-
A unified constraint formulation of immersed body techniques for coupled fluid-solid motion: continuous equations and numerical algorithms
Authors:
Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla,
Neelesh A. Patankar
Abstract:
Numerical simulation of moving immersed solid bodies in fluids is now practiced routinely following pioneering work of Peskin and co-workers on immersed boundary method (IBM), Glowinski and co-workers on fictitious domain method (FDM), and others on related methods. A variety of variants of IBM and FDM approaches have been published, most of which rely on using a background mesh for the fluid equa…
▽ More
Numerical simulation of moving immersed solid bodies in fluids is now practiced routinely following pioneering work of Peskin and co-workers on immersed boundary method (IBM), Glowinski and co-workers on fictitious domain method (FDM), and others on related methods. A variety of variants of IBM and FDM approaches have been published, most of which rely on using a background mesh for the fluid equations and tracking the solid body using Lagrangian points. The key idea that is common to these methods is to assume that the entire fluid-solid domain is a fluid and then to constrain the fluid within the solid domain to move in accordance with the solid governing equations. The immersed solid body can be rigid or deforming. Thus, in all these methods the fluid domain is extended into the solid domain. In this review, we provide a mathemarical perspective of various immersed methods by recasting the governing equations in an extended domain form for the fluid. The solid equations are used to impose appropriate constraints on the fluid that is extended into the solid domain. This leads to extended domain constrained fluid-solid governing equations that provide a unified framework for various immersed body techniques. The unified constrained governing equations in the strong form are independent of the temporal or spatial discretization schemes. We show that particular choices of time stepping and spatial discretization lead to different techniques reported in literature ranging from freely moving rigid to elastic self-propelling bodies. These techniques have wide ranging applications including aquatic locomotion, underwater vehicles, car aerodynamics, and organ physiology (e.g. cardiac flow, esophageal transport, respiratory flows), wave energy convertors, among others. We conclude with comments on outstanding challenges and future directions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Handling Neumann and Robin boundary conditions in a fictitious domain volume penalization framework
Authors:
Ramakrishnan Thirumalaisamy,
Neelesh A. Patankar,
Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla
Abstract:
Sakurai et al. (J Comput Phys, 2019) presented a flux-based volume penalization (VP) approach for imposing inhomogeneous Neumann boundary conditions on embedded interfaces. The flux-based VP method modifies the diffusion coefficient of the original elliptic (Poisson) equation and uses a flux-forcing function as a source term in the equation to impose the Neumann boundary conditions. As such, the f…
▽ More
Sakurai et al. (J Comput Phys, 2019) presented a flux-based volume penalization (VP) approach for imposing inhomogeneous Neumann boundary conditions on embedded interfaces. The flux-based VP method modifies the diffusion coefficient of the original elliptic (Poisson) equation and uses a flux-forcing function as a source term in the equation to impose the Neumann boundary conditions. As such, the flux-based VP method can be easily incorporated into existing fictitious domain codes. Sakurai et al. relied on an analytical construction of flux-forcing functions, which limits the practicality of the approach. Because of the analytical approach taken in the prior work, only (spatially) constant flux values on simple interfaces were considered. In this paper, we present a numerical technique for constructing flux-forcing functions for arbitrarily complex boundaries. The imposed flux values are also allowed to vary spatially in our approach. Furthermore, the flux-based VP method is extended to include (spatially varying) Robin boundary conditions, which makes the flux-based VP method even more general. We consider several two- and three-dimensional test examples to access the spatial accuracy of the numerical solutions. The method is also used to simulate flux-driven thermal convection in a concentric annular domain. We formally derive the flux-based volume penalized Poisson equation satisfying Neumann/Robin boundary condition in strong form; such a derivation was not presented in Sakurai et al., where the equation first appeared for the Neumann problem. The derivation reveals that the flux-based VP approach relies on a surface delta function to impose inhomogeneous Neumann/Robin boundary conditions. However, explicit construction of the delta function is not necessary for the flux-based VP method, which makes it different from other diffuse domain equations presented in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2021; v1 submitted 7 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A DLM immersed boundary method based wave-structure interaction solver for high density ratio multiphase flows
Authors:
Nishant Nangia,
Neelesh A. Patankar,
Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla
Abstract:
We present a robust immersed boundary (IB) method for high density ratio multiphase flows that is capable of modeling complex wave-structure interaction (WSI) problems arising in marine and coastal engineering applications. The IB/WSI methodology is enabled by combining the distributed Lagrange multiplier (DLM) method of Sharma and Patankar (J Comp Phys, 2005) with a robust level set method based…
▽ More
