-
The role of modularity in self-organisation dynamics in biological networks
Authors:
Bram A. Siebert,
Cameron L. Hall,
James P. Gleeson,
Malbor Asllani
Abstract:
Interconnected ensembles of biological entities are perhaps some of the most complex systems that modern science has encountered so far. In particular, scientists have concentrated on understanding how the complexity of the interacting structure between different neurons, proteins or species influences the functioning of their respective systems. It is well-established that many biological network…
▽ More
Interconnected ensembles of biological entities are perhaps some of the most complex systems that modern science has encountered so far. In particular, scientists have concentrated on understanding how the complexity of the interacting structure between different neurons, proteins or species influences the functioning of their respective systems. It is well-established that many biological networks are constructed in a highly hierarchical way with two main properties: short average paths that join two apparently distant nodes (neuronal, species, or protein patches) and a high proportion of nodes in modular aggregations. Although several hypotheses have been proposed so far, still little is known about the relation of the modules with the dynamical activity in such biological systems. Here we show that network modularity is a key ingredient for the formation of self-organising patterns of functional activity, independently of the topological peculiarities of the structure of the modules. In particular, we propose a self-organising mechanism which explains the formation of macroscopic spatial patterns, which are homogeneous within modules. This may explain how spontaneous order in biological networks follows their modular structural organisation. We test our results on real-world networks to confirm the important role of modularity in creating macro-scale patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2020; v1 submitted 27 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Dominance, Sharing, and Assessment in an Iterated Hawk--Dove Game
Authors:
Cameron L. Hall,
Mason A. Porter,
Marian S. Dawkins
Abstract:
Animals use a wide variety of strategies to reduce or avoid aggression in conflicts over resources. These strategies range from sharing resources without outward signs of conflict to the development of dominance hierarchies, in which initial fighting is followed by the submission of subordinates. Although models have been developed to analyze specific strategies for resolving conflicts over resour…
▽ More
Animals use a wide variety of strategies to reduce or avoid aggression in conflicts over resources. These strategies range from sharing resources without outward signs of conflict to the development of dominance hierarchies, in which initial fighting is followed by the submission of subordinates. Although models have been developed to analyze specific strategies for resolving conflicts over resources, little work has focused on trying to understand why particular strategies are more likely to arise in certain situations. In this paper, we use a model based on an iterated Hawk--Dove game to analyze how resource holding potentials (RHPs) and other factors affect whether sharing, dominance relationships, or other behaviours are evolutionarily stable. We find through extensive numerical simulations that sharing is stable only when the cost of fighting is low and the animals in a contest have similar RHPs, whereas dominance relationships are stable in most other situations. We also explore what happens when animals are unable to assess each other's RHPs without fighting, and we compare a range of strategies for this problem using simulations. We find (1) that the most successful strategies involve a limited period of assessment followed by a stable relationship in which fights are avoided and (2) that the duration of assessment depends both on the costliness of fighting and on the difference between the animals' RHPs. Along with our direct work on modeling and simulations, we develop extensive software to facilitate further testing; it is available at \url{https://bitbucket.org/CameronLHall/dominancesharingassessmentmatlab/}.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2019; v1 submitted 3 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Formation of Dominance Relationships via Strategy Updating in an Asymmetric Hawk-Dove Game
Authors:
Jasvir K. Grewal,
Cameron L. Hall,
Mason A. Porter,
Marian S. Dawkins
Abstract:
We develop a model to describe the development of dominance relations between social animals as they use past experiences to inform future interactions. Using the game-theoretic framework of a Hawk-Dove game with asymmetric resource-holding potentials (RHPs), we derive a simple model that describes the social interactions of animals that compete for resources. We then consider a game-playing strat…
▽ More
We develop a model to describe the development of dominance relations between social animals as they use past experiences to inform future interactions. Using the game-theoretic framework of a Hawk-Dove game with asymmetric resource-holding potentials (RHPs), we derive a simple model that describes the social interactions of animals that compete for resources. We then consider a game-playing strategy in which animals acquire information about their RHP asymmetry from the results of their previous contests and subsequently use their asymmetry assessment to inform their behavior in future contests. We examine how directly incorporating the fact that animals have incomplete information in their interactions can lead to outcomes that differ from what would be expected if one considers the situation as a static game in which the animals have perfect information about the asymmetry size. We thereby obtain results that are consistent with observations of dominance-hierarchy formation in social animals. We also discuss how increased interactions between animals can speed up the asymmetry assessment process and how this can explain why aggression can sometimes decrease as the number of interactions between animals increases over time.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
