-
Sandwiching the Riemann hypothesis
Authors:
R. C. McPhedran
Abstract:
We consider a system of three analytic functions, two of which are known to have all their zeros on the critical line $\Re (s)=σ=1/2$. We construct inequalities which constrain the third function, $ξ(s)$, on $\Im(s)=0$ to lie between the other two functions, in a sandwich structure. We investigate what can be said about the location of zeros and radius of convergence of expansions of $ξ(s)$, with…
▽ More
We consider a system of three analytic functions, two of which are known to have all their zeros on the critical line $\Re (s)=σ=1/2$. We construct inequalities which constrain the third function, $ξ(s)$, on $\Im(s)=0$ to lie between the other two functions, in a sandwich structure. We investigate what can be said about the location of zeros and radius of convergence of expansions of $ξ(s)$, with promising results.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2024; v1 submitted 16 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Towards a resolution of the Riemann hypothesis
Authors:
R C McPhedran
Abstract:
This article contains work associated with a resolution of the Riemann hypothesis, following work by Taylor \cite{prt}, Lagarias and Suzuki \cite{lagandsuz} and Ki \cite{ki}, as well as Pustyl'nikov \cite{pust, pust2} and Keiper \cite{keiper}. Functions $ξ_+(s)$ and $ξ_-(s)$ are considered, for which it is known that all zeros lie on the critical line. The Riemann hypothesis itself pertains to the…
▽ More
This article contains work associated with a resolution of the Riemann hypothesis, following work by Taylor \cite{prt}, Lagarias and Suzuki \cite{lagandsuz} and Ki \cite{ki}, as well as Pustyl'nikov \cite{pust, pust2} and Keiper \cite{keiper}. Functions $ξ_+(s)$ and $ξ_-(s)$ are considered, for which it is known that all zeros lie on the critical line. The Riemann hypothesis itself pertains to the question of the location of the zeros of the sum and difference of $ξ_+(s)$ and $ξ_-(s)$, and this is investigated. An argument is developed which prima facie establishes the validity of the Riemann hypothesis. It adds to a necessary condition of Pustyl'nikov a sufficient condition. A second argument is discussed, which could have been accessible to Riemann.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Arguments Related to the Riemann Hypothesis: New Methods and Results
Authors:
R. C. McPhedran
Abstract:
Four propositions are considered concerning the relationship between the zeros of two combinations of the Riemann zeta function and the function itself. The first is the Riemann hypothesis, while the second relates to the zeros of a derivative function. It is proved that these are equivalent, and that, if the Riemann hypothesis holds, then all zeros of the zeta function on the critical line are si…
▽ More
Four propositions are considered concerning the relationship between the zeros of two combinations of the Riemann zeta function and the function itself. The first is the Riemann hypothesis, while the second relates to the zeros of a derivative function. It is proved that these are equivalent, and that, if the Riemann hypothesis holds, then all zeros of the zeta function on the critical line are simple. The Riemann hypothesis is then shown to imply the third proposition holds, this being a new necessary condition for the Riemann hypothesis. The third proposition is shown to be equivalent to the fourth, and either is shown to yield the result that the distribution of zeros on the critical line of $ζ(s)$ is that given by the Riemann hypothesis. The results given are obtained from a combination of analytic arguments, experimental mathematical techniques and graphical reasoning.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2019; v1 submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Sum Rules for Functions of the Riemann Zeta Type
Authors:
R. C. McPhedran
Abstract:
We consider analytic functions of the Riemann zeta type, for which, if $s$ is a zero, so is $1-s$. We use infinite product representations of these functions, assuming their zeros to be of first order. We use exponential factors to accelerate convergence, and by comparing the exponential factors with the Taylor series coefficients about $s=0$ of the original function, connect these coefficients wi…
▽ More
We consider analytic functions of the Riemann zeta type, for which, if $s$ is a zero, so is $1-s$. We use infinite product representations of these functions, assuming their zeros to be of first order. We use exponential factors to accelerate convergence, and by comparing the exponential factors with the Taylor series coefficients about $s=0$ of the original function, connect these coefficients with sums of powers of reciprocals of the zeros, in the form of sum rules. Such sum rules have been previously considered by Lehmer and Keiper, but the approach and applications taken here are more general. In related work, a new sufficient condition is found for the Riemann hypothesis, and the basis for this condition is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2018; v1 submitted 23 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Macdonald's Theorem for Analytic Functions
Authors:
R. C. McPhedran
Abstract:
A proof is reconstructed for a useful theorem on the zeros of derivatives of analytic functions due to H. M. Macdonald, which appears to be now little known. The Theorem states that, if a function $f(z)$ is analytic inside a bounded region bounded by a contour on which the modulus of $f(z)$ is constant, then the number of zeros (counted according to multiplicity) of $f(z)$ and of its derivative in…
▽ More
A proof is reconstructed for a useful theorem on the zeros of derivatives of analytic functions due to H. M. Macdonald, which appears to be now little known. The Theorem states that, if a function $f(z)$ is analytic inside a bounded region bounded by a contour on which the modulus of $f(z)$ is constant, then the number of zeros (counted according to multiplicity) of $f(z)$ and of its derivative in the region differ by unity.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2017; v1 submitted 11 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Zeros of Lattice Sums: 2. A Geometry for the Generalised Riemann Hypothesis
Authors:
R. C. McPhedran
Abstract:
The location of zeros of the basic double sum over the square lattice is studied. This sum can be represented in terms of the product of the Riemann zeta function and the Dirichlet beta function, so that the assertion that all its non-trivial zeros lie on the critical line is a particular case of the Generalised Riemann Hypothesis (GRH). It is shown that a new necessary and sufficient condition fo…
▽ More
