-
Robust Topology Optimization of Electric Machines using Topological Derivatives
Authors:
Peter Gangl,
Theodor Komann,
Nepomuk Krenn,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
Designing high-performance electric machines that maintain their efficiency and reliability under uncertain material and operating conditions is crucial for industrial applications. In this paper, we present a novel framework for robust topology optimization with partial differential equation constraints to address this challenge. The robust optimization problem is formulated as a min-max optimiza…
▽ More
Designing high-performance electric machines that maintain their efficiency and reliability under uncertain material and operating conditions is crucial for industrial applications. In this paper, we present a novel framework for robust topology optimization with partial differential equation constraints to address this challenge. The robust optimization problem is formulated as a min-max optimization problem, where the inner maximization is the worst case with respect to predefined uncertainties, while the outer minimization aims to find an optimal topology that remains robust under these uncertainties using the topological derivative. The shape of the domain is represented by a level set function, which allows for arbitrary perturbation of the domain. The robust optimization problem is solved using a theorem of Clarke to compute subgradients of the worst case function. This allows the min-max problem to be solved efficiently and ensures that we find a design that performs well even in the presence of uncertainty. Finally, numerical results for a two-material permanent magnet synchronous machine demonstrate both the effectiveness of the method and the improved performance of robust designs under uncertain conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Spline-Based Rotor and Stator Optimization of a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
Authors:
Michael Wiesheu,
Theodor Komann,
Melina Merkel,
Sebastian Schöps,
Stefan Ulbrich,
Idoia Cortes Garcia
Abstract:
This work features the optimization of a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor using 2D nonlinear simulations in an Isogeometric Analysis framework. The rotor and stator designs are optimized for both geometric parameters and surface shapes via modifications of control points. The scaling laws for magnetism are employed to allow for axial and radial scaling, enabling a thorough optimization of all cr…
▽ More
This work features the optimization of a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor using 2D nonlinear simulations in an Isogeometric Analysis framework. The rotor and stator designs are optimized for both geometric parameters and surface shapes via modifications of control points. The scaling laws for magnetism are employed to allow for axial and radial scaling, enabling a thorough optimization of all critical machine parameters for multiple operating points. The process is carried out in a gradient-based fashion with the objectives of lowering motor material cost, torque ripple and losses. It is shown that the optimization can be efficiently conducted for many optimization variables and all objective values can be reduced.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Combined Parameter and Shape Optimization of Electric Machines with Isogeometric Analysis
Authors:
Michael Wiesheu,
Theodor Komann,
Melina Merkel,
Sebastian Schöps,
Stefan Ulbrich,
Idoia Cortes Garcia
Abstract:
In structural optimization, both parameters and shape are relevant for the model performance. Yet, conventional optimization techniques usually consider either parameters or the shape separately. This work addresses this problem by proposing a simple yet powerful approach to combine parameter and shape optimization in a framework using Isogeometric Analysis (IGA). The optimization employs sensitiv…
▽ More
In structural optimization, both parameters and shape are relevant for the model performance. Yet, conventional optimization techniques usually consider either parameters or the shape separately. This work addresses this problem by proposing a simple yet powerful approach to combine parameter and shape optimization in a framework using Isogeometric Analysis (IGA). The optimization employs sensitivity analysis by determining the gradients of an objective function with respect to parameters and control points that represent the geometry. The gradients with respect to the control points are calculated in an analytical way using the adjoint method, which enables straightforward shape optimization by altering of these control points. Given that a change in a single geometry parameter corresponds to modifications in multiple control points, the chain rule is employed to obtain the gradient with respect to the parameters in an efficient semi-analytical way. The presented method is exemplarily applied to nonlinear 2D magnetostatic simulations featuring a permanent magnet synchronous motor and compared to designs, which were optimized using parameter and shape optimization separately. It is numerically shown that the permanent magnet mass can be reduced and the torque ripple can be eliminated almost completely by simultaneously adjusting rotor parameters and shape. The approach allows for novel designs to be created with the potential to reduce the optimization time substantially.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2025; v1 submitted 10 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A simplified Newton method to generate snapshots for POD models of semilinear optimal control problems
Authors:
Paul Manns,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
In PDE-constrained optimization, proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) provides a surrogate model of a (potentially expensive) PDE discretization, on which optimization iterations are executed. Because POD models usually provide good approximation quality only locally, they have to be updated during optimization. Updating the POD model is usually expensive, however, and therefore often impossible…
▽ More
In PDE-constrained optimization, proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) provides a surrogate model of a (potentially expensive) PDE discretization, on which optimization iterations are executed. Because POD models usually provide good approximation quality only locally, they have to be updated during optimization. Updating the POD model is usually expensive, however, and therefore often impossible in a model-predictive control (MPC) context. Thus, reduced models of mediocre quality might be accepted. We take the view of a simplified Newton method for solving semilinear evolution equations to derive an algorithm that can serve as an offline phase to produce a POD model. Approaches that build the POD model with impulse response snapshots can be regarded as the first Newton step in this context.
