-
Spontaneous stochasticity in a 3d Weierstrass-ABC flow
Authors:
Antoine Barlet,
Adam Cheminet,
Bérengère Dubrulle,
Alexei A. Mailybaev
Abstract:
Chaotic systems are characterised by exponential separation between close-by trajectories, which in particular leads to deterministic unpredictability over an infinite time-window. It is now believed, that such butterfly effect is not fully relevant to account for the type of randomness observed in turbulence. For example, tracers in homogeneous isotropic flows are observed to separate algebraical…
▽ More
Chaotic systems are characterised by exponential separation between close-by trajectories, which in particular leads to deterministic unpredictability over an infinite time-window. It is now believed, that such butterfly effect is not fully relevant to account for the type of randomness observed in turbulence. For example, tracers in homogeneous isotropic flows are observed to separate algebraically, following a universal cubic growth, independent from the initial separation. This regime, known as Richardon's regime, suggests that at the level of trajectories, and unlike in chaos theory, randomness may in fact emerge in finite-time. This phenomenon called 'spontaneous stochasticity' originates from the singular nature of the underlying dynamics, and provides a candidate framework for turbulent randomness and transport. While spontaneous stochasticity has been mathematically formalised in simplified turbulence models, a precise and systematic tool for quantifying the various facets of this phenomenon is to this day missing. In particular, it is still unclear whether chaos is important for that behaviour to appear.
In this paper we introduce a 3d rough flow that can be tuned to present Lagrangian chaos. The flow is inspired by the Weierstrass function and is entitled 'the WABC model'. After analysing its properties, we define what is spontaneous stochasticity in this context. The provided formal definition is then adapted to better suit for numerical analysis. We present the results from Monte-Carlo simulations of Lagrangian particles in this flow. Within the numerical precision, we quantitatively observe the appearance of spontaneous stochasticity in this model. We investigate the influence of noise type and find that the observed spontaneous stochasticity does not depend on the chosen stochastic regularisations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Extreme statistics and extreme events in dynamical models of turbulence
Authors:
Xander M. de Wit,
Giulio Ortali,
Alessandro Corbetta,
Alexei A. Mailybaev,
Luca Biferale,
Federico Toschi
Abstract:
We present a study of the intermittent properties of a shell model of turbulence with unprecedented statistics, about $\sim 10^7$ eddy turn over time, achieved thanks to an implementation on a large-scale parallel GPU factory. This allows us to quantify the inertial range anomalous scaling properties of the velocity fluctuations up to the 24th order moment. Through a careful assessment of the stat…
▽ More
We present a study of the intermittent properties of a shell model of turbulence with unprecedented statistics, about $\sim 10^7$ eddy turn over time, achieved thanks to an implementation on a large-scale parallel GPU factory. This allows us to quantify the inertial range anomalous scaling properties of the velocity fluctuations up to the 24th order moment. Through a careful assessment of the statistical and systematic uncertainties, we show that none of the phenomenological and theoretical models previously proposed in the literature to predict the anomalous power-law exponents in the inertial range is in agreement with our high-precision numerical measurements. We find that at asymptotically high order moments, the anomalous exponents tend towards a linear scaling, suggesting that extreme turbulent events are dominated by one leading singularity. We found that systematic corrections to scaling induced by the infrared and ultraviolet (viscous) cut-offs are the main limitations to precision for low-order moments, while high orders are mainly affected by the finite statistical samples. The unprecedentedly high fidelity numerical results reported in this work offer an ideal benchmark for the development of future theoretical models of intermittency in dynamical systems for either extreme events (high-order moments) or typical fluctuations (low-order moments). For the latter, we show that we achieve a precision in the determination of the inertial range scaling exponents of the order of one part over ten thousand (5th significant digit), which must be considered a record for out-of-equilibrium fluid-mechanics systems and models.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2024; v1 submitted 5 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Post-blowup dynamics for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation
Authors:
José M. Escorcia,
Alexei A. Mailybaev
Abstract:
In this work we present a systematic numerical study of the post-blowup dynamics of singular solutions of the 1D focusing critical NLS equation in the framework of a nonlinear damped perturbation. The first part of this study shows that initially the post-blowup is described by the adiabatic approximation, in which the collapsing core approaches an universal profile and the solution width is gover…
▽ More
In this work we present a systematic numerical study of the post-blowup dynamics of singular solutions of the 1D focusing critical NLS equation in the framework of a nonlinear damped perturbation. The first part of this study shows that initially the post-blowup is described by the adiabatic approximation, in which the collapsing core approaches an universal profile and the solution width is governed by a system of ODEs (reduced system). After that, a non-adiabatic regime is observed soon after the maximum of the solution, in which our direct numerical simulations show a clear deviation from the dynamics based on the reduced system. Our study suggests that such non-adiabatic regime is caused by the increasing influx of mass into the collapsing core of the solution, which is not considered in the derivation of the reduced system. Also, adiabatic theoretical predictions related to the wave-maximum and wave-dissipation are compared with our numerical simulations. The second part of this work describes the non-adiabatic dynamics. Here, numerical simulations reveal a dominant quasi linear regime, caused by the rapid defocusing process. The collapsing core approaches the universal profile, after removing some oscillations resulting from the interference with the tail. Finally, our numerical study suggests that in the limit of vanishing dissipation, and in a free-space domain, the critical mass is radiated to infinity instantly at the collapse time.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Spontaneously stochastic Arnold's cat
Authors:
Alexei A. Mailybaev,
Artem Raibekas
Abstract:
We propose a simple model for the phenomenon of Eulerian spontaneous stochasticity in turbulence. This model is solved rigorously, proving that infinitesimal small-scale noise in otherwise a deterministic multi-scale system yields a large-scale stochastic process with Markovian properties. Our model shares intriguing properties with open problems of modern mathematical theory of turbulence, like n…
▽ More
We propose a simple model for the phenomenon of Eulerian spontaneous stochasticity in turbulence. This model is solved rigorously, proving that infinitesimal small-scale noise in otherwise a deterministic multi-scale system yields a large-scale stochastic process with Markovian properties. Our model shares intriguing properties with open problems of modern mathematical theory of turbulence, like non-uniqueness of the inviscid limit, existence of wild weak solutions and explosive effect of random perturbations. Thereby, it proposes rigorous, often counterintuitive answers to these questions. Besides its theoretical value, our model opens new ways for the experimental verification of spontaneous stochasticity, and suggests new applications beyond fluid dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2022; v1 submitted 5 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Computation of anomalous scaling exponents of turbulence from self-similar instanton dynamics
Authors:
Alexei A. Mailybaev
Abstract:
We show that multiscaling properties of developed turbulence in shell models, which lead to anomalous scaling exponents in the inertial range, are determined exclusively by instanton dynamics. Instantons represent correlated extreme events localized in space-time, whose structure is described by self-similar statistics with a single universal scaling exponent. We show that anomalous scaling expone…
▽ More
We show that multiscaling properties of developed turbulence in shell models, which lead to anomalous scaling exponents in the inertial range, are determined exclusively by instanton dynamics. Instantons represent correlated extreme events localized in space-time, whose structure is described by self-similar statistics with a single universal scaling exponent. We show that anomalous scaling exponents appear due to the process of instanton creation. A simplified model of instanton creation is suggested, which adequately describes this anomaly.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2012; v1 submitted 9 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
