-
Analysing the Moments of the Determinant of a Random Matrix Via Analytic Combinatorics of Permutation Tables
Authors:
Dominik Beck,
Zelin Lv,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
We consider the following natural question. Given a matrix $A$ with i.i.d. random entries, what are the moments of the determinant of $A$? In other words, what is $\mathbb{E}[\det(A)^k]$? While there is a general expression for $\mathbb{E}[\det(A)^k]$ when the entries of $A$ are Gaussian, much less is known when the entries of $A$ have some other distribution.
In two recent papers, we answered t…
▽ More
We consider the following natural question. Given a matrix $A$ with i.i.d. random entries, what are the moments of the determinant of $A$? In other words, what is $\mathbb{E}[\det(A)^k]$? While there is a general expression for $\mathbb{E}[\det(A)^k]$ when the entries of $A$ are Gaussian, much less is known when the entries of $A$ have some other distribution.
In two recent papers, we answered this question for $k = 4$ when the entries of $A$ are drawn from an arbitrary distribution and for $k = 6$ when the entries of $A$ are drawn from a distribution which has mean $0$. These analyses used recurrence relations and were highly intricate. In this paper, we show how these analyses can be simplified considerably by using analytic combinatorics on permutation tables.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
On the second moment of the determinant of random symmetric, Wigner, and Hermitian matrices
Authors:
Dominik Beck,
Zelin Lv,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper, we analyze the second moment of the determinant of random symmetric, Wigner, and Hermitian matrices. Using analytic combinatorics techniques, we determine the second moment of the determinant of Hermitian matrices whose entries on the diagonal are i.i.d and whose entries above the diagonal are i.i.d. and have real expected values. Our results extend previous work analyzing the secon…
▽ More
In this paper, we analyze the second moment of the determinant of random symmetric, Wigner, and Hermitian matrices. Using analytic combinatorics techniques, we determine the second moment of the determinant of Hermitian matrices whose entries on the diagonal are i.i.d and whose entries above the diagonal are i.i.d. and have real expected values. Our results extend previous work analyzing the second moment of the determinant of symmetric and Wigner matrices, providing a unified approach for this analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2024; v1 submitted 22 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Hardness of sampling for the anti-ferromagnetic Ising model on random graphs
Authors:
Neng Huang,
Will Perkins,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
We prove a hardness of sampling result for the anti-ferromagnetic Ising model on random graphs of average degree $d$ for large constant $d$, proving that when the normalized inverse temperature satisfies $β>1$ (asymptotically corresponding to the condensation threshold), then w.h.p. over the random graph there is no stable sampling algorithm that can output a sample close in $W_2$ distance to the…
▽ More
We prove a hardness of sampling result for the anti-ferromagnetic Ising model on random graphs of average degree $d$ for large constant $d$, proving that when the normalized inverse temperature satisfies $β>1$ (asymptotically corresponding to the condensation threshold), then w.h.p. over the random graph there is no stable sampling algorithm that can output a sample close in $W_2$ distance to the Gibbs measure. The results also apply to a fixed-magnetization version of the model, showing that there are no stable sampling algorithms for low but positive temperature max and min bisection distributions. These results show a gap in the tractability of search and sampling problems: while there are efficient algorithms to find near optimizers, stable sampling algorithms cannot access the Gibbs distribution concentrated on such solutions.
Our techniques involve extensions of the interpolation technique relating behavior of the mean field Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model to behavior of Ising models on random graphs of average degree $d$ for large $d$. While previous interpolation arguments compared the free energies of the two models, our argument compares the average energies and average overlaps in the two models.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
On induced subgraphs of $H(n,3)$ with maximum degree $1$
Authors:
Aaron Potechin,
Hing Yin Tsang
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider induced subgraphs of the Hamming graph $H(n,3)$. We show that if $U \subseteq \mathbb{Z}_3^n$ and $U$ induces a subgraph of $H(n,3)$ with maximum degree at most $1$ then
1. If $U$ is disjoint from a maximum size independent set of $H(n,3)$ then $|U| \leq 3^{n-1}+1$. Moreover, all such $U$ with size $3^{n-1}+1$ are isomorphic to each other.
