-
Probabilistic Stability Assessment for Active Distribution Grids
Authors:
Sebastian Liemann,
Lia Strenge,
Paul Schultz,
Holm Hinners,
Johannis Porst,
Marcel Sarstedt,
Frank Hellmann
Abstract:
This paper demonstrates the concept of probabilistic stability assessment on large-signal stability in the use case of short circuits in an active distribution grid. Here, the concept of survivability is applied, which extends classical stability assessments by evaluating the stability and operational limits during transients for a wide range of operating points and failures. For this purpose, a f…
▽ More
This paper demonstrates the concept of probabilistic stability assessment on large-signal stability in the use case of short circuits in an active distribution grid. Here, the concept of survivability is applied, which extends classical stability assessments by evaluating the stability and operational limits during transients for a wide range of operating points and failures. For this purpose, a free, open-source, and computationally efficient environment (Julia) for dynamic simulation of power grids is used to demonstrate its capabilities. The model implementation is validated against established commercial software and deviations are minimal with respect to power flow and dynamic simulations.The results of a large-scale survivability analysis reveal i) a broad field of application for probabilistic stability analysis and ii) that new non-intuitive stability correlations can be obtained. Hence,the proposed method shows strong potential to efficiently conduct power system stability analysis in active distribution grids.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
A normal form for grid forming power grid actors
Authors:
Raphael Kogler,
Anton Plietzsch,
Paul Schultz,
Frank Hellmann
Abstract:
Future power grids will be operating a large number of heterogeneous dynamical actors. Many of these will contribute to the fundamental dynamical stability of the system. By taking a complexity theoretic perspective we derive a normal form for grid forming components in power grids. This allows analyzing the grids systemic properties without the need for detailed technical models. Our approach is…
▽ More
Future power grids will be operating a large number of heterogeneous dynamical actors. Many of these will contribute to the fundamental dynamical stability of the system. By taking a complexity theoretic perspective we derive a normal form for grid forming components in power grids. This allows analyzing the grids systemic properties without the need for detailed technical models. Our approach is based on the physics of the power flow in the grid on the one hand, and on the common symmetry that is inherited from the control objectives grid-forming power grid components are trying to achieve. We provide a first experimental validation that this normal form can capture the behavior of complex grid forming inverters without any knowledge of the underlying technology, and show that it can be used to make technology independent statements on the stability of future grids.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2022; v1 submitted 1 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
A multilayer, multi-timescale model approach for economic and frequency control in power grids
Authors:
Lia Strenge,
Paul Schultz,
Jürgen Kurths,
Jörg Raisch,
Frank Hellmann
Abstract:
Power systems are subject to fundamental changes due to the increasing infeed of decentralised renewable energy sources and storage. The decentralised nature of the new actors in the system requires new concepts for structuring the power grid, and achieving a wide range of control tasks ranging from seconds to days. Here we introduce a multiplex dynamical network model covering all control timesca…
▽ More
Power systems are subject to fundamental changes due to the increasing infeed of decentralised renewable energy sources and storage. The decentralised nature of the new actors in the system requires new concepts for structuring the power grid, and achieving a wide range of control tasks ranging from seconds to days. Here we introduce a multiplex dynamical network model covering all control timescales. Crucially, we combine a decentralised, self-organised low-level control and a smart grid layer of devices that can aggregate information from remote sources. The safety-critical task of frequency control is performed by the former, the economic objective of demand matching dispatch by the latter. Having both aspects present in the same model allows us to study the interaction between the layers. Remarkably, we find that adding communication in the form of aggregation does not improve the performance in the cases considered. Instead, the self-organised state of the system already contains the information required to learn the demand structure in the entire grid. The model introduced here is highly flexible, and can accommodate a wide range of scenarios relevant to future power grids. We expect that it is especially useful in the context of low-energy microgrids with distributed generation.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Iterative learning control in prosumer-based microgrids with hierarchical control
Authors:
Lia Strenge,
Xiaohan Jing,
Ruth Boersma,
Paul Schultz,
Frank Hellmann,
Jürgen Kurths,
Jörg Raisch,
Thomas Seel
Abstract:
Power systems are subject to fundamental changes due to the increasing infeed of renewable energy sources. Taking the accompanying decentralization of power generation into account, the concept of prosumer-based microgrids gives the opportunity to rethink structuring and operation of power systems from scratch. In a prosumer-based microgrid, each power grid node can feed energy into the grid and d…
▽ More
