-
Phenotype structuring in collective cell migration:a tutorial of mathematical models and methods
Authors:
Tommaso Lorenzi,
Kevin J Painter,
Chiara Villa
Abstract:
Populations are heterogeneous, deviating in numerous ways. Phenotypic diversity refers to the range of traits or characteristics across a population, where for cells this could be the levels of signalling, movement and growth activity, etc. Clearly, the phenotypic distribution -- and how this changes over time and space -- could be a major determinant of population-level dynamics. For instance, ac…
▽ More
Populations are heterogeneous, deviating in numerous ways. Phenotypic diversity refers to the range of traits or characteristics across a population, where for cells this could be the levels of signalling, movement and growth activity, etc. Clearly, the phenotypic distribution -- and how this changes over time and space -- could be a major determinant of population-level dynamics. For instance, across a cancerous population, variations in movement, growth, and ability to evade death may determine its growth trajectory and response to therapy. In this review, we discuss how classical partial differential equation (PDE) approaches for modelling cellular systems and collective cell migration can be extended to include phenotypic structuring. The resulting non-local models -- which we refer to as phenotype-structured partial integro-differential equations (PS-PIDEs) -- form a sophisticated class of models with rich dynamics. We set the scene through a brief history of structured population modelling, and then review the extension of several classic movement models -- including the Fisher-KPP and Keller-Segel equations -- into a PS-PIDE form. We proceed with a tutorial-style section on derivation, analysis, and simulation techniques. First, we show a method to formally derive these models from underlying agent-based models. Second, we recount travelling waves in PDE models of spatial spread dynamics and concentration phenomena in non-local PDE models of evolutionary dynamics, and combine the two to deduce phenotypic structuring across travelling waves in PS-PIDE models. Third, we discuss numerical methods to simulate PS-PIDEs, illustrating with a simple scheme based on the method of lines and noting the finer points of consideration. We conclude with a discussion of future modelling and mathematical challenges.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2025; v1 submitted 17 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
The impact of different degrees of leadership on collective navigation in follower-leader systems
Authors:
Sara Bernardi,
Kevin J. Painter
Abstract:
In both animal and cell populations, the presence of leaders often underlies the success of collective migration processes, which we characterise by a group maintaining a cohesive configuration that consistently moves toward a target. We extend a recent non-local hyperbolic model for follower-leader systems to investigate different degrees of leadership. Specifically, we consider three levels of l…
▽ More
In both animal and cell populations, the presence of leaders often underlies the success of collective migration processes, which we characterise by a group maintaining a cohesive configuration that consistently moves toward a target. We extend a recent non-local hyperbolic model for follower-leader systems to investigate different degrees of leadership. Specifically, we consider three levels of leadership: indifferent leaders, who do not alter their movement according to followers; observant leaders, who attempt to remain connected with the followers, but do not allow followers to affect their desired alignment; and persuadable leaders, who integrate their attempt to reach some target with the alignment of all neighbours, both followers and leaders. A combination of analysis and numerical simulations is used to investigate under which conditions each degree of leadership allows successful collective movement to a destination. We find that the indifferent leaders' strategy can result in a cohesive and target-directed migration only for short times. Observant and persuadable leaders instead provide robust guidance, showing that the optimal leader behavior depends on the connection between the migrating individuals: if alignment is low, greater follower influence on leaders is beneficial for successful guidance; otherwise, it can be detrimental and may generate various unsuccessful swarming dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Derivation and travelling wave analysis of phenotype-structured haptotaxis models of cancer invasion
Authors:
Tommaso Lorenzi,
Fiona R. Macfarlane,
Kevin J. Painter
Abstract:
We formulate haptotaxis models of cancer invasion wherein the infiltrating cancer cells can occupy a spectrum of states in phenotype space, ranging from `fully mesenchymal' to `fully epithelial'. The more mesenchymal cells are those that display stronger haptotaxis responses and have greater capacity to modify the extracellular matrix (ECM) through enhanced secretion of matrix-degrading enzymes (M…
▽ More
We formulate haptotaxis models of cancer invasion wherein the infiltrating cancer cells can occupy a spectrum of states in phenotype space, ranging from `fully mesenchymal' to `fully epithelial'. The more mesenchymal cells are those that display stronger haptotaxis responses and have greater capacity to modify the extracellular matrix (ECM) through enhanced secretion of matrix-degrading enzymes (MDEs). However, as a trade-off, they have lower proliferative capacity than the more epithelial cells. The framework is multiscale in that we start with an individual-based model that tracks the dynamics of single cells, which is based on a branching random walk over a lattice representing both physical and phenotype space. We formally derive the corresponding continuum model, which takes the form of a coupled system comprising a partial integro-differential equation for the local cell population density function, a partial differential equation for the MDE concentration and an infinite-dimensional ordinary differential equation for the ECM density. Despite the intricacy of the model, we show, through formal asymptotic techniques, that for certain parameter regimes it is possible to carry out a detailed travelling wave analysis and obtain invading fronts with spatial structuring of phenotypes. Precisely, the most mesenchymal cells dominate the leading edge of the invasion wave and the most epithelial (and most proliferative) dominate the rear, representing a bulk tumour population. As such, the model recapitulates similar observations into a front to back structuring of invasion waves into leader-type and follower-type cells, witnessed in an increasing number of experimental studies over recent years.