-
Multiplicative assignment with upgrades
Authors:
Alexander Armbruster,
Lars Rohwedder,
Stefan Weltge,
Andreas Wiese,
Ruilong Zhang
Abstract:
We study a problem related to submodular function optimization and the exact matching problem for which we show a rather peculiar status: its natural LP-relaxation can have fractional optimal vertices, but there is always also an optimal integral vertex, which we can also compute in polynomial time.
More specifically, we consider the multiplicative assignment problem with upgrades in which we ar…
▽ More
We study a problem related to submodular function optimization and the exact matching problem for which we show a rather peculiar status: its natural LP-relaxation can have fractional optimal vertices, but there is always also an optimal integral vertex, which we can also compute in polynomial time.
More specifically, we consider the multiplicative assignment problem with upgrades in which we are given a set of customers and suppliers and we seek to assign each customer to a different supplier. Each customer has a demand and each supplier has a regular and an upgraded cost for each unit demand provided to the respective assigned client. Our goal is to upgrade at most $k$ suppliers and to compute an assignment in order to minimize the total resulting cost. This can be cast as the problem to compute an optimal matching in a bipartite graph with the additional constraint that we must select $k$ edges from a certain group of edges, similar to selecting $k$ red edges in the exact matching problem. Also, selecting the suppliers to be upgraded corresponds to maximizing a submodular set function under a cardinality constraint.
Our result yields an efficient LP-based algorithm to solve our problem optimally. In addition, we provide also a purely strongly polynomial-time algorithm for it. As an application, we obtain exact algorithms for the upgrading variant of the problem to schedule jobs on identical or uniformly related machines in order to minimize their sum of completion times, i.e., where we may upgrade up to $k$ jobs to reduce their respective processing times.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Integer programs with nearly totally unimodular matrices: the cographic case
Authors:
Manuel Aprile,
Samuel Fiorini,
Gwenaël Joret,
Stefan Kober,
Michał T. Seweryn,
Stefan Weltge,
Yelena Yuditsky
Abstract:
It is a notorious open question whether integer programs (IPs), with an integer coefficient matrix $M$ whose subdeterminants are all bounded by a constant $Δ$ in absolute value, can be solved in polynomial time. We answer this question in the affirmative if we further require that, by removing a constant number of rows and columns from $M$, one obtains a submatrix $A$ that is the transpose of a ne…
▽ More
It is a notorious open question whether integer programs (IPs), with an integer coefficient matrix $M$ whose subdeterminants are all bounded by a constant $Δ$ in absolute value, can be solved in polynomial time. We answer this question in the affirmative if we further require that, by removing a constant number of rows and columns from $M$, one obtains a submatrix $A$ that is the transpose of a network matrix.
Our approach focuses on the case where $A$ arises from $M$ after removing $k$ rows only, where $k$ is a constant. We achieve our result in two main steps, the first related to the theory of IPs and the second related to graph minor theory.
First, we derive a strong proximity result for the case where $A$ is a general totally unimodular matrix: Given an optimal solution of the linear programming relaxation, an optimal solution to the IP can be obtained by finding a constant number of augmentations by circuits of $[A\; I]$.
Second, for the case where $A$ is transpose of a network matrix, we reformulate the problem as a maximum constrained integer potential problem on a graph $G$. We observe that if $G$ is $2$-connected, then it has no rooted $K_{2,t}$-minor for $t = Ω(k Δ)$. We leverage this to obtain a tree-decomposition of $G$ into highly structured graphs for which we can solve the problem locally. This allows us to solve the global problem via dynamic programming.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
A Branch-Price-Cut-And-Switch Approach for Optimizing Team Formation and Routing for Airport Baggage Handling Tasks with Stochastic Travel Times
Authors:
Andreas Hagn,
Rainer Kolisch,
Giacomo Dall'Olio,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
In airport operations, optimally using dedicated personnel for baggage handling tasks plays a crucial role in the design of resource-efficient processes. Teams of workers with different qualifications must be formed, and loading or unloading tasks must be assigned to them. Each task has a time window within which it can be started and should be finished. Violating these temporal restrictions incur…
▽ More
In airport operations, optimally using dedicated personnel for baggage handling tasks plays a crucial role in the design of resource-efficient processes. Teams of workers with different qualifications must be formed, and loading or unloading tasks must be assigned to them. Each task has a time window within which it can be started and should be finished. Violating these temporal restrictions incurs severe financial penalties for the operator. In practice, various components of this process are subject to uncertainties. We consider the aforementioned problem under the assumption of stochastic travel times across the apron. We present two binary program formulations to model the problem at hand and solve it with a Branch-Price-Cut-and-Switch approach, in which we dynamically switch between two master problem formulations. Furthermore, we use an exact separation method to identify violated rank-1 Chvátal-Gomory cuts and utilize an efficient branching rule relying on task finish times. We test the algorithm on instances generated based on real-world data from a major European hub airport with a planning horizon of up to two hours, 30 flights per hour, and three available task execution modes to choose from. Our results indicate that our algorithm is able to significantly outperform existing solution approaches. Moreover, an explicit consideration of stochastic travel times allows for solutions that utilize the available workforce more efficiently, while simultaneously guaranteeing a stable service level for the baggage handling operator.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Lower Bounds on the Complexity of Mixed-Integer Programs for Stable Set and Knapsack
Authors:
Jamico Schade,
Makrand Sinha,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Standard mixed-integer programming formulations for the stable set problem on $n$-node graphs require $n$ integer variables. We prove that this is almost optimal: We give a family of $n$-node graphs for which every polynomial-size MIP formulation requires $Ω(n/\log^2 n)$ integer variables. By a polyhedral reduction we obtain an analogous result for $n$-item knapsack problems. In both cases, this i…
▽ More
Standard mixed-integer programming formulations for the stable set problem on $n$-node graphs require $n$ integer variables. We prove that this is almost optimal: We give a family of $n$-node graphs for which every polynomial-size MIP formulation requires $Ω(n/\log^2 n)$ integer variables. By a polyhedral reduction we obtain an analogous result for $n$-item knapsack problems. In both cases, this improves the previously known bounds of $Ω(\sqrt{n}/\log n)$ by Cevallos, Weltge & Zenklusen (SODA 2018).
