-
Evidence for dynamical changes in Betelgeuse using multi-wavelength data
Authors:
Sneha Kachhara,
Sandip V. George,
Ranjeev Misra,
G. Ambika
Abstract:
The reasons behind the Great Dimming and subsequent rising in the brightness of Betelgeuse between October 2019 and March 2020 still continue to baffle astronomers. It has been shown by George et. al. (2020) that critical slowing down preceded the dimming event. This suggested that the dimming was a result of the change in the nature of the nonlinear dynamics of the star. In this work we present a…
▽ More
The reasons behind the Great Dimming and subsequent rising in the brightness of Betelgeuse between October 2019 and March 2020 still continue to baffle astronomers. It has been shown by George et. al. (2020) that critical slowing down preceded the dimming event. This suggested that the dimming was a result of the change in the nature of the nonlinear dynamics of the star. In this work we present additional evidence for dynamical changes in Betelgeuse prior to the Great Dimming event, using nonlinear time series analysis. We study the relations between the different bands in the photometry data collected from the Wing photometry (IR/near-IR) and Wasatonic observatory (V-band). We also analyse how the early warning signals studied previously changed during and after the Great Dimming.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Early warning signals for critical transitions in complex systems
Authors:
Sandip V. George,
Sneha Kachhara,
G. Ambika
Abstract:
In this topical review, we present a brief overview of the different methods and measures to detect the occurrence of critical transitions in complex systems. We start by introducing the mechanisms that trigger critical transitions, and how they relate to early warning signals (EWS) and mention briefly the conventional measures based on critical slowing down as computed from data and applied to re…
▽ More
In this topical review, we present a brief overview of the different methods and measures to detect the occurrence of critical transitions in complex systems. We start by introducing the mechanisms that trigger critical transitions, and how they relate to early warning signals (EWS) and mention briefly the conventional measures based on critical slowing down as computed from data and applied to real systems. We then present in detail the approaches for multivariate data, including those defined for complex networks. More recent techniques like the warning signals derived from the recurrence pattern underlying the data, are presented in detail as measures from recurrence plots and recurrence networks. This is followed by a discussion on how methods based on machine learning are used most recently, to detect critical transitions in real and simulated data. Towards the end, we summarise the issues faced while computing the EWS from real-world data and conclude with our outlook and perspective on future trends in this area.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2023; v1 submitted 2 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Fractal Measures and Nonlinear Dynamics of Overcontact Binaries
Authors:
Sandip V. George,
R. Misra,
G. Ambika
Abstract:
Overcontact binary stars are systems of two stars where the component stars are in contact with each other. This implies that they share a common envelope of gas. In this work we seek signatures of nonlinearity and chaos in these stars by using time series analysis techniques. We use three main techniques, namely the correlation dimension,f (α) spectrum and the bicoherence. The former two are calc…
▽ More
Overcontact binary stars are systems of two stars where the component stars are in contact with each other. This implies that they share a common envelope of gas. In this work we seek signatures of nonlinearity and chaos in these stars by using time series analysis techniques. We use three main techniques, namely the correlation dimension,f (α) spectrum and the bicoherence. The former two are calculated from the reconstructed dynamics, while the latter is calculated from the Fourier transforms of the time series of intensity variations(light curves) of these stars. Our dataset consists of data from 463 overcontact binary stars in the Kepler field of view [1]. Our analysis indicates nonlinearity and signatures of chaos in almost all the light curves. We also explore whether the underlying nonlinear properties of the stars are related to their physical properties like fill-out-factor, a measure of the extend of contact between the components of an overcontact binary system . We observe that significant correlations exist between the fill out factor and the nonlinear quantifiers. This correlation is more pronounced in specific subcategories constructed based on the mass ratios and effective temperatures of the binaries. The correlations observed can be indicative of variations in the nonlinear properties of the star as it ages. We believe that this study relating nonlinear and astrophysical properties of binary stars is the first of its kind and is an important starting point for such studies in other astrophysical objects displaying nonlinear dynamical behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2019; v1 submitted 21 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Nonlinearity in Data with Gaps: Application to Ecological and Meteorological Datasets
Authors:
Sandip V. George,
G. Ambika
Abstract:
Datagaps are ubiquitous in real world observational data. Quantifying nonlinearity in data having gaps can be challenging. Reported research points out that interpolation can affect nonlinear quantifiers adversely, artificially introducing signatures of nonlinearity where none exist. In this paper we attempt to quantify the effect that datagaps have on the multifractal spectrum ($f(α)$), in the ab…
