Revisiting the Linear Chain Trick in epidemiological models: Implications of underlying assumptions for numerical solutions
Authors:
Lena Plötzke,
Anna Wendler,
René Schmieding,
Martin J. Kühn
Abstract:
In order to simulate the spread of infectious diseases, many epidemiological models use systems of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) to describe the underlying dynamics. These models incorporate the implicit assumption, that the stay time in each disease state follows an exponential distribution. However, a substantial number of epidemiological, data-based studies indicate that this assumptio…
▽ More
In order to simulate the spread of infectious diseases, many epidemiological models use systems of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) to describe the underlying dynamics. These models incorporate the implicit assumption, that the stay time in each disease state follows an exponential distribution. However, a substantial number of epidemiological, data-based studies indicate that this assumption is not plausible. One method to alleviate this limitation is to employ the Linear Chain Trick (LCT) for ODE systems, which realizes the use of Erlang distributed stay times. As indicated by data, this approach allows for more realistic models while maintaining the advantages of using ODEs.
In this work, we propose an advanced LCT SECIR-type model incorporating eight infection states with demographic stratification. We review key properties of the corresponding LCT model and demonstrate that predictions derived from a simple ODE-based model can be significantly distorted, potentially leading to wrong political decisions. Our findings demonstrate that the influence of distribution assumptions on the behavior at change points and on the prediction of epidemic peaks is substantial, while the assumption has no effect on the final size of the epidemic. With respect to prior findings in literature, we demonstrate that the influence of the number of subcompartments on the timing and size of the epidemic peak is nontrivial and that a general statement cannot be obtained. We, then, show how these age-resolved LCT SECIR-type models capture the spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Germany in 2020. Eventually, we study the implications on the time-to-solution for different LCT models using fixed and adaptive step-size Runge-Kutta methods and provide computational performance for these models in the MEmilio software framework, also using distributed memory parallelism to speed up ensemble runs.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2025; v1 submitted 12 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
A nonstandard numerical scheme for a novel SECIR integro-differential equation-based model allowing nonexponentially distributed stay times
Authors:
Anna Wendler,
Lena Plötzke,
Hannah Tritzschak,
Martin J. Kühn
Abstract:
Ordinary differential equations (ODE) are a popular tool to model the spread of infectious diseases, yet they implicitly assume an exponential distribution to describe the flow from one infection state to another. However, scientific experience yields more plausible distributions where the likelihood of disease progression changes accordingly with the duration spent in a particular state of the di…
▽ More
Ordinary differential equations (ODE) are a popular tool to model the spread of infectious diseases, yet they implicitly assume an exponential distribution to describe the flow from one infection state to another. However, scientific experience yields more plausible distributions where the likelihood of disease progression changes accordingly with the duration spent in a particular state of the disease. Furthermore, transmission dynamics depend heavily on the infectiousness of individuals. The corresponding nonlinear variation with the time individuals have already spent in an infectious state requires more realistic models. The previously mentioned items are particularly crucial when modeling dynamics at change points such as the implementation of nonpharmaceutical interventions. In order to capture these aspects and to enhance the accuracy of simulations, integro-differential equations (IDE) can be used. In this paper, we propose a generalized model based on IDEs with eight infection states. The model allows for variable stay time distributions and generalizes the concept of ODE-based models as well as IDE-based age-of-infection models. In this, we include particular infection states for severe and critical cases to allow for surveillance of the clinical sector, avoiding bottlenecks and overloads in critical epidemic situations. On the other hand, a drawback of IDE-based models is that efficient numerical solvers are not as widely available. We extend a recently introduced nonstandard numerical scheme. This scheme is adapted to our more advanced model and we prove important mathematical and biological properties. Furthermore, we validate our approach numerically by demonstrating the convergence rate. Eventually, we also show that our novel model is intrinsically capable of better assessing disease dynamics upon the introduction of nonpharmaceutical interventions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2025; v1 submitted 22 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
