-
Uniqueness of universal dimensions and configurations of points and lines
Authors:
M. Y. Avetisyan,
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
The problem of uniqueness of universal formulae for (quantum) dimensions of simple Lie algebras is investigated. We present generic functions, which multiplied by a universal (quantum) dimension formula, preserve both its structure and its values at the points from Vogel's table. Connection of some of these functions with geometrical configurations, such as the famous Pappus-Brianchon-Pascal…
▽ More
The problem of uniqueness of universal formulae for (quantum) dimensions of simple Lie algebras is investigated. We present generic functions, which multiplied by a universal (quantum) dimension formula, preserve both its structure and its values at the points from Vogel's table. Connection of some of these functions with geometrical configurations, such as the famous Pappus-Brianchon-Pascal $(9_3)_1$ configuration of points and lines, is established. Particularly, the appropriate realizable configuration $(144_336_{12})$ (yet to be found) will provide a symmetric non-uniqueness factor for any universal dimension formula.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2021; v1 submitted 22 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
On linear resolvability of universal quantum dimensions
Authors:
M. Y. Avetisyan,
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
In his study of finite (Vassiliev's) knot invariants,Vogel introduced the so-called universal parameters, belonging to the projective plane, which particularly parameterize the simple Lie algebras by the Vogel's table. Subsequently a number of quantities, such as some universal knot invariants, (quantum) dimensions of simple Lie algebras, etc., have been represented in terms of these parameters, i…
▽ More
In his study of finite (Vassiliev's) knot invariants,Vogel introduced the so-called universal parameters, belonging to the projective plane, which particularly parameterize the simple Lie algebras by the Vogel's table. Subsequently a number of quantities, such as some universal knot invariants, (quantum) dimensions of simple Lie algebras, etc., have been represented in terms of these parameters, i.e. in the universal form. We prove that at the points from the Vogel's table all known universal quantum dimension formulae are linearly resolvable, i.e. yield finite answers even if these points are singular, provided one restricts them to the appropriate lines. We show, that the same phenomenon takes place for another three distinguished points in Vogel's plane - $E_{7\frac{1}{2}}, X_1,$ and $X_2$. We also examine the same formulae on linear resolvability at the remaining 48 distinguished points in Vogel's plane, which correspond to the so-called $Y$-objects, and discover that there are three points among them, which are regular for all known quantum dimension formulae. Two of them happen to be sharing a remarkable similarity with the simple Lie algebras, namely, the universal formulae yield integer-valued outputs (dimensions) at those points in the classical limit.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
On universal quantum dimensions of certain two-parameter series of representations
Authors:
M. Y. Avetisyan,
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
We present the universal, in Vogel's sense, expression for the quantum dimension of Cartan product of an arbitrary number of adjoint and $X_2$ representations of simple Lie algebras. The same formula mysteriously gives quantum dimensions of some other representations of the same Lie algebra under permutations of universal parameters. We list these representations for exceptional algebras and stabl…
▽ More
We present the universal, in Vogel's sense, expression for the quantum dimension of Cartan product of an arbitrary number of adjoint and $X_2$ representations of simple Lie algebras. The same formula mysteriously gives quantum dimensions of some other representations of the same Lie algebra under permutations of universal parameters. We list these representations for exceptional algebras and stable versions for classical algebras, when the rank of the classical algebra is sufficiently large w.r.t. the powers of representations. We show that universal formulae can have singularities on Vogel's plane for some algebras and that they give correct answers when restricted on appropriate lines on Vogel's plane. We note that the same irreducible representation can have several universal formulae for its (quantum) dimension, and discuss the implication of this phenomena on the Cohen - de Man method of calculation of universal formulae.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
$X_2$ series of universal quantum dimensions
Authors:
M. Y. Avetisyan,
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
The antisymmetric square of the adjoint representation of any simple Lie algebra is equal to the sum of adjoint and $X_2$ representations. We present universal formulae for quantum dimensions of an arbitrary Cartan power of $X_2$. They are analyzed for singular cases and permuted universal Vogel's parameters. $X_2$ has been the only representation in the decomposition of the square of the adjoint…
▽ More
The antisymmetric square of the adjoint representation of any simple Lie algebra is equal to the sum of adjoint and $X_2$ representations. We present universal formulae for quantum dimensions of an arbitrary Cartan power of $X_2$. They are analyzed for singular cases and permuted universal Vogel's parameters. $X_2$ has been the only representation in the decomposition of the square of the adjoint with unknown universal series. Application to universal knot polynomials is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Partition function of Chern-Simons theory as renormalized q-dimension
Authors:
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
We calculate $q$-dimension of $k$-th Cartan power of fundamental representation $Λ_0$, corresponding to affine root of affine simply laced Kac-Moody algebras, and show that in the limit $q\rightarrow 1 $, and with natural renormalization, it is equal to universal partition function of Chern-Simons theory on three-dimensional sphere.
