-
Pattern Formation as a Resilience Mechanism in Cancer Immunotherapy
Authors:
Molly Brennan,
Andrew L. Krause,
Edgardo Villar-Sepúlveda,
Christopher B. Prior
Abstract:
Mathematical and computational modelling in oncology has played an increasingly important role in not only understanding the impact of various approaches to treatment on tumour growth, but in optimizing dosing regimens and aiding the development of treatment strategies. However, as with all modelling, only an approximation is made in the description of the biological and physical system. Here we s…
▽ More
Mathematical and computational modelling in oncology has played an increasingly important role in not only understanding the impact of various approaches to treatment on tumour growth, but in optimizing dosing regimens and aiding the development of treatment strategies. However, as with all modelling, only an approximation is made in the description of the biological and physical system. Here we show that tissue-scale spatial structure can have a profound impact on the resilience of tumours to immunotherapy using a classical model incorporating IL-2 compounds and effector cells as treatment parameters. Using linear stability analysis, numerical continuation, and direct simulations, we show that diffusing cancer cell populations can undergo pattern-forming (Turing) instabilities, leading to spatially-structured states that persist far into treatment regimes where the corresponding spatially homogeneous systems would uniformly predict a cancer-free state. These spatially-patterned states persist in a wide range of parameters, as well as under time-dependent treatment regimes. Incorporating treatment via domain boundaries can increase this resistance to treatment in the interior of the domain, further highlighting the importance of spatial modelling when designing treatment protocols informed by mathematical models. Counter-intuitively, this mechanism shows that increased effector cell mobility can increase the resilience of tumours to treatment. We conclude by discussing practical and theoretical considerations for understanding this kind of spatial resilience in other models of cancer treatment, in particular those incorporating more realistic spatial transport.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Beyond-all-order asymptotics for homoclinic snaking of localised patterns in reaction-transport systems
Authors:
Edgardo Villar-Sepúlveda
Abstract:
Spatially localised stationary patterns of arbitrary wide spatial extent emerge from subcritical Turing bifurcations in one-dimensional reaction-diffusion systems. They lie on characteristic bifurcation curves that oscillate around a Maxwell point in a homoclinic snaking phenomenon. Here, a generalisation of the exponential asymptotics method by Chapman \& Kozyreff is developed to provide leading-…
▽ More
Spatially localised stationary patterns of arbitrary wide spatial extent emerge from subcritical Turing bifurcations in one-dimensional reaction-diffusion systems. They lie on characteristic bifurcation curves that oscillate around a Maxwell point in a homoclinic snaking phenomenon. Here, a generalisation of the exponential asymptotics method by Chapman \& Kozyreff is developed to provide leading-order expressions for the width of the snaking region close to a Turing bifurcation's super/sub-critical transition in arbitrary $n$-component reaction-diffusion systems. First, general expressions are provided for the regular asymptotic approximation of the Maxwell point, which depends algebraically on the parametric distance from the codimension-two super/sub-critical Turing bifurcation. Then, expressions are derived for the width of the snaking, which is exponentially small in the same distance. The general theory is developed using a vectorised form of regular and exponential asymptotic expansions for localised patterns, which are matched at a Stokes line. Detailed calculations for a particular example are algebraically cumbersome, depend sensitively on the form of the reaction kinetics, and rely on the summation of a weakly convergent series obtained via optimal truncation. Nevertheless, the process can be automated, and code is provided that carries out the calculations automatically, only requiring the user to input the model, and the values of parameters at a codimension-two bifurcation. The general theory also applies to higher-order equations, including those that can be recast as a reaction-diffusion system. The theory is illustrated by comparing numerical computations of localised patterns in two versions of the Swift-Hohenberg equation with different nonlinearities, and versions of activator-inhibitor reaction-diffusion systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2025; v1 submitted 5 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Designing reaction-cross-diffusion systems with Turing and wave instabilities
