Showing 1–18 of 18 results for author: Paccagnan, D

Integrated Balanced and Staggered Routing in Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand Systems

Authors: Antonio Coppola, Gerhard Hiermann, Dario Paccagnan, Michel Gendreau, Maximilian Schiffer

Abstract: Autonomous mobility-on-demand (AMoD) systems, centrally coordinated fleets of self-driving vehicles, offer a promising alternative to traditional ride-hailing by improving traffic flow and reducing operating costs. Centralized control in AMoD systems enables two complementary routing strategies: balanced routing, which distributes traffic across alternative routes to ease congestion, and staggered… ▽ More Autonomous mobility-on-demand (AMoD) systems, centrally coordinated fleets of self-driving vehicles, offer a promising alternative to traditional ride-hailing by improving traffic flow and reducing operating costs. Centralized control in AMoD systems enables two complementary routing strategies: balanced routing, which distributes traffic across alternative routes to ease congestion, and staggered routing, which delays departures to smooth peak demand over time. In this work, we introduce a unified framework that jointly optimizes both route choices and departure times to minimize system travel times. We formulate the problem as an optimization model and show that our congestion model yields an unbiased estimate of travel times derived from a discretized version of Vickrey's bottleneck model. To solve large-scale instances, we develop a custom metaheuristic based on a large neighborhood search framework. We assess our method through a case study on the Manhattan street network using real-world taxi data. In a setting with exclusively centrally controlled AMoD vehicles, our approach reduces total traffic delay by up to 25 percent and mitigates network congestion by up to 35 percent compared to selfish routing. We also consider mixed-traffic settings with both AMoD and conventional vehicles, comparing a welfare-oriented operator that minimizes total system travel time with a profit-oriented one that optimizes only the fleet's travel time. Independent of the operator's objective, the analysis reveals a win-win outcome: across all control levels, both autonomous and non-autonomous traffic benefit from the implementation of balancing and staggering strategies. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2025; originally announced June 2025.

Multi-Agent Q-Learning Dynamics in Random Networks: Convergence due to Exploration and Sparsity

Authors: Aamal Hussain, Dan Leonte, Francesco Belardinelli, Raphael Huser, Dario Paccagnan

Abstract: Beyond specific settings, many multi-agent learning algorithms fail to converge to an equilibrium solution, and instead display complex, non-stationary behaviours such as recurrent or chaotic orbits. In fact, recent literature suggests that such complex behaviours are likely to occur when the number of agents increases. In this paper, we study Q-learning dynamics in network polymatrix games where… ▽ More Beyond specific settings, many multi-agent learning algorithms fail to converge to an equilibrium solution, and instead display complex, non-stationary behaviours such as recurrent or chaotic orbits. In fact, recent literature suggests that such complex behaviours are likely to occur when the number of agents increases. In this paper, we study Q-learning dynamics in network polymatrix games where the network structure is drawn from classical random graph models. In particular, we focus on the Erdos-Renyi model, a well-studied model for social networks, and the Stochastic Block model, which generalizes the above by accounting for community structures within the network. In each setting, we establish sufficient conditions under which the agents' joint strategies converge to a unique equilibrium. We investigate how this condition depends on the exploration rates, payoff matrices and, crucially, the sparsity of the network. Finally, we validate our theoretical findings through numerical simulations and demonstrate that convergence can be reliably achieved in many-agent systems, provided network sparsity is controlled. △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2025; originally announced March 2025.

MSC Class: 93A16; 91A26; 91A68; 58K35 ACM Class: G.3; J.4; F.2.2

Staggered Routing in Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand Systems

Authors: Antonio Coppola, Gerhard Hiermann, Dario Paccagnan, Maximilian Schiffer

Abstract: In autonomous mobility-on-demand systems, effectively managing vehicle flows to mitigate induced congestion and ensure efficient operations is imperative for system performance and positive customer experience. Against this background, we study the potential of staggered routing, i.e., purposely delaying trip departures from a system perspective, in order to reduce congestion and ensure efficient… ▽ More In autonomous mobility-on-demand systems, effectively managing vehicle flows to mitigate induced congestion and ensure efficient operations is imperative for system performance and positive customer experience. Against this background, we study the potential of staggered routing, i.e., purposely delaying trip departures from a system perspective, in order to reduce congestion and ensure efficient operations while still meeting customer time windows. We formalize the underlying planning problem and show how to efficiently model it as a mixed integer linear program. Moreover, we present a matheuristic that allows us to efficiently solve large-scale real-world instances both in an offline full-information setting and its online rolling horizon counterpart. We conduct a numerical study for Manhattan, New York City, focusing on low- and highly-congested scenarios. Our results show that in low-congestion scenarios, staggering trip departures allows mitigating, on average, 94% of the induced congestion in a full information setting. In a rolling horizon setting, our algorithm allows us to reduce 90% of the induced congestion. In high-congestion scenarios, we observe an average reduction of 66% as the full information bound and an average reduction of 56% in our online setting. Surprisingly, we show that these reductions can be reached by shifting trip departures by a maximum of six minutes in both the low and high-congestion scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 32 pages, 10 figures

