal{Z}_Q$, are summed weighted by $\exp(i Q θ)$ to obtain the pa… ▽ More QCD and related gauge theories have a sign problem when a $θ$-term is included; this complicates the extraction of physical information from Euclidean space calculations as one would do in lattice studies. The sign problem arises in this system because the partition function for configurations with fixed topological charge $Q$, $\mathcal{Z}_Q$, are summed weighted by $\exp(i Q θ)$ to obtain the partition function for fixed $θ$, $ \mathcal{Z}(θ)$. The sign problem gets exponentially worse numerically as the space-time volume is increased. Here it is shown that apart from the practical numerical issues associated with large volumes, there are some interesting issues of principle. A key quantity is the energy density as a function of $θ$, $\varepsilon(θ) = -\log \left( \mathcal{Z}(θ) \right )/V$. This is expected to be well defined in the large 4-volume limit. Similarly, one expects the energy density for a fixed topological density $\tilde{\varepsilon}(Q/V) = -\log \left(\mathcal{Z}_Q \right )/V$ to be well defined in the limit of large 4-volumes. Intuitively, one might expect that if one had the infinite volume expression for $\tilde{\varepsilon}(Q/V)$ to arbitrary accuracy, that one could reconstruct $\varepsilon(θ)$ by directly summing over the topological sectors of the partition function. We show here that there are circumstances where this is not the case. In particular, this occurs in regions where the curvature of $\varepsilon(θ)$ is negative. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2016; v1 submitted 1 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 93, 114510 (2016)

On the nature of an emergent symmetry in QCD

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: Remarkable symmetry properties appear to arise in lattice calculations of correlation functions in which the lowest-lying eigenmodes of the Dirac operator in quark propagators are removed by hand. The Banks-Casher relation ties the chiral condensate to the density of low lying modes; thus, it is plausible that removal of such modes could lead to a regime where spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking… ▽ More Remarkable symmetry properties appear to arise in lattice calculations of correlation functions in which the lowest-lying eigenmodes of the Dirac operator in quark propagators are removed by hand. The Banks-Casher relation ties the chiral condensate to the density of low lying modes; thus, it is plausible that removal of such modes could lead to a regime where spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking does not occur. Surprising, a pattern of identical correlation functions was observed that is larger than can be explained by a restoration of chiral symmetry. This suggests that a larger symmetry---one that is not present in the QCD lagrangian---emerges when these modes are removed. Previously it was argued that this emergent symmetry was SU(4). However, when the low-lying modes are removed, the correlation functions of sources in the SU(4) 15-plet of spin-1 mesons appear to coincide with the correlation function of the SU(4) singlet. A natural explanation for this is an emergent symmetry larger than SU(4). In this work, it is shown that there exists no continuous symmetry whose generators in the field theory are spatial integrals of local operators that can account for the full pattern of identical correlation functions unless the apparent coincidence of the singlet channel with the 15-plet is accidental. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2016; v1 submitted 12 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: References added; A few clarifying comments added

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 93, 034508 (2016)

Low Energy Effective Theory of QCD at High Isospin Chemical Potential

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Srimoyee Sen

Abstract: The goal of this paper is to arrive at a low energy effective theory of QCD with two massless flavors of quarks at very high isospin density and zero baryon density. In a seminal paper by Son and Stephanov in the year 2001, it was conjectured that the low energy dynamics of QCD with two light flavors at asymptotically high isospin density was described by that of a pure Yang-Mills effective Lagran… ▽ More The goal of this paper is to arrive at a low energy effective theory of QCD with two massless flavors of quarks at very high isospin density and zero baryon density. In a seminal paper by Son and Stephanov in the year 2001, it was conjectured that the low energy dynamics of QCD with two light flavors at asymptotically high isospin density was described by that of a pure Yang-Mills effective Lagrangian. Since the existence of a first order deconfinement phase transition with increasing temperature is a feature of every pure SU(N) Yang-Mills theory with N greater than or equal to 3, the regime considered in this paper is also expected to exhibit a first order deconfinement phase transition with increasing temperature. However, the low energy constants(LEC) of this pure Yang-Mills theory have not been calculated till date. We calculate the LEC s for this effective theory which in turn enables us to calculate the critical temperature of the deconfinement transition as a function of the isospin chemical potential $μ_I$.The scaling of the critical temperature as a function of the isospin chemical potential that we find in this paper can be compared with future lattice calculations at finite isospin density. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: Talk presented CIPANP2015. 8 pages, LaTeX, 5 figures

Report number: CIPANP2015-Sen

Nucleon-Antinucleon Annhiliation at Large Nc

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Brian Mc Peak, Bendeguz Offertaler