To this end, we show that there exists a family of $n$-node graphs whose stable set polytopes satisfy the following: any $(1+\varepsilon/n)$-approximate extended formulation for these polytopes, for some constant $\varepsilon > 0$, has size $2^{Ω(n/\log n)}$. Our proof extends and simplifies the information-theoretic methods due to Göös, Jain & Watson (FOCS 2016, SIAM J. Comput. 2018) who showed the same result for the case of exact extended formulations (i.e. $\varepsilon = 0$).
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2024; v1 submitted 31 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Driver-aware charging infrastructure design
Authors:
Stefan Kober,
Maximilian Schiffer,
Stephan Sorgatz,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Public charging infrastructure plays a crucial role in the context of electrifying the private mobility sector in particular for urban regions. Against this background, we develop a new mathematical model for the optimal placement of public charging stations for electric vehicles in cities. While existing approaches strongly aggregate traffic information or are only applicable to small instances,…
▽ More
Public charging infrastructure plays a crucial role in the context of electrifying the private mobility sector in particular for urban regions. Against this background, we develop a new mathematical model for the optimal placement of public charging stations for electric vehicles in cities. While existing approaches strongly aggregate traffic information or are only applicable to small instances, we formulate the problem as a specific combinatorial optimization problem that incorporates individual demand and temporal interactions of drivers, exact positioning of charging stations, as well as various charging speeds, and realistic charging curves. We show that the problem can be naturally cast as an integer program that, together with different reformulation techniques, can be efficiently solved for large instances. More specifically, we show that our approach can compute optimal placements of charging stations for instances based on traffic data for cities with up to $600\,000$ inhabitants and future electrification rates of up to $15\%$.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
The Pareto cover problem
Authors:
Bento Natura,
Meike Neuwohner,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
We introduce the problem of finding a set $B$ of $k$ points in $[0,1]^n$ such that the expected cost of the cheapest point in $B$ that dominates a random point from $[0,1]^n$ is minimized. We study the case where the coordinates of the random points are independently distributed and the cost function is linear. This problem arises naturally in various application areas where customers' requests ar…
▽ More
We introduce the problem of finding a set $B$ of $k$ points in $[0,1]^n$ such that the expected cost of the cheapest point in $B$ that dominates a random point from $[0,1]^n$ is minimized. We study the case where the coordinates of the random points are independently distributed and the cost function is linear. This problem arises naturally in various application areas where customers' requests are satisfied based on predefined products, each corresponding to a subset of features. We show that the problem is NP-hard already for $k=2$ when each coordinate is drawn from $\{0,1\}$, and obtain an FPTAS for general fixed $k$ under mild assumptions on the distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Lattice-free simplices with lattice width $2d - o(d)$
Authors:
Lukas Mayrhofer,
Jamico Schade,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
The Flatness theorem states that the maximum lattice width ${\rm Flt}(d)$ of a $d$-dimensional lattice-free convex set is finite. It is the key ingredient for Lenstra's algorithm for integer programming in fixed dimension, and much work has been done to obtain bounds on ${\rm Flt}(d)$. While most results have been concerned with upper bounds, only few techniques are known to obtain lower bounds. I…
▽ More
The Flatness theorem states that the maximum lattice width ${\rm Flt}(d)$ of a $d$-dimensional lattice-free convex set is finite. It is the key ingredient for Lenstra's algorithm for integer programming in fixed dimension, and much work has been done to obtain bounds on ${\rm Flt}(d)$. While most results have been concerned with upper bounds, only few techniques are known to obtain lower bounds. In fact, the previously best known lower bound ${\rm Flt}(d) \ge 1.138d$ arises from direct sums of a $3$-dimensional lattice-free simplex. In this work, we establish the lower bound ${\rm Flt}(d) \ge 2d - O(\sqrt{d})$, attained by a family of lattice-free simplices. Our construction is based on a differential equation that naturally appears in this context. Additionally, we provide the first local maximizers of the lattice width of $4$- and $5$-dimensional lattice-free convex bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022; v1 submitted 16 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Integer programs with bounded subdeterminants and two nonzeros per row
Authors:
Samuel Fiorini,
Gwenaël Joret,
Stefan Weltge,
Yelena Yuditsky
Abstract:
We give a strongly polynomial-time algorithm for integer linear programs defined by integer coefficient matrices whose subdeterminants are bounded by a constant and that contain at most two nonzero entries in each row. The core of our approach is the first polynomial-time algorithm for the weighted stable set problem on graphs that do not contain more than $k$ vertex-disjoint odd cycles, where…
▽ More
We give a strongly polynomial-time algorithm for integer linear programs defined by integer coefficient matrices whose subdeterminants are bounded by a constant and that contain at most two nonzero entries in each row. The core of our approach is the first polynomial-time algorithm for the weighted stable set problem on graphs that do not contain more than $k$ vertex-disjoint odd cycles, where $k$ is any constant. Previously, polynomial-time algorithms were only known for $k=0$ (bipartite graphs) and for $k=1$.
