Showing 1–44 of 44 results for author: Topping, P

Monotonicity of the modulus under curve shortening flow

Authors: Arjun Sobnack, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Given two disjoint nested embedded closed curves in the plane, both evolving under curve shortening flow, we show that the modulus of the enclosed annulus is monotonically increasing in time. An analogous result holds within any ambient surface satisfying a lower curvature bound. Given two disjoint nested embedded closed curves in the plane, both evolving under curve shortening flow, we show that the modulus of the enclosed annulus is monotonically increasing in time. An analogous result holds within any ambient surface satisfying a lower curvature bound. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

MSC Class: 53E10; 35K55; 30C85; 31A15

Delayed parabolic regularity for curve shortening flow

Authors: Arjun Sobnack, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Given two curves bounding a region of area $A$ that evolve under curve shortening flow, we propose the principle that the regularity of one should be controllable in terms of the regularity of the other, starting from time $A/π$. We prove several results of this form and demonstrate that no estimate can hold before that time. As an example application, we construct solutions to graphical curve sho… ▽ More Given two curves bounding a region of area $A$ that evolve under curve shortening flow, we propose the principle that the regularity of one should be controllable in terms of the regularity of the other, starting from time $A/π$. We prove several results of this form and demonstrate that no estimate can hold before that time. As an example application, we construct solutions to graphical curve shortening flow starting with initial data that is merely an $L^1$ function. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

MSC Class: 35B45; 35B65; 35K55; 35K20; 53E10

Ricci flow and PIC1

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We survey several problems concerning Riemannian manifolds with positive curvature of one form or another. We describe the PIC1 notion of positive curvature and argue that it is often the sharp notion of positive curvature to consider. Finally we explain how recent Ricci flow theory is particularly well adapted to solve these problems. We survey several problems concerning Riemannian manifolds with positive curvature of one form or another. We describe the PIC1 notion of positive curvature and argue that it is often the sharp notion of positive curvature to consider. Finally we explain how recent Ricci flow theory is particularly well adapted to solve these problems. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

MSC Class: 53E20; 53C20

All two-dimensional expanding Ricci solitons

Authors: Luke T. Peachey, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: The second author and H. Yin have developed a Ricci flow existence theory that gives a complete Ricci flow starting with a surface equipped with a conformal structure and a nonatomic Radon measure as a volume measure. This led to the discovery of a large array of new expanding Ricci solitons. In this paper we use the recent uniqueness theory in this context, also developed by the second author and… ▽ More The second author and H. Yin have developed a Ricci flow existence theory that gives a complete Ricci flow starting with a surface equipped with a conformal structure and a nonatomic Radon measure as a volume measure. This led to the discovery of a large array of new expanding Ricci solitons. In this paper we use the recent uniqueness theory in this context, also developed by the second author and H. Yin, to give a complete classification of all expanding Ricci solitons on surfaces. Along the way, we prove a converse to the existence theory that is not constrained to solitons: every complete Ricci flow on a surface over a time interval $(0,\varepsilon)$ admits a $t\downarrow 0$ limit within the class of admissible initial data. This makes surfaces the first nontrivial setting for Ricci flow in which a bijection can be given between the entire set of complete Ricci flows over maximal time intervals $(0,T)$, and a class of initial data that induces them. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2024; v1 submitted 11 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: v5: author accepted manuscript. To appear, Journal of the London Mathematical Society

MSC Class: 53E20

Uniqueness of Ricci flows from nonatomic Radon measures on Riemann surfaces

Authors: Peter M. Topping, Hao Yin

Abstract: In previous work we established the existence of a Ricci flow starting with a Riemann surface coupled with a nonatomic Radon measure as a conformal factor. In this paper we prove uniqueness. Combining these two works yields a canonical smoothing of such rough surfaces that also regularises their geometry at infinity. In previous work we established the existence of a Ricci flow starting with a Riemann surface coupled with a nonatomic Radon measure as a conformal factor. In this paper we prove uniqueness. Combining these two works yields a canonical smoothing of such rough surfaces that also regularises their geometry at infinity. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

MSC Class: 53E20

Manifolds with PIC1 pinched curvature

Authors: Man-Chun Lee, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Recently it has been proved (Lee-Topping 2022, Deruelle-Schulze-Simon 2022, Lott 2019) that three-dimensional complete manifolds with non-negatively pinched Ricci curvature must be flat or compact, thus confirming a conjecture of Hamilton. In this paper we generalise our work on the existence of Ricci flows from non-compact pinched three-manifolds in order to prove a higher-dimensional analogue. W… ▽ More Recently it has been proved (Lee-Topping 2022, Deruelle-Schulze-Simon 2022, Lott 2019) that three-dimensional complete manifolds with non-negatively pinched Ricci curvature must be flat or compact, thus confirming a conjecture of Hamilton. In this paper we generalise our work on the existence of Ricci flows from non-compact pinched three-manifolds in order to prove a higher-dimensional analogue. We construct a solution to Ricci flow, for all time, starting with an arbitrary complete non-compact manifold that is PIC1 pinched. As an application we prove that any complete manifold of non-negative complex sectional curvature that is PIC1 pinched must be flat or compact. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2025; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: To appear, Geometry and Topology

