-
A modeler's guide to handle complexity in energy systems optimization
Authors:
Leander Kotzur,
Lars Nolting,
Maximilian Hoffmann,
Theresa Groß,
Andreas Smolenko,
Jan Priesmann,
Henrik Büsing,
Robin Beer,
Felix Kullmann,
Bismark Singh,
Aaron Praktiknjo,
Detlef Stolten,
Martin Robinius
Abstract:
The determination of environmentally- and economically-optimal energy system designs and operations is complex. In particular, the integration of weather-dependent renewable energy technologies into energy system optimization models presents new challenges to computational tractability that cannot only be solved by advancements in computational resources. In consequence, energy system modelers mus…
▽ More
The determination of environmentally- and economically-optimal energy system designs and operations is complex. In particular, the integration of weather-dependent renewable energy technologies into energy system optimization models presents new challenges to computational tractability that cannot only be solved by advancements in computational resources. In consequence, energy system modelers must tackle the complexity of their models daily and introduce various methods to manipulate the underlying data and model structure, with the ultimate goal of finding optimal solutions. As which complexity reduction method is suitable for which research question is often unclear, herein we review some approaches to handling complexity. Thus, we first analyze the determinants of complexity and note that many drivers of complexity could be avoided a priori with a tailored model design. Second, we conduct a review of systematic complexity reduction methods for energy system optimization models, which can range from simple linearization performed by modelers to sophisticated multi-level approaches combining aggregation and decomposition methods. Based on this overview, we develop a guide for modelers who encounter computational limitations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2021; v1 submitted 15 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Extreme events in time series aggregation: A case study for optimal residential energy supply systems
Authors:
Holger Teichgraeber,
Constantin P. Lindenmeyer,
Nils Baumgärtner,
Leander Kotzur,
Detlef Stolten,
Martin Robinius,
Andre Bardow,
Adam R. Brandt
Abstract:
To account for volatile renewable energy supply, energy systems optimization problems require high temporal resolution. Many models use time-series clustering to find representative periods to reduce the amount of time-series input data and make the optimization problem computationally tractable. However, clustering methods remove peaks and other extreme events, which are important to achieve robu…
▽ More
To account for volatile renewable energy supply, energy systems optimization problems require high temporal resolution. Many models use time-series clustering to find representative periods to reduce the amount of time-series input data and make the optimization problem computationally tractable. However, clustering methods remove peaks and other extreme events, which are important to achieve robust system designs. We present a general decision framework to include extreme events in a set of representative periods. We introduce a method to find extreme periods based on the slack variables of the optimization problem itself. Our method is evaluated and benchmarked with other extreme period inclusion methods from the literature for a design and operations optimization problem: a residential energy supply system. Our method ensures feasibility over the full input data of the residential energy supply system although the design optimization is performed on the reduced data set.
We show that using extreme periods as part of representative periods improves the accuracy of the optimization results by 3% to more than 75% depending on system constraints compared to results with clustering only, and thus reduces system cost and enhances system reliability.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Bottom-up energy supply optimization of a national building stock
Authors:
Leander Kotzur,
Peter Markewitz,
Martin Robinius,
Gonçalo Cardoso,
Peter Stenzel,
Miguel Heleno,
Detlef Stolten
Abstract:
The installation and operation distributed energy resources (DER) and the electrification of the heat supply significantly changes the interaction of the residential building stock with the grid infrastructure. Evaluating the mass deployment of DER at the national level would require analyzing millions of individual buildings, entailing significant computational burden. To overcome this, this work…
▽ More
The installation and operation distributed energy resources (DER) and the electrification of the heat supply significantly changes the interaction of the residential building stock with the grid infrastructure. Evaluating the mass deployment of DER at the national level would require analyzing millions of individual buildings, entailing significant computational burden. To overcome this, this work proposes a novel bottom-up model that consists of an aggregation algorithm to create a spatially distributed set of typical residential buildings from census data. Each typical building is then optimized with a Mixed-Integer Linear Program to derive its cost optimal technology adoption and operation, determining its changing grid load in future scenarios. The model is validated for Germany, with 200 typical buildings considered to sufficiently represent the diversity of the residential building stock. In a future scenario for 2050, photovoltaic and heat pumps are predicted to be the most economically and ecologically robust supply solutions for the different building types. Nevertheless, their electricity generation and demand temporally do not match, resulting in a doubling of the peak electricity grid load in the rural areas during the winter. The urban areas can compensate this with efficient co-generation units, which are not cost-efficient in the rural areas.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Time series aggregation for energy system design: Modeling seasonal storage
Authors:
Leander Kotzur,
Peter Markewitz,
Martin Robinius,
Detlef Stolten
Abstract:
The optimization-based design of renewable energy systems is a computationally demanding task because of the high temporal fluctuation of supply and demand time series. In order to reduce these time series, the aggregation of typical operation periods has become common. The problem with this method is that these aggregated typical periods are modeled independently and cannot exchange energy. There…
▽ More
The optimization-based design of renewable energy systems is a computationally demanding task because of the high temporal fluctuation of supply and demand time series. In order to reduce these time series, the aggregation of typical operation periods has become common. The problem with this method is that these aggregated typical periods are modeled independently and cannot exchange energy. Therefore, seasonal storage cannot be adequately taken into account, although this will be necessary for energy systems with a high share of renewable generation.
To address this issue, this paper proposes a novel mathematical description for storage inventories based on the superposition of inter-period and intra-period states. Inter-period states connect the typical periods and are able to account their sequence. The approach has been adopted for different energy system configurations. The results show that a significant reduction in the computational load can be achieved also for long term storage-based energy system models in comparison to optimization models based on the full annual time series.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2018; v1 submitted 20 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Impact of different time series aggregation methods on optimal energy system design
Authors:
Leander Kotzur,
Peter Markewitz,
Martin Robinius,
Detlef Stolten
Abstract:
Modelling renewable energy systems is a computationally-demanding task due to the high fluctuation of supply and demand time series. To reduce the scale of these, this paper discusses different methods for their aggregation into typical periods. Each aggregation method is applied to a different type of energy system model, making the methods fairly incomparable. To overcome this, the different agg…
▽ More
Modelling renewable energy systems is a computationally-demanding task due to the high fluctuation of supply and demand time series. To reduce the scale of these, this paper discusses different methods for their aggregation into typical periods. Each aggregation method is applied to a different type of energy system model, making the methods fairly incomparable. To overcome this, the different aggregation methods are first extended so that they can be applied to all types of multidimensional time series and then compared by applying them to different energy system configurations and analyzing their impact on the cost optimal design. It was found that regardless of the method, time series aggregation allows for significantly reduced computational resources. Nevertheless, averaged values lead to underestimation of the real system cost in comparison to the use of representative periods from the original time series. The aggregation method itself, e.g. k means clustering, plays a minor role. More significant is the system considered: Energy systems utilizing centralized resources require fewer typical periods for a feasible system design in comparison to systems with a higher share of renewable feed-in. Furthermore, for energy systems based on seasonal storage, currently existing models integration of typical periods is not suitable.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