We calculate $q$-dimension of $k$-th Cartan power of fundamental representation $Λ_0$, corresponding to affine root of affine simply laced Kac-Moody algebras, and show that in the limit $q\rightarrow 1 $, and with natural renormalization, it is equal to universal partition function of Chern-Simons theory on three-dimensional sphere.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
On Universal Quantum Dimensions
Authors:
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
We represent in the universal form restricted one-instanton partition function of supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory. It is based on the derivation of universal expressions for quantum dimensions (universal characters) of Cartan powers of adjoint and some other series of irreps of simple Lie algebras. These formulae also provide a proof of formulae for universal quantum dimensions for low-dimensiona…
▽ More
We represent in the universal form restricted one-instanton partition function of supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory. It is based on the derivation of universal expressions for quantum dimensions (universal characters) of Cartan powers of adjoint and some other series of irreps of simple Lie algebras. These formulae also provide a proof of formulae for universal quantum dimensions for low-dimensional representations, needed in derivation of universal knot polynomials (i.e. colored Wilson averages of Chern-Simons theory on 3d sphere). As a check of the (complicated) formulae for universal quantum dimensions we prove numerically Deligne's hypothesis on universal characters for symmetric cube of adjoint representation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2017; v1 submitted 31 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Diophantine equations, Platonic solids, McKay correspondence, equivelar maps and Vogel's universality
Authors:
H. M. Khudaverdian,
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
We notice that one of the Diophantine equations, $knm=2kn+2km+2nm$, arising in the universality originated Diophantine classification of simple Lie algebras, has interesting interpretations for two different sets of signs of variables. In both cases it describes "regular polyhedrons" with $k$ edges in each vertex, $n$ edges of each face, with total number of edges $|m|$, and Euler characteristics…
▽ More
We notice that one of the Diophantine equations, $knm=2kn+2km+2nm$, arising in the universality originated Diophantine classification of simple Lie algebras, has interesting interpretations for two different sets of signs of variables. In both cases it describes "regular polyhedrons" with $k$ edges in each vertex, $n$ edges of each face, with total number of edges $|m|$, and Euler characteristics $χ=\pm 2$. In the case of negative $m$ this equation corresponds to $χ=2$ and describes true regular polyhedrons, Platonic solids. The case with positive $m$ corresponds to Euler characteristic $χ=-2$ and describes the so called equivelar maps (charts) on the surface of genus $2$. In the former case there are two routes from Platonic solids to simple Lie algebras - abovementioned Diophantine classification and McKay correspondence. We compare them for all solutions of this type, and find coincidence in the case of icosahedron (dodecahedron), corresponding to $E_8$ algebra. In the case of positive $k$, $n$ and $m$ we obtain in this way the interpretation of (some of) the mysterious solutions (Y-objects), appearing in the Diophantine classification and having some similarities with simple Lie algebras.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Universal volume of groups and anomaly of Vogel's symmetry
Authors:
H. M. Khudaverdian,
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
We show that integral representation of universal volume function of compact simple Lie groups gives rise to six analytic functions on $CP^2$, which transform as two triplets under group of permutations of Vogel's projective parameters. This substitutes expected invariance under permutations of universal parameters by more complicated covariance. We provide an analytical continuation of these func…
▽ More
We show that integral representation of universal volume function of compact simple Lie groups gives rise to six analytic functions on $CP^2$, which transform as two triplets under group of permutations of Vogel's projective parameters. This substitutes expected invariance under permutations of universal parameters by more complicated covariance. We provide an analytical continuation of these functions and particularly calculate their change under permutations of parameters. This last relation is universal generalization, for an arbitrary simple Lie group and an arbitrary point in Vogel's plane, of the Kinkelin's reflection relation on Barnes' $G(1+N)$ function. Kinkelin's relation gives asymmetry of the $G(1+N)$ function (which is essentially the volume function for $SU(N)$ groups) under $N\leftrightarrow -N$ transformation (which is equivalent of the permutation of parameters, for $SU(N)$ groups), and coincides with universal relation on permutations at the $SU(N)$ line on Vogel's plane. These results are also applicable to universal partition function of Chern-Simons theory on three-dimensional sphere. This effect is analogous to modular covariance, instead of invariance, of partition functions of appropriate gauge theories under modular transformation of couplings.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
A universal formula for the volume of compact Lie groups
Authors:
R. L. Mkrtchyan,
A. P. Veselov
Abstract:
We provide a closed formula for the volume of a simple compact Lie group in terms of the universal Vogel parameters. For the unitary groups SU_n this reduces to the integral representation of the classical Barnes G-function.