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024; v1 submitted 30 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Distinguishing between long-transient and asymptotic states in a biological aggregation model
Authors:
Jonathan R. Potts,
Kevin J. Painter
Abstract:
Aggregations are emergent features common to many biological systems. Mathematical models to understand their emergence are consequently widespread, with the aggregation-diffusion equation being a prime example. Here we study the aggregation-diffusion equation with linear diffusion. This equation is known to support solutions that involve both single and multiple aggregations. However, numerical e…
▽ More
Aggregations are emergent features common to many biological systems. Mathematical models to understand their emergence are consequently widespread, with the aggregation-diffusion equation being a prime example. Here we study the aggregation-diffusion equation with linear diffusion. This equation is known to support solutions that involve both single and multiple aggregations. However, numerical evidence suggests that the latter, which we term `multi-peaked solutions' may often be long-transient solutions rather than asymptotic steady states. We develop a novel technique for distinguishing between long transients and asymptotic steady states via an energy minimisation approach. The technique involves first approximating our study equation using a limiting process and a moment closure procedure. We then analyse local minimum energy states of this approximate system, hypothesising that these will correspond to asymptotic patterns in the aggregation-diffusion equation. Finally, we verify our hypotheses through numerical investigation, showing that our approximate analytic technique gives good predictions as to whether a state is asymptotic or a long transient. Overall, we find that almost all twin-peaked, and by extension multi-peaked, solutions are transient, except for some very special cases. We demonstrate numerically that these transients can be arbitrarily long-lived, depending on the parameters of the system.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
On the study of slow-fast dynamics, when the fast process has multiple invariant measures
Authors:
B. D. Goddard,
M. Ottobre,
K. J. Painter,
I. Souttar
Abstract:
Motivated by applications to mathematical biology, we study the averaging problem for slow-fast systems, {\em in the case in which the fast dynamics is a stochastic process with multiple invariant measures}. We consider both the case in which the fast process is decoupled from the slow process and the case in which the two components are fully coupled. We work in the setting in which the slow proc…
▽ More
Motivated by applications to mathematical biology, we study the averaging problem for slow-fast systems, {\em in the case in which the fast dynamics is a stochastic process with multiple invariant measures}. We consider both the case in which the fast process is decoupled from the slow process and the case in which the two components are fully coupled. We work in the setting in which the slow process evolves according to an Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) and the fast process is a continuous time Markov Process with finite state space and show that, in this setting, the limiting (averaged) dynamics can be described as a random ODE (that is, an ODE with random coefficients.)
Keywords. Multiscale methods, Processes with multiple equilibria, Averaging, Collective Navigation, Interacting Piecewise Deterministic Markov Processes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2023; v1 submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Phenotype switching in chemotaxis aggregation models controls the spontaneous emergence of large densities
Authors:
Kevin J Painter,
Michael Winkler
Abstract:
We consider a phenotype-switching chemotaxis model for aggregation, in which a chemotactic population is capable of switching back and forth between a chemotaxing state (performing chemotactic movement) and a secreting state (producing the attractant). We show that the switching rate provides a powerful mechanism for controlling the densities of spontaneously emerging aggregates. Specifically, in…
▽ More
We consider a phenotype-switching chemotaxis model for aggregation, in which a chemotactic population is capable of switching back and forth between a chemotaxing state (performing chemotactic movement) and a secreting state (producing the attractant). We show that the switching rate provides a powerful mechanism for controlling the densities of spontaneously emerging aggregates. Specifically, in two- and three-dimensional settings it is shown that when both switching rates coincide and are suitably large, then the densities of both the chemotaxing and the secreting population will exceed any prescribed level at some points in the considered domain. This is complemented by two results asserting the absence of such aggregation phenomena in corresponding scenarios in which one of the switching rates remains within some bounded interval.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The impact of phenotypic heterogeneity on chemotactic self-organisation
Authors:
Fiona R Macfarlane,
Tommaso Lorenzi,
