-
A Contract Theory for Layered Control Architectures
Authors:
Manuel Mazo Jr.,
Will Compton,
Max H. Cohen,
Aaron D. Ames
Abstract:
Autonomous systems typically leverage layered control architectures with a combination of discrete and continuous models operating at different timescales. As a result, layered systems form a new class of hybrid systems composed of systems operating on a diverse set of continuous and discrete signals. This paper formalizes the notion of a layered (hierarchical) control architecture through a theor…
▽ More
Autonomous systems typically leverage layered control architectures with a combination of discrete and continuous models operating at different timescales. As a result, layered systems form a new class of hybrid systems composed of systems operating on a diverse set of continuous and discrete signals. This paper formalizes the notion of a layered (hierarchical) control architecture through a theory of relations between its layers. This theory enables us to formulate contracts within layered control systems -- these define interfaces between layers and isolate the design of each layer, guaranteeing that composition of contracts at each layer results in a contract capturing the desired system-wide specification. Thus, the proposed theory yields the ability to analyze layered control architectures via a compositional approach.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Hierarchical Event-Triggered Systems: Safe Learning of Quasi-Optimal Deadline Policies
Authors:
Pio Ong,
Manuel Mazo Jr.,
Aaron D. Ames
Abstract:
We present a hierarchical architecture to improve the efficiency of event-triggered control (ETC) in reducing resource consumption. This paper considers event-triggered systems generally as an impulsive control system in which the objective is to minimize the number of impulses. Our architecture recognizes that traditional ETC is a greedy strategy towards optimizing average inter-event times and i…
▽ More
We present a hierarchical architecture to improve the efficiency of event-triggered control (ETC) in reducing resource consumption. This paper considers event-triggered systems generally as an impulsive control system in which the objective is to minimize the number of impulses. Our architecture recognizes that traditional ETC is a greedy strategy towards optimizing average inter-event times and introduces the idea of a deadline policy for the optimization of long-term discounted inter-event times. A lower layer is designed employing event-triggered control to guarantee the satisfaction of control objectives, while a higher layer implements a deadline policy designed with reinforcement learning to improve the discounted inter-event time. We apply this scheme to the control of an orbiting spacecraft, showing superior performance in terms of actuation frequency reduction with respect to a standard (one-layer) ETC while maintaining safety guarantees.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Formal Analysis of the Sampling Behaviour of Stochastic Event-Triggered Control
Authors:
Giannis Delimpaltadakis,
Luca Laurenti,
Manuel Mazo Jr
Abstract:
Analyzing Event-Triggered Control's (ETC) sampling behaviour is of paramount importance, as it enables formal assessment of its sampling performance and prediction of its sampling patterns. In this work, we formally analyze the sampling behaviour of stochastic linear periodic ETC (PETC) systems by computing bounds on associated metrics. Specifically, we consider functions over sequences of state m…
▽ More
Analyzing Event-Triggered Control's (ETC) sampling behaviour is of paramount importance, as it enables formal assessment of its sampling performance and prediction of its sampling patterns. In this work, we formally analyze the sampling behaviour of stochastic linear periodic ETC (PETC) systems by computing bounds on associated metrics. Specifically, we consider functions over sequences of state measurements and intersampling times that can be expressed as average, multiplicative or cumulative rewards, and introduce their expectations as metrics on PETC's sampling behaviour. We compute bounds on these expectations, by constructing appropriate Interval Markov Chains equipped with suitable reward structures, that abstract stochastic PETC's sampling behaviour. Our results are illustrated on a numerical example, for which we compute bounds on the expected average intersampling time and on the probability of triggering with the maximum possible intersampling time in a finite horizon.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Abstracting the Sampling Behaviour of Stochastic Linear Periodic Event-Triggered Control Systems
Authors:
Giannis Delimpaltadakis,
Luca Laurenti,
Manuel Mazo Jr
Abstract:
Recently, there have been efforts towards understanding the sampling behaviour of event-triggered control (ETC), for obtaining metrics on its sampling performance and predicting its sampling patterns. Finite-state abstractions, capturing the sampling behaviour of ETC systems, have proven promising in this respect. So far, such abstractions have been constructed for non-stochastic systems. Here, in…
▽ More