Power systems are subject to fundamental changes due to the increasing infeed of renewable energy sources. Taking the accompanying decentralization of power generation into account, the concept of prosumer-based microgrids gives the opportunity to rethink structuring and operation of power systems from scratch. In a prosumer-based microgrid, each power grid node can feed energy into the grid and draw energy from the grid. The concept allows for spatial aggregation such that also an interaction between microgrids can be represented as a prosumer-based microgrid. The contribution of this work is threefold: (i) we propose a decentralized hierarchical control approach in a network including different time scales, (ii) we use iterative learning control to compensate periodic demand patterns and save lower layer control energy and (iii) we assure asymptotic stability and monotonic convergence in the iteration domain for the linearized dynamics and validate the performance by simulating the nonlinear dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2020; v1 submitted 26 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Delay master stability of inertial oscillator networks
Authors:
Reyk Börner,
Paul Schultz,
Benjamin Ünzelmann,
Deli Wang,
Frank Hellmann,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
Time lags occur in a vast range of real-world dynamical systems due to finite reaction times or propagation speeds. Here we derive an analytical approach to determine the asymptotic stability of synchronous states in networks of coupled inertial oscillators with constant delay. Building on the master stability formalism, our technique provides necessary and sufficient delay master stability condit…
▽ More
Time lags occur in a vast range of real-world dynamical systems due to finite reaction times or propagation speeds. Here we derive an analytical approach to determine the asymptotic stability of synchronous states in networks of coupled inertial oscillators with constant delay. Building on the master stability formalism, our technique provides necessary and sufficient delay master stability conditions. We apply it to two classes of potential future power grids, where processing delays in control dynamics will likely pose a challenge as renewable energies proliferate. Distinguishing between phase and frequency delay, our method offers an insight into how bifurcation points depend on the network topology of these system designs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Network-induced multistability: Lossy coupling and exotic solitary states
Authors:
Frank Hellmann,
Paul Schultz,
Patrycja Jaros,
Roman Levchenko,
Tomasz Kapitaniak,
Jürgen Kurths,
Yuri Maistrenko
Abstract:
The stability of synchronised networked systems is a multi-faceted challenge for many natural and technological fields, from cardiac and neuronal tissue pacemakers to power grids. In the latter case, the ongoing transition to distributed renewable energy sources is leading to a proliferation of dynamical actors. The desynchronization of a few or even one of those would likely result in a substanti…
▽ More
The stability of synchronised networked systems is a multi-faceted challenge for many natural and technological fields, from cardiac and neuronal tissue pacemakers to power grids. In the latter case, the ongoing transition to distributed renewable energy sources is leading to a proliferation of dynamical actors. The desynchronization of a few or even one of those would likely result in a substantial blackout. Thus the dynamical stability of the synchronous state has become a focus of power grid research in recent years. In this letter we uncover that the non-linear stability against large perturbations is dominated and threatened by the presence of \textit{solitary states} in which individual actors desynchronise. Remarkably, when taking physical losses in the network into account, the back-reaction of the network induces new {\it exotic} solitary states in the individual actors, and the stability characteristics of the synchronous state are dramatically altered. These novel effects will have to be explicitly taken into account in the design of future power grids, and their existence poses a challenge for control. While this letter focuses on power grids, the form of the coupling we explore here is generic, and the presence of new states is very robust. We thus strongly expect the results presented here to transfer to other systems of coupled heterogeneous Newtonian oscillators.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Bounding the first exit from the basin: Independence Times and Finite-Time Basin Stability
Authors:
Paul Schultz,
Frank Hellmann,
Kevin N. Webster,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
We study the stability of deterministic systems given sequences of large, jump-like perturbations. Our main result is to dervie a lower bound for the probability of the system to remain in the basin, given that perturbations are rare enough. This bound is efficient to evaluate numerically.
To quantify rare enough, we define the notion of the independence time of such a system. This is the time a…
▽ More
We study the stability of deterministic systems given sequences of large, jump-like perturbations. Our main result is to dervie a lower bound for the probability of the system to remain in the basin, given that perturbations are rare enough. This bound is efficient to evaluate numerically.
To quantify rare enough, we define the notion of the independence time of such a system. This is the time after which a perturbed state has probably returned close to the attractor, meaning that subsequent perturbations can be considered separately. The effect of jump-like perturbations that occur at least the independence time apart is thus well described by a fixed probability to exit the basin at each jump, allowing us to obtain the bound.
