-
Quasispecies dynamics with time lags and periodic fluctuations in replication
Authors:
Edward A. Turner,
Francisco Crespo,
Josep Sardanyés,
Nolbert Morales
Abstract:
Quasispecies theory provides the conceptual and theoretical bases for describing the dynamics of biological information of replicators subject to large mutation rates. This theory, initially conceived within the framework of prebiotic evolution, is also being used to investigate the evolutionary dynamics of RNA viruses and heterogeneous cancer cells populations. In this sense, efforts to approxima…
▽ More
Quasispecies theory provides the conceptual and theoretical bases for describing the dynamics of biological information of replicators subject to large mutation rates. This theory, initially conceived within the framework of prebiotic evolution, is also being used to investigate the evolutionary dynamics of RNA viruses and heterogeneous cancer cells populations. In this sense, efforts to approximate the initial quasispecies theory to more realistic scenarios have been made in recent decades. Despite this, how time lags in RNA synthesis and periodic fluctuations impact quasispecies dynamics remains poorly studied. In this article, we combine the theory of delayed ordinary differential equations and topological Leray-Schauder degree to investigate the classical quasispecies model in the single-peak fitness landscape considering time lags and periodic fluctuations in replication. First, we prove that the dynamics with time lags under the constant population constraint remains in the simplex in both forward and backward times. With backward mutation and periodic fluctuations, we prove the existence of periodic orbits regardless of time lags. Nevertheless, without backward mutation, neither periodic fluctuation nor the introduction of time lags leads to periodic orbits. However, in the case of periodic fluctuations, solutions converge exponentially to a periodic oscillation around the equilibria associated with a constant replication rate. We check the validity of the error catastrophe hypothesis assuming no backward mutation; we determine that the error threshold remains sound for the case of time of periodic fitness and time lags with constant fitness. Finally, our results show that the error threshold is not found with backward mutations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Global bifurcation in a virus, defective genomes, satellite RNAs tripartite system: breakdown of a coexistence quasi-neutral curve
Authors:
Oriol Llopis-Almela,
J. Tomas Lazaro,
Santiago F. Elena,
Josep Sardanyes
Abstract:
The dynamics of wild-type (wt) RNA viruses and their defective viral genomes (DVGs) have been extensively studied both experimentally and theoretically. This research has paid special attention to the interference effects of DVGs on wt accumulation, transmission, disease severity, and induction of immunological responses. This subject is currently a highly active. However, viral infections involvi…
▽ More
The dynamics of wild-type (wt) RNA viruses and their defective viral genomes (DVGs) have been extensively studied both experimentally and theoretically. This research has paid special attention to the interference effects of DVGs on wt accumulation, transmission, disease severity, and induction of immunological responses. This subject is currently a highly active. However, viral infections involving wt, DVGs and other subviral genetic elements, like viral RNA satellites (satRNAs) have received scarce attention. Satellites are molecular parasites genetically different from the wt virus, which exploit the products of the latter for their own replication in as much as DVGs do, and thus they need to coinfect host cells along with the wt virus to complete their replication cycle. Here, we analyze a mathematical model describing the initial replication phase of a wt virus producing DVGs and coinfecting with a satRNA. The model has three different dynamical regimes depending upon the wt replication rate ($α$), the fraction of DVGs produced during replication ($ω$), and the replication rate of the satRNA ($β$): ($i$) full extinction when $β> α(1 - ω)$; ($ii$) a bistable regime with full coexistence governed by a quasi-neutral curve of equilibria and full extinction when $β= α(1 - ω)$; and ($iii$) a scenario of bistability separating full extinction from wt-DVGs coexistence with no satRNA when $β< α(1 - ω)$. The transition from scenarios ($i$) to ($iii$) occurs through the creation and destruction of a quasi-neutral curve of equilibria in a global bifurcation that we name as \textit{quasi-neutral nullcline confluence} (QNC) bifurcation: at the bifurcation value, two nullcline hypersurfaces coincide, giving rise to the curve of equilibria.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Resource-consumer dynamics in drylands: modeling the role of plant-plant facilitation-competition shifts with a piecewise system
Authors:
Leonardo Pereira Costa de Cruz,
Joan Torregrossa,
Miguel Berdugo,
Josep Sardanyés
Abstract:
In drylands, water availability determines plant population densities and whether they cooperate via facilitation or compete. When water scarcity intensifies, plant densities decrease and competition for water surpasses the benefits of soil improvement by facilitator plants, involving an abrupt shift from facilitation to competition. Here, we model this facilitation-competition shift using a piece…
▽ More