In particular, POD models that are based on impulse response snapshots are extended by adding a second simplified Newton step. This procedure improves the approximation quality of the POD model significantly by introducing a moderate amount of extra computational costs during optimization or the MPC loop. We illustrate our findings with an example satisfying our assumptions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
On the Characterization of Generalized Derivatives for the Solution Operator of the Bilateral Obstacle Problem
Authors:
Anne-Therese Rauls,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
We consider optimal control problems for a wide class of bilateral obstacle problems where the control appears in a possibly nonlinear source term. The non-differentiability of the solution operator poses the main challenge for the application of efficient optimization methods and the characterization of Bouligand generalized derivatives of the solution operator is essential for their theoretical…
▽ More
We consider optimal control problems for a wide class of bilateral obstacle problems where the control appears in a possibly nonlinear source term. The non-differentiability of the solution operator poses the main challenge for the application of efficient optimization methods and the characterization of Bouligand generalized derivatives of the solution operator is essential for their theoretical foundation and numerical realization. In this paper, we derive specific elements of the Bouligand generalized differential if the control operator satisfies natural monotonicity properties. We construct monotone sequences of controls where the solution operator is Gâteaux differentiable and characterize the corresponding limit element of the Bouligand generalized differential as being the solution operator of a Dirichlet problem on a quasi-open domain. In contrast to a similar recent result for the unilateral obstacle problem [RU19], we have to deal with an opposite monotonic behavior of the active and strictly active sets corresponding to the upper and lower obstacle. Moreover, the residual is no longer a nonnegative functional on H^{-1} and its representation as the difference of two nonnegative Radon measures requires special care. This necessitates new proof techniques that yield two elements of the Bouligand generalized differential. Also for the unilateral case we obtain an additional element to that derived in [RU19].
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2021; v1 submitted 10 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Differentiability results and sensitivity calculation for optimal control of incompressible two-phase Navier-Stokes equations with surface tension
Authors:
Elisabeth Diehl,
Johannes Haubner,
Michael Ulbrich,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
We analyze optimal control problems for two-phase Navier-Stokes equations with surface tension. Based on $L_p$-maximal regularity of the underlying linear problem and recent well-posedness results of the problem for sufficiently small data we show the differentiability of the solution with respect to initial and distributed controls for appropriate spaces resulting form the $L_p$-maximal regularit…
▽ More
We analyze optimal control problems for two-phase Navier-Stokes equations with surface tension. Based on $L_p$-maximal regularity of the underlying linear problem and recent well-posedness results of the problem for sufficiently small data we show the differentiability of the solution with respect to initial and distributed controls for appropriate spaces resulting form the $L_p$-maximal regularity setting. We consider first a formulation where the interface is transformed to a hyperplane. Then we deduce differentiability results for the solution in the physical coordinates. Finally, we state an equivalent Volume-of-Fluid type formulation and use the obtained differentiability results to derive rigorosly the corresponding sensitivity equations of the Volume-of-Fluid type formulation. For objective functionals involving the velocity field or the discontinuous pressure or phase indciator field we derive differentiability results with respect to controls and state formulas for the derivative. The results of the paper form an analytical foundation for stating optimality conditions, justifying the application of derivative based optimization methods and for studying the convergence of discrete sensitivity schemes based on Volume-of-Fluid discretizations for optimal control of two-phase Navier-Stokes equations.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2021; v1 submitted 9 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Identification of Model Uncertainty via Optimal Design of Experiments Applied to a Mechanical Press
Authors:
Tristan Gally,
Peter Groche,
Florian Hoppe,
Anja Kuttich,
Alexander Matei,
Marc E. Pfetsch,
Martin Rakowitsch,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
In engineering applications almost all processes are described with the help of models. Especially forming machines heavily rely on mathematical models for control and condition monitoring. Inaccuracies during the modeling, manufacturing and assembly of these machines induce model uncertainty which impairs the controller's performance. In this paper we propose an approach to identify model uncerta…
▽ More
In engineering applications almost all processes are described with the help of models. Especially forming machines heavily rely on mathematical models for control and condition monitoring. Inaccuracies during the modeling, manufacturing and assembly of these machines induce model uncertainty which impairs the controller's performance. In this paper we propose an approach to identify model uncertainty using parameter identification, optimal design of experiments and hypothesis testing. The experimental setup is characterized by optimal sensor positions such that specific model parameters can be determined with minimal variance. This allows for the computation of confidence regions in which the real parameters or the parameter estimates from different test sets have to lie. We claim that inconsistencies in the estimated parameter values, considering their approximated confidence ellipsoids as well, cannot be explained by data uncertainty but are indicators of model uncertainty. The proposed method is demonstrated using a component of the 3D Servo Press, a multi-technology forming machine that combines spindles with eccentric servo drives.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2020; v1 submitted 18 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Semi-automatically optimized calibration of internal combustion engines
