-
To Give or Not To Give: Pandemic Vaccine Donation Policy
Authors:
Abraham Holleran,
Susan E. Martonosi,
Michael Veatch
Abstract:
The global SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic highlighted the challenge of equitable vaccine distribution between high- and low-income countries. Many high-income countries were reluctant or slow to distribute extra doses of the vaccine to lower-income countries via the COVID-19 Vaccines Global Access (COVAX) collaboration. In addition to moral objections to such vaccine nationalism, vaccine inequity…
▽ More
The global SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic highlighted the challenge of equitable vaccine distribution between high- and low-income countries. Many high-income countries were reluctant or slow to distribute extra doses of the vaccine to lower-income countries via the COVID-19 Vaccines Global Access (COVAX) collaboration. In addition to moral objections to such vaccine nationalism, vaccine inequity during a pandemic could contribute to the evolution of new variants of the virus and possibly increase total deaths, including in the high-income countries. Using the COVID-19 pandemic as a case study, we use the epidemiological model of Holleran et al. that incorporates virus mutation. We identify realistic scenarios under which a donor country prefers to donate vaccines before distributing them locally in order to minimize local deaths during a pandemic. We demonstrate that a nondonor-first vaccination policy can delay, sometimes dramatically, the emergence of more-contagious variants. Even more surprising, donating all vaccines is sometimes better for the donor country than a sharing policy in which half of the vaccines are donated and half are retained because of the impact donation can have on delaying the emergence of a more contagious virus. Nondonor-first vaccine allocation is optimal in scenarios in which the local health impact of the vaccine is limited or when delaying emergence of a variant is especially valuable. In all cases, we find that vaccine distribution is not a zero-sum game between donor and nondonor countries. Thus, in addition to moral reasons to avoid vaccine nationalism, donor nations can also realize local health benefits from donating vaccines. The insights yielded by this framework can be used to guide equitable vaccine distribution in future pandemics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
International Vaccine Allocation: An Optimization Framework
Authors:
Abraham Holleran,
Susan E. Martonosi,
Michael Veatch
Abstract:
As observed during the COVID-19 pandemic, high-income countries, such as the U.S., may exhibit vaccine nationalism during a pandemic: stockpiling doses of vaccine for their own citizens and being reluctant to distribute doses of the vaccine to lower-income countries. While many cite moral objections to vaccine nationalism, vaccine inequity during a pandemic could possibly worsen the global effects…
▽ More
As observed during the COVID-19 pandemic, high-income countries, such as the U.S., may exhibit vaccine nationalism during a pandemic: stockpiling doses of vaccine for their own citizens and being reluctant to distribute doses of the vaccine to lower-income countries. While many cite moral objections to vaccine nationalism, vaccine inequity during a pandemic could possibly worsen the global effects of the pandemic, including in the high-income countries themselves, through the evolution of new variants of the virus. This paper uses the COVID-19 pandemic as a case study to identify scenarios under which it might be in a high-income nation's own interest to donate vaccine doses to another country before its own population has been fully vaccinated. We develop an extended SEIR (susceptible-exposed-infectious-recovered) epidemiological model embedded in an optimization framework and examine scenarios involving a single donor and multiple recipient (nondonor) geographic areas. We find that policies other than donor-first can delay the emergence of a more-contagious variant compared to donor-first, sometimes reducing donor-country deaths in addition to total deaths. Thus, vaccine distribution is not a zero-sum game between donor and nondonor countries: an optimization approach can achieve a dramatic reduction in total deaths with only a small increase in donor-country deaths. The iterative linear programming approximation approach we develop can help confirm those instances when a priority policy is optimal and, when not optimal, can identify superior policies. This optimization framework can be used to guide equitable vaccine distribution in future pandemics.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Predicting Elite NBA Lineups Using Individual Player Order Statistics
Authors:
Susan E. Martonosi,
Martin Gonzalez,
Nicolas Oshiro
Abstract:
NBA team managers and owners try to acquire high-performing players. An important consideration in these decisions is how well the new players will perform in combination with their teammates. Our objective is to identify elite five-person lineups, which we define as those having a positive plus-minus per minute (PMM). Using individual player order statistics, our model can identify an elite lineu…
▽ More
NBA team managers and owners try to acquire high-performing players. An important consideration in these decisions is how well the new players will perform in combination with their teammates. Our objective is to identify elite five-person lineups, which we define as those having a positive plus-minus per minute (PMM). Using individual player order statistics, our model can identify an elite lineup even if the five players in the lineup have never played together, which can inform player acquisition decisions, salary negotiations, and real-time coaching decisions. We combine seven classification tools into a unanimous consent classifier (all-or-nothing classifier, or ANC) in which a lineup is predicted to be elite only if all seven classifiers predict it to be elite. In this way, we achieve high positive predictive value (i.e., precision), the likelihood that a lineup classified as elite will indeed have a positive PMM. We train and test the model on individual player and lineup data from the 2017-18 season and use the model to predict the performance of lineups drawn from all 30 NBA teams' 2018-19 regular season rosters. Although the ANC is conservative and misses some high-performing lineups, it achieves high precision and recommends positionally balanced lineups.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Multi-year optimization of malaria intervention: a mathematical model