Abstract: Nucleon-antinucleon annihilation in the large $N_c$ limit of QCD in the Witten regime of fixed velocity is considered with a focus on the spin and isospin dependence of the annihilation cross-section. In general, time-reversal and isospin invariance restricts the annihilation cross-section to depend on 6 independent energy-dependent terms. At large $N_c$, a spin-flavor symmetry emerges in the theo… ▽ More Nucleon-antinucleon annihilation in the large $N_c$ limit of QCD in the Witten regime of fixed velocity is considered with a focus on the spin and isospin dependence of the annihilation cross-section. In general, time-reversal and isospin invariance restricts the annihilation cross-section to depend on 6 independent energy-dependent terms. At large $N_c$, a spin-flavor symmetry emerges in the theory that acts to further restrict the dependence of the annihilation cross-section to three of these terms; the other terms amount to $1/N_c$ corrections. Assuming dominance of the leading order terms, several identities are derived that relate annihilation in different spin-isospin channels. A key prediction is that for unpolarized nucleons in Witten kinematics, the proton-antiproton annihilation cross-section should be equal to the proton-antineutron annihilation cross-section up to corrections of relative order $1/N_c$. Unpolarized nucleon-antinucleon annihilation data appears to be consistent with this expectation. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2015; v1 submitted 21 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Comments: Minor typos fixed in new version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 92, 015204 (2015)

Deconfinement Transition at High Isospin Chemical Potential and Low Temperature

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Srimoyee Sen

Abstract: We consider QCD with two degenerate flavors of light quarks(up and down) at asymptotically high isospin chemical potential with zero baryon chemical potential and calculate for the first time a quantitative expression for the critical temperature of the deconfinement transition in this regime. At high isospin chemical potential and sufficiently low temperatures this theory becomes equivalent to a… ▽ More We consider QCD with two degenerate flavors of light quarks(up and down) at asymptotically high isospin chemical potential with zero baryon chemical potential and calculate for the first time a quantitative expression for the critical temperature of the deconfinement transition in this regime. At high isospin chemical potential and sufficiently low temperatures this theory becomes equivalent to a pure Yang-Mills theory and accordingly has a first order deconfinement phase transition. Although this was conjectured in a seminal paper by Son and Stephanov in the year 2001, the critical temperature of this deconfinement phase transition was not computed. This paper computes the energy scale associated with this transition as a function of the isospin chemical potential by relating the parameters of the equivalent Yang-Mills theory to those of the underlying theory. We also relate the equation of state in one strongly interacting regime of QCD namely at finite isospin density to that in pure Yang-Mills, with the latter being amenable to straightforward numerical calculation. Our results for the critical temperature of deconfinement transition can be compared with future lattice calculations. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2015; v1 submitted 27 February, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: Added corrections to the speed of Goldstone modes and rephrased abstract

Center symmetry and Hagedorn spectrum

Authors: Adi Armoni, Thomas D. Cohen, Srimoyee Sen

Abstract: This paper explores the conjecture that large Nc gauge theories have a Hagedorn spectrum, if, and only if, they are confining and posses an explicit or emergent center symmetry. Evidence in support of this conjecture is presented. Many classes of large Nc gauge theories are considered. In all cases, we find that theories for which there exists a strong plausibility argument for a Hagedorn spectrum… ▽ More This paper explores the conjecture that large Nc gauge theories have a Hagedorn spectrum, if, and only if, they are confining and posses an explicit or emergent center symmetry. Evidence in support of this conjecture is presented. Many classes of large Nc gauge theories are considered. In all cases, we find that theories for which there exists a strong plausibility argument for a Hagedorn spectrum at large Nc are also believed to be confining and possess either an explicit center symmetric or have a strong plausibility argument for the existence of an emergent center symmetry at large Nc . Conversely, all theories we considered which are believed not to have a Hagedorn spectrum at large Nc, either were known not to be confining or else were believed to lack an emergent center symmetry. This is consistent with expectations based on the conjecture. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2015; v1 submitted 4 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: expanded version. few references and one author added

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 085007 (2015)

Finite Isospin Chiral Perturbation Theory in a Magnetic Field

Authors: Prabal Adhikari, Thomas D. Cohen, Julia Sakowitz

Abstract: The phase diagram of finite isospin, zero temperature QCD with the pions coupled to photons in a uniform external magnetic field is explored in the low field, small isospin density regime for which chiral perturbation theory is a valid description. For realistic pion masses, the system behaves as a type-II superconductor: a uniform superconducting state is formed at low-enough magnetic fields, a v… ▽ More The phase diagram of finite isospin, zero temperature QCD with the pions coupled to photons in a uniform external magnetic field is explored in the low field, small isospin density regime for which chiral perturbation theory is a valid description. For realistic pion masses, the system behaves as a type-II superconductor: a uniform superconducting state is formed at low-enough magnetic fields, a vortex state for intermediate magnetic fields and finally a normal state for large magnetic fields. In each these phases (including the vortex phase), the $π^{0}$ remains uncondensed just as in the zero-external field problem. The critical magnetic field where the phase transition from the uniform superconducting state to a vortex state occurs was found numerically. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 91, 045202 (2015)

