-
Functoriality of Enriched Data Types
Authors:
Lukas Mulder,
Paige Randall North,
Maximilien Péroux
Abstract:
In previous work, categories of algebras of endofunctors were shown to be enriched in categories of coalgebras of the same endofunctor, and the extra structure of that enrichment was used to define a generalization of inductive data types. These generalized inductive data types are parametrized by a coalgebra $C$, so we call them $C$-inductive data types; we call the morphisms induced by their uni…
▽ More
In previous work, categories of algebras of endofunctors were shown to be enriched in categories of coalgebras of the same endofunctor, and the extra structure of that enrichment was used to define a generalization of inductive data types. These generalized inductive data types are parametrized by a coalgebra $C$, so we call them $C$-inductive data types; we call the morphisms induced by their universal property $C$-inductive functions. We extend that work by incorporating natural transformations into the theory: given a suitable natural transformation between endofunctors, we show that this induces enriched functors between their categories of algebras which preserve $C$-inductive data types and $C$-inductive functions. Such $C$-inductive data types are often finite versions of the corresponding inductive data type, and we show how our framework can extend classical initial algebra semantics to these types. For instance, we show that our theory naturally produces partially inductive functions on lists, changes in list element types, and tree pruning functions.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
A Type Theory for Comprehension Categories with Applications to Subtyping
Authors:
Niyousha Najmaei,
Niels van der Weide,
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
In this paper we develop a type theory that we show is an internal language for comprehension categories. This type theory is closely related to Martin-Löf type theory (MLTT). Indeed, semantics of MLTT are often given in comprehension categories, albeit usually only in discrete or full ones. As we explain, requiring a comprehension category to be full or discrete can be understood as removing one…
▽ More
In this paper we develop a type theory that we show is an internal language for comprehension categories. This type theory is closely related to Martin-Löf type theory (MLTT). Indeed, semantics of MLTT are often given in comprehension categories, albeit usually only in discrete or full ones. As we explain, requiring a comprehension category to be full or discrete can be understood as removing one `dimension' of morphisms. Thus, in our syntax, we recover this extra dimension. We show that this extra dimension can be used to encode subtyping in a natural way. Important instances of non-full comprehension categories include ones used for constructive or univalent intensional models of MLTT and directed type theory, and so our syntax is a more faithful internal language for these than is MLTT.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Categorical Diffusion of Weighted Lattices
Authors:
Robert Ghrist,
Miguel Lopez,
Paige Randall North,
Hans Riess
Abstract:
We introduce a categorical formalization of diffusion, motivated by data science and information dynamics. Central to our construction is the Lawvere Laplacian, an endofunctor on a product category indexed by a graph and enriched in a quantale. This framework permits the systematic study of diffusion processes on network sheaves taking values in a class of enriched categories.
We introduce a categorical formalization of diffusion, motivated by data science and information dynamics. Central to our construction is the Lawvere Laplacian, an endofunctor on a product category indexed by a graph and enriched in a quantale. This framework permits the systematic study of diffusion processes on network sheaves taking values in a class of enriched categories.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Comparing semantic frameworks for dependently-sorted algebraic theories
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Peter LeFanu Lumsdaine,
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
Algebraic theories with dependency between sorts form the structural core of Martin-Löf type theory and similar systems. Their denotational semantics are typically studied using categorical techniques; many different categorical structures have been introduced to model them (contextual categories, categories with families, display map categories, etc.) Comparisons of these models are scattered thr…
▽ More
Algebraic theories with dependency between sorts form the structural core of Martin-Löf type theory and similar systems. Their denotational semantics are typically studied using categorical techniques; many different categorical structures have been introduced to model them (contextual categories, categories with families, display map categories, etc.) Comparisons of these models are scattered throughout the literature, and a detailed, big-picture analysis of their relationships has been lacking.