In drylands, water availability determines plant population densities and whether they cooperate via facilitation or compete. When water scarcity intensifies, plant densities decrease and competition for water surpasses the benefits of soil improvement by facilitator plants, involving an abrupt shift from facilitation to competition. Here, we model this facilitation-competition shift using a piecewise system in a resource species such as grasses studying its impact on a resource-consumer dynamical system. First, the dynamics of each system are introduced separately. The competitive system, by setting conditions to have a monodromic equilibrium in the first quadrant, has no limit cycles. With a monodromy condition in the same quadrant, the cooperative system only has a hyperbolic, small amplitude limit cycle, allowing for an oscillating coexistence. The dynamic properties of the piecewise system become richer. We here prove the extension of the center-focus problem in this particular case, and from a weak focus of order three, we find 3 limit cycles arising from it. We also study the case assuming continuity in the piecewise system. Finally, we present a special and restricted way of obtaining a limit cycle of small amplitude in a pseudo-Hopf bifurcation type. Our results suggest that abrupt density-dependent functional shifts, such as those described in drylands, could introduce novel dynamical phenomena. Our work also provides a theoretical framework to model and investigate sharp density-dependent processes in Ecology.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Quasineutral multistability in an epidemiological-like model for defective-helper betacoronavirus infection in cell cultures
Authors:
Juan C. Muñoz-Sánchez,
J. Tomás Lázaro,
Julia Hillung,
María J. Olmo-Uceda,
Josep Sardanyés,
Santiago F. Elena
Abstract:
It is well known that, during replication, RNA viruses spontaneously generate defective viral genomes (DVGs). DVGs are unable to complete an infectious cycle autonomously, and depend on coinfection with a helper wild-type virus (HV) for their replication and/or transmission. The study of the dynamics arising from a HV and its DVGs has been a longstanding question in virology. It has been shown tha…
▽ More
It is well known that, during replication, RNA viruses spontaneously generate defective viral genomes (DVGs). DVGs are unable to complete an infectious cycle autonomously, and depend on coinfection with a helper wild-type virus (HV) for their replication and/or transmission. The study of the dynamics arising from a HV and its DVGs has been a longstanding question in virology. It has been shown that DVGs can modulate HV replication and, depending on the strength of interference, result in HV extinctions or self-sustained persistent fluctuations. Extensive experimental work has provided mechanistic explanations for DVG generation and compelling evidences of HV-DVGs virus coevolution. Some of these observations have been captured in mathematical models. Here, we develop and investigate an epidemiological-like mathematical model specifically designed to study the dynamics of betacoronavirus in cell cultures experiments. The dynamics of the model is governed by several degenerate normally hyperbolic invariant manifolds given by quasineutral planes - i.e. filled by equilibrium points. Three different quasineutral planes have been identified depending on parameters and involving: (i) persistence of HV and DVGs; (\emph{ii}) persistence of non-infected cells and DVG-infected cells; and (iii) persistence of DVG-infected cells and DVGs. Sensitivity analyses indicate that model dynamics largely depend on the maximum burst size ($B$), and both the production rate ($β$) and replicative advantage ($δ$) of DVGs. Finally, the model has been fitted to single-passage experimental data using artificial intelligence and key virological parameters have been estimated.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2024; v1 submitted 13 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Functional shift-induced degenerate transcritical Neimark-Sacker bifurcation in a discrete hypercycle
Authors:
E. Fontich,
A. Guillamon,
J. Perona,
J. Sardanyés
Abstract:
In this article we investigate the impact of functional shifts in a time-discrete cross-catalytic system. We use the hypercycle model considering that one of the species shifts from a cooperator to a degradader. At the bifurcation caused by this functional shift, an invariant curve collapses to a point $P$ while, simultaneously, two fixed points collide with $P$ in a transcritical manner. All poin…
▽ More
In this article we investigate the impact of functional shifts in a time-discrete cross-catalytic system. We use the hypercycle model considering that one of the species shifts from a cooperator to a degradader. At the bifurcation caused by this functional shift, an invariant curve collapses to a point $P$ while, simultaneously, two fixed points collide with $P$ in a transcritical manner. All points of a line containing $P$ become fixed points at the bifurcation and only at the bifurcation. Hofbauer and Iooss~\cite{HofbauerIooss1984} presented and proved a result that provides sufficient conditions for a Neimark-Sacker bifurcation (the authors called it "Hopf") to occur in a special degenerate situation. They use it to prove the existence of an invariant curve for the model when a parameter related to the time discreteness of the system goes to infinity becoming a continuous-time system. Here we study the bifurcation that governs the functional shift and demonstrate the existence of an invariant curve when the cooperation parameter approaches zero and thus approaches the switch to degrading species. This invariant curve lives in a different domain and exists for a different set of values of the parameters described by these authors. In order to apply the mentioned result we uncouple the Neimark-Sacker and the transcritical bifurcations. This is accomplished by a preliminary singular change of coordinates that puts the involved fixed points at a fixed position, so that they stay at a fixed distance among them. Finally, going back to the original variables, we can describe mathematically the details of this bifurcation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Dispersal-enhanced resilience in two-patch metapopulations: origin's instability type matters