Authors:
Timo Burggraf,
Michael Joswig,
Marc E. Pfetsch,
Manuel Radons,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
Modern combustion engines incorporate a number of actuators and sensors that can be used to control and optimize the performance and emissions. We describe a semi-automatic method to simultaneously measure and calibrate the actuator settings and the resulting behavior of the engine. The method includes an adaptive process for refining the measurements, a data cleaning step, and an optimization pro…
▽ More
Modern combustion engines incorporate a number of actuators and sensors that can be used to control and optimize the performance and emissions. We describe a semi-automatic method to simultaneously measure and calibrate the actuator settings and the resulting behavior of the engine. The method includes an adaptive process for refining the measurements, a data cleaning step, and an optimization procedure. The optimization works in a discretized space and incorporates the conditions to describe the dependence between the actuators and the engine behavior as well as emission bounds. We demonstrate our method on practical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2019; v1 submitted 28 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Robust Shape Optimization of Electric Devices Based on Deterministic Optimization Methods and Finite Element Analysis With Affine Decomposition and Design Elements
Authors:
Ion Gabriel Ion,
Zeger Bontinck,
Dimitrios Loukrezis,
Ulrich Römer,
Oliver Lass,
Stefan Ulbrich,
Sebastian Schöps,
Herbert De Gersem
Abstract:
In this paper, gradient-based optimization methods are combined with finite-element modeling for improving electric devices. Geometric design parameters are considered by affine decomposition of the geometry or by the design element approach, both of which avoid remeshing. Furthermore, it is shown how to robustify the optimization procedure, i.e., how to deal with uncertainties on the design param…
▽ More
In this paper, gradient-based optimization methods are combined with finite-element modeling for improving electric devices. Geometric design parameters are considered by affine decomposition of the geometry or by the design element approach, both of which avoid remeshing. Furthermore, it is shown how to robustify the optimization procedure, i.e., how to deal with uncertainties on the design parameters. The overall procedure is illustrated by an academic example and by the example of a permanent-magnet synchronous machine. The examples show the advantages of deterministic optimization compared to standard and popular stochastic optimization procedures such as, e.g., particle swarm optimization.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Robust Optimization Approaches for the Design of an Electric Machine
Authors:
Zeger Bontinck,
Oliver Lass,
Sebastian Schöps,
Stefan Ulbrich,
Oliver Rain
Abstract:
In this paper two formulations for the robust optimization of the size of the permanent magnet in a synchronous machine are discussed. The optimization is constrained by a partial differential equation to describe the electromagnetic behavior of the machine. The need for a robust optimization procedure originates from the fact that optimization parameters have deviations. The first approach, i.e.,…
▽ More
In this paper two formulations for the robust optimization of the size of the permanent magnet in a synchronous machine are discussed. The optimization is constrained by a partial differential equation to describe the electromagnetic behavior of the machine. The need for a robust optimization procedure originates from the fact that optimization parameters have deviations. The first approach, i.e., \textcolor{red}{worst-case} optimization, makes use of local sensitivities. The second approach takes into account expectation values and standard deviations. The latter are associated with global sensitivities. The geometry parametrization is elegantly handled thanks to the introduction of an affine decomposition. Since the stochastic quantities are determined by tools from uncertainty quantification (UQ) and thus require a lot of finite element evaluations, model order reduction is used in order to increase the efficiency of the procedure. It is shown that both approaches are equivalent if a linearization is carried out. \textcolor{blue}{This finding is supported by the application on an electric machine. The optimization algorithms used are sequential quadratic programming, particle swarm optimization and genetic algorithm}. While both formulations reduce the size of the magnets, the UQ based optimization approach is less pessimistic with respect to deviations and yields smaller magnets.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2018; v1 submitted 5 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
A Certified Model Reduction Approach for Robust Parameter Optimization with PDE Constraints
Authors:
Alessandro Alla,
Michael Hinze,
Philip Kolvenbach,
Oliver Lass,
Stefan Ulbrich
Abstract:
We investigate an optimization problem governed by an elliptic partial differential equation with uncertain parameters. We introduce a robust optimization framework that accounts for uncertain model parameters. The resulting non-linear optimization problem has a bi-level structure due to the min-max formulation. To approximate the worst-case in the optimization problem we propose linear and quadra…
▽ More
We investigate an optimization problem governed by an elliptic partial differential equation with uncertain parameters. We introduce a robust optimization framework that accounts for uncertain model parameters. The resulting non-linear optimization problem has a bi-level structure due to the min-max formulation. To approximate the worst-case in the optimization problem we propose linear and quadratic approximations. However, this approach still turns out to be very expensive, therefore we propose an adaptive model order reduction technique which avoids long offline stages and provides a certified reduced order surrogate model for the parametrized PDE which is then utilized in the numerical optimization. Numerical results are presented to validate the presented approach.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2019; v1 submitted 5 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
