Showing 1–50 of 77 results for author: Wiggins, S

Structured pathways in the turbulence organizing recent oil spill events in the Eastern Mediterranean

Authors: Guillermo Garcia-Sanchez, Ana M. Mancho, Antonio G. Ramos, Josep Coca, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: The chaotic nature of ocean motion is a major challenge that hinders the discovery of spatio-temporal current routes that govern the transport of material. Certain material, such as oil spills, pose significant environmental threats and these are enhanced by the fact that they evolve in a chaotic sea, in a way which still nowadays is far from being systematically anticipated. Recently such an oil… ▽ More The chaotic nature of ocean motion is a major challenge that hinders the discovery of spatio-temporal current routes that govern the transport of material. Certain material, such as oil spills, pose significant environmental threats and these are enhanced by the fact that they evolve in a chaotic sea, in a way which still nowadays is far from being systematically anticipated. Recently such an oil spill event has affected the Mediterranean coast of several Middle Eastern countries. No accidents were reported for these spills previous to their arrival at the coast, and therefore there was no hint of their origin. Modelling such an event, in which uncertainties are increased due to the lack of information on where and when the spills was produced, stretches available technologies to their limits, and requires the use of novel ideas that help to understand the essential features of oil and tar transport by ocean currents. In this regard Lagrangian Coherent Structures enable us to find order within ocean chaos and provide powerful insights into chaotic events and their relationships over different locations and times like the one addressed. Using the observed locations of the oil impacting the coast at specific times, we seek to determine its original location and the time it was released in the open ocean. We have determined both using a combination of earlier satellite observations and computational modelling of the time evolution. The observed agreement between modeled cases and satellite observations highlights the power of these ideas. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Comments: 12 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Scientific Reports 12, 3662 (2022)

A Causation-Based Computationally Efficient Strategy for Deploying Lagrangian Drifters to Improve Real-Time State Estimation

Authors: Erik Bollt, Nan Chen, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Deploying Lagrangian drifters that facilitate the state estimation of the underlying flow field within a future time interval is practically important. However, the uncertainty in estimating the flow field prevents using standard deterministic approaches for designing strategies and applying trajectory-wise skill scores to evaluate performance. In this paper an information measurement is developed… ▽ More Deploying Lagrangian drifters that facilitate the state estimation of the underlying flow field within a future time interval is practically important. However, the uncertainty in estimating the flow field prevents using standard deterministic approaches for designing strategies and applying trajectory-wise skill scores to evaluate performance. In this paper an information measurement is developed to quantitatively assess the information gain in the estimated flow field by deploying an additional set of drifters. This information measurement is derived by exploiting causal inference. It is characterized by the inferred probability density function of the flow field, which naturally considers the uncertainty. Although the information measurement is an ideal theoretical metric, using it as the direct cost makes the optimization problem computationally expensive. To this end, an effective surrogate cost function is developed. It is highly efficient to compute while capturing the essential features of the information measurement when solving the optimization problem. Based upon these properties, a practical strategy for deploying drifter observations to improve future state estimation is designed. Due to the forecast uncertainty, the approach exploits the expected value of spatial maps of the surrogate cost associated with different forecast realizations to seek the optimal solution. Numerical experiments justify the effectiveness of the surrogate cost. The proposed strategy significantly outperforms the method by randomly deploying the drifters. It is also shown that, under certain conditions, the drifters determined by the expected surrogate cost remain skillful for the state estimation of a single forecast realization of the flow field as in reality. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 24 pages, 8 figures

Bifurcation of Dividing Surfaces Constructed from Period-Doubling Bifurcations of Periodic Orbits in a Caldera Potential Energy Surface

Authors: Matthaios Katsanikas, Makrina Agaoglou, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this work we analyze the bifurcation of dividing surfaces that occurs as a result of two period-doubling bifurcations in a 2D caldera-type potential. We study the structure, the range, the minimum and maximum extents of the periodic orbit dividing surfaces before and after a subcritical period-doubling bifurcation of the family of the central minimum of the potential energy surface. Furthermore… ▽ More In this work we analyze the bifurcation of dividing surfaces that occurs as a result of two period-doubling bifurcations in a 2D caldera-type potential. We study the structure, the range, the minimum and maximum extents of the periodic orbit dividing surfaces before and after a subcritical period-doubling bifurcation of the family of the central minimum of the potential energy surface. Furthermore, we repeat the same study for the case of a supercritical perioddoubling bifurcation of the family of the central minimum of the potential energy surface. We will discuss and compare the results for the two cases of bifurcations of dividing surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 15 pages. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2107.09623

MSC Class: 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

Journal ref: International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos, Vol. 32, No. 07, 2230015 (2022)

Launching Drifter Observations in the Presence of Uncertainty

Authors: Nan Chen, Evelyn Lunasin, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Determining the optimal locations for placing extra observational measurements has practical significance. However, the exact underlying flow field is never known in practice. Significant uncertainty appears when the flow field is inferred from a limited number of existing observations via data assimilation or statistical forecast. In this paper, a new computationally efficient strategy for deploy… ▽ More Determining the optimal locations for placing extra observational measurements has practical significance. However, the exact underlying flow field is never known in practice. Significant uncertainty appears when the flow field is inferred from a limited number of existing observations via data assimilation or statistical forecast. In this paper, a new computationally efficient strategy for deploying Lagrangian drifters that highlights the central role of uncertainty is developed. A nonlinear trajectory diagnostic approach that underlines the importance of uncertainty is built to construct a phase portrait map. It consists of both the geometric structure of the underlying flow field and the uncertainty in the estimated state from Lagrangian data assimilation. The drifters are deployed at the maxima of this map and are required to be separated enough. Such a strategy allows the drifters to travel the longest distances to collect both the local and global information of the flow field. It also facilitates the reduction of a significant amount of uncertainty. To characterize the uncertainty, the estimated state is given by a probability density function (PDF). An information metric is then introduced to assess the information gain in such a PDF, which is fundamentally different from the traditional path-wise measurements. The information metric also avoids using the unknown truth to quantify the uncertainty reduction, making the method practical. Mathematical analysis exploiting simple illustrative examples is used to validate the strategy. Numerical simulations based on multiscale turbulent flows are then adopted to demonstrate the advantages of this strategy over some other methods. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 45 pages, 11 figures

MSC Class: 37N10; 93E11; 62E17; 37J25

Lagrangian Descriptors with Uncertainty

Authors: Nan Chen, Evelyn Lunasin, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Lagrangian descriptors provide a global dynamical picture of the geometric structures for arbitrarily time-dependent flows with broad applications. This paper develops a mathematical framework for computing Lagrangian descriptors when uncertainty appears. The uncertainty originates from estimating the underlying flow field as a natural consequence of data assimilation or statistical forecast. It a… ▽ More Lagrangian descriptors provide a global dynamical picture of the geometric structures for arbitrarily time-dependent flows with broad applications. This paper develops a mathematical framework for computing Lagrangian descriptors when uncertainty appears. The uncertainty originates from estimating the underlying flow field as a natural consequence of data assimilation or statistical forecast. It also appears in the resulting Lagrangian trajectories. The uncertainty in the flow field directly affects the path integration of the crucial nonlinear positive scalar function in computing the Lagrangian descriptor, making it fundamentally different from many other diagnostic methods. Despite being highly nonlinear and non-Gaussian, closed analytic formulae are developed to efficiently compute the expectation of such a scalar function due to the uncertain velocity field by exploiting suitable approximations. A rapid and accurate sampling algorithm is then built to assist the forecast of the probability density function (PDF) of the Lagrangian trajectories. Such a PDF provides the weight to combine the Lagrangian descriptors along different paths. Simple but illustrative examples are designed to show the distinguished behavior of using Lagrangian descriptors in revealing the flow field when uncertainty appears. Uncertainty can either completely erode the coherent structure or barely affect the underlying geometry of the flow field. The method is also applied for eddy identification, indicating that uncertainty has distinct impacts on detecting eddies at different time scales. Finally, when uncertainty is incorporated into the Lagrangian descriptor for inferring the source target, the likelihood criterion provides a very different conclusion from the deterministic methods. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 51 pages, 17 figures

Navigating Phase Space Transport with the Origin-Fate Map

Authors: Malcolm Hillebrand, Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen Wiggins, Charalampos Skokos