We aim to provide a clear and comprehensive overview of the relationships between as many such models as possible. Specifically, we take *comprehension categories* as a unifying language and show how almost all established notions of model embed as sub-2-categories (usually full) of the 2-category of comprehension categories.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Measuring data types
Authors:
Lukas Mulder,
Paige Randall North,
Maximilien Péroux
Abstract:
In this article, we combine Sweedler's classic theory of measuring coalgebras -- by which $k$-algebras are enriched in $k$-coalgebras for $k$ a field -- with the theory of W-types -- by which the categorical semantics of inductive data types in functional programming languages are understood. In our main theorem, we find that under some hypotheses, algebras of an endofunctor are enriched in coalge…
▽ More
In this article, we combine Sweedler's classic theory of measuring coalgebras -- by which $k$-algebras are enriched in $k$-coalgebras for $k$ a field -- with the theory of W-types -- by which the categorical semantics of inductive data types in functional programming languages are understood. In our main theorem, we find that under some hypotheses, algebras of an endofunctor are enriched in coalgebras of the same endofunctor, and we find polynomial endofunctors provide many interesting examples of this phenomenon. We then generalize the notion of initial algebra of an endofunctor using this enrichment, thus generalizing the notion of W-type. This article is an extended version of arXiv:2303.16793, it adds expository introductions to the original theories of measuring coalgebras and W-types along with some improvements to the main theory and many explicitly worked examples.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Insights From Univalent Foundations: A Case Study Using Double Categories
Authors:
Nima Rasekh,
Niels van der Weide,
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
Category theory unifies mathematical concepts, aiding comparisons across structures by incorporating objects and morphisms, which capture their interactions. It has influenced areas of computer science such as automata theory, functional programming, and semantics. Certain objects naturally exhibit two classes of morphisms, leading to the concept of a double category, which has found applications…
▽ More
Category theory unifies mathematical concepts, aiding comparisons across structures by incorporating objects and morphisms, which capture their interactions. It has influenced areas of computer science such as automata theory, functional programming, and semantics. Certain objects naturally exhibit two classes of morphisms, leading to the concept of a double category, which has found applications in computing science (e.g., ornaments, profunctor optics, denotational semantics).
The emergence of diverse categorical structures motivated a unified framework for category theory. However, unlike other mathematical objects, classification of categorical structures faces challenges due to various relevant equivalences. This poses significant challenges when pursuing the formalization of categories and restricts the applicability of powerful techniques, such as transport along equivalences. This work contends that univalent foundations offers a suitable framework for classifying different categorical structures based on desired notions of equivalences, and remedy the challenges when formalizing categories. The richer notion of equality in univalent foundations makes the equivalence of a categorical structure an inherent part of its structure.
We concretely apply this analysis to double categorical structures. We characterize and formalize various definitions in Coq UniMath, including (pseudo) double categories and double bicategories, up to chosen equivalences. We also establish univalence principles, making chosen equivalences part of the double categorical structure, analyzing strict double setcategories (invariant under isomorphisms), pseudo double setcategories (invariant under isomorphisms), univalent pseudo double categories (invariant under vertical equivalences) and univalent double bicategories (invariant under gregarious equivalences).
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Univalent Double Categories
Authors:
Niels van der Weide,
Nima Rasekh,
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
Category theory is a branch of mathematics that provides a formal framework for understanding the relationship between mathematical structures. To this end, a category not only incorporates the data of the desired objects, but also "morphisms", which capture how different objects interact with each other. Category theory has found many applications in mathematics and in computer science, for examp…
▽ More
Category theory is a branch of mathematics that provides a formal framework for understanding the relationship between mathematical structures. To this end, a category not only incorporates the data of the desired objects, but also "morphisms", which capture how different objects interact with each other. Category theory has found many applications in mathematics and in computer science, for example in functional programming. Double categories are a natural generalization of categories which incorporate the data of two separate classes of morphisms, allowing a more nuanced representation of relationships and interactions between objects. Similar to category theory, double categories have been successfully applied to various situations in mathematics and computer science, in which objects naturally exhibit two types of morphisms. Examples include categories themselves, but also lenses, petri nets, and spans. While categories have already been formalized in a variety of proof assistants, double categories have received far less attention. In this paper we remedy this situation by presenting a formalization of double categories via the proof assistant Coq, relying on the Coq UniMath library. As part of this work we present two equivalent formalizations of the definition of a double category, an unfolded explicit definition and a second definition which exhibits excellent formal properties via 2-sided displayed categories. As an application of the formal approach we establish a notion of univalent double category along with a univalence principle: equivalences of univalent double categories coincide with their identities
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Coinductive control of inductive data types