▽ More
Datagaps are ubiquitous in real world observational data. Quantifying nonlinearity in data having gaps can be challenging. Reported research points out that interpolation can affect nonlinear quantifiers adversely, artificially introducing signatures of nonlinearity where none exist. In this paper we attempt to quantify the effect that datagaps have on the multifractal spectrum ($f(α)$), in the absence of interpolation. We identify tolerable gap ranges, where the measures defining the $f(α)$ curve do not show considerable deviation from the evenly sampled case. We apply this to the multifractal spectra of multiple data-sets with missing data from the SMEAR database. The datasets we consider include ecological datasets from SMEAR I, namely CO$_2$ exchange variation, photosynthetically active radiation levels and soil moisture variation time series, and meteorological datasets from SMEAR II, namely dew point variation and air temperature variation. We could establish multifractality due to deterministic nonlinearity in two of these datasets, even in the presence of gaps.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Detecting Dynamical States from Noisy Time Series using Bicoherence
Authors:
Sandip V. George,
G. Ambika,
R. Misra
Abstract:
Deriving meaningful information from observational data is often restricted by many limiting factors, the most important of which is the presence of noise. In this work, we present the use of the bicoherence function to extract information about the underlying nonlinearity from noisy time series. We show that a system evolving in the presence of noise which has its dynamical state concealed from q…
▽ More
Deriving meaningful information from observational data is often restricted by many limiting factors, the most important of which is the presence of noise. In this work, we present the use of the bicoherence function to extract information about the underlying nonlinearity from noisy time series. We show that a system evolving in the presence of noise which has its dynamical state concealed from quantifiers like the power spectrum and correlation dimension D2, can be revealed using the bicoherence function. We define an index called main peak bicoherence function as the bicoherence associated with the maximal power spectral peak. We show that this index is extremely useful while dealing with quasi-periodic data as it can distinguish strange non chaos from quasi periodicity even with added noise. We demonstrate this in a real world scenario, by taking the bicoherence of variable stars showing period doubling and strange non-chaotic behavior. Our results indicate that bicoherence analysis can also bypass the method of surrogate analysis using Fourier phase randomization, used to differentiate linear stochastic processes from non linear ones, in conventional methods involving measures like D2.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2017; v1 submitted 18 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Effect of data gaps on correlation dimension computed from light curves of variable stars
Authors:
Sandip V. George,
G. Ambika,
R. Misra
Abstract:
Observational data, especially astrophysical data, is often limited by gaps in data that arises due to lack of observations for a variety of reasons. Such inadvertent gaps are usually smoothed over using interpolation techniques. However the smoothing techniques can introduce artificial effects, especially when non-linear analysis is undertaken. We investigate how gaps can affect the computed valu…
▽ More
Observational data, especially astrophysical data, is often limited by gaps in data that arises due to lack of observations for a variety of reasons. Such inadvertent gaps are usually smoothed over using interpolation techniques. However the smoothing techniques can introduce artificial effects, especially when non-linear analysis is undertaken. We investigate how gaps can affect the computed values of correlation dimension of the system, without using any interpolation. For this we introduce gaps artificially in synthetic data derived from standard chaotic systems, like the R{ö}ssler and Lorenz, with frequency of occurrence and size of missing data drawn from two Gaussian distributions. Then we study the changes in correlation dimension with change in the distributions of position and size of gaps. We find that for a considerable range of mean gap frequency and size, the value of correlation dimension is not significantly affected, indicating that in such specific cases, the calculated values can still be reliable and acceptable. Thus our study introduces a method of checking the reliability of computed correlation dimension values by calculating the distribution of gaps with respect to its size and position. This is illustrated for the data from light curves of three variable stars, R Scuti, U Monocerotis and SU Tauri. We also demonstrate how a cubic spline interpolation can cause a time series of Gaussian noise with missing data to be misinterpreted as being chaotic in origin. This is demonstrated for the non chaotic light curve of variable star SS Cygni, which gives a saturated D$_{2}$ value, when interpolated using a cubic spline. In addition we also find that a careful choice of binning, in addition to reducing noise, can help in shifting the gap distribution to the reliable range for D$_2$ values.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2015; v1 submitted 16 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
