-
Predicting Instabilities in Transient Landforms and Interconnected Ecosystems
Authors:
Taylor Smith,
Andreas Morr,
Bodo Bookhagen,
Niklas Boers
Abstract:
Many parts of the Earth system are thought to have multiple stable equilibrium states, with the potential for rapid and sometimes catastrophic shifts between them. The most common frameworks for analyzing stability changes, however, require stationary (trend- and seasonality-free) data, which necessitates error-prone data pre-processing. Here we propose a novel method of quantifying system stabili…
▽ More
Many parts of the Earth system are thought to have multiple stable equilibrium states, with the potential for rapid and sometimes catastrophic shifts between them. The most common frameworks for analyzing stability changes, however, require stationary (trend- and seasonality-free) data, which necessitates error-prone data pre-processing. Here we propose a novel method of quantifying system stability based on eigenvalue tracking and Floquet Multipliers, which can be applied directly to diverse data without first removing trend and seasonality, and is robust to changing noise levels, as can be caused by merging signals from different sensors. We first demonstrate this approach with synthetic data and further show how glacier surge onset can be predicted from observed surface velocity time series. We then show that our method can be extended to analyze spatio-temporal data and illustrate this flexibility with remotely sensed Amazon rainforest vegetation productivity, highlighting the spatial patterns of whole-ecosystem destabilization. Our work applies critical slowing down theory to glacier dynamics for the first time, and provides a novel and flexible method to quantify the stability or resilience of a wide range of spatiotemporal systems, including climate subsystems, ecosystems, and transient landforms.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
The influence of data gaps and outliers on resilience indicators
Authors:
Teng Liu,
Andreas Morr,
Sebastian Bathiany,
Lana L. Blaschke,
Zhen Qian,
Chan Diao,
Taylor Smith,
Niklas Boers
Abstract:
The resilience, or stability, of major Earth system components is increasingly threatened by anthropogenic pressures, demanding reliable early warning signals for abrupt and irreversible regime shifts. Widely used data-driven resilience indicators based on variance and autocorrelation detect `critical slowing down', a signature of decreasing stability. However, the interpretation of these indicato…
▽ More
The resilience, or stability, of major Earth system components is increasingly threatened by anthropogenic pressures, demanding reliable early warning signals for abrupt and irreversible regime shifts. Widely used data-driven resilience indicators based on variance and autocorrelation detect `critical slowing down', a signature of decreasing stability. However, the interpretation of these indicators is hampered by poorly understood interdependencies and their susceptibility to common data issues such as missing values and outliers. Here, we establish a rigorous mathematical analysis of the statistical dependency between variance- and autocorrelation-based resilience indicators, revealing that their agreement is fundamentally driven by the time series' initial data point. Using synthetic and empirical data, we demonstrate that missing values substantially weaken indicator agreement, while outliers introduce systematic biases that lead to overestimation of resilience based on temporal autocorrelation. Our results provide a necessary and rigorous foundation for preprocessing strategies and accuracy assessments across the growing number of disciplines that use real-world data to infer changes in system resilience.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2025; v1 submitted 25 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Chaotic Kramers' Law: Hasselmann's Program and AMOC Tipping
Authors:
Jakob Deser,
Raphael Römer,
Niklas Boers,
Christian Kuehn
Abstract:
In bistable dynamical systems driven by Wiener processes, the widely used Kramers' law relates the strength of the noise forcing to the average time it takes to see a noise-induced transition from one attractor to the other. We extend this law to bistable systems forced with fast chaotic dynamics, which we argue to be a more realistic modeling approach than unbounded noise forcing in some cases. W…
▽ More
In bistable dynamical systems driven by Wiener processes, the widely used Kramers' law relates the strength of the noise forcing to the average time it takes to see a noise-induced transition from one attractor to the other. We extend this law to bistable systems forced with fast chaotic dynamics, which we argue to be a more realistic modeling approach than unbounded noise forcing in some cases. We test our results numerically in a reduced-order model of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and discuss the limits of the chaotic Kramers' law as well as its surprisingly wide parameter range of applicability. Hereby, we show in detail how to apply Hasselmann's program in practice and give a possible explanation for recent findings of AMOC collapse and recovery in complex climate models.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Machine Learning for Predicting Chaotic Systems
Authors:
Christof Schötz,
Alistair White,
Maximilian Gelbrecht,
Niklas Boers
Abstract:
Predicting chaotic dynamical systems is critical in many scientific fields, such as weather forecasting, but challenging due to the characteristic sensitive dependence on initial conditions. Traditional modeling approaches require extensive domain knowledge, often leading to a shift towards data-driven methods using machine learning. However, existing research provides inconclusive results on whic…
▽ More
Predicting chaotic dynamical systems is critical in many scientific fields, such as weather forecasting, but challenging due to the characteristic sensitive dependence on initial conditions. Traditional modeling approaches require extensive domain knowledge, often leading to a shift towards data-driven methods using machine learning. However, existing research provides inconclusive results on which machine learning methods are best suited for predicting chaotic systems. In this paper, we compare different lightweight and heavyweight machine learning architectures using extensive existing benchmark databases, as well as a newly introduced database that allows for uncertainty quantification in the benchmark results. In addition to state-of-the-art methods from the literature, we also present new advantageous variants of established methods. Hyperparameter tuning is adjusted based on computational cost, with more tuning allocated to less costly methods. Furthermore, we introduce the cumulative maximum error, a novel metric that combines desirable properties of traditional metrics and is tailored for chaotic systems. Our results show that well-tuned simple methods, as well as untuned baseline methods, often outperform state-of-the-art deep learning models, but their performance can vary significantly with different experimental setups. These findings highlight the importance of aligning prediction methods with data characteristics and caution against the indiscriminate use of overly complex models.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2025; v1 submitted 29 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Analysis of a bistable climate toy model with physics-based machine learning methods
Authors:
Maximilian Gelbrecht,
Valerio Lucarini,
Niklas Boers,
Jürgen Kurths
Abstract:
We propose a comprehensive framework able to address both the predictability of the first and of the second kind for high-dimensional chaotic models. For this purpose, we analyse the properties of a newly introduced multistable climate toy model constructed by coupling the Lorenz '96 model with a zero-dimensional energy balance model. First, the attractors of the system are identified with Monte C…
▽ More
We propose a comprehensive framework able to address both the predictability of the first and of the second kind for high-dimensional chaotic models. For this purpose, we analyse the properties of a newly introduced multistable climate toy model constructed by coupling the Lorenz '96 model with a zero-dimensional energy balance model. First, the attractors of the system are identified with Monte Carlo Basin Bifurcation Analysis. Additionally, we are able to detect the Melancholia state separating the two attractors. Then, Neural Ordinary Differential Equations are applied in order to predict the future state of the system in both of the identified attractors.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2021; v1 submitted 13 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