Authors:
Edgardo Villar-Sepúlveda,
Alan R. Champneys,
Andrew L. Krause
Abstract:
General conditions are established under which reaction-cross-diffusion systems can undergo spatiotemporal pattern-forming instabilities. Recent work has focused on designing systems theoretically and experimentally to exhibit patterns with specific features, but the case of non-diagonal diffusion matrices has yet to be analysed. Here, a framework is presented for the design of general $n$-compone…
▽ More
General conditions are established under which reaction-cross-diffusion systems can undergo spatiotemporal pattern-forming instabilities. Recent work has focused on designing systems theoretically and experimentally to exhibit patterns with specific features, but the case of non-diagonal diffusion matrices has yet to be analysed. Here, a framework is presented for the design of general $n$-component reaction-cross-diffusion systems that exhibit Turing and wave instabilities of a given wavelength. For a fixed set of reaction kinetics, it is shown how to choose diffusion matrices that produce each instability; conversely, for a given diffusion tensor, how to choose linearised kinetics. The theory is applied to several examples including a hyperbolic reaction-diffusion system, two different 3-component models, and a spatio-temporal version of the Ross-Macdonald model for the spread of malaria.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Pattern formation of bulk-surface reaction-diffusion systems in a ball
Authors:
Edgardo Villar-Sepúlveda,
Alan R. Champneys,
Davide Cusseddu,
Anotida Madzvamuse
Abstract:
Weakly nonlinear amplitude equations are derived for the onset of spatially extended patterns on a general class of n-component bulk-surface reaction-diffusion systems in a ball, under the assumption of linear kinetics in the bulk and coupling Robin-type boundary conditions. Linear analysis shows conditions under which various pattern modes can become unstable to either generalised pitchfork or tr…
▽ More
Weakly nonlinear amplitude equations are derived for the onset of spatially extended patterns on a general class of n-component bulk-surface reaction-diffusion systems in a ball, under the assumption of linear kinetics in the bulk and coupling Robin-type boundary conditions. Linear analysis shows conditions under which various pattern modes can become unstable to either generalised pitchfork or transcritical bifurcations depending on the parity of the spatial wavenumber. Weakly nonlinear analysis is used to derive general expressions for the multi-component amplitude equations of different patterned states. These reduced-order systems are found to agree with prior normal forms for pattern formation bifurcations with O(3) symmetry and they provide information on the stability of bifurcating patterns of different symmetry types. The analysis is complemented with numerical results using a dedicated bulk-surface finite-element method. The theory is illustrated in two examples: a bulk-surface version of the Brusselator and a four-component bulk-surface cell-polarity model.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2025; v1 submitted 10 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
A case study of multiple wave solutions in a reaction-diffusion system using invariant manifolds and global bifurcations
Authors:
Edgardo Villar-Sepúlveda,
Pablo Aguirre,
Víctor F. Breña-Medina
Abstract:
A thorough analysis is performed to find traveling waves in a qualitative reaction-diffusion system inspired by a predator-prey model. We provide rigorous results coming from a standard local stability analysis, numerical bifurcation analysis, and relevant computations of invariant manifolds to exhibit homoclinic and heteroclinic connections, and periodic orbits in the associated traveling wave sy…
▽ More
A thorough analysis is performed to find traveling waves in a qualitative reaction-diffusion system inspired by a predator-prey model. We provide rigorous results coming from a standard local stability analysis, numerical bifurcation analysis, and relevant computations of invariant manifolds to exhibit homoclinic and heteroclinic connections, and periodic orbits in the associated traveling wave system with four components. In so doing, we present and describe a zoo of different traveling wave solutions. In addition, homoclinic chaos is manifested via both saddle-focus and focus-focus bifurcations as well as a Belyakov point. An actual computation of global invariant manifolds near a focus-focus homoclinic bifurcation is also presented to unravel a multiplicity of wave solutions in the model.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2022; v1 submitted 12 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
