-
Chance-constrained allocation of UFLS candidate feeders under high penetration of distributed generation
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Cormac O'Malley,
Maria Parajeles,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
Under-Frequency Load Shedding (UFLS) schemes are the last resort to contain a frequency drop in the grid by disconnecting part of the demand. The allocation methods for selecting feeders that would contribute to the UFLS scheme have traditionally relied on the fact that electric demand followed fairly regular patterns, and could be forecast with high accuracy. However, recent integration of Distri…
▽ More
Under-Frequency Load Shedding (UFLS) schemes are the last resort to contain a frequency drop in the grid by disconnecting part of the demand. The allocation methods for selecting feeders that would contribute to the UFLS scheme have traditionally relied on the fact that electric demand followed fairly regular patterns, and could be forecast with high accuracy. However, recent integration of Distributed Generation (DG) increases the uncertainty in net consumption of feeders which, in turn, requires a reformulation of UFLS-allocation methods to account for this uncertainty. In this paper, a chance-constrained methodology for selecting feeders is proposed, with mathematical guarantees for the disconnection of the required amount of load with a certain pre-defined probability. The correlation in net-load forecasts among feeders is explicitly considered, given that uncertainty in DG power output is driven by meteorological conditions with high correlation across the network. Furthermore, this method is applicable either to systems with conventional UFLS schemes (where relays measure local frequency and trip if this magnitude falls below a certain threshold), or adaptive UFLS schemes (where relays are triggered by control signals sent in the few instants following a contingency). Relevant case studies demonstrate the applicability of the proposed method, and the need for explicit consideration of uncertainty in the UFLS-allocation process.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Convergent Economic Model Predictive Control through parameter-varying storage functions for dissipativity
Authors:
Zihang Dong,
David Angeli,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
This paper presents a new concept of controlled dissipativity as an extension of the standard dissipativity property to systems with parameter-varying storage functions under the framework of economic model predictive control (EMPC). Based on this concept, two EMPC controllers, integrated with the dissipation inequality constraints rendering the storage function parameters as decision variables, a…
▽ More
This paper presents a new concept of controlled dissipativity as an extension of the standard dissipativity property to systems with parameter-varying storage functions under the framework of economic model predictive control (EMPC). Based on this concept, two EMPC controllers, integrated with the dissipation inequality constraints rendering the storage function parameters as decision variables, are formulated and the associated recursive feasibility is ensured. Then, the asymptotic convergence to an optimal equilibrium in closed-loop, without requiring the standard dissipativity assumption, is enforced by trading it off with asymptotic performance. The upper bound of asymptotic average closed-loop performance is also evaluated. Finally, an illustrative example by using the EMPC controllers with terminal equilibrium or terminal region conditions is provided to show the effectiveness of our methods.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2023; v1 submitted 28 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Assigning Shadow Prices to Synthetic Inertia and Frequency Response Reserves from Renewable Energy Sources
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Carlos Matamala,
Yujing Zhou,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
Modern electricity grids throughout the world, particularly in islands such as Great Britain, face a major problem on the road to decarbonisation: the significantly reduced level of system inertia due to integration of Renewable Energy Sources (RES). Given that most RES such as wind and solar are decoupled from the grid through power electronics converters, they do not naturally contribute to syst…
▽ More
Modern electricity grids throughout the world, particularly in islands such as Great Britain, face a major problem on the road to decarbonisation: the significantly reduced level of system inertia due to integration of Renewable Energy Sources (RES). Given that most RES such as wind and solar are decoupled from the grid through power electronics converters, they do not naturally contribute to system inertia. However, RES could support grid stability through appropriately controlling the converters, but currently no market incentives exist for RES to provide this support. In this paper we develop a methodology to optimally clear a market of ancillary services for frequency control, while explicitly considering the participation of grid-forming and grid-following inverter-based technologies. We propose a mathematical framework that allows to compute shadow prices for ancillary services offered by a pool of diverse providers: synchronous and synthetic inertia, enhanced frequency response (e.g. from curtailed RES) and traditional primary frequency response (e.g. by thermal generators). Several case studies are run on a simplified Great Britain system, to illustrate the applicability and benefits of this pricing scheme.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
A framework for receding-horizon control in infinite-horizon aggregative games
Authors:
Filiberto Fele,
Antonio De Paola,
David Angeli,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
A novel modelling framework is proposed for the analysis of aggregative games on an infinite-time horizon, assuming that players are subject to heterogeneous periodic constraints. A new aggregative equilibrium notion is presented and the strategic behaviour of the agents is analysed under a receding horizon paradigm. The evolution of the strategies predicted and implemented by the players over tim…