Recently, there have been efforts towards understanding the sampling behaviour of event-triggered control (ETC), for obtaining metrics on its sampling performance and predicting its sampling patterns. Finite-state abstractions, capturing the sampling behaviour of ETC systems, have proven promising in this respect. So far, such abstractions have been constructed for non-stochastic systems. Here, inspired by this framework, we abstract the sampling behaviour of stochastic narrow-sense linear periodic ETC (PETC) systems via Interval Markov Chains (IMCs). Particularly, we define functions over sequences of state-measurements and interevent times that can be expressed as discounted cumulative sums of rewards, and compute bounds on their expected values by constructing appropriate IMCs and equipping them with suitable rewards. Finally, we argue that our results are extendable to more general forms of functions, thus providing a generic framework to define and study various ETC sampling indicators.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021; v1 submitted 25 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Abstracting the Traffic of Nonlinear Event-Triggered Control Systems
Authors:
Giannis Delimpaltadakis,
Manuel Mazo Jr
Abstract:
Scheduling communication traffic in networks of event-triggered control (ETC) systems is challenging, as their sampling times are unknown, hindering application of ETC in networks. In previous work, finite-state abstractions were created, capturing the sampling behaviour of LTI ETC systems with quadratic triggering functions. Offering an infinite-horizon look to all sampling patterns of an ETC sys…
▽ More
Scheduling communication traffic in networks of event-triggered control (ETC) systems is challenging, as their sampling times are unknown, hindering application of ETC in networks. In previous work, finite-state abstractions were created, capturing the sampling behaviour of LTI ETC systems with quadratic triggering functions. Offering an infinite-horizon look to all sampling patterns of an ETC system, such abstractions can be used for scheduling of ETC traffic. Here we significantly extend this framework, by abstracting perturbed uncertain nonlinear ETC systems with general triggering functions. To construct an ETC system's abstraction: a) the state space is partitioned into regions, b) for each region an interval is determined, containing all intersampling times of points in the region, and c) the abstraction's transitions are determined through reachability analysis. To determine intervals and transitions, we devise algorithms based on reachability analysis. For partitioning, we propose an approach based on isochronous manifolds, resulting into tighter intervals and providing control over them, thus containing the abstraction's non-determinism. Simulations showcase our developments.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2021; v1 submitted 23 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Region-Based Self-Triggered Control for Perturbed and Uncertain Nonlinear Systems
Authors:
Giannis Delimpaltadakis,
Manuel Mazo Jr
Abstract:
In this work, we derive a region-based self-triggered control (STC) scheme for nonlinear systems with bounded disturbances and model uncertainties. The proposed STC scheme is able to guarantee different performance specifications (e.g. stability, boundedness, etc.), depending on the event-triggered control (ETC) triggering function that is chosen to be emulated. To deal with disturbances and uncer…
▽ More
In this work, we derive a region-based self-triggered control (STC) scheme for nonlinear systems with bounded disturbances and model uncertainties. The proposed STC scheme is able to guarantee different performance specifications (e.g. stability, boundedness, etc.), depending on the event-triggered control (ETC) triggering function that is chosen to be emulated. To deal with disturbances and uncertainties, we employ differential inclusions (DIs). By introducing ETC/STC notions in the context of DIs, we extend well-known results on ETC/STC to perturbed uncertain systems. Given these results, and adapting tools from our previous work, we derive inner-approximations of isochronous manifolds of perturbed uncertain ETC systems. These approximations dictate a partition of the state-space into regions, each of which is associated to a uniform inter-sampling time. At each sampling time instant, the controller checks to which region the measured state belongs and correspondingly decides the next sampling instant.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2021; v1 submitted 1 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Lyapunov Event-triggered Stabilization with a Known Convergence Rate
Authors:
Anton V. Proskurnikov,
Manuel Mazo Jr
Abstract:
A constructive tool of nonlinear control systems design, the method of Control Lyapunov Functions (CLF) has found numerous applications in stabilization problems for continuous time, discrete-time and hybrid systems. In this paper, we address the fundamental question: given a CLF, corresponding to the continuous-time controller with some predefined (e.g. exponential) convergence rate, can the same…
▽ More
