-
Directed First-Order Logic
Authors:
Andrea Laretto,
Fosco Loregian,
Niccolò Veltri
Abstract:
We present a first-order logic equipped with an "asymmetric" directed notion of equality, which can be thought of as transitions/rewrites between terms, allowing for types to be interpreted as preorders. We then provide a universal property to such "directed equalities" by describing introduction and elimination rules that allows them to be contracted only with certain syntactic restrictions, base…
▽ More
We present a first-order logic equipped with an "asymmetric" directed notion of equality, which can be thought of as transitions/rewrites between terms, allowing for types to be interpreted as preorders. We then provide a universal property to such "directed equalities" by describing introduction and elimination rules that allows them to be contracted only with certain syntactic restrictions, based on polarity, which do not allow for symmetry to be derived. We give a characterization of such directed equality as a relative left adjoint, generalizing the idea by Lawvere of equality as left adjoint. The logic is equipped with a precise syntactic system of polarities, inspired by dinaturality, that keeps track of the occurrence of variables (positive/negative/both). The semantics of this logic and its system of variances is then captured categorically using the notion of directed doctrine, which we prove sound and complete with respect to the syntax.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Directed equality with dinaturality
Authors:
Andrea Laretto,
Fosco Loregian,
Niccolò Veltri
Abstract:
We show how dinaturality plays a central role in the interpretation of directed type theory where types are interpreted as (1-)categories and directed equality is represented by $\hom$-functors. We present a general elimination principle based on dinaturality for directed equality which very closely resembles the $J$-rule used in Martin-Löf type theory, and we highlight which syntactical restricti…
▽ More
We show how dinaturality plays a central role in the interpretation of directed type theory where types are interpreted as (1-)categories and directed equality is represented by $\hom$-functors. We present a general elimination principle based on dinaturality for directed equality which very closely resembles the $J$-rule used in Martin-Löf type theory, and we highlight which syntactical restrictions are needed to interpret this rule in the context of directed equality. We then use these rules to characterize directed equality as a left relative adjoint to a functor between (para)categories of dinatural transformations which contracts together two variables appearing naturally with a single dinatural one, with the relative functor imposing the syntactic restrictions needed. We then argue that the quantifiers of such a directed type theory should be interpreted as ends and coends, which dinaturality allows us to present in adjoint-like correspondences to a weakening functor. Using these rules we give a formal interpretation to Yoneda reductions and (co)end calculus, and we use logical derivations to prove the Fubini rule for quantifier exchange, the adjointness property of Kan extensions via (co)ends, exponential objects of presheaves, and the (co)Yoneda lemma. We show transitivity (composition), congruence (functoriality), and transport (coYoneda) for directed equality by closely following the same approach of Martin-Löf type theory, with the notable exception of symmetry. We formalize our main theorems in Agda.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Proof Theory of Partially Normal Skew Monoidal Categories
Authors:
Tarmo Uustalu,
Niccolò Veltri,
Noam Zeilberger
Abstract:
The skew monoidal categories of Szlachányi are a weakening of monoidal categories where the three structural laws of left and right unitality and associativity are not required to be isomorphisms but merely transformations in a particular direction. In previous work, we showed that the free skew monoidal category on a set of generating objects can be concretely presented as a sequent calculus. Thi…
▽ More
The skew monoidal categories of Szlachányi are a weakening of monoidal categories where the three structural laws of left and right unitality and associativity are not required to be isomorphisms but merely transformations in a particular direction. In previous work, we showed that the free skew monoidal category on a set of generating objects can be concretely presented as a sequent calculus. This calculus enjoys cut elimination and admits focusing, i.e. a subsystem of canonical derivations, which solves the coherence problem for skew monoidal categories.
In this paper, we develop sequent calculi for partially normal skew monoidal categories, which are skew monoidal categories with one or more structural laws invertible. Each normality condition leads to additional inference rules and equations on them. We prove cut elimination and we show that the calculi admit focusing. The result is a family of sequent calculi between those of skew monoidal categories and (fully normal) monoidal categories. On the level of derivability, these define 8 weakenings of the (unit,tensor) fragment of intuitionistic non-commutative linear logic.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Deductive Systems and Coherence for Skew Prounital Closed Categories
Authors:
Tarmo Uustalu,
Niccolò Veltri,
Noam Zeilberger
Abstract:
In this paper, we develop the proof theory of skew prounital closed categories. These are variants of the skew closed categories of Street where the unit is not represented. Skew closed categories in turn are a weakening of the closed categories of Eilenberg and Kelly where no structural law is required to be invertible. The presence of a monoidal structure in these categories is not required. We…
▽ More
In this paper, we develop the proof theory of skew prounital closed categories. These are variants of the skew closed categories of Street where the unit is not represented. Skew closed categories in turn are a weakening of the closed categories of Eilenberg and Kelly where no structural law is required to be invertible. The presence of a monoidal structure in these categories is not required. We construct several equivalent presentations of the free skew prounital closed category on a given set of generating objects: a categorical calculus (Hilbert-style system), a cut-free sequent calculus and a natural deduction system corresponding to a variant of planar (= non-commutative linear) typed lambda-calculus. We solve the coherence problem for skew prounital closed categories by showing that the sequent calculus admits focusing and presenting two reduction-free normalization procedures for the natural deduction calculus: normalization by evaluation and hereditary substitutions. Normal natural deduction derivations (beta-eta-long forms) are in one-to-one correspondence with derivations in the focused sequent calculus. Unexpectedly, the free skew prounital closed category on a set satisfies a left-normality condition which makes it lose its skew aspect. This pitfall can be avoided by considering the free skew prounital closed category on a skew multicategory instead. The latter has a presentation as a cut-free sequent calculus for which it is easy to see that the left-normality condition generally fails.