Center symmetry and area laws

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: SU($N_c$) gauge theories containing matter fields may be invariant under transformations of some subgroup of the $\mathbb{Z}_{N_c}$ center; the maximum such subgroup is $\mathbb{Z}_{p}$, with $p$ depending on $N_c$ and the representations of the various matter fields in the theory. Confining SU($N_c$) gauge theories in either 3+1 or 2+1 space-time dimensions and with matter fields in any represent… ▽ More SU($N_c$) gauge theories containing matter fields may be invariant under transformations of some subgroup of the $\mathbb{Z}_{N_c}$ center; the maximum such subgroup is $\mathbb{Z}_{p}$, with $p$ depending on $N_c$ and the representations of the various matter fields in the theory. Confining SU($N_c$) gauge theories in either 3+1 or 2+1 space-time dimensions and with matter fields in any representation have string tensions for representation $R$ given by $σ_R =σ_f \, \, \frac{p_R (p-p_R) \, \, g\left (p_R (p-p_R) \right )}{(p-1) \, \, g(p -1 )} $ with $p_R={n_R \, \rm mod}(p)$, where $σ_f $ is the string tension for the fundamental representation, $g$ is a positive finite function and $n_R$ is the n-ality of $R$. This implies that a necessary condition for a theory in this class to have an area law is invariance of the theory under a nontrivial subgroup of the center. Significantly, these results depend on $p$ regardless of the value of $N_c$. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 90, 047703 (2014)

Large Nc gauge theory with quarks in high representations

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Srimoyee Sen

Abstract: This paper explores a novel tractable regime for ultraviolet-complete quantum field theories -- the large Nc limit of non-abelian gauge theories with quarks in high dimensional representations (scaling with Nc faster than Nc^2 ), such as quarks with 'a' fundamental indices with a greater than or equal to 3. A smooth and nontrivial Nc limit can be obtained if g^2 Nc^(a-1) is held fixed instead of t… ▽ More This paper explores a novel tractable regime for ultraviolet-complete quantum field theories -- the large Nc limit of non-abelian gauge theories with quarks in high dimensional representations (scaling with Nc faster than Nc^2 ), such as quarks with 'a' fundamental indices with a greater than or equal to 3. A smooth and nontrivial Nc limit can be obtained if g^2 Nc^(a-1) is held fixed instead of the standard t Hooft coupling g^2 Nc as Nc goes to infinity where g is the gauge coupling. SU(Nc) gauge theories in 3+1 dimensions are not asymptotically free at large Nc when they contain quarks in representations whose dimensions scale faster than Nc^2 and hence are not ultraviolet complete. However, in lower space-time dimensions (2+1, 1+1), for any Nc, renormalization group flow for such theories always has a stable ultraviolet fixed point at g = 0; the theory is thus ultraviolet complete. For the case of massless quarks, the theory has an infrared fixed point. For massive quarks, the theory is confining. The confining scale is parametrically of the order Nc^((2-a)/(4-d)) and is driven to zero at large Nc for theories with a > 2 and d < 4 where d is the space time dimension. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2014; v1 submitted 18 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 90, 085008 (2014)

QCD and strongly coupled gauge theories: challenges and perspectives

Authors: N. Brambilla, S. Eidelman, P. Foka, S. Gardner, A. S. Kronfeld, M. G. Alford, R. Alkofer, M. Butenschoen, T. D. Cohen, J. Erdmenger, L. Fabbietti, M. Faber, J. L. Goity, B. Ketzer, H. W. Lin, F. J. Llanes-Estrada, H. Meyer, P. Pakhlov, E. Pallante, M. I. Polikarpov, H. Sazdjian, A. Schmitt, W. M. Snow, A. Vairo, R. Vogt , et al. (24 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We highlight the progress, current status, and open challenges of QCD-driven physics, in theory and in experiment. We discuss how the strong interaction is intimately connected to a broad sweep of physical problems, in settings ranging from astrophysics and cosmology to strongly-coupled, complex systems in particle and condensed-matter physics, as well as to searches for physics beyond the Standar… ▽ More We highlight the progress, current status, and open challenges of QCD-driven physics, in theory and in experiment. We discuss how the strong interaction is intimately connected to a broad sweep of physical problems, in settings ranging from astrophysics and cosmology to strongly-coupled, complex systems in particle and condensed-matter physics, as well as to searches for physics beyond the Standard Model. We also discuss how success in describing the strong interaction impacts other fields, and, in turn, how such subjects can impact studies of the strong interaction. In the course of the work we offer a perspective on the many research streams which flow into and out of QCD, as well as a vision for future developments. △ Less

Submitted 18 May, 2014; v1 submitted 14 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 246 pp, around 128 figures; v2 adds material, references, and corrections suggested by readers of v1 -- to be submitted to EPJC

Report number: CCQCN-2014-24, CCTP-2014-5, CERN-PH-TH/2014-033, DF-1-2014, FERMILAB-PUB-14-024/T, HIP-2014-03/TH, ITEP-LAT-2014-1, JLAB-THY-14-1865, LLNL-JRNL-651216, MITP/14-016, NT@UW 14-04, RUB-TPII-01/2014, TUM-EFT 46/14, UWThPh-2014-006

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. C 74:2981 (2014) 1

Are There Tetraquarks at Large $N_c$ in QCD(F)?