Abstract: We introduce and demonstrate the usage of the origin-fate map (OFM) as a tool for the detailed investigation of phase space transport in reactant-product type systems. For these systems, which exhibit clearly defined start and end states, it is possible to build a comprehensive picture of the lobe dynamics by considering backward and forward integration of sets of initial conditions to index their… ▽ More We introduce and demonstrate the usage of the origin-fate map (OFM) as a tool for the detailed investigation of phase space transport in reactant-product type systems. For these systems, which exhibit clearly defined start and end states, it is possible to build a comprehensive picture of the lobe dynamics by considering backward and forward integration of sets of initial conditions to index their origin and fate. We illustrate the method and its utility in the study of a two degrees of freedom caldera potential with four exits, demonstrating that the OFM not only recapitulates results from classical manifold theory, but even provides more detailed information about complex lobe structures. The OFM allows the detection of dynamically significant transitions caused by the creation of new lobes, and is also able to guide the prediction of the position of unstable periodic orbits (UPOs). Further, we compute the OFM on the periodic orbit dividing surface (PODS) associated with the transition state of a caldera entrance, which allows for a powerful analysis of reactive trajectories. The intersection of the manifolds corresponding to this UPO with other manifolds in the phase space results in the appearance of lobes on the PODS, which are directly classified by the OFM. This allows computations of branching ratios and the exploration of a fractal cascade of lobes as the caldera is stretched, which results in fluctuations in the branching ratio and chaotic selectivity. The OFM is found to be a simple and very useful tool with a vast range of descriptive and quantitative applications. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 11 pages, 10 figures

Performance of chaos diagnostics based on Lagrangian descriptors. Application to the 4D standard map

Authors: Sebastian Zimper, Arnold Ngapasare, Malcolm Hillebrand, Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen R. Wiggins, Charalampos Skokos

Abstract: We investigate the ability of simple diagnostics based on Lagrangian descriptor (LD) computations of initially nearby orbits to detect chaos in conservative dynamical systems with phase space dimensionality higher than two. In particular, we consider the recently introduced methods of the difference ($D_L^n$) and the ratio ($R_L^n$) of the LDs of neighboring orbits, as well as a quantity ($S_L^n$)… ▽ More We investigate the ability of simple diagnostics based on Lagrangian descriptor (LD) computations of initially nearby orbits to detect chaos in conservative dynamical systems with phase space dimensionality higher than two. In particular, we consider the recently introduced methods of the difference ($D_L^n$) and the ratio ($R_L^n$) of the LDs of neighboring orbits, as well as a quantity ($S_L^n$) related to the finite-difference second spatial derivative of the LDs, and use them to determine the chaotic or regular nature of ensembles of orbits of a prototypical area-preserving map model, the 4-dimensional (4D) symplectic standard map. Using the distributions of the indices' values we determine appropriate thresholds to discriminate between regular and chaotic orbits, and compare the obtained characterization against that achieved by the Smaller Alignment Index (SALI) method of chaos detection, by recording the percentage agreement $P_A$ between the two classifications. We study the influence of various factors on the performance of these indices, and show that the increase of the final number of orbit iterations T and the order n of the indices (i.e. the dimensionality of the space where the considered nearby orbits lie), as well as the decrease of the distance $σ$ of neighboring orbits, increase the $P_A$ values along with the required computational effort. Balancing between these two factors we find appropriate T, n and $σ$ values, which allow the efficient use of the $D_L^n$, $R_L^n$ and $S_L^n$ indices as short time and computationally cheap chaos diagnostics achieving $P_A \gtrsim 90 \%$, with $D_L^n$ and $S_L^n$ having larger $P_A$ values than $R_L^n$. Our results show that the three LDs-based indices perform better for systems with large percentages of chaotic orbits. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Quantifying chaos using Lagrangian descriptors

Authors: Malcolm Hillebrand, Sebastian Zimper, Arnold Ngapasare, Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen R. Wiggins, Charalampos Skokos

Abstract: We present and validate simple and efficient methods to estimate the chaoticity of orbits in low dimensional dynamical systems from computations of Lagrangian descriptors (LDs) on short time scales. Two quantities are proposed for determining the chaotic or regular nature of orbits in a system's phase space, which are based on the values of the LDs of these orbits and of nearby ones: The differenc… ▽ More We present and validate simple and efficient methods to estimate the chaoticity of orbits in low dimensional dynamical systems from computations of Lagrangian descriptors (LDs) on short time scales. Two quantities are proposed for determining the chaotic or regular nature of orbits in a system's phase space, which are based on the values of the LDs of these orbits and of nearby ones: The difference (DNLD) and ratio (RNLD) of neighboring orbits' LDs. We find that, typically, these indicators are able to correctly characterize the chaotic or regular nature of orbits to better than 90 % agreement with results obtained by implementing the Smaller Alignment Index (SALI) method, which is a well established chaos detection technique. Further investigating the performance of the two introduced quantities we discuss the effects of the total integration time and of the spacing between the used neighboring orbits on the accuracy of the methods, finding that even typical short time, coarse grid LD computations are sufficient to provide a reliable quantification of a system's chaotic component, using less CPU time than the SALI. In addition to quantifying chaos, the introduced indicators have the ability to reveal details about the systems' local and global chaotic phase space structure. Our findings clearly suggest that LDs can also be used to quantify and investigate chaos in continuous and discrete low dimensional dynamical systems. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2022; v1 submitted 21 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Phase space transport in a symmetric Caldera potential with three index-1 saddles and no minima

Authors: M. Katsanikas, M. Agaoglou, S. Wiggins, A. M. Mancho

Abstract: We apply the method of Lagrangian Descriptors (LDs) to a symmetric Caldera-type potential energy surface which has three index-1 saddles surrounding a relatively flat region that contains no minimum. Using this method we show the phase space transport mechanism that is responsible for the existence and non-existence of the phenomenon of dynamical matching for this form of Caldera potential energy… ▽ More We apply the method of Lagrangian Descriptors (LDs) to a symmetric Caldera-type potential energy surface which has three index-1 saddles surrounding a relatively flat region that contains no minimum. Using this method we show the phase space transport mechanism that is responsible for the existence and non-existence of the phenomenon of dynamical matching for this form of Caldera potential energy surface. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures

The Nature of Reactive and Non-reactive Trajectories for a Three Dimensional Caldera Potential Energy Surface

Authors: Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We used for the first time the method of periodic orbit dividing surfaces in a non-integrable Hamiltonian system with three degrees of freedom. We have studied the structure of these four dimensional objects in the five dimensional phase space. This method enabled us to detect the reactive and non-reactive trajectories in a three dimensional Caldera potential energy surface. We distinguished four… ▽ More We used for the first time the method of periodic orbit dividing surfaces in a non-integrable Hamiltonian system with three degrees of freedom. We have studied the structure of these four dimensional objects in the five dimensional phase space. This method enabled us to detect the reactive and non-reactive trajectories in a three dimensional Caldera potential energy surface. We distinguished four distinct types of trajectory behavior. Two of the types of trajectories could only occur in a three dimensional Caldera potential energy surface and not in a two dimensional surface, and we have shown that this is a result of homoclinic intersections. These homoclinic intersections were analyzed with the method of Lagrangian descriptors. Finally, we were able to detect and describe the phenomenon of dynamical matching in the three dimensional Caldera potential energy surface, which is an important mechanism for understanding the reaction dynamics of organic molecules. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 13 figures, it was accepted for publication in Physica D

Lagrangian Descriptors and the Action Integral of Classical Mechanics

Authors: V. J. García-Garrido, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we bring together the method of Lagrangian descriptors and the principle of least action, or more precisely, of stationary action, in both deterministic and stochastic settings. In particular, we show how the action can be used as a Lagrangian descriptor. This provides a direct connection between Lagrangian descriptors and Hamiltonian mechanics, and we illustrate this connection with… ▽ More In this paper we bring together the method of Lagrangian descriptors and the principle of least action, or more precisely, of stationary action, in both deterministic and stochastic settings. In particular, we show how the action can be used as a Lagrangian descriptor. This provides a direct connection between Lagrangian descriptors and Hamiltonian mechanics, and we illustrate this connection with benchmark examples. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

The Influence of a Parameter that Controls the Asymmetry of a Potential Energy Surface with an Entrance Channel and Two Potential Wells