Fair Interventions in Weighted Congestion Games

Authors: Miriam Fischer, Martin Gairing, Dario Paccagnan

Abstract: In this work we study the power and limitations of fair interventions in weighted congestion games. Specifically, we focus on interventions that aim at improving the equilibrium quality (price of anarchy) and are fair in a suitably defined sense. Within this setting, we provide three key contributions. First, we show that no fair intervention can reduce the price of anarchy below a given factor de… ▽ More In this work we study the power and limitations of fair interventions in weighted congestion games. Specifically, we focus on interventions that aim at improving the equilibrium quality (price of anarchy) and are fair in a suitably defined sense. Within this setting, we provide three key contributions. First, we show that no fair intervention can reduce the price of anarchy below a given factor depending solely on the class of latencies considered. Interestingly, this lower bound is unconditional, i.e., it applies regardless of how much computation interventions are allowed to use. Second, we design a taxation mechanism that is fair and achieves a price of anarchy matching this unconditional lower bound, all the while being polynomial-time computable. Third, we show that no intervention (fair or not) can achieve a better approximation if polynomial computability is required. We do so by proving that the minimum social cost is NP-hard to minimize below a factor identical to the one previously introduced. In doing so, our work shows that the algorithm proposed by Makarychev and Sviridenko (Journal of the ACM, 2018) to tackle optimization problems with a "diseconomy of scale" is optimal, and provide a novel way to derandomize its solution via equilibrium computation. △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2024; v1 submitted 28 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Model-free False Data Injection Attack in Networked Control Systems: A Feedback Optimization Approach

Authors: Xiaoyu Luo, Chongrong Fang, Jianping He, Chengcheng Zhao, Dario Paccagnan

Abstract: Security issues have gathered growing interest within the control systems community, as physical components and communication networks are increasingly vulnerable to cyber attacks. In this context, recent literature has studied increasingly sophisticated \emph{false data injection} attacks, with the aim to design mitigative measures that improve the systems' security. Notably, data-driven attack s… ▽ More Security issues have gathered growing interest within the control systems community, as physical components and communication networks are increasingly vulnerable to cyber attacks. In this context, recent literature has studied increasingly sophisticated \emph{false data injection} attacks, with the aim to design mitigative measures that improve the systems' security. Notably, data-driven attack strategies -- whereby the system dynamics is oblivious to the adversary -- have received increasing attention. However, many of the existing works on the topic rely on the implicit assumption of linear system dynamics, significantly limiting their scope. Contrary to that, in this work we design and analyze \emph{truly} model-free false data injection attack that applies to general linear and nonlinear systems. More specifically, we aim at designing an injected signal that steers the output of the system toward a (maliciously chosen) trajectory. We do so by designing a zeroth-order feedback optimization policy and jointly use probing signals for real-time measurements. We then characterize the quality of the proposed model-free attack through its optimality gap, which is affected by the dimensions of the attack signal, the number of iterations performed, and the convergence rate of the system. Finally, we extend the proposed attack scheme to the systems with internal noise. Extensive simulations show the effectiveness of the proposed attack scheme. △ Less

Submitted 21 August, 2023; v1 submitted 15 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Online Traffic Routing: Deterministic Limits and Data-driven Enhancements