The whole development has been fully formalized in the dependently typed programming language Agda.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
The Sequent Calculus of Skew Monoidal Categories
Authors:
Tarmo Uustalu,
Niccolò Veltri,
Noam Zeilberger
Abstract:
Szlachányi's skew monoidal categories are a well-motivated variation of monoidal categories in which the unitors and associator are not required to be natural isomorphisms, but merely natural transformations in a particular direction. We present a sequent calculus for skew monoidal categories, building on the recent formulation by one of the authors of a sequent calculus for the Tamari order (skew…
▽ More
Szlachányi's skew monoidal categories are a well-motivated variation of monoidal categories in which the unitors and associator are not required to be natural isomorphisms, but merely natural transformations in a particular direction. We present a sequent calculus for skew monoidal categories, building on the recent formulation by one of the authors of a sequent calculus for the Tamari order (skew semigroup categories). In this calculus, antecedents consist of a stoup (an optional formula) followed by a context, and the connectives behave like in the standard monoidal sequent calculus except that the left rules may only be applied in stoup position. We prove that this calculus is sound and complete with respect to existence of maps in the free skew monoidal category, and moreover that it captures equality of maps once a suitable equivalence relation is imposed on derivations. We then identify a subsystem of focused derivations and establish that it contains exactly one canonical representative from each equivalence class. This coherence theorem leads directly to simple procedures for deciding equality of maps in the free skew monoidal category and for enumerating any homset without duplicates. Finally, and in the spirit of Lambek's work, we describe the close connection between this proof-theoretic analysis and Bourke and Lack's recent characterization of skew monoidal categories as left representable skew multicategories. We have formalized this development in the dependently typed programming language Agda.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Terminal Coalgebras and Non-wellfounded Sets in Homotopy Type Theory
Authors:
Håkon Robbestad Gylterud,
Elisabeth Stenholm,
Niccolò Veltri
Abstract:
Non-wellfounded material sets have been modeled in Martin-Löf type theory by Lindström using setoids. In this paper we construct models of non-wellfounded material sets in Homotopy Type Theory (HoTT) where equality is interpreted as the identity type. The first model satisfies Scott's Anti-Foundation Axiom (SAFA) and dualises the construction of iterative sets. The second model satisfies Aczel's A…
▽ More
Non-wellfounded material sets have been modeled in Martin-Löf type theory by Lindström using setoids. In this paper we construct models of non-wellfounded material sets in Homotopy Type Theory (HoTT) where equality is interpreted as the identity type. The first model satisfies Scott's Anti-Foundation Axiom (SAFA) and dualises the construction of iterative sets. The second model satisfies Aczel's Anti-Foundation Axiom (AFA), and is constructed by adaption of Aczel--Mendler's terminal coalgebra theorem to type theory, which requires propositional resizing.
In an bid to extend coalgebraic theory and anti-foundation axioms to higher type levels, we formulate generalisations of AFA and SAFA, and construct a hierarchy of models which satisfies the SAFA generalisations. These generalisations build on the framework of Univalent Material Set Theory, previously developed by two of the authors.
Since the model constructions are based on M-types, the paper also includes a characterisation of the identity type of M-types as indexed M-types.
Our results are formalised in the proof-assistant Agda.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2025; v1 submitted 18 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Bicategories in Univalent Foundations
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Dan Frumin,
Marco Maggesi,
Niccolò Veltri,
Niels van der Weide
Abstract:
We develop bicategory theory in univalent foundations. Guided by the notion of univalence for (1-)categories studied by Ahrens, Kapulkin, and Shulman, we define and study univalent bicategories. To construct examples of univalent bicategories in a modular fashion, we develop displayed bicategories, an analog of displayed 1-categories introduced by Ahrens and Lumsdaine. We demonstrate the applicabi…
▽ More
We develop bicategory theory in univalent foundations. Guided by the notion of univalence for (1-)categories studied by Ahrens, Kapulkin, and Shulman, we define and study univalent bicategories. To construct examples of univalent bicategories in a modular fashion, we develop displayed bicategories, an analog of displayed 1-categories introduced by Ahrens and Lumsdaine. We demonstrate the applicability of this notion, and prove that several bicategories of interest are univalent. Among these are the bicategory of univalent categories with families and the bicategory of pseudofunctors between univalent bicategories. Furthermore, we show that every bicategory with univalent hom-categories is weakly equivalent to a univalent bicategory. All of our work is formalized in Coq as part of the UniMath library of univalent mathematics.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2022; v1 submitted 4 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
