-
Breakdown of rotational tori in 2D and 4D conservative and dissipative standard maps
Authors:
Adrian P. Bustamante,
Alessandra Celletti,
Christoph Lhotka
Abstract:
We study the breakdown of rotational invariant tori in 2D and 4D standard maps by implementing three different methods. First, we analyze the domains of analyticity of a torus with given frequency through the computation of the Lindstedt series expansions of the embedding of the torus and the drift term. The Padé approximants provide the shape of the analyticity domains by plotting the poles of th…
▽ More
We study the breakdown of rotational invariant tori in 2D and 4D standard maps by implementing three different methods. First, we analyze the domains of analyticity of a torus with given frequency through the computation of the Lindstedt series expansions of the embedding of the torus and the drift term. The Padé approximants provide the shape of the analyticity domains by plotting the poles of the polynomial at the denominator of the approximants. Secondly, we implement a Newton method to construct the embedding of the torus; the breakdown threshold is then estimated by looking at the blow-up of the Sobolev norms of the embedding. Finally, we implement an extension of Greene method to get information on the breakdown threshold of an invariant torus with irrational frequency by looking at the stability of the periodic orbits with periods approximating the frequency of the torus.
We apply these methods to 2D and 4D standard maps. The 2D maps can either be conservative (symplectic) or dissipative ( more precisely, conformally symplectic, namely a dissipative map with the geometric property to transform the symplectic form into a multiple of itself). The 4D maps are obtained coupling $(i)$ two symplectic standard maps, or $(ii)$ two conformally symplectic standard maps, or $(iii)$ a symplectic and a conformally symplectic standard map.
Concerning the results, Padé and Newton methods perform well and provide reliable and consistent results (although we implemented Newton method only for symplectic and conformally symplectic maps). Our implementation of the extension of Greene method is inconclusive, since it is computationally expensive and delicate, especially in 4D non-symplectic maps, also due to the existence of Arnold tongues.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2023; v1 submitted 28 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Laplace-like resonances with tidal effects
Authors:
A. Celletti,
E. Karampotsiou,
C. Lhotka,
G. Pucacco,
M. Volpi
Abstract:
We generalize the Laplace resonance among three satellites, S1, S2 , and S3, by considering different ratios of the mean-longitude variations. These resonances, which we call Laplace-like, are classified as first order in the cases of the 2:1&2:1, 3:2&3:2, and 2:1&3:2 resonances, second order in the case of the 3:1&3:1 resonance, and mixed order in the case of the 2:1&3:1 resonance. We consider a…
▽ More
We generalize the Laplace resonance among three satellites, S1, S2 , and S3, by considering different ratios of the mean-longitude variations. These resonances, which we call Laplace-like, are classified as first order in the cases of the 2:1&2:1, 3:2&3:2, and 2:1&3:2 resonances, second order in the case of the 3:1&3:1 resonance, and mixed order in the case of the 2:1&3:1 resonance. We consider a model that includes the gravitational interaction with the central body together with the effect due to its oblateness, the mutual gravitational influence of the satellites S1, S2, and S3 and the secular gravitational effect of a fourth satellite S 4 , which plays the role of Callisto in the Galilean system. In addition, we consider the dissipative effect due to the tidal torque between the inner satellite and the central body. We investigate these Laplace-like resonances by studying different aspects: (i) we study the survival of the resonances when the dissipation is included, taking two different expressions for the dissipative effect in the case of a fast- or a slowly rotating central body, (ii) we investigate the behavior of the Laplace-like resonances when some parameters are varied, specifically, the oblateness coefficient, the semimajor axes, and the eccentricities of the satellites, (iii) we analyze the linear stability of first-order resonances for different values of the parameters, and (iv) we also include the full gravitational interaction with S 4 to analyze its possible capture into resonance. The results show a marked difference between first-, second-, and mixed-order resonances, which might find applications when the evolutionary history of the satellites in the Solar System are studied, and also in possible actual configurations of extrasolar planetary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Tadpole type motion of charged dust in the Lagrange problem with planet Jupiter
Authors:
Christoph Lhotka,
Lei Zhou
Abstract:
We investigate the dynamics of charged dust interacting with the interplanetary magnetic field in a Parker spiral type model and subject to the solar wind and Poynting-Robertson effect in the vicinity of the 1:1 mean motion resonance with planet Jupiter. We estimate the shifts of the location of the minimum libration amplitude solutions close to the location of the L4 and L5 points of the classica…