2. For $n \geq 6$, there ex…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider induced subgraphs of the Hamming graph $H(n,3)$. We show that if $U \subseteq \mathbb{Z}_3^n$ and $U$ induces a subgraph of $H(n,3)$ with maximum degree at most $1$ then
1. If $U$ is disjoint from a maximum size independent set of $H(n,3)$ then $|U| \leq 3^{n-1}+1$. Moreover, all such $U$ with size $3^{n-1}+1$ are isomorphic to each other.
2. For $n \geq 6$, there exists such a $U$ with size $|U| = 3^{n-1}+18$ and this is optimal for $n = 6$.
3. If $U \cap \{x, x+e_1, x+2e_1\} \ne φ$ for all $x \in \mathbb{Z}_3^n$ then $|U| \leq 3^{n-1} + 729$.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2025; v1 submitted 23 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Ellipsoid Fitting Up to a Constant
Authors:
Jun-Ting Hsieh,
Pravesh K. Kothari,
Aaron Potechin,
Jeff Xu
Abstract:
In [Sau11,SPW13], Saunderson, Parrilo and Willsky asked the following elegant geometric question: what is the largest $m= m(d)$ such that there is an ellipsoid in $\mathbb{R}^d$ that passes through $v_1, v_2, \ldots, v_m$ with high probability when the $v_i$s are chosen independently from the standard Gaussian distribution $N(0,I_{d})$. The existence of such an ellipsoid is equivalent to the exist…
▽ More
In [Sau11,SPW13], Saunderson, Parrilo and Willsky asked the following elegant geometric question: what is the largest $m= m(d)$ such that there is an ellipsoid in $\mathbb{R}^d$ that passes through $v_1, v_2, \ldots, v_m$ with high probability when the $v_i$s are chosen independently from the standard Gaussian distribution $N(0,I_{d})$. The existence of such an ellipsoid is equivalent to the existence of a positive semidefinite matrix $X$ such that $v_i^{\top}X v_i =1$ for every $1 \leq i \leq m$ - a natural example of a random semidefinite program. SPW conjectured that $m= (1-o(1)) d^2/4$ with high probability. Very recently, Potechin, Turner, Venkat and Wein and Kane and Diakonikolas proved that $m \geq d^2/\log^{O(1)}(d)$ via certain explicit constructions.
In this work, we give a substantially tighter analysis of their construction to prove that $m \geq d^2/C$ for an absolute constant $C>0$. This resolves one direction of the SPW conjecture up to a constant. Our analysis proceeds via the method of Graphical Matrix Decomposition that has recently been used to analyze correlated random matrices arising in various areas [BHK+19]. Our key new technical tool is a refined method to prove singular value upper bounds on certain correlated random matrices that are tight up to absolute dimension-independent constants. In contrast, all previous methods that analyze such matrices lose logarithmic factors in the dimension.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Separating MAX 2-AND, MAX DI-CUT and MAX CUT
Authors:
Joshua Brakensiek,
Neng Huang,
Aaron Potechin,
Uri Zwick
Abstract:
Assuming the Unique Games Conjecture (UGC), the best approximation ratio that can be obtained in polynomial time for the MAX CUT problem is $α_{\text{CUT}}\simeq 0.87856$, obtained by the celebrated SDP-based approximation algorithm of Goemans and Williamson. The currently best approximation algorithm for MAX DI-CUT, i.e., the MAX CUT problem in directed graphs, achieves a ratio of about…
▽ More
Assuming the Unique Games Conjecture (UGC), the best approximation ratio that can be obtained in polynomial time for the MAX CUT problem is $α_{\text{CUT}}\simeq 0.87856$, obtained by the celebrated SDP-based approximation algorithm of Goemans and Williamson. The currently best approximation algorithm for MAX DI-CUT, i.e., the MAX CUT problem in directed graphs, achieves a ratio of about $0.87401$, leaving open the question whether MAX DI-CUT can be approximated as well as MAX CUT. We obtain a slightly improved algorithm for MAX DI-CUT and a new UGC-hardness result for it, showing that $0.87446\le α_{\text{DI-CUT}}\le 0.87461$, where $α_{\text{DI-CUT}}$ is the best approximation ratio that can be obtained in polynomial time for MAX DI-CUT under UGC. The new upper bound separates MAX DI-CUT from MAX CUT, resolving a question raised by Feige and Goemans.
