-
The Impact of Symmetry Handling for the Stable Set Problem via Schreier-Sims Cuts
Authors:
Christopher Hojny,
Marc E. Pfetsch,
José Verschae
Abstract:
Symmetry handling inequalities (SHIs) are an appealing and popular tool for handling symmetries in integer programming. Despite their practical application, little is known about their interaction with optimization problems. This article focuses on Schreier-Sims (SST) cuts, a recently introduced family of SHIs, and investigate their impact on the computational and polyhedral complexity of optimiza…
▽ More
Symmetry handling inequalities (SHIs) are an appealing and popular tool for handling symmetries in integer programming. Despite their practical application, little is known about their interaction with optimization problems. This article focuses on Schreier-Sims (SST) cuts, a recently introduced family of SHIs, and investigate their impact on the computational and polyhedral complexity of optimization problems. Given that SST cuts are not unique, a crucial question is to understand how different constructions of SST cuts influence the solving process.
First, we observe that SST cuts do not increase the computational complexity of solving a linear optimization problem over any polytope $P$. However, separating the integer hull of $P$ enriched by SST cuts can be NP-hard, even if $P$ is integral and has a compact formulation. We study this phenomenon more in-depth for the stable set problem, particularly for subclasses of perfect graphs. For bipartite graphs, we give a complete characterization of the integer hull after adding SST cuts based on odd-cycle inequalities. For trivially perfect graphs, we observe that the separation problem is still NP-hard after adding a generic set of SST cuts. Our main contribution is to identify a specific class of SST cuts, called stringent SST cuts, that keeps the separation problem polynomial and a complete set of inequalities, namely SST clique cuts, that yield a complete linear description.
We complement these results by giving SST cuts based presolving techniques and provide a computational study to compare the different approaches. In particular, our newly identified stringent SST cuts dominate other approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Schreier-Sims Cuts meet Stable Set: Preserving Problem Structure when Handling Symmetries
Authors:
Christopher Hojny,
Marc E. Pfetsch,
José Verschae
Abstract:
Symmetry handling inequalities (SHIs) are a popular tool to handle symmetries in integer programming. Despite their successful application in practice, only little is known about the interaction of SHIs with optimization problems. In this article, we focus on SST cuts, an attractive class of SHIs, and investigate their computational and polyhedral consequences for optimization problems. After show…
▽ More
Symmetry handling inequalities (SHIs) are a popular tool to handle symmetries in integer programming. Despite their successful application in practice, only little is known about the interaction of SHIs with optimization problems. In this article, we focus on SST cuts, an attractive class of SHIs, and investigate their computational and polyhedral consequences for optimization problems. After showing that they do not increase the computational complexity of solving optimization problems, we focus on the stable set problem for which we derive presolving techniques based on SST cuts. Moreover, we derive strengthened versions of SST cuts and identify cases in which adding these inequalities to the stable set polytope maintains integrality. Preliminary computational experiments show that our techniques have a high potential to reduce both the size of stable set problems and the time to solve them.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
On the geometry of symmetry breaking inequalities
Authors:
José Verschae,
Matías Villagra,
Léonard von Niederhäusern
Abstract:
Breaking symmetries is a popular way of speeding up the branch-and-bound method for symmetric integer programs. We study fundamental domains, which are minimal and closed symmetry breaking polyhedra. Our long-term goal is to understand the relationship between the complexity of such polyhedra and their symmetry breaking capability.
Borrowing ideas from geometric group theory, we provide structur…
▽ More
Breaking symmetries is a popular way of speeding up the branch-and-bound method for symmetric integer programs. We study fundamental domains, which are minimal and closed symmetry breaking polyhedra. Our long-term goal is to understand the relationship between the complexity of such polyhedra and their symmetry breaking capability.
Borrowing ideas from geometric group theory, we provide structural properties that relate the action of the group with the geometry of the facets of fundamental domains. Inspired by these insights, we provide a new generalized construction for fundamental domains, which we call generalized Dirichlet domain (GDD). Our construction is recursive and exploits the coset decomposition of the subgroups that fix given vectors in $\mathbb{R}^n$. We use this construction to analyze a recently introduced set of symmetry breaking inequalities by Salvagnin (2018) and Liberti and Ostrowski (2014), called Schreier-Sims inequalities. In particular, this shows that every permutation group admits a fundamental domain with less than $n$ facets. We also show that this bound is tight.
Finally, we prove that the Schreier-Sims inequalities can contain an exponential number of isomorphic binary vectors for a given permutation group $G$, which provides evidence of the lack of symmetry breaking effectiveness of this fundamental domain. Conversely, a suitably constructed GDD for this $G$ has linearly many inequalities and contains unique representatives for isomorphic binary vectors.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
A Water-Filling Primal-Dual Algorithm for Approximating Non-Linear Covering Problems
Authors:
Andrés Fielbaum,
Ignacio Morales,
José Verschae
Abstract:
Obtaining strong linear relaxations of capacitated covering problems constitute a major technical challenge even for simple settings. For one of the most basic cases, the Knapsack-Cover (Min-Knapsack) problem, the relaxation based on knapsack-cover inequalities achieves an integrality gap of 2. These inequalities have been exploited in more general environments, many of which admit primal-dual app…
▽ More
Obtaining strong linear relaxations of capacitated covering problems constitute a major technical challenge even for simple settings. For one of the most basic cases, the Knapsack-Cover (Min-Knapsack) problem, the relaxation based on knapsack-cover inequalities achieves an integrality gap of 2. These inequalities have been exploited in more general environments, many of which admit primal-dual approximation algorithms.
Inspired by problems from power and transport systems, we introduce a new general setting in which items can be taken fractionally to cover a given demand. The cost incurred by an item is given by an arbitrary non-decreasing function of the chosen fraction. We generalize the knapsack-cover inequalities to this setting an use them to obtain a $(2+\varepsilon)$-approximate primal-dual algorithm. Our procedure has a natural interpretation as a bucket-filling algorithm, which effectively balances the difficulties given by having different slopes in the cost functions: when some superior portion of an item presents a low slope, it helps to increase the priority with which the inferior portions may be taken. We also present a rounding algorithm with an approximation guarantee of 2.
We generalize our algorithm to the Unsplittable Flow-Cover problem on a line, also for the setting where items can be taken fractionally. For this problem we obtain a $(4+\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm in polynomial time, almost matching the $4$-approximation known for the classical setting.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
