-
A packing lemma for VCN${}_k$-dimension and learning high-dimensional data
Authors:
Leonardo N. Coregliano,
Maryanthe Malliaris
Abstract:
Recently, the authors introduced the theory of high-arity PAC learning, which is well-suited for learning graphs, hypergraphs and relational structures. In the same initial work, the authors proved a high-arity analogue of the Fundamental Theorem of Statistical Learning that almost completely characterizes all notions of high-arity PAC learning in terms of a combinatorial dimension, called the Vap…
▽ More
Recently, the authors introduced the theory of high-arity PAC learning, which is well-suited for learning graphs, hypergraphs and relational structures. In the same initial work, the authors proved a high-arity analogue of the Fundamental Theorem of Statistical Learning that almost completely characterizes all notions of high-arity PAC learning in terms of a combinatorial dimension, called the Vapnik--Chervonenkis--Natarajan (VCN${}_k$) $k$-dimension, leaving as an open problem only the characterization of non-partite, non-agnostic high-arity PAC learnability.
In this work, we complete this characterization by proving that non-partite non-agnostic high-arity PAC learnability implies a high-arity version of the Haussler packing property, which in turn implies finiteness of VCN${}_k$-dimension. This is done by obtaining direct proofs that classic PAC learnability implies classic Haussler packing property, which in turn implies finite Natarajan dimension and noticing that these direct proofs nicely lift to high-arity.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
High-arity PAC learning via exchangeability
Authors:
Leonardo N. Coregliano,
Maryanthe Malliaris
Abstract:
We develop a theory of high-arity PAC learning, which is statistical learning in the presence of "structured correlation". In this theory, hypotheses are either graphs, hypergraphs or, more generally, structures in finite relational languages, and i.i.d. sampling is replaced by sampling an induced substructure, producing an exchangeable distribution. Our main theorems establish a high-arity (agnos…
▽ More
We develop a theory of high-arity PAC learning, which is statistical learning in the presence of "structured correlation". In this theory, hypotheses are either graphs, hypergraphs or, more generally, structures in finite relational languages, and i.i.d. sampling is replaced by sampling an induced substructure, producing an exchangeable distribution. Our main theorems establish a high-arity (agnostic) version of the fundamental theorem of statistical learning.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2024; v1 submitted 22 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Realizing Infinity
Authors:
Maryanthe Malliaris,
Assaf Peretz
Abstract:
What happens when mathematics realizes infinity. When are mathematical definitions actually useful?
What happens when mathematics realizes infinity. When are mathematical definitions actually useful?
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The unstable formula theorem revisited via algorithms
Authors:
Maryanthe Malliaris,
Shay Moran
Abstract:
This paper is about the surprising interaction of a foundational result from model theory, about stability of theories, with algorithmic stability in learning. First, in response to gaps in existing learning models, we introduce a new statistical learning model, called ``Probably Eventually Correct'' or PEC. We characterize Littlestone (stable) classes in terms of this model. As a corollary, Littl…
▽ More
This paper is about the surprising interaction of a foundational result from model theory, about stability of theories, with algorithmic stability in learning. First, in response to gaps in existing learning models, we introduce a new statistical learning model, called ``Probably Eventually Correct'' or PEC. We characterize Littlestone (stable) classes in terms of this model. As a corollary, Littlestone classes have frequent short definitions in a natural statistical sense. In order to obtain a characterization of Littlestone classes in terms of frequent definitions, we build an equivalence theorem highlighting what is common to many existing approximation algorithms, and to the new PEC. This is guided by an analogy to definability of types in model theory, but has its own character. Drawing on these theorems and on other recent work, we present a complete algorithmic analogue of Shelah's celebrated Unstable Formula Theorem, with algorithmic properties taking the place of the infinite.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2025; v1 submitted 9 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Weak randomness in graphons and theons
Authors:
Leonardo N. Coregliano,
Maryanthe Malliaris
Abstract:
Call a hereditary family $\mathcal{F}$ of graphs strongly persistent if there exists a graphon $W$ such that in all subgraphons $W'$ of $W$, $\mathcal{F}$ is precisely the class of finite graphs that have positive density in $W'$. Our first result is a complete characterization of the hereditary families of graphs that are strongly persistent as precisely those that are closed under substitutions.…
▽ More
Call a hereditary family $\mathcal{F}$ of graphs strongly persistent if there exists a graphon $W$ such that in all subgraphons $W'$ of $W$, $\mathcal{F}$ is precisely the class of finite graphs that have positive density in $W'$. Our first result is a complete characterization of the hereditary families of graphs that are strongly persistent as precisely those that are closed under substitutions.