A constructive tool of nonlinear control systems design, the method of Control Lyapunov Functions (CLF) has found numerous applications in stabilization problems for continuous time, discrete-time and hybrid systems. In this paper, we address the fundamental question: given a CLF, corresponding to the continuous-time controller with some predefined (e.g. exponential) convergence rate, can the same convergence rate be provided by an event-triggered controller? Under certain assumptions, we give an affirmative answer to this question and show that the corresponding event-based controllers provide positive dwelltimes between the consecutive events. Furthermore, we prove the existence of self-triggered and periodic event-triggered controllers, providing stabilization with a known convergence rate.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2020; v1 submitted 23 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Lyapunov Design for Event-Triggered Exponential Stabilization
Authors:
Anton V. Proskurnikov,
Manuel Mazo Jr
Abstract:
Control Lyapunov Functions (CLF) method gives a constructive tool for stabilization of nonlinear systems. To find a CLF, many methods have been proposed in the literature, e.g. backstepping for cascaded systems and sum of squares (SOS) programming for polynomial systems. Dealing with continuous-time systems, the CLF-based controller is also continuous-time, whereas practical implementation on a di…
▽ More
Control Lyapunov Functions (CLF) method gives a constructive tool for stabilization of nonlinear systems. To find a CLF, many methods have been proposed in the literature, e.g. backstepping for cascaded systems and sum of squares (SOS) programming for polynomial systems. Dealing with continuous-time systems, the CLF-based controller is also continuous-time, whereas practical implementation on a digital platform requires sampled-time control. In this paper, we show that if the continuous-time controller provides exponential stabilization, then an exponentially stabilizing event-triggered control strategy exists with the convergence rate arbitrarily close to the rate of the continuous-time system.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Solutions of Quadratic First-Order ODEs applied to Computer Vision Problems
Authors:
David Casillas-Perez,
Daniel Pizarro,
Manuel Mazo,
Adrien Bartoli
Abstract:
This article is a study about the existence and the uniqueness of solutions of a specific quadratic first-order ODE that frequently appears in multiple reconstruction problems. It is called the \emph{planar-perspective equation} due to the duality with the geometric problem of reconstruction of planar-perspective curves from their modulus. Solutions of the \emph{planar-perspective equation} are re…
▽ More
This article is a study about the existence and the uniqueness of solutions of a specific quadratic first-order ODE that frequently appears in multiple reconstruction problems. It is called the \emph{planar-perspective equation} due to the duality with the geometric problem of reconstruction of planar-perspective curves from their modulus. Solutions of the \emph{planar-perspective equation} are related with planar curves parametrized with perspective parametrization due to this geometric interpretation. The article proves the existence of only two local solutions to the \emph{initial value problem} with \emph{regular initial conditions} and a maximum of two analytic solutions with \emph{critical initial conditions}. The article also gives theorems to extend the local definition domain where the existence of both solutions are guaranteed. It introduces the \emph{maximal depth function} as a function that upper-bound all possible solutions of the \emph{planar-perspective equation} and contains all its possible \emph{critical points}. Finally, the article describes the \emph{maximal-depth solution problem} that consists of finding the solution of the referred equation that has maximum the depth and proves its uniqueness. It is an important problem as it does not need initial conditions to obtain the unique solution and its the frequent solution that practical algorithms of the state-of-the-art give.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2018; v1 submitted 11 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Symbolic Abstractions of Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Majid Zamani,
Manuel Mazo Jr,
Mahmoud Khaled,
Alessandro Abate
Abstract:
The last decade has witnessed significant attention on networked control systems (NCS) due to their ubiquitous presence in industrial applications, and, in the particular case of wireless NCS, because of their architectural flexibility and low installation and maintenance costs. In wireless NCS the communication between sensors, controllers, and actuators is supported by a communication channel th…
▽ More