Authors:
Paige Randall North,
Maximilien Péroux
Abstract:
We combine the theory of inductive data types with the theory of universal measurings. By doing so, we find that many categories of algebras of endofunctors are actually enriched in the corresponding category of coalgebras of the same endofunctor. The enrichment captures all possible partial algebra homomorphisms, defined by measuring coalgebras. Thus this enriched category carries more informatio…
▽ More
We combine the theory of inductive data types with the theory of universal measurings. By doing so, we find that many categories of algebras of endofunctors are actually enriched in the corresponding category of coalgebras of the same endofunctor. The enrichment captures all possible partial algebra homomorphisms, defined by measuring coalgebras. Thus this enriched category carries more information than the usual category of algebras which captures only total algebra homomorphisms. We specify new algebras besides the initial one using a generalization of the notion of initial algebra.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2023; v1 submitted 29 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Univalent foundations and the equivalence principle
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
In this paper, we explore the 'equivalence principle' (EP): roughly, statements about mathematical objects should be invariant under an appropriate notion of equivalence for the kinds of objects under consideration. In set theoretic foundations, EP may not always hold: for instance, the statement '1 \in N' is not invariant under isomorphism of sets. In univalent foundations, on the other hand, EP…
▽ More
In this paper, we explore the 'equivalence principle' (EP): roughly, statements about mathematical objects should be invariant under an appropriate notion of equivalence for the kinds of objects under consideration. In set theoretic foundations, EP may not always hold: for instance, the statement '1 \in N' is not invariant under isomorphism of sets. In univalent foundations, on the other hand, EP has been proven for many mathematical structures. We first give an overview of earlier attempts at designing foundations that satisfy EP. We then describe how univalent foundations validates EP.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Bicategorical type theory: semantics and syntax
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North,
Niels van der Weide
Abstract:
We develop semantics and syntax for bicategorical type theory. Bicategorical type theory features contexts, types, terms, and directed reductions between terms. This type theory is naturally interpreted in a class of structured bicategories. We start by developing the semantics, in the form of comprehension bicategories. Examples of comprehension bicategories are plentiful; we study both specific…
▽ More
We develop semantics and syntax for bicategorical type theory. Bicategorical type theory features contexts, types, terms, and directed reductions between terms. This type theory is naturally interpreted in a class of structured bicategories. We start by developing the semantics, in the form of comprehension bicategories. Examples of comprehension bicategories are plentiful; we study both specific examples as well as classes of examples constructed from other data. From the notion of comprehension bicategory, we extract the syntax of bicategorical type theory, that is, judgment forms and structural inference rules. We prove soundness of the rules by giving an interpretation in any comprehension bicategory. The semantic aspects of our work are fully checked in the Coq proof assistant, based on the UniMath library.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2023; v1 submitted 25 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Algebraic Presentations of Type Dependency
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Jacopo Emmenegger,
Paige Randall North,
Egbert Rijke
Abstract:
C-systems were defined by Cartmell as the algebraic structures that correspond exactly to generalised algebraic theories. B-systems were defined by Voevodsky in his quest to formulate and prove an initiality conjecture for type theories. They play a crucial role in Voevodsky's construction of a syntactic C-system from a term monad. In this work, we construct an equivalence between the category of…
▽ More
C-systems were defined by Cartmell as the algebraic structures that correspond exactly to generalised algebraic theories. B-systems were defined by Voevodsky in his quest to formulate and prove an initiality conjecture for type theories. They play a crucial role in Voevodsky's construction of a syntactic C-system from a term monad. In this work, we construct an equivalence between the category of C-systems and the category of B-systems, thus proving a conjecture by Voevodsky. We construct this equivalence as the restriction of an equivalence between more general structures, called CE-systems and E-systems, respectively. To this end, we identify C-systems and B-systems as "stratified" CE-systems and E-systems, respectively; that is, systems whose contexts are built iteratively via context extension, starting from the empty context.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2025; v1 submitted 18 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The Univalence Principle
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North,
Michael Shulman,
Dimitris Tsementzis
Abstract:
The Univalence Principle is the statement that equivalent mathematical structures are indistinguishable. We prove a general version of this principle that applies to all set-based, categorical, and higher-categorical structures defined in a non-algebraic and space-based style, as well as models of higher-order theories such as topological spaces. In particular, we formulate a general definition of…
▽ More
The Univalence Principle is the statement that equivalent mathematical structures are indistinguishable. We prove a general version of this principle that applies to all set-based, categorical, and higher-categorical structures defined in a non-algebraic and space-based style, as well as models of higher-order theories such as topological spaces. In particular, we formulate a general definition of indiscernibility for objects of any such structure, and a corresponding univalence condition that generalizes Rezk's completeness condition for Segal spaces and ensures that all equivalences of structures are levelwise equivalences.