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Richard F. Lebed

Abstract: Weinberg recently pointed out a flaw in the standard argument that large $N_c$ QCD with color-fundamental quarks [QCD(F)] cannot yield narrow tetraquark states. In particular, he observed that the argument does not rule out narrow tetraquarks associated with the leading-order connected diagrams; such tetraquarks would have a width scaling as $N_c^{-1}$. It is shown here, however, that while the st… ▽ More Weinberg recently pointed out a flaw in the standard argument that large $N_c$ QCD with color-fundamental quarks [QCD(F)] cannot yield narrow tetraquark states. In particular, he observed that the argument does not rule out narrow tetraquarks associated with the leading-order connected diagrams; such tetraquarks would have a width scaling as $N_c^{-1}$. It is shown here, however, that while the standard analysis of tetraquarks does not rule them out, a more thorough analysis rules out quantum-number exotic tetraquarks associated with the leading-order connected diagrams. This analysis is based entirely on conventional assumptions used in large $N_c$ physics applied to the analytic properties of meson-meson scattering. Our result implies that one of three possibilities must be true: i) quantum-number exotic tetraquarks do not exist at large $N_c$; ii) quantum-number exotic tetraquarks exist, but are associated with subleading connected diagrams and have anomalously small widths that scale as $N_c^{-2}$ or smaller; or iii) the conventional assumptions used in large $N_c$ analysis are inadequate. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 8 pages, 4 .eps figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 90, 016001 (2014)

Quantum-Number Exotic Tetraquarks at Large $N_c$ in QCD(AS)

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Richard F. Lebed

Abstract: It is shown that the large $N_c$ limit of QCD with quarks in the two-index antisymmetric color representation [QCD(AS)] has narrow tetraquark states with exotic flavor quantum numbers. They decay into mesons with a width that is parametrically $O(1/N_c^2)$. Tetraquarks with non-exotic quantum numbers mix at leading order with mesons of the same overall quantum numbers. QCD(AS) at $N_c=3$ correspon… ▽ More It is shown that the large $N_c$ limit of QCD with quarks in the two-index antisymmetric color representation [QCD(AS)] has narrow tetraquark states with exotic flavor quantum numbers. They decay into mesons with a width that is parametrically $O(1/N_c^2)$. Tetraquarks with non-exotic quantum numbers mix at leading order with mesons of the same overall quantum numbers. QCD(AS) at $N_c=3$ corresponds to ordinary QCD; its large $N_c$ limit represents an alternative starting point for a $1/N_c$ expansion to the standard one with quarks in the fundamental color representation. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 .eps figures, ReVTeX

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 89, 054018 (2014)

The inelastic vs. total nucleon-nucleon cross section at large $N_c$

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Vojtěch Krejčiřík

Abstract: In this paper, the implication of the extreme large $N_c$ limit for nucleon-nucleon cross section is examined. Starting from the $N_c$ scaling of the S-matrix elements, a relation between the total inelastic and total cross sections is derived for the regime in which the momenta are much larger than the QCD scale. A conceptual complication arise from the fact that there is a tower of baryons, such… ▽ More In this paper, the implication of the extreme large $N_c$ limit for nucleon-nucleon cross section is examined. Starting from the $N_c$ scaling of the S-matrix elements, a relation between the total inelastic and total cross sections is derived for the regime in which the momenta are much larger than the QCD scale. A conceptual complication arise from the fact that there is a tower of baryons, such as the $Δ$, with mass splittings from the nucleon which go to zero at large $N_c$. Since these baryons are stable at large $N_c$, the meaning of elasticity must be modified. Processes which only transform nucleons to these baryons are considered elastic; processes in which at least one additional meson is produced are considered inelastic. It is shown that in the extreme large $N_c$ limit, the total inelastic cross section is exactly one eighth of the total cross section. In contrast, in the physical world of $N_c=3$ the total cross section for high-energy nucleon-nucleon scattering is dominated by inelastic processes. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 89, 024003 (2014)

Density of Saturated Nuclear Matter at Large $N_{c}$ and Heavy Quark Mass Limits

Authors: Prabal Adhikari, Thomas D. Cohen, Ishaun Datta

Abstract: We exhibit the existence of stable, saturated nuclear matter in the large $N_{c}$ and heavy quark mass limits of QCD. In this limit, baryons (with the same spin flavor structure) interact at leading order in $N_{c}$ via a repulsive interaction due to the Pauli exclusion principle and at subleading order in $1/N_c$ via the exchange of glueballs. Assuming that the lightest glueball is a scalar, whic… ▽ More We exhibit the existence of stable, saturated nuclear matter in the large $N_{c}$ and heavy quark mass limits of QCD. In this limit, baryons (with the same spin flavor structure) interact at leading order in $N_{c}$ via a repulsive interaction due to the Pauli exclusion principle and at subleading order in $1/N_c$ via the exchange of glueballs. Assuming that the lightest glueball is a scalar, which implies that the subleading baryon interaction is attractive, we find that nuclear matter saturates since the subleading attractive interaction is longer ranged than the leading order repulsive one. We find that the saturated matter is in the form of a crystal with either a face-centered cubic or a hexagonal-close-packed symmetry with baryon densities of $\mathcal{O}((\, \tildeα_{s} m_q (\ln (N_{c}m_{q}Λ_{\textrm{QCD}}^{-1}))^{-1})^3 )$. Remarkably, the leading order expression for the density of saturated nuclear matter is independent of the lighest glueball mass and scalar-glueball-baryon coupling in the extreme large $N_{c}$ limit or heavy quark limit (or both), which we define precisely in this work. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Comments: 6 pages, no figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 89, 065201 (2014)