We observe that integer linear programs defined by coefficient matrices with bounded subdeterminants and two nonzeros per column can be also solved in strongly polynomial-time, using a reduction to $b$-matching.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2024; v1 submitted 10 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Lifts for Voronoi cells of lattices
Authors:
Matthias Schymura,
Ina Seidel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Many polytopes arising in polyhedral combinatorics are linear projections of higher-dimensional polytopes with significantly fewer facets. Such lifts may yield compressed representations of polytopes, which are typically used to construct small-size linear programs. Motivated by algorithmic implications for the closest vector problem, we study lifts of Voronoi cells of lattices.
We construct an…
▽ More
Many polytopes arising in polyhedral combinatorics are linear projections of higher-dimensional polytopes with significantly fewer facets. Such lifts may yield compressed representations of polytopes, which are typically used to construct small-size linear programs. Motivated by algorithmic implications for the closest vector problem, we study lifts of Voronoi cells of lattices.
We construct an explicit $d$-dimensional lattice such that every lift of the respective Voronoi cell has $2^{Ω(d / \log d)}$ facets. On the positive side, we show that Voronoi cells of $d$-dimensional root lattices and their dual lattices have lifts with $O(d)$ and $O(d \log d)$ facets, respectively. We obtain similar results for spectrahedral lifts.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
A Simple Method for Convex Optimization in the Oracle Model
Authors:
Daniel Dadush,
Christopher Hojny,
Sophie Huiberts,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
We give a simple and natural method for computing approximately optimal solutions for minimizing a convex function $f$ over a convex set $K$ given by a separation oracle. Our method utilizes the Frank--Wolfe algorithm over the cone of valid inequalities of $K$ and subgradients of $f$. Under the assumption that $f$ is $L$-Lipschitz and that $K$ contains a ball of radius $r$ and is contained inside…
▽ More
We give a simple and natural method for computing approximately optimal solutions for minimizing a convex function $f$ over a convex set $K$ given by a separation oracle. Our method utilizes the Frank--Wolfe algorithm over the cone of valid inequalities of $K$ and subgradients of $f$. Under the assumption that $f$ is $L$-Lipschitz and that $K$ contains a ball of radius $r$ and is contained inside the origin centered ball of radius $R$, using $O(\frac{(RL)^2}{\varepsilon^2} \cdot \frac{R^2}{r^2})$ iterations and calls to the oracle, our main method outputs a point $x \in K$ satisfying $f(x) \leq \varepsilon + \min_{z \in K} f(z)$.
Our algorithm is easy to implement, and we believe it can serve as a useful alternative to existing cutting plane methods. As evidence towards this, we show that it compares favorably in terms of iteration counts to the standard LP based cutting plane method and the analytic center cutting plane method, on a testbed of combinatorial, semidefinite and machine learning instances.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2022; v1 submitted 17 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Binary scalar products
Authors:
Andrey Kupavskii,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Let $A,B \subseteq \mathbb{R}^d $ both span $\mathbb{R}^d$ such that $\langle a, b \rangle \in \{0,1\}$ holds for all $a \in A$, $b \in B$. We show that $ |A| \cdot |B| \le (d+1) 2^d $. This allows us to settle a conjecture by Bohn, Faenza, Fiorini, Fisikopoulos, Macchia, and Pashkovich (2015) concerning 2-level polytopes. Such polytopes have the property that for every facet-defining hyperplane…
▽ More
Let $A,B \subseteq \mathbb{R}^d $ both span $\mathbb{R}^d$ such that $\langle a, b \rangle \in \{0,1\}$ holds for all $a \in A$, $b \in B$. We show that $ |A| \cdot |B| \le (d+1) 2^d $. This allows us to settle a conjecture by Bohn, Faenza, Fiorini, Fisikopoulos, Macchia, and Pashkovich (2015) concerning 2-level polytopes. Such polytopes have the property that for every facet-defining hyperplane $H$ there is a parallel hyperplane $H'$ such that $H \cup H'$ contain all vertices. The authors conjectured that for every $d$-dimensional 2-level polytope $P$ the product of the number of vertices of $P$ and the number of facets of $P$ is at most $d 2^{d+1}$, which we show to be true.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Improved lower bound on the dimension of the EU council's voting rules
Authors:
Stefan Kober,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Kurz and Napel (2015) proved that the voting system of the EU council (based on the 2014 population data) cannot be represented as the intersection of six weighted games, i.e., its dimension is at least 7. This set a new record for real-world voting rules and the authors posed the exact determination as a challenge. Recently, Chen, Cheung, and Ng (2019) showed that the dimension is at most 24.