To determine the independence time, we introduce the concept of finite-time basin stability, which corresponds to the probability that a perturbed trajectory returns to an attractor within a given time. The independence time can then be determined as the time scale at which the finite-time basin stability reaches its asymptotic value. Besides that, finite-time basin stability is a novel probabilistic stability measure on its own, with potential broad applications in complex systems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
A Network of Networks Approach to Interconnected Power Grids
Authors:
Paul Schultz,
Frank Hellmann,
Jobst Heitzig,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
We present two different approaches to model power grids as interconnected networks of networks. Both models are derived from a model for spatially embedded mono-layer networks and are generalised to handle an arbitrary number of network layers. The two approaches are distinguished by their use case. The static glue stick construction model yields a multi-layer network from a predefined layer inte…
▽ More
We present two different approaches to model power grids as interconnected networks of networks. Both models are derived from a model for spatially embedded mono-layer networks and are generalised to handle an arbitrary number of network layers. The two approaches are distinguished by their use case. The static glue stick construction model yields a multi-layer network from a predefined layer interconnection scheme, i.e. different layers are attached with transformer edges. It is especially suited to construct multi-layer power grids with a specified number of nodes in and transformers between layers. We contrast it with a genuine growth model which we label interconnected layer growth model.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2016;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Deciphering the imprint of topology on nonlinear dynamical network stability
Authors:
Jan Nitzbon,
Paul Schultz,
Jobst Heitzig,
Jürgen Kurths,
Frank Hellmann
Abstract:
Coupled oscillator networks show a complex interrelations between topological characteristics of the network and the nonlinear stability of single nodes with respect to large but realistic perturbations. We extend previous results on these relations by incorporating sampling-based measures of the transient behaviour of the system, its survivability, as well as its asymptotic behaviour, its basin s…
▽ More
Coupled oscillator networks show a complex interrelations between topological characteristics of the network and the nonlinear stability of single nodes with respect to large but realistic perturbations. We extend previous results on these relations by incorporating sampling-based measures of the transient behaviour of the system, its survivability, as well as its asymptotic behaviour, its basin stability. By combining basin stability and survivability we uncover novel, previously unknown asymptotic states with solitary, desynchronized oscillators which are rotating with a frequency different from their natural one. They occur almost exclusively after perturbations at nodes with specific topological properties.
More generally we confirm and significantly refine the results on the distinguished role tree-shaped appendices play for nonlinear stability. We find a topological classification scheme for nodes located in such appendices, that exactly separates them according to their stability properties, thus establishing a strong link between topology and dynamics. Hence, the results can be used for the identification of vulnerable nodes in power grids or other coupled oscillator networks. From this classification we can derive general design principles for resilient power grids. We find that striving for homogeneous network topologies facilitates a better performance in terms of nonlinear dynamical network stability. While the employed second-order Kuramoto-like model is parametrized to be representative for power grids, we expect these insights to transfer to other critical infrastructure systems or complex network dynamics appearing in various other fields.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Tweaking Synchronisation by Link Addition
Authors:
Paul Schultz,
Thomas Peron,
Deniz Eroglu,
Thomas Stemler,
Gonzalo Marcelo Ramírez-Ávila,
Francisco A. Rodrigues,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
Natural and man-made networks often possess locally tree-like sub-structures. Taking such tree networks as our starting point, we show how the addition of links changes the synchronization properties of the network. We focus on two different methods of link addition. The first method adds single links that create cycles of a well-defined length. Following a topological approach we introduce cycles…
▽ More
Natural and man-made networks often possess locally tree-like sub-structures. Taking such tree networks as our starting point, we show how the addition of links changes the synchronization properties of the network. We focus on two different methods of link addition. The first method adds single links that create cycles of a well-defined length. Following a topological approach we introduce cycles of varying length and analyze how this feature, as well as the position in the network, alters the synchronous behaviour. We show that in particular short cycles can lead to a maximum change of the Laplacian's eigenvalue spectrum, dictating the synchronization properties of such networks. The second method connects a certain proportion of the initially unconnected nodes. We simulate dynamical systems on these network topologies, with the nodes' local dynamics being either a discrete or continuous. Here our main result is that a certain amount of additional links, with the relative position in the network being crucial, can be beneficial to ensure stable synchronization.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2016; v1 submitted 23 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Potentials and Limits to Basin Stability Estimation
Authors:
Paul Schultz,
Peter J. Menck,
Jobst Heitzig,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
Stability assessment methods for dynamical systems have recently been complemented by basin stability and derived measures, i.e. probabilistic statements whether systems remain in a basin of attraction given a distribution of perturbations. This requires numerical estimation via Monte-Carlo sampling and integration of differential equations. Here, we analyze the applicability of basin stability to…