Authors:
Marc Jorba-Cuscó,
Ruth I. Oliva-Zúniga,
Josep Sardanyés,
Daniel Pérez-Palau
Abstract:
Many populations of animals or plants, exhibit a metapopulation structure with close, spatially-separated subpopulations. The field of metapopulation theory has made significant advancements since the influential Levins model. Various modeling approaches have provided valuable insights to theoretical Ecology. Despite extensive research on metapopulation models, there are still challenging question…
▽ More
Many populations of animals or plants, exhibit a metapopulation structure with close, spatially-separated subpopulations. The field of metapopulation theory has made significant advancements since the influential Levins model. Various modeling approaches have provided valuable insights to theoretical Ecology. Despite extensive research on metapopulation models, there are still challenging questions that are difficult to answer from ecological metapopulational data or multi-patch models. Low-dimension mathematical models offer a promising avenue to address these questions, especially for global dynamics which have been scarcely investigated. In this study, we investigate a two-patch metapopulation model with logistic growth and diffusion between patches. By using analytical and numerical methods, we thoroughly analyze the impact of diffusion on the dynamics of the metapopulation. We identify the equilibrium points and assess their local and global stability. Furthermore, we analytically derive the optimal diffusion rate that leads to the highest metapopulation values. Our findings demonstrate that increased diffusion plays a crucial role in the preservation of both subpopulations and the full metapopulation, especially under the presence of stochastic perturbations. Specifically, at low diffusion values, the origin is a repeller, causing orbits starting around it to travel closely parallel to the axes. This configuration makes the metapopulation less resilient and thus more susceptible to local and global extinctions. However, as diffusion increases, the repeller transitions to a saddle point, and orbits starting near the origin rapidly converge to the unstable manifold of the saddle. This phenomenon reduces the likelihood of stochastic extinctions and the metapopulation becomes more resilient due to these changes in the vector field of the phase space.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
No two without three: Modelling dynamics of the trio RNA virus-defective interfering genomes-RNA satellite
Authors:
J. T. Lázaro,
A. Albó,
T. Alarcón,
S. F. Elena,
J. Sardanyés
Abstract:
Almost all viruses, regardless of their genomic material, produce defective viral genomes (DVG) as an unavoidable byproduct of their error-prone replication. Defective interfering (DI) elements are a subgroup of DVGs that have been shown to interfere with the replication of the wild-type (WT) virus. Along with DIs, other genetic elements known as satellite RNAs (satRNAs), that show no genetic rela…
▽ More
Almost all viruses, regardless of their genomic material, produce defective viral genomes (DVG) as an unavoidable byproduct of their error-prone replication. Defective interfering (DI) elements are a subgroup of DVGs that have been shown to interfere with the replication of the wild-type (WT) virus. Along with DIs, other genetic elements known as satellite RNAs (satRNAs), that show no genetic relatedness with the WT virus, can co-infect cells with WT helper viruses and take advantage of viral proteins for their own benefit. These satRNAs have effects that range from reduced symptom severity to enhanced virulence. The interference dynamics of DIs over WT viruses has been thoroughly modelled at within-cell, within-host, and population levels. However, nothing is known about the dynamics resulting from the nonlinear interactions between WT viruses and DIs in the presence of satellites, a process that is frequently seen in plant RNA viruses and in biomedically relevant pathosystems like hepatitis B virus and its $δ$ satellite. Here, we look into a phenomenological mathematical model that describes how a WT virus replicates and produces DIs in presence of a satRNA at the intra-host level. The WT virus is subject to mechanisms of complementation, competition, and various levels of interference from DIs and the satRNA. Examining the dynamics analytically and numerically reveals three possible stable states: (i) full extinction, (ii) satellite extinction and virus-DIs coexistence and (iii) full coexistence. Assuming DIs replicate faster than the satRNA owed to their smaller size drives to scenario (ii), which implies that DIs could wipe out the satRNA. In addition, a small region of the parameter space exists wherein the system is bistable (either scenarios (ii) or (iii) are concurrently stable).
