-
Ubiquity of power sums in graph profiles
Authors:
Grigoriy Blekherman,
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
Graph density profiles are fundamental objects in extremal combinatorics. Very few profiles are fully known, and all are two-dimensional. We show that even in high dimensions ratios of graph densities and numbers often form the power-sum profile (the limit of the image of the power-sum map) studied recently by Acevedo, Blekherman, Debus and Riener. Our choice of graphs is motivated by recent work…
▽ More
Graph density profiles are fundamental objects in extremal combinatorics. Very few profiles are fully known, and all are two-dimensional. We show that even in high dimensions ratios of graph densities and numbers often form the power-sum profile (the limit of the image of the power-sum map) studied recently by Acevedo, Blekherman, Debus and Riener. Our choice of graphs is motivated by recent work by Blekherman, Raymond and Wei on undecidability of polynomial inequalities in graph densities. While the ratios do not determine the complete density profile, they contain high-dimensional information. For instance, to reconstruct the density profile of $4k$-cycles from our results, one needs to solve only one-parameter extremal problems, for any number of $4k$-cycles.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Tropicalizing the Graph Profile of Some Almost-Stars
Authors:
Maria Dascălu,
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
Many important problems in extremal combinatorics can be stated as certifying polynomial inequalities in graph homomorphism numbers, and in particular, many ask to certify pure binomial inequalities. For a fixed collection of graphs $\mathcal{U}$, the tropicalization of the graph profile of $\mathcal{U}$ essentially records all valid pure binomial inequalities involving graph homomorphism numbers…
▽ More
Many important problems in extremal combinatorics can be stated as certifying polynomial inequalities in graph homomorphism numbers, and in particular, many ask to certify pure binomial inequalities. For a fixed collection of graphs $\mathcal{U}$, the tropicalization of the graph profile of $\mathcal{U}$ essentially records all valid pure binomial inequalities involving graph homomorphism numbers for graphs in $\mathcal{U}$. Building upon ideas and techniques described by Blekherman and Raymond in 2022, we compute the tropicalization of the graph profile for $K_1$ and $S_{2,1^k}$-trees, almost-star graphs with one branch containing two edges and $k$ branches containing one edge. This allows pure binomial inequalities in homomorphism numbers (or densities) for these graphs to be verified through an explicit linear program where the number of variables is equal to the number of edges in the biggest $S_{2,1^k}$-tree involved.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Generalized Pitman-Stanley polytope: vertices and faces
Authors:
William T. Dugan,
Maura Hegarty,
Alejandro H. Morales,
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
In 1999, Pitman and Stanley introduced the polytope bearing their name along with a study of its faces, lattice points, and volume. The Pitman-Stanley polytope is well-studied due to its connections to probability, parking functions, the generalized permutahedra, and flow polytopes. Its lattice points correspond to plane partitions of skew shape with entries 0 and 1. Pitman and Stanley remarked th…
▽ More
In 1999, Pitman and Stanley introduced the polytope bearing their name along with a study of its faces, lattice points, and volume. The Pitman-Stanley polytope is well-studied due to its connections to probability, parking functions, the generalized permutahedra, and flow polytopes. Its lattice points correspond to plane partitions of skew shape with entries 0 and 1. Pitman and Stanley remarked that their polytope can be generalized so that lattice points correspond to plane partitions of skew shape with entries $0,1, \ldots , m$. Since then, this generalization has been untouched. We study this generalization and show that it can also be realized as a flow polytope of a grid graph. We give multiple characterizations of its vertices in terms of plane partitions of skew shape and integer flows. For a fixed skew shape, we show that the number of vertices of this polytope is a polynomial in $m$ whose leading term, in certain cases, counts standard Young tableaux of a skew shifted shape. Moreover, we give formulas for the number of faces, as well as generating functions for the number of vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Undecidability of polynomial inequalities in weighted graph homomorphism densities
Authors:
Grigoriy Blekherman,
Annie Raymond,
Fan Wei
Abstract:
Many problems and conjectures in extremal combinatorics concern polynomial inequalities between homomorphism densities of graphs where we allow edges to have real weights. Using the theory of graph limits, we can equivalently evaluate polynomial expressions in homomorphism densities on kernels $W$, i.e., symmetric, bounded, and measurable functions $W$ from $[0,1]^2 \to \mathbb{R}$. In 2011, Hatam…
▽ More