Authors: Makrina Agaoglou, Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we study an asymmetric valley-ridge inflection point (VRI) potential, whose energy surface (PES) features two sequential index-1 saddles (the upper and the lower), with one saddle having higher energy than the other and two potential wells separated by the lower index-1 saddle. We show how the depth and the flatness of our potential changes as we modify the parameter that controls th… ▽ More In this paper we study an asymmetric valley-ridge inflection point (VRI) potential, whose energy surface (PES) features two sequential index-1 saddles (the upper and the lower), with one saddle having higher energy than the other and two potential wells separated by the lower index-1 saddle. We show how the depth and the flatness of our potential changes as we modify the parameter that controls the asymmetry as well as how the branching ratio (ratio of the trajectories that enter each well) is changing as we modify the same parameter and its correlation with the area of the lobes as they have formulated by the stable and unstable manifolds that have been extracted from the gradient of the LD scalar fields. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

MSC Class: 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

The time evolution of the trajectories after the selectivity in a symmetric potential energy surface with a post-transition-state bifurcation

Authors: Douglas Haigh, Matthaios Katsanikas, Makrina Agaoglou, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Selectivity is an important phenomenon in chemical reaction dynamics. This can be quantified by the branching ratio of the trajectories that visit one or the other wells to the total number of trajectories in a system with a potential with two sequential index-1 saddles and two wells (top well and bottom well). In our case, the branching ratio is 1:1 because of the symmetry of our potential energy… ▽ More Selectivity is an important phenomenon in chemical reaction dynamics. This can be quantified by the branching ratio of the trajectories that visit one or the other wells to the total number of trajectories in a system with a potential with two sequential index-1 saddles and two wells (top well and bottom well). In our case, the branching ratio is 1:1 because of the symmetry of our potential energy surface. The mechanisms of transport and the behavior of the trajectories in this kind of systems have been studied recently. In this paper we study the time evolution after the selectivity as energy varies using periodic orbit dividing surfaces. We investigate what happens after the first visit of a trajectory to the region of the top or the bottom well for different values of energy. We answer the natural question, what is the destiny of these trajectories? △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

MSC Class: 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

Bifurcation of dividing surfaces constructed from a pitchfork bifurcation of periodic orbits in a symmetric potential energy surface with a post-transition-state bifurcation

Authors: Matthaios Katsanikas, Makrina Agaoglou, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this work we analyze the bifurcation of dividing surfaces that occurs as a result of a pitchfork bifurcation of periodic orbits in a two degrees of freedom Hamiltonian System. The potential energy surface of the system that we consider has four critical points: two minima, a high energy saddle and a lower energy saddle separating two wells (minima). In this paper we study the structure, the ran… ▽ More In this work we analyze the bifurcation of dividing surfaces that occurs as a result of a pitchfork bifurcation of periodic orbits in a two degrees of freedom Hamiltonian System. The potential energy surface of the system that we consider has four critical points: two minima, a high energy saddle and a lower energy saddle separating two wells (minima). In this paper we study the structure, the range, and the minimum and maximum extent of the periodic orbit dividing surfaces of the family of periodic orbits of the lower saddle as a function of the total energy. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 15 pages

MSC Class: 34Cxx; 70Hxx

The Generalization of the Periodic Orbit Dividing Surface in Hamiltonian Systems with three or more degrees of freedom -- I

Authors: M. Katsanikas, S. Wiggins

Abstract: We present a method that generalizes the periodic orbit dividing surface construction for Hamiltonian systems with three or more degrees of freedom. We construct a torus using as a basis a periodic orbit and we extend this to a $2n-2$ dimensional object in the $2n-1$ dimensional energy surface. We present our methods using benchmark examples for two and three degree of freedom Hamiltonian systems… ▽ More We present a method that generalizes the periodic orbit dividing surface construction for Hamiltonian systems with three or more degrees of freedom. We construct a torus using as a basis a periodic orbit and we extend this to a $2n-2$ dimensional object in the $2n-1$ dimensional energy surface. We present our methods using benchmark examples for two and three degree of freedom Hamiltonian systems to illustrate the corresponding algorithm for this construction. Towards this end we use the normal form quadratic Hamiltonian system with two and three degrees of freedom. We found that the periodic orbit dividing surface can provide us the same dynamical information as the dividing surface constructed using normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds. This is significant because, in general, computations of normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds are very difficult in Hamiltonian systems with three or more degrees of freedom. However, our method avoids this computation and the only information that we need is the location of one periodic orbit. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2021; v1 submitted 2 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 26 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in the International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos

Bifurcation Study on a Degenerate Double van der Waals Cirque Potential Energy Surface using Lagrangian Descriptors

Authors: M. Katsanikas, B. Aguilar Sanjuan, F. Gonzalez Montoya, V. Garcia-Garrido, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper, we explore the dynamics of a Hamiltonian system after a double van der Waals potential energy surface degenerates into a single well. The energy of the system is increased from the bottom of the potential well up to the dissociation energy, which occurs when the system becomes open. In particular, we study the bifurcations of the basic families of periodic orbits of this system as t… ▽ More In this paper, we explore the dynamics of a Hamiltonian system after a double van der Waals potential energy surface degenerates into a single well. The energy of the system is increased from the bottom of the potential well up to the dissociation energy, which occurs when the system becomes open. In particular, we study the bifurcations of the basic families of periodic orbits of this system as the energy increases using Lagrangian descriptors and Poincaré maps. We investigate the capability of Lagrangian descriptors to find periodic orbits of bifurcating families for the case of resonant, saddle-node and pitchfork bifurcations. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 14 figures

The bifurcations of the critical points and the role of the depth in a symmetric Caldera potential energy surface

Authors: Y. Geng, M. Katsanikas, M. Agaoglou, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this work, we continue the study of the bifurcations of the critical points in a symmetric Caldera potential energy surface. In particular, we study the influence of the depth of the potential on the trajectory behavior before and after the bifurcations of the critical points. We observe two different types of trajectory behavior: dynamical matching and the non-existence of dynamical matching.… ▽ More In this work, we continue the study of the bifurcations of the critical points in a symmetric Caldera potential energy surface. In particular, we study the influence of the depth of the potential on the trajectory behavior before and after the bifurcations of the critical points. We observe two different types of trajectory behavior: dynamical matching and the non-existence of dynamical matching. Dynamical matching is a phenomenon that limits the way in which a trajectory can exit the Caldera based solely on how it enters the Caldera. Furthermore, we discuss two different types of symmetric Caldera potential energy surface and the transition from the one type to the other through the bifurcations of the critical points. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

MSC Class: 34Cxx; 70Hxx

The Dynamical Significance of Valley-Ridge Inflection Points

Authors: V. J. García-Garrido, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we demonstrate that valley-ridge inflection (VRI) points of a potential energy surface (PES) have a dynamical influence on the fate of trajectories of the underlying Hamiltonian system. These points have attracted the attention of chemists in the past decades when studying selectivity problems in organic chemical reactions whose energy landscape exhibits a post-transition-state bifur… ▽ More In this paper we demonstrate that valley-ridge inflection (VRI) points of a potential energy surface (PES) have a dynamical influence on the fate of trajectories of the underlying Hamiltonian system. These points have attracted the attention of chemists in the past decades when studying selectivity problems in organic chemical reactions whose energy landscape exhibits a post-transition-state bifurcation in the region between two sequential saddles without an intervening energy minimum. To address the dynamical significance of valley-ridge inflection points, we construct a symmetric potential energy function that allows us to move the location of the VRI point while keeping the locations and energies of the critical points fixed. In this setup, we carry out a parametric study of the dynamical behavior of ensembles of trajectories in terms of the energy of the chemical system and the position of the VRI point. Our analysis reveals that the location of the VRI point controls the fraction of trajectories that recross the high energy saddle region of the PES without entering either of the potential wells that are separated by the low energy saddle. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures

MSC Class: 70Kxx; 34Cxx; 70Hxx

Reactive Islands for Three Degrees-of-Freedom Hamiltonian Systems

Authors: Vladimír Krajňák, Víctor J. García-Garrido, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We develop the geometrical, analytical, and computational framework for reactive island theory for three degrees-of-freedom time-independent Hamiltonian systems. In this setting, the dynamics occurs in a 5-dimensional energy surface in phase space and is governed by four-dimensional stable and unstable manifolds of a three-dimensional normally hyperbolic invariant sphere. The stable and unstable m… ▽ More We develop the geometrical, analytical, and computational framework for reactive island theory for three degrees-of-freedom time-independent Hamiltonian systems. In this setting, the dynamics occurs in a 5-dimensional energy surface in phase space and is governed by four-dimensional stable and unstable manifolds of a three-dimensional normally hyperbolic invariant sphere. The stable and unstable manifolds have the geometrical structure of spherinders and we provide the means to investigate the ways in which these spherinders and their intersections determine the dynamical evolution of trajectories. This geometrical picture is realized through the computational technique of Lagrangian descriptors. In a set of trajectories, Lagrangian descriptors allow us to identify the ones closest to a stable or unstable manifold. Using an approximation of the manifold on a surface of section we are able to calculate the flux between two regions of the energy surface. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2021; v1 submitted 12 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Visualizing the Phase Space of the HeI_2 van der Waals Complex using Lagrangian Descriptors