MSC Class: 53E20; 53C20; 53C21

Three-manifolds with non-negatively pinched Ricci curvature

Authors: Man-Chun Lee, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We show that every complete non-compact three-manifold with non-negatively pinched Ricci curvature admits a complete Ricci flow solution for all positive time, with scale-invariant curvature decay and preservation of pinching. Combining with recent work of Lott and Deruelle-Schulze-Simon gives a proof of Hamilton's pinching conjecture without additional hypotheses. We show that every complete non-compact three-manifold with non-negatively pinched Ricci curvature admits a complete Ricci flow solution for all positive time, with scale-invariant curvature decay and preservation of pinching. Combining with recent work of Lott and Deruelle-Schulze-Simon gives a proof of Hamilton's pinching conjecture without additional hypotheses. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2024; v1 submitted 1 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: Accepted to The Journal of Differential Geometry

MSC Class: 53E20; 53C20; 53C21

Metric limits of manifolds with positive scalar curvature

Authors: Man-Chun Lee, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We show that any Riemannian metric conformal to the round metric on $S^n$, for $n\geq 4$, arises as a limit of a sequence of Riemannian metrics of positive scalar curvature on $S^n$ in the sense of uniform convergence of Riemannian distance. In particular, non-negativity of scalar curvature is not preserved under such limits. We show that any Riemannian metric conformal to the round metric on $S^n$, for $n\geq 4$, arises as a limit of a sequence of Riemannian metrics of positive scalar curvature on $S^n$ in the sense of uniform convergence of Riemannian distance. In particular, non-negativity of scalar curvature is not preserved under such limits. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2024; v1 submitted 2 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: To appear in the American Journal of Mathematics

MSC Class: 53C21

Time zero regularity of Ricci flow

Authors: Man-Chun Lee, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We consider the problem of when a smooth Ricci flow, for positive time, that attains smooth initial data in a weak sense must be smooth down to the initial time. We obtain curvature estimates for an example where this fails. We prove a positive result in the case that the flow satisfies a lower IC1 curvature bound, equivalent to a lower Ricci bound in three dimensions. As an application, we prove… ▽ More We consider the problem of when a smooth Ricci flow, for positive time, that attains smooth initial data in a weak sense must be smooth down to the initial time. We obtain curvature estimates for an example where this fails. We prove a positive result in the case that the flow satisfies a lower IC1 curvature bound, equivalent to a lower Ricci bound in three dimensions. As an application, we prove that Gromov-Hausdorff limits of WPIC1 manifolds are WPIC1. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2022; v1 submitted 25 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: Accepted to IMRN

MSC Class: 53E20

Smoothing a measure on a Riemann surface using Ricci flow

Authors: Peter M. Topping, Hao Yin

Abstract: We formulate and solve the existence problem for Ricci flow on a Riemann surface with initial data given by a Radon measure as volume measure. The theory leads us to a large class of new examples of nongradient expanding Ricci solitons, including the first example of a nongradient Kaehler Ricci soliton. It also settles the question of whether a smooth flow for positive time that attains smooth ini… ▽ More We formulate and solve the existence problem for Ricci flow on a Riemann surface with initial data given by a Radon measure as volume measure. The theory leads us to a large class of new examples of nongradient expanding Ricci solitons, including the first example of a nongradient Kaehler Ricci soliton. It also settles the question of whether a smooth flow for positive time that attains smooth initial data in a distance metric sense must be smooth down to the initial time. We disprove this by giving an example of a complete Ricci flow starting with the Euclidean plane that is not the static solution. △ Less

Submitted 19 December, 2024; v1 submitted 30 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

MSC Class: 53E20

Journal ref: Ars Inveniendi Analytica (2024), Paper No. 4, 28 pp

Nontrivial breathers for Ricci flow

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Perelman has proved that there cannot exist a nontrivial breather for Ricci flow on a closed manifold. Here we construct nontrivial expanding breathers for Ricci flow in all dimensions when the underlying manifold is allowed to be noncompact. Perelman has proved that there cannot exist a nontrivial breather for Ricci flow on a closed manifold. Here we construct nontrivial expanding breathers for Ricci flow in all dimensions when the underlying manifold is allowed to be noncompact. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2021; v1 submitted 30 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: Version 2 contains new remark pointing out that the same technique works for other geometric flows such as mean curvature flow

MSC Class: 53E20

A rigidity estimate for maps from $S^2$ to $S^2$ via the harmonic map flow

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We show how a rigidity estimate introduced in recent work of Bernand-Mantel, Muratov and Simon can be derived using the harmonic map flow. We show how a rigidity estimate introduced in recent work of Bernand-Mantel, Muratov and Simon can be derived using the harmonic map flow. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C43; 58E20

Uniqueness and nonuniqueness of limits of Teichmueller harmonic map flow

Authors: James Kohout, Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: The harmonic map energy of a map from a closed, constant-curvature surface to a closed target manifold can be seen as a functional on the space of maps and domain metrics. We consider the gradient flow for this energy. In the absence of singularities, previous theory established that the flow converges to a branched minimal immersion, but only at a sequence of times converging to infinity, and onl… ▽ More The harmonic map energy of a map from a closed, constant-curvature surface to a closed target manifold can be seen as a functional on the space of maps and domain metrics. We consider the gradient flow for this energy. In the absence of singularities, previous theory established that the flow converges to a branched minimal immersion, but only at a sequence of times converging to infinity, and only after pulling back by a sequence of diffeomorphisms. In this paper we investigate whether it is necessary to pull back by these diffeomorphisms, and whether the convergence is uniform as time tends to infinity. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C43