Authors: Devansh Jalota, Dario Paccagnan, Maximilian Schiffer, Marco Pavone

Abstract: Over the past decade, GPS enabled traffic applications, such as Google Maps and Waze, have become ubiquitous and have had a significant influence on billions of daily commuters' travel patterns. A consequence of the online route suggestions of such applications, e.g., via greedy routing, has often been an increase in traffic congestion since the induced travel patterns may be far from the system o… ▽ More Over the past decade, GPS enabled traffic applications, such as Google Maps and Waze, have become ubiquitous and have had a significant influence on billions of daily commuters' travel patterns. A consequence of the online route suggestions of such applications, e.g., via greedy routing, has often been an increase in traffic congestion since the induced travel patterns may be far from the system optimum. Spurred by the widespread impact of traffic applications on travel patterns, this work studies online traffic routing in the context of capacity-constrained parallel road networks and analyzes this problem from two perspectives. First, we perform a worst-case analysis to identify the limits of deterministic online routing and show that the ratio between the total travel cost of the online solution of any deterministic algorithm and that of the optimal offline solution is unbounded, even in simple settings. This result motivates us to move beyond worst-case analysis. Here, we consider algorithms that exploit knowledge of past problem instances and show how to design data-driven algorithms whose performance can be quantified and formally generalized to unseen future instances. We present numerical experiments based on an application case for the San Francisco Bay Area to evaluate the performance of our approach. Our results show that the data-driven algorithms we develop outperform commonly used greedy online-routing algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

In Congestion Games, Taxes Achieve Optimal Approximation

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Martin Gairing

Abstract: In this work, we consider the problem of minimising the social cost in atomic congestion games. For this problem, we provide tight computational lower bounds along with taxation mechanisms yielding polynomial time algorithms with optimal approximation. Perhaps surprisingly, our results show that indirect interventions, in the form of efficiently computed taxation mechanisms, yield the same perfo… ▽ More In this work, we consider the problem of minimising the social cost in atomic congestion games. For this problem, we provide tight computational lower bounds along with taxation mechanisms yielding polynomial time algorithms with optimal approximation. Perhaps surprisingly, our results show that indirect interventions, in the form of efficiently computed taxation mechanisms, yield the same performance achievable by the best polynomial time algorithm, even when the latter has full control over the agents' actions. It follows that no other tractable approach geared at incentivizing desirable system behavior can improve upon this result, regardless of whether it is based on taxations, coordination mechanisms, information provision, or any other principle. In short: Judiciously chosen taxes achieve optimal approximation. Three technical contributions underpin this conclusion. First, we show that computing the minimum social cost is NP-hard to approximate within a given factor depending solely on the admissible resource costs. Second, we design a tractable taxation mechanism whose efficiency (price of anarchy) matches this hardness factor, and thus is worst-case optimal. As these results extend to coarse correlated equilibria, any no-regret algorithm inherits the same performances, allowing us to devise polynomial time algorithms with optimal approximation. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2022; v1 submitted 16 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: A preliminary version of this work appeared at the 22nd ACM Conference on Economics & Computation (EC'21)

Stochastic Strategies for Robotic Surveillance as Stackelberg Games

Authors: Xiaoming Duan, Dario Paccagnan, Francesco Bullo

Abstract: This paper studies a stochastic robotic surveillance problem where a mobile robot moves randomly on a graph to capture a potential intruder that strategically attacks a location on the graph. The intruder is assumed to be omniscient: it knows the current location of the mobile agent and can learn the surveillance strategy. The goal for the mobile robot is to design a stochastic strategy so as to m… ▽ More This paper studies a stochastic robotic surveillance problem where a mobile robot moves randomly on a graph to capture a potential intruder that strategically attacks a location on the graph. The intruder is assumed to be omniscient: it knows the current location of the mobile agent and can learn the surveillance strategy. The goal for the mobile robot is to design a stochastic strategy so as to maximize the probability of capturing the intruder. We model the strategic interactions between the surveillance robot and the intruder as a Stackelberg game, and optimal and suboptimal Markov chain based surveillance strategies in star, complete and line graphs are studied. We first derive a universal upper bound on the capture probability, i.e., the performance limit for the surveillance agent. We show that this upper bound is tight in the complete graph and further provide suboptimality guarantees for a natural design. For the star and line graphs, we first characterize dominant strategies for the surveillance agent and the intruder. Then, we rigorously prove the optimal strategy for the surveillance agent. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Assign and Appraise: Achieving Optimal Performance in Collaborative Teams