Authors: M. Agaoglou, V. J. Garcia-Garrido, M. Katsanikas, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we demonstrate the capability of the method of Lagrangian descriptors to unveil the phase space structures that characterize transport in high-dimensional symplectic maps. In order to illustrate its use, we apply it to a four-dimensional symplectic map model that is used in chemistry to explore the nonlinear dynamics of van der Waals complexes. The advantage of this technique is that… ▽ More In this paper we demonstrate the capability of the method of Lagrangian descriptors to unveil the phase space structures that characterize transport in high-dimensional symplectic maps. In order to illustrate its use, we apply it to a four-dimensional symplectic map model that is used in chemistry to explore the nonlinear dynamics of van der Waals complexes. The advantage of this technique is that it allows us to easily and effectively extract the invariant manifolds that determine the dynamics of the system under study by means of examining the intersections of the underlying phase space structures with low-dimensional slices. With this approach, one can perform a full computational phase space tomography from which three-dimensional representations of the higher-dimensional phase space can be systematically reconstructed. This analysis may be of much help for the visualization and understanding of the nonlinear dynamical mechanisms that take place in high-dimensional systems. In this context, we demonstrate how this tool can be used to detect whether the stable and unstable manifolds of the system intersect forming turnstile lobes that enclose a certain phase space volume, and the nature of their intersection. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 24 pages

MSC Class: 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

Hamiltonian pitchfork bifurcation in transition across index-1 saddles

Authors: Wenyang Lyu, Shibabrat Naik, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We study the effect of changes in the parameters of a two-dimensional potential energy surface on the phase space structures relevant for chemical reaction dynamics. The changes in the potential energy are representative of chemical reactions such as isomerization between two structural conformations or dissociation of a molecule with an intermediate. We present a two degrees of freedom quartic Ha… ▽ More We study the effect of changes in the parameters of a two-dimensional potential energy surface on the phase space structures relevant for chemical reaction dynamics. The changes in the potential energy are representative of chemical reactions such as isomerization between two structural conformations or dissociation of a molecule with an intermediate. We present a two degrees of freedom quartic Hamiltonian that shows pitchfork bifurcation when the parameters are varied and we derive the bifurcation criteria relating the parameters. Next, we describe the phase space structures - unstable periodic orbits and their associated invariant manifolds, and phase space dividing surfaces - for the systems that can show trajectories undergo reaction defined as crossing of a potential energy barrier. Finally, we quantify the reaction dynamics for these systems by obtaining the directional flux and gap time distribution to illustrate the dependence on total energy and the coupling strength between the two degrees of freedom. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 16 pages, 8 figures

MSC Class: 37J06 (Primary); 37M25; 37N20 (Secondary)

From Poincare Maps to Lagrangian Descriptors: The Case of the Valley Ridge Inflection Point Potential

Authors: R. Crossley, M. Agaoglou, M. Katsanikas, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we compare the method of Lagrangian descriptors with the classical method of Poincare maps for revealing the phase space structure of two degree-of-freedom Hamiltonian systems. The comparison is carried out by considering the dynamics of a two degree-of-freedom system having a valley ridge inflection point (VRI) potential energy surface. VRI potential energy surfaces have four critic… ▽ More In this paper we compare the method of Lagrangian descriptors with the classical method of Poincare maps for revealing the phase space structure of two degree-of-freedom Hamiltonian systems. The comparison is carried out by considering the dynamics of a two degree-of-freedom system having a valley ridge inflection point (VRI) potential energy surface. VRI potential energy surfaces have four critical points: a high energy saddle and a lower energy saddle separating two wells. In between the two saddle points is a valley ridge inflection point that is the point where the potential energy surface geometry changes from a valley to a ridge. The region between the two saddles forms a reaction channel and the dynamical issue of interest is how trajectories cross the high energy saddle, evolve towards the lower energy saddle, and select a particular well to enter. Lagrangian descriptors and Poincare maps are compared for their ability to determine the phase space structures that govern this dynamical process. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 19 pages

MSC Class: 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

The Influence of a Pitchfork Bifurcation of the Critical Points of a Symmetric Caldera Potential Energy Surface on Dynamical Matching

Authors: Y. Geng, M. Katsanikas, M. Agaoglou, S. Wiggins

Abstract: Many organic chemical reactions are governed by potential energy surfaces that have a region with the topographical features of a caldera. If the caldera has a symmetry then trajectories transiting the caldera region are observed to exhibit a phenomenon that is referred to as dynamical matching. Dynamical matching is a constraint that restricts the way in which a trajectory can exit the caldera ba… ▽ More Many organic chemical reactions are governed by potential energy surfaces that have a region with the topographical features of a caldera. If the caldera has a symmetry then trajectories transiting the caldera region are observed to exhibit a phenomenon that is referred to as dynamical matching. Dynamical matching is a constraint that restricts the way in which a trajectory can exit the caldera based solely on how it enters the caldera. In this paper we show that bifurcations of the critical points of the caldera potential energy surface can destroy dynamical matching even when the symmetry of the caldera is not affected by the bifurcation. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures

MSC Class: 34Cxx; 70Hxx

Transport and roaming on the Double van der Waals Potential Energy Surface

Authors: Francisco Gonzalez Montoya, Víctor J. García-Garrido, Broncio Aguilar-Sanjuan, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: This paper explores the phase space structures characterising transport for a double-well van der Waals potential surface. Trajectories are classified as inter-well, intra-well, and escaping-from-a-well to define different dynamical fates. In particular, roaming trajectories, which are a new paradigm in chemical reaction dynamics, are observed. We apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors to unco… ▽ More This paper explores the phase space structures characterising transport for a double-well van der Waals potential surface. Trajectories are classified as inter-well, intra-well, and escaping-from-a-well to define different dynamical fates. In particular, roaming trajectories, which are a new paradigm in chemical reaction dynamics, are observed. We apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors to uncover the boundaries between the fates. We find that the boundaries between different fates are the stable and unstable manifolds of the hyperbolic periodic orbits, which bifurcate when the energy increases. The methodology presented here applies to other open systems with a double-well potential. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2021; v1 submitted 21 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

MSC Class: 70H07; 70K05; 70K50

Phase space structure and escape time dynamics in a Van der Waals model for exothermic reactions

Authors: Francisco Gonzalez Montoya, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We study the phase space structures that control the transport in a classical Hamiltonian model for a chemical reaction. This model has been proposed to study the yield of products in an ultracold exothermic reaction. In the considered model, two elements determine the evolution of the system: a Van der Waals force and short-range force associated with the many-body interactions. In the previous w… ▽ More We study the phase space structures that control the transport in a classical Hamiltonian model for a chemical reaction. This model has been proposed to study the yield of products in an ultracold exothermic reaction. In the considered model, two elements determine the evolution of the system: a Van der Waals force and short-range force associated with the many-body interactions. In the previous work has been used small random periodic changes in the direction of the momentum to simulate the short-range many-body interactions. In the present work, random Gaussian bumps have been added to the Van der Waals potential energy simulate the short-range effects between the particles in the system. We compare both variants of the model and explain their differences similarities and differences from a phase space perspective. In order to visualize the structures that direct the dynamics in the phase space, we construct a natural Lagrangian descriptor for Hamiltonian systems based on the Maupertuis action $S_0$. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2020; v1 submitted 28 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

MSC Class: 70K05; 70H99

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 102, 062203 (2020)

Tuning the Branching Ratio in a Symmetric Potential Energy Surface with a Post-Transition State Bifurcation using External Time Dependence