Pyramid Ricci Flow in Higher Dimensions

Authors: Andrew D. McLeod, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: In this paper, we construct a pyramid Ricci flow starting with a complete Riemannian manifold $(M^n,g_0)$ that is PIC1, or more generally satisfies a lower curvature bound $K_{IC_1}\geq -α_0$. That is, instead of constructing a flow on $M\times [0,T]$, we construct it on a subset of space-time that is a union of parabolic cylinders $B_{g_0}(x_0,k)\times [0,T_k]$ for each natural number $k$, where… ▽ More In this paper, we construct a pyramid Ricci flow starting with a complete Riemannian manifold $(M^n,g_0)$ that is PIC1, or more generally satisfies a lower curvature bound $K_{IC_1}\geq -α_0$. That is, instead of constructing a flow on $M\times [0,T]$, we construct it on a subset of space-time that is a union of parabolic cylinders $B_{g_0}(x_0,k)\times [0,T_k]$ for each natural number $k$, where $T_k\downarrow 0$, and prove estimates on the curvature and Riemannian distance. More generally, we construct a pyramid Ricci flow starting with any noncollapsed $IC_1$-limit space, and use it to establish that such limit spaces are globally homeomorphic to smooth manifolds via homeomorphisms that are locally bi-Hölder. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2019; v1 submitted 17 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: Version 2 updates references

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C23; 58J35; 35B45; 35K40; 35K55

Ricci flow and Ricci Limit Spaces

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: I survey some of the developments in the theory of Ricci flow and its applications from the past decade. I focus mainly on the understanding of Ricci flows that are permitted to have unbounded curvature in the sense that the curvature can blow up as we wander off to spatial infinity and/or as we decrease time to some singular time. Applications to the study of Ricci limit spaces are surveyed. I em… ▽ More I survey some of the developments in the theory of Ricci flow and its applications from the past decade. I focus mainly on the understanding of Ricci flows that are permitted to have unbounded curvature in the sense that the curvature can blow up as we wander off to spatial infinity and/or as we decrease time to some singular time. Applications to the study of Ricci limit spaces are surveyed. I emphasise the intuition behind the subject. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2020; v1 submitted 25 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: Lectures given at the summer school on "Geometric Analysis" at Cetraro in June 2018. To appear in Springer Lecture Notes in Mathematics, CIME subseries. Numbering of theorems etc has changed in v2 in an attempt to match Springer style

Loss of initial data under limits of Ricci flows

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We construct a sequence of smooth Ricci flows on $T^2$, with standard uniform $C/t$ curvature decay, and with initial metrics converging to the standard flat unit-area square torus $g_0$ in the Gromov-Hausdorff sense, with the property that the flows themselves converge not to the static Ricci flow $g(t)\equiv g_0$, but to the static Ricci flow $g(t)\equiv 2g_0$ of twice the area. We construct a sequence of smooth Ricci flows on $T^2$, with standard uniform $C/t$ curvature decay, and with initial metrics converging to the standard flat unit-area square torus $g_0$ in the Gromov-Hausdorff sense, with the property that the flows themselves converge not to the static Ricci flow $g(t)\equiv g_0$, but to the static Ricci flow $g(t)\equiv 2g_0$ of twice the area. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2021; v1 submitted 25 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 4 pages. This is the submitted version from 2019, but with updated references. Problem 1.2 can be answered using the theory in [19]

MSC Class: 53E20

Journal ref: `Minimal surfaces: integrable systems and visualisation,' [Granada, 2018] T. Hoffmann, M. Kilian, K. Leschke, F. Martin (Eds.) Springer Proceedings in Mathematics & Statistics 349, 2021

Global Regularity of Three-Dimensional Ricci Limit Spaces

Authors: Andrew D. McLeod, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We construct a global homeomorphism from any 3D Ricci limit space to a smooth manifold, that is locally bi-Holder. This extends the recent work of Miles Simon and the second author, and we build upon their techniques. A key step in our proof is the construction of local "pyramid Ricci flows", existing on uniform regions of spacetime, that are inspired by Hochard's partial Ricci flows. We construct a global homeomorphism from any 3D Ricci limit space to a smooth manifold, that is locally bi-Holder. This extends the recent work of Miles Simon and the second author, and we build upon their techniques. A key step in our proof is the construction of local "pyramid Ricci flows", existing on uniform regions of spacetime, that are inspired by Hochard's partial Ricci flows. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2018; v1 submitted 1 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: Improvements in exposition; minor corrections

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C23; 58J35; 35B45; 35K40; 35K55

Global weak solutions of the Teichmüller harmonic map flow into general targets

Authors: Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We analyse finite-time singularities of the Teichmüller harmonic map flow -- a natural gradient flow of the harmonic map energy -- and find a canonical way of flowing beyond them in order to construct global solutions in full generality. Moreover, we prove a no-loss-of-topology result at finite time, which completes the proof that this flow decomposes an arbitrary map into a collection of branched… ▽ More We analyse finite-time singularities of the Teichmüller harmonic map flow -- a natural gradient flow of the harmonic map energy -- and find a canonical way of flowing beyond them in order to construct global solutions in full generality. Moreover, we prove a no-loss-of-topology result at finite time, which completes the proof that this flow decomposes an arbitrary map into a collection of branched minimal immersions connected by curves. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Journal ref: Analysis & PDE 12 (2019) 815-842