A natural generalization of MAX DI-CUT is the MAX 2-AND problem in which each constraint is of the form $z_1\land z_2$, where $z_1$ and $z_2$ are literals, i.e., variables or their negations (In MAX DI-CUT each constraint is of the form $\bar{x}_1\land x_2$, where $x_1$ and $x_2$ are variables.) Austrin separated MAX 2-AND from MAX CUT by showing that $α_{\text{2AND}} < 0.87435$ and conjectured that MAX 2-AND and MAX DI-CUT have the same approximation ratio. Our new lower bound on MAX DI-CUT refutes this conjecture, completing the separation of the three problems MAX 2-AND, MAX DI-CUT and MAX CUT. We also obtain a new lower bound for MAX 2-AND, showing that $0.87414\le α_{\text{2AND}}\le 0.87435$.
Our upper bound on MAX DI-CUT is achieved via a simple, analytical proof. The lower bounds on MAX DI-CUT and MAX 2-AND (the new approximation algorithms) use experimentally-discovered distributions of rounding functions which are then verified via computer-assisted proofs.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2023; v1 submitted 21 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Near-optimal fitting of ellipsoids to random points
Authors:
Aaron Potechin,
Paxton Turner,
Prayaag Venkat,
Alexander S. Wein
Abstract:
Given independent standard Gaussian points $v_1, \ldots, v_n$ in dimension $d$, for what values of $(n, d)$ does there exist with high probability an origin-symmetric ellipsoid that simultaneously passes through all of the points? This basic problem of fitting an ellipsoid to random points has connections to low-rank matrix decompositions, independent component analysis, and principal component an…
▽ More
Given independent standard Gaussian points $v_1, \ldots, v_n$ in dimension $d$, for what values of $(n, d)$ does there exist with high probability an origin-symmetric ellipsoid that simultaneously passes through all of the points? This basic problem of fitting an ellipsoid to random points has connections to low-rank matrix decompositions, independent component analysis, and principal component analysis. Based on strong numerical evidence, Saunderson, Parrilo, and Willsky [Proc. of Conference on Decision and Control, pp. 6031-6036, 2013] conjecture that the ellipsoid fitting problem transitions from feasible to infeasible as the number of points $n$ increases, with a sharp threshold at $n \sim d^2/4$. We resolve this conjecture up to logarithmic factors by constructing a fitting ellipsoid for some $n = Ω( \, d^2/\mathrm{polylog}(d) \,)$, improving prior work of Ghosh et al. [Proc. of Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science, pp. 954-965, 2020] that requires $n = o(d^{3/2})$. Our proof demonstrates feasibility of the least squares construction of Saunderson et al. using a convenient decomposition of a certain non-standard random matrix and a careful analysis of its Neumann expansion via the theory of graph matrices.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2023; v1 submitted 19 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
The Sixth Moment of Random Determinants
Authors:
Dominik Beck,
Zelin Lv,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper, we determine the sixth moment of the determinant of an asymmetric $n \times n$ random matrix where the entries are drawn independently from an arbitrary distribution $Ω$ with mean $0$. Furthermore, we derive the asymptotic behavior of the sixth moment of the determinant as the size of the matrix tends to infinity.