Many problems and conjectures in extremal combinatorics concern polynomial inequalities between homomorphism densities of graphs where we allow edges to have real weights. Using the theory of graph limits, we can equivalently evaluate polynomial expressions in homomorphism densities on kernels $W$, i.e., symmetric, bounded, and measurable functions $W$ from $[0,1]^2 \to \mathbb{R}$. In 2011, Hatami and Norin proved a fundamental result that it is undecidable to determine the validity of polynomial inequalities in homomorphism densities for graphons (i.e., the case where the range of $W$ is $[0,1]$, which corresponds to unweighted graphs, or equivalently, to graphs with edge weights between $0$ and $1$). The corresponding problem for more general sets of kernels, e.g., for all kernels or for kernels with range $[-1,1]$, remains open. For any $a > 0$, we show undecidability of polynomial inequalities for any set of kernels which contains all kernels with range $\{0,a\}$. This result also answers a question raised by Lovász about finding computationally effective certificates for the validity of homomorphism density inequalities in kernels.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Non-trivial squares and Sidorenko's conjecture
Authors:
Pranav Garg,
Annie Raymond,
Amanda Redlich
Abstract:
Let $t(H;G)$ be the homomorphism density of a graph $H$ into a graph $G$. Sidorenko's conjecture states that for any bipartite graph $H$, $t(H;G)\geq t(K_2;G)^{|E(H)|}$ for all graphs $G$. It is already known that such inequalities cannot be certified through the sums of squares method when $H$ is a so-called trivial square. In this paper, we investigate recent results about Sidorenko's conjecture…
▽ More
Let $t(H;G)$ be the homomorphism density of a graph $H$ into a graph $G$. Sidorenko's conjecture states that for any bipartite graph $H$, $t(H;G)\geq t(K_2;G)^{|E(H)|}$ for all graphs $G$. It is already known that such inequalities cannot be certified through the sums of squares method when $H$ is a so-called trivial square. In this paper, we investigate recent results about Sidorenko's conjecture and classify those involving trivial versus non-trivial squares. We then present some computational results. In particular, we categorize the bipartite graphs $H$ on at most 7 edges for which $t(H;G)\geq t(K_2;G)^{|E(H)|}$ has a sum of squares certificate. We then discuss other limitations for sums of squares proofs beyond trivial squares.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
A Path Forward: Tropicalization in Extremal Combinatorics
Authors:
Grigoriy Blekherman,
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
Many important problems in extremal combinatorics can be be stated as proving a pure binomial inequality in graph homomorphism numbers, i.e., proving that hom$(H_1,G)^{a_1}\cdots$hom$(H_k,G)^{a_k}\geq$hom$(H_{k+1},G)^{a_{k+1}}\cdots$hom$(H_m,G)^{a_m}$ holds for some fixed graphs $H_1,\dots,H_m$ and all graphs $G$. One prominent example is Sidorenko's conjecture. For a fixed collection of graphs…
▽ More
Many important problems in extremal combinatorics can be be stated as proving a pure binomial inequality in graph homomorphism numbers, i.e., proving that hom$(H_1,G)^{a_1}\cdots$hom$(H_k,G)^{a_k}\geq$hom$(H_{k+1},G)^{a_{k+1}}\cdots$hom$(H_m,G)^{a_m}$ holds for some fixed graphs $H_1,\dots,H_m$ and all graphs $G$. One prominent example is Sidorenko's conjecture. For a fixed collection of graphs $\mathcal{U}=\{H_1,\dots,H_m\}$, the exponent vectors of valid pure binomial inequalities in graphs of $\mathcal{U}$ form a convex cone. We compute this cone for several families of graphs including complete graphs, even cycles, stars and paths; the latter is the most interesting and intricate case that we compute. In all of these cases, we observe a tantalizing polyhedrality phenomenon: the cone of valid pure binomial inequalities is actually rational polyhedral, and therefore all valid pure binomial inequalities can be generated from the finite collection of exponent vectors of the extreme rays. Using the work of Kopparty and Rossman, we show that the cone of valid inequalities is indeed rational polyhedral when all graphs $H_i$ are series-parallel and chordal, and we conjecture that polyhedrality holds for any finite collection $\mathcal{U}$. We demonstrate that the polyhedrality phenomenon also occurs in matroids and simplicial complexes. Our description of the inequalities for paths involves a generalization of the Erdős-Simonovits conjecture recently proved in its original form by Sağlam and a new family of inequalities not observed previously. We also solve an open problem of Kopparty and Rossman on the homomorphism domination exponent of paths. One of our main tools is tropicalization, a well-known technique in complex algebraic geometry. We prove several results about tropicalizations which may be of independent interest.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2022; v1 submitted 13 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Proof of the Erdős-Simonovits conjecture on walks
Authors:
Grigoriy Blekherman,
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
Let $G^n$ be a graph on $n$ vertices and let $w_k(G^n)$ denote the number of walks of length $k$ in $G^n$ divided by $n$. Erdős and Simonovits conjectured that $w_k(G^n)^t \geq w_t(G^n)^k$ when $k\geq t$ and both $t$ and $k$ are odd. We prove this conjecture.