W…
▽ More
Kurz and Napel (2015) proved that the voting system of the EU council (based on the 2014 population data) cannot be represented as the intersection of six weighted games, i.e., its dimension is at least 7. This set a new record for real-world voting rules and the authors posed the exact determination as a challenge. Recently, Chen, Cheung, and Ng (2019) showed that the dimension is at most 24.
We provide the first improved lower bound and show that the dimension is at least 8.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Extended Formulations for Stable Set Polytopes of Graphs Without Two Disjoint Odd Cycles
Authors:
Michele Conforti,
Samuel Fiorini,
Tony Huynh,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Let $G$ be an $n$-node graph without two disjoint odd cycles. The algorithm of Artmann, Weismantel and Zenklusen (STOC'17) for bimodular integer programs can be used to find a maximum weight stable set in $G$ in strongly polynomial time. Building on structural results characterizing sufficiently connected graphs without two disjoint odd cycles, we construct a size-$O(n^2)$ extended formulation for…
▽ More
Let $G$ be an $n$-node graph without two disjoint odd cycles. The algorithm of Artmann, Weismantel and Zenklusen (STOC'17) for bimodular integer programs can be used to find a maximum weight stable set in $G$ in strongly polynomial time. Building on structural results characterizing sufficiently connected graphs without two disjoint odd cycles, we construct a size-$O(n^2)$ extended formulation for the stable set polytope of $G$.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2021; v1 submitted 27 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Minimum-cost integer circulations in given homology classes
Authors:
Sarah Morell,
Ina Seidel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Let $D$ be a directed graph cellularly embedded in a surface together with non-negative cost on its arcs. Given any integer circulation in $D$, we study the problem of finding a minimum-cost non-negative integer circulation in $D$ that is homologous over the integers to the given circulation. A special case of this problem arises in recent work on the stable set problem for graphs with bounded odd…
▽ More
Let $D$ be a directed graph cellularly embedded in a surface together with non-negative cost on its arcs. Given any integer circulation in $D$, we study the problem of finding a minimum-cost non-negative integer circulation in $D$ that is homologous over the integers to the given circulation. A special case of this problem arises in recent work on the stable set problem for graphs with bounded odd cycle packing number, in which the surface is non-orientable (Conforti et al., SODA'20).
For orientable surfaces, polynomial-time algorithms have been obtained for different variants of this problem. We complement these results by showing that the convex hull of feasible solutions has a very simple polyhedral description.
In contrast, only little seems to be known about the case of non-orientable surfaces. We show that the problem is strongly NP-hard for general non-orientable surfaces, and give the first polynomial-time algorithm for surfaces of fixed genus. For the latter, we provide a characterization of homology (over the integers) that allows us to recast the problem as a special integer program, which can be efficiently solved using proximity results and dynamic programming.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2020; v1 submitted 25 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Persistency of Linear Programming Relaxations for the Stable Set Problem
Authors:
Elisabeth Rodríguez-Heck,
Karl Stickler,
Matthias Walter,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
The Nemhauser-Trotter theorem states that the standard linear programming (LP) formulation for the stable set problem has a remarkable property, also known as (weak) persistency: for every optimal LP solution that assigns integer values to some variables, there exists an optimal integer solution in which these variables retain the same values. While the standard LP is defined by only non-negativit…
▽ More
The Nemhauser-Trotter theorem states that the standard linear programming (LP) formulation for the stable set problem has a remarkable property, also known as (weak) persistency: for every optimal LP solution that assigns integer values to some variables, there exists an optimal integer solution in which these variables retain the same values. While the standard LP is defined by only non-negativity and edge constraints, a variety of other LP formulations have been studied and one may wonder whether any of them has this property as well. We show that any other formulation that satisfies mild conditions cannot have the persistency property on all graphs, unless it is always equal to the stable set polytope.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2020; v1 submitted 4 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The stable set problem in graphs with bounded genus and bounded odd cycle packing number
Authors:
Michele Conforti,
Samuel Fiorin,
Tony Huynh,
Gwenaël Joret,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Consider the family of graphs without $ k $ node-disjoint odd cycles, where $ k $ is a constant. Determining the complexity of the stable set problem for such graphs $ G $ is a long-standing problem. We give a polynomial-time algorithm for the case that $ G $ can be further embedded in a (possibly non-orientable) surface of bounded genus. Moreover, we obtain polynomial-size extended formulations f…
▽ More
Consider the family of graphs without $ k $ node-disjoint odd cycles, where $ k $ is a constant. Determining the complexity of the stable set problem for such graphs $ G $ is a long-standing problem. We give a polynomial-time algorithm for the case that $ G $ can be further embedded in a (possibly non-orientable) surface of bounded genus. Moreover, we obtain polynomial-size extended formulations for the respective stable set polytopes.