We provide a closed formula for the volume of a simple compact Lie group in terms of the universal Vogel parameters. For the unitary groups SU_n this reduces to the integral representation of the classical Barnes G-function.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
On the map of Vogel's plane
Authors:
R. L. Mkrtchyan
Abstract:
We search points in a Vogel plane with regular universal expression for character of adjoint representation. This gives seven patterns of singularities cancellation, each giving a certain Diophantine equation of third order on three variables. Solutions of these equations are classical series of simple Lie algebras (including an "odd symplectic" one), $D_{2,1,λ}$ superalgebra, the straight line of…
▽ More
We search points in a Vogel plane with regular universal expression for character of adjoint representation. This gives seven patterns of singularities cancellation, each giving a certain Diophantine equation of third order on three variables. Solutions of these equations are classical series of simple Lie algebras (including an "odd symplectic" one), $D_{2,1,λ}$ superalgebra, the straight line of three-dimensional algebras, and a number of isolated solutions, including exceptional simple Lie algebras. One of these Diophantine equations, namely knm=4k+4n+2m+12 contains all simple Lie algebras, except SO(2N+1). Isolated solutions contain, beside exceptional simple Lie algebras, so called $E_{71/2}$ algebra and also two other similar (unknown) objects with positive dimensions. In addition, there are 47 isolated solutions in "unphysical semiplane" with negative dimensions. Isolated solutions mainly lie on a few straight lines in Vogel plane. All solutions give an integers in universal dimension formulae for first three symmetric powers of adjoint representation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Casimir eigenvalues for universal Lie algebra
Authors:
R. L. Mkrtchyan,
A. N. Sergeev,
A. P. Veselov
Abstract:
For two different natural definitions of Casimir operators for simple Lie algebras we show that their eigenvalues in the adjoint representation can be expressed polynomially in the universal Vogel's parameters $α, β, γ$ and give explicit formulae for the generating functions of these eigenvalues.
For two different natural definitions of Casimir operators for simple Lie algebras we show that their eigenvalues in the adjoint representation can be expressed polynomially in the universal Vogel's parameters $α, β, γ$ and give explicit formulae for the generating functions of these eigenvalues.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2012; v1 submitted 30 April, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
On duality and negative dimensions in the theory of Lie groups and symmetric spaces
Authors:
Ruben L. Mkrtchyan,
Alexander P. Veselov
Abstract:
We give one more interpretation of the symbolic formulae $U(-N)=U(N)$ and $Sp(-2N)=SO(2N)$ by comparing the values of certain Casimir operators in the corresponding tensor representations. We show also that such relations can be extended to the classical symmetric spaces using Macdonald duality for Jack and Jacobi symmetric functions.
We give one more interpretation of the symbolic formulae $U(-N)=U(N)$ and $Sp(-2N)=SO(2N)$ by comparing the values of certain Casimir operators in the corresponding tensor representations. We show also that such relations can be extended to the classical symmetric spaces using Macdonald duality for Jack and Jacobi symmetric functions.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.