Local mollification of Riemannian metrics using Ricci flow, and Ricci limit spaces

Authors: Miles Simon, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We use Ricci flow to obtain a local bi-Holder correspondence between Ricci limit spaces in three dimensions and smooth manifolds. This is more than a complete resolution of the three-dimensional case of the conjecture of Anderson-Cheeger-Colding-Tian, describing how Ricci limit spaces in three dimensions must be homeomorphic to manifolds, and we obtain this in the most general, locally non-collaps… ▽ More We use Ricci flow to obtain a local bi-Holder correspondence between Ricci limit spaces in three dimensions and smooth manifolds. This is more than a complete resolution of the three-dimensional case of the conjecture of Anderson-Cheeger-Colding-Tian, describing how Ricci limit spaces in three dimensions must be homeomorphic to manifolds, and we obtain this in the most general, locally non-collapsed case. The proofs build on results and ideas from recent papers of Hochard and the current authors. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2020; v1 submitted 28 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: To appear, Geometry and Topology

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C23; 58J35; 35B45; 35K40; 35K55

Journal ref: Geom. Topol. 25 (2021) 913-948

Local control on the geometry in 3D Ricci flow

Authors: Miles Simon, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: The geometry of a ball within a Riemannian manifold is coarsely controlled if it has a lower bound on its Ricci curvature and a positive lower bound on its volume. We prove that such coarse local geometric control must persist for a definite amount of time under three-dimensional Ricci flow, and leads to local C/t decay of the full curvature tensor, irrespective of what is happening beyond the loc… ▽ More The geometry of a ball within a Riemannian manifold is coarsely controlled if it has a lower bound on its Ricci curvature and a positive lower bound on its volume. We prove that such coarse local geometric control must persist for a definite amount of time under three-dimensional Ricci flow, and leads to local C/t decay of the full curvature tensor, irrespective of what is happening beyond the local region. As a by-product, our results generalise the Pseudolocality theorem of Perelman and Tian-Wang in this dimension by not requiring the Ricci curvature to be almost-positive, and not asking the volume growth to be almost-Euclidean. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2017; v1 submitted 18 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: Minor updates in order to integrate with arXiv:1706.09490 prior to being submitted

MSC Class: 53C44; 35B45; 35K40; 35K55; 58J35

Rate of curvature decay for the contracting cusp Ricci flow

Authors: Peter M. Topping, Hao Yin

Abstract: We prove that the Ricci flow that contracts a hyperbolic cusp has curvature decay like one over time squared. In order to do this, we prove a new Li-Yau type differential Harnack inequality for Ricci flow on surfaces. We prove that the Ricci flow that contracts a hyperbolic cusp has curvature decay like one over time squared. In order to do this, we prove a new Li-Yau type differential Harnack inequality for Ricci flow on surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

MSC Class: 35K55; 53C44; 58J35; 35K05; 35K10

Horizontal curves of hyperbolic metrics

Authors: Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We analyse the fine convergence properties of one parameter families of hyperbolic metrics, on a fixed underlying surface, that move always in a horizontal direction, i.e. orthogonal to the action of diffeomorphisms. We analyse the fine convergence properties of one parameter families of hyperbolic metrics, on a fixed underlying surface, that move always in a horizontal direction, i.e. orthogonal to the action of diffeomorphisms. △ Less

Submitted 20 June, 2018; v1 submitted 21 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: Minor changes, final version, to appear in Calc Var PDE

MSC Class: 30F10; 30F60; 53C44

Journal ref: Calc. Var. (2018) 57: 106

Sharp decay estimates for the logarithmic fast diffusion equation and the Ricci flow on surfaces

Authors: Peter M. Topping, Hao Yin

Abstract: We prove the sharp local L^1 - L^\infty smoothing estimate for the logarithmic fast diffusion equation, or equivalently, for the Ricci flow on surfaces. Our estimate almost instantly implies an improvement of the known L^p - L^\infty estimate for p larger than 1. It also has several applications in geometry, providing the missing step in order to pose the Ricci flow with rough initial data in the… ▽ More We prove the sharp local L^1 - L^\infty smoothing estimate for the logarithmic fast diffusion equation, or equivalently, for the Ricci flow on surfaces. Our estimate almost instantly implies an improvement of the known L^p - L^\infty estimate for p larger than 1. It also has several applications in geometry, providing the missing step in order to pose the Ricci flow with rough initial data in the noncompact case, for example starting with a general noncompact Alexandrov surface, and giving the sharp asymptotics for the contracting cusp Ricci flow, as we show elsewhere. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 13 pages, 2 figures