Authors: Elizabeth Y. Huang, Dario Paccagnan, Wenjun Mei, Francesco Bullo

Abstract: Tackling complex team problems requires understanding each team member's skills in order to devise a task assignment maximizing the team performance. This paper proposes a novel quantitative model describing the decentralized process by which individuals in a team learn who has what abilities, while concurrently assigning tasks to each of the team members. In the model, the appraisal network repre… ▽ More Tackling complex team problems requires understanding each team member's skills in order to devise a task assignment maximizing the team performance. This paper proposes a novel quantitative model describing the decentralized process by which individuals in a team learn who has what abilities, while concurrently assigning tasks to each of the team members. In the model, the appraisal network represents team member's evaluations of one another and each team member chooses their own workload. The appraisals and workload assignment change simultaneously: each member builds their own local appraisal of neighboring members based on the performance exhibited on previous tasks, while the workload is redistributed based on the current appraisal estimates. We show that the appraisal states can be reduced to a lower dimension due to the presence of conserved quantities associated to the cycles of the appraisal network. Building on this, we provide rigorous results characterizing the ability, or inability, of the team to learn each other's skill and thus converge to an allocation maximizing the team performance. We complement our analysis with extensive numerical experiments. △ Less

Submitted 22 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Optimal Taxes in Atomic Congestion Games

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Rahul Chandan, Bryce L Ferguson, Jason R Marden

Abstract: How can we design mechanisms to promote efficient use of shared resources? Here, we answer this question in relation to the well-studied class of atomic congestion games, used to model a variety of problems, including traffic routing. Within this context, a methodology for designing tolling mechanisms that minimize the system inefficiency (price of anarchy) exploiting solely local information is s… ▽ More How can we design mechanisms to promote efficient use of shared resources? Here, we answer this question in relation to the well-studied class of atomic congestion games, used to model a variety of problems, including traffic routing. Within this context, a methodology for designing tolling mechanisms that minimize the system inefficiency (price of anarchy) exploiting solely local information is so far missing in spite of the scientific interest. In this manuscript we resolve this problem through a tractable linear programming formulation that applies to and beyond polynomial congestion games. When specializing our approach to the polynomial case, we obtain tight values for the optimal price of anarchy and corresponding tolls, uncovering an unexpected link with load balancing games. We also derive optimal tolling mechanisms that are constant with the congestion level, generalizing the results of Caragiannis et al. [ACM Transactions on Algorithms, 2010] to polynomial congestion games and beyond. Finally, we apply our techniques to compute the efficiency of the marginal cost mechanism. Surprisingly, optimal tolling mechanism using only local information perform closely to existing mechanism that utilize global information [Bilò and Vinci, ACM Transactions on Economics and Computation, 2019], while the marginal cost mechanism, known to be optimal in the continuous-flow model, has lower efficiency than that encountered levying no toll. All results are tight for pure Nash equilibria, and extend to coarse correlated equilibria. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2021; v1 submitted 21 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: To appear in ACM Transactions on Economics and Computation, 32 pages, 5 figures

The scenario approach meets uncertain variational inequalities and game theory

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Marco C. Campi

Abstract: Variational inequalities are modelling tools used to capture a variety of decision-making problems arising in mathematical optimization, operations research, game theory. The scenario approach is a set of techniques developed to tackle stochastic optimization problems, take decisions based on historical data, and quantify their risk. The overarching goal of this manuscript is to bridge these two a… ▽ More Variational inequalities are modelling tools used to capture a variety of decision-making problems arising in mathematical optimization, operations research, game theory. The scenario approach is a set of techniques developed to tackle stochastic optimization problems, take decisions based on historical data, and quantify their risk. The overarching goal of this manuscript is to bridge these two areas of research, and thus broaden the class of problems amenable to be studied under the lens of the scenario approach. First and foremost, we provide out-of-samples feasibility guarantees for the solution of variational and quasi variational inequality problems. Second, we apply these results to two classes of uncertain games. In the first class, the uncertainty enters in the constraint sets, while in the second class the uncertainty enters in the cost functions. Finally, we exemplify the quality and relevance of our bounds through numerical simulations on a demand-response model. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures

Distributed control and game design: From strategic agents to programmable machines