Authors: V. J. García-Garrido, M. Katsanikas, M. Agaoglou, S. Wiggins

Abstract: Chemical selectivity, as quantified by a branching ratio, is a phenomenon relevant for many organic chemical reactions. It may be exhibited on a potential energy surface that features a valley-ridge inflection point in the region between two sequential index-1 saddles, with one saddle having higher energy than the other. Reaction occurs when a trajectory crosses the region of the higher energy sad… ▽ More Chemical selectivity, as quantified by a branching ratio, is a phenomenon relevant for many organic chemical reactions. It may be exhibited on a potential energy surface that features a valley-ridge inflection point in the region between two sequential index-1 saddles, with one saddle having higher energy than the other. Reaction occurs when a trajectory crosses the region of the higher energy saddle (the entrance channel) and approaches the lower energy saddle. On both sides of the lower energy saddle, there are two wells and the question we address in this work is that, given an initial ensemble of trajectories, what is the relative fraction of trajectories that enter each well. For a symmetric PES this fraction is 1:1. We consider a symmetric PES subjected to a time-periodic forcing characterized by an amplitude, frequency, and phase. In this letter we analyse how the branching ratio depends on these three parameters. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 9 figures

MSC Class: 34C37; 70K44; 34Cxx; 70Hxx

Phase Space Analysis of the Dynamics on a Potential Energy Surface with an Entrance Channel and Two Potential Wells

Authors: M. Katsanikas, V. J. García-Garrido, M. Agaoglou, S. Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we unveil the geometrical template of phase space structures that governs transport in a Hamiltonian system described by a potential energy surface with an entrance/exit channel and two wells separated by an index-1 saddle. For the analysis of the nonlinear dynamics mechanisms, we apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors, a trajectory-based scalar diagnostic tool that is capable of… ▽ More In this paper we unveil the geometrical template of phase space structures that governs transport in a Hamiltonian system described by a potential energy surface with an entrance/exit channel and two wells separated by an index-1 saddle. For the analysis of the nonlinear dynamics mechanisms, we apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors, a trajectory-based scalar diagnostic tool that is capable of providing a detailed phase space tomography of the interplay between the invariant manifolds of the system. Our analysis reveals that, the stable and unstable manifolds of two families of unstable periodic orbits (UPOs) that exist in the regions of the wells are responsible for controlling the access to the wells of trajectories that enter the system through the channel. In fact, we demonstrate that the heteroclinic and homoclinic connections that arise in the system between the manifolds of the families of UPOs characterize the branching ratio, a relevant quantity used to measure product distributions in chemical reaction dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2020; v1 submitted 21 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 17 pages, 10 figures

MSC Class: 70H12; 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 102, 012215 (2020)

The Phase Space Mechanism for Selectivity in a Symmetric Potential Energy Surface with a Post-Transition-State Bifurcation

Authors: M. Agaoglou, V. J. Garcıa-Garrido, M. Katsanikas, S. Wiggins

Abstract: Chemical selectivity is a phenomenon displayed by potential energy surfaces (PES) that is relevant for many organic chemical reactions whose PES feature a valley-ridge inflection point (VRI) in the region between two sequential index-1 saddles. In this letter we describe the underlying dynamical phase space mechanism that qualitatively determines the product distributions resulting from bifurcatin… ▽ More Chemical selectivity is a phenomenon displayed by potential energy surfaces (PES) that is relevant for many organic chemical reactions whose PES feature a valley-ridge inflection point (VRI) in the region between two sequential index-1 saddles. In this letter we describe the underlying dynamical phase space mechanism that qualitatively determines the product distributions resulting from bifurcating reaction pathways. We show that selectivity is a consequence of the heteroclinic and homoclinic connections established between the invariant manifolds of the families of unstable periodic orbits (UPOs) present in the system. The geometry of the homoclinic and heteroclininc connections is determined using the technique of Lagrangian descriptors, a trajectory-based scalar technique with the capability of unveiling the geometrical template of phase space structures that characterizes transport. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures

MSC Class: 70H12; 37N99; 70K44; 70H05; 70H07; 34C45; 34C37

Elementary exposition of realizing phase space structures relevant to chemical reaction dynamics

Authors: Wenyang Lyu, Shibabrat Naik, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this article, we review the analytical and numerical approaches for computing the phase space structures in two degrees-of-freedom Hamiltonian systems that arise in chemical reactions. In particular, these phase space structures are the unstable periodic orbit associated with an index-1 saddle, the periodic orbit dividing surface, and the stable and unstable invariant manifolds of the unstable… ▽ More In this article, we review the analytical and numerical approaches for computing the phase space structures in two degrees-of-freedom Hamiltonian systems that arise in chemical reactions. In particular, these phase space structures are the unstable periodic orbit associated with an index-1 saddle, the periodic orbit dividing surface, and the stable and unstable invariant manifolds of the unstable periodic orbit. We review the approaches in the context of a two degrees-of-freedom Hamiltonian with a quartic potential coupled with a quadratic potential. We derive the analytical form of the phase space structures for the integrable case and visualize their geometry on the three dimensional energy surface. We then investigate the bifurcation of the dividing surface due to the changes in the parameters of the potential energy. We also review the numerical method of \emph{turning point} and present its new modification called the \emph{turning point based on configuration difference} for computing the unstable periodic orbit in two degrees-of-freedom systems. These methods are implemented in the open-source python package, UPOsHam~\cite{Lyu2020}. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 27 pages, 20 figures

The role of depth and flatness of a potential energy surface in chemical reaction dynamics

Authors: Wenyang Lyu, Shibabrat Naik, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this study, we analyze how changes in the geometry of a potential energy surface in terms of depth and flatness can affect the reaction dynamics. We formulate depth and flatness in the context of one and two degree-of-freedom (DOF) Hamiltonian normal form for the saddle-node bifurcation and quantify their influence on chemical reaction dynamics. In a recent work, García-Garrido, Naik, and Wiggi… ▽ More In this study, we analyze how changes in the geometry of a potential energy surface in terms of depth and flatness can affect the reaction dynamics. We formulate depth and flatness in the context of one and two degree-of-freedom (DOF) Hamiltonian normal form for the saddle-node bifurcation and quantify their influence on chemical reaction dynamics. In a recent work, García-Garrido, Naik, and Wiggins illustrated how changing the well-depth of a potential energy surface (PES) can lead to a saddle-node bifurcation. They have shown how the geometry of cylindrical manifolds associated with the rank-1 saddle changes en route to the saddle-node bifurcation. Using the formulation presented here, we show how changes in the parameters of the potential energy control the depth and flatness and show their role in the quantitative measures of a chemical reaction. We quantify this role of the depth and flatness by calculating the ratio of the bottleneck-width and well-width, reaction probability (also known as transition fraction or population fraction), gap time (or first passage time) distribution, and directional flux through the dividing surface (DS) for small to high values of total energy. The results obtained for these quantitative measures are in agreement with the qualitative understanding of the reaction dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 16 figures

MSC Class: 37J06 (Primary); 37M25; 37N20 (Secondary)

The tipping times in an Arctic sea ice system under influence of extreme events

Authors: Fang Yang, Yayun Zheng, Jinqiao Duan, Ling Fu, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In light of the rapid recent retreat of Arctic sea ice, the extreme weather events triggering the variability in Arctic ice cover has drawn increasing attention. A non-Gaussian $α$-stable Lévy process is thought to be an appropriate model to describe such extreme event. The maximal likely trajectory, based on the nonlocal Fokker-Planck equation, is applied to a nonautonomous Arctic sea ice system… ▽ More In light of the rapid recent retreat of Arctic sea ice, the extreme weather events triggering the variability in Arctic ice cover has drawn increasing attention. A non-Gaussian $α$-stable Lévy process is thought to be an appropriate model to describe such extreme event. The maximal likely trajectory, based on the nonlocal Fokker-Planck equation, is applied to a nonautonomous Arctic sea ice system under $α$-stable Lévy noise. Two types of tipping times, the early-warning tipping time and the disaster-happening tipping time, are used to predict the critical time for the maximal likely transition from a perennially ice-covered state to a seasonally ice-free one, and from a seasonally ice-free state to a perennially ice-free one, respectively. We find that the increased intensity of extreme events results in shorter warning time for sea ice melting, and that an enhanced greenhouse effect will intensify this influence, making the arrival of warning time significantly earlier. Meanwhile, for the enhanced greenhouse effect, we discover that increased intensity and frequency of extreme events will advance the disaster-happening tipping time, in which an ice-free state is maintained throughout the year in the Arctic Ocean. Finally, we identify values of Lévy index $α$ and noise intensity $ε$ in $αε$-space that can trigger a transition between the Arctic sea ice state. These results provide an effective theoretical framework for studying Arctic sea ice variations under the influence of extreme events. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2020; v1 submitted 4 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Exploring Isomerization Dynamics on a Potential Energy Surface with an Index-2 Saddle using Lagrangian Descriptors