MSC Class: 35K55; 53C44; 58J35

Refined asymptotics of the Teichmüller harmonic map flow into general targets

Authors: Tobias Huxol, Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: The Teichmüller harmonic map flow is a gradient flow for the harmonic map energy of maps from a closed surface to a general closed Riemannian target manifold of any dimension, where both the map and the domain metric are allowed to evolve. Given a weak solution of the flow that exists for all time $t\geq 0$, we find a sequence of times $t_i\to\infty$ at which the flow at different scales converges… ▽ More The Teichmüller harmonic map flow is a gradient flow for the harmonic map energy of maps from a closed surface to a general closed Riemannian target manifold of any dimension, where both the map and the domain metric are allowed to evolve. Given a weak solution of the flow that exists for all time $t\geq 0$, we find a sequence of times $t_i\to\infty$ at which the flow at different scales converges to a collection of branched minimal immersions with no loss of energy. We do this by developing a compactness theory, establishing no loss of energy, for sequences of almost-minimal maps. Moreover, we construct an example of a smooth flow for which the image of the limit branched minimal immersions is disconnected. In general, we show that the necks connecting the images of the branched minimal immersions become arbitrarily thin as $i\to\infty$. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2015; v1 submitted 20 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: Substantial revision in order to strengthen the main results and to make them applicable to general sequences of almost-minimal maps

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C43; 58E20; 53A10

Ricci flows with unbounded curvature

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Until recently, Ricci flow was viewed almost exclusively as a way of deforming Riemannian metrics of bounded curvature. Unfortunately, the bounded curvature hypothesis is unnatural for many applications, but is hard to drop because so many new phenomena can occur in the general case. This article surveys some of the theory from the past few years that has sought to rectify the situation in differe… ▽ More Until recently, Ricci flow was viewed almost exclusively as a way of deforming Riemannian metrics of bounded curvature. Unfortunately, the bounded curvature hypothesis is unnatural for many applications, but is hard to drop because so many new phenomena can occur in the general case. This article surveys some of the theory from the past few years that has sought to rectify the situation in different ways. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2014; originally announced August 2014.

Comments: appears in Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Seoul 2014

Report number: 1033-1048 MSC Class: 53C44; 35K55; 58J35

Teichmüller harmonic map flow into nonpositively curved targets

Authors: Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: The Teichmüller harmonic map flow deforms both a map from an oriented closed surface $M$ into an arbitrary closed Riemannian manifold, and a constant curvature metric on $M$, so as to reduce the energy of the map as quickly as possible [16]. The flow then tries to converge to a branched minimal immersion when it can [16,18]. The only thing that can stop the flow is a finite-time degeneration of th… ▽ More The Teichmüller harmonic map flow deforms both a map from an oriented closed surface $M$ into an arbitrary closed Riemannian manifold, and a constant curvature metric on $M$, so as to reduce the energy of the map as quickly as possible [16]. The flow then tries to converge to a branched minimal immersion when it can [16,18]. The only thing that can stop the flow is a finite-time degeneration of the metric on $M$ where one or more collars are pinched. In this paper we show that finite-time degeneration cannot happen in the case that the target has nonpositive sectional curvature, and indeed more generally in the case that the target supports no bubbles. In particular, when combined with [16,18,9], this shows that the flow will decompose an arbitrary such map into a collection of branched minimal immersions. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2016; v1 submitted 13 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: Minor changes, final version, to appear in JDG

MSC Class: 53C44; 53C43; 58E20; 53A10; 30F60

Uniqueness of Instantaneously Complete Ricci flows

Authors: Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We prove uniqueness of instantaneously complete Ricci flows on surfaces. We do not require any bounds of any form on the curvature or its growth at infinity, nor on the metric or its growth (other than that implied by instantaneous completeness). Coupled with earlier work, particularly [23, 11], this completes the well-posedness theory for instantaneously complete Ricci flows on surfaces. We prove uniqueness of instantaneously complete Ricci flows on surfaces. We do not require any bounds of any form on the curvature or its growth at infinity, nor on the metric or its growth (other than that implied by instantaneous completeness). Coupled with earlier work, particularly [23, 11], this completes the well-posedness theory for instantaneously complete Ricci flows on surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

MSC Class: 35K55; 53C44; 58J35

Journal ref: Geom. Topol. 19 (2015) 1477-1492

Ricci flows with bursts of unbounded curvature

Authors: Gregor Giesen, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Given a completely arbitrary surface, whether or not it has bounded curvature, or even whether or not it is complete, there exists an instantaneously complete Ricci flow evolution of that surface that exists for a specific amount of time [GT11]. In the case that the underlying Riemann surface supports a hyperbolic metric, this Ricci flow always exists for all time and converges (after scaling by a… ▽ More Given a completely arbitrary surface, whether or not it has bounded curvature, or even whether or not it is complete, there exists an instantaneously complete Ricci flow evolution of that surface that exists for a specific amount of time [GT11]. In the case that the underlying Riemann surface supports a hyperbolic metric, this Ricci flow always exists for all time and converges (after scaling by a factor $\frac1{2t}$) to this hyperbolic metric [GT11], i.e. our Ricci flow geometrises the surface. In this paper we show that there exist complete, bounded curvature initial metrics, including those conformal to a hyperbolic metric, which have subsequent Ricci flows developing unbounded curvature at certain intermediate times. In particular, when coupled with the uniqueness from [Top13], we find that any complete Ricci flow starting with such initial metrics must develop unbounded curvature over some intermediate time interval, but that nevertheless, the curvature must later become bounded and the flow must achieve geometrisation as $t\to\infty$, even though there are other conformal deformations to hyperbolic metrics that do not involve unbounded curvature. Another consequence of our constructions is that while our Ricci flow from [GT11] must agree initially with the classical flow of Hamilton and Shi in the special case that the initial surface is complete and of bounded curvature, by uniqueness, it is now clear that our flow lasts for a longer time interval in general, with Shi's flow stopping when the curvature blows up, but our flow continuing strictly beyond in these situations. All our constructions of unbounded curvature developing and then disappearing are in two dimensions. Generalisations to higher dimensions are then immediate. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2014; v1 submitted 22 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: 22 pages, 7 figures; significant revisions based on a generalised main result and the resulting new applications