▽ More
We investigate the dynamics of charged dust interacting with the interplanetary magnetic field in a Parker spiral type model and subject to the solar wind and Poynting-Robertson effect in the vicinity of the 1:1 mean motion resonance with planet Jupiter. We estimate the shifts of the location of the minimum libration amplitude solutions close to the location of the L4 and L5 points of the classical - gravitational - problem and provide the extension of the 'librational regimes of motion' and the width of the resonance in dependency of the nongravitational parameters related to the dust grain size and surface potential of the particles. Our study is based on numerical simulations in the framework of the spatial, elliptic restricted three-body problem and semi-analytical estimates obtained by averaging of Gauss' planetary equations of motion.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Resonances in the Earth's Space Environment
Authors:
Alessandra Celletti,
Catalin Gales,
Christoph Lhotka
Abstract:
We study the presence of resonances in the region of space around the Earth. We consider a massless body (e.g, a dust particle or a small space debris) subject to different forces: the gravitational attraction of the geopotential, the effects of Sun and Moon. We distinguish different types of resonances: tesseral resonances are due to a commensurability involving the revolution of the particle and…
▽ More
We study the presence of resonances in the region of space around the Earth. We consider a massless body (e.g, a dust particle or a small space debris) subject to different forces: the gravitational attraction of the geopotential, the effects of Sun and Moon. We distinguish different types of resonances: tesseral resonances are due to a commensurability involving the revolution of the particle and the rotation of the Earth, semi-secular resonances include the rates of variation of the mean anomalies of Moon and Sun, while secular resonances just depend on the rates of variation of the arguments of perigee and the longitudes of the ascending nodes of the perturbing bodies. We characterize such resonances, giving precise statements on the regions where the resonances can be found and provide examples of some specific commensurability relations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Charged dust close to outer mean-motion resonances in the heliosphere
Authors:
Christoph Lhotka,
Catalin Gales
Abstract:
We investigate the dynamics of charged dust close to outer mean-motion resonances with planet Jupiter. The importance of the interplanetary magnetic field on the orbital evolution of dust is clearly demonstrated. New dynamical phenomena are found that do not exist in the classical problem of uncharged dust. We find changes in the orientation of the orbital planes of dust particles, an increased am…
▽ More
We investigate the dynamics of charged dust close to outer mean-motion resonances with planet Jupiter. The importance of the interplanetary magnetic field on the orbital evolution of dust is clearly demonstrated. New dynamical phenomena are found that do not exist in the classical problem of uncharged dust. We find changes in the orientation of the orbital planes of dust particles, an increased amount of chaotic orbital motions, sudden 'jumps' in the resonant argument, and a decrease in time of temporary capture due to the Lorentz force. Variations in the orbital planes of dust grain orbits are found to be related to the angle between the orbital angular momentum and magnetic axes of the heliospheric field and the rotation rate of the Sun. These variations are bound using a simplified model derived from the full dynamical problem using first order averaging theory. It is found that the interplanetary magnetic field does not affect the capture process, that is still dominated by the other non-gravitational forces. Our study is based on a dynamical model in the framework of the inclined circular restricted three-body problem. Additional forces include solar radiation pressure, solar wind drag, the Poynting-Robertson effect, and the influence of a Parker spiral type interplanetary magnetic field model. The analytical estimates are derived on the basis of Gauss' form of planetary equations of motion. Numerical results are obtained by simulations of dust grain orbits together with the system of variational equations. Chaotic regions in phase space are revealed by means of Fast Lyapunov Chaos Indicators.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Charged dust grain dynamics subject to solar wind, Poynting-Robertson drag, and the interplanetary magnetic field
Authors:
Christoph Lhotka,
Philippe Bourdin,
Yasuhito Narita
Abstract:
We investigate the combined effect of solar wind, Poynting-Robertson drag, and the frozen-in interplanetary magnetic field on the motion of charged dust grains in our solar system. For this reason we derive a secular theory of motion by the means of averaging method and validate it with numerical simulations of the un-averaged equations of motions. The theory predicts that the secular motion of ch…
▽ More