▽ More
A novel modelling framework is proposed for the analysis of aggregative games on an infinite-time horizon, assuming that players are subject to heterogeneous periodic constraints. A new aggregative equilibrium notion is presented and the strategic behaviour of the agents is analysed under a receding horizon paradigm. The evolution of the strategies predicted and implemented by the players over time is modelled through a discrete-time multi-valued dynamical system. By considering Lyapunov stability notions and applying limit and invariance results for set-valued correspondences, necessary conditions are derived for convergence of a receding horizon map to a periodic equilibrium of the aggregative game. This result is achieved for any (feasible) initial condition, thus ensuring implicit adaptivity of the proposed control framework to real-time variations in the number and parameters of players. Design and implementation of the proposed control strategy are discussed and an example of distributed control for data routing is presented, evaluating its performance in simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
On optimal coordinated dispatch for heterogeneous storage fleets with partial availability
Authors:
David Angeli,
Zihang Dong,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
This paper addresses the problem of optimal scheduling of an aggregated power profile (during a coordinated discharging or charging operation) by means of a heterogeneous fleet of storage devices subject to availability constraints. Devices have heterogeneous initial levels of energy, power ratings and efficiency; moreover, the fleet operates without cross-charging of the units. An explicit feedba…
▽ More
This paper addresses the problem of optimal scheduling of an aggregated power profile (during a coordinated discharging or charging operation) by means of a heterogeneous fleet of storage devices subject to availability constraints. Devices have heterogeneous initial levels of energy, power ratings and efficiency; moreover, the fleet operates without cross-charging of the units. An explicit feedback policy is proposed to compute a feasible schedule whenever one exists and scalable design procedures to achieve maximum time to failure or minimal unserved energy in the case of unfeasible aggregated demand profiles. Finally, a time-domain characterization of the set of feasible demand profiles using aggregate constraints is proposed, suitable for optimization problems where the aggregate population behaviour is of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Exact aggregate models for optimal management of heterogeneous fleets of storage devices
Authors:
David Angeli,
Zihang Dong,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
Future power grids will entail large fleets of storage devices capable of scheduling their charging/discharging profiles so as to achieve lower peak demand and reduce energy bills, by shifting absorption times in sync with the availability of renewable energy sources. Optimal management of such fleets entails large scale optimisation problems which are better dealt with in a hierarchical manner, b…
▽ More
Future power grids will entail large fleets of storage devices capable of scheduling their charging/discharging profiles so as to achieve lower peak demand and reduce energy bills, by shifting absorption times in sync with the availability of renewable energy sources. Optimal management of such fleets entails large scale optimisation problems which are better dealt with in a hierarchical manner, by clustering together individual devices into fleets. Leveraging on recent results characterizing the set of aggregate demand profiles of a heterogeneous fleet of charging (or, respectively, discharging) devices we propose a way to achieve optimality, in a unit commitment problem, by adopting a simplified formulation with a number of constraints for the fleet that scales linearly in the number of time-slots considered and is independent of the size of the fleet. This is remarkable, as it shows that, under suitable conditions, a heterogeneous fleet of any size can effectively be treated as a single storage unit.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Importance of Linking Inertia and Frequency Response Procurement: The Great Britain Case
Authors:
Aimon Mirza Baig,
Luis Badesa,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
In order to decarbonise the electricity sector, the future Great Britain (GB) power system will be largely dominated by non-synchronous renewables. This will cause low levels of inertia, a key parameter that could lead to frequency deterioration. Therefore, the requirement for ancillary services that contain frequency deviations will increase significantly, particularly given the increase in size…
▽ More
In order to decarbonise the electricity sector, the future Great Britain (GB) power system will be largely dominated by non-synchronous renewables. This will cause low levels of inertia, a key parameter that could lead to frequency deterioration. Therefore, the requirement for ancillary services that contain frequency deviations will increase significantly, particularly given the increase in size of the largest possible loss with the commissioning of large nuclear plants in the near future. In this paper, an inertia-dependent Stochastic Unit Commitment (SUC) model is used to illustrate the benefits of linking inertia and frequency response provision in low-inertia systems. We demonstrate that the cost of procuring ancillary services in GB could increase by 165% if the level of inertia is not explicitly considered when procuring frequency response. These results highlight the need to re-think the structure of ancillary-services markets, which in GB are nowadays held one month ahead of delivery.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2021; v1 submitted 14 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Conditions for Regional Frequency Stability in Power System Scheduling -- Part II: Application to Unit Commitment