Authors: Dario Paccagnan

Abstract: Large scale systems are forecasted to greatly impact our future lives thanks to their wide ranging applications including cooperative robotics, mobility on demand, resource allocation, supply chain management. While technological developments have paved the way for the realization of such futuristic systems, we have a limited grasp on how to coordinate the individual components to achieve the desi… ▽ More Large scale systems are forecasted to greatly impact our future lives thanks to their wide ranging applications including cooperative robotics, mobility on demand, resource allocation, supply chain management. While technological developments have paved the way for the realization of such futuristic systems, we have a limited grasp on how to coordinate the individual components to achieve the desired global objective. This thesis deals with the analysis and coordination of large scale systems without the need of a centralized authority. In the first part of this thesis, we consider non-cooperative decision making problems where each agent's objective is a function of the aggregate behavior of the population. First, we compare the performance of an equilibrium allocation with that of an optimal allocation and propose conditions under which all equilibrium allocations are efficient. Towards this goal, we prove a novel result bounding the distance between the strategies at a Nash and Wardrop equilibrium that might be of independent interest. Second, we show how to derive scalable algorithms that guide agents towards an equilibrium allocation. In the second part of this thesis, we consider large-scale cooperative problems, where a number of agents need to be allocated to a set of resources with the goal of jointly maximizing a given submodular or supermodular set function. Since this class of problems is computationally intractable, we aim at deriving tractable algorithms for attaining approximate solutions. We approach the problem from a game-theoretic perspective and ask the following: how should we design agents' utilities so that any equilibrium configuration is almost optimal? To answer this question we introduce a novel framework that allows to characterize and optimize the system performance as a function of the chosen utilities by means of a tractable linear program. △ Less

Submitted 18 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: PhD Thesis, ETH Zurich

Utility Design for Distributed Resource Allocation -- Part II: Applications to Submodular, Covering, and Supermodular Problems

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Jason R. Marden

Abstract: A fundamental component of the game theoretic approach to distributed control is the design of local utility functions.Relative to resource allocation problems that are additive over the resources, Part I showed how to design local utilities so as to maximize the associated performance guarantees [Paccagnan et al., TAC 2019] which we measure by the price of anarchy. The purpose of the present manu… ▽ More A fundamental component of the game theoretic approach to distributed control is the design of local utility functions.Relative to resource allocation problems that are additive over the resources, Part I showed how to design local utilities so as to maximize the associated performance guarantees [Paccagnan et al., TAC 2019] which we measure by the price of anarchy. The purpose of the present manuscript is to specialize these results to the case of submodular, covering, and supermodular problems. In all these cases we obtain tight expressions for the price of anarchy that often match or improve the guarantees associated to state-of-the-art approximation algorithms. Two applications and corresponding numerics are presented: the vehicle-target assignment problem and a coverage problem arising in wireless data caching. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2021; v1 submitted 3 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 15 pages, 10 figures

Utility Design for Distributed Resource Allocation -- Part I: Characterizing and Optimizing the Exact Price of Anarchy

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Rahul Chandan, Jason R. Marden

Abstract: Game theory has emerged as a fruitful paradigm for the design of networked multiagent systems. A fundamental component of this approach is the design of agents' utility functions so that their self-interested maximization results in a desirable collective behavior. In this work we focus on a well-studied class of distributed resource allocation problems where each agent is requested to select a su… ▽ More Game theory has emerged as a fruitful paradigm for the design of networked multiagent systems. A fundamental component of this approach is the design of agents' utility functions so that their self-interested maximization results in a desirable collective behavior. In this work we focus on a well-studied class of distributed resource allocation problems where each agent is requested to select a subset of resources with the goal of optimizing a given system-level objective. Our core contribution is the development of a novel framework to tightly characterize the worst case performance of any resulting Nash equilibrium (price of anarchy) as a function of the chosen agents' utility functions. Leveraging this result, we identify how to design such utilities so as to optimize the price of anarchy through a tractable linear program. This provides us with a priori performance certificates applicable to any existing learning algorithm capable of driving the system to an equilibrium. Part II of this work specializes these results to submodular and supermodular objectives, discusses the complexity of computing Nash equilibria, and provides multiple illustrations of the theoretical findings. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2019; v1 submitted 3 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures

On the Efficiency of Nash Equilibria in Aggregative Charging Games

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Francesca Parise, John Lygeros

Abstract: Several works have recently suggested to model the problem of coordinating the charging needs of a fleet of electric vehicles as a game, and have proposed distributed algorithms to coordinate the vehicles towards a Nash equilibrium of such game. However, Nash equilibria have been shown to posses desirable system-level properties only in simplified cases. In this work, we use the concept of price o… ▽ More Several works have recently suggested to model the problem of coordinating the charging needs of a fleet of electric vehicles as a game, and have proposed distributed algorithms to coordinate the vehicles towards a Nash equilibrium of such game. However, Nash equilibria have been shown to posses desirable system-level properties only in simplified cases. In this work, we use the concept of price of anarchy to analyze the inefficiency of Nash equilibria when compared to the social optimum solution. More precisely, we show that i) for linear price functions depending on all the charging instants, the price of anarchy converges to one as the population of vehicles grows; ii) for price functions that depend only on the instantaneous demand, the price of anarchy converges to one if the price function takes the form of a positive pure monomial; iii) for general classes of price functions, the asymptotic price of anarchy can be bounded. For finite populations, we additionaly provide a bound on the price of anarchy as a function of the number vehicles in the system. We support the theoretical findings by means of numerical simulations. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2018; v1 submitted 7 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 2 figures