We call graphons with the self-similarity property above weakly random. A hereditary family $\mathcal{F}$ is said to have the weakly random Erdős--Hajnal property (WR) if every graphon that is a limit of graphs in $\mathcal{F}$ has a weakly random subgraphon. Among families of graphs that are closed under substitutions, we completely characterize the families that belong to WR as those with "few" prime graphs.
We also extend some of the results above to structures in finite relational languages by using the theory of theons.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2024; v1 submitted 18 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Countable Ramsey
Authors:
Leonardo N. Coregliano,
Maryanthe Malliaris
Abstract:
The celebrated Erdős-Hajnal Conjecture says that in any proper hereditary class of finite graphs we are guaranteed to have a clique or anti-clique of size $n^c$, which is a much better bound than the logarithmic size that is provided by Ramsey's Theorem in general. On the other hand, in uncountable cardinalities, the model-theoretic property of stability guarantees a uniform set much larger than t…
▽ More
The celebrated Erdős-Hajnal Conjecture says that in any proper hereditary class of finite graphs we are guaranteed to have a clique or anti-clique of size $n^c$, which is a much better bound than the logarithmic size that is provided by Ramsey's Theorem in general. On the other hand, in uncountable cardinalities, the model-theoretic property of stability guarantees a uniform set much larger than the bound provided by the Erdős-Rado Theorem in general.
Even though the consequences of stability in the finite have been much studied in the literature, the countable setting seems a priori quite different, namely, in the countably infinite the notion of largeness based on cardinality alone does not reveal any structure as Ramsey's Theorem already provides a countably infinite uniform set in general. In this paper, we show that the natural notion of largeness given by upper density reveals that these phenomena meet in the countable: a countable graph has an almost clique or anti-clique of positive upper density if and only if it has a positive upper density almost stable set. Moreover, this result also extends naturally to countable models of a universal theory in a finite relational language.
Our methods explore a connection with the notion of convergence in the theory of limits of dense combinatorial objects, introducing and studying a natural approximate version of the Erdős-Hajnal property that allows for a negligible error in the edges (in general, predicates) but requires linear-sized uniform sets in convergent sequences of models (this is much stronger than what stable regularity can provide as the error is required to go to zero). Finally, surprisingly, we completely characterize all hereditary classes of finite graphs that have this approximate Erdős-Hajnal property. The proof highlights both differences and similarities with the original conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2022; v1 submitted 19 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Shearing in some simple rank one theories
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
Dividing asks about inconsistency along indiscernible sequences. In order to study the finer structure of simple theories without much dividing, the authors recently introduced shearing, which essentially asks about inconsistency along generalized indiscernible sequences. Here we characterize the shearing of the random graph. We then use shearing to distinguish between the random graph and the the…
▽ More
Dividing asks about inconsistency along indiscernible sequences. In order to study the finer structure of simple theories without much dividing, the authors recently introduced shearing, which essentially asks about inconsistency along generalized indiscernible sequences. Here we characterize the shearing of the random graph. We then use shearing to distinguish between the random graph and the theories $T_{n,k}$, the higher-order analogues of the triangle-free random graph. It follows that shearing is distinct from dividing in simple unstable theories, and distinguishes meaningfully between classes of simple unstable rank one theories. The paper begins with an overview of shearing, and includes open questions.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2023; v1 submitted 26 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Agnostic Online Learning and Excellent Sets
Authors:
Maryanthe Malliaris,
Shay Moran
Abstract:
We use algorithmic methods from online learning to explore some important objects at the intersection of model theory and combinatorics, and find natural ways that algorithmic methods can detect and explain (and improve our understanding of) stable structure in the sense of model theory. The main theorem deals with existence of $ε$-excellent sets (which are key to the Stable Regularity Lemma, a th…
▽ More