In this paper, we determine the sixth moment of the determinant of an asymmetric $n \times n$ random matrix where the entries are drawn independently from an arbitrary distribution $Ω$ with mean $0$. Furthermore, we derive the asymptotic behavior of the sixth moment of the determinant as the size of the matrix tends to infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2023; v1 submitted 22 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
On Mixing Distributions Via Random Orthogonal Matrices and the Spectrum of the Singular Values of Multi-Z Shaped Graph Matrices
Authors:
Wenjun Cai,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper, we introduce and analyze a new operation $\circ_{R}$ which mixes two distributions $Ω$ and $Ω'$ via a random orthogonal matrix. In particular, we take $Ω\circ_R Ω'$ to be the limit as $n \to \infty$ of the distribution of singular values of $DRD'$ where $D$ and $D'$ are $n \times n$ diagonal matrices whose diagonal entries have distributions $Ω$ and $Ω'$ respectively and $R$ is a ra…
▽ More
In this paper, we introduce and analyze a new operation $\circ_{R}$ which mixes two distributions $Ω$ and $Ω'$ via a random orthogonal matrix. In particular, we take $Ω\circ_R Ω'$ to be the limit as $n \to \infty$ of the distribution of singular values of $DRD'$ where $D$ and $D'$ are $n \times n$ diagonal matrices whose diagonal entries have distributions $Ω$ and $Ω'$ respectively and $R$ is a random $n \times n$ orthogonal matrix. We show that $\circ_R$ has several nice properties. We first observe that $\circ_R$ is commutative and associative and compute the moments of $Ω\circ_R Ω'$ in terms of the moments of $Ω$ and $Ω'$. We then show that $\circ_R$ interacts very nicely with the spectrum of the singular values of Z-shaped and multi-Z-shaped graph matrices. This allows us to answer the question posed by our previous paper of how to describe the spectrum of the singular values of Z-shaped and multi-Z-shaped graph matrices when the input distribution is not $\{-1,1\}$. In our analysis, we show that the moments of our distributions are closely connected to non-crossing partitions and prove a number of new results on non-crossing partitions which may be of independent interest.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2022; v1 submitted 5 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Bounds on the Total Coefficient Size of Nullstellensatz Proofs of the Pigeonhole Principle and the Ordering Principle
Authors:
Aaron Potechin,
Aaron Zhang
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the total coefficient size of Nullstellensatz proofs. We show that Nullstellensatz proofs of the pigeonhole principle on $n$ pigeons require total coefficient size $2^{Ω(n)}$ and that there exist Nullstellensatz proofs of the ordering principle on $n$ elements with total coefficient size $2^n - n$.
In this paper, we investigate the total coefficient size of Nullstellensatz proofs. We show that Nullstellensatz proofs of the pigeonhole principle on $n$ pigeons require total coefficient size $2^{Ω(n)}$ and that there exist Nullstellensatz proofs of the ordering principle on $n$ elements with total coefficient size $2^n - n$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Almost-Orthogonal Bases for Inner Product Polynomials
Authors:
Chris Jones,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider low-degree polynomials of inner products between a collection of random vectors. We give an almost orthogonal basis for this vector space of polynomials when the random vectors are Gaussian, spherical, or Boolean. In all three cases, our basis admits an interesting combinatorial description based on the topology of the underlying graph of inner products.
We also analyz…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider low-degree polynomials of inner products between a collection of random vectors. We give an almost orthogonal basis for this vector space of polynomials when the random vectors are Gaussian, spherical, or Boolean. In all three cases, our basis admits an interesting combinatorial description based on the topology of the underlying graph of inner products.
We also analyze the expected value of the product of two polynomials in our basis. In all three cases, we show that this expected value can be expressed in terms of collections of matchings on the underlying graph of inner products. In the Gaussian and Boolean cases, we show that this expected value is always non-negative. In the spherical case, we show that this expected value can be negative but we conjecture that if the underlying graph of inner products is planar then this expected value will always be non-negative.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2021; v1 submitted 1 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Exact nuclear norm, completion and decomposition for random overcomplete tensors via degree-4 SOS
Authors:
Bohdan Kivva,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper we show that simple semidefinite programs inspired by degree $4$ SOS can exactly solve the tensor nuclear norm, tensor decomposition, and tensor completion problems on tensors with random asymmetric components. More precisely, for tensor nuclear norm and tensor decomposition, we show that w.h.p. these semidefinite programs can exactly find the nuclear norm and components of an…
▽ More
In this paper we show that simple semidefinite programs inspired by degree $4$ SOS can exactly solve the tensor nuclear norm, tensor decomposition, and tensor completion problems on tensors with random asymmetric components. More precisely, for tensor nuclear norm and tensor decomposition, we show that w.h.p. these semidefinite programs can exactly find the nuclear norm and components of an $(n\times n\times n)$-tensor $\mathcal{T}$ with $m\leq n^{3/2}/polylog(n)$ random asymmetric components. Unlike most of the previous algorithms, our algorithm provides a certificate for the decomposition, does not require knowledge about the number of components in the decomposition and does not make any assumptions on the sizes of the coefficients in the decomposition. As a byproduct, we show that w.h.p. the nuclear norm decomposition exactly coincides with the minimum rank decomposition for tensors with $m\leq n^{3/2}/polylog(n)$ random asymmetric components.