To this end, we show that $2$-sided odd cycles satisfy the Erdős-Pósa property in graphs embedded in a fixed surface. This extends the fact that odd cycles satisfy the Erdős-Pósa property in graphs embedded in a fixed orientable surface (Kawarabayashi & Nakamoto, 2007).
Eventually, our findings allow us to reduce the original problem to the problem of finding a minimum-cost non-negative integer circulation of a certain homology class, which turns out to be efficiently solvable in our case.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Extended Formulations for Radial Cones
Authors:
Matthias Walter,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
This paper studies extended formulations for radial cones at vertices of polyhedra, where the radial cone of a polyhedron $ P $ at a vertex $ v \in P $ is the polyhedron defined by the constraints of $ P $ that are active at $ v $. Given an extended formulation for $ P $, it is easy to obtain an extended formulation of comparable size for each its radial cones. On the contrary, it is possible that…
▽ More
This paper studies extended formulations for radial cones at vertices of polyhedra, where the radial cone of a polyhedron $ P $ at a vertex $ v \in P $ is the polyhedron defined by the constraints of $ P $ that are active at $ v $. Given an extended formulation for $ P $, it is easy to obtain an extended formulation of comparable size for each its radial cones. On the contrary, it is possible that radial cones of $ P $ admit much smaller extended formulations than $ P $ itself. A prominent example of this type is the perfect-matching polytope, which cannot be described by subexponential-size extended formulations (Rothvoß 2014). However, Ventura & Eisenbrand (2003) showed that its radial cones can be described by polynomial-size extended formulations. Moreover, they generalized their construction to $ V $-join polyhedra. In the same paper, the authors asked whether the same holds for the odd-cut polyhedron, the blocker of the $ V $-join polyhedron. We answer this question negatively. Precisely, we show that radial cones of odd-cut polyhedra cannot be described by subexponential-size extended formulations. To obtain our result, for a polyhedron $ P $ of blocking type, we establish a general relationship between its radial cones and certain faces of the blocker of $ P $.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Distances of optimal solutions of mixed-integer programs
Authors:
Joseph Paat,
Robert Weismantel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
A classic result of Cook et al. (1986) bounds the distances between optimal solutions of mixed-integer linear programs and optimal solutions of the corresponding linear relaxations. Their bound is given in terms of the number of variables and a parameter $ Δ$, which quantifies sub-determinants of the underlying linear inequalities. We show that this distance can be bounded in terms of $ Δ$ and the…
▽ More
A classic result of Cook et al. (1986) bounds the distances between optimal solutions of mixed-integer linear programs and optimal solutions of the corresponding linear relaxations. Their bound is given in terms of the number of variables and a parameter $ Δ$, which quantifies sub-determinants of the underlying linear inequalities. We show that this distance can be bounded in terms of $ Δ$ and the number of integer variables rather than the total number of variables. To this end, we make use of a result by Olson (1969) in additive combinatorics and demonstrate how it implies feasibility of certain mixed-integer linear programs. We conjecture that our bound can be improved to a function that only depends on $ Δ$, in general.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Lifting Linear Extension Complexity Bounds to the Mixed-Integer Setting
Authors:
Alfonso Cevallos,
Stefan Weltge,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
Mixed-integer mathematical programs are among the most commonly used models for a wide set of problems in Operations Research and related fields. However, there is still very little known about what can be expressed by small mixed-integer programs. In particular, prior to this work, it was open whether some classical problems, like the minimum odd-cut problem, can be expressed by a compact mixed-i…
▽ More
Mixed-integer mathematical programs are among the most commonly used models for a wide set of problems in Operations Research and related fields. However, there is still very little known about what can be expressed by small mixed-integer programs. In particular, prior to this work, it was open whether some classical problems, like the minimum odd-cut problem, can be expressed by a compact mixed-integer program with few (even constantly many) integer variables. This is in stark contrast to linear formulations, where recent breakthroughs in the field of extended formulations have shown that many polytopes associated to classical combinatorial optimization problems do not even admit approximate extended formulations of sub-exponential size.
We provide a general framework for lifting inapproximability results of extended formulations to the setting of mixed-integer extended formulations, and obtain almost tight lower bounds on the number of integer variables needed to describe a variety of classical combinatorial optimization problems. Among the implications we obtain, we show that any mixed-integer extended formulation of sub-exponential size for the matching polytope, cut polytope, traveling salesman polytope or dominant of the odd-cut polytope, needs $ Ω(n/\log n) $ many integer variables, where $ n $ is the number of vertices of the underlying graph. Conversely, the above-mentioned polyhedra admit polynomial-size mixed-integer formulations with only $ O(n) $ or $ O(n \log n) $ (for the traveling salesman polytope) many integer variables.