We use algorithmic methods from online learning to explore some important objects at the intersection of model theory and combinatorics, and find natural ways that algorithmic methods can detect and explain (and improve our understanding of) stable structure in the sense of model theory. The main theorem deals with existence of $ε$-excellent sets (which are key to the Stable Regularity Lemma, a theorem characterizing the appearance of irregular pairs in Szemerédi's celebrated Regularity Lemma). We prove that $ε$-excellent sets exist for any $ε< \frac{1}{2}$ in $k$-edge stable graphs in the sense of model theory (equivalently, Littlestone classes); earlier proofs had given this only for $ε< 1/{2^{2^k}}$ or so. We give two proofs: the first uses regret bounds from online learning, the second uses Boolean closure properties of Littlestone classes and sampling. We also give a version of the dynamic Sauer-Shelah-Perles lemma appropriate to this setting, related to definability of types. We conclude by characterizing stable/Littlestone classes as those supporting a certain abstract notion of majority: the proof shows that the two distinct, natural notions of majority, arising from measure and from dimension, densely often coincide.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2025; v1 submitted 12 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
New simple theories from hypergraph sequences
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We develop a family of simple rank one theories built over quite arbitrary sequences of finite hypergraphs. (This extends an idea from the recent proof that Keisler's order has continuum many classes, however, the construction does not require familiarity with the earlier proof.) We prove a model-completion and quantifier-elimination result for theories in this family. We develop a combinatorial p…
▽ More
We develop a family of simple rank one theories built over quite arbitrary sequences of finite hypergraphs. (This extends an idea from the recent proof that Keisler's order has continuum many classes, however, the construction does not require familiarity with the earlier proof.) We prove a model-completion and quantifier-elimination result for theories in this family. We develop a combinatorial property which they share. We invoke regular ultrafilters to show the strength of this property, showing that any flexible ultrafilter which is good for the random graph is able to saturate such theories.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2023; v1 submitted 12 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Some simple theories from a Boolean algebra point of view
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We find a strong separation between two natural families of simple rank one theories in Keisler's order: the theories $T_\mathfrak{m}$ reflecting graph sequences, which witness that Keisler's order has the maximum number of classes, and the theories $T_{n,k}$, which are the higher-order analogues of the triangle-free random graph. The proof involves building Boolean algebras and ultrafilters "by h…
▽ More
We find a strong separation between two natural families of simple rank one theories in Keisler's order: the theories $T_\mathfrak{m}$ reflecting graph sequences, which witness that Keisler's order has the maximum number of classes, and the theories $T_{n,k}$, which are the higher-order analogues of the triangle-free random graph. The proof involves building Boolean algebras and ultrafilters "by hand" to satisfy certain model theoretically meaningful chain conditions. This may be seen as advancing a line of work going back through Kunen's construction of good ultrafilters in ZFC using families of independent functions. We conclude with a theorem on flexible ultrafilters, and open questions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2023; v1 submitted 11 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Complexity and randomness in the Heisenberg groups (and beyond)
Authors:
Persi Diaconis,
Maryanthe Malliaris
Abstract:
By studying the commuting graphs of conjugacy classes of the sequence of Heisenberg groups $H_{2n+1}(p)$ and their limit $H_\infty(p)$ we find pseudo-random behavior (and the random graph in the limiting case). This makes a nice case study for transfer of information between finite and infinite objects. Some of this behavior transfers to the problem of understanding what makes understanding the ch…
▽ More
By studying the commuting graphs of conjugacy classes of the sequence of Heisenberg groups $H_{2n+1}(p)$ and their limit $H_\infty(p)$ we find pseudo-random behavior (and the random graph in the limiting case). This makes a nice case study for transfer of information between finite and infinite objects. Some of this behavior transfers to the problem of understanding what makes understanding the character theory of the uni-upper-triangular group (mod p) "wild". Our investigations in this paper may be seen as a meditation on the question: is randomness simple or is it complicated?
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2021; v1 submitted 6 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Notes on the stable regularity lemma
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
This is a short expository account of the regularity lemma for stable graphs proved by the authors, with some comments on the model theoretic context, written for a general logical audience.