Kevin J Painter
Abstract:
The capacity to aggregate through chemosensitive movement forms a paradigm of self-organisation, with examples spanning cellular and animal systems. A basic mechanism assumes a phenotypically homogeneous population that secretes its own attractant, with the well known system introduced more than five decades ago by Keller and Segel proving resolutely popular in modelling studies. The typical assum…
▽ More
The capacity to aggregate through chemosensitive movement forms a paradigm of self-organisation, with examples spanning cellular and animal systems. A basic mechanism assumes a phenotypically homogeneous population that secretes its own attractant, with the well known system introduced more than five decades ago by Keller and Segel proving resolutely popular in modelling studies. The typical assumption of population phenotypic homogeneity, however, often lies at odds with the heterogeneity of natural systems, where populations may comprise distinct phenotypes that vary according to their chemotactic ability, attractant secretion, {\it etc}. To initiate an understanding into how this diversity can impact on autoaggregation, we propose a simple extension to the classical Keller and Segel model, in which the population is divided into two distinct phenotypes: those performing chemotaxis and those producing attractant. Using a combination of linear stability analysis and numerical simulations, we demonstrate that switching between these phenotypic states alters the capacity of a population to self-aggregate. Further, we show that switching based on the local environment (population density or chemoattractant level) leads to diverse patterning and provides a route through which a population can effectively curb the size and density of an aggregate. We discuss the results in the context of real world examples of chemotactic aggregation, as well as theoretical aspects of the model such as global existence and blow-up of solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2022; v1 submitted 29 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Non-mean-field Vicsek-type models for collective behaviour
Authors:
P. Buttà,
B. Goddard,
T. M. Hodgson,
M. Ottobre,
K. J. Painter
Abstract:
We consider interacting particle dynamics with Vicsek type interactions, and their macroscopic PDE limit, in the non-mean-field regime; that is, we consider the case in which each particle/agent in the system interacts only with a prescribed subset of the particles in the system (for example, those within a certain distance). In this non-mean-field regime the influence between agents (i.e. the int…
▽ More
We consider interacting particle dynamics with Vicsek type interactions, and their macroscopic PDE limit, in the non-mean-field regime; that is, we consider the case in which each particle/agent in the system interacts only with a prescribed subset of the particles in the system (for example, those within a certain distance). In this non-mean-field regime the influence between agents (i.e. the interaction term) can be normalised either by the total number of agents in the system (\textit{global scaling}) or by the number of agents with which the particle is effectively interacting (\textit{local scaling}). We compare the behaviour of the globally scaled and the locally scaled systems in many respects, considering for each scaling both the PDE and the corresponding particle model. In particular we observe that both the locally and globally scaled particle system exhibit pattern formation (i.e. formation of travelling-wave-like solutions) within certain parameter regimes, and generally display similar dynamics. The same is not true of the corresponding PDE models. Indeed, while both PDE models have multiple stationary states, for the globally scaled PDE such (space-homogeneous) equilibria are unstable for certain parameter regimes, with the instability leading to travelling wave solutions, while they are always stable for the locally scaled one, which never produces travelling waves. This observation is based on a careful numerical study of the model, supported by further analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Leadership through influence: what mechanisms allow leaders to steer a swarm?
Authors:
Sara Bernardi,
Raluca Eftimie,
Kevin J. Painter
Abstract:
Collective migration of cells and animals often relies on a specialised set of "leaders", whose role is to steer a population of naive followers towards some target. We formulate a continuous model to understand the dynamics and structure of such groups, splitting a population into separate follower and leader types with distinct orientation responses. We incorporate "leader influence" via three p…
▽ More
Collective migration of cells and animals often relies on a specialised set of "leaders", whose role is to steer a population of naive followers towards some target. We formulate a continuous model to understand the dynamics and structure of such groups, splitting a population into separate follower and leader types with distinct orientation responses. We incorporate "leader influence" via three principal mechanisms: a bias in the orientation of leaders according to the destination, distinct speeds of movement and distinct levels of conspicuousness. Using a combination of analysis and numerical computation on a sequence of models of increasing complexity, we assess the extent to which leaders successfully shepherd the swarm. While all three mechanisms can lead to a successfully steered swarm, parameter regime is crucial with non successful choices generating a variety of unsuccessful attempts, including movement away from the target, swarm splitting or swarm dispersal.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Macroscopic descriptions of follower-leader systems
Authors:
Sara Bernardi,
Gissell Estrada-Rodriguez,
Heiko Gimperlein,
Kevin J. Painter
Abstract:
The fundamental derivation of macroscopic model equations to describe swarms based on microscopic movement laws and mathematical analyses into their self-organisation capabilities remains a challenge from the perspective of both modelling and analysis. In this paper we clarify relevant continuous macroscopic model equations that describe follower-leader interactions for a swarm where these two pop…
▽ More
The fundamental derivation of macroscopic model equations to describe swarms based on microscopic movement laws and mathematical analyses into their self-organisation capabilities remains a challenge from the perspective of both modelling and analysis. In this paper we clarify relevant continuous macroscopic model equations that describe follower-leader interactions for a swarm where these two populations are fixed. We study the behaviour of the swarm over long and short time scales to shed light on the number of leaders needed to initiate swarm movement, according to the homogeneous or inhomogeneous nature of the interaction (alignment) kernel. The results indicate the crucial role played by the interaction kernel to model transient behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2021; v1 submitted 1 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Space-time fractional diffusion in cell movement models with delay
Authors:
Gissell Estrada-Rodriguez,
Heiko Gimperlein,
Kevin J. Painter,
Jakub Stocek
Abstract:
The movement of organisms and cells can be governed by occasional long distance runs, according to an approximate Lévy walk. For T cells migrating through chronically-infected brain tissue, runs are further interrupted by long pauses, and the aim here is to clarify the form of continuous model equations which describe such movements. Starting from a microscopic velocity-jump model based on experim…
▽ More
The movement of organisms and cells can be governed by occasional long distance runs, according to an approximate Lévy walk. For T cells migrating through chronically-infected brain tissue, runs are further interrupted by long pauses, and the aim here is to clarify the form of continuous model equations which describe such movements. Starting from a microscopic velocity-jump model based on experimental observations, we include power-law distributions of run and waiting times and investigate the relevant parabolic limit from a kinetic equation for resting and moving individuals. In biologically relevant regimes we derive nonlocal diffusion equations, including fractional Laplacians in space and fractional time derivatives. Its analysis and numerical experiments shed light on how the searching strategy, and the impact from chemokinesis responses to chemokines, shorten the average time taken to find rare targets in the absence of direct guidance information such as chemotaxis.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2018; v1 submitted 23 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Fractional Patlak-Keller-Segel equations for chemotactic superdiffusion
Authors:
Gissell Estrada-Rodriguez,
Heiko Gimperlein,
Kevin J. Painter
Abstract:
The long range movement of certain organisms in the presence of a chemoattractant can be governed by long distance runs, according to an approximate Levy distribution. This article clarifies the form of biologically relevant model equations: We derive Patlak-Keller-Segel-like equations involving nonlocal, fractional Laplacians from a microscopic model for cell movement. Starting from a power-law d…
▽ More
The long range movement of certain organisms in the presence of a chemoattractant can be governed by long distance runs, according to an approximate Levy distribution. This article clarifies the form of biologically relevant model equations: We derive Patlak-Keller-Segel-like equations involving nonlocal, fractional Laplacians from a microscopic model for cell movement. Starting from a power-law distribution of run times, we derive a kinetic equation in which the collision term takes into account the long range behaviour of the individuals. A fractional chemotactic equation is obtained in a biologically relevant regime. Apart from chemotaxis, our work has implications for biological diffusion in numerous processes.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2018; v1 submitted 9 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Travelling waves in hybrid chemotaxis models
Authors:
Benjamin Franz,
Chuan Xue,
Kevin J. Painter,
Radek Erban
Abstract:
Hybrid models of chemotaxis combine agent-based models of cells with partial differential equation models of extracellular chemical signals. In this paper, travelling wave properties of hybrid models of bacterial chemotaxis are investigated. Bacteria are modelled using an agent-based (individual-based) approach with internal dynamics describing signal transduction. In addition to the chemotactic b…
▽ More
Hybrid models of chemotaxis combine agent-based models of cells with partial differential equation models of extracellular chemical signals. In this paper, travelling wave properties of hybrid models of bacterial chemotaxis are investigated. Bacteria are modelled using an agent-based (individual-based) approach with internal dynamics describing signal transduction. In addition to the chemotactic behaviour of the bacteria, the individual-based model also includes cell proliferation and death. Cells consume the extracellular nutrient field (chemoattractant) which is modelled using a partial differential equation. Mesoscopic and macroscopic equations representing the behaviour of the hybrid model are derived and the existence of travelling wave solutions for these models is established. It is shown that cell proliferation is necessary for the existence of non-transient (stationary) travelling waves in hybrid models. Additionally, a numerical comparison between the wave speeds of the continuum models and the hybrid models shows good agreement in the case of weak chemotaxis and qualitative agreement for the strong chemotaxis case. In the case of slow cell adaptation, we detect oscillating behaviour of the wave, which cannot be explained by mean-field approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