Our results build upon a new decomposition technique that, for any convex set $ C $, allows for approximating any mixed-integer description of $ C $ by the intersection of $ C $ with the union of a small number of affine subspaces.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Strengthening Convex Relaxations of 0/1-Sets Using Boolean Formulas
Authors:
Samuel Fiorini,
Tony Huynh,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
In convex integer programming, various procedures have been developed to strengthen convex relaxations of sets of integer points. On the one hand, there exist several general-purpose methods that strengthen relaxations without specific knowledge of the set $ S $, such as popular linear programming or semi-definite programming hierarchies. On the other hand, various methods have been designed for o…
▽ More
In convex integer programming, various procedures have been developed to strengthen convex relaxations of sets of integer points. On the one hand, there exist several general-purpose methods that strengthen relaxations without specific knowledge of the set $ S $, such as popular linear programming or semi-definite programming hierarchies. On the other hand, various methods have been designed for obtaining strengthened relaxations for very specific sets that arise in combinatorial optimization. We propose a new efficient method that interpolates between these two approaches.
Our procedure strengthens any convex set $ Q \subseteq \mathbb{R}^n $ containing a set $ S \subseteq \{0,1\}^n $ by exploiting certain additional information about $ S $. Namely, the required extra information will be in the form of a Boolean formula $ φ$ defining the target set $ S $.
The aim of this work is to analyze various aspects regarding the strength of our procedure. As one result, interpreting an iterated application of our procedure as a hierarchy, our findings simplify, improve, and extend previous results by Bienstock and Zuckerberg on covering problems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2018; v1 submitted 3 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Extension complexities of Cartesian products involving a pyramid
Authors:
Hans Raj Tiwary,
Stefan Weltge,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
It is an open question whether the linear extension complexity of the Cartesian product of two polytopes P, Q is the sum of the extension complexities of P and Q. We give an affirmative answer to this question for the case that one of the two polytopes is a pyramid.
It is an open question whether the linear extension complexity of the Cartesian product of two polytopes P, Q is the sum of the extension complexities of P and Q. We give an affirmative answer to this question for the case that one of the two polytopes is a pyramid.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Characterizing Polytopes Contained in the $0/1$-Cube with Bounded Chvátal-Gomory Rank
Authors:
Yohann Benchetrit,
Samuel Fiorini,
Tony Huynh,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Let $S \subseteq \{0,1\}^n$ and $R$ be any polytope contained in $[0,1]^n$ with $R \cap \{0,1\}^n = S$. We prove that $R$ has bounded Chvátal-Gomory rank (CG-rank) provided that $S$ has bounded notch and bounded gap, where the notch is the minimum integer $p$ such that all $p$-dimensional faces of the $0/1$-cube have a nonempty intersection with $S$, and the gap is a measure of the size of the fac…
▽ More
Let $S \subseteq \{0,1\}^n$ and $R$ be any polytope contained in $[0,1]^n$ with $R \cap \{0,1\}^n = S$. We prove that $R$ has bounded Chvátal-Gomory rank (CG-rank) provided that $S$ has bounded notch and bounded gap, where the notch is the minimum integer $p$ such that all $p$-dimensional faces of the $0/1$-cube have a nonempty intersection with $S$, and the gap is a measure of the size of the facet coefficients of $\mathsf{conv}(S)$.
Let $H[\bar{S}]$ denote the subgraph of the $n$-cube induced by the vertices not in $S$. We prove that if $H[\bar{S}]$ does not contain a subdivision of a large complete graph, then both the notch and the gap are bounded. By our main result, this implies that the CG-rank of $R$ is bounded as a function of the treewidth of $H[\bar{S}]$. We also prove that if $S$ has notch $3$, then the CG-rank of $R$ is always bounded. Both results generalize a recent theorem of Cornuéjols and Lee, who proved that the CG-rank is bounded by a constant if the treewidth of $H[\bar{S}]$ is at most $2$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2017; v1 submitted 20 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Optimality certificates for convex minimization and Helly numbers
Authors:
Amitabh Basu,
Michele Conforti,
Gérard Cornuéjols,
Robert Weismantel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
We consider the problem of minimizing a convex function over a subset of R^n that is not necessarily convex (minimization of a convex function over the integer points in a polytope is a special case). We define a family of duals for this problem and show that, under some natural conditions, strong duality holds for a dual problem in this family that is more restrictive than previously considered d…
▽ More
We consider the problem of minimizing a convex function over a subset of R^n that is not necessarily convex (minimization of a convex function over the integer points in a polytope is a special case). We define a family of duals for this problem and show that, under some natural conditions, strong duality holds for a dual problem in this family that is more restrictive than previously considered duals.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Maximum Semidefinite and Linear Extension Complexity of Families of Polytopes
Authors:
Gennadiy Averkov,
Volker Kaibel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
We relate the maximum semidefinite and linear extension complexity of a family of polytopes to the cardinality of this family and the minimum pairwise Hausdorff distance of its members. This result directly implies a known lower bound on the maximum semidefinite extension complexity of 0/1-polytopes. We further show how our result can be used to improve on the corresponding bounds known for polygo…
▽ More
We relate the maximum semidefinite and linear extension complexity of a family of polytopes to the cardinality of this family and the minimum pairwise Hausdorff distance of its members. This result directly implies a known lower bound on the maximum semidefinite extension complexity of 0/1-polytopes. We further show how our result can be used to improve on the corresponding bounds known for polygons with integer vertices.