Let $G^n$ be a graph on $n$ vertices and let $w_k(G^n)$ denote the number of walks of length $k$ in $G^n$ divided by $n$. Erdős and Simonovits conjectured that $w_k(G^n)^t \geq w_t(G^n)^k$ when $k\geq t$ and both $t$ and $k$ are odd. We prove this conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The Linear Relaxation of an Integer Program for the Union-Closed Conjecture
Authors:
Brianna Amaral,
Lucien Dalton,
Drew Polakowski,
Annie Raymond,
Bertram Thomas
Abstract:
The Frankl conjecture, also known as the union-closed sets conjecture, states that in any finite non-empty union-closed family, there exists an element in at least half of the sets. Let $f(n,a)$ be the maximum number of sets in a union-closed family on a ground set of $n$ elements where each element is in at most $a$ sets for some $a,n\in \mathbb{N}^+$. Proving that $f(n,a)\leq 2a$ for all…
▽ More
The Frankl conjecture, also known as the union-closed sets conjecture, states that in any finite non-empty union-closed family, there exists an element in at least half of the sets. Let $f(n,a)$ be the maximum number of sets in a union-closed family on a ground set of $n$ elements where each element is in at most $a$ sets for some $a,n\in \mathbb{N}^+$. Proving that $f(n,a)\leq 2a$ for all $a, n \in \mathbb{N}^+$ is equivalent to proving the Frankl conjecture. By considering the linear relaxation of the integer programming formulation that was proposed in New Conjectures for Union-Closed Families by Pulaj, Raymond and Theis, we prove that $O(a^2)$ is an upper bound for $f(n,a)$. We also provide different ways that this result could be strengthened. Additionally, we give a new proof that $f(n,2^{n-1}-1)=2^n-n$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Tropicalization of Graph Profiles
Authors:
Grigoriy Blekherman,
Annie Raymond,
Mohit Singh,
Rekha R. Thomas
Abstract:
A graph profile records all possible densities of a fixed finite set of graphs. Profiles can be extremely complicated; for instance the full profile of any triple of connected graphs is not known, and little is known about hypergraph profiles. We introduce the tropicalization of graph and hypergraph profiles. Tropicalization is a well-studied operation in algebraic geometry, which replaces a varie…
▽ More
A graph profile records all possible densities of a fixed finite set of graphs. Profiles can be extremely complicated; for instance the full profile of any triple of connected graphs is not known, and little is known about hypergraph profiles. We introduce the tropicalization of graph and hypergraph profiles. Tropicalization is a well-studied operation in algebraic geometry, which replaces a variety (the set of real or complex solutions to a finite set of algebraic equations) with its "combinatorial shadow". We prove that the tropicalization of a graph profile is a closed convex cone, which still captures interesting combinatorial information. We explicitly compute these tropicalizations for arbitrary sets of complete and star hypergraphs. We show they are rational polyhedral cones even though the corresponding profiles are not even known to be semialgebraic in some of these cases. We then use tropicalization to prove strong restrictions on the power of the sums of squares method, equivalently Cauchy-Schwarz calculus, to test (which is weaker than certification) the validity of graph density inequalities. In particular, we show that sums of squares cannot test simple binomial graph density inequalities, or even their approximations. Small concrete examples of such inequalities are presented, and include the famous Blakley-Roy inequalities for paths of odd length. As a consequence, these simple inequalities cannot be written as a rational sum of squares of graph densities.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022; v1 submitted 10 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Simple Graph Density Inequalities with no Sum of Squares Proofs
Authors:
Grigoriy Blekherman,
Annie Raymond,
Mohit Singh,
Rekha R. Thomas
Abstract:
Establishing inequalities among graph densities is a central pursuit in extremal combinatorics. A standard tool to certify the nonnegativity of a graph density expression is to write it as a sum of squares. In this paper, we identify a simple condition under which a graph density expression cannot be a sum of squares. Using this result, we prove that the Blakley-Roy inequality does not have a sum…
▽ More
