A Feasibility-Seeking Approach to Two-stage Robust Optimization in Kidney Exchange
Authors:
Lizeth Carolina Riascos-Alvarez,
Merve Bodur,
Dionne M. Aleman
Abstract:
Kidney paired donation programs (KPDPs) match patients with willing but incompatible donors to compatible donors with an assurance that when they donate, their intended recipient receives a kidney in return from a different donor. A patient and donor join a KPDP as a pair, represented as a vertex in a compatibility graph, where arcs represent compatible kidneys flowing from a donor in one pair to…
▽ More
Kidney paired donation programs (KPDPs) match patients with willing but incompatible donors to compatible donors with an assurance that when they donate, their intended recipient receives a kidney in return from a different donor. A patient and donor join a KPDP as a pair, represented as a vertex in a compatibility graph, where arcs represent compatible kidneys flowing from a donor in one pair to a patient in another. A challenge faced in real-world KPDPs is the possibility of a planned match being cancelled, e.g., due to late detection of organ incompatibility or patient-donor dropout. We therefore develop a two-stage robust optimization approach to the kidney exchange problem wherein (1) the first stage determines a kidney matching solution according to the original compatibility graph, and then (2) the second stage repairs the solution after observing transplant cancellations. In addition to considering homogeneous failure, we present the first approach that considers non-homogeneous failure between vertices and arcs. To this end, we develop solution algorithms with a feasibility-seeking master problem and evaluate two types of recourse policies. Our framework outperforms the state-of-the-art kidney exchange algorithm under homogeneous failure on publicly available instances. Moreover, we provide insights on the scalability of our solution algorithms under non-homogeneous failure for two recourse policies and analyze their impact on highly-sensitized patients, patients for whom few kidney donors are available and whose associated exchanges tend to fail at a higher rate than non-sensitized patients.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023; v1 submitted 16 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
A Branch-and-Price Algorithm Enhanced by Decision Diagrams for the Kidney Exchange Problem
Authors:
Lizeth Carolina Riascos-Álvarez,
Merve Bodur,
Dionne M. Aleman
Abstract:
Kidney paired donation programs allow patients registered with an incompatible donor to receive a suitable kidney from another donor, as long as the latter's co-registered patient, if any, also receives a kidney from a different donor. The kidney exchange problem (KEP) aims to find an optimal collection of kidney exchanges taking the form of cycles and chains. Existing exact solution methods for K…
▽ More
Kidney paired donation programs allow patients registered with an incompatible donor to receive a suitable kidney from another donor, as long as the latter's co-registered patient, if any, also receives a kidney from a different donor. The kidney exchange problem (KEP) aims to find an optimal collection of kidney exchanges taking the form of cycles and chains. Existing exact solution methods for KEP either are designed for the case where only cyclic exchanges are considered, or can handle long chains but are scalable as long as cycles are short. We develop the first decomposition method that is able to deal with long cycles and long chains for large realistic instances. More specifically, we propose a branch-and-price framework, in which the pricing problems are solved (for the first time in packing problems in a digraph) through multi-valued decision diagrams. Also, we present a new upper bound on the optimal value of KEP, stronger than the one proposed in the literature, which is obtained via our master problem. Computational experiments show superior performance of our method over the state of the art by optimally solving almost all instances in the PrefLib library for multiple cycle and chain lengths.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