The Importance of System-Level Information in Multiagent Systems Design: Cardinality and Covering Problems

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Jason R. Marden

Abstract: A fundamental challenge in multiagent systems is to design local control algorithms to ensure a desirable collective behaviour. The information available to the agents, gathered either through communication or sensing, naturally restricts the achievable performance. Hence, it is fundamental to identify what piece of information is valuable and can be exploited to design control laws with enhanced… ▽ More A fundamental challenge in multiagent systems is to design local control algorithms to ensure a desirable collective behaviour. The information available to the agents, gathered either through communication or sensing, naturally restricts the achievable performance. Hence, it is fundamental to identify what piece of information is valuable and can be exploited to design control laws with enhanced performance guarantees. This paper studies the case when such information is uncertain or inaccessible for a class of submodular resource allocation problems termed covering problems. In the first part of this work we pinpoint a fundamental risk-reward tradeoff faced by the system operator when conditioning the control design on a valuable but uncertain piece of information, which we refer to as the cardinality, that represents the maximum number of agents that can simultaneously select any given resource. Building on this analysis, we propose a distributed algorithm that allows agents to learn the cardinality while adjusting their behaviour over time. This algorithm is proved to perform on par or better to the optimal design obtained when the exact cardinality is known a priori. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2018; v1 submitted 20 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, double column, 7 figures

Multiagent Maximum Coverage Problems: The Trade-off Between Anarchy and Stability

Authors: Vinod Ramaswamy, Dario Paccagnan, Jason R. Marden

Abstract: The price of anarchy and price of stability are three well-studied performance metrics that seek to characterize the inefficiency of equilibria in distributed systems. The distinction between these two performance metrics centers on the equilibria that they focus on: the price of anarchy characterizes the quality of the worst-performing equilibria, while the price of stability characterizes the qu… ▽ More The price of anarchy and price of stability are three well-studied performance metrics that seek to characterize the inefficiency of equilibria in distributed systems. The distinction between these two performance metrics centers on the equilibria that they focus on: the price of anarchy characterizes the quality of the worst-performing equilibria, while the price of stability characterizes the quality of the best-performing equilibria. While much of the literature focuses on these metrics from an analysis perspective, in this work we consider these performance metrics from a design perspective. Specifically, we focus on the setting where a system operator is tasked with designing local utility functions to optimize these performance metrics in a class of games termed covering games. Our main result characterizes a fundamental trade-off between the price of anarchy and price of stability in the form of a fully explicit Pareto frontier. Within this setup, optimizing the price of anarchy comes directly at the expense of the price of stability (and vice versa). Our second results demonstrates how a system-operator could incorporate an additional piece of system-level information into the design of the agents' utility functions to breach these limitations and improve the system's performance. This valuable piece of system-level information pertains to the performance of worst performing agent in the system. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2020; v1 submitted 3 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, 4 figures

Nash and Wardrop equilibria in aggregative games with coupling constraints

Authors: Dario Paccagnan, Basilio Gentile, Francesca Parise, Maryam Kamgarpour, John Lygeros

Abstract: We consider the framework of aggregative games, in which the cost function of each agent depends on his own strategy and on the average population strategy. As first contribution, we investigate the relations between the concepts of Nash and Wardrop equilibrium. By exploiting a characterization of the two equilibria as solutions of variational inequalities, we bound their distance with a decreasin… ▽ More We consider the framework of aggregative games, in which the cost function of each agent depends on his own strategy and on the average population strategy. As first contribution, we investigate the relations between the concepts of Nash and Wardrop equilibrium. By exploiting a characterization of the two equilibria as solutions of variational inequalities, we bound their distance with a decreasing function of the population size. As second contribution, we propose two decentralized algorithms that converge to such equilibria and are capable of coping with constraints coupling the strategies of different agents. Finally, we study the applications of charging of electric vehicles and of route choice on a road network. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2018; v1 submitted 28 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: IEEE Trans. on Automatic Control (Accepted without changes). The first three authors contributed equally