For tensor completion, we show that w.h.p. the semidefinite program, introduced by Potechin & Steurer (2017) for tensors with orthogonal components, can exactly recover an $(n\times n\times n)$-tensor $\mathcal{T}$ with $m$ random asymmetric components from only $n^{3/2}m polylog(n)$ randomly observed entries. For non-orthogonal tensors, this improves the dependence on $m$ of the number of entries needed for exact recovery over all previously known algorithms and provides the first theoretical guarantees for exact tensor completion in the overcomplete regime.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Sum-of-Squares Lower Bounds for Sherrington-Kirkpatrick via Planted Affine Planes
Authors:
Mrinalkanti Ghosh,
Fernando Granha Jeronimo,
Chris Jones,
Aaron Potechin,
Goutham Rajendran
Abstract:
The Sum-of-Squares (SoS) hierarchy is a semi-definite programming meta-algorithm that captures state-of-the-art polynomial time guarantees for many optimization problems such as Max-$k$-CSPs and Tensor PCA. On the flip side, a SoS lower bound provides evidence of hardness, which is particularly relevant to average-case problems for which NP-hardness may not be available.
In this paper, we consid…
▽ More
The Sum-of-Squares (SoS) hierarchy is a semi-definite programming meta-algorithm that captures state-of-the-art polynomial time guarantees for many optimization problems such as Max-$k$-CSPs and Tensor PCA. On the flip side, a SoS lower bound provides evidence of hardness, which is particularly relevant to average-case problems for which NP-hardness may not be available.
In this paper, we consider the following average case problem, which we call the \emph{Planted Affine Planes} (PAP) problem: Given $m$ random vectors $d_1,\ldots,d_m$ in $\mathbb{R}^n$, can we prove that there is no vector $v \in \mathbb{R}^n$ such that for all $u \in [m]$, $\langle v, d_u\rangle^2 = 1$? In other words, can we prove that $m$ random vectors are not all contained in two parallel hyperplanes at equal distance from the origin? We prove that for $m \leq n^{3/2-ε}$, with high probability, degree-$n^{Ω(ε)}$ SoS fails to refute the existence of such a vector $v$.
When the vectors $d_1,\ldots,d_m$ are chosen from the multivariate normal distribution, the PAP problem is equivalent to the problem of proving that a random $n$-dimensional subspace of $\mathbb{R}^m$ does not contain a boolean vector. As shown by Mohanty--Raghavendra--Xu [STOC 2020], a lower bound for this problem implies a lower bound for the problem of certifying energy upper bounds on the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Hamiltonian, and so our lower bound implies a degree-$n^{Ω(ε)}$ SoS lower bound for the certification version of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick problem.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The Spectrum of the Singular Values of Z-Shaped Graph Matrices
Authors:
Wenjun Cai,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
Graph matrices are a type of matrix which has played a crucial role in analyzing the sum of squares hierarchy on average case problems. However, except for rough norm bounds, little is known about graph matrices. In this paper, we take a step towards better understanding graph matrices by determining the limiting distribution of the spectrum of the singular values of Z-shaped graph matrices. We th…
▽ More
Graph matrices are a type of matrix which has played a crucial role in analyzing the sum of squares hierarchy on average case problems. However, except for rough norm bounds, little is known about graph matrices. In this paper, we take a step towards better understanding graph matrices by determining the limiting distribution of the spectrum of the singular values of Z-shaped graph matrices. We then give a partial generalization of our results for $m$-layer Z-shaped graph matrices.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2024; v1 submitted 24 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A Conjecture on Induced Subgraphs of Cayley Graphs
Authors:
Aaron Potechin,
Hing Yin Tsang