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
In Part I of this paper we have introduced the closed-form conditions for guaranteeing regional frequency stability in a power system. Here we propose a methodology to represent these conditions in the form of linear constraints and demonstrate their applicability by implementing them in a generation-scheduling model. This model simultaneously optimises energy production and ancillary services for…
▽ More
In Part I of this paper we have introduced the closed-form conditions for guaranteeing regional frequency stability in a power system. Here we propose a methodology to represent these conditions in the form of linear constraints and demonstrate their applicability by implementing them in a generation-scheduling model. This model simultaneously optimises energy production and ancillary services for maintaining frequency stability in the event of a generation outage, by solving a frequency-secured Stochastic Unit Commitment (SUC). We consider the Great Britain system, characterised by two regions that create a non-uniform distribution of inertia: England in the South, where most of the load is located, and Scotland in the North, containing significant wind resources. Through several case studies, it is shown that inertia and frequency response cannot be considered as system-wide magnitudes in power systems that exhibit inter-area oscillations in frequency, as their location in a particular region is key to guarantee stability. In addition, securing against a medium-sized loss in the low-inertia region proves to cause significant wind curtailment, which could be alleviated through reinforced transmission corridors. In this context, the proposed constraints allow to find the optimal volume of ancillary services to be procured in each region.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2021; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Conditions for Regional Frequency Stability in Power System Scheduling -- Part I: Theory
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
This paper considers the phenomenon of distinct regional frequencies recently observed in some power systems. First, a reduced-order mathematical model describing this behaviour is developed. Then, techniques to solve the model are discussed, demonstrating that the post-fault frequency evolution in any given region is equal to the frequency evolution of the Centre Of Inertia plus certain inter-are…
▽ More
This paper considers the phenomenon of distinct regional frequencies recently observed in some power systems. First, a reduced-order mathematical model describing this behaviour is developed. Then, techniques to solve the model are discussed, demonstrating that the post-fault frequency evolution in any given region is equal to the frequency evolution of the Centre Of Inertia plus certain inter-area oscillations. This finding leads to the deduction of conditions for guaranteeing frequency stability in all regions of a power system, a deduction performed using a mixed analytical-numerical approach that combines mathematical analysis with regression methods on simulation samples. The proposed stability conditions are linear inequalities that can be implemented in any optimisation routine allowing the co-optimisation of all existing ancillary services for frequency support: inertia, multi-speed frequency response, load damping and an optimised largest power infeed. This is the first reported mathematical framework with explicit conditions to maintain frequency stability in a power system exhibiting inter-area oscillations in frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2021; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Economic Value of Inertia in Low-Carbon Power Systems
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
Most renewable energy sources (RES) do not provide any inertial response. Their integration in a power grid implies a highly reduced level of system inertia, which leads to a deteriorated frequency performance. Then, the requirement for frequency response is significantly increased in order to maintain frequency security. Alternatively, enhanced provision of inertia from auxiliary sources may alle…
▽ More
Most renewable energy sources (RES) do not provide any inertial response. Their integration in a power grid implies a highly reduced level of system inertia, which leads to a deteriorated frequency performance. Then, the requirement for frequency response is significantly increased in order to maintain frequency security. Alternatively, enhanced provision of inertia from auxiliary sources may alleviate this problem. However, the benefits of inertia provision are not yet fully understood.
In this paper, an inertia-dependent Stochastic Unit Commitment (SUC) tool is applied to quantify the economic value of inertia. The results demonstrate that enhanced provision of inertia would lead to significant economic savings, although these savings vary under different system conditions. These results should be brought to the attention of both market operators and investors, in order to inform the design of an ancillary-services market for inertia and the investment in auxiliary provision of inertia.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Optimal Scheduling of Frequency Services Considering a Variable Largest-Power-Infeed-Loss
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
Low levels of inertia due to increasing renewable penetration bring several challenges, such as the higher need for Primary Frequency Response (PFR). A potential solution to mitigate this problem consists on reducing the largest possible power loss in the grid. This paper develops a novel modelling framework to analyse the benefits of such approach.
A new frequency-constrained Stochastic Unit Co…
▽ More
Low levels of inertia due to increasing renewable penetration bring several challenges, such as the higher need for Primary Frequency Response (PFR). A potential solution to mitigate this problem consists on reducing the largest possible power loss in the grid. This paper develops a novel modelling framework to analyse the benefits of such approach.