MSC Class: 35K55; 53C44; 58J35

Bouncing of charged droplets: An explanation using mean curvature flow

Authors: Sebastian Helmensdorfer, Peter Topping

Abstract: Two oppositely charged droplets of (say) water in e.g. oil or air will tend to drift together under the influence of their charges. As they make contact, one might expect them to coalesce and form one large droplet, and this indeed happens when the charge difference is sufficiently small. However, Ristenpart et al discovered a remarkable physical phenomenon whereby for large enough charge differen… ▽ More Two oppositely charged droplets of (say) water in e.g. oil or air will tend to drift together under the influence of their charges. As they make contact, one might expect them to coalesce and form one large droplet, and this indeed happens when the charge difference is sufficiently small. However, Ristenpart et al discovered a remarkable physical phenomenon whereby for large enough charge differentials, the droplets bounce off each other as they make contact. Explanations based on minimisation of area under a volume constraint have been proposed based on the premise that consideration of surface energy cannot be sufficient. However, in this note we explain that on the contrary, the bouncing phenomenon can be completely explained in terms of energy, including an accurate prediction of the threshold charge differential between coalescence and bouncing. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2014; v1 submitted 20 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: Updated to reflect revisions in published version

MSC Class: 53C44

Journal ref: EPL (Europhysics Letters) 104 (2013) 34001

The Geometry of Differential Harnack Estimates

Authors: Sebastian Helmensdorfer, Peter Topping

Abstract: In this short note, we hope to give a rapid induction for non-experts into the world of Differential Harnack inequalities, which have been so influential in geometric analysis and probability theory over the past few decades. At the coarsest level, these are often mysterious-looking inequalities that hold for `positive' solutions of some parabolic PDE, and can be verified quickly by grinding out a… ▽ More In this short note, we hope to give a rapid induction for non-experts into the world of Differential Harnack inequalities, which have been so influential in geometric analysis and probability theory over the past few decades. At the coarsest level, these are often mysterious-looking inequalities that hold for `positive' solutions of some parabolic PDE, and can be verified quickly by grinding out a computation and applying a maximum principle. In this note we emphasise the geometry behind the Harnack inequalities, which typically turn out to be assertions of the convexity of some natural object. As an application, we explain how Hamilton's Differential Harnack inequality for mean curvature flow of a $n$-dimensional submanifold of $R^{n+1}$ can be viewed as following directly from the well-known preservation of convexity under mean curvature flow, but this time of a $(n+1)$-dimensional submanifold of $R^{n+2}$. We also briefly survey the earlier work that led us to these observations. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

MSC Class: 53C44; 35K05; 35K08; 35K10; 35K55

A uniform Poincaré estimate for quadratic differentials on closed surfaces

Authors: Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We prove a uniform estimate, valid for every closed Riemann surface of genus at least two, that bounds the distance of any quadratic differential to the finite dimensional space of holomorphic quadratic differentials in terms of its antiholomorphic derivative. We prove a uniform estimate, valid for every closed Riemann surface of genus at least two, that bounds the distance of any quadratic differential to the finite dimensional space of holomorphic quadratic differentials in terms of its antiholomorphic derivative. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

MSC Class: 30F10; 30F30; 30F45; 30F60; 32G15; 35A23; 35J46; 53A30; 58J05

Asymptotics of the Teichmüller harmonic map flow

Authors: Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping, Miaomiao Zhu

Abstract: The Teichmüller harmonic map flow, introduced in [9], evolves both a map from a closed Riemann surface to an arbitrary compact Riemannian manifold, and a constant curvature metric on the domain, in order to reduce its harmonic map energy as quickly as possible. In this paper, we develop the geometric analysis of holomorphic quadratic differentials in order to explain what happens in the case that… ▽ More The Teichmüller harmonic map flow, introduced in [9], evolves both a map from a closed Riemann surface to an arbitrary compact Riemannian manifold, and a constant curvature metric on the domain, in order to reduce its harmonic map energy as quickly as possible. In this paper, we develop the geometric analysis of holomorphic quadratic differentials in order to explain what happens in the case that the domain metric of the flow degenerates at infinite time. We obtain a branched minimal immersion from the degenerate domain. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