We investigate the combined effect of solar wind, Poynting-Robertson drag, and the frozen-in interplanetary magnetic field on the motion of charged dust grains in our solar system. For this reason we derive a secular theory of motion by the means of averaging method and validate it with numerical simulations of the un-averaged equations of motions. The theory predicts that the secular motion of charged particles is mainly affected by the z-component of the solar magnetic axis, or the normal component of the interplanetary magnetic field. The normal component of the interplanetary magnetic field leads to an increase or decrease of semi-major axis depending on its functional form and sign of charge of the dust grain. It is generally accepted that the combined effects of solar wind and photon absorption and re-emmision (Poynting-Robertson drag) lead to a decrease in semi-major axis on secular time scales. On the contrary, we demonstrate that the interplanetary magnetic field may counteract these drag forces under certain circumstances. We derive a simple relation between the parameters of the magnetic field, the physical properties of the dust grain as well as the shape and orientation of the orbital ellipse of the particle, which is a necessary conditions for the stabilization in semi-major axis.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Poynting-Robertson drag and solar wind in the space debris problem
Authors:
Christoph Lhotka,
Alessandra Celletti,
Catalin Gales
Abstract:
We analyze the combined effect of Poynting-Robertson and solar wind drag on space debris. We derive a model within Cartesian, Gaussian and Hamiltonian frameworks. We focus on the geosynchronous resonance, although the results can be easily generalized to any resonance. By numerical and analytical techniques, we compute the drift in semi-major axis due to Poynting-Robertson and solar wind drag. Aft…
▽ More
We analyze the combined effect of Poynting-Robertson and solar wind drag on space debris. We derive a model within Cartesian, Gaussian and Hamiltonian frameworks. We focus on the geosynchronous resonance, although the results can be easily generalized to any resonance. By numerical and analytical techniques, we compute the drift in semi-major axis due to Poynting-Robertson and solar wind drag. After a linear stability analysis of the equilibria, we combine a careful investigation of the regular, resonant, chaotic behavior of the phase space with a long-term propagation of a sample of initial conditions. The results strongly depend on the value of the area-to-mass ratio of the debris, which might show different dynamical behaviors: temporary capture or escape from the geosynchronous resonance, as well as temporary capture or escape from secondary resonances involving the rate of variation of the longitude of the Sun. Such analysis shows that Poynting-Robertson and solar wind drag must be taken into account, when looking at the long-term behavior of space debris. Trapping or escape from the resonance can be used to place the debris in convenient regions of the phase space.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Effective resonant stability of Mercury
Authors:
M. Sansottera,
C. Lhotka,
A. Lemaître
Abstract:
Mercury is the unique known planet that is situated in a 3:2 spin-orbit resonance nowadays. Observations and models converge to the same conclusion: the planet is presently deeply trapped in the resonance and situated at the Cassini state $1$, or very close to it. We investigate the complete non-linear stability of this equilibrium, with respect to several physical parameters, in the framework of…
▽ More
Mercury is the unique known planet that is situated in a 3:2 spin-orbit resonance nowadays. Observations and models converge to the same conclusion: the planet is presently deeply trapped in the resonance and situated at the Cassini state $1$, or very close to it. We investigate the complete non-linear stability of this equilibrium, with respect to several physical parameters, in the framework of Birkhoff normal form and Nekhoroshev stability theory. We use the same approach adopted for the 1:1 spin-orbit case with a peculiar attention to the role of Mercury's non negligible eccentricity. The selected parameters are the polar moment of inertia, the Mercury's inclination and eccentricity and the precession rates of the perihelion and node. Our study produces a bound to both the latitudinal and longitudinal librations (of 0.1 radians) for a long but finite time (greatly exceeding the age of the solar system). This is the so-called effective stability time. Our conclusion is that Mercury, placed inside the 3:2 spin-orbit resonance, occupies a very stable position in the space of these physical parameters, but not the most stable possible one.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Effective stability around the Cassini state in the spin-orbit problem
Authors:
Marco Sansottera,
Christoph Lhotka,
Anne Lemaître
Abstract:
We investigate the long-time stability in the neighborhood of the Cassini state in the conservative spin-orbit problem. Starting with an expansion of the Hamiltonian in the canonical Andoyer-Delaunay variables, we construct a high-order Birkhoff normal form and give an estimate of the effective stability time in the Nekhoroshev sense. By extensively using algebraic manipulations on a computer, we…
▽ More