This is a short expository account of the regularity lemma for stable graphs proved by the authors, with some comments on the model theoretic context, written for a general logical audience.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2021; v1 submitted 17 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Keisler's order is not simple (and simple theories may not be either)
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
Solving a decades-old problem we show that Keisler's 1967 order on theories has the maximum number of classes. The theories we build are simple unstable with no nontrivial forking, and reflect growth rates of sequences which may be thought of as densities of certain regular pairs, in the sense of Szemerédi's regularity lemma. The proof involves ideas from model theory, set theory, and finite combi…
▽ More
Solving a decades-old problem we show that Keisler's 1967 order on theories has the maximum number of classes. The theories we build are simple unstable with no nontrivial forking, and reflect growth rates of sequences which may be thought of as densities of certain regular pairs, in the sense of Szemerédi's regularity lemma. The proof involves ideas from model theory, set theory, and finite combinatorics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2021; v1 submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
A separation theorem for simple theories
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
This paper builds model-theoretic tools to detect changes in complexity among the simple theories. We develop a generalization of dividing, called shearing, which depends on a so-called context c. This leads to defining c-superstability, a syntactical notion, which includes supersimplicity as a special case. We prove a separation theorem showing that for any countable context c and any two theorie…
▽ More
This paper builds model-theoretic tools to detect changes in complexity among the simple theories. We develop a generalization of dividing, called shearing, which depends on a so-called context c. This leads to defining c-superstability, a syntactical notion, which includes supersimplicity as a special case. We prove a separation theorem showing that for any countable context c and any two theories $T_1$, $T_2$ such that $T_1$ is c-superstable and $T_2$ is c-unsuperstable, and for arbitrarily large $μ$, it is possible to build models of any theory interpreting both $T_1$ and $T_2$ whose restriction to $τ(T_1)$ is $μ$-saturated and whose restriction to $τ(T_2)$ is not $\aleph_1$-saturated. (This suggests "c-superstable" is really a dividing line.) The proof uses generalized Ehrenfeucht-Mostowski models, and along the way, we clarify the use of these techniques to realize certain types while omitting others. In some sense, shearing allows us to study the interaction of complexity coming from the usual notion of dividing in simple theories and the more combinatorial complexity detected by the general definition. This work is inspired by our recent progress on Keisler's order, but does not use ultrafilters, rather aiming to build up the internal model theory of these classes.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2021; v1 submitted 22 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Private PAC learning implies finite Littlestone dimension
Authors:
Noga Alon,
Roi Livni,
Maryanthe Malliaris,
Shay Moran
Abstract:
We show that every approximately differentially private learning algorithm (possibly improper) for a class $H$ with Littlestone dimension~$d$ requires $Ω\bigl(\log^*(d)\bigr)$ examples. As a corollary it follows that the class of thresholds over $\mathbb{N}$ can not be learned in a private manner; this resolves open question due to [Bun et al., 2015, Feldman and Xiao, 2015]. We leave as an open qu…
▽ More
We show that every approximately differentially private learning algorithm (possibly improper) for a class $H$ with Littlestone dimension~$d$ requires $Ω\bigl(\log^*(d)\bigr)$ examples. As a corollary it follows that the class of thresholds over $\mathbb{N}$ can not be learned in a private manner; this resolves open question due to [Bun et al., 2015, Feldman and Xiao, 2015]. We leave as an open question whether every class with a finite Littlestone dimension can be learned by an approximately differentially private algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2019; v1 submitted 4 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
An example of a new simple theory
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We construct a countable simple theory which, in Keisler's order, is strictly above the random graph (but "barely so") and also in some sense orthogonal to the building blocks of the recently discovered infinite descending chain. As a result we prove in ZFC that there are incomparable classes in Keisler's order.
We construct a countable simple theory which, in Keisler's order, is strictly above the random graph (but "barely so") and also in some sense orthogonal to the building blocks of the recently discovered infinite descending chain. As a result we prove in ZFC that there are incomparable classes in Keisler's order.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2019; v1 submitted 9 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Model theory and ultraproducts
Authors:
M. Malliaris
Abstract:
The article motivates recent work on saturation of ultrapowers from a general mathematical point of view.
The article motivates recent work on saturation of ultrapowers from a general mathematical point of view.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A new look at interpretability and saturation
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We investigate the interpretability ordering $\trianglelefteq^*$ using generalized Ehrenfeucht-Mostowski models. This gives a new approach to proving inequalities and investigating the structure of types.