Authors: Víctor J. García-Garrido, Makrina Agaoglou, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we explore the phase space structures governing isomerization dynamics on a potential energy surface with four wells and an index-2 saddle. For this model, we analyze the influence that coupling both degrees of freedom of the system and breaking the symmetry of the problem have on the geometrical template of phase space structures that characterizes reaction. To achieve this goal we… ▽ More In this paper we explore the phase space structures governing isomerization dynamics on a potential energy surface with four wells and an index-2 saddle. For this model, we analyze the influence that coupling both degrees of freedom of the system and breaking the symmetry of the problem have on the geometrical template of phase space structures that characterizes reaction. To achieve this goal we apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors, a technique with the capability of unveiling the key invariant manifolds that determine transport processes in nonlinear dynamical systems. This approach reveals with extraordinary detail the intricate geometry of the isomerization routes interconnecting the different potential wells, and provides us with valuable information to distinguish between initial conditions that undergo sequential and concerted isomerization. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 37 pages, 18 Figures (Submitted)

Revealing Roaming on the Double Morse Potential Energy Surface with Lagrangian Descriptors

Authors: Francisco Gonzalez Montoya, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper, we analyse the phase space structure of the roaming dynamics in a two degree of freedom potential energy surface consisting of two identical planar Morse potentials separated by a distance. This potential energy surface was previously studied in [1], and it has two potential wells surrounded by an unbounded flat region containing no critical points. We study the phase space mechanis… ▽ More In this paper, we analyse the phase space structure of the roaming dynamics in a two degree of freedom potential energy surface consisting of two identical planar Morse potentials separated by a distance. This potential energy surface was previously studied in [1], and it has two potential wells surrounded by an unbounded flat region containing no critical points. We study the phase space mechanism for the transference between the wells using the method of Lagrangian descriptors. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2020; v1 submitted 3 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

MSC Class: 70-XX

Detection of Dynamical Matching in a Caldera Hamiltonian System using Lagrangian Descriptors

Authors: M. Katsanikas, Víctor J. García-Garrido, S. Wiggins

Abstract: The goal of this paper is to apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors to reveal the phase space mechanism by which a Caldera-type potential energy surface (PES) exhibits the dynamical matching phenomenon. Using this technique, we can easily establish that the non-existence of dynamical matching is a consequence of heteroclinic connections between the unstable manifolds of the unstable periodic o… ▽ More The goal of this paper is to apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors to reveal the phase space mechanism by which a Caldera-type potential energy surface (PES) exhibits the dynamical matching phenomenon. Using this technique, we can easily establish that the non-existence of dynamical matching is a consequence of heteroclinic connections between the unstable manifolds of the unstable periodic orbits (UPOs) of the upper index-1 saddles (entrance channels to the Caldera) and the stable manifolds of the family of UPOs of the central minimum of the Caldera, resulting in the temporary trapping of trajectories. Moreover, dynamical matching will occur when there is no heteroclinic connection, which allows trajectories to enter and exit the Caldera without interacting with the shallow region of the central minimum. Knowledge of this phase space mechanism is relevant because it allows us to effectively predict the existence, and non-existence, of dynamical matching. In this work we explore a stretched Caldera potential by means of Lagrangian descriptors, allowing us to accurately compute the critical value for the stretching parameter for which dynamical matching behavior occurs in the system. This approach is shown to provide a tremendous advantage for exploring this mechanism in comparison to other methods from nonlinear dynamics that use phase space dividing surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2020; v1 submitted 26 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 16 pages, 9 figures

MSC Class: 34C37; 70K44; 34Cxx; 70Hxx

Journal ref: Int.J. Bifurcation Chaos 30, 2030026 - Feature article (2020)

The Dynamical Matching Mechanism in Phase Space for Caldera-Type Potential Energy Surfaces

Authors: M. Katsanikas, V. J. García-Garrido, S. Wiggins

Abstract: Dynamical matching occurs in a variety of important organic chemical reactions. It is observed to be a result of a potential energy surface (PES) having specific geometric features. In particular, a region of relative flatness where entrance and exit to this region is controlled by index-one saddles. Examples of potential energy surfaces having these features are the so-called caldera potential en… ▽ More Dynamical matching occurs in a variety of important organic chemical reactions. It is observed to be a result of a potential energy surface (PES) having specific geometric features. In particular, a region of relative flatness where entrance and exit to this region is controlled by index-one saddles. Examples of potential energy surfaces having these features are the so-called caldera potential energy surfaces. We develop a predictive level of understanding of the phenomenon of dynamical matching in a caldera potential energy surface. We show that the phase space structure that governs dynamical matching is a particular type of heteroclinic trajectory which gives rise to trapping of trajectories in the central region of the caldera PES. When the heteroclinic trajectory is broken, as a result of parameter variations, then dynamical matching occurs. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures

MSC Class: 34C37; 70K44; 34Cxx; 70Hxx

Roaming at Constant Kinetic Energy: Chesnavich's Model and the Hamiltonian Isokinetic Thermostat

Authors: Vladimír Krajňák, Gregory S. Ezra, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We consider the roaming mechanism for chemical reactions under the nonholonomic constraint of constant kinetic energy. Our study is carried out in the context of the Hamiltonian isokinetic thermostat applied to Chesnavich's model for an ion-molecule reaction. Through an analysis of phase space structures we show that imposing the nonholonomic constraint does not prevent the system from exhibiting… ▽ More We consider the roaming mechanism for chemical reactions under the nonholonomic constraint of constant kinetic energy. Our study is carried out in the context of the Hamiltonian isokinetic thermostat applied to Chesnavich's model for an ion-molecule reaction. Through an analysis of phase space structures we show that imposing the nonholonomic constraint does not prevent the system from exhibiting roaming dynamics, and that the origin of the roaming mechanism turns out to be analogous to that found in the previously studied Hamiltonian case. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1909.05551

Journal ref: Regul. Chaot. Dyn. 24, 615-627 (2019)

Using Lagrangian descriptors to uncover invariant structures in Chesnavich's Isokinetic Model with application to roaming

Authors: Vladimir Krajnak, Gregory S. Ezra, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Complementary to existing applications of Lagrangian descriptors as an exploratory method, we use Lagrangian descriptors to find invariant manifolds in a system where some invariant structures have already been identified. In this case we use the parametrisation of a periodic orbit to construct a Lagrangian descriptor that will be locally minimised on its invariant manifolds. The procedure is appl… ▽ More Complementary to existing applications of Lagrangian descriptors as an exploratory method, we use Lagrangian descriptors to find invariant manifolds in a system where some invariant structures have already been identified. In this case we use the parametrisation of a periodic orbit to construct a Lagrangian descriptor that will be locally minimised on its invariant manifolds. The procedure is applicable (but not limited) to systems with highly unstable periodic orbits, such as the isokinetic Chesnavich CH4+ model subject to a Hamiltonian isokinetic theromostat. Aside from its low computational requirements, the method enables us to study the invariant structures responsible for roaming in the isokinetic Chesnavich CH4+ model. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2020; v1 submitted 12 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Tilting and Squeezing: Phase space geometry of Hamiltonian saddle-node bifurcation and its influence on chemical reaction dynamics

Authors: Víctor J. García-Garrido, Shibabrat Naik, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this article we present the influence of a Hamiltonian saddle-node bifurcation on the high-dimensional phase space structures that mediate reaction dynamics. To achieve this goal, we identify the phase space invariant manifolds using Lagrangian descriptors, which is a trajectory-based diagnostic suitable for the construction of a complete ``phase space tomography'' by means of analyzing dynamic… ▽ More In this article we present the influence of a Hamiltonian saddle-node bifurcation on the high-dimensional phase space structures that mediate reaction dynamics. To achieve this goal, we identify the phase space invariant manifolds using Lagrangian descriptors, which is a trajectory-based diagnostic suitable for the construction of a complete ``phase space tomography'' by means of analyzing dynamics on low-dimensional slices. First, we build a Hamiltonian system with one degree-of-freedom (DoF) that models reaction, and study the effect of adding a parameter to the potential energy function that controls the depth of the well. Then, we extend this framework to a saddle-node bifurcation for a two DoF Hamiltonian, constructed by coupling a harmonic oscillator, i.e. a bath mode, to the other reactive DoF in the system. For this problem, we describe the phase space structures associated with the rank-1 saddle equilibrium point in the bottleneck region, which is a Normally Hyperbolic Invariant Manifold (NHIM) and its stable and unstable manifolds. Finally, we address the qualitative changes in the reaction dynamics of the Hamiltonian system due to changes in the well depth of the potential energy surface that gives rise to the saddle-node bifurcation. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 54 pages, 15 figures, Submitted to Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation

MSC Class: 37N99; 34C45; 34C60; 70H05; 70K50

Dynamics of the Morse Oscillator: Analytical Expressions for Trajectories, Action-Angle Variables, and Chaotic Dynamics

Authors: Vladimír Krajňák, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We consider the one degree-of-freedom Hamiltonian system defined by the Morse potential energy function (the "Morse oscillator"). We use the geometry of the level sets to construct explicit expressions for the trajectories as a function of time, their period for the bounded trajectories, and action-angle variables. We use these trajectories to prove sufficient conditions for chaotic dynamics, in t… ▽ More We consider the one degree-of-freedom Hamiltonian system defined by the Morse potential energy function (the "Morse oscillator"). We use the geometry of the level sets to construct explicit expressions for the trajectories as a function of time, their period for the bounded trajectories, and action-angle variables. We use these trajectories to prove sufficient conditions for chaotic dynamics, in the sense of Smale horseshoes, for the time-periodically perturbed Morse oscillator using a Melnikov type approach. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Journal ref: Int. J. Bifurcation Chaos 29, 1950157 (2019)

Finding NHIM in 2 and 3 degrees-of-freedom with Hénon-Heiles type potential

Authors: Shibabrat Naik, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We present the capability of Lagrangian descriptors for revealing the high dimensional phase space structures that are of interest in nonlinear Hamiltonian systems with index-1 saddle. These phase space structures include normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds and their stable and unstable manifolds, and act as codimenision-1 barriers to phase space transport. The method is applied to classical t… ▽ More We present the capability of Lagrangian descriptors for revealing the high dimensional phase space structures that are of interest in nonlinear Hamiltonian systems with index-1 saddle. These phase space structures include normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds and their stable and unstable manifolds, and act as codimenision-1 barriers to phase space transport. The method is applied to classical two and three degrees-of-freedom Hamiltonian systems which have implications for myriad applications in physics and chemistry. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 6 figures. This manuscript is better served as dessert to the main course: arXiv:1903.10264

MSC Class: 37N99; 34C45; 34C60; 70H05; 70H06; 70H15

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 100, 022204 (2019)

Finding NHIM: Identifying High Dimensional Phase Space Structures in Reaction Dynamics using Lagrangian Descriptors

Authors: Shibabrat Naik, Víctor J. García-Garrido, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Phase space structures such as dividing surfaces, normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds, their stable and unstable manifolds have been an integral part of computing quantitative results such as transition fraction, stability erosion in multi-stable mechanical systems, and reaction rates in chemical reaction dynamics. Thus, methods that can reveal their geometry in high dimensional phase space (4… ▽ More Phase space structures such as dividing surfaces, normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds, their stable and unstable manifolds have been an integral part of computing quantitative results such as transition fraction, stability erosion in multi-stable mechanical systems, and reaction rates in chemical reaction dynamics. Thus, methods that can reveal their geometry in high dimensional phase space (4 or more dimensions) need to be benchmarked by comparing with known results. In this study, we assess the capability of one such method called Lagrangian descriptor for revealing the types of high dimensional phase space structures associated with index-1 saddle in Hamiltonian systems. The Lagrangian descriptor based approach is applied to two and three degree-of-freedom quadratic Hamiltonian systems where the high dimensional phase space structures are known, that is as closed-form analytical expressions. This leads to a direct comparison of features in the Lagrangian descriptor plots and the phase space structures' intersection with an isoenergetic two-dimensional surface and hence provides a validation of the approach. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 39 pages, 7 figures, Submitted to Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation

MSC Class: 37N99; 34C45; 34C60; 70H05; 70H06; 70H15

Phase Space Analysis of the Non-Existence of Dynamical Matching in a Stretched Caldera Potential Energy Surface

Authors: Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we continue our studies of the two dimensional caldera potential energy surface in a parametrized family that allows for a study of the effect of symmetry on the phase space structures that govern how trajectories enter, cross, and exit the region of the caldera. As a particular form of trajectory crossing, we are able to determine the effect of symmetry and phase space structure on… ▽ More In this paper we continue our studies of the two dimensional caldera potential energy surface in a parametrized family that allows for a study of the effect of symmetry on the phase space structures that govern how trajectories enter, cross, and exit the region of the caldera. As a particular form of trajectory crossing, we are able to determine the effect of symmetry and phase space structure on dynamical matching. We show that there is a critical value of the symmetry parameter which controls the phase space structures responsible for the manner of crossing, interacting with the central region (including trapping in this region) and exiting the caldera. We provide an explanation for the existence of this critical value in terms of the behavior of the Henon stability parameter for the associated periodic orbits. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 10 pages, International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos (in press). arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1809.06702

Influence of mass and potential energy surface geometry on roaming in Chesnavich's CH$_4^+$ model

Authors: Vladimir Krajnak, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: Chesnavich's model Hamiltonian for the reaction CH$_4^+ \rightarrow$ CH$_3^+$ is known to exhibit a range of interesting dynamical phenomena including roaming. The model system consists of two parts: a rigid, symmetric top representing the CH$_3^+$ ion and a free H atom. We study roaming in this model with focus on the evolution of geometrical features of the invariant manifolds in phase space tha… ▽ More Chesnavich's model Hamiltonian for the reaction CH$_4^+ \rightarrow$ CH$_3^+$ is known to exhibit a range of interesting dynamical phenomena including roaming. The model system consists of two parts: a rigid, symmetric top representing the CH$_3^+$ ion and a free H atom. We study roaming in this model with focus on the evolution of geometrical features of the invariant manifolds in phase space that govern roaming under variations of the mass of the free atom m and a parameter a that couples radial and angular motion. In addition, we establish an upper bound on the prominence of roaming in Chesnavich's model. The bound highlights the intricacy of roaming as a type of dynamics on the verge between isomerisation and nonreactivity as it relies on generous access to the potential wells to allow reactions as well as a prominent area of high potential that aids sufficient transfer of energy between the degrees of freedom to prevent isomerisation. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 149, 094109 (2018)

Phase Space Structure and Transport in a Caldera Potential Energy Surface

Authors: Matthaios Katsanikas, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We study phase space transport in a 2D caldera potential energy surface (PES) using techniques from nonlinear dynamics. The caldera PES is characterized by a flat region or shallow minimum at its center surrounded by potential walls and multiple symmetry related index one saddle points that allow entrance and exit from this intermediate region.We have discovered four qualitatively distinct cases o… ▽ More We study phase space transport in a 2D caldera potential energy surface (PES) using techniques from nonlinear dynamics. The caldera PES is characterized by a flat region or shallow minimum at its center surrounded by potential walls and multiple symmetry related index one saddle points that allow entrance and exit from this intermediate region.We have discovered four qualitatively distinct cases of the structure of the phase space that govern phase space transport. These cases are categorized according to the total energy and the stability of the periodic orbits associated with the family of the central minimum, the bifurcations of the same family, and the energetic accessibility of the index one saddles. In each case we have computed the invariant manifolds of the unstable periodic orbits of the central region of the potential and the invariant manifolds of the unstable periodic orbits of the families of periodic orbits associated with the index one saddles. We have found that there are three distinct mechanisms determined by the invariant manifold structure of the unstable periodic orbits govern the phase space transport. The first mechanism explains the nature of the entrance of the trajectories from the region of the low energy saddles into the caldera and how they may become trapped in the central region of the potential. The second mechanism describes the trapping of the trajectories that begin from the central region of the caldera, their transport to the regions of the saddles, and the nature of their exit from the caldera. The third mechanism describes the phase space geometry responsible for the dynamical matching of trajectories originally proposed by Carpenter and described in Collins et al. (2014) for the two dimensional caldera PES that we consider. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2018; v1 submitted 18 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 24 pages, International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos (in press)

Journal ref: Int. J. Bifurcation Chaos 28, 1830042 - Feature Article (2018) [20 pages]

Dynamics on the Double Morse Potential: A Paradigm for Roaming Reactions with no Saddle Points