We investigate the long-time stability in the neighborhood of the Cassini state in the conservative spin-orbit problem. Starting with an expansion of the Hamiltonian in the canonical Andoyer-Delaunay variables, we construct a high-order Birkhoff normal form and give an estimate of the effective stability time in the Nekhoroshev sense. By extensively using algebraic manipulations on a computer, we explicitly apply our method to the rotation of Titan. We obtain physical bounds of Titan's latitudinal and longitudinal librations, finding a stability time greatly exceeding the estimated age of the Universe. In addition, we study the dependence of the effective stability time on three relevant physical parameters: the orbital inclination, $i$, the mean precession of the ascending node of Titan orbit, $\dotΩ$, and the polar moment of inertia, $C$.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
The effect of Poynting-Robertson drag on the triangular Lagrangian points
Authors:
Christoph Lhotka,
Alessandra Celletti
Abstract:
We investigate the stability of motion close to the Lagrangian equilibrium points L4 and L5 in the framework of the spatial, elliptic, restricted three- body problem, subject to the radial component of Poynting-Robertson drag. For this reason we develop a simplified resonant model, that is based on averaging theory, i.e. averaged over the mean anomaly of the perturbing planet. We find temporary st…
▽ More
We investigate the stability of motion close to the Lagrangian equilibrium points L4 and L5 in the framework of the spatial, elliptic, restricted three- body problem, subject to the radial component of Poynting-Robertson drag. For this reason we develop a simplified resonant model, that is based on averaging theory, i.e. averaged over the mean anomaly of the perturbing planet. We find temporary stability of particles displaying a tadpole motion in the 1:1 resonance. From the linear stability study of the averaged simplified resonant model, we find that the time of temporary stability is proportional to beta a1 n1 , where beta is the ratio of the solar radiation over the gravitational force, and a1, n1 are the semi-major axis and the mean motion of the perturbing planet, respectively. We extend previous results (Murray (1994)) on the asymmetry of the stability indices of L4 and L5 to a more realistic force model. Our analytical results are supported by means of numerical simulations. We implement our study to Jupiter-like perturbing planets, that are also found in extra-solar planetary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Stability of nearly-integrable systems with dissipation
Authors:
Alessandra Celletti,
Christoph Lhotka
Abstract:
We study the stability of a vector field associated to a nearly-integrable Hamiltonian dynamical system to which a dissipation is added. Such a system is governed by two parameters, named the perturbing and dissipative parameters, and it depends on a drift function. Assuming that the frequency of motion satisfies some resonance assumption, we investigate the stability of the dynamics, and precisel…
▽ More
We study the stability of a vector field associated to a nearly-integrable Hamiltonian dynamical system to which a dissipation is added. Such a system is governed by two parameters, named the perturbing and dissipative parameters, and it depends on a drift function. Assuming that the frequency of motion satisfies some resonance assumption, we investigate the stability of the dynamics, and precisely the variation of the action variables associated to the conservative model. According to the structure of the vector field, one can find linear and exponential stability times, which are established under smallness con- ditions on the parameters. We also provide some applications to concrete examples, which exhibit a linear or exponential stability behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Stability estimates of nearly-integrable systems with dissipation and non-resonant frequency
Authors:
Alessandra Celletti,
Christoph Lhotka
Abstract:
We consider a dissipative vector field which is represented by a nearly-integrable Hamiltonian flow to which a non symplectic force is added, so that the phase space volume is not preserved. The vector field depends upon two parameters, namely the perturbing and dissipative parameters, and by a drift function. We study the general case of an l-dimensional, time-dependent vector field. Assuming to…
▽ More
We consider a dissipative vector field which is represented by a nearly-integrable Hamiltonian flow to which a non symplectic force is added, so that the phase space volume is not preserved. The vector field depends upon two parameters, namely the perturbing and dissipative parameters, and by a drift function. We study the general case of an l-dimensional, time-dependent vector field. Assuming to start with non-resonant initial conditions, we prove the stability of the variables which are actions of the conservative system (namely, when the dissipative parameter is set to zero) for exponentially long times. In order to construct the normal form, a suitable choice of the drift function must be performed. We also provide some simple examples in which we construct explicitly the normal form, we make a comparison with a numerical integration and we compute theoretical bounds on the parameters as well as we give explicit stability estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