MSC Class: 35K55; 53A10; 58E12

Flowing maps to minimal surfaces

Authors: Melanie Rupflin, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We introduce a flow of maps from a compact surface of arbitrary genus to an arbitrary Riemannian manifold which has elements in common with both the harmonic map flow and the mean curvature flow, but is more effective at finding minimal surfaces. In the genus 0 case, our flow is just the harmonic map flow, and it tries to find branched minimal 2-spheres as in Sacks-Uhlenbeck and Struwe etc. In the… ▽ More We introduce a flow of maps from a compact surface of arbitrary genus to an arbitrary Riemannian manifold which has elements in common with both the harmonic map flow and the mean curvature flow, but is more effective at finding minimal surfaces. In the genus 0 case, our flow is just the harmonic map flow, and it tries to find branched minimal 2-spheres as in Sacks-Uhlenbeck and Struwe etc. In the genus 1 case, we show that our flow is exactly equivalent to that considered by Ding-Li-Lui. In general, we recover the result of Schoen-Yau and Sacks-Uhlenbeck that an incompressible map from a surface can be adjusted to a branched minimal immersion with the same action on $π_1$, and this minimal immersion will be homotopic to the original map in the case that $π_2=0$. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2016; v1 submitted 29 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: Updated to reflect galley proof corrections. To appear in The American Journal of Mathematics

MSC Class: 35K55; 53A10; 58E12

Remarks on Hamilton's Compactness Theorem for Ricci flow

Authors: Peter Topping

Abstract: A fundamental tool in the analysis of Ricci flow is a compactness result of Hamilton in the spirit of the work of Cheeger, Gromov and others. Roughly speaking it allows one to take a sequence of Ricci flows with uniformly bounded curvature and uniformly controlled injectivity radius, and extract a subsequence that converges to a complete limiting Ricci flow. A widely quoted extension of this resul… ▽ More A fundamental tool in the analysis of Ricci flow is a compactness result of Hamilton in the spirit of the work of Cheeger, Gromov and others. Roughly speaking it allows one to take a sequence of Ricci flows with uniformly bounded curvature and uniformly controlled injectivity radius, and extract a subsequence that converges to a complete limiting Ricci flow. A widely quoted extension of this result allows the curvature to be bounded uniformly only in a local sense. However, in this note we give a counterexample. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Comments: 18 pages, 1 figure

MSC Class: 53C44; 35K55; 58J35; 30C80

Ricci flows with unbounded curvature

Authors: Gregor Giesen, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We show that any noncompact Riemann surface admits a complete Ricci flow g(t), t\in[0,\infty), which has unbounded curvature for all t\in[0,\infty). We show that any noncompact Riemann surface admits a complete Ricci flow g(t), t\in[0,\infty), which has unbounded curvature for all t\in[0,\infty). △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2011; v1 submitted 13 June, 2011; originally announced June 2011.

Comments: 12 pages, 1 figure; updated references

MSC Class: 35K55; 53C44; 58J35

Journal ref: Math. Z. 273 (2013), no. 1-2, 449-460

Decay estimates for Rivière's equation, with applications to regularity and compactness

Authors: Ben Sharp, Peter Topping

Abstract: We derive a selection of energy estimates for a generalisation of a critical equation on the unit disc in $\mathbb{R}^2$ introduced by Rivière. Applications include sharp regularity results and compactness theorems which generalise a large amount of previous geometric PDE theory, including some of the theory of harmonic and almost-harmonic maps from surfaces. We derive a selection of energy estimates for a generalisation of a critical equation on the unit disc in $\mathbb{R}^2$ introduced by Rivière. Applications include sharp regularity results and compactness theorems which generalise a large amount of previous geometric PDE theory, including some of the theory of harmonic and almost-harmonic maps from surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2011; v1 submitted 3 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: 26 pages, updated bibliographic information and discussion of examples showing that the results are sharp

MSC Class: 30H10; 30H35; 35B33; 35R01; 35A23; 35B65; 35J47; 42B20; 42B37; 46E30; 46E35; 53C42; 53C43; 58E20

Uniqueness and nonuniqueness for Ricci flow on surfaces: Reverse cusp singularities

Authors: Peter Topping

Abstract: We extend the notion of what it means for a complete Ricci flow to have a given initial metric, and consider the resulting well-posedness issues that arise in the 2D case. On one hand we construct examples of nonuniqueness by showing that surfaces with cusps can evolve either by keeping the cusps or by contracting them. On the other hand, by adding a noncollapsedness assumption for the initial met… ▽ More We extend the notion of what it means for a complete Ricci flow to have a given initial metric, and consider the resulting well-posedness issues that arise in the 2D case. On one hand we construct examples of nonuniqueness by showing that surfaces with cusps can evolve either by keeping the cusps or by contracting them. On the other hand, by adding a noncollapsedness assumption for the initial metric, we establish a uniqueness result. △ Less

Submitted 13 October, 2010; originally announced October 2010.

MSC Class: 35K55; 35K45; 53C44; 58J35

Existence of Ricci flows of incomplete surfaces

Authors: Gregor Giesen, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We prove a general existence result for instantaneously complete Ricci flows starting at an arbitrary Riemannian surface which may be incomplete and may have unbounded curvature. We give an explicit formula for the maximal existence time, and describe the asymptotic behaviour in most cases. We prove a general existence result for instantaneously complete Ricci flows starting at an arbitrary Riemannian surface which may be incomplete and may have unbounded curvature. We give an explicit formula for the maximal existence time, and describe the asymptotic behaviour in most cases. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2011; v1 submitted 19 July, 2010; originally announced July 2010.