New critical point for QCD in a magnetic field

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Naoki Yamamoto

Abstract: We provide a general argument for the possible existence of a new critical point associated with a deconfinement phase transition in QCD at finite temperature $T$ and in a magnetic field $B$ with zero chemical potential. This is the first example of a QCD critical point in a physical external parameter region that can be studied using lattice QCD simulations without suffering from a sign problem. We provide a general argument for the possible existence of a new critical point associated with a deconfinement phase transition in QCD at finite temperature $T$ and in a magnetic field $B$ with zero chemical potential. This is the first example of a QCD critical point in a physical external parameter region that can be studied using lattice QCD simulations without suffering from a sign problem. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2014; v1 submitted 8 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures; v3: published version

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D89:054029,2014

Nucleon-nucleon scattering matrix and its Nc scaling

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Vojtěch Krejčiřík

Abstract: This paper focuses on the scaling of the S-matrix for elastic nucleon-nucleon scattering at large Nc. It is argued that the logarithm of a typical S-matrix element is proportional to Nc in the regime where the large Nc limit is taken with momentum of the incident nucleons proportional Nc. The suggested scaling was previously derived within the framework of potential scattering models for purely el… ▽ More This paper focuses on the scaling of the S-matrix for elastic nucleon-nucleon scattering at large Nc. It is argued that the logarithm of a typical S-matrix element is proportional to Nc in the regime where the large Nc limit is taken with momentum of the incident nucleons proportional Nc. The suggested scaling was previously derived within the framework of potential scattering models for purely elastic scattering in which the parameters scale the same way as in large Nc QCD. A variety of heuristic arguments strongly suggest that the same scaling holds in the realistic case where both elastic and inelastic scattering are possible. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 88, 054003 (2013)

Mean-field theory of baryonic matter for QCD in the large $N_{c}$ and heavy quark mass limits

Authors: Prabal Adhikari, Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: We discuss theoretical issues pertaining to baryonic matter in the combined heavy-quark and large $N_c$ limits of QCD. Witten's classic argument that baryons and interacting systems of baryons can be described in a mean-field approximation with each of the quarks moving in an average potential due to the remaining quarks is heuristic. It is important to justify this heuristic description for the c… ▽ More We discuss theoretical issues pertaining to baryonic matter in the combined heavy-quark and large $N_c$ limits of QCD. Witten's classic argument that baryons and interacting systems of baryons can be described in a mean-field approximation with each of the quarks moving in an average potential due to the remaining quarks is heuristic. It is important to justify this heuristic description for the case of baryonic matter since systems of interacting baryons are intrinsically more complicated than single baryons due to the possibility of hidden color states---states in which the subsystems making up the entire baryon crystal are not color-singlet nucleons but rather colorful states coupled together to make a color-singlet state. In this work, we provide a formal justification of this heuristic prescription. In order to do this, we start by taking the heavy quark limit, thus effectively reducing the problem to a many-body quantum mechanical system. This problem can be formulated in terms of integrals over coherent states, which for this problem are simple Slater determinants. We show that for the many-body problem, the support region for these integrals becomes narrow at large $N_c$, yielding an energy which is well-approximated by a single coherent state---that is a mean-field description. Corrections to the energy are of relative order $1/N_c$. While hidden color states are present in the exact state of the heavy quark system, they only influence the interaction energy at sub-leading order in $1/N_{c}$. △ Less

Submitted 29 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: 9 pages

Baryons and Low-Density Baryonic Matter in 1+1 Dimensional Large N_c QCD with Heavy Quarks

Authors: Prabal Adhikari, Thomas D. Cohen, Arec Jamgochian, Nilay Kumar

Abstract: This paper studies baryons and baryonic matter in the combined large N_c and heavy quark mass limits of QCD in 1+1 dimension. In this non-relativistic limit, baryons are composed of N_c quarks that interact, at leading order in N_c, through a color Coulomb potential. Using variational techniques, very accurate calculations of single baryon masses and interaction energies of low-density baryon crys… ▽ More This paper studies baryons and baryonic matter in the combined large N_c and heavy quark mass limits of QCD in 1+1 dimension. In this non-relativistic limit, baryons are composed of N_c quarks that interact, at leading order in N_c, through a color Coulomb potential. Using variational techniques, very accurate calculations of single baryon masses and interaction energies of low-density baryon crystal are performed. These results are used to cross-check a general numerical approach applicable for arbitrary quark masses and baryon densities recently proposed by Bringoltz, which is based on a lattice in a finite box with periodic boundary conditions. The Bringoltz method differs from a previous approach of Salcedo, et al. in its treatment of a finite box effect - namely gauge configurations that wind around the box. One might expect these effects to be small for large enough boxes, in which the baryon density approaches zero to high accuracy at the edges. However, the effects of these windings appear to be quite large even in such boxes. The large mass infinite volume calculations performed here are consistent with the results of numerical calculations using the Bringoltz method. The calculation of the baryon crystal interaction energy requires the assumption that at low-densities the ground state is composed of individual baryons, each in a color-singlet state and orthogonal to each other. This assumption is plausible but ad hoc in that one can construct configurations in which the entire state is color-singlet but cannot be broken into individual color-singlet baryons. The interaction energy of low-density baryon crystals calculated with the assumption is consistent with numerical results based on Bringoltz's approach suggesting that the assumption is justified. This further supports a similar assumption that was made in 3+1 dimensions, where no alternative means of calculation exist. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 14 pages, 7 figures