We investigate the interpretability ordering $\trianglelefteq^*$ using generalized Ehrenfeucht-Mostowski models. This gives a new approach to proving inequalities and investigating the structure of types.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2019; v1 submitted 14 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Notes on Cofinality Spectrum Problems
Authors:
David Casey,
Maryanthe Malliaris
Abstract:
These notes are based on Appalachian Set Theory lectures given by M. Malliaris on November 5, 2016 with D. Casey as the official scribe. The aim of the lectures was to present the setup and some key arguments of "Cofinality spectrum problems in model theory, set theory and general topology" by Malliaris and Shelah. This provides a sketch of the proof that $\mathfrak{p} = \mathfrak{t}$ and that…
▽ More
These notes are based on Appalachian Set Theory lectures given by M. Malliaris on November 5, 2016 with D. Casey as the official scribe. The aim of the lectures was to present the setup and some key arguments of "Cofinality spectrum problems in model theory, set theory and general topology" by Malliaris and Shelah. This provides a sketch of the proof that $\mathfrak{p} = \mathfrak{t}$ and that $SOP_2$ theories are maximal in Keisler's Order.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
On unavoidable induced subgraphs in large prime graphs
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
C. Terry
Abstract:
Chudnovsky, Kim, Oum, and Seymour recently established that any prime graph contains one of a short list of induced prime subgraphs [1]. In the present paper we reprove their theorem using many of the same ideas, but with the key model-theoretic ingredient of first determining the so-called amount of stability of the graph. This approach changes the applicable Ramsey theorem, improves the bounds a…
▽ More
Chudnovsky, Kim, Oum, and Seymour recently established that any prime graph contains one of a short list of induced prime subgraphs [1]. In the present paper we reprove their theorem using many of the same ideas, but with the key model-theoretic ingredient of first determining the so-called amount of stability of the graph. This approach changes the applicable Ramsey theorem, improves the bounds and offers a different structural perspective on the graphs in question. Complementing this, we give an infinitary proof which implies the finite result.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
The stable regularity lemma revisited
Authors:
Maryanthe Malliaris,
Anand Pillay
Abstract:
We prove a regularity lemma with respect to arbitrary Keisler measures mu on V, nu on W where the bipartite graph (V,W,R) is definable in a saturated structure M and the formula R(x,y) is stable. The proof is rather quick and uses local stability theory. The special case where (V,W,R) is pseudofinite, mu, nu are the counting measures and M is suitably chosen (for example a nonstandard model of set…
▽ More
We prove a regularity lemma with respect to arbitrary Keisler measures mu on V, nu on W where the bipartite graph (V,W,R) is definable in a saturated structure M and the formula R(x,y) is stable. The proof is rather quick and uses local stability theory. The special case where (V,W,R) is pseudofinite, mu, nu are the counting measures and M is suitably chosen (for example a nonstandard model of set theory), yields the stable regularity theorem of Malliaris-Shelah (Transactions AMS, 366, 2014, 1551-1585), though without explicit bounds or equitability.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2015; v1 submitted 23 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Keisler's order has infinitely many classes
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We prove, in ZFC, that there is an infinite strictly descending chain of classes of theories in Keisler's order. Thus Keisler's order is infinite and not a well order. Moreover, this chain occurs within the simple unstable theories, considered model-theoretically tame. Keisler's order is a central notion of the model theory of the 60s and 70s which compares first-order theories (and implicitly ult…
▽ More
We prove, in ZFC, that there is an infinite strictly descending chain of classes of theories in Keisler's order. Thus Keisler's order is infinite and not a well order. Moreover, this chain occurs within the simple unstable theories, considered model-theoretically tame. Keisler's order is a central notion of the model theory of the 60s and 70s which compares first-order theories (and implicitly ultrafilters) according to saturation of ultrapowers. Prior to this paper, it was long thought to have finitely many classes, linearly ordered. The model-theoretic complexity we find is witnessed by a very natural class of theories, the $n$-free $k$-hypergraphs studied by Hrushovski. This complexity reflects the difficulty of amalgamation and appears orthogonal to forking.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2015; v1 submitted 28 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Model-theoretic applications of cofinality spectrum problems
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We apply the recently developed technology of cofinality spectrum problems to prove a range of theorems in model theory. First, we prove that any model of Peano arithmetic is $λ$-saturated iff it has cofinality $\geq λ$ and the underlying order has no $(κ, κ)$-cuts for regular $κ< λ$. Second, assuming instances of GCH, we prove that $SOP_2$ characterizes maximality in the interpretability order…
▽ More