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose the following conjecture which generalizes a theorem proved by Huang [Hua19] in his recent breakthrough proof of the sensitivity conjecture. We conjecture that for any Cayley graph $X = Γ(G,S)$ on a group $G$ and any generating set $S$, if $U \subseteq G$ has size $|U| > |G|/2$, then the induced subgraph of $X$ on $U$ has maximum degree at least $\sqrt{|S|/2}$. Using a re…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose the following conjecture which generalizes a theorem proved by Huang [Hua19] in his recent breakthrough proof of the sensitivity conjecture. We conjecture that for any Cayley graph $X = Γ(G,S)$ on a group $G$ and any generating set $S$, if $U \subseteq G$ has size $|U| > |G|/2$, then the induced subgraph of $X$ on $U$ has maximum degree at least $\sqrt{|S|/2}$. Using a recent idea of Alon and Zheng [AZ20], who proved this conjecture for the special case when $G = Z_2^n$, we prove that this conjecture is true whenever $G$ is abelian. We also observe that for this conjecture to hold for a graph $X$, some symmetry is required: it is insufficient for $X$ to just be regular and bipartite.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Graph Matrices: Norm Bounds and Applications
Authors:
Kwangjun Ahn,
Dhruv Medarametla,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper, we derive nearly tight probabilistic norm bounds for a class of random matrices we call graph matrices. While the classical case of symmetric matrices with independent random entries (Wigner's matrices) is a special case, in general, the entries of our matrices will be dependent in a way that can be specified in terms of a fixed-size graph we refer to as the shape. For Wigner's matr…
▽ More
In this paper, we derive nearly tight probabilistic norm bounds for a class of random matrices we call graph matrices. While the classical case of symmetric matrices with independent random entries (Wigner's matrices) is a special case, in general, the entries of our matrices will be dependent in a way that can be specified in terms of a fixed-size graph we refer to as the shape. For Wigner's matrices, this shape is $K_2$, the clique on 2 vertices. To prove our norm bounds, we use the trace power method.
In a recent series of papers by Potechin and coauthors, graph matrices played a crucial role in proving average-case lower bounds for the Sum-of-Squares (SoS) hierarchy of proof systems, one of the most powerful, but difficult to analyze, techniques in combinatorial optimization. In particular, graph matrices played a crucial role in proving that low-degree SoS cannot refute the existence of a large clique in a random graph and proving that low-degree SoS cannot prove a tight lower bound on the ground state energy of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Hamiltonian. In this paper, we give several additional applications of graph matrices. We show that for several technical lemmas in the literature, while the original analyses were quite involved, we can give direct proofs using graph matrices and our norm bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2021; v1 submitted 12 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Sum-of-squares lower bounds for planted clique
Authors:
Raghu Meka,
Aaron Potechin,
Avi Wigderson
Abstract:
Finding cliques in random graphs and the closely related "planted" clique variant, where a clique of size k is planted in a random G(n, 1/2) graph, have been the focus of substantial study in algorithm design. Despite much effort, the best known polynomial-time algorithms only solve the problem for k ~ sqrt(n).
In this paper we study the complexity of the planted clique problem under algorithms…
▽ More
Finding cliques in random graphs and the closely related "planted" clique variant, where a clique of size k is planted in a random G(n, 1/2) graph, have been the focus of substantial study in algorithm design. Despite much effort, the best known polynomial-time algorithms only solve the problem for k ~ sqrt(n).
In this paper we study the complexity of the planted clique problem under algorithms from the Sum-of-squares hierarchy. We prove the first average case lower bound for this model: for almost all graphs in G(n,1/2), r rounds of the SOS hierarchy cannot find a planted k-clique unless k > n^{1/2r} (up to logarithmic factors). Thus, for any constant number of rounds planted cliques of size n^{o(1)} cannot be found by this powerful class of algorithms. This is shown via an integrability gap for the natural formulation of maximum clique problem on random graphs for SOS and Lasserre hierarchies, which in turn follow from degree lower bounds for the Positivestellensatz proof system.