The location of zeros of the basic double sum over the square lattice is studied. This sum can be represented in terms of the product of the Riemann zeta function and the Dirichlet beta function, so that the assertion that all its non-trivial zeros lie on the critical line is a particular case of the Generalised Riemann Hypothesis (GRH). It is shown that a new necessary and sufficient condition for this special case of the GRH to hold is that a particular set of equimodular and equiargument contours of a ratio of MacDonald function double sums intersect only on the critical line. It is further shown that these contours could only intersect off the critical line on the boundary of discrete regions of the complex plane called "inner islands". Numerical investigations are described related to this geometrical condition, and it is shown that for the first ten thousand zeros of both the zeta function and the beta function over 70\% of zeros lie outside the inner islands, and thus would be guaranteed to lie on the critical line by the arguments presented here. A new sufficient condition for the Riemann Hypothesis to hold is also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Zeros of Lattice Sums: 1. Zeros off the Critical Line
Authors:
Ross C. McPhedran
Abstract:
Zeros of two-dimensional sums of the Epstein zeta type over rectangular lattices of the type investigated by Hejhal and Bombieri in 1987 are considered, and in particular a sum first studied by Potter and Titchmarsh in 1935. These latter proved several properties of the zeros of sums over the rectangular lattice, and commented on the fact that a particular sum had zeros off the critical line. The…
▽ More
Zeros of two-dimensional sums of the Epstein zeta type over rectangular lattices of the type investigated by Hejhal and Bombieri in 1987 are considered, and in particular a sum first studied by Potter and Titchmarsh in 1935. These latter proved several properties of the zeros of sums over the rectangular lattice, and commented on the fact that a particular sum had zeros off the critical line. The behaviour of one such zero is investigated as a function of the ratio of the periods $λ$ of the rectangular lattice, and it is shown that it evolves continuously along a trajectory which approaches the critical line, reaching it at a point which is a second-order zero of the rectangular lattice sum. It is further shown that ranges of the period ratio $λ$ can be so identified for which zeros of the rectangular lattice sum lie off the critical line.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Constructing a Proof of the Riemann Hypothesis
Authors:
Ross C. McPhedran
Abstract:
This paper compares the distribution of zeros of the Riemann zeta function $ζ(s)$ with those of a symmetric combination of zeta functions, denoted ${\cal T}_+(s)$, known to have all its zeros located on the critical line $\Re(s)=1/2$. Criteria are described for constructing a suitable quotient function of these, with properties advantageous for establishing an accessible proof that $ζ(s)$ must als…
▽ More
This paper compares the distribution of zeros of the Riemann zeta function $ζ(s)$ with those of a symmetric combination of zeta functions, denoted ${\cal T}_+(s)$, known to have all its zeros located on the critical line $\Re(s)=1/2$. Criteria are described for constructing a suitable quotient function of these, with properties advantageous for establishing an accessible proof that $ζ(s)$ must also have all its zeros on the critical line: the celebrated Riemann hypothesis. While the argument put forward is not at the level of rigour required to constitute a full proof of the Riemann hypothesis, it should convince non-specialists that it must hold.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
The searchlight effect in hyperbolic materials
Authors:
Graeme W. Milton,
Ross C. McPhedran,
Ari Sihvola
Abstract:
The quasistatic field around a circular hole in a two-dimensional hyperbolic medium is studied. As the loss parameter goes to zero, it is found that the electric field diverges along four lines each tangent to the hole. In this limit, the power dissipated by the field in the vicinity of these lines, per unit length of the line, goes to zero but extends further and further out so that the net power…
▽ More
The quasistatic field around a circular hole in a two-dimensional hyperbolic medium is studied. As the loss parameter goes to zero, it is found that the electric field diverges along four lines each tangent to the hole. In this limit, the power dissipated by the field in the vicinity of these lines, per unit length of the line, goes to zero but extends further and further out so that the net power dissipated remains finite. Additionally the interaction between polarizable dipoles in a hyperbolic medium is studied. It is shown that a dipole with small polarizability can dramatically influence the dipole moment of a distant polarizable dipole, if it is appropriately placed. We call this the searchlight effect, as the enhancement depends on the orientation of the line joining the polarizable dipoles and can be varied by changing the frequency. For some particular polarizabilities the enhancement can actually increase the further the polarizable dipoles are apart.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Spectral super-resolution in metamaterial composites
Authors:
Johan Helsing,
Ross C. McPhedran,
Graeme W. Milton
Abstract:
We investigate the optical properties of periodic composites containing metamaterial inclusions in a normal material matrix. We consider the case where these inclusions have sharp corners, and following Hetherington and Thorpe, use analytic results to argue that it is then possible to deduce the shape of the corner (its included angle) by measurements of the absorptance of such composites when the…
▽ More
We investigate the optical properties of periodic composites containing metamaterial inclusions in a normal material matrix. We consider the case where these inclusions have sharp corners, and following Hetherington and Thorpe, use analytic results to argue that it is then possible to deduce the shape of the corner (its included angle) by measurements of the absorptance of such composites when the scale size of the inclusions and period cell is much finer than the wavelength. These analytic arguments are supported by highly accurate numerical results for the effective permittivity function of such composites as a function of the permittivity ratio of inclusions to matrix. The results show that this function has a continuous spectral component with limits independent of the area fraction of inclusions, and with the same limits for both square and staggered square arrays.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