Multi-channel S-matrices from energy levels in finite boxes

Authors: Evan Berkowitz, Thomas D. Cohen, Patrick Jefferson

Abstract: We show that for a generic quantum mechanical system with more than one open scattering channel, it is not possible to fully reconstruct the theory's S-matrix from spectral information obtained in large finite volumes with periodic boundary conditions. Physically distinct S-matrices can have identical finite-volume spectra for large finite boxes of arbitrary sizes. If the theory is not time-revers… ▽ More We show that for a generic quantum mechanical system with more than one open scattering channel, it is not possible to fully reconstruct the theory's S-matrix from spectral information obtained in large finite volumes with periodic boundary conditions. Physically distinct S-matrices can have identical finite-volume spectra for large finite boxes of arbitrary sizes. If the theory is not time-reversal symmetric, there exists an uncountably infinite set of distinct S-matrices with the same spectra. If the theory respects time-reversal symmetry there exists a discrete set of S-matrices with identical energy levels for finite boxes. We illustrate the issue for simple quantum mechanical systems in 1+1 dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2013; v1 submitted 9 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Report number: UM-DOE/ER/40762-526

Alternate 1/N_c Expansions and SU(3) Breaking from Baryon Lattice Results

Authors: Aleksey Cherman, Thomas D. Cohen, Richard F. Lebed

Abstract: A combined expansion in the number of QCD colors 1/N_c and SU(3) flavor breaking parameter epsilon has long been known to provide an excellent accounting for the mass spectrum of the lightest spin-1/2, 3/2 baryons when the quarks are taken to transform under the fundamental SU(N_c) representation, and in the final step N_c \to 3 and epsilon is set to its physical value ~0.3. Subsequent work shows… ▽ More A combined expansion in the number of QCD colors 1/N_c and SU(3) flavor breaking parameter epsilon has long been known to provide an excellent accounting for the mass spectrum of the lightest spin-1/2, 3/2 baryons when the quarks are taken to transform under the fundamental SU(N_c) representation, and in the final step N_c \to 3 and epsilon is set to its physical value ~0.3. Subsequent work shows that placing quarks in the two-index antisymmetric SU(N_c) representation leads to quantitatively equally successful mass relations. Recent lattice simulations allow for varying the value of epsilon and confirm the robustness of the original 1/N_c relations. In this paper we show that the same conclusion holds for the antisymmetric quarks, and demonstrate that the mass relations also hold under alternate prescriptions for identifying physical baryons with particular members of the large N_c multiplets. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2012; v1 submitted 4 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 tables, 8 figures; v3: typos fixed, references added, journal version

Report number: DAMTP-2012-36

The total nucleon-nucleon cross section at large N_c

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: It is shown that at sufficiently large $N_c$ for incident momenta which are much larger than the QCD, the total nucleon-nucleon cross section is independent of incident momentum and given by $σ^{\rm total}=2 π\log^2(N_c) / (m^2_π)$. This result is valid in the extreme large $N_c$ regime of $\log(N_c) \gg 1$ and has corrections of relative order $\log (\log(N_c))/\log(N_c)$. A possible connection o… ▽ More It is shown that at sufficiently large $N_c$ for incident momenta which are much larger than the QCD, the total nucleon-nucleon cross section is independent of incident momentum and given by $σ^{\rm total}=2 π\log^2(N_c) / (m^2_π)$. This result is valid in the extreme large $N_c$ regime of $\log(N_c) \gg 1$ and has corrections of relative order $\log (\log(N_c))/\log(N_c)$. A possible connection of this result to the Froissart-Martin bound is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 4 pages

Model-independent form factor relations at large $N_c$

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Vojtěch Krejčiřík

Abstract: In this paper a model-independent relation which holds for the long distance part of the Fourier transform of the electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon in the large $N_c$ and chiral limits is demonstrated. This relation was previously conjectured based on the fact that it emerged in {\it all} semiclassical chiral models independent of the details of the model. Here we show that the result is… ▽ More In this paper a model-independent relation which holds for the long distance part of the Fourier transform of the electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon in the large $N_c$ and chiral limits is demonstrated. This relation was previously conjectured based on the fact that it emerged in {\it all} semiclassical chiral models independent of the details of the model. Here we show that the result is, in fact, model independent by deriving it directly in large $N_c$ chiral perturbation theory which is known to capture the long distance behavior of the form factors. The relation is valid when the large $N_c$ limit is formally taken before the chiral limit. A new relation is derived for the case where the chiral limit is taken prior to the large $N_c$ limit. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2012; v1 submitted 25 January, 2012; originally announced January 2012.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 85, 035205 (2012)