A new frequency-constrained Stochastic Unit Commitment (SUC) is proposed here, which allows to dynamically reduce the largest possible loss in the optimisation problem. Furthermore, the effect of load damping is included by means of an approximation, while its effect is typically neglected in previous frequency-secured-UC studies. Through several case studies, we demonstrate that reducing the largest loss could significantly decrease operational cost and carbon emissions in the future Great Britain's grid.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Pricing inertia and Frequency Response with diverse dynamics in a Mixed-Integer Second-Order Cone Programming formulation
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
Low levels of system inertia in power grids with significant penetration of non-synchronous Renewable Energy Sources (RES) have increased the risk of frequency instability. The provision of a certain type of ancillary services such as inertia and Frequency Response (FR) is needed at all times, to maintain system frequency within secure limits if the loss of a large power infeed were to occur. In t…
▽ More
Low levels of system inertia in power grids with significant penetration of non-synchronous Renewable Energy Sources (RES) have increased the risk of frequency instability. The provision of a certain type of ancillary services such as inertia and Frequency Response (FR) is needed at all times, to maintain system frequency within secure limits if the loss of a large power infeed were to occur. In this paper we propose a frequency-secured optimisation framework for the procurement of inertia and FR with diverse dynamics, which enables to apply a marginal-pricing scheme for these services. This pricing scheme, deduced from a Mixed-Integer Second-Order Cone Program (MISOCP) formulation that represents frequency-security constraints, allows for the first time to appropriately value multi-speed FR.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2019; v1 submitted 14 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Optimal Portfolio of Distinct Frequency-Response Services in Low-Inertia Systems
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
A reduced level of system inertia due to renewable integration increases the need for cost-effective provision of ancillary services, such as Frequency Response (FR). In this paper we propose a closed-form solution to the differential equation describing frequency dynamics, which allows to obtain frequency-security algebraic constraints to be implemented in optimisation routines. This is done whil…
▽ More
A reduced level of system inertia due to renewable integration increases the need for cost-effective provision of ancillary services, such as Frequency Response (FR). In this paper we propose a closed-form solution to the differential equation describing frequency dynamics, which allows to obtain frequency-security algebraic constraints to be implemented in optimisation routines. This is done while considering any finite number of FR services with distinguished characteristics, such as different delivery times and activation delays. The problem defined by these frequency-security constraints can be formulated as a Mixed-Integer Second-Order Cone Program (MISOCP), which can be efficiently handled by off-the-shelf conic optimisation solvers. This paper also takes into account the uncertainty in inertia contribution from the demand side by formulating the frequency-security conditions as chance constraints, for which an exact convex reformulation is provided. Finally, case studies highlighting the effectiveness of this frequency-secured formulation are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2020; v1 submitted 21 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Chance-Constrained Ancillary Service Specification for Heterogeneous Storage Devices
Authors:
Michael P. Evans,
Simon H. Tindemans,
David Angeli,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
We present a method to find the maximum magnitude of any supply-shortfall service that an aggregator of energy storage devices is able to sell to a grid operator. This is first demonstrated in deterministic settings, then applied to scenarios in which device availabilities are stochastic. In this case we implement chance constraints on the inability to deliver as promised. We show a significant co…
▽ More
We present a method to find the maximum magnitude of any supply-shortfall service that an aggregator of energy storage devices is able to sell to a grid operator. This is first demonstrated in deterministic settings, then applied to scenarios in which device availabilities are stochastic. In this case we implement chance constraints on the inability to deliver as promised. We show a significant computational improvement in using our method in place of straightforward scenario simulation. As an extension, we present an approximation to this method which allows the determined fleet capability to be applied to any chosen service, rather than having to re-solve the chance-constrained optimisation each time.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2019; v1 submitted 6 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Simultaneous Scheduling of Multiple Frequency Services in Stochastic Unit Commitment
Authors:
Luis Badesa,
Fei Teng,
Goran Strbac
Abstract:
The reduced level of system inertia in low-carbon power grids increases the need for alternative frequency services. However, simultaneously optimising the provision of these services in the scheduling process, subject to significant uncertainty, is a complex task given the challenge of linking the steady-state optimisation with frequency dynamics. This paper proposes a novel frequency-constrained…
▽ More
The reduced level of system inertia in low-carbon power grids increases the need for alternative frequency services. However, simultaneously optimising the provision of these services in the scheduling process, subject to significant uncertainty, is a complex task given the challenge of linking the steady-state optimisation with frequency dynamics. This paper proposes a novel frequency-constrained Stochastic Unit Commitment (SUC) model which, for the first time, co-optimises energy production along with the provision of synchronised and synthetic inertia, Enhanced Frequency Response (EFR), Primary Frequency Response (PFR) and a dynamically-reduced largest power infeed. The contribution of load damping is modelled through a linear inner approximation. The effectiveness of the proposed model is demonstrated through several case studies for Great Britain's 2030 power system, which highlight the synergies and conflicts among alternative frequency services, as well as the significant economic savings and carbon reduction achieved by simultaneously optimising all these services.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2019; v1 submitted 27 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