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Semiclassical theory explains stochastic ghosts scaling
Authors:
J. Tomás Lázaro,
Tomás Alarcón,
Carlos Peña,
Josep Sardanyés
Abstract:
Slowing down phenomena occur in both deterministic and stochastic dynamical systems at the vicinity of phase transitions or bifurcations. An example is found in systems exhibiting a saddle-node bifurcation, which undergo a dramatic time delay towards equilibrium. Specifically the duration of the transient, $τ$, close to this bifurcation in deterministic systems follows scaling laws of the form…
▽ More
Slowing down phenomena occur in both deterministic and stochastic dynamical systems at the vicinity of phase transitions or bifurcations. An example is found in systems exhibiting a saddle-node bifurcation, which undergo a dramatic time delay towards equilibrium. Specifically the duration of the transient, $τ$, close to this bifurcation in deterministic systems follows scaling laws of the form $τ\sim |ε- ε_c|^{-1/2}$, where $ε$ is the bifurcation or control parameter, and $ε_c$ its critical value. For systems undergoing a saddle-node bifurcation, the mechanism involves transients getting trapped by a so-called ghost. In a recent article we explored how intrinsic noise affected the deterministic picture. Extensive numerical simulations showed that, although scaling behaviour persisted in the presence of noise, the scaling law was more complicated than a simple power law. In order to gain deeper insight into this scaling behaviour, we resort to the WKB asymptotic approximation of the Master Equation. According to this approximation, the behaviour of the system is given as the weighted sum of \emph{trajectories} within the phase space of the Hamiltonian associated to the corresponding Hamilton-Jacobi equation. By analysing the flight time of the Hamilton equations, we show that the statistically significant paths follow a scaling function that exactly matches the one observed in the stochastic simulations. We therefore put forward that the properties of the flight times of the Hamiltonian system underpin the scaling law of the underlying stochastic system, and that the same properties should extend in a universal way to all stochastic systems whose associated Hamiltonian exhibits the same behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Dynamical mechanism behind ghosts unveiled in a map complexification
Authors:
Jordi Canela,
Lluís Alsedà,
Núria Fagella,
Josep Sardanyés
Abstract:
Complex systems such as ecosystems, electronic circuits, lasers or chemical reactions can be modelled by dynamical systems which typically experience bifurcations. Transients typically suffer extremely long delays at the vicinity of bifurcations and it is also known that these transients follow scaling laws as the bifurcation parameter gets closer the bifurcation value in deterministic systems. Th…
▽ More
Complex systems such as ecosystems, electronic circuits, lasers or chemical reactions can be modelled by dynamical systems which typically experience bifurcations. Transients typically suffer extremely long delays at the vicinity of bifurcations and it is also known that these transients follow scaling laws as the bifurcation parameter gets closer the bifurcation value in deterministic systems. The mechanisms involved in local bifurcations are well-known. However, for saddle-node bifurcations, the relevant dynamics after the bifurcation occur in the complex phase space. Hence, the mechanism responsible for the delays and the associated inverse-square root scaling law for this bifurcation can be better understood by looking at the dynamics in the complex space. We follow this approach and complexify a simple ecological system undergoing a saddle-node bifurcation. The discrete model describes a biological system with facilitation (cooperation) under habitat destruction for species with non-overlapping generations. We study the complex (as opposed to real) dynamics once the bifurcation has occurred. We identify the fundamental mechanism causing these long delays (called ghosts), given by two repellers in the complex space. Such repellers appear to be extremely close to the real line, thus forming a narrow channel close to the two new fixed points and responsible for the slow passage of the orbits, which remains tangible in the real numbers phase space. We analytically provide the relation between the inverse square-root scaling law and the multipliers of these repellers. We finally prove that the same phenomenon occurs for more general i.e., non-necessarily polynomial, models.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Host-virus evolutionary dynamics with specialist and generalist infection strategies: bifurcations, bistability and chaos
Authors:
Anel Nurtay,
Matthew G. Hennessy,
Lluís Alsedà,
Santiago F. Elena,
Josep Sardanyés
Abstract:
In this work we have investigated the evolutionary dynamics of a generalist pathogen, e.g. a virus population, that evolves towards specialisation in an environment with multiple host types. We have particularly explored under which conditions generalist viral strains may rise in frequency and coexist with specialist strains or even dominate the population. By means of a nonlinear mathematical mod…
▽ More