Total nucleon-nucleon cross sections in large N(c) QCD

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Boris A. Gelman

Abstract: We use contracted spin-flavor symmetry which emerges in the large Nc limit of QCD to obtain relations between proton-proton and proton-neutron total cross sections for both polarized and unpolarized scattering. The formalism used is valid in the semi-classical regime in which the relative momentum of the incident nucleons is much larger than the inverse size of the nucleon, provided that certain t… ▽ More We use contracted spin-flavor symmetry which emerges in the large Nc limit of QCD to obtain relations between proton-proton and proton-neutron total cross sections for both polarized and unpolarized scattering. The formalism used is valid in the semi-classical regime in which the relative momentum of the incident nucleons is much larger than the inverse size of the nucleon, provided that certain technical assumptions are met. The relations should be phenomenologically useful provided that Nc=3 is sufficiently large so that the large Nc results have at least semi-quantitative predictive power. The relations are model-independent in the sense that they depend on properties of large Nc QCD only and not on any particular model-dependent details of the nucleon-nucleon interaction. We compare these model-independent results to experimental data. We find the relation for spin-unpolarized scattering works well empirically. For the case of polarized scattering, the data is consistent with the relations but the cross sections are too small to make sharp predictions. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2012; v1 submitted 18 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 9 pages, 3 figures, typographical errors corrected

Conference Discussion of the Nuclear Force

Authors: Franz Gross, Thomas D. Cohen, Evgeny Epelbaum, Ruprecht Machleidt

Abstract: Discussion of the nuclear force, lead by a round table consisting of T. Cohen, E. Epelbaum, R. Machleidt, and F. Gross (chair). After an invited talk by Machleidt, published elsewhere in these proceedings, brief remarks are made by Epelbaum, Cohen, and Gross, followed by discussion from the floor moderated by the chair. The chair asked the round table and the participants to focus on the following… ▽ More Discussion of the nuclear force, lead by a round table consisting of T. Cohen, E. Epelbaum, R. Machleidt, and F. Gross (chair). After an invited talk by Machleidt, published elsewhere in these proceedings, brief remarks are made by Epelbaum, Cohen, and Gross, followed by discussion from the floor moderated by the chair. The chair asked the round table and the participants to focus on the following issues: (i) What does each approach (chiral effective field theory, large Nc, and relativistic phenomenology) contribute to our knowledge of the nuclear force? Do we need them all? Is any one transcendent? (ii) How important for applications (few body, nuclear structure, EMC effect, for example) are precise fits to the NN data below 350 MeV? How precise do these fits have to be? (iii) Can we learn anything about nonperturbative QCD from these studies of the nuclear force? The discussion presented here is based on a video recording made at the conference and transcribed afterward. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Comments: Discussion at the 21st European Conference on Few Body Problems (EFP21) held at Salamanca, Spain, 30 Aug - 3 Sept 2010

Journal ref: Few-Body Syst. 50 (2011) 31-44

The Hagedorn spectrum and large $N_c$ QCD in 2+1 and 3+1 dimensions

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Vojtěch Krejčiřík

Abstract: We show that a Hagedorn spectrum (i.e., spectrum where the number of hadrons grows exponentially with the mass) emerges automatically in large $N_c$ QCD in 2+1 and 3+1 dimensions. The approach is based on the study of Euclidean space correlation functions for composite operators constructed from quark and gluon fields and exploits the fact that the short time behavior of the correlators is known i… ▽ More We show that a Hagedorn spectrum (i.e., spectrum where the number of hadrons grows exponentially with the mass) emerges automatically in large $N_c$ QCD in 2+1 and 3+1 dimensions. The approach is based on the study of Euclidean space correlation functions for composite operators constructed from quark and gluon fields and exploits the fact that the short time behavior of the correlators is known in QCD. The demonstration relies on one critical assumption: that perturbation theory accurately describes the trace of the logarithm of a matrix of point-to-point correlation functions in the regime where the perturbative corrections to the asymptotically free value are small. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 18 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: JHEP08, 138, (2011)

On Chiral Symmetry Restoration at Finite Density in Large N_c QCD

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Prabal Adhikari, Mark C. Strother, Raja R. M. Ayyagari

Abstract: At large N_c, cold nuclear matter is expected to form a crystal and thus spontaneously break translational symmetry. The description of chiral symmetry breaking and translational symmetry breaking can become intertwined. Here, the focus is on aspects of chiral symmetry breaking and its possible restoration that are by construction independent of the nature of translational symmetry breaking---name… ▽ More At large N_c, cold nuclear matter is expected to form a crystal and thus spontaneously break translational symmetry. The description of chiral symmetry breaking and translational symmetry breaking can become intertwined. Here, the focus is on aspects of chiral symmetry breaking and its possible restoration that are by construction independent of the nature of translational symmetry breaking---namely spatial averages of chiral order parameters. A system will be considered to be chirally restored provided all spatially-averaged chiral order parameters are zero. A critical question is whether chiral restoration in this sense is possible for phases in which chiral order parameters are locally non-zero but whose spatial averages all vanish. We show that this is not possible unless all chirally-invariant observables are spatially uniform. This result is first derived for Skyrme-type models, which are based on a nonlinear sigma model and by construction break chiral symmetry on a point-by-point basis. A no-go theorem for chiral restoration (in the average sense) for all models of this type is obtained by showing that in these models there exist chirally symmetric order parameters which cannot be spatially uniform. Next we show that the no-go theorem applies to large N_c QCD in any phase which has a non-zero but spatially varying chiral condensate. The theorem is demonstrated by showing that in a putative chirally-restored phase, the field configuration can be reduced to that of a nonlinear sigma model. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 12 pages, 1 table