Our work builds on Makkai's First-Order Logic with Dependent Sorts, but is expressed in Voevodsky's Univalent Foundations (UF), extending previous work on the Structure Identity Principle and univalent categories in UF. This enables indistinguishability to be expressed simply as identification, and yields a formal theory that is interpretable in classical homotopy theory, but also in other higher topos models. It follows that Univalent Foundations is a fully equivalence-invariant foundation for higher-categorical mathematics, as intended by Voevodsky.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022; v1 submitted 11 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
A Higher Structure Identity Principle
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
Paige Randall North,
Michael Shulman,
Dimitris Tsementzis
Abstract:
The ordinary Structure Identity Principle states that any property of set-level structures (e.g., posets, groups, rings, fields) definable in Univalent Foundations is invariant under isomorphism: more specifically, identifications of structures coincide with isomorphisms. We prove a version of this principle for a wide range of higher-categorical structures, adapting FOLDS-signatures to specify a…
▽ More
The ordinary Structure Identity Principle states that any property of set-level structures (e.g., posets, groups, rings, fields) definable in Univalent Foundations is invariant under isomorphism: more specifically, identifications of structures coincide with isomorphisms. We prove a version of this principle for a wide range of higher-categorical structures, adapting FOLDS-signatures to specify a general class of structures, and using two-level type theory to treat all categorical dimensions uniformly. As in the previously known case of 1-categories (which is an instance of our theory), the structures themselves must satisfy a local univalence principle, stating that identifications coincide with "isomorphisms" between elements of the structure. Our main technical achievement is a definition of such isomorphisms, which we call "indiscernibilities", using only the dependency structure rather than any notion of composition.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2020; v1 submitted 14 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
A Hurewicz Model Structure for Directed Topology
Authors:
Sanjeevi Krishnan,
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
This paper constructs an h-model structure for diagrams of streams, locally preordered spaces. Along the way, the paper extends some classical characterizations of Hurewicz fibrations and closed Hurewicz cofibrations. The usual characterization of classical closed Hurewicz cofibrations as inclusions of neighborhood deformation retracts extends. A characterization of classical Hurewicz fibrations a…
▽ More
This paper constructs an h-model structure for diagrams of streams, locally preordered spaces. Along the way, the paper extends some classical characterizations of Hurewicz fibrations and closed Hurewicz cofibrations. The usual characterization of classical closed Hurewicz cofibrations as inclusions of neighborhood deformation retracts extends. A characterization of classical Hurewicz fibrations as algebras over a pointed Moore cocylinder endofunctor also extends. An immediate consequence is a long exact sequence for directed homotopy monoids, with applications to safety verifications for database protocols.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2021; v1 submitted 6 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Type-theoretic weak factorization systems
Authors:
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
This article presents three characterizations of the weak factorization systems on finitely complete categories that interpret intensional dependent type theory with Sigma-, Pi-, and Id-types. The first characterization is that the weak factorization system (L,R) has the properties that L is stable under pullback along R and that all maps to a terminal object are in R. We call such weak factorizat…
▽ More
This article presents three characterizations of the weak factorization systems on finitely complete categories that interpret intensional dependent type theory with Sigma-, Pi-, and Id-types. The first characterization is that the weak factorization system (L,R) has the properties that L is stable under pullback along R and that all maps to a terminal object are in R. We call such weak factorization systems type-theoretic. The second is that the weak factorization system has an Id-presentation: roughly, it is generated by Id-types in the empty context. The third is that the weak factorization system (L, R) is generated by a Moore relation system, a generalization of the notion of Moore paths.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Identity types and weak factorization systems in Cauchy complete categories
Authors:
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
It has been known that categorical interpretations of dependent type theory with Sigma- and Id-types induce weak factorization systems. When one has a weak factorization system (L, R) on a category C in hand, it is then natural to ask whether or not (L, R) harbors an interpretation of dependent type theory with Sigma- and Id- (and possibly Pi-) types. Using the framework of display map categories…
▽ More
It has been known that categorical interpretations of dependent type theory with Sigma- and Id-types induce weak factorization systems. When one has a weak factorization system (L, R) on a category C in hand, it is then natural to ask whether or not (L, R) harbors an interpretation of dependent type theory with Sigma- and Id- (and possibly Pi-) types. Using the framework of display map categories to phrase this question more precisely, one would ask whether or not there exists a class D of morphisms of C such that the retract closure of D is the class R and the pair (C, D) forms a display map category modeling Sigma- and Id- (and possibly Pi-) types. In this paper, we show, with the hypothesis that C is Cauchy complete, that there exists such a class D if and only if (C,R) itself forms a display map category modeling Sigma- and Id- (and possibly Pi-) types. Thus, we reduce the search space of our original question from a potentially proper class to a singleton.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Towards a directed homotopy type theory
Authors:
Paige Randall North
Abstract:
In this paper, we present a directed homotopy type theory for reasoning synthetically about (higher) categories, directed homotopy theory, and its applications to concurrency. We specify a new `homomorphism' type former for Martin-Löf type theory which is roughly analogous to the identity type former originally introduced by Martin-Löf. The homomorphism type former is meant to capture the notions…
▽ More
In this paper, we present a directed homotopy type theory for reasoning synthetically about (higher) categories, directed homotopy theory, and its applications to concurrency. We specify a new `homomorphism' type former for Martin-Löf type theory which is roughly analogous to the identity type former originally introduced by Martin-Löf. The homomorphism type former is meant to capture the notions of morphism (from the theory of categories) and directed path (from directed homotopy theory) just as the identity type former is known to capture the notions of isomorphism (from the theory of groupoids) and path (from homotopy theory). Our main result is an interpretation of these homomorphism types into Cat, the category of small categories. There, the interpretation of each homomorphism type hom(a,b) is indeed the set of morphisms between the objects a and b of a category C. We end the paper with an analysis of the interpretation in Cat with which we argue that our homomorphism types are indeed the directed version of Martin-Löf's identity types.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