Our geometric proof builds upon nothing else than a simple well-known property of maximum volume inscribed ellipsoids of convex bodies. In particular, it does not rely on factorizations over the semidefinite cone and thus avoids involved procedures of balancing them as required, e.g., in [Briet, Dadush & Pokutta 2015]. We hope that revealing the geometry behind the phenomenon opens doors for further results.
Moreover, we show that the linear extension complexity of every d-dimensional 0/1-polytope is bounded from above by O(2^d / d).
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Tight bounds on discrete quantitative Helly numbers
Authors:
Gennadiy Averkov,
Bernardo González Merino,
Matthias Henze,
Ingo Paschke,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Given a subset S of R^n, let c(S,k) be the smallest number t such that whenever finitely many convex sets have exactly k common points in S, there exist at most t of these sets that already have exactly k common points in S. For S = Z^n, this number was introduced by Aliev et al. [2014] who gave an explicit bound showing that c(Z^n,k) = O(k) holds for every fixed n. Recently, Chestnut et al. [2015…
▽ More
Given a subset S of R^n, let c(S,k) be the smallest number t such that whenever finitely many convex sets have exactly k common points in S, there exist at most t of these sets that already have exactly k common points in S. For S = Z^n, this number was introduced by Aliev et al. [2014] who gave an explicit bound showing that c(Z^n,k) = O(k) holds for every fixed n. Recently, Chestnut et al. [2015] improved this to c(Z^n,k) = O(k (log log k)(log k)^{-1/3} ) and provided the lower bound c(Z^n,k) = Omega(k^{(n-1)/(n+1)}).
We provide a combinatorial description of c(S,k) in terms of polytopes with vertices in S and use it to improve the previously known bounds as follows: We strengthen the bound of Aliev et al. [2014] by a constant factor and extend it to general discrete sets S. We close the gap for Z^n by showing that c(Z^n,k) = Theta(k^{(n-1)/(n+1)}) holds for every fixed n. Finally, we determine the exact values of c(Z^n,k) for all k <= 4.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Notions of maximality for integral lattice-free polyhedra: the case of dimension three
Authors:
Gennadiy Averkov,
Jan Krümpelmann,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Lattice-free sets (convex subsets of $\mathbb{R}^d$ without interior integer points) and their applications for cutting-plane methods in mixed-integer optimization have been studied in recent literature. Notably, the family of all integral lattice-free polyhedra which are not properly contained in another integral lattice-free polyhedron has been of particular interest. We call these polyhedra…
▽ More
Lattice-free sets (convex subsets of $\mathbb{R}^d$ without interior integer points) and their applications for cutting-plane methods in mixed-integer optimization have been studied in recent literature. Notably, the family of all integral lattice-free polyhedra which are not properly contained in another integral lattice-free polyhedron has been of particular interest. We call these polyhedra $\mathbb{Z}^d$-maximal.
It is known that, for fixed $d$, the family $\mathbb{Z}^d$-maximal integral lattice-free polyhedra is finite up to unimodular equivalence. In view of possible applications in cutting-plane theory, one would like to have a classification of this family. However, this turns out to be a challenging task already for small dimensions.
In contrast, the subfamily of all integral lattice-free polyhedra which are not properly contained in any other lattice-free set, which we call $\mathbb{R}^d$-maximal lattice-free polyhedra, allow a rather simple geometric characterization. Hence, the question was raised for which dimensions the notions of $\mathbb{Z}^d$-maximality and $\mathbb{R}^d$-maximality are equivalent. This was known to be the case for dimensions one and two. On the other hand, Nill and Ziegler (2011) showed that for dimension $d \ge 4$, there exist polyhedra which are $\mathbb{Z}^d$-maximal but not $\mathbb{R}^d$-maximal. In this article, we consider the remaining case $d = 3$ and prove that for integral polyhedra the notions of $\mathbb{R}^3$-maximality and $\mathbb{Z}^3$-maximality are equivalent. As a consequence, the classification of all $\mathbb{R}^3$-maximal integral polyhedra by Averkov, Wagner and Weismantel (2011) contains all $\mathbb{Z}^3$-maximal integral polyhedra.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Extended Formulations for Independence Polytopes of Regular Matroids
Authors:
Volker Kaibel,
Jon Lee,
Matthias Walter,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
The ancillary file Corrigendum.pdf contains an explanation why our proof does not work.