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.C83:065201,2011

Baryons and baryonic matter in the large Nc and heavy quark limits

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Nilay Kumar, Kamal K. Ndousse

Abstract: This paper explores properties of baryons and finite density baryonic matter in an artificial world in which Nc, the number of colors, is large and the quarks of all species are degenerate and much larger than Λ_QCD. It has long been known that in large Nc QCD, baryons composed entirely of heavy quarks are accurately described in the mean-field approximation. However, the detailed properties of ba… ▽ More This paper explores properties of baryons and finite density baryonic matter in an artificial world in which Nc, the number of colors, is large and the quarks of all species are degenerate and much larger than Λ_QCD. It has long been known that in large Nc QCD, baryons composed entirely of heavy quarks are accurately described in the mean-field approximation. However, the detailed properties of baryons in the combined large Nc and heavy quark limits have not been fully explored. Here some basic properties of baryons are computed using a variational approach. At leading order in both the large Nc and heavy quark expansions the baryon mass is computed explicitly as is the baryon form factor. Baryonic matter, the analog of nuclear matter in this artificial world, should also be well described in the mean-field approximation. In the special case where all baryons have an identical spin flavor structure, it is shown that in the formal heavy quark and large Nc limit interactions between baryons are strictly repulsive at low densities. The energy per baryon is computed in this limit and found to be exponentially small. It is shown that when the restriction to baryons with an identical spin-flavor structure is dropped, a phase of baryonic matter exists with a density of 2Nf times that for the restricted case but with the same energy (where Nf is the number of degenerate flavors). It is shown that this phase is at least metastable. △ Less

Submitted 10 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: 19 pages

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.C84:015204,2011

To what systems does the Bohigas conjecture apply?

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen, Garrett Goon

Abstract: We test the applicability of the Bohigas conjecture to systems whose Hamiltonian is not written as a closed form analytic expression. A class of such Hamiltonians is created and appear to violate the conjecture. Numerical methods are employed to find the spectra of a two-dimensional, classically chaotic "billiard" system whose Hamiltonian is in this class. We find that the spectral fluctuations… ▽ More We test the applicability of the Bohigas conjecture to systems whose Hamiltonian is not written as a closed form analytic expression. A class of such Hamiltonians is created and appear to violate the conjecture. Numerical methods are employed to find the spectra of a two-dimensional, classically chaotic "billiard" system whose Hamiltonian is in this class. We find that the spectral fluctuations are not in agreement with the conjecture. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: 10 pages; 4 figures

Model Independent Tests of Skyrmions and Their Holographic Cousins

Authors: Aleksey Cherman, Thomas D. Cohen, Marina Nielsen

Abstract: We describe a new exact relation for large $N_c$ QCD for the long-distance behavior of baryon form factors in the chiral limit. This model-independent relation is used to test the consistency of the structure of several baryon models. All 4D semiclassical chiral soliton models satisfy the relation, as does the Pomarol-Wulzer holographic model of baryons as 5D Skyrmions. However, remarkably, we f… ▽ More We describe a new exact relation for large $N_c$ QCD for the long-distance behavior of baryon form factors in the chiral limit. This model-independent relation is used to test the consistency of the structure of several baryon models. All 4D semiclassical chiral soliton models satisfy the relation, as does the Pomarol-Wulzer holographic model of baryons as 5D Skyrmions. However, remarkably, we find that the holographic model treating baryons as instantons in the Sakai-Sugimoto model does not satisfy the relation. △ Less

Submitted 24 March, 2009; v1 submitted 15 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: v2. Added references, corrected typos

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett.103:022001,2009

QCD and the Hagedorn spectrum

Authors: Thomas D. Cohen

Abstract: It is shown that large Nc QCD must have a Hagedorn spectrum (i.e. a spectrum of hadron which grows exponentially with the hadrons mass) provided that certain technical assumptions concerning the applicability of perturbation theory to a certain class of correlation functions apply. The basic argument exploits the interplay of confinement and asymptotic freedom. It is shown that large Nc QCD must have a Hagedorn spectrum (i.e. a spectrum of hadron which grows exponentially with the hadrons mass) provided that certain technical assumptions concerning the applicability of perturbation theory to a certain class of correlation functions apply. The basic argument exploits the interplay of confinement and asymptotic freedom. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2010; v1 submitted 5 January, 2009; originally announced January 2009.

Comments: 16 pages, 1 figure. This version is expanded from the original version. Additional discussion has been added to clarify the central issues. Typos have been fixed. The appendix has been updated and greatly expanded.

Journal ref: JHEP 1006:098,2010