-
Modular Differential Equations with Movable Poles and Admissible RCFT Characters
Authors:
Arpit Das,
Chethan N. Gowdigere,
Sunil Mukhi,
Jagannath Santara
Abstract:
Studies of modular linear differential equations (MLDE) for the classification of rational CFT characters have been limited to the case where the coefficient functions (in monic form) have no poles, or poles at special points of moduli space. Here we initiate an exploration of the vast territory of MLDEs with two characters and any number of poles at arbitrary points of moduli space. We show how t…
▽ More
Studies of modular linear differential equations (MLDE) for the classification of rational CFT characters have been limited to the case where the coefficient functions (in monic form) have no poles, or poles at special points of moduli space. Here we initiate an exploration of the vast territory of MLDEs with two characters and any number of poles at arbitrary points of moduli space. We show how to parametrise the most general equation precisely and count its parameters. Eliminating logarithmic singularities at all the poles provides constraint equations for the accessory parameters. By taking suitable limits, we find recursion relations between solutions for different numbers of poles. The cases of one and two movable poles are examined in detail and compared with predictions based on quasi-characters to find complete agreement. We also comment on the limit of coincident poles. Finally we show that there exist genuine CFT corresponding to many of the newly-studied cases. We emphasise that the modular data is an output, rather than an input, of our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2023; v1 submitted 31 July, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Meromorphic Cosets and the Classification of Three-Character CFT
Authors:
Arpit Das,
Chethan N. Gowdigere,
Sunil Mukhi
Abstract:
We investigate the admissible vector-valued modular forms having three independent characters and vanishing Wronskian index and determine which ones correspond to genuine 2d conformal field theories. This is done by finding bilinear coset-type relations that pair them into meromorphic characters with central charges 8, 16, 24, 32 and 40. Such pairings allow us to identify some characters with defi…
▽ More
We investigate the admissible vector-valued modular forms having three independent characters and vanishing Wronskian index and determine which ones correspond to genuine 2d conformal field theories. This is done by finding bilinear coset-type relations that pair them into meromorphic characters with central charges 8, 16, 24, 32 and 40. Such pairings allow us to identify some characters with definite CFTs and rule out others. As a key result we classify all unitary three-character CFT with vanishing Wronskian index, excluding $c=8,16$. The complete list has two infinite affine series $B_{r,1},D_{r,1}$ and 45 additional theories. As a by-product, at higher values of the total central charge we also find constraints on the existence or otherwise of meromorphic theories. We separately list several cases that potentially correspond to Intermediate Vertex Operator Algebras.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Classification of Unitary RCFTs with Two Primaries and Central Charge Less Than 25
Authors:
Sunil Mukhi,
Brandon C. Rayhaun
Abstract:
We classify all two-dimensional, unitary, rational conformal field theories with two primaries, central charge $c<25$, and arbitrary Wronskian index. In mathematical parlance, we classify all strongly regular vertex operator algebras (VOAs) with central charge $c<25$ and exactly two simple modules. We find that any such theory is either one of the Mathur-Mukhi-Sen (MMS) theories…
▽ More
We classify all two-dimensional, unitary, rational conformal field theories with two primaries, central charge $c<25$, and arbitrary Wronskian index. In mathematical parlance, we classify all strongly regular vertex operator algebras (VOAs) with central charge $c<25$ and exactly two simple modules. We find that any such theory is either one of the Mathur-Mukhi-Sen (MMS) theories $\mathsf{A}_{1,1}$, $\mathsf{G}_{2,1}$, $\mathsf{F}_{4,1}$, or $\mathsf{E}_{7,1}$, or it is a coset of a chiral algebra with one primary operator (also known as a holomorphic VOA) by such an MMS theory. By leveraging existing results on the classification of holomorphic VOAs, we are able to explicitly enumerate all of the aforementioned cosets and compute their characters. This leads to 123 theories, most of which are new. We emphasize that our work is a bona fide classification of RCFTs, not just of characters. Our techniques are general, and we argue that they offer a promising strategy for classifying chiral algebras with low central charge beyond two primaries.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2023; v1 submitted 10 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
New meromorphic CFTs from cosets
Authors:
Arpit Das,
Chethan N. Gowdigere,
Sunil Mukhi
Abstract:
In recent years it has been understood that new rational CFTs can be discovered by applying the coset construction to meromorphic CFTs. Here we turn this approach around and show that the coset construction, together with the classification of meromorphic CFT with $c\leq 24$, can be used to predict the existence of new meromorphic CFTs with $c\geq 32$ whose Kac-Moody algebras are non-simply-laced…
▽ More
In recent years it has been understood that new rational CFTs can be discovered by applying the coset construction to meromorphic CFTs. Here we turn this approach around and show that the coset construction, together with the classification of meromorphic CFT with $c\leq 24$, can be used to predict the existence of new meromorphic CFTs with $c\geq 32$ whose Kac-Moody algebras are non-simply-laced and/or at levels greater than 1. This implies they are non-lattice theories. Using three-character coset relations, we propose 34 infinite series of meromorphic theories with arbitrarily large central charge, as well as 46 theories at $c=32$ and $c=40$.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Rational CFT With Three Characters: The Quasi-Character Approach
Authors:
Sunil Mukhi,
Rahul Poddar,
Palash Singh
Abstract:
Quasi-characters are vector-valued modular functions having an integral, but not necessarily positive, q-expansion. Using modular differential equations, a complete classification has been provided in arXiv:1810.09472 for the case of two characters. These in turn generate all possible admissible characters, of arbitrary Wronskian index, in order two. Here we initiate a study of the three-character…
▽ More
Quasi-characters are vector-valued modular functions having an integral, but not necessarily positive, q-expansion. Using modular differential equations, a complete classification has been provided in arXiv:1810.09472 for the case of two characters. These in turn generate all possible admissible characters, of arbitrary Wronskian index, in order two. Here we initiate a study of the three-character case. We conjecture several infinite families of quasi-characters and show in examples that their linear combinations an generate admissible characters with arbitrarily large Wronskian index. The structure is completely different from the order two case, and the novel coset construction of arXiv:1602.01022 plays a key role in discovering the appropriate families. Using even unimodular lattices, we construct some explicit three-character CFT corresponding to the new admissible characters.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2020; v1 submitted 5 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Contour Integrals and the Modular S-Matrix
Authors:
Sunil Mukhi,
Rahul Poddar,
Palash Singh
Abstract:
We investigate a conjecture to describe the characters of large families of RCFT's in terms of contour integrals of Feigin-Fuchs type. We provide a simple algorithm to determine the modular S-matrix for arbitrary numbers of characters as a sum over paths. Thereafter we focus on the case of 2, 3 and 4 characters, where agreement between the critical exponents of the integrals and the characters imp…
▽ More
We investigate a conjecture to describe the characters of large families of RCFT's in terms of contour integrals of Feigin-Fuchs type. We provide a simple algorithm to determine the modular S-matrix for arbitrary numbers of characters as a sum over paths. Thereafter we focus on the case of 2, 3 and 4 characters, where agreement between the critical exponents of the integrals and the characters implies that the conjecture is true. In these cases, we compute the modular S-matrix explicitly, verify that it agrees with expectations for known theories, and use it to compute degeneracies and multiplicities of primaries. We also compute S in an 8-character example to provide additional evidence for the original conjecture. On the way we note that the Verlinde formula provides interesting constraints on the critical exponents of RCFT in this context.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Classification of RCFT from Holomorphic Modular Bootstrap: A Status Report
Authors:
Sunil Mukhi
Abstract:
Following the initial proposal in 1988, there has been much progress in classifying Rational Conformal Field Theories in 2 dimensions from the Holomorphic Bootstrap approach. This method starts by postulating a generic holomorphic Modular Linear Differential Equation of a given order and imposing the requirement of non-negative integrality of the coefficients in the series expansion of the solutio…
▽ More
Following the initial proposal in 1988, there has been much progress in classifying Rational Conformal Field Theories in 2 dimensions from the Holomorphic Bootstrap approach. This method starts by postulating a generic holomorphic Modular Linear Differential Equation of a given order and imposing the requirement of non-negative integrality of the coefficients in the series expansion of the solutions, which are then identified as admissible characters, from which a modular-invariant partition function is constructed. In this short note, the status of this project is summarised.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Curiosities above c = 24
Authors:
A. Ramesh Chandra,
Sunil Mukhi
Abstract:
Two-dimensional rational CFT are characterised by an integer $\ell$, related to the number of zeroes of the Wronskian of the characters. For two-character RCFT's with $\ell<6$ there is a finite number of theories and most of these are classified. Recently it has been shown that for $\ell \ge 6$ there are infinitely many admissible characters that could potentially describe CFT's. In this note we e…
▽ More
Two-dimensional rational CFT are characterised by an integer $\ell$, related to the number of zeroes of the Wronskian of the characters. For two-character RCFT's with $\ell<6$ there is a finite number of theories and most of these are classified. Recently it has been shown that for $\ell \ge 6$ there are infinitely many admissible characters that could potentially describe CFT's. In this note we examine the $\ell=6$ case, whose central charges lie between 24 and 32, and propose a classification method based on cosets of meromorphic CFT's. We illustrate the method using theories on Kervaire lattices with complete root systems. In the process we construct the first known two-character RCFT's beyond $\ell=2$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2019; v1 submitted 12 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Towards a Classification of Two-Character Rational Conformal Field Theories
Authors:
A. Ramesh Chandra,
Sunil Mukhi
Abstract:
We provide a simple and general construction of infinite families of consistent, modular-covariant pairs of characters satisfying the basic requirements to describe two-character RCFT. These correspond to solutions of generic second-order modular linear differential equations. To find these solutions, we first construct "quasi-characters" from the Kaneko-Zagier equation and subsequent works by Kan…
▽ More
We provide a simple and general construction of infinite families of consistent, modular-covariant pairs of characters satisfying the basic requirements to describe two-character RCFT. These correspond to solutions of generic second-order modular linear differential equations. To find these solutions, we first construct "quasi-characters" from the Kaneko-Zagier equation and subsequent works by Kaneko and collaborators, together with coset dual generalisations that we provide in this paper. We relate our construction to the Hecke images recently discussed by Harvey and Wu.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2019; v1 submitted 22 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Fermions on replica geometries and the $Θ$-$θ$ relation
Authors:
Sunil Mukhi,
Sameer Murthy
Abstract:
In arXiv:1706:09426 we conjectured and provided evidence for an identity between Siegel $Θ$-constants for special Riemann surfaces of genus $n$ and products of Jacobi $θ$-functions. This arises by comparing two different ways of computing the \nth \Renyi entropy of free fermions at finite temperature. Here we show that for $n=2$ the identity is a consequence of an old result due to Fay for doubly…
▽ More
In arXiv:1706:09426 we conjectured and provided evidence for an identity between Siegel $Θ$-constants for special Riemann surfaces of genus $n$ and products of Jacobi $θ$-functions. This arises by comparing two different ways of computing the \nth \Renyi entropy of free fermions at finite temperature. Here we show that for $n=2$ the identity is a consequence of an old result due to Fay for doubly branched Riemann surfaces. For $n>2$ we provide a detailed matching of certain zeros on both sides of the identity. This amounts to an elementary proof of the identity for $n=2$, while for $n\ge 3$ it gives new evidence for it. We explain why the existence of additional zeros renders the general proof difficult.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Entanglement, Replicas, and Thetas
Authors:
Sunil Mukhi,
Sameer Murthy,
Jie-Qiang Wu
Abstract:
We compute the single-interval Renyi entropy (replica partition function) for free fermions in 1+1d at finite temperature and finite spatial size by two methods: (i) using the higher-genus partition function on the replica Riemann surface, and (ii) using twist operators on the torus. We compare the two answers for a restricted set of spin structures, leading to a non-trivial proposed equivalence b…
▽ More
We compute the single-interval Renyi entropy (replica partition function) for free fermions in 1+1d at finite temperature and finite spatial size by two methods: (i) using the higher-genus partition function on the replica Riemann surface, and (ii) using twist operators on the torus. We compare the two answers for a restricted set of spin structures, leading to a non-trivial proposed equivalence between higher-genus Siegel $Θ$-functions and Jacobi $θ$-functions. We exhibit this proposal and provide substantial evidence for it. The resulting expressions can be elegantly written in terms of Jacobi forms. Thereafter we argue that the correct Renyi entropy for modular-invariant free-fermion theories, such as the Ising model and the Dirac CFT, is given by the higher-genus computation summed over all spin structures. The result satisfies the physical checks of modular covariance, the thermal entropy relation, and Bose-Fermi equivalence.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2018; v1 submitted 28 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