We apply the recently developed technology of cofinality spectrum problems to prove a range of theorems in model theory. First, we prove that any model of Peano arithmetic is $λ$-saturated iff it has cofinality $\geq λ$ and the underlying order has no $(κ, κ)$-cuts for regular $κ< λ$. Second, assuming instances of GCH, we prove that $SOP_2$ characterizes maximality in the interpretability order $\trianglelefteq^*$, settling a prior conjecture and proving that $SOP_2$ is a real dividing line. Third, we establish the beginnings of a structure theory for $NSOP_2$, proving that $NSOP_2$ can be characterized by the existence of few inconsistent higher formulas. In the course of the paper, we show that $\mathfrak{p}_s = \mathfrak{t}_s$ in any weak cofinality spectrum problem closed under exponentiation (naturally defined). We also prove that the local versions of these cardinals need not coincide, even in cofinality spectrum problems arising from Peano arithmetic.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Existence of optimal ultrafilters and the fundamental complexity of simple theories
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
In the first edition of Classification Theory, the second author characterized the stable theories in terms of saturation of ultrapowers. Prior to this theorem, stability had already been defined in terms of counting types, and the unstable formula theorem was known. A contribution of the ultrapower characterization was that it involved sorting out the global theory, and introducing nonforking, se…
▽ More
In the first edition of Classification Theory, the second author characterized the stable theories in terms of saturation of ultrapowers. Prior to this theorem, stability had already been defined in terms of counting types, and the unstable formula theorem was known. A contribution of the ultrapower characterization was that it involved sorting out the global theory, and introducing nonforking, seminal for the development of stability theory. Prior to the present paper, there had been no such characterization of an unstable class. In the present paper, we first establish the existence of so-called optimal ultrafilters on Boolean algebras, which are to simple theories as Keisler's good ultrafilters are to all theories. Then, assuming a supercompact cardinal, we characterize the simple theories in terms of saturation of ultrapowers. To do so, we lay the groundwork for analyzing the global structure of simple theories, in ZFC, via complexity of certain amalgamation patterns. This brings into focus a fundamental complexity in simple unstable theories having no real analogue in stability.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2015; v1 submitted 10 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Saturating the random graph with an independent family of small range
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
Motivated by Keisler's order, a far-reaching program of understanding basic model-theoretic structure through the lens of regular ultrapowers, we prove that for a class of regular filters $D$ on $I$, $|I| = λ> \aleph_0$, the fact that $P(I)/\de$ has little freedom (as measured by the fact that any maximal antichain is of size $<λ$, or even countable) does not prevent extending $D$ to an ultrafilte…
▽ More
Motivated by Keisler's order, a far-reaching program of understanding basic model-theoretic structure through the lens of regular ultrapowers, we prove that for a class of regular filters $D$ on $I$, $|I| = λ> \aleph_0$, the fact that $P(I)/\de$ has little freedom (as measured by the fact that any maximal antichain is of size $<λ$, or even countable) does not prevent extending $D$ to an ultrafilter $D_1$ on $I$ which saturates ultrapowers of the random graph. "Saturates" means that $M^I/\de_1$ is $λ^+$-saturated whenever M is a model of the theory of the random graph. This was known to be true for stable theories, and false for non-simple and non-low theories. This result and the techniques introduced in the proof have catalyzed the authors' subsequent work on Keisler's order for simple unstable theories. The introduction, which includes a part written for model theorists and a part written for set theorists, discusses our current program and related results.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Cofinality spectrum theorems in model theory, set theory and general topology
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We connect and solve two longstanding open problems in quite different areas: the model-theoretic question of whether $SOP_2$ is maximal in Keisler's order, and the question from set theory/general topology of whether $\mathfrak{p} = \mathfrak{t}$, the oldest problem on cardinal invariants of the continuum. We do so by showing these problems can be translated into instances of a more fundamental p…
▽ More
We connect and solve two longstanding open problems in quite different areas: the model-theoretic question of whether $SOP_2$ is maximal in Keisler's order, and the question from set theory/general topology of whether $\mathfrak{p} = \mathfrak{t}$, the oldest problem on cardinal invariants of the continuum. We do so by showing these problems can be translated into instances of a more fundamental problem which we state and solve completely, using model-theoretic methods.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2015; v1 submitted 27 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Model-theoretic properties of ultrafilters built by independent families of functions