▽ More
Stability assessment methods for dynamical systems have recently been complemented by basin stability and derived measures, i.e. probabilistic statements whether systems remain in a basin of attraction given a distribution of perturbations. This requires numerical estimation via Monte-Carlo sampling and integration of differential equations. Here, we analyze the applicability of basin stability to systems with basin geometries challenging for this numerical method, having fractal basin boundaries and riddled or intermingled basins of attraction. We find that numerical basin stability estimation is still meaningful for fractal boundaries but reaches its limits for riddled basins with holes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
A Random Growth Model for Power Grids and Other Spatially Embedded Infrastructure Networks
Authors:
Paul Schultz,
Jobst Heitzig,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
We propose a model to create synthetic networks that may also serve as a narrative of a certain kind of infrastructure network evolution. It consists of an initialization phase with the network extending tree-like for minimum cost and a growth phase with an attachment rule giving a trade-off between cost-optimization and redundancy. Furthermore, we implement the feature of some lines being split d…
▽ More
We propose a model to create synthetic networks that may also serve as a narrative of a certain kind of infrastructure network evolution. It consists of an initialization phase with the network extending tree-like for minimum cost and a growth phase with an attachment rule giving a trade-off between cost-optimization and redundancy. Furthermore, we implement the feature of some lines being split during the grid's evolution. We show that the resulting degree distribution has an exponential tail and may show a maximum at degree two, suitable to observations of real-world power grid networks. In particular, the mean degree and the slope of the exponential decay can be controlled in partial independence. To verify to which extent the degree distribution is described by our analytic form, we conduct statistical tests, showing that the hypothesis of an exponential tail is well-accepted for our model data.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
The impact of model detail on power grid resilience measures
Authors:
Sabine Auer,
Kirsten Kleis,
Paul Schultz,
Jürgen Kurths,
Frank Hellmann
Abstract:
Extreme events represent a challenge to natural as well as man-made systems. For critical infrastructure like power grids, we need to understand their resilience against large disturbances. Recently, new measures of the resilience of dynamical systems have been developed in the complex system literature. Basin stability and survivability respectively assess the asymptotic and transient behavior of…
▽ More
Extreme events represent a challenge to natural as well as man-made systems. For critical infrastructure like power grids, we need to understand their resilience against large disturbances. Recently, new measures of the resilience of dynamical systems have been developed in the complex system literature. Basin stability and survivability respectively assess the asymptotic and transient behavior of a system when subjected to arbitrary, localized but large perturbations. To employ these methods to assess the resilience of power grids, we need to choose a model of the power grid. So far the most popular model that has been studied is the classical swing equation model for the frequency response of generators and motors. In this paper we study a more sophisticated model of synchronous machines that also takes voltage dynamics into account, and compare it to the previously studied model. This model has been found to give an accurate picture of the long term evolution of synchronous machines in the engineering literature for post fault studies. We find evidence that some stable fix points of the swing equation become unstable when we add voltage dynamics. If this occurs the asymptotic behavior of the system can be dramatically altered, and basin stability estimates obtained with the swing equation can be dramatically wrong. We also find that the survivability does not change significantly when taking the voltage dynamics into account. Further, the limit cycle type asymptotic behaviour is strongly correlated with transient voltages that violate typical operational voltage bounds. Thus, transient voltage bounds are dominated by transient frequency bounds and play no large role for realistic parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Survivability of Deterministic Dynamical Systems
Authors:
Frank Hellmann,
Paul Schultz,
Carsten Grabow,
Jobst Heitzig,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
The notion of a part of phase space containing desired (or allowed) states of a dynamical system is important in a wide range of complex systems research. It has been called the safe operating space, the viability kernel or the sunny region. In this paper we define the notion of survivability: Given a random initial condition, what is the likelihood that the transient behaviour of a deterministic…
▽ More
The notion of a part of phase space containing desired (or allowed) states of a dynamical system is important in a wide range of complex systems research. It has been called the safe operating space, the viability kernel or the sunny region. In this paper we define the notion of survivability: Given a random initial condition, what is the likelihood that the transient behaviour of a deterministic system does not leave a region of desirable states. We demonstrate the utility of this novel stability measure by considering models from climate science, neuronal networks and power grids. We also show that a semi-analytic lower bound for the survivability of linear systems allows a numerically very efficient survivability analysis in realistic models of power grids. Our numerical and semi-analytic work underlines that the type of stability measured by survivability is not captured by common asymptotic stability measures.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2016; v1 submitted 3 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