Comments: 20 pages; updated to reflect galley proof corrections

MSC Class: 35K55; 35K20; 53C44; 58J35; 58J32; 30C80

Journal ref: Comm. Partial Differential Equations, 36 (2011) 1860--1880

On Type I Singularities in Ricci flow

Authors: Joerg Enders, Reto Müller, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We define several notions of singular set for Type I Ricci flows and show that they all coincide. In order to do this, we prove that blow-ups around singular points converge to nontrivial gradient shrinking solitons, thus extending work of Naber. As a by-product we conclude that the volume of a finite-volume singular set vanishes at the singular time. We also define a notion of density for Type I… ▽ More We define several notions of singular set for Type I Ricci flows and show that they all coincide. In order to do this, we prove that blow-ups around singular points converge to nontrivial gradient shrinking solitons, thus extending work of Naber. As a by-product we conclude that the volume of a finite-volume singular set vanishes at the singular time. We also define a notion of density for Type I Ricci flows and use it to prove a regularity theorem reminiscent of White's partial regularity result for mean curvature flow. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2011; v1 submitted 10 May, 2010; originally announced May 2010.

Comments: 13 pages, references added, final version, to appear in CAG

Journal ref: Commun. Anal. Geom., Vol. 19, No. 5 (2011), 905-922

Almost-Schur lemma

Authors: Camillo De Lellis, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: Schur's lemma states that every Einstein manifold of dimension $n\geq 3$ has constant scalar curvature. Here $(M,g)$ is defined to be Einstein if its traceless Ricci tensor $$\Rico:=\Ric-\frac{R}{n}g$$ is identically zero. In this short note we ask to what extent the scalar curvature is constant if the traceless Ricci tensor is assumed to be \emph{small} rather than identically zero. Schur's lemma states that every Einstein manifold of dimension $n\geq 3$ has constant scalar curvature. Here $(M,g)$ is defined to be Einstein if its traceless Ricci tensor $$\Rico:=\Ric-\frac{R}{n}g$$ is identically zero. In this short note we ask to what extent the scalar curvature is constant if the traceless Ricci tensor is assumed to be \emph{small} rather than identically zero. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2011; v1 submitted 18 March, 2010; originally announced March 2010.

Comments: Remarks and references added. To appear in Calc. Var. See also http://www.math.uzh.ch/delellis

MSC Class: 53C24; 58J99

The Canonical Expanding Soliton and Harnack inequalities for Ricci flow

Authors: Esther Cabezas-Rivas, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We introduce the notion of Canonical Expanding Ricci Soliton, and use it to derive new Harnack inequalities for Ricci flow. This viewpoint also gives geometric insight into the existing Harnack inequalities of Hamilton and Brendle. We introduce the notion of Canonical Expanding Ricci Soliton, and use it to derive new Harnack inequalities for Ricci flow. This viewpoint also gives geometric insight into the existing Harnack inequalities of Hamilton and Brendle. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2009; originally announced November 2009.

MSC Class: 53C44

Ricci flow of negatively curved incomplete surfaces

Authors: Gregor Giesen, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: We show uniqueness of Ricci flows starting at a surface of uniformly negative curvature, with the assumption that the flows become complete instantaneously. Together with the more general existence result proved in [10], this settles the issue of well-posedness in this class. We show uniqueness of Ricci flows starting at a surface of uniformly negative curvature, with the assumption that the flows become complete instantaneously. Together with the more general existence result proved in [10], this settles the issue of well-posedness in this class. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 11 pages

MSC Class: 35K55; 35K20; 53C44; 58J35; 58J32; 30C80

Journal ref: Calc. Var. (2010) 38(3):357-367

The canonical shrinking soliton associated to a Ricci flow

Authors: Esther Cabezas-Rivas, Peter M. Topping

Abstract: To every Ricci flow on a manifold M over a time interval I, we associate a shrinking Ricci soliton on the space-time M x I. We relate properties of the original Ricci flow to properties of the new higher-dimensional Ricci flow equipped with its own time-parameter. This geometric construction was discovered by consideration of the theory of optimal transportation, and in particular the results of… ▽ More To every Ricci flow on a manifold M over a time interval I, we associate a shrinking Ricci soliton on the space-time M x I. We relate properties of the original Ricci flow to properties of the new higher-dimensional Ricci flow equipped with its own time-parameter. This geometric construction was discovered by consideration of the theory of optimal transportation, and in particular the results of the second author, and McCann and the second author; we briefly survey the link between these subjects. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2009; v1 submitted 25 July, 2008; originally announced July 2008.

Comments: slight changes in hypotheses theorem 1.1, a sign corrected in Proposition 2.2, section 6 made more precise

MSC Class: 53C44

Local monotonicity and mean value formulas for evolving Riemannian manifolds

Authors: Klaus Ecker, Dan Knopf, Lei Ni, Peter Topping

Abstract: We derive identities for general flows of Riemannian metrics that may be regarded as local mean-value, monotonicity, or Lyapunov formulae. These generalize previous work of the first author for mean curvature flow and other nonlinear diffusions. Our results apply in particular to Ricci flow, where they yield a local monotone quantity directly analogous to Perelman's reduced volume V and a local… ▽ More We derive identities for general flows of Riemannian metrics that may be regarded as local mean-value, monotonicity, or Lyapunov formulae. These generalize previous work of the first author for mean curvature flow and other nonlinear diffusions. Our results apply in particular to Ricci flow, where they yield a local monotone quantity directly analogous to Perelman's reduced volume V and a local identity related to Perelman's average energy F. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

MSC Class: 53C44; 58J35; 35K55