The ancillary file Corrigendum.pdf contains an explanation why our proof does not work.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2019; v1 submitted 15 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Subgraph Polytopes and Independence Polytopes of Count Matroids
Authors:
Michele Conforti,
Volker Kaibel,
Matthias Walter,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Given an undirected graph, the non-empty subgraph polytope is the convex hull of the characteristic vectors of pairs (F, S) where S is a non-empty subset of nodes and F is a subset of the edges with both endnodes in S. We obtain a strong relationship between the non-empty subgraph polytope and the spanning forest polytope. We further show that these polytopes provide polynomial size extended formu…
▽ More
Given an undirected graph, the non-empty subgraph polytope is the convex hull of the characteristic vectors of pairs (F, S) where S is a non-empty subset of nodes and F is a subset of the edges with both endnodes in S. We obtain a strong relationship between the non-empty subgraph polytope and the spanning forest polytope. We further show that these polytopes provide polynomial size extended formulations for independence polytopes of count matroids, which generalizes recent results obtained by Iwata et al. referring to sparsity matroids. As a byproduct, we obtain new lower bounds on the extension complexity of the spanning forest polytope in terms of extension complexities of independence polytopes of these matroids.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2015; v1 submitted 10 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Computing The Extension Complexities of All 4-Dimensional 0/1-Polytopes
Authors:
Michael Oelze,
Arnaud Vandaele,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
We present slight refinements of known general lower and upper bounds on sizes of extended formulations for polytopes. With these observations we are able to compute the extension complexities of all 0/1-polytopes up to dimension 4. We provide a complete list of our results including geometric constructions of minimum size extensions for all considered polytopes. Furthermore, we show that all of t…
▽ More
We present slight refinements of known general lower and upper bounds on sizes of extended formulations for polytopes. With these observations we are able to compute the extension complexities of all 0/1-polytopes up to dimension 4. We provide a complete list of our results including geometric constructions of minimum size extensions for all considered polytopes. Furthermore, we show that all of these extensions have strong properties. In particular, one of our computational results is that every 0/1-polytope up to dimension 4 has a minimum size extension that is also a 0/1-polytope.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Hidden Vertices in Extensions of Polytopes
Authors:
Kanstantsin Pashkovich,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Some widely known compact extended formulations have the property that each vertex of the corresponding extension polytope is projected onto a vertex of the target polytope. In this paper, we prove that for heptagons with vertices in general position none of the minimum size extensions has this property. Additionally, for any d >= 2 we construct a family of d-polytopes such that at least 1/9 of al…
▽ More
Some widely known compact extended formulations have the property that each vertex of the corresponding extension polytope is projected onto a vertex of the target polytope. In this paper, we prove that for heptagons with vertices in general position none of the minimum size extensions has this property. Additionally, for any d >= 2 we construct a family of d-polytopes such that at least 1/9 of all vertices of any of their minimum size extensions is not projected onto vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2015; v1 submitted 10 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Lower Bounds on the Sizes of Integer Programs Without Additional Variables
Authors:
Volker Kaibel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
Let X be the set of integer points in some polyhedron. We investigate the smallest number of facets of any polyhedron whose set of integer points is X. This quantity, which we call the relaxation complexity of X, corresponds to the smallest number of linear inequalities of any integer program having X as the set of feasible solutions that does not use auxiliary variables. We show that the use of a…
▽ More
Let X be the set of integer points in some polyhedron. We investigate the smallest number of facets of any polyhedron whose set of integer points is X. This quantity, which we call the relaxation complexity of X, corresponds to the smallest number of linear inequalities of any integer program having X as the set of feasible solutions that does not use auxiliary variables. We show that the use of auxiliary variables is essential for constructing polynomial size integer programming formulations in many relevant cases. In particular, we provide asymptotically tight exponential lower bounds on the relaxation complexity of the integer points of several well-known combinatorial polytopes, including the traveling salesman polytope and the spanning tree polytope.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2014; v1 submitted 13 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
A Short Proof that the Extension Complexity of the Correlation Polytope Grows Exponentially
Authors:
Volker Kaibel,
Stefan Weltge
Abstract:
We establish that the extension complexity of the nXn correlation polytope is at least 1.5^n by a short proof that is self-contained except for using the fact that every face of a polyhedron is the intersection of all facets it is contained in. The main innovative aspect of the proof is a simple combinatorial argument showing that the rectangle covering number of the unique-disjointness matrix is…
▽ More
We establish that the extension complexity of the nXn correlation polytope is at least 1.5^n by a short proof that is self-contained except for using the fact that every face of a polyhedron is the intersection of all facets it is contained in. The main innovative aspect of the proof is a simple combinatorial argument showing that the rectangle covering number of the unique-disjointness matrix is at least 1.5^n, and thus the nondeterministic communication complexity of the unique-disjointness predicate is at least .58n. We thereby slightly improve on the previously best known lower bounds 1.24^n and .31n, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2016; v1 submitted 12 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