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
Our results in this paper increase the model-theoretic precision of a widely used method for building ultrafilters, and so advance the general problem of constructing ultrafilters whose ultrapowers have a precise degree of saturation. We begin by showing that any flexible regular ultrafilter makes the product of an unbounded sequence of finite cardinals large, {thus} saturating any stable theory.…
▽ More
Our results in this paper increase the model-theoretic precision of a widely used method for building ultrafilters, and so advance the general problem of constructing ultrafilters whose ultrapowers have a precise degree of saturation. We begin by showing that any flexible regular ultrafilter makes the product of an unbounded sequence of finite cardinals large, {thus} saturating any stable theory. We then prove directly that a "bottleneck" in the inductive construction of a regular ultrafilter on $λ$ (i.e. a point after which all antichains of $P(λ)/D$ have cardinality less than $λ$) essentially prevents any subsequent ultrafilter from being flexible, {thus} from saturating any non-low theory. The paper's three main constructions are as follows. First, we construct a regular filter $D$ on $λ$ so that any ultrafilter extending $D$ fails to $λ^+$-saturate ultrapowers of the random graph, {thus} of any unstable theory. The proof constructs the omitted random graph type directly. Second, assuming existence of a measurable cardinal $κ$, we construct a regular ultrafilter on $λ> κ$ which is $λ$-flexible but not $κ^{++}$-good, improving our previous answer to a question raised in Dow 1975. Third, assuming a weakly compact cardinal $κ$, we construct an ultrafilter to show that $\lcf(\aleph_0)$ may be small while all symmetric cuts of cofinality $κ$ are realized. Thus certain families of pre-cuts may be realized while still failing to saturate any unstable theory.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
A Dividing Line Within Simple Unstable Theories
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
We give the first (ZFC) dividing line in Keisler's order among the unstable theories, specifically among the simple unstable theories. That is, for any infinite cardinal $λ$ for which there is $μ< λ\leq 2^μ$, we construct a regular ultrafilter D on $λ$ such that (i) for any model $M$ of a stable theory or of the random graph, $M^λ/D$ is $λ^+$-saturated but (ii) if $Th(N)$ is not simple or not low…
▽ More
We give the first (ZFC) dividing line in Keisler's order among the unstable theories, specifically among the simple unstable theories. That is, for any infinite cardinal $λ$ for which there is $μ< λ\leq 2^μ$, we construct a regular ultrafilter D on $λ$ such that (i) for any model $M$ of a stable theory or of the random graph, $M^λ/D$ is $λ^+$-saturated but (ii) if $Th(N)$ is not simple or not low then $N^λ/D$ is not $λ^+$-saturated. The non-saturation result relies on the notion of flexible ultrafilters. To prove the saturation result we develop a property of a class of simple theories, called Qr1, generalizing the fact that whenever $B$ is a set of parameters in some sufficiently saturated model of the random graph, $|B| = λ$ and $μ< λ\leq 2^μ$, then there is a set $A$ with $|A| = μ$ such that any non-algebraic $p \in S(B)$ is finitely realized in $A$. In addition to giving information about simple unstable theories, our proof reframes the problem of saturation of ultrapowers in several key ways. We give a new characterization of good filters in terms of "excellence," a measure of the accuracy of the quotient Boolean algebra. We introduce and develop the notion of {moral} ultrafilters on Boolean algebras. We prove a so-called "separation of variables" result which shows how the problem of constructing ultrafilters to have a precise degree of saturation may be profitably separated into a more set-theoretic stage, building an excellent filter, followed by a more model-theoretic stage: building moral ultrafilters on the quotient Boolean algebra, a process which highlights the complexity of certain patterns, arising from first-order formulas, in certain Boolean algebras.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Constructing regular ultrafilters from a model-theoretic point of view
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
This paper contributes to the set-theoretic side of understanding Keisler's order. We consider properties of ultrafilters which affect saturation of unstable theories: the lower cofinality $\lcf(\aleph_0, \de)$ of $\aleph_0$ modulo $\de$, saturation of the minimum unstable theory (the random graph), flexibility, goodness, goodness for equality, and realization of symmetric cuts. We work in ZFC exc…
▽ More