Establishing inequalities among graph densities is a central pursuit in extremal combinatorics. A standard tool to certify the nonnegativity of a graph density expression is to write it as a sum of squares. In this paper, we identify a simple condition under which a graph density expression cannot be a sum of squares. Using this result, we prove that the Blakley-Roy inequality does not have a sum of squares certificate when the path length is odd. We also show that the same Blakley-Roy inequalities cannot be certified by sums of squares using a multiplier of the form one plus a sum of squares. These results answer two questions raised by Lovász. Our main tool is used again to show that the smallest open case of Sidorenko's conjectured inequality cannot be certified by a sum of squares. Finally, we show that our setup is equivalent to existing frameworks by Razborov and Lovász-Szegedy, and thus our results hold in these settings too.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
The Turán Polytope
Authors:
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
The Turán hypergraph problem asks to find the maximum number of $r$-edges in a $r$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices that does not contain a clique of size $a$. When $r=2$, i.e., for graphs, the answer is well-known and can be found in Turán's theorem. However, when $r\geq 3$, the problem remains open. We model the problem as an integer program and call the underlying polytope the Turán polytope.…
▽ More
The Turán hypergraph problem asks to find the maximum number of $r$-edges in a $r$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices that does not contain a clique of size $a$. When $r=2$, i.e., for graphs, the answer is well-known and can be found in Turán's theorem. However, when $r\geq 3$, the problem remains open. We model the problem as an integer program and call the underlying polytope the Turán polytope. We draw parallels between the latter and the stable set polytope: we show that generalized and transformed versions of the web and wheel inequalities are also facet-defining for the Turán polytope. We also show clique inequalities and what we call doubling inequalities are facet-defining when $r=2$. These facets lead to a simple new polyhedral proof of Turán's theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
The bullet problem with discrete speeds
Authors:
Brittany Dygert,
Christoph Kinzel,
Jennifer Zhu,
Matthew Junge,
Annie Raymond,
Erik Slivken
Abstract:
Bullets are fired, one per second, with independent speeds sampled uniformly from a discrete set. Collisions result in mutual annihilation. We show that the second fastest bullet survives with positive probability, while a slowest bullet does not. This also holds for exponential spacings between firing times, and for certain non-uniform measures that place less probability on the second fastest bu…
▽ More
Bullets are fired, one per second, with independent speeds sampled uniformly from a discrete set. Collisions result in mutual annihilation. We show that the second fastest bullet survives with positive probability, while a slowest bullet does not. This also holds for exponential spacings between firing times, and for certain non-uniform measures that place less probability on the second fastest bullet. Our results provide new insights into a two-sided version of the bullet process known to physicists as ballistic annihilation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2018; v1 submitted 2 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Symmetric Sums of Squares over $k$-Subset Hypercubes
Authors:
Annie Raymond,
James Saunderson,
Mohit Singh,
Rekha R. Thomas
Abstract:
We consider the problem of finding sum of squares (sos) expressions to establish the non-negativity of a symmetric polynomial over a discrete hypercube whose coordinates are indexed by the $k$-element subsets of $[n]$. For simplicity, we focus on the case $k=2$, but our results extend naturally to all values of $k \geq 2$. We develop a variant of the Gatermann-Parrilo symmetry-reduction method tai…
▽ More
We consider the problem of finding sum of squares (sos) expressions to establish the non-negativity of a symmetric polynomial over a discrete hypercube whose coordinates are indexed by the $k$-element subsets of $[n]$. For simplicity, we focus on the case $k=2$, but our results extend naturally to all values of $k \geq 2$. We develop a variant of the Gatermann-Parrilo symmetry-reduction method tailored to our setting that allows for several simplifications and a connection to flag algebras.