In this work we have investigated the evolutionary dynamics of a generalist pathogen, e.g. a virus population, that evolves towards specialisation in an environment with multiple host types. We have particularly explored under which conditions generalist viral strains may rise in frequency and coexist with specialist strains or even dominate the population. By means of a nonlinear mathematical model and bifurcation analysis, we have determined the theoretical conditions for stability of nine identified equilibria and provided biological interpretation in terms of the infection rates for the viral specialist and generalist strains. By means of a stability diagram we identified stable fixed points and stable periodic orbits, as well as regions of bistability. For arbitrary biologically feasible initial population sizes, the probability of evolving towards stable solutions is obtained for each point of the analyzed parameter space. This probability map shows combinations of infection rates of the generalist and specialist strains that might lead to equal chances for each type becoming the dominant strategy. Furthermore, we have identified infection rates for which the model predicts the onset of chaotic dynamics. Several degenerate Bogdanov-Takens and zero-Hopf bifurcations are detected along with generalized Hopf and zero-Hopf bifurcations. This manuscript provides additional insights into the dynamical complexity of host-pathogen evolution towards different infection strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Dynamics in a time-discrete food-chain model with strong pressure on preys
Authors:
Lluís Alsedà,
José Tomás Lázaro,
Ricard Solé,
Blai Vidiella,
Josep Sardanyés
Abstract:
Ecological systems are complex dynamical systems. Modelling efforts on ecosystems' dynamical stability have revealed that population dynamics, being highly nonlinear, can be governed by complex fluctuations. Indeed, experimental and field research has provided mounting evidence of chaos in species' abundances, especially for discrete-time systems. Discrete-time dynamics, mainly arising in boreal a…
▽ More
Ecological systems are complex dynamical systems. Modelling efforts on ecosystems' dynamical stability have revealed that population dynamics, being highly nonlinear, can be governed by complex fluctuations. Indeed, experimental and field research has provided mounting evidence of chaos in species' abundances, especially for discrete-time systems. Discrete-time dynamics, mainly arising in boreal and temperate ecosystems for species with non-overlapping generations, have been largely studied to understand the dynamical outcomes due to changes in relevant ecological parameters. The local and global dynamical behaviour of many of these models is difficult to investigate analytically in the parameter space and, typically, numerical approaches are employed when the dimension of the phase space is large. In this article we provide topological and dynamical results for a map modelling a discrete-time, three-species food chain with two predator species interacting on the same prey population. The domain where dynamics live is characterized, as well as the so-called escaping regions, for which the species go rapidly to extinction after surpassing the carrying capacity. We also provide a full description of the local stability of equilibria within a volume of the parameter space given by the prey's growth rate and the predation rates. We have found that the increase of the pressure of predators on the prey results in chaos. The entry into chaos is achieved via a supercritical Neimarck-Sacker bifurcation followed by period-doubling bifurcations of invariant curves. Interestingly, an increasing predation directly on preys can shift the extinction of top predators to their survival, allowing an unstable persistence of the three species by means of periodic and strange chaotic attractors.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Dynamics and bifurcations in a simple quasispecies model of tumorigenesis
Authors:
V. Castillo,
J. Tomas Lazaro,
J. Sardanyes
Abstract:
Cancer is a complex disease and thus is complicated to model. However, simple models that describe the main processes involved in tumoral dynamics, e.g., competition and mutation, can give us clues about cancer behaviour, at least qualitatively, also allowing us to make predictions. Here we analyze a simplified quasispecies mathematical model given by differential equations describing the time beh…
▽ More
Cancer is a complex disease and thus is complicated to model. However, simple models that describe the main processes involved in tumoral dynamics, e.g., competition and mutation, can give us clues about cancer behaviour, at least qualitatively, also allowing us to make predictions. Here we analyze a simplified quasispecies mathematical model given by differential equations describing the time behaviour of tumor cells populations with different levels of genomic instability. We find the equilibrium points, also characterizing their stability and bifurcations focusing on replication and mutation rates. We identify a transcritical bifurcation at increasing mutation rates of the tumor cells population. Such a bifurcation involves an scenario with dominance of healthy cells and impairment of tumor populations. Finally, we characterize the transient times for this scenario, showing that a slight increase beyond the critical mutation rate may be enough to have a fast response towards the desired state (i.e., low tumor populations) during directed mutagenic therapies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