This paper contributes to the set-theoretic side of understanding Keisler's order. We consider properties of ultrafilters which affect saturation of unstable theories: the lower cofinality $\lcf(\aleph_0, \de)$ of $\aleph_0$ modulo $\de$, saturation of the minimum unstable theory (the random graph), flexibility, goodness, goodness for equality, and realization of symmetric cuts. We work in ZFC except when noted, as several constructions appeal to complete ultrafilters thus assume a measurable cardinal. The main results are as follows. First, we investigate the strength of flexibility, detected by non-low theories. Assuming $κ> \aleph_0$ is measurable, we construct a regular ultrafilter on $λ\geq 2^κ$ which is flexible (thus: ok) but not good, and which moreover has large $\lcf(\aleph_0)$ but does not even saturate models of the random graph. We prove that there is a loss of saturation in regular ultrapowers of unstable theories, and give a new proof that there is a loss of saturation in ultrapowers of non-simple theories. Finally, we investigate realization and omission of symmetric cuts, significant both because of the maximality of the strict order property in Keisler's order, and by recent work of the authors on $SOP_2$. We prove that for any $n < ω$, assuming the existence of $n$ measurable cardinals below $λ$, there is a regular ultrafilter $D$ on $λ$ such that any $D$-ultrapower of a model of linear order will have $n$ alternations of cuts, as defined below. Moreover, $D$ will $λ^+$-saturate all stable theories but will not $(2^κ)^+$-saturate any unstable theory, where $κ$ is the smallest measurable cardinal used in the construction.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Regularity lemmas for stable graphs
Authors:
M. Malliaris,
S. Shelah
Abstract:
Let G be a finite graph with the non-k-order property (essentially, a uniform finite bound on the size of an induced sub-half-graph). A major result of the paper applies model-theoretic arguments to obtain a stronger version of Szemerédi's regularity lemma for such graphs, Theorem 5.18, in which there are no irregular pairs, the bounds are significantly improved, and each component satisfies an in…
▽ More
Let G be a finite graph with the non-k-order property (essentially, a uniform finite bound on the size of an induced sub-half-graph). A major result of the paper applies model-theoretic arguments to obtain a stronger version of Szemerédi's regularity lemma for such graphs, Theorem 5.18, in which there are no irregular pairs, the bounds are significantly improved, and each component satisfies an indivisibility condition. Motivation for this work comes from a coincidence of model-theoretic and graph-theoretic ideas. Namely, it was known that the "irregular pairs" in the statement of Szemerédi's regularity lemma cannot be eliminated, due to the counterexample of half-graphs. The results of this paper show in what sense this counterexample is the only essential difficulty. The proof is largely model-theoretic (though written to be accessible to finite combinatorialists): arbitrarily large half-graphs coincide with model-theoretic instability, so in their absence, structure theorems and technology from stability theory apply. In addition to the theorem quoted, we give several other regularity lemmas with different advantages, in which the indivisibility condition on the components is improved (at the expense of letting the number of components grow with |G|) and extend some of these results to the larger class of graphs without the independence property.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Edge distribution and density in the characteristic sequence
Authors:
M. E. Malliaris
Abstract:
The characteristic sequence of hypergraphs $<P_n : n<ω>$ associated to a formula $φ(x;y)$, introduced in [arXiv:0908.4111], is defined by $P_n(y_1,... y_n) = (\exists x) \bigwedge_{i\leq n} φ(x;y_i)$. This paper continues the study of characteristic sequences, showing that graph-theoretic techniques, notably Szemerédi's celebrated regularity lemma, can be naturally applied to the study of model-…
▽ More
The characteristic sequence of hypergraphs $<P_n : n<ω>$ associated to a formula $φ(x;y)$, introduced in [arXiv:0908.4111], is defined by $P_n(y_1,... y_n) = (\exists x) \bigwedge_{i\leq n} φ(x;y_i)$. This paper continues the study of characteristic sequences, showing that graph-theoretic techniques, notably Szemerédi's celebrated regularity lemma, can be naturally applied to the study of model-theoretic complexity via the characteristic sequence. Specifically, we relate classification-theoretic properties of $φ$ and of the $P_n$ (considered as formulas) to density between components in Szemerédi-regular decompositions of graphs in the characteristic sequence. In addition, we use Szemerédi regularity to calibrate model-theoretic notions of independence by describing the depth of independence of a constellation of sets and showing that certain failures of depth imply Shelah's strong order property $SOP_3$; this sheds light on the interplay of independence and order in unstable theories.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Persistence and NIP in the characteristic sequence
Authors:
M. E. Malliaris
Abstract:
For a first-order formula $φ(x;y)$ we introduce and study the characteristic sequence $<P_n : n < ω>$ of hypergraphs defined by $P_n(y_1,...,y_n) := (\exists x) \bigwedge_{i \leq n} φ(x;y_i)$. We show that combinatorial and classification theoretic properties of the characteristic sequence reflect classification theoretic properties of $φ$ and vice versa. Specifically, we show that some tree pro…
▽ More
For a first-order formula $φ(x;y)$ we introduce and study the characteristic sequence $<P_n : n < ω>$ of hypergraphs defined by $P_n(y_1,...,y_n) := (\exists x) \bigwedge_{i \leq n} φ(x;y_i)$. We show that combinatorial and classification theoretic properties of the characteristic sequence reflect classification theoretic properties of $φ$ and vice versa. Specifically, we show that some tree properties are detected by the presence of certain combinatorial configurations in the characteristic sequence while other properties such as instability and the independence property manifest themselves in the persistence of complicated configurations under localization.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