The last decade has witnessed significant attention on networked control systems (NCS) due to their ubiquitous presence in industrial applications, and, in the particular case of wireless NCS, because of their architectural flexibility and low installation and maintenance costs. In wireless NCS the communication between sensors, controllers, and actuators is supported by a communication channel that is likely to introduce variable communication delays, packet losses, limited bandwidth, and other practical non-idealities leading to numerous technical challenges. Although stability properties of NCS have been investigated extensively in the literature, results for NCS under more complex and general objectives, and in particular results dealing with verification or controller synthesis for logical specifications, are much more limited. This work investigates how to address such complex objectives by constructively deriving symbolic models of NCS, while encompassing the mentioned network non-idealities. The obtained abstracted (symbolic) models can then be employed to synthesize hybrid controllers enforcing rich logical specifications over the concrete NCS models. Examples of such general specifications include properties expressed as formulae in linear temporal logic (LTL) or as automata on infinite strings. We thus provide a general synthesis framework that can be flexibly adapted to a number of NCS setups. We illustrate the effectiveness of the results over some case studies.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2016; v1 submitted 24 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Asynchronous Decentralized Event-triggered Control
Authors:
Manuel Mazo Jr,
Ming Cao
Abstract:
In this paper we propose an approach to the implementation of controllers with decentralized strategies triggering controller updates. We consider set-ups with a central node in charge of the computation of the control commands, and a set of not co-located sensors providing measurements to the controller node. The solution we propose does not require measurements from the sensors to be synchronize…
▽ More
In this paper we propose an approach to the implementation of controllers with decentralized strategies triggering controller updates. We consider set-ups with a central node in charge of the computation of the control commands, and a set of not co-located sensors providing measurements to the controller node. The solution we propose does not require measurements from the sensors to be synchronized in time. The sensors in our proposal provide measurements in an aperiodic way triggered by local conditions. Furthermore, in the proposed implementation (most of) the communication between nodes requires only the exchange of one bit of information (per controller update), which could aid in reducing transmission delays and as a secondary effect result in fewer transmissions being triggered.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2013; v1 submitted 28 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Symbolic Approximate Time-Optimal Control
Authors:
Manuel Mazo Jr.,
Paulo Tabuada
Abstract:
There is an increasing demand for controller design techniques capable of addressing the complex requirements of todays embedded applications. This demand has sparked the interest in symbolic control where lower complexity models of control systems are used to cater for complex specifications given by temporal logics, regular languages, or automata. These specification mechanisms can be regarded a…
▽ More
There is an increasing demand for controller design techniques capable of addressing the complex requirements of todays embedded applications. This demand has sparked the interest in symbolic control where lower complexity models of control systems are used to cater for complex specifications given by temporal logics, regular languages, or automata. These specification mechanisms can be regarded as qualitative since they divide the trajectories of the plant into bad trajectories (those that need to be avoided) and good trajectories. However, many applications require also the optimization of quantitative measures of the trajectories retained by the controller, as specified by a cost or utility function. As a first step towards the synthesis of controllers reconciling both qualitative and quantitative specifications, we investigate in this paper the use of symbolic models for time-optimal controller synthesis. We consider systems related by approximate (alternating) simulation relations and show how such relations enable the transfer of time-optimality information between the systems. We then use this insight to synthesize approximately time-optimal controllers for a control system by working with a lower complexity symbolic model. The resulting approximately time-optimal controllers are equipped with upper and lower bounds for the time to reach a target, describing the quality of the controller. The results described in this paper were implemented in the Matlab Toolbox Pessoa which we used to workout several illustrative examples reported in this paper.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2011; v1 submitted 5 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Decentralized event-triggered control over wireless sensor/actuator networks
Authors:
Manuel Mazo Jr.,
Paulo Tabuada
Abstract:
In recent years we have witnessed a move of the major industrial automation providers into the wireless domain. While most of these companies already offer wireless products for measurement and monitoring purposes, the ultimate goal is to be able to close feedback loops over wireless networks interconnecting sensors, computation devices, and actuators. In this paper we present a decentralized even…
▽ More