We show that every symmetric polynomial that has a sos expression of a fixed degree also has a succinct sos expression whose size depends only on the degree and not on the number of variables. Our method bypasses much of the technical difficulties needed to apply the Gatermann-Parrilo method, and offers flexibility in obtaining succinct sos expressions that are combinatorially meaningful. As a byproduct of our results, we arrive at a natural representation-theoretic justification for the concept of flags as introduced by Razborov in his flag algebra calculus. Furthermore, this connection exposes a family of non-negative polynomials that cannot be certified with any fixed set of flags, answering a question of Razborov in the context of our finite setting.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2016; v1 submitted 17 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
New Conjectures for Union-Closed Families
Authors:
Jonad Pulaj,
Annie Raymond,
Dirk Theis
Abstract:
The Frankl conjecture, also known as the union-closed sets conjecture, states that in any finite non-empty union-closed family, there exists an element in at least half of the sets. From an optimization point of view, one could instead prove that $2a$ is an upper bound to the number of sets in a union-closed family on a ground set of $n$ elements where each element is in at most $a$ sets for all…
▽ More
The Frankl conjecture, also known as the union-closed sets conjecture, states that in any finite non-empty union-closed family, there exists an element in at least half of the sets. From an optimization point of view, one could instead prove that $2a$ is an upper bound to the number of sets in a union-closed family on a ground set of $n$ elements where each element is in at most $a$ sets for all $a,n\in \mathbb{N}^+$. Similarly, one could prove that the minimum number of sets containing the most frequent element in a (non-empty) union-closed family with $m$ sets and $n$ elements is at least $\frac{m}{2}$ for any $m,n\in \mathbb{N}^+$. Formulating these problems as integer programs, we observe that the optimal values we computed do not vary with $n$. We formalize these observations as conjectures, and show that they are not equivalent to the Frankl conjecture while still having wide-reaching implications if proven true. Finally, we prove special cases of the new conjectures and discuss possible approaches to solve them completely.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2016; v1 submitted 30 November, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Symmetry in Turán Sums of Squares Polynomials from Flag Algebras
Authors:
Annie Raymond,
Mohit Singh,
Rekha R. Thomas
Abstract:
Turán problems in extremal combinatorics ask to find asymptotic bounds on the edge densities of graphs and hypergraphs that avoid specified subgraphs. The theory of flag algebras proposed by Razborov provides powerful methods based on semidefinite programming to find sums of squares that establish edge density inequalities in Turán problems. Working with polynomial analogs of the flag algebra enti…
▽ More
Turán problems in extremal combinatorics ask to find asymptotic bounds on the edge densities of graphs and hypergraphs that avoid specified subgraphs. The theory of flag algebras proposed by Razborov provides powerful methods based on semidefinite programming to find sums of squares that establish edge density inequalities in Turán problems. Working with polynomial analogs of the flag algebra entities, we prove that such sums of squares created by flag algebras can be retrieved from a restricted version of the symmetry-adapted semidefinite program proposed by Gatermann and Parrilo. This involves using the representation theory of the symmetric group for finding succinct sums of squares expressions for invariant polynomials. The connection reveals several combinatorial and structural properties of flag algebra sums of squares, and offers new tools for Turán and other related problems.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2017; v1 submitted 10 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
The centers of gravity of the associahedron and of the permutahedron are the same
Authors:
Christophe Hohlweg,
Jonathan Lortie,
Annie Raymond
Abstract:
In this article, we show that Loday's realization of the associahedron has the the same center of gravity than the permutahedron. This proves an observation made by F. Chapoton. We also prove that this result holds for the associahedron and the cyclohedron as realized by the first author and C. Lange.
In this article, we show that Loday's realization of the associahedron has the the same center of gravity than the permutahedron. This proves an observation made by F. Chapoton. We also prove that this result holds for the associahedron and the cyclohedron as realized by the first author and C. Lange.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Small Chvatal rank
Authors:
Tristram Bogart,
Annie Raymond,
Rekha R. Thomas
Abstract:
We propose a variant of the Chvatal-Gomory procedure that will produce a sufficient set of facet normals for the integer hulls of all polyhedra {xx : Ax <= b} as b varies. The number of steps needed is called the small Chvatal rank (SCR) of A. We characterize matrices for which SCR is zero via the notion of supernormality which generalizes unimodularity. SCR is studied in the context of the stab…
▽ More
We propose a variant of the Chvatal-Gomory procedure that will produce a sufficient set of facet normals for the integer hulls of all polyhedra {xx : Ax <= b} as b varies. The number of steps needed is called the small Chvatal rank (SCR) of A. We characterize matrices for which SCR is zero via the notion of supernormality which generalizes unimodularity. SCR is studied in the context of the stable set problem in a graph, and we show that many of the well-known facet normals of the stable set polytope appear in at most two rounds of our procedure. Our results reveal a uniform hypercyclic structure behind the normals of many complicated facet inequalities in the literature for the stable set polytope. Lower bounds for SCR are derived both in general and for polytopes in the unit cube.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2009; v1 submitted 7 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