Authors: Barry K. Carpenter, Gregory S. Ezra, Stavros C. Farantos, Zeb C. Kramer, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: In this paper we analyze a two degree of freedom Hamiltonian system constructed from two planar Morse potentials. The resulting potential energy surface has two potential wells surrounded by an unbounded flat region containing no critical points. In addition, the model has an index one saddle between the potential wells. We study the dynamical mechanisms underlying transport between the two potent… ▽ More In this paper we analyze a two degree of freedom Hamiltonian system constructed from two planar Morse potentials. The resulting potential energy surface has two potential wells surrounded by an unbounded flat region containing no critical points. In addition, the model has an index one saddle between the potential wells. We study the dynamical mechanisms underlying transport between the two potential wells, with emphasis on the role of the flat region surrounding the wells. The model allows us to probe many of the features of the roaming mechanism whose reaction dynamics are of current interest in the chemistry community. △ Less

Submitted 20 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: 22 pages, 31 figures

Response to: "Limitations of the Method of Lagrangian Descriptors" [arXiv:1510.04838]

Authors: F. Balibrea-Iniesta, J. Curbelo, V. J. García-Garrido, C. Lopesino, A. M. Mancho, C. Mendoza, S. Wiggins

Abstract: This Response is concerned with the recent Comment of Ruiz-Herrera, "Limitations of the Method of Lagrangian Descriptors" [arXiv:1510.04838], criticising the method of Lagrangian Descriptors. In spite of the significant body of literature asserting the contrary, Ruiz-Herrera claims that the method fails to reveal the presence of stable and unstable manifolds of hyperbolic trajectories in incompres… ▽ More This Response is concerned with the recent Comment of Ruiz-Herrera, "Limitations of the Method of Lagrangian Descriptors" [arXiv:1510.04838], criticising the method of Lagrangian Descriptors. In spite of the significant body of literature asserting the contrary, Ruiz-Herrera claims that the method fails to reveal the presence of stable and unstable manifolds of hyperbolic trajectories in incompressible systems and in almost all linear systems. He supports this claim by considering the method of Lagrangian descriptors applied to three specific examples. However in this response we show that Ruiz-Herrera does not understand the proper application and interpretation of the method and, when correctly applied, the method beautifully and unambiguously detects the stable and unstable manifolds of the hyperbolic trajectories in his examples. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures

Phase space barriers and dividing surfaces in the absence of critical points of the potential energy: Application to roaming in ozone

Authors: Frédéric A. L. Mauguière, Peter Collins, Zeb C. Kramer, Barry K. Carpenter, Gregory S. Ezra, Stavros C. Farantos, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We examine the phase space structures that govern reaction dynamics in the absence of critical points on the potential energy surface. We show that in the vicinity of hyperbolic invariant tori it is possible to define phase space dividing surfaces that are analogous to the dividing surfaces governing transition from reactants to products near a critical point of the potential energy surface. We in… ▽ More We examine the phase space structures that govern reaction dynamics in the absence of critical points on the potential energy surface. We show that in the vicinity of hyperbolic invariant tori it is possible to define phase space dividing surfaces that are analogous to the dividing surfaces governing transition from reactants to products near a critical point of the potential energy surface. We investigate the problem of capture of an atom by a diatomic molecule and show that a normally hyperbolic invariant manifold exists at large atom-diatom distances, away from any critical points on the potential. This normally hyperbolic invariant manifold is the anchor for the construction of a dividing surface in phase space, which defines the outer or loose transition state governing capture dynamics. We present an algorithm for sampling an approximate capture dividing surface, and apply our methods to the recombination of the ozone molecule. We treat both 2 and 3 degree of freedom models with zero total angular momentum. We have located the normally hyperbolic invariant manifold from which the orbiting (outer) transition state is constructed. This forms the basis for our analysis of trajectories for ozone in general, but with particular emphasis on the roaming trajectories. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 35 pages, 3 figures

The Role of Variability in Transport for Large-Scale Flow Dynamics

Authors: Kayo Ide, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We develop a framework to study the role of variability in transport across a streamline of a reference flow. Two complementary schemes are presented: a graphical approach for individual cases, and an analytical approach for general properties. The spatially nonlinear interaction of dynamic variability and the reference flow results in flux variability. The characteristic time-scale of the dynamic… ▽ More We develop a framework to study the role of variability in transport across a streamline of a reference flow. Two complementary schemes are presented: a graphical approach for individual cases, and an analytical approach for general properties. The spatially nonlinear interaction of dynamic variability and the reference flow results in flux variability. The characteristic time-scale of the dynamic variability and the length-scale of the flux variability in a unit of flight-time govern the spatio-temporal interaction that leads to transport. The non-dimensional ratio of the two characteristic scales is shown to be a a critical parameter. The pseudo-lobe sequence along the reference streamline describes spatial coherency and temporal evolution of transport. For finite-time transport from an initial time up to the present, the characteristic length-scale of the flux variability regulates the width of the pseudo-lobes. The phase speed of pseudo-lobe propagation averages the reference flow and the flux variability. In contrast, for definite transport over a fixed time interval and spatial segment, the characteristic time-scale of the dynamic variability regulates the width of the pseudo-lobes. Generation of the pseudo-lobe sequence appears to be synchronous with the dynamic variability, although it propagates with the reference flow. In either case, the critical characteristic ratio is found to be one, corresponding to a resonance of the flux variability with the reference flow. Using a kinematic model, we demonstrate the framework for two types of transport in a blocked flow of the mid-latitude atmosphere: across the meandering jet axis and between the jet and recirculating cell. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 49 pages, 13 figures

Nonstatistical dynamics on the caldera

Authors: Peter Collins, Zeb C. Kramer, Barry K. Carpenter, Gregory S. Ezra, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: We explore both classical and quantum dynamics of a model potential exhibiting a caldera: that is, a shallow potential well with two pairs of symmetry related index one saddles associated with entrance/exit channels. Classical trajectory simulations at several different energies confirm the existence of the `dynamical matching' phenomenon originally proposed by Carpenter, where the momentum direct… ▽ More We explore both classical and quantum dynamics of a model potential exhibiting a caldera: that is, a shallow potential well with two pairs of symmetry related index one saddles associated with entrance/exit channels. Classical trajectory simulations at several different energies confirm the existence of the `dynamical matching' phenomenon originally proposed by Carpenter, where the momentum direction associated with an incoming trajectory initiated at a high energy saddle point determines to a considerable extent the outcome of the reaction (passage through the diametrically opposing exit channel). By studying a `stretched' version of the caldera model, we have uncovered a generalized dynamical matching: bundles of trajectories can reflect off a hard potential wall so as to end up exiting predominantly through the transition state opposite the reflection point. We also investigate the effects of dissipation on the classical dynamics. In addition to classical trajectory studies, we examine the dynamics of quantum wave packets on the caldera potential (stretched and unstretched). These computations reveal a quantum mechanical analogue of the `dynamical matching' phenomenon, where the initial expectation value of the momentum direction for the wave packet determines the exit channel through which most of the probability density passes to product. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: 54 pages, 17 figures

Roaming dynamics in Ketene isomerization

Authors: Frédéric A. L. Mauguière, Peter Collins, Gregory S. Ezra, Stavros C. Farantos, Stephen Wiggins

Abstract: A reduced two dimensional model is used to study Ketene isomerization reaction. In light of recent results by Ulusoy \textit{et al.} [J.\ Phys.\ Chem.\ A {\bf 117}, 7553 (2013)], the present work focuses on the generalization of the roaming mechanism to the Ketene isomerization reaction by applying our phase space approach previously used to elucidate the roaming phenomenon in ion-molecule reactio… ▽ More A reduced two dimensional model is used to study Ketene isomerization reaction. In light of recent results by Ulusoy \textit{et al.} [J.\ Phys.\ Chem.\ A {\bf 117}, 7553 (2013)], the present work focuses on the generalization of the roaming mechanism to the Ketene isomerization reaction by applying our phase space approach previously used to elucidate the roaming phenomenon in ion-molecule reactions. Roaming is again found be associated with the trapping of trajectories in a phase space region between two dividing surfaces; trajectories are classified as reactive or nonreactive, and are further naturally classified as direct or non-direct (roaming). The latter long-lived trajectories are trapped in the region of non-linear mechanical resonances, which in turn define alternative reaction pathways in phase space. It is demonstrated that resonances associated with periodic orbits provide a dynamical explanation of the quantum mechanical resonances found in the isomerization rate constant calculations by Gezelter and Miller [J.\ Chem.\ Phys.\ {\bf 103}, 7868-7876 (1995)]. Evidence of the trapping of trajectories by `sticky' resonant periodic orbits is provided by plotting Poincaré surfaces of section, and a gap time analysis is carried out in order to investigate the statistical assumption inherent in transition state theory for Ketene isomerization. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 22 pages, 9 figures