We present a robust immersed boundary (IB) method for high density ratio multiphase flows that is capable of modeling complex wave-structure interaction (WSI) problems arising in marine and coastal engineering applications. The IB/WSI methodology is enabled by combining the distributed Lagrange multiplier (DLM) method of Sharma and Patankar (J Comp Phys, 2005) with a robust level set method based multiphase flow solver. The fluid solver integrates the conservative form of the variable-coefficient incompressible Navier-Stokes equations using a hybrid preconditioner and ensures consistent transport of mass and momentum at a discrete level. The consistent transport scheme preserves the numerical stability of the method in the presence of large density ratios found in problems involving air, water, and an immersed structure. The air-water interface is captured by the level set method on an Eulerian grid, whereas the free-surface piercing immersed structure is represented on a Lagrangian mesh. The fluid-structure interaction (FSI) coupling is mediated via Peskin's regularized delta functions in an implicit manner, which obviates the need to integrate the hydrodynamic stress tensor on the complex surface of the immersed structure. The IB/WSI numerical scheme is implemented within an adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) framework, in which the Lagrangian structure and the air-water interface are embedded on the finest mesh level to capture the thin boundary layers and the vortical structures arising from WSI. We use a well-balanced force discretization for gravity force that eliminates spurious velocity currents in the hydrostatic limit due to density variation in the three phases (air, water and solid). An effective wave generation and absorption technique for a numerical wave tank is presented and used to simulate a benchmark case of water wave distortion due to a submerged structure.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2019; v1 submitted 21 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Stabilization approaches for the hyperelastic immersed boundary method for problems of large-deformation incompressible elasticity
Authors:
Ben Vadala-Roth,
Shashank Acharya,
Neelesh A Patankar,
Simone Rossi,
Boyce E Griffith
Abstract:
The immersed boundary method is a mathematical framework for modeling fluid-structure interaction. This formulation describes the momentum, viscosity, and incompressibility of the fluid-structure system in Eulerian form, and it uses Lagrangian coordinates to describe the structural deformations, stresses, and resultant forces. Integral transforms with Dirac delta function kernels connect the Euler…
▽ More
The immersed boundary method is a mathematical framework for modeling fluid-structure interaction. This formulation describes the momentum, viscosity, and incompressibility of the fluid-structure system in Eulerian form, and it uses Lagrangian coordinates to describe the structural deformations, stresses, and resultant forces. Integral transforms with Dirac delta function kernels connect the Eulerian and Lagrangian frames. The fluid and the structure are both typically treated as incompressible materials. Upon discretization, however, the incompressibility of the structure is only maintained approximately. To obtain an immersed method for incompressible hyperelastic structures that is robust under large structural deformations, we introduce a volumetric energy in the solid region that stabilizes the formulation and improves the accuracy of the numerical scheme. This formulation augments the discrete Lagrange multiplier for the incompressibility constraint, thereby improving the original method's accuracy. This volumetric energy is incorporated by decomposing the strain energy into isochoric and dilatational components, as in standard solid mechanics formulations of nearly incompressible elasticity. We study the performance of the stabilized method using several quasi-static solid mechanics benchmarks, a dynamic fluid-structure interaction benchmark, and a detailed three-dimensional model of esophageal transport. The accuracy achieved by the stabilized immersed formulation is comparable to that of a stabilized finite element method for incompressible elasticity using similar numbers of structural degrees of freedom.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2020; v1 submitted 15 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
A robust incompressible Navier-Stokes solver for high density ratio multiphase flows
Authors:
Nishant Nangia,
Boyce E. Griffith,
Neelesh A. Patankar,
Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla
Abstract:
This paper presents a robust, adaptive numerical scheme for simulating high density ratio and high shear multiphase flows on locally refined Cartesian grids that adapt to the evolving interfaces and track regions of high vorticity. The algorithm combines the interface capturing level set method with a variable-coefficient incompressible Navier-Stokes solver that is demonstrated to stably resolve m…
▽ More
This paper presents a robust, adaptive numerical scheme for simulating high density ratio and high shear multiphase flows on locally refined Cartesian grids that adapt to the evolving interfaces and track regions of high vorticity. The algorithm combines the interface capturing level set method with a variable-coefficient incompressible Navier-Stokes solver that is demonstrated to stably resolve material contrast ratios of up to six orders of magnitude. The discretization approach ensures second-order pointwise accuracy for both velocity and pressure with several physical boundary treatments, including velocity and traction boundary conditions. The paper includes several test cases that demonstrate the order of accuracy and algorithmic scalability of the flow solver. To ensure the stability of the numerical scheme in the presence of high density and viscosity ratios, we employ a consistent treatment of mass and momentum transport in the conservative form of discrete equations. This consistency is achieved by solving an additional mass balance equation, which we approximate via a strong stability preserving Runga-Kutta time integrator and by employing the same mass flux (obtained from the mass equation) in the discrete momentum equation. The scheme uses higher-order total variation diminishing (TVD) and convection-boundedness criterion (CBC) satisfying limiter to avoid numerical fluctuations in the transported density field. The high-order bounded convective transport is done on a dimension-by-dimension basis, which makes the scheme simple to implement. We also demonstrate through several test cases that the lack of consistent mass and momentum transport in non-conservative formulations, which are commonly used in practice, or the use of non-CBC satisfying limiters can yield very large numerical error and very poor accuracy for convection-dominant high density ratio flows.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2019; v1 submitted 31 August, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A moving control volume approach to computing hydrodynamic forces and torques on immersed bodies