We follow the usual recipe for such proofs. First, we introduce a natural "dual certificate" (also known as a "vector-solution" or "pseudo-expectation") for the given system of polynomial equations representing the problem for every fixed input graph. Then we show that the matrix associated with this dual certificate is PSD (positive semi-definite) with high probability over the choice of the input graph.This requires the use of certain tools. One is the theory of association schemes, and in particular the eigenspaces and eigenvalues of the Johnson scheme. Another is a combinatorial method we develop to compute (via traces) norm bounds for certain random matrices whose entries are highly dependent; we hope this method will be useful elsewhere.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
A note on a problem of Erdos and Rothschild
Authors:
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
A set of $q$ triangles sharing a common edge is a called a book of size $q$. Letting $bk(G)$ denote the size of the largest book in a graph $G$, Erdős and Rothschild \cite{erdostwo} asked what the minimal value of $bk(G)$ is for graphs $G$ with $n$ vertices and a set number of edges where every edge is contained in at least one triangle. In this paper, we show that for any graph $G$ with $n$ verti…
▽ More
A set of $q$ triangles sharing a common edge is a called a book of size $q$. Letting $bk(G)$ denote the size of the largest book in a graph $G$, Erdős and Rothschild \cite{erdostwo} asked what the minimal value of $bk(G)$ is for graphs $G$ with $n$ vertices and a set number of edges where every edge is contained in at least one triangle. In this paper, we show that for any graph $G$ with $n$ vertices and $\frac{n^2}{4} - nf(n)$ edges where every edge is contained in at least one triangle, $bk(G) \geq Ω\left(\min{\{\frac{n}{\sqrt{f(n)}}, \frac{n^2}{f(n)^2}\}}\right)$.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Bounds on the Size of Sound Monotone Switching Networks Accepting Permutation Sets of Directed Trees
Authors:
Joshua Brakensiek,
Aaron Potechin
Abstract:
In this paper, we prove almost tight bounds on the size of sound monotone switching networks accepting permutations sets of directed trees. This roughly corresponds to proving almost tight bounds bounds on the monotone memory efficiency of the directed ST-connectivity problem for the special case in which the input graph is guaranteed to have no path from s to t or be isomorphic to a specific dire…
▽ More
In this paper, we prove almost tight bounds on the size of sound monotone switching networks accepting permutations sets of directed trees. This roughly corresponds to proving almost tight bounds bounds on the monotone memory efficiency of the directed ST-connectivity problem for the special case in which the input graph is guaranteed to have no path from s to t or be isomorphic to a specific directed tree.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
The critical group of a line graph
Authors:
Andrew Berget,
Andrew Manion,
Molly Maxwell,
Aaron Potechin,
Victor Reiner
Abstract:
The critical group of a graph is a finite abelian group whose order is the number of spanning forests of the graph. This paper provides three basic structural results on the critical group of a line graph.
The first deals with connected graphs containing no cut-edge. Here the number of independent cycles in the graph, which is known to bound the number of generators for the critical group of the…
▽ More
The critical group of a graph is a finite abelian group whose order is the number of spanning forests of the graph. This paper provides three basic structural results on the critical group of a line graph.
The first deals with connected graphs containing no cut-edge. Here the number of independent cycles in the graph, which is known to bound the number of generators for the critical group of the graph, is shown also to bound the number of generators for the critical group of its line graph.
The second gives, for each prime p, a constraint on the p-primary structure of the critical group, based on the largest power of p dividing all sums of degrees of two adjacent vertices.
The third deals with connected graphs whose line graph is regular. Here known results relating the number of spanning trees of the graph and of its line graph are sharpened to exact sequences which relate their critical groups.
The first two results interact extremely well with the third. For example, they imply that in a regular nonbipartite graph, the critical group of the graph and that of its line graph determine each other uniquely in a simple fashion.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2010; v1 submitted 7 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Proof of Han's Hook Expansion Conjecture
Authors:
Kevin Carde,
Joe Loubert,
Aaron Potechin,
Adrian Sanborn
Abstract:
We prove a conjecture by Guo-Niu Han which interpolates between two known hook expansion formulas.
We prove a conjecture by Guo-Niu Han which interpolates between two known hook expansion formulas.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