Authors:
Harry J. Dudley,
Abhishek Goenka,
Cesar J. Orellana,
Susan E. Martonosi
Abstract:
Malaria is a mosquito-borne, lethal disease that affects millions and kills hundreds of thousands of people each year. In this paper, we develop a model for allocating malaria interventions across geographic regions and time, subject to budget constraints, with the aim of minimizing the number of person-days of malaria infection. The model considers a range of several conditions: climatic characte…
▽ More
Malaria is a mosquito-borne, lethal disease that affects millions and kills hundreds of thousands of people each year. In this paper, we develop a model for allocating malaria interventions across geographic regions and time, subject to budget constraints, with the aim of minimizing the number of person-days of malaria infection. The model considers a range of several conditions: climatic characteristics, treatment efficacy, distribution costs, and treatment coverage. We couple an expanded susceptible-infected-recovered (SIR) compartment model for the disease dynamics with an integer linear programming (ILP) model for selecting the disease interventions. Our model produces an intervention plan for all regions, identifying which combination of interventions, with which level of coverage, to use in each region and year in a five-year planning horizon. Simulations using the model yield high-level, qualitative insights on optimal intervention policies: The optimal policy is different when considering a five-year time horizon than when considering only a single year, due to the effects that interventions have on the disease transmission dynamics. The vaccine intervention is rarely selected, except if its assumed cost is significantly lower than that predicted in the literature. Increasing the available budget causes the number of person-days of malaria infection to decrease linearly up to a point, after which the benefit of increased budget starts to taper. The optimal policy is highly dependent on assumptions about mosquito density, selecting different interventions for wet climates with high density than for dry climates with low density, and the interventions are found to be less effective at controlling malaria in the wet climates when attainable intervention coverage is 60% or lower. However, when intervention coverage of 80% is attainable, then malaria prevalence drops quickly.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2016; v1 submitted 4 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
A New Framework for Network Disruption
Authors:
Susan E. Martonosi,
Doug Altner,
Michael Ernst,
Elizabeth Ferme,
Kira Langsjoen,
Danika Lindsay,
Sean Plott,
Andrew S. Ronan
Abstract:
Traditional network disruption approaches focus on disconnecting or lengthening paths in the network. We present a new framework for network disruption that attempts to reroute flow through critical vertices via vertex deletion, under the assumption that this will render those vertices vulnerable to future attacks. We define the load on a critical vertex to be the number of paths in the network th…
▽ More
Traditional network disruption approaches focus on disconnecting or lengthening paths in the network. We present a new framework for network disruption that attempts to reroute flow through critical vertices via vertex deletion, under the assumption that this will render those vertices vulnerable to future attacks. We define the load on a critical vertex to be the number of paths in the network that must flow through the vertex. We present graph-theoretic and computational techniques to maximize this load, firstly by removing either a single vertex from the network, secondly by removing a subset of vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Characteristics of Optimal Solutions to the Sensor Location Problem
Authors:
David R. Morrison,
Susan E. Martonosi
Abstract:
In [Bianco, L., Giuseppe C., and P. Reverberi. 2001. "A network based model for traffic sensor location with implications on O/D matrix estimates". Transportation Science 35(1):50-60.], the authors present the Sensor Location Problem: that of locating the minimum number of traffic sensors at intersections of a road network such that the traffic flow on the entire network can be determined. They of…
▽ More
In [Bianco, L., Giuseppe C., and P. Reverberi. 2001. "A network based model for traffic sensor location with implications on O/D matrix estimates". Transportation Science 35(1):50-60.], the authors present the Sensor Location Problem: that of locating the minimum number of traffic sensors at intersections of a road network such that the traffic flow on the entire network can be determined. They offer a necessary and sufficient condition on the set of monitored nodes in order for the flow everywhere to be determined. In this paper, we present a counterexample that demonstrates that the condition is not actually sufficient (though it is still necessary). We present a stronger necessary condition for flow calculability, and show that it is a sufficient condition in a large class of graphs in which a particular subgraph is a tree. Many typical road networks are included in this category, and we show how our condition can be used to inform traffic sensor placement.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