In recent years we have witnessed a move of the major industrial automation providers into the wireless domain. While most of these companies already offer wireless products for measurement and monitoring purposes, the ultimate goal is to be able to close feedback loops over wireless networks interconnecting sensors, computation devices, and actuators. In this paper we present a decentralized event-triggered implementation, over sensor/actuator networks, of centralized nonlinear controllers. Event-triggered control has been recently proposed as an alternative to the more traditional periodic execution of control tasks. In a typical event-triggered implementation, the control signals are kept constant until the violation of a condition on the state of the plant triggers the re-computation of the control signals. The possibility of reducing the number of re-computations, and thus of transmissions, while guaranteeing desired levels of performance makes event-triggered control very appealing in the context of sensor/actuator networks. In these systems the communication network is a shared resource and event-triggered implementations of control laws offer a flexible way to reduce network utilization. Moreover reducing the number of times that a feedback control law is executed implies a reduction in transmissions and thus a reduction in energy expenditures of battery powered wireless sensor nodes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2011; v1 submitted 3 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Symbolic models for nonlinear control systems without stability assumptions
Authors:
Majid Zamani,
Giordano Pola,
Manuel Mazo Jr.,
Paulo Tabuada
Abstract:
Finite-state models of control systems were proposed by several researchers as a convenient mechanism to synthesize controllers enforcing complex specifications. Most techniques for the construction of such symbolic models have two main drawbacks: either they can only be applied to restrictive classes of systems, or they require the exact computation of reachable sets. In this paper, we propose a…
▽ More
Finite-state models of control systems were proposed by several researchers as a convenient mechanism to synthesize controllers enforcing complex specifications. Most techniques for the construction of such symbolic models have two main drawbacks: either they can only be applied to restrictive classes of systems, or they require the exact computation of reachable sets. In this paper, we propose a new abstraction technique that is applicable to any smooth control system as long as we are only interested in its behavior in a compact set. Moreover, the exact computation of reachable sets is not required. The effectiveness of the proposed results is illustrated by synthesizing a controller to steer a vehicle.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2011; v1 submitted 3 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Superstability and Finite Time Extinction For C_0-Semigroups
Authors:
D. Creutz,
M. Mazo Jr.,
C. Preda
Abstract:
A new approach to superstability and finite time extinction of strongly continuous semigroups is presented, unifying known results and providing new criteria for these conditions to hold analogous to the well-known Pazy condition for stability. That finite time extinction implies superstability which is in turn equivalent to several (both known and new) conditions follow from this new approach in…
▽ More
A new approach to superstability and finite time extinction of strongly continuous semigroups is presented, unifying known results and providing new criteria for these conditions to hold analogous to the well-known Pazy condition for stability. That finite time extinction implies superstability which is in turn equivalent to several (both known and new) conditions follow from this new approach in a consistent fashion. Examples showing that the converse statements fail are constructed, in particular, an answer to a question of Balakrishnan on superstable systems not exhibiting finite time extinction.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2013; v1 submitted 27 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
An ISS self-triggered implementation of linear controller
Authors:
Manuel Mazo Jr.,
Adolfo Anta,
Paulo Tabuada
Abstract:
Nowadays control systems are mostly implemented on digital platforms and, increasingly, over shared communication networks. Reducing resources (processor utilization, network bandwidth, etc.) in such implementations increases the potential to run more applications on the same hardware. We present a self-triggered implementation of linear controllers that reduces the amount of controller updates ne…
▽ More
Nowadays control systems are mostly implemented on digital platforms and, increasingly, over shared communication networks. Reducing resources (processor utilization, network bandwidth, etc.) in such implementations increases the potential to run more applications on the same hardware. We present a self-triggered implementation of linear controllers that reduces the amount of controller updates necessary to retain stability of the closed-loop system. Furthermore, we show that the proposed self-triggered implementation is robust against additive disturbances and provide explicit guarantees of performance. The proposed technique exhibits an inherent trade-off between computation and potential savings on actuation.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2010; v1 submitted 19 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