Authors:
Nishant Nangia,
Hans Johansen,
Neelesh A. Patankar,
Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla
Abstract:
We present a moving control volume (CV) approach to computing hydrodynamic forces and torques on complex geometries. The method requires surface and volumetric integrals over a simple and regular Cartesian box that moves with an arbitrary velocity to enclose the body at all times. The moving box is aligned with Cartesian grid faces, which makes the integral evaluation straightforward in an immerse…
▽ More
We present a moving control volume (CV) approach to computing hydrodynamic forces and torques on complex geometries. The method requires surface and volumetric integrals over a simple and regular Cartesian box that moves with an arbitrary velocity to enclose the body at all times. The moving box is aligned with Cartesian grid faces, which makes the integral evaluation straightforward in an immersed boundary (IB) framework. Discontinuous and noisy derivatives of velocity and pressure at the fluid-structure interface are avoided and far-field (smooth) velocity and pressure information is used. We re-visit the approach to compute hydrodynamic forces and torques through force/torque balance equation in a Lagrangian frame that some of us took in a prior work (Bhalla et al., J Comp Phys, 2013). We prove the equivalence of the two approaches for IB methods, thanks to the use of Peskin's delta functions. Both approaches are able to suppress spurious force oscillations and are in excellent agreement, as expected theoretically. Test cases ranging from Stokes to high Reynolds number regimes are considered. We discuss regridding issues for the moving CV method in an adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) context. The proposed moving CV method is not limited to a specific IB method and can also be used, for example, with embedded boundary methods.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2017; v1 submitted 1 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Fluctuating Immersed Material (FIMAT) Dynamics for Fully Resolved Simulation of the Brownian Motion of Particles
Authors:
Yong Chen,
Neelesh A. Patankar
Abstract:
Fluctuating hydrodynamics based techniques have been developed in recent years for the simulation of Brownian motion of particles. These mesoscale simulation tools are viable approaches for problems where molecular dynamics simulations may be deemed expensive. We have developed a rigid constraint-based formulation where the key idea is to assume that the entire domain is a fluctuating fluid. Rigid…
▽ More
Fluctuating hydrodynamics based techniques have been developed in recent years for the simulation of Brownian motion of particles. These mesoscale simulation tools are viable approaches for problems where molecular dynamics simulations may be deemed expensive. We have developed a rigid constraint-based formulation where the key idea is to assume that the entire domain is a fluctuating fluid. Rigid motion constraints are then imposed in regions that are occupied by rigid particles. The resulting solution gives the Brownian motion of the particles. This approach is shown to be viable for the simulation of long time scale diffusive behavior as well as for short time scale dynamics by using two separate solution techniques. Test cases are reported to validate the approach and to establish its efficacy.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
A Minimally-Resolved Immersed Boundary Model for Reaction-Diffusion Problems
Authors:
A. Pal Singh Bhalla,
B. E. Griffith,
N. A. Patankar,
A. Donev
Abstract:
We develop an immersed-boundary approach to modeling reaction-diffusion processes in dispersions of reactive spherical particles, from the diffusion-limited to the reaction-limited setting. We represent each reactive particle with a minimally-resolved 'blob' using many fewer degrees of freedom per particle than standard discretization approaches. More complicated or more highly resolved particle s…
▽ More
We develop an immersed-boundary approach to modeling reaction-diffusion processes in dispersions of reactive spherical particles, from the diffusion-limited to the reaction-limited setting. We represent each reactive particle with a minimally-resolved 'blob' using many fewer degrees of freedom per particle than standard discretization approaches. More complicated or more highly resolved particle shapes can be built out of a collection of reactive blobs. We demonstrate numerically that the blob model can provide an accurate representation at low to moderate packing densities of the reactive particles, at a cost not much larger than solving a Poisson equation in the same domain. Unlike multipole expansion methods, our method does not require analytically-computed Green's functions, but rather, computes regularized discrete Green's functions on the fly by using a standard grid-based discretization of the Poisson equation. This allows for great flexibility in implementing different boundary conditions, coupling to fluid flow or thermal transport, and the inclusion of other effects such as temporal evolution and even nonlinearities. We develop multigrid-based preconditioners for solving the linear systems that arise when using implicit temporal discretizations or studying steady states. In the diffusion-limited case the resulting linear system is a saddle-point problem, the efficient solution of which remains a challenge for suspensions of many particles. We validate our method by comparing to published results on reaction-diffusion in ordered and disordered suspensions of reactive spheres.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2013; v1 submitted 13 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.